1
00:00:06,049 --> 00:00:10,970
‪NETFLIX 影集

2
00:00:11,971 --> 00:00:15,641
{\an8}‪我們請求對嫌犯作成公正判決

3
00:00:15,725 --> 00:00:17,351
{\an8}‪我們要求廢止

4
00:00:17,435 --> 00:00:19,604
{\an8}‪漠視被害人權益的《少年法》

5
00:00:20,271 --> 00:00:24,067
‪這次延和國小學童凶殺案的
‪一審判決結果

6
00:00:24,150 --> 00:00:25,943
‪引起社會輿論熱烈討論

7
00:00:26,027 --> 00:00:28,446
‪即使犯下了嚴重罪行
‪一人僅被判處20年有期徒刑

8
00:00:28,529 --> 00:00:31,741
‪一人則被裁定移送少年輔育院
‪短暫兩年的少年保護處分

9
00:00:31,824 --> 00:00:33,951
‪-對
‪-你有什麼看法？

10
00:00:34,035 --> 00:00:38,372
‪是，我認同少年保護處分
‪收容年限應提高到5年

11
00:00:38,456 --> 00:00:41,918
‪也同意修法調整法定刑事責任年齡

12
00:00:42,001 --> 00:00:43,044
‪雖然持同意立場

13
00:00:43,127 --> 00:00:45,421
‪但我反對廢止《少年法》

14
00:00:45,505 --> 00:00:49,717
‪一旦廢止，所有少年犯罪行為
‪都應受《刑法》拘束規範

15
00:00:50,301 --> 00:00:51,844
‪這太不切實際了

16
00:00:59,227 --> 00:01:01,229
‪公設輔佐人剛才有跟我聯繫

17
00:01:01,312 --> 00:01:03,606
‪他說成友的媽媽決定不抗告了

18
00:01:03,689 --> 00:01:05,691
‪她願意接受一審判決結果

19
00:01:05,775 --> 00:01:06,901
‪這樣嗎？

20
00:01:08,778 --> 00:01:10,154
‪好，那我知道了

21
00:01:10,238 --> 00:01:11,697
‪明天上班時間再詳談

22
00:01:11,781 --> 00:01:13,574
‪是，那麼明天見

23
00:01:15,284 --> 00:01:16,119
‪喂？

24
00:01:16,202 --> 00:01:18,996
‪有個學生說要找法官，該怎麼辦呢？

25
00:01:20,414 --> 00:01:21,707
‪讓人上來吧

26
00:01:24,168 --> 00:01:25,461
‪（陪席法官室）

27
00:01:28,339 --> 00:01:29,340
‪妳…

28
00:01:31,509 --> 00:01:33,678
‪車泰柱法官在哪裡？

29
00:01:34,428 --> 00:01:35,763
‪車法官？

30
00:01:35,847 --> 00:01:37,348
‪車泰柱…

31
00:01:37,890 --> 00:01:39,142
‪喂！

32
00:01:39,225 --> 00:01:40,810
‪喂，妳醒醒

33
00:01:40,893 --> 00:01:42,562
‪妳醒醒啊，徐有悧

34
00:01:42,645 --> 00:01:43,521
‪徐有悧！

35
00:01:44,689 --> 00:01:45,731
‪沈法官

36
00:01:45,815 --> 00:01:47,900
‪妳醒醒啊，徐有悧

37
00:01:47,984 --> 00:01:50,361
‪-徐有悧！有悧！她是怎麼了？
‪-徐有悧

38
00:01:50,444 --> 00:01:52,697
‪-先叫救護車，快打電話
‪-好的

39
00:01:54,740 --> 00:01:56,075
‪-他出來了
‪-他來了

40
00:01:58,661 --> 00:02:02,206
‪這次的判決讓近來風評不佳的
‪司法部重振聲譽

41
00:02:02,290 --> 00:02:03,249
‪你有什麼感言嗎？

42
00:02:03,332 --> 00:02:05,960
‪你支持目前吵得沸沸揚揚的
‪《少年法》修法嗎？

43
00:02:06,043 --> 00:02:08,296
‪經過這次的案件
‪我們體認到一個事實

44
00:02:09,297 --> 00:02:12,800
‪那就是少年案件不再只是個人問題

45
00:02:12,884 --> 00:02:17,263
‪現在該是社會和國家站出來的時候了

46
00:02:18,848 --> 00:02:23,311
‪我只是做了我分內該做的事

47
00:02:23,394 --> 00:02:24,604
‪辛苦各位了

48
00:02:24,687 --> 00:02:26,272
‪-請再說句話
‪-請再說明一下

49
00:02:26,355 --> 00:02:28,149
‪-姜法官
‪-請多說幾句話

50
00:02:30,526 --> 00:02:31,736
‪（急診醫療中心）

51
00:02:34,697 --> 00:02:37,617
‪-往這邊
‪-請先填好資料再進去

52
00:02:42,205 --> 00:02:43,497
‪沈法官，我來…

53
00:02:45,833 --> 00:02:48,002
{\an8}‪（急診室掛號單
‪患者姓名：徐有悧）

54
00:02:53,090 --> 00:02:54,592
‪你們跟那名患者是什麼關係？

55
00:02:55,218 --> 00:02:56,177
‪為什麼這麼問呢？

56
00:02:57,053 --> 00:02:58,221
‪就是他們兩位

57
00:03:03,017 --> 00:03:04,101
‪車法官

58
00:03:04,769 --> 00:03:05,937
‪你好

59
00:03:06,771 --> 00:03:08,064
‪妳是說暴力案件嗎？

60
00:03:08,147 --> 00:03:09,899
‪這在急診室裡很常見

61
00:03:09,982 --> 00:03:13,569
‪我們發現疑似暴力被害人到院時
‪有義務立即報警

62
00:03:14,987 --> 00:03:17,240
‪雖然警方接獲通報就會出動

63
00:03:17,323 --> 00:03:20,117
‪但絕大多數的暴力案件
‪最後總是不了了之

64
00:03:20,201 --> 00:03:22,411
‪現代人不想介入別人的事

65
00:03:22,495 --> 00:03:24,580
‪被害人不願報警的情況也很常見

66
00:03:25,206 --> 00:03:26,874
‪等她醒來後，請通知我們

67
00:03:28,167 --> 00:03:29,293
‪辛苦你們了

68
00:03:32,505 --> 00:03:34,090
‪我想應該不是家庭暴力

69
00:03:35,174 --> 00:03:36,801
‪她身邊沒有會施暴的監護人

70
00:03:44,934 --> 00:03:47,103
‪有悧12歲時父母離婚

71
00:03:47,186 --> 00:03:49,397
‪她從那時起就跟祖父母一起生活

72
00:03:51,315 --> 00:03:52,858
‪-他說他要來嗎？
‪-他要來

73
00:03:53,484 --> 00:03:56,195
‪-那俊燮也會來嗎？
‪-他應該會來吧

74
00:03:56,279 --> 00:03:58,781
‪-我們快走吧
‪-幹嘛？妳喜歡他嗎？

75
00:03:59,657 --> 00:04:01,993
‪她爺爺罹患失智症，目前住院中

76
00:04:02,076 --> 00:04:04,495
‪奶奶身體狀況也不好

77
00:04:05,079 --> 00:04:06,622
‪她很久以前就和父母斷了聯絡

78
00:04:06,706 --> 00:04:09,083
‪-打我啊，王八蛋
‪-夠了，別衝動

79
00:04:09,166 --> 00:04:11,836
‪-該死的賤女人！
‪-先忍著…

80
00:04:11,919 --> 00:04:14,213
‪-喂！別亂來！
‪-打我啊！

81
00:04:14,297 --> 00:04:15,715
‪-打我啊！媽的！
‪-喂！

82
00:04:18,467 --> 00:04:20,428
‪所以那孩子之後會怎麼樣？

83
00:04:20,511 --> 00:04:22,763
‪我剛才看她的傷勢相當嚴重

84
00:04:22,847 --> 00:04:24,932
‪不會怎麼樣，肯定又是不了了之

85
00:04:25,599 --> 00:04:28,269
‪反正對我們來說
‪花心思在少年案件上毫無好處

86
00:04:28,936 --> 00:04:30,771
‪沒人會認為那是重大案件

87
00:04:33,065 --> 00:04:35,192
‪-回到局裡再叫我
‪-是，知道了

88
00:04:40,239 --> 00:04:43,284
‪她曾因為竊盜及性交易罪
‪被裁定第五、六號處分

89
00:04:43,367 --> 00:04:44,869
‪她的名字是徐有悧

90
00:04:44,952 --> 00:04:47,204
‪徐有悧？她很有名啊

91
00:04:47,288 --> 00:04:49,123
‪她已經消失好一陣子了

92
00:04:49,206 --> 00:04:52,293
‪我正打算向你們報告
‪妳是承辦法官吧？

93
00:04:53,044 --> 00:04:56,922
‪保護觀察所每晚會致電
‪確認她是否正常返家，但她從來不接

94
00:04:57,006 --> 00:04:59,675
‪連每週一次的出勤，她也從沒出現過

95
00:05:00,176 --> 00:05:02,345
‪家訪時她不在家，又聯絡不上她

96
00:05:02,428 --> 00:05:05,139
‪我們也是第一次碰到
‪那麼不配合的孩子

97
00:05:05,222 --> 00:05:06,974
