1
00:00:05,767 --> 00:00:09,629
This is a case of a killer
who is smart, methodical,
2
00:00:09,663 --> 00:00:13,180
able to cover his tracks,
and for his victims,
3
00:00:13,215 --> 00:00:14,905
he doesn't just kill then.
4
00:00:14,939 --> 00:00:16,353
He erases them.
5
00:00:16,387 --> 00:00:18,387
♪
6
00:00:18,422 --> 00:00:21,215
You don't even have
a single body.
7
00:00:21,249 --> 00:00:23,836
How do you catch a killer
that's invisible
8
00:00:23,870 --> 00:00:28,663
and that picks victims
that no one will miss?
9
00:00:28,698 --> 00:00:31,525
You know he's out there.
10
00:00:31,560 --> 00:00:34,353
You know he'll kill again.
11
00:00:34,387 --> 00:00:36,180
How do you stop him?
12
00:00:39,215 --> 00:00:45,767
♪
13
00:00:50,801 --> 00:00:53,939
Woonsocket is 8.6 square miles,
14
00:00:53,974 --> 00:00:58,560
and everybody is
pretty much close-knit.
15
00:00:58,594 --> 00:01:01,801
What I love about Woonsocket
is the people.
16
00:01:01,836 --> 00:01:02,905
There are some great people.
17
00:01:02,939 --> 00:01:04,594
There are some
great neighborhoods,
18
00:01:04,629 --> 00:01:07,456
but there are also
some bad elements.
19
00:01:07,491 --> 00:01:08,870
It's a tough little city.
20
00:01:08,905 --> 00:01:11,698
♪
21
00:01:11,732 --> 00:01:15,767
On March 2nd, 2003,
early-morning hours,
22
00:01:15,801 --> 00:01:17,387
the Woonsocket
Police Department
23
00:01:17,422 --> 00:01:18,905
was notified by a motorist
24
00:01:18,939 --> 00:01:22,008
that there was a woman
completely naked
25
00:01:22,043 --> 00:01:26,008
lying in the middle of the
road by the Mill District.
26
00:01:26,043 --> 00:01:28,146
She was severely beaten.
27
00:01:28,180 --> 00:01:30,215
She was transported
to the hospital.
28
00:01:32,905 --> 00:01:35,249
We responded and met
with the victim,
29
00:01:35,284 --> 00:01:37,422
and we were able
to speak with her.
30
00:01:37,456 --> 00:01:39,767
Her name was Jane Smith.
31
00:01:39,801 --> 00:01:44,422
She told us
that she was walking down
32
00:01:44,456 --> 00:01:47,318
one of the streets
in Woonsocket.
33
00:01:47,353 --> 00:01:49,284
She was in the area
of High and Arnold Street
34
00:01:49,318 --> 00:01:50,560
when she was approached
35
00:01:50,594 --> 00:01:55,215
by a male driving
a small-style SUV.
36
00:01:55,249 --> 00:01:57,422
He asked
if she wanted to party.
37
00:01:57,456 --> 00:01:59,974
She was a working girl.
She didn't hide it.
38
00:02:00,008 --> 00:02:03,353
She got in the vehicle.
39
00:02:03,387 --> 00:02:06,077
She was brought to the rear
of an old working mill
40
00:02:06,111 --> 00:02:08,008
in the woods.
41
00:02:08,043 --> 00:02:10,836
Then the abuse
and the terror began.
42
00:02:10,870 --> 00:02:13,284
♪
43
00:02:13,318 --> 00:02:14,629
He punched her.
44
00:02:14,663 --> 00:02:16,077
He stabbed her
45
00:02:16,111 --> 00:02:18,008
in the face numerous times
with a screwdriver,
46
00:02:18,043 --> 00:02:20,732
stabbed her neck, her torso.
47
00:02:20,767 --> 00:02:22,663
She truly felt
that she was gonna die.
48
00:02:22,698 --> 00:02:24,698
♪
49
00:02:24,732 --> 00:02:28,111
She described her assailant
as a man in his 30s
50
00:02:28,146 --> 00:02:32,525
with blond hair,
glasses, tattoos on his arms.
51
00:02:32,560 --> 00:02:34,387
♪
52
00:02:34,422 --> 00:02:36,560
We hit the streets.
53
00:02:36,594 --> 00:02:38,077
We started from High
and Arnold,
54
00:02:38,111 --> 00:02:39,422
where she was picked up,
55
00:02:39,456 --> 00:02:41,698
looked for witnesses,
kind of traced her steps
56
00:02:41,732 --> 00:02:45,387
all the way down to the street
where she was found.
57
00:02:45,422 --> 00:02:48,387
We were able to find
the exact location
58
00:02:48,422 --> 00:02:50,318
where the assault took place.
59
00:02:50,353 --> 00:02:52,077
We were hoping
to find a screwdriver,
60
00:02:52,111 --> 00:02:53,318
any type of physical evidence.
61
00:02:53,353 --> 00:02:55,456
♪
62
00:02:55,491 --> 00:02:58,180
Unfortunately, we weren't
able to locate anything.
63
00:02:58,215 --> 00:03:01,318
He took all of her clothes.
He took the screwdriver.
64
00:03:01,353 --> 00:03:05,008
So the only thing
that was there was her blood.
65
00:03:05,043 --> 00:03:06,560
The fact that we didn't find
66
00:03:06,594 --> 00:03:08,215
any physical evidence
at the scene,
67
00:03:08,249 --> 00:03:09,663
we started to think
68
00:03:09,698 --> 00:03:11,836
he was taking steps
to cover his actions,
69
00:03:11,870 --> 00:03:13,767
meaning that he seemed
calculated.
70
00:03:13,801 --> 00:03:15,767
This isn't his first night
on the street
71
00:03:15,801 --> 00:03:17,767
and it's probably
not gonna be his last.
72
00:03:17,801 --> 00:03:22,043
♪
73
00:03:22,077 --> 00:03:26,008
On April 4th, a woman
came to the police station
74
00:03:26,043 --> 00:03:28,077
to file
a missing-person complaint
75
00:03:28,111 --> 00:03:31,456
on behalf of her daughter,
Audrey Harris.
76
00:03:31,491 --> 00:03:33,491
♪
77
00:03:33,525 --> 00:03:36,560
She was 33 years of age.
78
00:03:36,594 --> 00:03:38,284
And the mother
basically tells me
79
00:03:38,318 --> 00:03:41,077
that Audrey
would always come and go,
80
00:03:41,111 --> 00:03:43,560
but she had close ties
with her mother.
81
00:03:43,594 --> 00:03:44,974
At least once or twice a week,
82
00:03:45,008 --> 00:03:48,663
she went and made sure
mom was okay.
83
00:03:48,698 --> 00:03:51,249
Audrey's mother
was extremely concerned
84
00:03:51,284 --> 00:03:53,698
because it was three months
that had elapsed
85
00:03:53,732 --> 00:03:56,215
where she didn't see her.
86
00:03:56,249 --> 00:03:59,698
Audrey was well-known
as a prostitute.
87
00:03:59,732 --> 00:04:04,422
She worked around
the High and Arnold area.
88
00:04:04,456 --> 00:04:08,077
So I spoke to practically
every prostitute
89
00:04:08,111 --> 00:04:10,663
in the High and Arnold area.
90
00:04:10,698 --> 00:04:13,560
Some of these women showed
a great deal of concern
91
00:04:13,594 --> 00:04:15,629
about Audrey
not being around.
92
00:04:15,663 --> 00:04:18,801
They were nervous.
They were scared.
93
00:04:18,836 --> 00:04:23,146
But they had no information
whatsoever to supply.
94
00:04:23,180 --> 00:04:26,732
I wasn't getting any leads
as to where she could be
95
00:04:26,767 --> 00:04:28,767
or who she was last with.
96
00:04:28,801 --> 00:04:32,146
She kind of just vanished.
97
00:04:32,180 --> 00:04:34,525
When we learned of Audrey
being reported missing,
98
00:04:34,560 --> 00:04:36,491
my concern was that
99
00:04:36,525 --> 00:04:38,698
we were in the middle
of the Jane investigation.
100
00:04:38,732 --> 00:04:43,008
Janie was violently beaten,
stabbed with a screwdriver.
101
00:04:43,043 --> 00:04:46,215
She had been picked up
in the High and Arnold area--
102
00:04:46,249 --> 00:04:49,215
same area Audrey
would frequent.
103
00:04:49,249 --> 00:04:51,318
It's all
within a couple months.
104
00:04:51,353 --> 00:04:54,008
So you'd think,
"Are these connected?
105
00:04:54,043 --> 00:04:55,387
"Is Audrey really missing?
106
00:04:55,422 --> 00:04:57,284
What are the chances
that she could have been
107
00:04:57,318 --> 00:04:59,387
a victim as well?
108
00:04:59,422 --> 00:05:00,939
So we started
109
00:05:00,974 --> 00:05:03,180
to not really put
these investigations together,
110
00:05:03,215 --> 00:05:04,456
but sort of run parallel
111
00:05:04,491 --> 00:05:06,732
to see if there is
a common denominator here.
112
00:05:06,767 --> 00:05:10,146
♪
113
00:05:10,180 --> 00:05:12,732
A week after Audrey Harris
was reported missing,
114
00:05:12,767 --> 00:05:14,905
we were notified
that another woman
115
00:05:14,939 --> 00:05:17,732
was violently attacked...