‪是，我知道了，好的

98
00:05:12,646 --> 00:05:13,689
‪你還沒回去啊？

99
00:05:13,773 --> 00:05:14,982
‪是

100
00:05:15,066 --> 00:05:17,318
‪我剛才試著聯絡了有悧身邊的朋友

101
00:05:18,110 --> 00:05:21,822
‪他們都說有悧去髮廊工作後
‪就已經很久沒見到她了

102
00:05:21,906 --> 00:05:24,158
‪因為她每天早出晚歸的

103
00:05:24,742 --> 00:05:26,994
‪那樣違反《勞動基準法》了吧？

104
00:05:28,329 --> 00:05:29,789
‪這點我倒是沒追問

105
00:05:30,706 --> 00:05:33,084
‪看來還是得等她醒來再問問了

106
00:05:34,668 --> 00:05:36,754
‪很晚了，你先回去吧

107
00:05:36,837 --> 00:05:38,089
‪妳不一起離開嗎？

108
00:05:38,172 --> 00:05:41,467
‪嗯，等她醒來我有很多事想問她

109
00:05:52,561 --> 00:05:55,564
‪詳情要等檢查結果出來才知道

110
00:05:55,648 --> 00:05:59,485
‪但根據初步診斷
‪她肋骨骨折，左手腕挫傷

111
00:05:59,568 --> 00:06:00,861
‪發炎指數也很高

112
00:06:01,487 --> 00:06:03,447
‪這種情況不是一、兩天造成的

113
00:06:03,531 --> 00:06:04,824
‪她應該長期遭受暴力對待

114
00:06:09,078 --> 00:06:10,830
‪嗯，妳醒了嗎？

115
00:06:14,417 --> 00:06:16,210
‪妳等等，我請醫生過來

116
00:06:16,293 --> 00:06:17,253
‪不用…

117
00:06:20,798 --> 00:06:21,799
‪我…

118
00:06:22,425 --> 00:06:24,468
‪我一定是一時瘋了

119
00:06:24,552 --> 00:06:26,178
‪我真的沒事

120
00:06:26,887 --> 00:06:28,013
‪我該走了

121
00:06:33,853 --> 00:06:35,104
‪如果妳真的沒事

122
00:06:36,147 --> 00:06:37,523
‪為什麼會跑來法院？

123
00:06:38,274 --> 00:06:39,358
‪而且還是在深夜

124
00:06:44,113 --> 00:06:45,114
‪妳想跟車法官談吧？

125
00:06:46,323 --> 00:06:47,908
‪如果我讓妳不自在，跟他談也行

126
00:06:47,992 --> 00:06:50,202
‪不，我真的沒事

127
00:06:57,251 --> 00:06:58,502
‪妳的身體明明有事

128
00:06:59,753 --> 00:07:01,130
‪嘴巴卻說沒事

129
00:07:01,630 --> 00:07:03,257
‪如果我一直沒發現就算了

130
00:07:03,340 --> 00:07:04,800
‪但現在既然知道了

131
00:07:06,093 --> 00:07:07,386
‪我不可能草草帶過

132
00:07:08,596 --> 00:07:11,557
‪我只給妳一天時間，妳好好考慮清楚

133
00:07:12,183 --> 00:07:14,268
‪如果改變心意了就跟我聯絡

134
00:07:15,978 --> 00:07:18,022
‪時間一過，我就會以我的方式處理

135
00:07:22,276 --> 00:07:24,945
‪我已經付清醫藥費了
‪妳一定要住院才行

136
00:07:26,697 --> 00:07:27,740
‪先接受治療吧

137
00:07:42,296 --> 00:07:45,382
‪最後，美國是最強調人權及尊嚴

138
00:07:45,466 --> 00:07:48,886
‪也是最嚴格看待家庭暴力的國家之一

139
00:07:48,969 --> 00:07:51,847
‪因此美國大部分的司法機關

140
00:07:51,931 --> 00:07:56,018
‪必須在家暴案件發生後
‪24小時內將加害人交付審判

141
00:07:56,101 --> 00:07:59,188
‪對加害人做出嚴厲的刑事處分

142
00:07:59,271 --> 00:08:03,901
‪此外，在審判過程中
‪盡量減少被害人與加害人接觸

143
00:08:03,984 --> 00:08:05,945
‪以確保被害人安全無虞

144
00:08:06,028 --> 00:08:08,906
‪並透過律師支援制度協助被害人

145
00:08:08,989 --> 00:08:13,786
‪這些都是基於“家暴視同犯罪”的意識
‪所做出的努力

146
00:08:14,453 --> 00:08:15,538
‪我的簡報到此結束

147
00:08:17,122 --> 00:08:21,335
{\an8}‪是，以上是李正碩部長法官的簡報

148
00:08:21,418 --> 00:08:22,628
{\an8}‪（延和地方法院）

149
00:08:22,711 --> 00:08:27,174
{\an8}‪請問有人對於簡報內容
‪持有不同的意見嗎？

150
00:08:35,599 --> 00:08:36,600
‪請說

151
00:08:38,936 --> 00:08:40,271
‪沈恩錫法官？

152
00:08:40,354 --> 00:08:41,438
‪所以…

153
00:08:42,690 --> 00:08:43,857
‪重點是什麼？

154
00:08:44,567 --> 00:08:48,445
‪你的意思是建議我國
‪仿照美國的做法嗎？

155
00:08:50,489 --> 00:08:51,991
‪根據女性家族部的統計

156
00:08:52,074 --> 00:08:54,326
‪全國有58.3%的家庭曾發生暴力行為

157
00:08:54,410 --> 00:08:57,913
‪每年至少有93名以上的
‪家庭暴力被害人

158
00:08:57,997 --> 00:09:01,458
‪人身安全遭受加害人威脅
‪甚或失去性命

159
00:09:01,542 --> 00:09:04,712
‪若再加上未通報案件
‪還有比數據上更多的家庭

160
00:09:04,795 --> 00:09:06,714
‪正處於暴力的痛苦之中

161
00:09:07,715 --> 00:09:09,967
‪然而最令人絕望的現實是

162
00:09:10,593 --> 00:09:12,761
‪沒有人知道這些家庭暴力

163
00:09:13,470 --> 00:09:15,014
‪何時會停歇

164
00:09:18,934 --> 00:09:22,271
‪讓我們假設有一名女孩
‪疑似遭受家庭暴力

165
00:09:22,855 --> 00:09:25,941
‪警方已經接獲學校和醫院通報

166
00:09:26,567 --> 00:09:28,902
‪但她的家人卻主張那不是家庭暴力

167
00:09:28,986 --> 00:09:30,029
‪聲稱是誤會一場

168
00:09:30,613 --> 00:09:32,156
‪從他們否認的那一刻起

169
00:09:33,240 --> 00:09:36,285
‪警方再也無法介入處理
‪調查程序也必須立即中止

170
00:09:36,952 --> 00:09:39,747
‪即便是此刻
‪也有不計其數的家庭暴力案件

171
00:09:39,830 --> 00:09:42,207
‪因為那種荒唐的理由被迫中斷調查

172
00:09:42,291 --> 00:09:43,459
‪現實就是如此

173
00:09:43,542 --> 00:09:46,962
‪該如何盡量減少加害人與被害人接觸

174
00:09:47,046 --> 00:09:49,423
‪並在24小時內將加害人交付審判？

175
00:09:49,506 --> 00:09:52,009
‪這真的可行嗎？

176
00:09:53,677 --> 00:09:58,057
‪我們至少該研商改善
‪現行家庭暴力調查機制才有用

177
00:09:58,682 --> 00:10:03,354
‪這樣才能在研討會中
‪交流更多對現實有幫助的意見

178
00:10:05,189 --> 00:10:07,066
‪姜部長是怎麼教育陪席法官的？

179
00:10:07,900 --> 00:10:09,985
‪總之最近的年輕法官真不可取

180
00:10:10,069 --> 00:10:14,281
‪她竟敢對部長法官的簡報
‪做出那麼不成熟的批評

181
00:10:14,365 --> 00:10:16,116
‪-真是沒教養
‪-天啊

182
00:10:16,200 --> 00:10:18,035
‪-真是世風日下啊
‪-真是的

183
00:10:18,619 --> 00:10:20,954
‪妳這個人到底有什麼毛病？

184
00:10:23,666 --> 00:10:28,379
‪妳不知道在研討會上
‪擔任發表人的部長法官都很敏感嗎？

185
00:10:28,462 --> 00:10:32,883
‪妳無法判斷何時該發表意見
‪何時該保持低調嗎？

186
00:10:32,966 --> 00:10:34,718
‪那不就是要讓人發表意見的場合？

187
00:10:34,802 --> 00:10:36,595
‪就算是那樣，妳態度不能好一點嗎？

188
00:10:38,472 --> 00:10:41,934
‪這年頭連大學生都不會
‪像李部長那樣做簡報

189
00:10:42,601 --> 00:10:46,021
‪隨便翻幾本相關書籍
‪再上網查點資料東拼西湊

190
00:10:47,064 --> 00:10:48,691
‪俗話說“一寸光陰一寸金”

191
00:10:48,774 --> 00:10:50,651
‪黃金就相當於錢

192
00:10:51,610 --> 00:10:52,820
‪我今天浪費了很多錢

193
00:10:53,862 --> 00:10:54,780
‪喂，沈恩錫

194
00:10:54,863 --> 00:10:58,325
‪研討會無疑是為了
‪讓不同年紀跟職等的人交流意見

195
00:10:58,409 --> 00:11:01,537
‪我今天並沒有反駁任何簡報內容

196
00:11:02,496 --> 00:11:04,039
‪只是發表了個人意見而已

197
00:11:04,123 --> 00:11:07,626
‪那就是問題所在
‪妳知道部長法官們現在氣瘋了嗎？

198
00:11:09,712 --> 00:11:10,713
‪看到了吧？

199
00:11:11,922 --> 00:11:12,840
‪嗨

200
00:11:14,967 --> 00:11:16,176
‪李部長，嗯

201
00:11:17,052 --> 00:11:19,388
‪是，我知道了，好的

202
00:11:20,180 --> 00:11:23,350
‪車法官，你現在得去大廳一趟

203
00:11:24,184 --> 00:11:25,269
‪我嗎？

204
00:11:27,855 --> 00:11:28,981
‪為什麼？

205
00:11:37,740 --> 00:11:39,032
‪媽

206
00:11:39,116 --> 00:11:40,200
‪泰柱

207
00:11:41,326 --> 00:11:42,828
‪妳來之前應該先打給我啊

208
00:11:43,954 --> 00:11:45,330
‪我帶了一點小菜過來

209
00:11:47,166 --> 00:11:49,960
‪妳怎麼又準備了這麼多？

210
00:11:53,881 --> 00:11:55,132
‪車法官去哪了？

211
00:11:55,215 --> 00:11:58,093
‪車法官的媽媽來找他
‪所以他下樓一趟

212
00:11:58,177 --> 00:12:01,054
‪他媽媽經常帶一些小菜來給他

213
00:12:01,138 --> 00:12:03,348
‪如果他正好有庭審，我會下去幫他拿

214
00:12:03,432 --> 00:12:05,142
‪不過她今天選對日子了

215
00:12:05,809 --> 00:12:08,353
‪-這樣啊
‪-我每次看到都覺得很神奇

216
00:12:08,437 --> 00:12:11,648
‪車法官跟媽媽的關係就像是朋友一樣

217
00:12:11,732 --> 00:12:15,194
‪如果是女兒還有可能
‪兒子能做到那樣真的不容易

218
00:12:15,277 --> 00:12:18,405
‪我想他一定是備受父母關愛長大的

219
00:12:19,156 --> 00:12:22,534
‪希望我將來也能跟兒子融洽地相處

220
00:12:22,618 --> 00:12:23,994
‪就像車法官一樣

221
00:12:27,039 --> 00:12:28,791
‪妳們沒有偷說我壞話吧？

222
00:12:28,874 --> 00:12:30,125
‪沒有

223
00:12:30,209 --> 00:12:34,046
‪我媽又準備了很多小菜
‪我得分給大家吃了

224
00:12:34,129 --> 00:12:36,799
‪我正想念你媽做的招牌辣拌魷魚絲呢

225
00:12:36,882 --> 00:12:38,509
‪麻煩替我謝謝她

226
00:12:39,635 --> 00:12:41,762
‪對了，我媽也準備了妳的份

227
00:12:44,306 --> 00:12:46,225
‪不用了，送給別人吃吧

228
00:12:46,975 --> 00:12:48,227
‪我不在家裡吃飯

229
00:12:51,980 --> 00:12:53,899
‪我是不是說錯話了？

230
00:12:53,982 --> 00:12:55,859
‪沒有，不知道她是怎麼了

231
00:12:57,402 --> 00:12:59,613
‪天啊，看起來真好吃

232
00:13:00,697 --> 00:13:04,034
‪（龍血樹美髮沙龍）

233
00:13:07,454 --> 00:13:10,040
‪歡迎光臨，請問有預約嗎？

234
00:13:11,041 --> 00:13:13,168
‪我是延和地方法院的法官

235
00:13:14,044 --> 00:13:15,879
‪妳認識徐有悧吧？

236
00:13:17,005 --> 00:13:18,590
‪什麼暴力行為啊？

237
00:13:18,674 --> 00:13:21,718
‪我承認店裡的工作壓力比其他髮廊大

238
00:13:22,553 --> 00:13:23,720
‪但絕對沒那回事

239
00:13:23,804 --> 00:13:25,973
‪有悧說我們動手打她嗎？

240
00:13:26,807 --> 00:13:29,935
‪不，我只是來確認事實關係的

241
00:13:30,018 --> 00:13:32,896
‪徐有悧平時表現如何？

242
00:13:34,940 --> 00:13:37,526
‪我都說不是6號了，是8874號

243
00:13:39,403 --> 00:13:40,946
‪這到底是第幾次了？

244
00:13:41,029 --> 00:13:42,531
‪妳連整理都不會嗎？

245
00:13:43,031 --> 00:13:44,491
‪我說過產品不能混在一起

246
00:13:44,575 --> 00:13:46,201
‪她是需要注意的問題人物

247
00:13:46,285 --> 00:13:49,705
‪動不動就犯錯
‪還經常不假外出、無故缺勤

248
00:13:50,289 --> 00:13:52,791
‪她在髮型設計師間的風評也不佳

249
00:13:52,875 --> 00:13:55,252
‪整間髮廊被她搞得氣氛很差

250
00:13:57,170 --> 00:14:00,465
‪這裡的工作時段是怎麼安排的？

251
00:14:00,549 --> 00:14:02,634
‪要看是早班還是晚班

252
00:14:03,302 --> 00:14:05,721
‪她是未成年人，根據《勞動基準法》

253
00:14:05,804 --> 00:14:07,723
‪每天工作七小時後就會下班

254
00:14:08,765 --> 00:14:09,725
‪妳確定嗎？

255
00:14:10,392 --> 00:14:13,729
‪如果妳想確認的話
‪我可以讓妳看監視器影像

256
00:14:18,233 --> 00:14:20,319
‪等等！小姐！

257
00:14:21,028 --> 00:14:21,862
‪我…

258
00:14:23,363 --> 00:14:25,616
‪我有話想對妳說

259
00:14:27,868 --> 00:14:29,995
‪-歡迎下次再來
‪-真是的

260
00:14:31,455 --> 00:14:35,834
‪有個奇怪的男人曾來找過有悧幾次

261
00:14:39,087 --> 00:14:41,006
‪我不確定是不是他動手的

262
00:14:41,089 --> 00:14:43,342
‪但她好幾次回來臉上都帶著瘀青

263
00:14:44,217 --> 00:14:46,720
‪她會無故缺勤都是那個男人造成的

264
00:14:46,803 --> 00:14:49,389
‪一開始我跟她換了幾次班

265
00:14:49,473 --> 00:14:50,766
‪因為她看起來被打得很慘

266
00:14:52,142 --> 00:14:53,810
‪那個男人看起來年紀大她很多

267
00:14:54,686 --> 00:14:57,314
‪但他給人的感覺有點…

268
00:14:59,733 --> 00:15:01,610
‪我不知道該不該這麼說

269
00:15:03,070 --> 00:15:04,613
‪但看起來就像援助交際

270
00:15:09,117 --> 00:15:11,078
‪司機先生，麻煩你掉頭

271
00:15:11,161 --> 00:15:13,664
‪我不去法院了，改去醫院
‪請送我到延和綜合醫院

272
00:15:13,747 --> 00:15:14,957
‪好的，知道了

273
00:15:16,124 --> 00:15:19,962
‪是，那麼我會變更處分
‪有進度請跟我聯絡

274
00:15:21,338 --> 00:15:22,339
‪好的

275
00:15:24,216 --> 00:15:25,217
‪打擾了

276
00:15:26,093 --> 00:15:28,929
‪請問你是釜山中學畢業的嗎？

277
00:15:30,222 --> 00:15:31,306
‪什麼？

278
00:15:32,057 --> 00:15:33,684
‪你是車泰柱，對吧？