116
00:05:17,767 --> 00:05:20,215
again, from the High
and Arnold Street area.
117
00:05:21,456 --> 00:05:23,732
She was transported
to the hospital.
118
00:05:23,767 --> 00:05:27,008
We were informed that the
victim was Christine Dumont.
119
00:05:27,043 --> 00:05:30,525
♪
120
00:05:30,560 --> 00:05:33,111
Early that morning,
we went to the hospital.
121
00:05:33,146 --> 00:05:35,663
Christine is visibly shaken.
She was crying.
122
00:05:35,698 --> 00:05:37,491
She was emotional.
123
00:05:37,525 --> 00:05:42,318
Christine Dumont
was a very slight woman.
124
00:05:42,353 --> 00:05:45,008
When I met her the first time,
I was kind of surprised,
125
00:05:45,043 --> 00:05:47,905
but she looked like she was
about 100 pounds,
126
00:05:47,939 --> 00:05:50,939
but clearly quite a fighter.
127
00:05:50,974 --> 00:05:54,629
She told us she was walking
down that same street
128
00:05:54,663 --> 00:05:56,801
that Jane Smith
was walking down
129
00:05:56,836 --> 00:05:58,732
just a little
over a month prior.
130
00:05:58,767 --> 00:06:02,732
She had been picked up
by a male subject.
131
00:06:02,767 --> 00:06:04,974
She was driven
to the mill area.
132
00:06:06,560 --> 00:06:08,732
The same secluded mill area
133
00:06:08,767 --> 00:06:11,801
where Jane Smith was attacked.
134
00:06:11,836 --> 00:06:14,905
She was removed
from the vehicle.
135
00:06:14,939 --> 00:06:16,801
He was screaming at her,
136
00:06:16,836 --> 00:06:19,284
telling her
her life was worth nothing.
137
00:06:19,318 --> 00:06:21,318
The suspect then hit her
over the head
138
00:06:21,353 --> 00:06:24,594
repeatedly with a metal pipe.
139
00:06:24,629 --> 00:06:28,077
She tried to fight, but he
continued to assault her.
140
00:06:28,111 --> 00:06:29,974
She thought she was gonna die.
141
00:06:30,008 --> 00:06:34,008
At some point, she just
lied there motionless.
142
00:06:34,043 --> 00:06:37,663
And then he just drove away...
143
00:06:37,698 --> 00:06:40,422
left her there lying, bleeding.
144
00:06:40,456 --> 00:06:42,698
Christine Dumont provided
145
00:06:42,732 --> 00:06:46,146
a very detailed description
of her assailant,
146
00:06:46,180 --> 00:06:49,905
very similar
to Jane Smith's...
147
00:06:49,939 --> 00:06:53,560
blondish hair, stocky white man
148
00:06:53,594 --> 00:06:56,732
in his 20s with tattoos.
149
00:06:56,767 --> 00:06:58,111
It was obvious to us
150
00:06:58,146 --> 00:07:00,387
that, you know, we're looking
for the same suspect.
151
00:07:00,422 --> 00:07:03,801
If he is a person who's
brutally assaulting prostitutes
152
00:07:03,836 --> 00:07:05,008
in the same area
153
00:07:05,043 --> 00:07:07,077
over a very short period
of time,
154
00:07:07,111 --> 00:07:08,905
there's also
a good possibility
155
00:07:08,939 --> 00:07:10,284
that he could be responsible
156
00:07:10,318 --> 00:07:13,870
for Audrey Harris's
disappearance.
157
00:07:13,905 --> 00:07:16,422
What can we tell
about who this person is?
158
00:07:16,456 --> 00:07:20,008
He's preying on women
who are sex workers.
159
00:07:20,043 --> 00:07:21,836
He is full of rage.
160
00:07:21,870 --> 00:07:24,318
This was unprovoked.
It was spontaneous.
161
00:07:24,353 --> 00:07:28,111
Think about the weapons that
were used during their attack--
162
00:07:28,146 --> 00:07:32,077
a screwdriver, something that
was readily accessible to him,
163
00:07:32,111 --> 00:07:35,939
and a tire iron, which was
in the trunk of a vehicle.
164
00:07:35,974 --> 00:07:38,732
This is not
a sort of meticulous
165
00:07:38,767 --> 00:07:40,353
well planned out crime.
166
00:07:40,387 --> 00:07:44,629
This is someone who had a lot
of rage towards these women
167
00:07:44,663 --> 00:07:46,663
and clearly took it out
on them.
168
00:07:46,698 --> 00:07:50,456
This often comes
from potentially their mother
169
00:07:50,491 --> 00:07:54,353
or some sort of relationship
that they had in the past
170
00:07:54,387 --> 00:07:56,836
that created this anger
towards women
171
00:07:56,870 --> 00:07:59,387
and a need to degrade them,
172
00:07:59,422 --> 00:08:02,077
hurt them, and potentially
even kill them.
173
00:08:02,111 --> 00:08:04,594
♪
174
00:08:04,629 --> 00:08:07,008
That day,
after meeting with Christine,
175
00:08:07,043 --> 00:08:09,767
we went and picked up Jane,
the first woman attacked,
176
00:08:09,801 --> 00:08:11,560
and brought her
into the station
177
00:08:11,594 --> 00:08:13,560
to do another interview.
178
00:08:13,594 --> 00:08:17,284
As we were speaking to her,
out of the blue, she says,
179
00:08:17,318 --> 00:08:19,525
"Oh, I remember
180
00:08:19,560 --> 00:08:22,801
"that prior
to being attacked that night,
181
00:08:22,836 --> 00:08:24,215
we went to an ATM."
182
00:08:24,249 --> 00:08:26,353
♪
183
00:08:26,387 --> 00:08:29,146
Now we have the assailant
go into an ATM,
184
00:08:29,180 --> 00:08:31,008
who did
a financial transaction,
185
00:08:31,043 --> 00:08:33,284
who's most likely on camera.
186
00:08:33,318 --> 00:08:36,387
This was really
the break we needed.
187
00:08:36,422 --> 00:08:38,284
♪
188
00:08:38,318 --> 00:08:41,215
She just started crying
and said, "That is him.
189
00:08:41,249 --> 00:08:43,043
That's him."
190
00:08:43,077 --> 00:08:45,422
And another woman
was reported missing
191
00:08:45,456 --> 00:08:47,974
from the High
and Arnold Street area.
192
00:08:48,008 --> 00:08:50,284
It's getting stranger
and stranger in Woonsocket
193
00:08:50,318 --> 00:08:52,387
that these girls
are going missing.
194
00:08:52,422 --> 00:08:54,732
♪
195
00:08:58,077 --> 00:09:00,525
By April of 2003,
196
00:09:00,560 --> 00:09:02,043
in a very short amount
of time,
197
00:09:02,077 --> 00:09:04,077
in the same, you know, area,
198
00:09:04,111 --> 00:09:06,698
we had vicious assaults
on Christine Dumont,
199
00:09:06,732 --> 00:09:08,939
vicious assault on Jane Smith,
200
00:09:08,974 --> 00:09:11,249
and we had an active
missing-persons case
201
00:09:11,284 --> 00:09:13,146
with Audrey Harris.
202
00:09:14,767 --> 00:09:17,422
The Woonsocket police
had reached out again
203
00:09:17,456 --> 00:09:18,905
to Jane Smith
204
00:09:18,939 --> 00:09:22,353
to try to learn
if there was any other details
205
00:09:22,387 --> 00:09:23,939
that she could remember--
206
00:09:23,974 --> 00:09:28,077
try and identify
this dangerous guy.
207
00:09:28,111 --> 00:09:29,456
That is when Jane told us
208
00:09:29,491 --> 00:09:33,111
that her assailant
drove to Sovereign bank.
209
00:09:33,146 --> 00:09:36,111
He went into the ATM, came back
out a couple of minutes later,
210
00:09:36,146 --> 00:09:38,939
and said, "I have $100.
Now we're gonna party."
211
00:09:38,974 --> 00:09:42,663
She remembered it was
a little before 1:00 a.m.
212
00:09:42,698 --> 00:09:44,905
The police immediately
went to the bank
213
00:09:44,939 --> 00:09:46,422
and were able to secure
214
00:09:46,456 --> 00:09:49,801
the photo
of the ATM transaction.
215
00:09:52,870 --> 00:09:56,180
There was only one person
who withdrew $100.
216
00:09:56,215 --> 00:10:01,077
The subject making the
transaction was a white male...
217
00:10:01,111 --> 00:10:04,043
blondish short hair, goatee.
218
00:10:04,077 --> 00:10:07,318
The exact description
that Jane and Christine
219
00:10:07,353 --> 00:10:10,249
gave as their assailant.
220
00:10:10,284 --> 00:10:12,767
The cardholder
for that debit card
221
00:10:12,801 --> 00:10:15,249
was a Timothy Scanlon
of Woonsocket.
222
00:10:15,284 --> 00:10:17,663
♪
223
00:10:17,698 --> 00:10:19,629
He had been arrested
in the past
224
00:10:19,663 --> 00:10:23,249
for larceny and...
225
00:10:23,284 --> 00:10:26,560
possession of a stolen motor vehicle.