279
00:15:33,767 --> 00:15:36,979
‪是我啊，住在你家隔壁的鄭辰慕

280
00:15:40,399 --> 00:15:43,318
‪我想你應該認錯人了
‪我不是釜山中學畢業的

281
00:15:43,402 --> 00:15:46,488
‪對不起，看來是我認錯人了

282
00:15:46,571 --> 00:15:48,991
‪我有個朋友叫車泰柱

283
00:15:49,074 --> 00:15:50,075
‪他跟你長得很像

284
00:15:51,118 --> 00:15:52,327
‪是，真抱歉

285
00:16:03,755 --> 00:16:06,508
‪（延和綜合醫院，急診室）

286
00:16:06,591 --> 00:16:07,843
‪我是沈恩錫

287
00:16:07,926 --> 00:16:11,638
‪請幫我查一下徐有悧離開機構後
‪是否曾捲入性犯罪案件

288
00:16:11,722 --> 00:16:12,889
‪明天上午前告訴我

289
00:16:15,225 --> 00:16:16,727
‪我都說不是了

290
00:16:16,810 --> 00:16:18,603
‪妳到底要我否認幾次？

291
00:16:18,687 --> 00:16:20,772
‪我只是自己摔倒，沒有人打我

292
00:16:20,856 --> 00:16:22,607
‪別再胡說八道了

293
00:16:23,108 --> 00:16:26,236
‪既然是妳自己摔倒的
‪為什麼要去法院求助？

294
00:16:27,320 --> 00:16:29,072
‪妳傷得這麼重，到底是怎麼摔的？

295
00:16:29,156 --> 00:16:31,324
‪算我拜託妳，請妳別再管我了

296
00:16:32,367 --> 00:16:33,702
‪那個男人到底是誰？

297
00:16:36,747 --> 00:16:38,582
‪聽說他之前也曾打過妳幾次

298
00:16:38,665 --> 00:16:40,042
‪妳私下調查我嗎？

299
00:16:40,125 --> 00:16:40,959
‪不只那樣

300
00:16:45,756 --> 00:16:46,673
‪只要一句話

301
00:16:47,174 --> 00:16:49,134
‪妳願意的話，我現在就讓妳回機構

302
00:16:51,219 --> 00:16:52,429
‪有悧

303
00:16:53,180 --> 00:16:54,473
‪原來妳在這裡

304
00:16:54,973 --> 00:16:58,226
‪不過，請問妳是誰？

305
00:16:58,310 --> 00:17:00,479
‪我是延和地方法院的沈恩錫法官

306
00:17:00,979 --> 00:17:02,314
‪妳是有悧的奶奶嗎？

307
00:17:02,397 --> 00:17:05,484
‪該怎麼辦才好？我真是太慚愧了

308
00:17:05,567 --> 00:17:06,735
‪我們有悧…

309
00:17:07,402 --> 00:17:12,032
‪妳也真是的，法官特地過來
‪至少該請她喝杯飲料

310
00:17:12,115 --> 00:17:14,618
‪不用，沒關係，我馬上就要走了

311
00:17:15,160 --> 00:17:16,536
‪重點是有悧受傷的事…

312
00:17:16,620 --> 00:17:19,706
‪是啊，這孩子摔倒了

313
00:17:20,373 --> 00:17:24,211
‪她的身體本來就很柔弱

314
00:17:24,294 --> 00:17:26,088
‪-什麼？
‪-是真的

315
00:17:26,755 --> 00:17:28,590
‪她真的很常摔倒

316
00:17:28,673 --> 00:17:30,759
‪孩子，妳說是吧？

317
00:17:36,056 --> 00:17:38,016
‪-可是奶奶…
‪-天啊，我記性真差

318
00:17:38,767 --> 00:17:42,145
‪護理師正在找我們有悧

319
00:17:43,688 --> 00:17:45,690
‪我們可以走了嗎？

320
00:17:45,774 --> 00:17:48,860
‪法官，對不起，真的很抱歉

321
00:17:50,529 --> 00:17:51,696
‪我們走吧

322
00:17:52,989 --> 00:17:55,117
‪法官，真的很抱歉

323
00:18:07,129 --> 00:18:08,171
‪喂？金記者

324
00:18:08,922 --> 00:18:10,882
‪是啊，我還在法院

325
00:18:11,591 --> 00:18:12,509
‪晚餐嗎？

326
00:18:14,136 --> 00:18:16,304
‪好，我看一下訊息

327
00:18:19,391 --> 00:18:20,934
‪（《韓于日報》金記者）

328
00:18:21,017 --> 00:18:23,186
‪（景華苑，晚上7點
‪訂位人：嚴峻奇）

329
00:18:31,736 --> 00:18:34,197
‪（國會議員，嚴峻奇）

330
00:18:37,784 --> 00:18:40,537
‪今年10月即將舉行補選

331
00:18:41,830 --> 00:18:44,082
‪你的政治哲學跟本黨很契合

332
00:18:45,000 --> 00:18:47,419
‪我們認為你是最佳人選

333
00:18:47,502 --> 00:18:49,087
‪因此排除萬難約你見面

334
00:18:52,048 --> 00:18:53,133
‪這樣啊

335
00:18:53,884 --> 00:18:56,511
‪我當了22年的法官

336
00:18:57,137 --> 00:18:59,264
‪比起立法與修法的工作

337
00:19:00,682 --> 00:19:01,933
‪我認為披上法袍

338
00:19:02,767 --> 00:19:04,477
‪站上法庭更讓我感到熟悉

339
00:19:05,145 --> 00:19:07,230
‪我想比起國會

340
00:19:08,106 --> 00:19:11,401
‪我應該更適合待在法院裡

341
00:19:12,444 --> 00:19:13,486
‪是

342
00:19:14,196 --> 00:19:17,991
‪我前陣子聽到一件令人震驚的事
‪想請教你一個問題

343
00:19:18,074 --> 00:19:18,950
‪請說

344
00:19:19,576 --> 00:19:21,536
‪在所有少年犯罪案件中

345
00:19:21,620 --> 00:19:24,748
‪登上新聞報導的重大犯罪約占1%

346
00:19:25,582 --> 00:19:27,292
‪校園暴力約占15%

347
00:19:27,375 --> 00:19:31,213
‪其餘則是為了擺脫貧困
‪家庭暴力、家庭失和等

348
00:19:32,214 --> 00:19:34,341
‪導致青少年做出非法行為
‪這種說法正確嗎？

349
00:19:34,925 --> 00:19:38,595
‪雖然不能說完全正確，但大致上沒錯

350
00:19:38,678 --> 00:19:42,474
‪在惡劣的環境之下
‪身邊自然會缺乏關心及保護

351
00:19:45,143 --> 00:19:47,812
‪對於這一點，法院也深感痛心

352
00:19:50,732 --> 00:19:52,150
‪那麼就更適合了

353
00:19:52,943 --> 00:19:55,487
‪少年福利規範與《少年法》修訂

354
00:19:55,570 --> 00:19:56,863
‪本來就是國會的職責

355
00:19:58,448 --> 00:20:01,868
‪如果單純考慮為少年做事的觀點

356
00:20:02,535 --> 00:20:04,162
‪我相信你進入國會

357
00:20:05,038 --> 00:20:07,207
‪一定會對少年們更有助益

358
00:20:12,128 --> 00:20:15,382
‪如今年滿18歲的未成年人
‪也能行使投票權

359
00:20:15,924 --> 00:20:18,718
‪站在黨內立場，我們迫切需要你加入

360
00:20:20,011 --> 00:20:23,807
‪今後國會也該懂得害怕未成年人了

361
00:20:29,271 --> 00:20:32,565
‪雖然年滿18歲的選民
‪僅占全體的1、2%

362
00:20:32,649 --> 00:20:35,110
‪但主導社群媒體風向的
‪都是那個世代的人

363
00:20:35,735 --> 00:20:37,445
‪我們絕對不能輕忽那股影響力

364
00:20:39,030 --> 00:20:42,909
‪“少年案件不再只是個人問題

365
00:20:42,993 --> 00:20:47,330
‪現在該是社會和國家
‪站出來的時候了”

366
00:20:47,414 --> 00:20:51,751
‪現在該是社會和國家站出來的時候了

367
00:20:52,419 --> 00:20:54,587
‪請站出來吧，就像你受訪時說的那樣

368
00:20:56,589 --> 00:20:58,800
‪不是法院，而是站在國會裡

369
00:21:00,051 --> 00:21:02,012
‪只要你下定決心

370
00:21:03,805 --> 00:21:05,682
‪接下來的事就交給我們處理

371
00:21:08,184 --> 00:21:12,188
‪我們保證會讓你成為
‪比起法院，更適合國會的人

372
00:21:18,611 --> 00:21:21,239
‪（友利醫院，友利療養院）

373
00:21:22,240 --> 00:21:23,825
‪我是法院過來調查的

374
00:21:23,908 --> 00:21:25,243
{\an8}‪我想找一間病房

375
00:21:44,971 --> 00:21:46,097
{\an8}‪（患者：姜東權）

376
00:21:47,057 --> 00:21:48,224
‪（患者：崔秉吉）

377
00:21:57,734 --> 00:21:59,152
{\an8}‪（患者：徐勸春）

378
00:22:09,329 --> 00:22:11,706
‪請問有什麼事嗎？

379
00:22:13,583 --> 00:22:16,920
‪我們整天陪伴這些老人家

380
00:22:17,003 --> 00:22:20,882
‪很難不知道他們家裡發生的大小事
‪這份工作就是這樣

381
00:22:22,509 --> 00:22:25,470
‪我知道他們兒子的職業

382
00:22:25,553 --> 00:22:27,639
‪甚至知道他們家裡有幾口人吃飯

383
00:22:28,681 --> 00:22:30,683
‪妳是為了他孫女的事過來的嗎？

384
00:22:31,851 --> 00:22:32,852
‪對

385
00:22:32,936 --> 00:22:34,229
‪別再說了！

386
00:22:34,312 --> 00:22:35,313
‪有悧

387
00:22:35,397 --> 00:22:37,440
‪為什麼每次都要我體諒？

388
00:22:37,524 --> 00:22:39,234
‪為什麼每次都叫我要體諒？

389
00:22:39,317 --> 00:22:41,528
‪這年頭的孫子、孫女們

390
00:22:41,611 --> 00:22:43,696
‪根本不在乎生病的老人家

391
00:22:44,531 --> 00:22:46,324
‪一看就知道是怎麼回事

392
00:22:46,408 --> 00:22:49,327
‪她染了一頭紅髮又滿身菸味

393
00:22:49,411 --> 00:22:53,331
‪經常對著奶奶破口大罵
‪真的非常沒教養

394
00:22:53,415 --> 00:22:54,791
‪好，已經完成了

395
00:22:54,874 --> 00:22:56,793
‪我這輩子沒見過那種壞孩子

396
00:22:58,753 --> 00:23:00,588
‪她未必是妳想的那樣

397
00:23:00,672 --> 00:23:02,298
‪如果她真的那麼沒教養

398
00:23:02,382 --> 00:23:04,300
‪就不會來療養院探病了

399
00:23:04,384 --> 00:23:07,762
‪更不可能為她爺爺理髮

400
00:23:08,346 --> 00:23:09,973
‪徐有悧幾乎每天都來吧？

401
00:23:10,557 --> 00:23:12,392
‪是啊，幾乎是那樣

402
00:23:12,475 --> 00:23:14,269
‪我還在想她每天工作七小時

403
00:23:14,978 --> 00:23:16,729
‪為什麼總是那麼晚回家

404
00:23:18,273 --> 00:23:20,108
‪原來答案就在這裡

405
00:23:22,318 --> 00:23:23,611
‪有悧的父母呢？

406
00:23:25,530 --> 00:23:26,781
‪妳知道他們的事嗎？

407
00:23:26,865 --> 00:23:27,824
‪當然知道

408
00:23:28,491 --> 00:23:30,660
‪她爸在這家療養院赫赫有名

409
00:23:31,453 --> 00:23:33,746
‪天啊，他的脾氣真的很火爆

410
00:23:33,830 --> 00:23:36,040
‪他每次過來一定會大鬧一場

411
00:23:36,124 --> 00:23:39,794
‪他們是靠政府補助
‪才能勉強支付醫藥費

412
00:23:39,878 --> 00:23:41,671
‪家裡根本沒有錢啊

413
00:23:42,213 --> 00:23:44,382
‪但他甚至連補助金都狠心搶走

414
00:23:44,466 --> 00:23:46,301
‪他不是跟家裡斷絕聯絡了嗎？

415
00:23:46,384 --> 00:23:47,844
‪怎麼可能？

416
00:23:47,927 --> 00:23:50,597
‪有悧也對她爸恨之入骨啊

417
00:23:52,140 --> 00:23:55,685
‪有個奇怪的男人曾來找過有悧幾次

418
00:23:55,768 --> 00:23:58,938
‪這孩子摔倒了，妳說是吧？

419
00:24:02,984 --> 00:24:04,402
‪原來是她爸

420
00:24:09,073 --> 00:24:10,200
‪我是沈恩錫

421
00:24:10,283 --> 00:24:12,327
‪我是延和警察局女青科的高强植

422
00:24:12,410 --> 00:24:14,496
‪請問徐有悧已經出院了嗎？

423
00:24:14,579 --> 00:24:15,955
‪為什麼這麼問呢？

424
00:24:16,039 --> 00:24:18,041
‪徐有悧的父親現在在局裡

425
00:24:18,917 --> 00:24:20,752
‪他是來通報有悧逃家的

426
00:24:22,212 --> 00:24:23,254
‪你說什麼？

427
00:24:23,880 --> 00:24:27,509
‪原則上，我們接獲通報就得立刻出動

428
00:24:28,551 --> 00:24:31,221
‪可是我總覺得不太對勁

429
00:24:31,304 --> 00:24:33,389
‪徐有悧是家庭暴力的被害人

430
00:24:33,473 --> 00:24:34,641
‪她父親是加害人

431
00:24:35,475 --> 00:24:37,644
‪絕對不能讓她跟加害人接觸

432
00:24:38,144 --> 00:24:41,606
‪請你們務必撤銷他的逃家通報

433
00:24:54,786 --> 00:24:56,621
‪我出院之後，我們要去哪裡？

434
00:24:58,456 --> 00:25:01,334
‪那混蛋發現我們不見了
‪一定會氣到抓狂

435
00:25:02,877 --> 00:25:04,128
‪說話沒大沒小的

436
00:25:08,550 --> 00:25:10,677
‪我受夠那該死的汗蒸幕了

437
00:25:11,261 --> 00:25:13,429
‪既然要逃跑，乾脆逃遠一點

438
00:25:14,639 --> 00:25:15,932