226
00:10:26,594 --> 00:10:28,353
And we created
a photo array
227
00:10:28,387 --> 00:10:33,111
and went to the hospital
where Christine still was.
228
00:10:33,146 --> 00:10:35,836
We just asked her to take her
time, look at the photographs,
229
00:10:35,870 --> 00:10:40,077
and tell us if she could
identify her assailant.
230
00:10:40,111 --> 00:10:41,801
She became
extremely emotional.
231
00:10:41,836 --> 00:10:44,422
She pointed to
Timothy Scanlon's photograph,
232
00:10:44,456 --> 00:10:47,008
said, "That's the mother F
that did it."
233
00:10:47,043 --> 00:10:50,008
♪
234
00:10:50,043 --> 00:10:51,422
The next step--
235
00:10:51,456 --> 00:10:53,732
the detectives
went to the first victim,
236
00:10:53,767 --> 00:10:55,939
Jane Smith's house.
237
00:10:55,974 --> 00:10:58,146
She just started crying
and said,
238
00:10:58,180 --> 00:10:59,870
"That is him. That's him."
239
00:10:59,905 --> 00:11:02,698
♪
240
00:11:02,732 --> 00:11:05,422
So now that both Jane
and Christine Dumont
241
00:11:05,456 --> 00:11:08,560
identified Timothy Scanlon
as the assailant,
242
00:11:08,594 --> 00:11:10,249
we were starting to wonder,
243
00:11:10,284 --> 00:11:12,767
is there any connections
with the Audrey Harris case?
244
00:11:12,801 --> 00:11:14,491
She's in that timeframe?
245
00:11:14,525 --> 00:11:18,387
She's a prostitute that works
basically the same streets.
246
00:11:18,422 --> 00:11:20,698
It wasn't a far leap
to think that Timothy Scanlon
247
00:11:20,732 --> 00:11:23,318
had something to do with
Audrey Harris's disappearance.
248
00:11:23,353 --> 00:11:30,284
♪
249
00:11:30,318 --> 00:11:32,836
About a week
after he had been identified,
250
00:11:32,870 --> 00:11:35,008
we obtained a warrant
for Timothy Scanlon
251
00:11:35,043 --> 00:11:39,318
for kidnapping and assault
on Jane and Christine.
252
00:11:40,939 --> 00:11:42,353
Later that evening,
we moved in.
253
00:11:42,387 --> 00:11:44,284
He was placed under arrest him
without incident.
254
00:11:44,318 --> 00:11:46,456
He was brought up
into the interrogation room.
255
00:11:46,491 --> 00:11:48,801
He denied any involvement.
256
00:11:48,836 --> 00:11:50,525
He immediately stated
he want a lawyer.
257
00:11:50,560 --> 00:11:52,594
And that was the end of the
interview with him,
258
00:11:52,629 --> 00:11:55,215
unfortunately.
259
00:11:55,249 --> 00:11:59,525
Timothy Scanlon was charged
with multiple counts
260
00:11:59,560 --> 00:12:01,594
of first-degree assault
261
00:12:01,629 --> 00:12:05,456
on Jane Smith
and Christine Dumont.
262
00:12:05,491 --> 00:12:07,939
He pled not guilty
at his arraignment
263
00:12:07,974 --> 00:12:11,594
and was held without bail
pending his trial.
264
00:12:11,629 --> 00:12:14,594
His defense was that he was
with Jane Smith
265
00:12:14,629 --> 00:12:17,905
and Christine Dumont
in a consensual manner,
266
00:12:17,939 --> 00:12:20,767
and they were assaulted
after that.
267
00:12:20,801 --> 00:12:22,077
So the testimony
268
00:12:22,111 --> 00:12:26,008
of both Jane Smith
and Christine Dumont
269
00:12:26,043 --> 00:12:29,043
was the key to this case.
270
00:12:29,077 --> 00:12:31,836
But Jane was so paralyzed
with fear
271
00:12:31,870 --> 00:12:34,284
of being in the same room
with him again
272
00:12:34,318 --> 00:12:36,939
that she did not
want to testify.
273
00:12:36,974 --> 00:12:39,111
♪
274
00:12:39,146 --> 00:12:42,180
Christine wanted to testify
and tell her story.
275
00:12:42,215 --> 00:12:44,767
She was happy
for a second chance in life.
276
00:12:44,801 --> 00:12:46,249
She had a plan
in her mind, right?
277
00:12:46,284 --> 00:12:48,801
"I'm gonna be a better mother.
I'm gonna get a job."
278
00:12:48,836 --> 00:12:50,870
It seemed like
she was gonna carry through.
279
00:12:50,905 --> 00:12:52,249
Maybe a little bit of good
280
00:12:52,284 --> 00:12:54,801
was gonna come
out of this horrific event.
281
00:12:54,836 --> 00:12:58,077
Christine
was very dedicated.
282
00:12:58,111 --> 00:12:59,111
She's a fighter.
283
00:12:59,146 --> 00:13:01,767
She wasn't going to let
her demon
284
00:13:01,801 --> 00:13:04,284
stop her from testifying.
285
00:13:04,318 --> 00:13:07,525
Christine's testimony
is critical in the prosecution
286
00:13:07,560 --> 00:13:10,215
of Scanlon
for the assault on her.
287
00:13:10,249 --> 00:13:12,974
Without her, they
may not have a provable case.
288
00:13:13,008 --> 00:13:15,284
If she does testify,
she runs the risk
289
00:13:15,318 --> 00:13:19,249
that he may come
after her one day
290
00:13:19,284 --> 00:13:21,249
or he may arrange
for someone else
291
00:13:21,284 --> 00:13:23,767
to come after her
for testifying against him.
292
00:13:23,801 --> 00:13:26,249
You're concerned
about her safety.
293
00:13:26,284 --> 00:13:29,939
There's always the factor
of witness intimidation.
294
00:13:29,974 --> 00:13:32,974
And that's very real,
and it does happen.
295
00:13:33,008 --> 00:13:34,939
There's multiple reasons
why women
296
00:13:34,974 --> 00:13:37,456
don't want to testify
against their assailant.
297
00:13:37,491 --> 00:13:40,422
When you're testify and you
step up onto the stand,
298
00:13:40,456 --> 00:13:42,905
in some ways, you yourself
are being put on trial.
299
00:13:42,939 --> 00:13:46,249
So, if you have any wrongdoing,
have used drugs,
300
00:13:46,284 --> 00:13:48,594
anything that could
look poorly on you,
301
00:13:48,629 --> 00:13:50,077
they're gonna bring that up
in the courtroom
302
00:13:50,111 --> 00:13:51,422
and that can be incredibly
303
00:13:51,456 --> 00:13:54,594
damaging and hurtful
to the person testifying.
304
00:13:54,629 --> 00:13:56,767
♪
305
00:13:56,801 --> 00:13:58,249
We didn't have a trial date,
306
00:13:58,284 --> 00:14:01,491
but Christine Dumont
was absolutely ready, willing,
307
00:14:01,525 --> 00:14:04,284
and able
to get in that courtroom
308
00:14:04,318 --> 00:14:07,387
and tell what Scanlon
had done to her.
309
00:14:07,422 --> 00:14:09,146
But that's not what happened.
310
00:14:09,180 --> 00:14:11,870
♪
311
00:14:11,905 --> 00:14:14,767
On May 3rd of 2004,
312
00:14:14,801 --> 00:14:16,180
Christine's sister
313
00:14:16,215 --> 00:14:17,939
came to the station
314
00:14:17,974 --> 00:14:21,146
to report her missing.
315
00:14:21,180 --> 00:14:24,318
She had not been seen
or heard from
316
00:14:24,353 --> 00:14:26,353
in almost ten days.
317
00:14:26,387 --> 00:14:28,284
♪
318
00:14:28,318 --> 00:14:30,318
She hadn't communicated
with family, her kids.
319
00:14:30,353 --> 00:14:34,249
She didn't pick up
her state check.
320
00:14:34,284 --> 00:14:35,629
That's always a red flag.
321
00:14:35,663 --> 00:14:39,836
♪
322
00:14:39,870 --> 00:14:41,594
I was...
323
00:14:41,629 --> 00:14:43,525
"Shocked" isn't
the word for it.
324
00:14:43,560 --> 00:14:46,560
I'm thinking, "Oh, my word,
325
00:14:46,594 --> 00:14:49,732
I just lost
the best witness I have.
326
00:14:49,767 --> 00:14:53,146
♪
327
00:14:53,180 --> 00:14:55,767
I believe Timothy Scanlon
had something to do
328
00:14:55,801 --> 00:14:57,629
with the disappearance.
329
00:14:57,663 --> 00:14:59,491
It would be a much easier trial
330
00:14:59,525 --> 00:15:02,594
if Christine Dumont
wasn't around.
331
00:15:02,629 --> 00:15:04,318
But there was no evidence.
332
00:15:04,353 --> 00:15:08,249
There was no conversations
that Timothy Scanlon had
333
00:15:08,284 --> 00:15:10,767
with anyone
that we had uncovered
334
00:15:10,801 --> 00:15:14,732
that was pointing in the
direction of a murder for hire
335
00:15:14,767 --> 00:15:17,767
or any attempts
to silence Christine
336
00:15:17,801 --> 00:15:19,077
from testifying.