‪妳都不覺得我可憐嗎？

439
00:25:16,558 --> 00:25:18,434
‪我甚至被那個混蛋打到住院了

440
00:25:19,394 --> 00:25:20,687
‪我當然覺得妳很可憐

441
00:25:21,896 --> 00:25:23,273
‪我替妳感到很難過

442
00:25:24,274 --> 00:25:27,485
‪我的心痛到都快碎了

443
00:25:28,987 --> 00:25:30,196
‪可是有悧

444
00:25:30,863 --> 00:25:35,326
‪再怎麼說，妳爸還是我兒子，對吧？

445
00:25:36,494 --> 00:25:38,913
‪有悧…

446
00:25:39,664 --> 00:25:45,211
‪妳可以再忍讓一下妳爸嗎？

447
00:25:46,421 --> 00:25:49,424
‪妳爸也是個可憐的人

448
00:25:50,049 --> 00:25:51,009
‪有悧

449
00:25:52,343 --> 00:25:53,261
‪有悧

450
00:25:59,142 --> 00:26:00,435
‪請問有什麼事嗎？

451
00:26:00,518 --> 00:26:04,105
‪這是要送給車泰柱法官的
‪是釜山少年輔育院送的

452
00:26:04,689 --> 00:26:05,898
‪-釜山嗎？
‪-對

453
00:26:07,066 --> 00:26:08,610
‪喂？少年刑事合議庭

454
00:26:08,693 --> 00:26:10,111
‪這裡是釜山少年輔育院

455
00:26:10,194 --> 00:26:11,988
‪請問是少年刑事合議庭嗎？

456
00:26:12,071 --> 00:26:14,490
‪對，沒錯
‪你是為了盆栽的事打來的吧？

457
00:26:14,574 --> 00:26:16,909
‪我會幫你轉交給車泰柱法官

458
00:26:16,993 --> 00:26:19,245
‪真的嗎？那太感謝妳了

459
00:26:19,871 --> 00:26:23,333
‪他捐款資助這裡的孩子們超過六年了

460
00:26:23,416 --> 00:26:26,836
‪我想請他吃飯也被他拒絕
‪實在是沒有辦法了

461
00:26:26,919 --> 00:26:28,046
‪這樣啊

462
00:26:29,255 --> 00:26:31,883
‪是，請妳一定要幫忙轉達

463
00:26:31,966 --> 00:26:33,134
‪好，我會的

464
00:26:35,511 --> 00:26:36,679
‪早安

465
00:26:36,763 --> 00:26:39,766
‪車法官，你收到一件快遞

466
00:26:42,435 --> 00:26:45,313
‪（謝謝車泰柱法官
‪釜山少年輔育院）

467
00:26:50,568 --> 00:26:55,657
‪我會另外跟對方聯繫的
‪請妳幫我退回盆栽吧

468
00:26:55,740 --> 00:26:58,117
‪可是他再三拜託我務必轉交給你

469
00:26:58,201 --> 00:27:00,161
‪我有收到心意就好

470
00:27:00,244 --> 00:27:01,287
‪這個就不用了

471
00:27:02,038 --> 00:27:03,206
‪那就拜託妳了

472
00:27:03,289 --> 00:27:05,166
‪是，我會退回去的

473
00:27:09,420 --> 00:27:12,215
‪這是妳昨晚說的徐有悧相關資料

474
00:27:13,049 --> 00:27:13,966
‪好

475
00:27:14,676 --> 00:27:17,053
‪有查到任何紀錄嗎？

476
00:27:17,136 --> 00:27:20,348
‪沒有，只有之前那件
‪保護觀察所違規案件

477
00:27:21,015 --> 00:27:22,058
‪那我去忙了

478
00:27:23,142 --> 00:27:24,852
‪（姓名：徐有悧）

479
00:27:32,402 --> 00:27:34,445
‪這是什麼？我們買了新盆栽啊？

480
00:27:35,196 --> 00:27:37,990
‪這不是我們買的
‪是釜山少年輔育院送來的

481
00:27:38,074 --> 00:27:39,200
‪釜山嗎？

482
00:27:39,283 --> 00:27:40,410
‪他們幹嘛送盆栽來？

483
00:27:44,664 --> 00:27:48,167
‪有悧不是住院了嗎？
‪為什麼突然調她的紀錄？

484
00:27:50,086 --> 00:27:51,713
‪事情有變化

485
00:27:51,796 --> 00:27:53,589
‪徐有悧遭受家庭暴力

486
00:27:54,424 --> 00:27:55,717
‪加害人似乎是她爸

487
00:27:55,800 --> 00:27:56,676
‪什麼？

488
00:27:57,427 --> 00:27:58,553
‪那妳通報了嗎？

489
00:27:59,262 --> 00:28:00,722
‪她爸現在在哪裡？

490
00:28:00,805 --> 00:28:03,433
‪警察局那邊怎麼說？

491
00:28:05,685 --> 00:28:06,519
‪沈法官

492
00:28:07,270 --> 00:28:09,188
‪當事人拒絕報警

493
00:28:09,272 --> 00:28:11,357
‪（犯罪經歷查詢彙報表
‪姓名：徐有悧）

494
00:28:12,442 --> 00:28:14,569
‪但為什麼需要她的紀錄呢？

495
00:28:18,573 --> 00:28:19,782
‪不是那樣吧？沈法官

496
00:28:19,866 --> 00:28:21,993
{\an8}‪（禁止外出電子監控結果
‪違反規定）

497
00:28:26,664 --> 00:28:27,707
‪沒錯

498
00:28:28,374 --> 00:28:30,168
‪就是你現在想的那樣

499
00:28:30,251 --> 00:28:32,503
‪徐有悧會以虞犯少年的身分被關起來

500
00:28:35,131 --> 00:28:36,257
‪妳說什麼？

501
00:28:38,176 --> 00:28:40,178
‪不覺得車法官真的很了不起嗎？

502
00:28:40,928 --> 00:28:42,930
‪竟然連續六年捐款

503
00:28:43,014 --> 00:28:47,310
‪但他卻要我把盆栽退回去
‪說他收到心意就好

504
00:28:47,894 --> 00:28:51,230
‪車法官的確會那麼做
‪他本來就很善良

505
00:28:52,648 --> 00:28:53,524
‪我在想

506
00:28:54,275 --> 00:28:56,402
‪到底要怎麼教出那麼優秀的人呢？

507
00:28:57,570 --> 00:28:59,363
‪但是有點奇怪

508
00:28:59,447 --> 00:29:01,449
‪為什麼偏偏是釜山呢？

509
00:29:02,033 --> 00:29:06,078
‪你們想想，車法官第一次
‪負責少年法庭就是在這裡

510
00:29:06,162 --> 00:29:09,290
‪我們法院主要是跟首爾
‪或京畿少年輔育院有往來

511
00:29:09,373 --> 00:29:12,752