337
00:15:19,111 --> 00:15:20,836
♪
338
00:15:20,870 --> 00:15:22,629
So, obviously, we went back
339
00:15:22,663 --> 00:15:25,594
to, you know,
was it her lifestyle?
340
00:15:25,629 --> 00:15:28,284
Having spoken
with Christine's sister,
341
00:15:28,318 --> 00:15:32,974
we learned that Christine
was still often seen
342
00:15:33,008 --> 00:15:36,077
in the High
and Arnold Street area.
343
00:15:36,111 --> 00:15:39,422
I really thought that the
page had turned for Christine,
344
00:15:39,456 --> 00:15:42,422
but it seemed like
she went back to the street.
345
00:15:42,456 --> 00:15:44,456
So we began pounding
the streets
346
00:15:44,491 --> 00:15:47,594
and trying to speak to people
that frequent that area.
347
00:15:47,629 --> 00:15:50,387
♪
348
00:15:50,422 --> 00:15:53,801
The days turned into weeks.
349
00:15:53,836 --> 00:15:57,077
There were no solid leads
to go on.
350
00:15:57,111 --> 00:16:01,180
It was a completely cold case
as if she just disappeared.
351
00:16:01,215 --> 00:16:03,732
♪
352
00:16:03,767 --> 00:16:06,215
We could rule out
that it was Timothy Scanlon
353
00:16:06,249 --> 00:16:08,249
because we knew
his whereabouts
354
00:16:08,284 --> 00:16:11,146
during the time
of her disappearance.
355
00:16:11,180 --> 00:16:13,939
And so now we're thinking,
"Is the person responsible
356
00:16:13,974 --> 00:16:15,939
"for Christine Dumont's
disappearance
357
00:16:15,974 --> 00:16:18,318
"also responsible
for Audrey Harris' missing
358
00:16:18,353 --> 00:16:20,939
the year prior to this?"
359
00:16:20,974 --> 00:16:23,215
If it is all connected,
360
00:16:23,249 --> 00:16:26,491
there's another person out
there targeting prostitutes.
361
00:16:31,905 --> 00:16:33,801
Timothy Scanlon was
responsible
362
00:16:33,836 --> 00:16:35,111
for Jane Smith's assault,
363
00:16:35,146 --> 00:16:36,491
Christine Dumont's assault
364
00:16:36,525 --> 00:16:39,284
and we were hoping to find
something to lock him
365
00:16:39,318 --> 00:16:40,732
into the Audrey Harris case.
366
00:16:42,491 --> 00:16:45,974
But now Christine Dumont
was missing.
367
00:16:46,008 --> 00:16:47,629
We could rule out
that it was Timothy
368
00:16:47,663 --> 00:16:49,525
because we knew
his whereabouts
369
00:16:49,560 --> 00:16:52,111
during the time
of her disappearance.
370
00:16:52,146 --> 00:16:54,801
So was there someone else
out there
371
00:16:54,836 --> 00:16:56,456
preying on these people
372
00:16:56,491 --> 00:16:59,698
in the High Street
and Arnold Street area?
373
00:17:01,422 --> 00:17:04,629
When prostitutes go missing
nine out of ten times,
374
00:17:04,663 --> 00:17:08,939
it's a homicide
or, you know, tragic ending.
375
00:17:08,974 --> 00:17:11,146
So we were,
at that point, assuming
376
00:17:11,180 --> 00:17:14,284
that we're probably looking
at a murder investigation.
377
00:17:14,318 --> 00:17:17,629
♪
378
00:17:17,663 --> 00:17:20,353
On July 4, 2004,
379
00:17:20,387 --> 00:17:23,387
James Nelson
came into the station
380
00:17:23,422 --> 00:17:27,456
to report his girlfriend,
Stacie Goulet,
381
00:17:27,491 --> 00:17:30,353
had gone missing
sometime the night before.
382
00:17:30,387 --> 00:17:33,629
♪
383
00:17:33,663 --> 00:17:36,077
Mr. Nelson said
that he was with Stacie
384
00:17:36,111 --> 00:17:38,870
in the area north
of Arnold and High Street.
385
00:17:38,905 --> 00:17:41,077
They were there
for some of the celebrations
386
00:17:41,111 --> 00:17:44,560
that were taking place,
the fireworks.
387
00:17:44,594 --> 00:17:46,456
♪
388
00:17:46,491 --> 00:17:49,284
He decided to bum a cigarette
off a friend of his,
389
00:17:49,318 --> 00:17:52,180
and when he went back
to where Stacie was walking,
390
00:17:52,215 --> 00:17:54,043
he had no longer seen her.
391
00:17:54,077 --> 00:17:57,180
So he just hung around knowing
that she would come back
392
00:17:57,215 --> 00:17:59,422
to that area,
but she never did.
393
00:17:59,456 --> 00:18:02,387
♪
394
00:18:02,422 --> 00:18:05,043
We knew from Stacie's record
395
00:18:05,077 --> 00:18:09,974
that Stacie was also known
to be a prostitute in the city.
396
00:18:10,008 --> 00:18:13,801
James was not being
completely honest.
397
00:18:13,836 --> 00:18:15,456
He doesn't want to
embarrass Stacie
398
00:18:15,491 --> 00:18:16,905
by saying she's prostituting.
399
00:18:16,939 --> 00:18:21,422
So we pretty much gave him
a rough interview.
400
00:18:21,456 --> 00:18:23,353
We made him think that we were
gonna arrest him
401
00:18:23,387 --> 00:18:26,491
for her murder
just to see where he was at.
402
00:18:26,525 --> 00:18:30,077
But he stood up to
the interrogation pretty well.
403
00:18:30,111 --> 00:18:33,456
He told us he knew that
she was working that night.
404
00:18:33,491 --> 00:18:37,629
He was doing his best
to watch Stacie.
405
00:18:37,663 --> 00:18:39,387
He just assumed at the time
406
00:18:39,422 --> 00:18:41,525
that she was picked up
by a john.
407
00:18:43,008 --> 00:18:45,318
So, when we ended it,
we were like, "You know what?
408
00:18:45,353 --> 00:18:47,111
We don't think it's him."
409
00:18:47,146 --> 00:18:49,491
♪
410
00:18:49,525 --> 00:18:52,111
After interviewing
Mr. Nelson,
411
00:18:52,146 --> 00:18:54,284
we needed to reach out
to the parents.
412
00:18:54,318 --> 00:18:56,353
♪
413
00:18:56,387 --> 00:18:58,353
Mom had a hard time.
414
00:18:58,387 --> 00:19:01,111
She was extremely upset,
tearful.
415
00:19:01,146 --> 00:19:03,008
♪
416
00:19:03,043 --> 00:19:07,284
The plainclothes detectives
came in, and they said to me,
417
00:19:07,318 --> 00:19:08,767
"Are you
Stacie Goulet's mother?"
418
00:19:08,801 --> 00:19:10,284
I said, "Yes," and they said,
419
00:19:10,318 --> 00:19:13,111
"Well, Stacie
was reported missing,
420
00:19:13,146 --> 00:19:17,387
"and, you know...
421
00:19:17,422 --> 00:19:20,732
we have some information
that we need to give you."
422
00:19:20,767 --> 00:19:23,974
And they said, "Did you know
that Stacie was a prostitute?"
423
00:19:24,008 --> 00:19:27,043
And I said, "Well,
she had told me she was."
424
00:19:27,077 --> 00:19:29,111
When I found out, I said,
425
00:19:29,146 --> 00:19:31,111
"Stacie, you know,
it's dangerous.
426
00:19:31,146 --> 00:19:33,077
You can get killed out there."
427
00:19:33,111 --> 00:19:35,732
And I was like,
"Well, Stacie, it's wrong."
428
00:19:35,767 --> 00:19:38,767
"I know it's wrong, Mom,
but I'm gonna do it anyways."
429
00:19:38,801 --> 00:19:40,905
So I was kind of, like,
all nervous
430
00:19:40,939 --> 00:19:42,629
and all shaken up
and everything.
431
00:19:42,663 --> 00:19:44,698
♪
432
00:19:44,732 --> 00:19:47,767
I kind of, like, just hoped
for the best.
433
00:19:47,801 --> 00:19:50,836
You know, I didn't want to put
that she was murdered.
434
00:19:50,870 --> 00:19:53,801
I didn't want to put that
in my head.
435
00:19:53,836 --> 00:19:57,870
Audrey Harris is missing.
Christine Dumont is missing.
436
00:19:57,905 --> 00:20:01,284
And now with this new
Stacie Goulet case,
437
00:20:01,318 --> 00:20:02,870
3 missing in 15 months
438
00:20:02,905 --> 00:20:06,422
was just too much
to believe it was chance.
439
00:20:06,456 --> 00:20:08,180
♪
440
00:20:08,215 --> 00:20:11,560
They were all involved in
the same prostitution trade.
441
00:20:11,594 --> 00:20:13,077
But if they were related,
442
00:20:13,111 --> 00:20:15,629
then we could possibly have
a serial killer on our hands.
443
00:20:15,663 --> 00:20:17,767
♪
444
00:20:17,801 --> 00:20:19,836
So, if prostitutes
are going missing,
445
00:20:19,870 --> 00:20:22,491
what's the best way
to drudge up some suspects?
446
00:20:22,525 --> 00:20:24,111
We decided to do a john sting.
447
00:20:24,146 --> 00:20:28,801
♪
448
00:20:28,836 --> 00:20:31,284
The best practice
identifying johns,
449
00:20:31,318 --> 00:20:35,974
is putting a female police
officer out on the street.
450
00:20:36,008 --> 00:20:38,491
We set up decoys
at the corners
451
00:20:38,525 --> 00:20:42,284
where the prostitutes were
known to frequent and loiter.
452
00:20:42,318 --> 00:20:46,974
We ended up arresting
quite a few johns.
453
00:20:47,008 --> 00:20:51,111
The biggest thing
was not so much charging them
454
00:20:51,146 --> 00:20:54,456
but using that opportunity
to question them
455
00:20:54,491 --> 00:20:58,456
to see if anything may come up,
any leads in any investigation,
456
00:20:58,491 --> 00:21:01,284
or certain anomalies
on the johns
457
00:21:01,318 --> 00:21:03,387
that may indicate
they may be involved
458
00:21:03,422 --> 00:21:06,456
in some type of foul play.
459
00:21:06,491 --> 00:21:08,491
Unfortunately,
we didn't get anything.
460
00:21:08,525 --> 00:21:11,629
♪
461
00:21:11,663 --> 00:21:14,732
If there is a serial killer
who is preying on sex workers,
462
00:21:14,767 --> 00:21:17,146
then police have
some challenges ahead.
463
00:21:17,180 --> 00:21:20,180
There are no bodies,
and there are no crime scenes.
464
00:21:20,215 --> 00:21:22,663
If these women
who have gone missing
465
00:21:22,698 --> 00:21:24,422
are in fact being killed,
466
00:21:24,456 --> 00:21:26,008
you're dealing
with a serial killer
467
00:21:26,043 --> 00:21:29,629
who has the means and ability
to hide these bodies.
468
00:21:29,663 --> 00:21:31,629
So this is
a sophisticated killer,
469
00:21:31,663 --> 00:21:35,629
who's able to elude detection,
elude law enforcement
470
00:21:35,663 --> 00:21:38,801
and hide any potential evidence
of their crimes.
471
00:21:38,836 --> 00:21:41,456
All three women did frequent
472
00:21:41,491 --> 00:21:44,456
the same track or area
473
00:21:44,491 --> 00:21:46,456
that was known
for prostitution.
474
00:21:46,491 --> 00:21:49,111
That might be
a common denominator
475
00:21:49,146 --> 00:21:50,629
among the women.
476
00:21:50,663 --> 00:21:53,629
Do you have other women
on that track
477
00:21:53,663 --> 00:21:56,284
that might have been assaulted
and survived?
478
00:21:56,318 --> 00:21:57,974
That's where your real case
479
00:21:58,008 --> 00:22:01,801
is gonna start
to pick up some wheels.
480
00:22:01,836 --> 00:22:03,456
As the investigation
progressed,
481
00:22:03,491 --> 00:22:05,456
we really spent a lot of time
482
00:22:05,491 --> 00:22:08,629
talking to other street girls,
483
00:22:08,663 --> 00:22:10,974
stopping cars,
talking to patrol.
484
00:22:11,008 --> 00:22:13,629
We were just trying to get
any further information.
485
00:22:13,663 --> 00:22:15,767
Our activity helped
486
00:22:15,801 --> 00:22:17,801
in us receiving
an anonymous tip.
487
00:22:23,732 --> 00:22:25,284
From out of the blue,
488
00:22:25,318 --> 00:22:29,146
she said that he came up
from behind, choked her.
489
00:22:29,180 --> 00:22:31,043
That's the most nervous
I've ever been
490
00:22:31,077 --> 00:22:32,387
as a police officer.
491
00:22:36,491 --> 00:22:39,353
All three cases
of the missing females,
492
00:22:39,387 --> 00:22:41,974
Audrey, Christine, and Stacie,
493
00:22:42,008 --> 00:22:43,836
were eerily similar.
494
00:22:43,870 --> 00:22:45,491
There was no leads to go on.
495
00:22:45,525 --> 00:22:48,180
It was extremely frustrating.
496
00:22:49,767 --> 00:22:52,146
On July 11th,
497
00:22:52,180 --> 00:22:55,111
I received a message
on my work phone.
498
00:22:55,146 --> 00:22:56,318
It was a male voice.
499
00:23:05,663 --> 00:23:08,663
All it said was, "You may want
to speak to Jocelin Martel.
500
00:23:08,698 --> 00:23:11,318
She may have some information
on your missing girls."
501
00:23:11,353 --> 00:23:13,249
Click. That was it.
502
00:23:15,249 --> 00:23:16,767
We were familiar
with Jocelin Martel.
503
00:23:16,801 --> 00:23:18,318
She was a known prostitute.
504
00:23:18,353 --> 00:23:22,939
She was currently incarcerated
at the women's prison,
505
00:23:22,974 --> 00:23:25,180
and we immediately
made arrangements
506
00:23:25,215 --> 00:23:27,146
to go speak with her.
507
00:23:27,180 --> 00:23:30,663
After she'd heard
that three girls were missing,
508
00:23:30,698 --> 00:23:33,008
she started to feel
that maybe she could help
509
00:23:33,043 --> 00:23:34,491
in an investigation.
510
00:23:36,732 --> 00:23:39,663
She told us about an incident
that she had with a john,
511
00:23:39,698 --> 00:23:41,215
maybe a month before,
512
00:23:41,249 --> 00:23:43,905
and that he brought her
back to his apartment
513
00:23:43,939 --> 00:23:45,836
on Cato Street.
514
00:23:45,870 --> 00:23:47,249
From out of the blue,
515
00:23:47,284 --> 00:23:50,905
she said that he came up
from behind, choked her.
516
00:23:52,456 --> 00:23:54,732
She thought
that her life was over.
517
00:23:54,767 --> 00:23:56,456
♪
518
00:23:56,491 --> 00:23:59,422
She somehow
managed to fight him off
519
00:23:59,456 --> 00:24:01,008
and get away from him.
520
00:24:01,043 --> 00:24:03,698
♪
521
00:24:03,732 --> 00:24:07,594
She told us that the man was
male, Caucasian, short, stocky,
522
00:24:07,629 --> 00:24:12,146
maybe in the early 30s,
late 20s, short hair.
523
00:24:13,870 --> 00:24:16,732
She thought that just
the way that he came after her
524
00:24:16,767 --> 00:24:18,594
in such a violent nature,
525
00:24:18,629 --> 00:24:19,836
it was not the first time
526
00:24:19,870 --> 00:24:23,422
he's been involved
in something like this.
527
00:24:23,456 --> 00:24:25,836
She wasn't sure of
the street number at the time,
528
00:24:25,870 --> 00:24:28,456
but she was able to explain.
529
00:24:28,491 --> 00:24:32,249
It was a white multifamily
house with green shutters,
530
00:24:32,284 --> 00:24:34,698
small white fence
in front of the house.
531
00:24:34,732 --> 00:24:36,663
♪
532
00:24:36,698 --> 00:24:40,318
On the way back, we actually
drove down Cato Street.
533
00:24:40,353 --> 00:24:42,836
The location that she gave us
and the house
534
00:24:42,870 --> 00:24:47,491
was a spitting image
of how she described it,
535
00:24:47,525 --> 00:24:50,836
and we retrieved the address
number of the house.
536
00:24:50,870 --> 00:24:53,111
At that point, I notified
the electrical company
537
00:24:53,146 --> 00:24:55,043
to find out who lived there.
538
00:24:55,077 --> 00:24:56,801
And then I went back
to the station
539
00:24:56,836 --> 00:24:59,698
and start looking through
our database at this location
540
00:24:59,732 --> 00:25:02,560
to see if there had been
any incidents there.
541
00:25:02,594 --> 00:25:05,836
And to our surprise,
one popped up right away
542
00:25:05,870 --> 00:25:08,525
with a known prostitute--
Teese Morris.
543
00:25:08,560 --> 00:25:11,836
So we needed to speak
with Teese immediately.
544
00:25:11,870 --> 00:25:14,560
♪
545
00:25:14,594 --> 00:25:17,663
Teese had a story
extremely similar
546
00:25:17,698 --> 00:25:21,146
to Jocelin's story.
547
00:25:21,180 --> 00:25:24,146
It was February 15, 2004.
548
00:25:24,180 --> 00:25:25,732
It was my birthday.
549
00:25:25,767 --> 00:25:28,146
I wanted to go out.
I wanted to have fun.
550
00:25:29,629 --> 00:25:31,387
There was one gentleman,
and he said,
551
00:25:31,422 --> 00:25:34,491
"Put your money away.
I'll buy you a beer.
552
00:25:34,525 --> 00:25:37,318
This man looked...
553
00:25:37,353 --> 00:25:39,663
like a everyday man.
554
00:25:39,698 --> 00:25:41,594
♪
555
00:25:41,629 --> 00:25:44,146
We ended up back at his home.
556
00:25:44,180 --> 00:25:46,801
I needed a napkin, and he said,
557
00:25:46,836 --> 00:25:49,663
"Go to that drawer
right there."
558
00:25:49,698 --> 00:25:54,043
When I opened the drawer
is when he pounced.