‪但他為什麼長期捐助
‪釜山少年輔育院？

512
00:29:12,835 --> 00:29:13,753
‪是他的故鄉嗎？

513
00:29:13,836 --> 00:29:15,421
‪-這倒是有可能
‪-是吧？

514
00:29:15,505 --> 00:29:17,423
‪她可是被害少女

515
00:29:17,507 --> 00:29:20,009
‪妳不替有悧想想嗎？
‪她應該受到合理的保護

516
00:29:20,593 --> 00:29:21,886
‪但妳怎麼會…

517
00:29:22,470 --> 00:29:24,972
‪妳怎麼會想利用處分把她關起來？

518
00:29:26,724 --> 00:29:29,393
‪她沒做任何應該受罰的事
‪即便真的有

519
00:29:29,477 --> 00:29:31,354
‪她現在最需要被保護

520
00:29:31,437 --> 00:29:33,064
‪如果她拒絕報警，那就得說服她

521
00:29:33,147 --> 00:29:35,650
‪為什麼要這樣強制處分她？

522
00:29:38,069 --> 00:29:39,654
‪這個案件由我獨任審判

523
00:29:40,363 --> 00:29:43,074
‪不管要做什麼處分
‪都是我的權限吧？

524
00:29:44,909 --> 00:29:48,371
‪是，可是這種處分真的太過分了

525
00:29:48,955 --> 00:29:50,581
‪這件事我無法坐視不管

526
00:29:51,374 --> 00:29:52,208
‪無法坐視不管？

527
00:29:52,291 --> 00:29:55,545
‪你是想侵害我的獨任審判權嗎？

528
00:30:08,891 --> 00:30:10,142
‪我是沈恩錫

529
00:30:10,226 --> 00:30:12,603
‪這裡是延和綜合醫院病房

530
00:30:12,687 --> 00:30:14,564
‪妳是負責徐有悧的法官嗎？

531
00:30:14,647 --> 00:30:16,607
‪請問妳現在跟徐有悧小姐在一起嗎？

532
00:30:20,403 --> 00:30:23,739
‪我想告訴她出院日期確定了
‪但她卻不見人影

533
00:30:24,323 --> 00:30:25,491
‪也聯絡不上她的監護人

534
00:30:25,575 --> 00:30:26,951
‪有看到523房的徐有悧嗎？

535
00:30:30,037 --> 00:30:33,583
‪我們也會試著找找，之後再跟妳聯絡

536
00:30:35,960 --> 00:30:37,086
‪怎麼了？發生什麼事？

537
00:30:37,962 --> 00:30:39,547
‪徐有悧在醫院裡失蹤了

538
00:30:51,058 --> 00:30:52,643
‪（殷昭熙：妳在哪裡？）

539
00:30:52,727 --> 00:30:55,104
‪我是沈恩錫，我們之前在療養院見過

540
00:30:55,813 --> 00:30:58,774
‪如果妳今天有看到徐有悧的話

541
00:30:58,858 --> 00:31:01,068
‪請妳一看到她就立刻打給我

542
00:31:02,862 --> 00:31:05,114
‪不，不是嚴重的事

543
00:31:06,616 --> 00:31:07,700
‪是

544
00:31:08,951 --> 00:31:10,661
‪是，那就拜託妳了

545
00:31:13,998 --> 00:31:17,209
‪上午測量生命徵象時她明明還在

546
00:31:17,293 --> 00:31:19,086
‪我看了醫院的監視器影像

547
00:31:19,170 --> 00:31:20,129
‪她的確離開醫院了

548
00:31:21,589 --> 00:31:22,632
‪她的監護人呢？

549
00:31:22,715 --> 00:31:25,217
‪她跟醫院的保安組一起去找人了

550
00:31:25,301 --> 00:31:26,552
‪好，我知道了

551
00:31:26,636 --> 00:31:28,971
‪（管制區域，非探病時間禁止進出）

552
00:31:30,431 --> 00:31:31,599
‪我們分頭找吧

553
00:31:32,433 --> 00:31:34,268
‪我一邊打這些電話一邊找人

554
00:31:34,352 --> 00:31:37,021
‪好，那我去有悧常去的地方看看
‪再跟妳聯絡

555
00:31:37,104 --> 00:31:38,022
‪好

556
00:31:39,315 --> 00:31:40,608
‪是保護觀察所嗎？

557
00:31:41,317 --> 00:31:42,818
‪我是延和地院的沈恩錫法官

558
00:31:43,611 --> 00:31:45,237
‪有一名少女現在行蹤不明

559
00:31:45,321 --> 00:31:48,074
‪她叫徐有悧，2004年12月1日生

560
00:31:49,033 --> 00:31:49,867
‪麻煩快一點

561
00:31:51,827 --> 00:31:52,995
{\an8}‪（姓名，電話號碼）

562
00:31:55,915 --> 00:31:56,958
‪（明星投幣式KTV）

563
00:31:57,041 --> 00:31:59,710
‪-請問妳看過這個人嗎？
‪-沒有，沒看過

564
00:32:01,128 --> 00:32:03,506
‪-我進去稍微找一下
‪-好的

565
00:32:13,391 --> 00:32:15,142
‪-搞什麼啊？
‪-抱歉

566
00:32:19,188 --> 00:32:21,107
‪拜託妳快接電話啊

567
00:32:21,190 --> 00:32:23,401
‪妳真的沒有告訴任何人吧？

568
00:32:24,777 --> 00:32:26,278
‪我待個幾天就走

569
00:32:27,405 --> 00:32:29,782
‪我當然有帶錢啊

570
00:32:29,865 --> 00:32:30,992
‪等一下

571
00:32:31,075 --> 00:32:31,951
‪（車泰柱法官）

572
00:32:32,034 --> 00:32:33,244
‪該死的

573
00:32:34,912 --> 00:32:36,414
‪嗯，我已經到了

574
00:32:37,248 --> 00:32:39,417
‪該死，今天怎麼這麼冷？

575
00:32:39,500 --> 00:32:40,793
‪我有找對地方嗎？

576
00:32:41,877 --> 00:32:43,629
‪嗯，我想應該沒錯

577
00:32:53,806 --> 00:32:54,974
‪喂，殷昭熙

578
00:33:04,025 --> 00:33:05,401
‪妳不是說妳一個人嗎？

579
00:33:09,989 --> 00:33:11,490
‪喂，搜她身

580
00:33:13,159 --> 00:33:14,326
‪媽的

581
00:33:15,494 --> 00:33:18,080
‪讓開，放開我，媽的！

582
00:33:18,164 --> 00:33:19,790
‪-放開我
‪-妳要去哪裡？

583
00:33:19,874 --> 00:33:21,292
‪-放手！
‪-把錢交出來！

584