559
00:25:54,077 --> 00:25:56,318
He grabbed me in my neck,
560
00:25:56,353 --> 00:25:59,663
and he just got tighter,
561
00:25:59,698 --> 00:26:01,836
and I'm thinking...
562
00:26:01,870 --> 00:26:04,249
"Okay, he's not playing."
563
00:26:04,284 --> 00:26:07,663
Instantly you go
into panic mode.
564
00:26:07,698 --> 00:26:10,180
So, "All right,
I can't get him off my neck."
565
00:26:10,215 --> 00:26:12,974
I couldn't get air.
566
00:26:13,008 --> 00:26:15,318
I'm grabbing at his eyes.
567
00:26:15,353 --> 00:26:16,767
I'm trying to get at him.
568
00:26:16,801 --> 00:26:18,387
I'm thinking to myself like,
569
00:26:18,422 --> 00:26:20,318
"This guy has got
to get off of me.
570
00:26:20,353 --> 00:26:22,215
He's got to get off me."
571
00:26:23,698 --> 00:26:25,594
I pushed all the way back.
572
00:26:25,629 --> 00:26:28,318
I banged his back on his stove,
573
00:26:28,353 --> 00:26:32,008
and I went with a lot of force.
574
00:26:32,043 --> 00:26:33,629
And I'm begging,
I'm screaming,
575
00:26:33,663 --> 00:26:36,732
"Please, my daughter!
I got to see my daughter!"
576
00:26:38,180 --> 00:26:40,491
He dragged me
towards the door, and he said,
577
00:26:40,525 --> 00:26:43,008
"If I ever see you
outside again"...
578
00:26:43,043 --> 00:26:47,146
"I'll kill you."
579
00:26:51,353 --> 00:26:57,767
♪
580
00:26:57,801 --> 00:27:01,077
Both the victims,
Jocelin and Teese,
581
00:27:01,111 --> 00:27:03,939
described as assault on them...
582
00:27:03,974 --> 00:27:07,318
as a choking-hold
to render them unconscious,
583
00:27:07,353 --> 00:27:10,974
♪
584
00:27:11,008 --> 00:27:12,905
He invited these women
back to the house.
585
00:27:12,939 --> 00:27:15,146
So, obviously, the objective
586
00:27:15,180 --> 00:27:17,318
is maybe to have a good time,
587
00:27:17,353 --> 00:27:20,491
but he attacked these women
from the rear.
588
00:27:20,525 --> 00:27:23,836
He placed them in a choke hold
that is, you know,
589
00:27:23,870 --> 00:27:26,008
similar to that
of a pro wrestler.
590
00:27:26,043 --> 00:27:28,836
Maybe just the act
of strangling them
591
00:27:28,870 --> 00:27:31,456
was what aroused him,
and he didn't need to have sex.
592
00:27:31,491 --> 00:27:35,491
Pouncing on them,
unaware, from behind,
593
00:27:35,525 --> 00:27:37,180
that's what he seemed
to get a rush out of.
594
00:27:37,215 --> 00:27:39,008
He's sort of jumping
595
00:27:39,043 --> 00:27:41,318
straight to strangulation.
596
00:27:41,353 --> 00:27:43,215
And this says a lot about him.
597
00:27:43,249 --> 00:27:47,215
In this instance, the
strangulation in and of itself
598
00:27:47,249 --> 00:27:49,870
might be enough to bring him
the gratification
599
00:27:49,905 --> 00:27:52,146
that he needs.
600
00:27:52,180 --> 00:27:54,939
We started thinking,
"Well, maybe this was connected
601
00:27:54,974 --> 00:27:57,318
with these
three missing girls."
602
00:27:57,353 --> 00:27:58,939
Through
the electrical bills,
603
00:27:58,974 --> 00:28:01,043
we were able to determine
604
00:28:01,077 --> 00:28:04,663
that one person was living in
the whole building at the time.
605
00:28:04,698 --> 00:28:06,525
His name was Jeffrey Mailhot.
606
00:28:06,560 --> 00:28:09,146
♪
607
00:28:09,180 --> 00:28:13,732
From there, we start checking
all type of background issues,
608
00:28:13,767 --> 00:28:16,077
and we just didn't come up
with anything.
609
00:28:16,111 --> 00:28:18,077
There was no prior history.
610
00:28:18,111 --> 00:28:21,491
We had to actually go to
the registry of motor vehicles
611
00:28:21,525 --> 00:28:24,905
and use a picture
from his license
612
00:28:24,939 --> 00:28:27,008
to form a lineup.
613
00:28:27,043 --> 00:28:29,353
♪
614
00:28:29,387 --> 00:28:31,249
He looked like
such an unassuming person.
615
00:28:31,284 --> 00:28:33,318
It'd be hard to believe
that he was involved
616
00:28:33,353 --> 00:28:35,318
in this type of activity.
617
00:28:35,353 --> 00:28:39,146
♪
618
00:28:39,180 --> 00:28:41,215
I took the lineup
back to Jocelin,
619
00:28:41,249 --> 00:28:44,146
and she picked out
Jeffery Mailhot.
620
00:28:44,180 --> 00:28:46,077
♪
621
00:28:46,111 --> 00:28:47,836
Then we spoke
with Teese Morris.
622
00:28:47,870 --> 00:28:50,491
And it just was like, boom,
623
00:28:50,525 --> 00:28:52,146
that's him.
624
00:28:52,180 --> 00:28:54,870
♪
625
00:28:54,905 --> 00:28:58,043
We were able to obtain
a search warrant.
626
00:28:58,077 --> 00:29:00,491
We could see what was
clearly blood spatter.
627
00:29:00,525 --> 00:29:02,284
♪
628
00:29:02,318 --> 00:29:05,008
He said, "You think I killed
those three girls?"
629
00:29:05,043 --> 00:29:06,491
And I looked at him, I said,
630
00:29:06,525 --> 00:29:08,560
"We never said
that they were dead."
631
00:29:15,077 --> 00:29:16,905
We had three missing
prostitutes--
632
00:29:16,939 --> 00:29:19,939
Audrey Harris,
Christine Dumont...
633
00:29:19,974 --> 00:29:23,525
and Stacie Goulet.
634
00:29:23,560 --> 00:29:27,318
We also established
that there was a John out there
635
00:29:27,353 --> 00:29:30,870
that had two violent assaults
with Jocelin Martel
636
00:29:30,905 --> 00:29:33,111
and Teese Morris.
637
00:29:33,146 --> 00:29:35,422
From what we determined
from those two witnesses,
638
00:29:35,456 --> 00:29:38,043
his name was Jeffrey Mailhot.
639
00:29:38,077 --> 00:29:41,043
♪
640
00:29:41,077 --> 00:29:43,215
So we were able to obtain
a search warrant
641
00:29:43,249 --> 00:29:46,767
and an arrest warrant for
Mr. Mailhot for the assaults.
642
00:29:48,077 --> 00:29:50,318
We set up a surveillance
on the house
643
00:29:50,353 --> 00:29:53,870
and waited for Mr. Mailhot
to return from work.
644
00:29:55,422 --> 00:29:57,043
We're sitting there
a little bit down the street,
645
00:29:57,077 --> 00:29:58,629
waiting for Jeffrey Mailhot
to show up,
646
00:29:58,663 --> 00:30:02,905
and then we were gonna grab him
before he got in his house.
647
00:30:02,939 --> 00:30:06,008
So, as soon as he pulled up,
got out of his vehicle,
648
00:30:06,043 --> 00:30:07,698
we quickly approached him.
649
00:30:07,732 --> 00:30:09,663
♪
650
00:30:09,698 --> 00:30:11,077
I said,
"Are you Jeffrey Mailhot?"
651
00:30:11,111 --> 00:30:14,663
He said, "Yes."
I said, "You're under arrest."
652
00:30:14,698 --> 00:30:16,249
Then he asked me, "What for?"
653
00:30:16,284 --> 00:30:20,111
I said, "For the assault
of two young ladies."
654
00:30:20,146 --> 00:30:23,111
I told him that we would
have a conversation with him
655
00:30:23,146 --> 00:30:26,353
at the station,
and he was very cooperative.
656
00:30:26,387 --> 00:30:29,629
And he was put in the back
of a police cruiser
657
00:30:29,663 --> 00:30:31,215
and transported to the station.
658
00:30:31,249 --> 00:30:33,767
♪
659
00:30:33,801 --> 00:30:36,111
I walked into that house
with a search warrant,
660
00:30:36,146 --> 00:30:40,939
and the house
was just orderly and neat.
661
00:30:42,387 --> 00:30:43,698
We opened up the cupboards,
662
00:30:43,732 --> 00:30:46,318
and it almost looked like
he took a ruler
663
00:30:46,353 --> 00:30:49,008
and measured the distance
between the glasses.
664
00:30:50,905 --> 00:30:55,077
Everything was size-coded,
color-coded, and alphabetized.
665
00:30:55,111 --> 00:30:57,353
It was just super orderly.
666
00:30:57,387 --> 00:30:59,146
♪
667
00:30:59,180 --> 00:31:00,663
Jeff Mailhot's house
668
00:31:00,698 --> 00:31:02,491
didn't look like
it supported the two assaults,
669
00:31:02,525 --> 00:31:04,767
let alone
three missing victims.
670
00:31:06,077 --> 00:31:08,456
But then we went
into the bathroom
671
00:31:08,491 --> 00:31:09,801
and looked at the tub,
672
00:31:09,836 --> 00:31:12,180
and the bottom was just grimy
673
00:31:12,215 --> 00:31:15,180
in, like, ground-in filth.
674
00:31:15,215 --> 00:31:17,215
♪
675
00:31:17,249 --> 00:31:20,180
And as the lieutenant
got his flashlight,
676
00:31:20,215 --> 00:31:22,732
in that area
underneath the tub,
677
00:31:22,767 --> 00:31:27,525
we could see what was
clearly a blood spatter.
678
00:31:27,560 --> 00:31:30,698
And so we sprayed the bathroom
area with luminol,
679
00:31:30,732 --> 00:31:33,836
and you could see
the floor fluoresce--
680
00:31:33,870 --> 00:31:35,732
a big area of the floor.
681
00:31:35,767 --> 00:31:39,905
This was pooling blood
that had been on that surface
682
00:31:39,939 --> 00:31:43,008
long enough for it
to seep into grout,
683
00:31:43,043 --> 00:31:45,043
which is almost like cement.
684
00:31:45,077 --> 00:31:47,180
♪
685
00:31:47,215 --> 00:31:50,698
That's the most nervous I've
ever been as a police officer,
686
00:31:50,732 --> 00:31:52,663
because I'm standing in a house
687
00:31:52,698 --> 00:31:55,043
where there
is potential evidence
688
00:31:55,077 --> 00:31:57,491
of a serial killer.
689
00:31:57,525 --> 00:32:00,525
If Jeffrey Mailhot is in fact
the killer,
690
00:32:00,560 --> 00:32:04,629
what authorities find
in his house is very telling.
691
00:32:04,663 --> 00:32:07,180
They find, in some ways,
692
00:32:07,215 --> 00:32:10,043
a meticulous household
693
00:32:10,077 --> 00:32:12,215
with everything
sort of in its place,
694
00:32:12,249 --> 00:32:14,043
and then certain areas
of the house
695
00:32:14,077 --> 00:32:17,008
are in complete disarray
and absolutely filthy.
696
00:32:17,043 --> 00:32:18,905
This tells us, in some ways,
697
00:32:18,939 --> 00:32:20,663
a lot
about how his brain works.
698
00:32:20,698 --> 00:32:21,836
He compartmentalizes.
699
00:32:21,870 --> 00:32:24,456
He is likely
a highly organized killer.
700
00:32:24,491 --> 00:32:27,663
An organized killer
is someone
701
00:32:27,698 --> 00:32:30,870
who methodically chooses
702
00:32:30,905 --> 00:32:32,353
the right victim.
703
00:32:32,387 --> 00:32:35,353
He has a plan of attack...
704
00:32:35,387 --> 00:32:37,180
and he's going to do this
705
00:32:37,215 --> 00:32:40,491
the same way every time.
706
00:32:40,525 --> 00:32:43,870
If Jeffrey Mailhot
is an organized killer
707
00:32:43,905 --> 00:32:46,663
then there are going to be
challenges for the police
708
00:32:46,698 --> 00:32:49,698
'cause he's an expert
at covering his tracks.
709
00:32:49,732 --> 00:32:55,353
♪
710
00:32:55,387 --> 00:32:58,422
The time is 8:33 p.m....
711
00:33:01,008 --> 00:33:03,077
We had Jeffrey Mailhot
brought up
712
00:33:03,111 --> 00:33:05,629
to the interrogation room
by a uniformed police.
713
00:33:08,043 --> 00:33:09,698
Sergeant Lee
sat across the room.
714
00:33:09,732 --> 00:33:10,801
I sat off to the side.
715
00:33:10,836 --> 00:33:13,043
Basically what we try to do
716
00:33:13,077 --> 00:33:14,974
from the beginning
is establish a rapport.
717
00:33:24,353 --> 00:33:26,836
At first,
he was very hesitant,
718
00:33:26,870 --> 00:33:29,318
but after talking with him,
719
00:33:29,353 --> 00:33:32,525
he then admitted that
he had been with prostitutes.
720
00:33:32,560 --> 00:33:35,939
I mentioned the assaults
on Teese and Jocelin.
721
00:33:35,974 --> 00:33:39,698
That's when he was able to say,
"Yeah, I had an incident,
722
00:33:39,732 --> 00:33:41,180
and things got
a little bit physical."
723
00:33:43,215 --> 00:33:44,249
Yeah.
724
00:33:51,111 --> 00:33:55,180
At that point,
I had three pictures--
725
00:33:55,215 --> 00:33:57,560
one of the each
of the missing girls.
726
00:33:57,594 --> 00:34:01,111
I decided to put those pitches
out in front of him on a table
727
00:34:01,146 --> 00:34:03,836
to see, you know,
what type of reaction
728
00:34:03,870 --> 00:34:07,180
I would be able to garner
from him.
729
00:34:07,215 --> 00:34:11,284
He immediately became
visibly shaking, nervous.
730
00:34:11,318 --> 00:34:13,180
And Eddie asked and said,
731
00:34:13,215 --> 00:34:15,353
"Well, what are you
so nervous for?"
732
00:34:15,387 --> 00:34:19,698
And Jeff told us, he said,
"Well, it's 'cause you think
733
00:34:19,732 --> 00:34:22,180
I killed those three girls."
734
00:34:22,215 --> 00:34:24,629
And I looked at him, I said,
"Well, Jeff, we never said
735
00:34:24,663 --> 00:34:26,043
"that they were dead.
736
00:34:26,077 --> 00:34:27,525
"Do you know
if they're dead or not?
737
00:34:27,560 --> 00:34:30,077
We only told you that we're
investigating missing girls."
738
00:34:38,215 --> 00:34:41,353
♪
739
00:34:41,387 --> 00:34:44,732
Eddie gets up and walks
out of the interview room.
740
00:34:44,767 --> 00:34:46,387
So I started to sit with him,
and I'm like,
741
00:34:46,422 --> 00:34:49,456
"Listen, dude, you're
in some sh-- right now.
742
00:34:49,491 --> 00:34:51,146
"You already talked
about assault
743
00:34:51,180 --> 00:34:53,215
"on a couple of girls,
and that seems
744
00:34:53,249 --> 00:34:54,974
"to have something to do with
these three missing girls.
745
00:34:55,008 --> 00:34:57,043
So why don't you just say it?"
746
00:34:57,077 --> 00:34:59,801
So he's almost
breaking down, crying.
747
00:34:59,836 --> 00:35:02,043
I walk outside,
748
00:35:02,077 --> 00:35:06,146
and I say, "Hey,
I think he's ready to go."
749
00:35:06,180 --> 00:35:08,422
You could just tell
that he was starting
750
00:35:08,456 --> 00:35:10,732
to get ready to say something.
751
00:35:26,215 --> 00:35:27,249
Huh?
752
00:35:32,525 --> 00:35:34,663
We were all just in shock,
you know?
753
00:35:34,698 --> 00:35:36,491
And we were like, "Oh, my God,
this is a reality.
754
00:35:36,525 --> 00:35:39,180
This guy is, like,
killing these women."
755
00:35:39,215 --> 00:35:41,043
We said, "Start with
Audrey Harris, the first girl.
756
00:35:41,077 --> 00:35:42,146
What happened?"
757
00:35:43,905 --> 00:35:44,939
Mm-hmm.
758
00:36:08,629 --> 00:36:11,698
He said when he woke up,
it was a little hazy.
759
00:36:11,732 --> 00:36:13,180
He thought it was a bad dream.
760
00:36:13,215 --> 00:36:17,525
He walked into the bathroom,
saw her laying there.
761
00:36:17,560 --> 00:36:19,318
He was scared for a while.
762
00:36:19,353 --> 00:36:23,077
Then once he realized that,
"Hey, nobody caught me,
763
00:36:23,111 --> 00:36:24,870
"no police knocked on my door,
764
00:36:24,905 --> 00:36:26,801
it wasn't even
in the newspaper,"
765
00:36:26,836 --> 00:36:29,043
after a while, he was like,
"Oh, you know what?
766
00:36:29,077 --> 00:36:30,594
I can do that again."
767
00:36:35,215 --> 00:36:38,318
He said he had
an uncontrollable urge
768
00:36:38,353 --> 00:36:39,525
to kill again.
769
00:36:39,560 --> 00:36:41,525
He said it was just
something inside him
770
00:36:41,560 --> 00:36:43,215
that just kept
telling him to do it.
771
00:36:43,249 --> 00:36:45,043
He was haunted.
772
00:36:45,077 --> 00:36:49,663
So he went out,
and he got Christine Dumont.
773
00:36:58,387 --> 00:37:01,491
♪
774
00:37:01,525 --> 00:37:05,111
So, after successfully
murdering two young ladies
775
00:37:05,146 --> 00:37:08,284
and getting away with it, he
picked up young Stacie Goulet,
776
00:37:08,318 --> 00:37:10,249
strangled, and murdered her.
777
00:37:19,491 --> 00:37:21,180
He said the biggest rush
he would get
778
00:37:21,215 --> 00:37:23,215
is not
when he was choking them,
779
00:37:23,249 --> 00:37:24,870
but when he actually
locked the door
780
00:37:24,905 --> 00:37:26,836
and knew that
they couldn't leave.
781
00:37:28,560 --> 00:37:32,043
So my immediate question was,
"Well, where are they?"
782
00:37:43,698 --> 00:37:45,974
Jeff Mailhot
was in the interrogation room.
783
00:37:49,422 --> 00:37:50,905
Now we got the confession.
784
00:37:50,939 --> 00:37:53,594
I'm looking, you know,
for the bodies at this point.
785
00:37:53,629 --> 00:37:56,043
So my immediate question
was, "Where are they now?"
786
00:38:29,146 --> 00:38:32,043
He thought about an episode
on "The Sopranos"
787
00:38:32,077 --> 00:38:35,043
where someone
had dismembered a body,
788
00:38:35,077 --> 00:38:37,525
and he decided
that he would take that route.
789
00:38:37,560 --> 00:38:41,146
Went to a hardware store,
bought a saw.
790
00:38:42,422 --> 00:38:44,939
He would throw the bags
in the dumpster,
791
00:38:44,974 --> 00:38:47,629
figuring that all the garbage
will just be taken away.
792
00:38:47,663 --> 00:38:50,663
♪
793
00:38:50,698 --> 00:38:53,318
This guy gave them
explicit detail
794
00:38:53,353 --> 00:38:55,905
for each particular woman,
795
00:38:55,939 --> 00:38:58,491
even down to the body parts...
796
00:38:58,525 --> 00:39:00,732
of how they were dismembered.
797
00:39:00,767 --> 00:39:05,560
The overwhelming amount
of detail...
798
00:39:05,594 --> 00:39:07,836
shows the pleasure
that he got out of it.
799
00:39:07,870 --> 00:39:11,249
His decision to cut up
the bodies wasn't emotional.
800
00:39:11,284 --> 00:39:14,077
It wasn't blood lust.
It was a practical decision.
801
00:39:14,111 --> 00:39:16,284
He needed to get rid
of the bodies.
802
00:39:16,318 --> 00:39:18,284
Knowing what we do
about him,
803
00:39:18,318 --> 00:39:20,353
it sort of makes sense.
804
00:39:20,387 --> 00:39:23,077
He keeps a meticulous home.
805
00:39:23,111 --> 00:39:24,732
He's organized.
806
00:39:24,767 --> 00:39:27,111
He's not necessarily impulsive,
807
00:39:27,146 --> 00:39:29,387
and cutting up a body
and disposing of it
808
00:39:29,422 --> 00:39:31,939
is easier than disposing
of an entire body.
809
00:39:31,974 --> 00:39:36,111
It also poses a unique
challenge for investigators.
810
00:39:37,767 --> 00:39:39,111
We had no bodies.
811
00:39:39,146 --> 00:39:42,077
His confession was detailed
and compelling,
812
00:39:42,111 --> 00:39:45,077
but if a suspect confesses
to a crime,
813
00:39:45,111 --> 00:39:47,111
that statement
cannot be used against him
814
00:39:47,146 --> 00:39:51,249
unless there's evidence
independent of the confession
815
00:39:51,284 --> 00:39:53,525
that that crime occurred.
816
00:39:53,560 --> 00:39:56,422
Jeffrey Mailhot described
where the dumpsters were
817
00:39:56,456 --> 00:39:57,905
that he put the body parts,
818
00:39:57,939 --> 00:40:01,732
and we could determine
where the Woonsocket trash
819
00:40:01,767 --> 00:40:04,077
was dumped
at the central landfill.
820
00:40:04,111 --> 00:40:05,905
♪
821
00:40:05,939 --> 00:40:07,353
We had some state police
822
00:40:07,387 --> 00:40:09,801
and the guys
who work the landfill.
823
00:40:09,836 --> 00:40:12,732
They ended up digging
a 100 yards wide
824
00:40:12,767 --> 00:40:17,560
by a 100 yards long
by 20 feet deep.
825
00:40:17,594 --> 00:40:20,215
That was their area of search.
826
00:40:20,249 --> 00:40:22,836
Audrey had been gone
for a year and a half.
827
00:40:22,870 --> 00:40:24,732
And Christine, four months.
828
00:40:24,767 --> 00:40:26,801
We're looking for bags
of body parts.
829
00:40:26,836 --> 00:40:28,043
It wasn't one body.
830
00:40:28,077 --> 00:40:30,698
It was pieces of bodies,
831
00:40:30,732 --> 00:40:35,215
double-bagged, cinch-tied,
buried under tons of debris
832
00:40:35,249 --> 00:40:38,801
with material spread on it
through enhanced decomposition.
833
00:40:38,836 --> 00:40:41,732
So it was like looking
for a needle on a haystack.
834
00:40:41,767 --> 00:40:45,905
♪
835
00:40:45,939 --> 00:40:50,560
One of our patrol officers--
he was still a recruit--
836
00:40:50,594 --> 00:40:53,698
he was raking,
and the bag ripped open,
837
00:40:53,732 --> 00:40:56,560
and he saw
what looked like remains.
838
00:40:56,594 --> 00:41:00,353
He said like hair,
and it looked like arms.
839
00:41:00,387 --> 00:41:03,249
He could see that it was
a petite female.
840
00:41:03,284 --> 00:41:05,318
Then the body
was immediately transported
841
00:41:05,353 --> 00:41:07,560
to the medical examiner's
office.
842
00:41:07,594 --> 00:41:10,905
♪
843
00:41:10,939 --> 00:41:14,284
Came back that the remains
that we found in the landfill
844
00:41:14,318 --> 00:41:17,387
matched the DNA profile
of Stacie Goulet.
845
00:41:17,422 --> 00:41:19,215
♪
846
00:41:19,249 --> 00:41:21,387
Finding Stacie was a miracle.
847
00:41:21,422 --> 00:41:23,870
♪
848
00:41:23,905 --> 00:41:26,215
No remains
of Christine Dumont
849
00:41:26,249 --> 00:41:28,077
or Audrey Harris
were ever found.
850
00:41:28,111 --> 00:41:31,525
♪
851
00:41:31,560 --> 00:41:34,422
We got results
for the bloodstains
852
00:41:34,456 --> 00:41:36,387
in Jeff Mailhot's house.
853
00:41:36,422 --> 00:41:40,560
There were three distinct
bloodstains underneath the tub.
854
00:41:40,594 --> 00:41:42,870
The biggest
of those blood drops
855
00:41:42,905 --> 00:41:46,008
matched a combination
of Audrey Harris
856
00:41:46,043 --> 00:41:48,387
and Christine Dumont's DNA.
857
00:41:48,422 --> 00:41:54,215
♪
858
00:41:54,249 --> 00:41:57,043
Jeffrey Mailhot was charged
with three counts of murder,
859
00:41:57,077 --> 00:42:00,456
one count with assault and
intent to murder on Jocelin,
860
00:42:00,491 --> 00:42:04,318
one count of felony assault
on Teese.
861
00:42:04,353 --> 00:42:07,560
On February 16, 2006,
862
00:42:07,594 --> 00:42:09,456
he pled guilty
to all five counts.
863
00:42:09,491 --> 00:42:11,594
The three murder counts
carried life sentence.
864
00:42:11,629 --> 00:42:13,077
It was first-degree murder.
865
00:42:13,111 --> 00:42:14,732
♪
866
00:42:14,767 --> 00:42:17,353
The scary part
about Jeffrey Mailhot,
867
00:42:17,387 --> 00:42:19,387
he lived in plain sight--
868
00:42:19,422 --> 00:42:22,560
just red-blooded
American male,
869
00:42:22,594 --> 00:42:25,663
choking prostitutes
in the middle of the night,
870
00:42:25,698 --> 00:42:28,215
chopping their bodies up
and scattering them about,
871
00:42:28,249 --> 00:42:29,698
then going to work
the next day.
872
00:42:29,732 --> 00:42:31,180
There are people
in the world like that
873
00:42:31,215 --> 00:42:33,387
that live amongst us,
874
00:42:33,422 --> 00:42:35,077
and not all of them get caught.
875
00:42:35,111 --> 00:42:40,560
♪
876
00:42:40,594 --> 00:42:44,180
After all these years,
you know, it still--
877
00:42:44,215 --> 00:42:46,111
it bothers me in my heart.
878
00:42:46,146 --> 00:42:48,215
Stacie didn't deserve that.
879
00:42:48,249 --> 00:42:49,905
Nobody deserves that.
880
00:42:49,939 --> 00:42:51,905
♪
881
00:42:51,939 --> 00:42:54,215
The day the police came
and told me,
882
00:42:54,249 --> 00:42:55,525
that was the day
883
00:42:55,560 --> 00:42:59,146
Jeffrey Mailhot ripped
my heart apart.
884
00:42:59,180 --> 00:43:03,387
He took away my only daughter
who meant everything to me.
885
00:43:03,422 --> 00:43:08,249
♪
886
00:43:08,284 --> 00:43:11,767
I did go back and speak
to Audrey's mother.
887
00:43:11,801 --> 00:43:14,387
She was still hurt bad.
888
00:43:14,422 --> 00:43:16,974
I felt a lot of sorrow.
889
00:43:17,008 --> 00:43:20,077
There isn't a human alive
890
00:43:20,111 --> 00:43:21,905
that deserves to have their
life taken
891
00:43:21,939 --> 00:43:23,043
the way these girls did.
892
00:43:23,767 --> 00:43:30,801
♪