00:33:21,375 --> 00:33:22,334
‪放開我！

585
00:33:23,836 --> 00:33:26,130
‪放開我，媽的！我叫你放手！

586
00:33:26,213 --> 00:33:27,214
‪該死的臭女人！

587
00:33:40,269 --> 00:33:42,605
‪不行，那是我的錢！媽的！

588
00:33:42,688 --> 00:33:43,689
‪還給我！

589
00:33:44,857 --> 00:33:47,359
‪-媽的！
‪-瘋女人，那不關我的事

590
00:33:47,443 --> 00:33:49,070
‪把錢還給我！媽的！

591
00:33:55,826 --> 00:33:57,661
‪妳怎麼能這樣對我？

592
00:33:57,745 --> 00:34:00,247
‪就是說啊，媽的，誰叫妳這麼好騙

593
00:34:00,915 --> 00:34:03,417
‪-白痴
‪-妳這該死的賤女人

594
00:34:03,501 --> 00:34:05,294
‪媽的，妳亂說什麼？

595
00:34:06,545 --> 00:34:08,589
‪妳最好安分一點，臭女人

596
00:34:17,973 --> 00:34:19,683
‪（青少年警察學校）

597
00:34:26,273 --> 00:34:31,112
‪沈法官，有悧會不會被她爸帶走了？

598
00:34:31,195 --> 00:34:32,738
‪不，應該不可能

599
00:34:32,822 --> 00:34:34,698
‪有悧的爸爸不知道她住院的事

600
00:34:37,118 --> 00:34:40,287
‪我先繼續找
‪一有消息麻煩馬上通知我

601
00:34:44,708 --> 00:34:45,709
‪我是沈恩錫

602
00:34:46,335 --> 00:34:48,254
‪這裡是療養院

603
00:34:48,838 --> 00:34:49,797
‪是

604
00:34:50,840 --> 00:34:53,592
‪車法官，我剛才接到電話

605
00:34:53,676 --> 00:34:55,136
‪（友利療養院）

606
00:34:55,219 --> 00:34:56,512
‪我好像找到徐有悧了

607
00:35:11,735 --> 00:35:13,487
‪妳有什麼資格哭？

608
00:35:18,701 --> 00:35:19,785
‪什麼情況？

609
00:35:20,619 --> 00:35:22,037
‪妳的臉是怎麼回事？

610
00:35:22,580 --> 00:35:23,622
‪是誰對妳動手的？

611
00:35:24,373 --> 00:35:26,625
‪我的人生為什麼會這樣？

612
00:35:27,793 --> 00:35:30,546
‪為什麼只有我過得這麼悲慘？

613
00:35:33,215 --> 00:35:34,925
‪我好想擺脫這一切

614
00:35:35,634 --> 00:35:38,512
‪我真的很想振作起來好好過生活

615
00:35:40,723 --> 00:35:42,850
‪但是我卻擺脫不了

616
00:35:49,648 --> 00:35:50,608
‪有悧

617
00:35:51,483 --> 00:35:54,111
‪我們去報警吧，我也會幫助妳的

618
00:35:55,696 --> 00:35:58,365
‪那又如何？報警能改變什麼？

619
00:35:58,449 --> 00:36:01,076
‪判他禁止接觸，聲請停止親權

620
00:36:01,160 --> 00:36:05,289
‪可以限制妳爸不得以任何方式
‪跟妳聯絡或接觸

621
00:36:05,372 --> 00:36:09,126
‪-妳也可以離開家裡在收容所生活
‪-我就是討厭那樣！

622
00:36:10,461 --> 00:36:12,338
‪我一直都在忍讓他啊

623
00:36:13,255 --> 00:36:15,549
‪但為什麼是我要離開？

624
00:36:15,633 --> 00:36:17,551
‪我是挨打的人啊

625
00:36:18,552 --> 00:36:21,555
‪為什麼每次都是我要逃跑？

626
00:36:25,392 --> 00:36:29,563
‪判他禁止接觸的話
‪警方就會24小時保護我嗎？

627
00:36:30,522 --> 00:36:31,899
‪他們不會的

628
00:36:31,982 --> 00:36:36,862
‪萬一那混蛋狠下心來報復我
‪到時我該怎麼辦？

629
00:36:38,364 --> 00:36:40,658
‪我不敢報警，我很害怕

630
00:36:40,741 --> 00:36:42,368
‪我不是不想報警

631
00:36:43,035 --> 00:36:44,578
‪而是太害怕了所以做不到

632
00:36:49,541 --> 00:36:50,834
‪那妳保持沉默

633
00:36:52,211 --> 00:36:53,295
‪就會有答案嗎？

634
00:36:55,422 --> 00:36:57,758
‪妳還是會被毆打到逃家，等錢花光後

635
00:36:58,550 --> 00:36:59,802
‪妳打算再行竊嗎？

636
00:37:00,844 --> 00:37:02,346
‪這不關妳的事

637
00:37:05,975 --> 00:37:07,101
‪我受夠了

638
00:37:09,103 --> 00:37:11,230
‪妳知道今天有多少人
‪為了找妳而活受罪嗎？

639
00:37:11,313 --> 00:37:13,732
‪但妳態度這麼糟，我當然會生氣

640
00:37:13,816 --> 00:37:14,775
‪沈法官

641
00:37:16,193 --> 00:37:18,362
‪是啊，既然她本人不願意

642
00:37:18,445 --> 00:37:20,114
‪我也無法逼迫她做任何事

643
00:37:20,698 --> 00:37:23,367
‪能做的我都已經做了，是吧？

644
00:37:25,286 --> 00:37:27,830
‪找到她了，她在療養院

645
00:37:28,622 --> 00:37:29,456
‪是

646
00:37:31,583 --> 00:37:32,543
‪妳打給誰？

647
00:37:32,626 --> 00:37:34,712
‪妳擅自離開機構時認識的朋友

648
00:37:35,546 --> 00:37:38,882
‪-你們是逃家犯罪集團吧？
‪-對，但我是被害人

649
00:37:38,966 --> 00:37:40,467
‪那等妳接受調查時再解釋

650
00:37:40,551 --> 00:37:42,928
‪所以妳剛才是打給…

651
00:37:43,012 --> 00:37:45,014
‪根據《少年法》第四條第一項規定

652
00:37:45,097 --> 00:37:47,391
‪“犯罪或有非法行為疑慮之少年

653
00:37:48,559 --> 00:37:50,185
‪應視為虞犯少年並移送法辦”

654
00:37:51,395 --> 00:37:54,273
‪-沈法官
‪-是啊，我一度在想

655
00:37:55,274 --> 00:37:57,609
‪我是否真如你說的那麼過分

656
00:37:58,652 --> 00:38:01,447
‪但妳剛才承認了
‪自己是逃家犯罪集團的一員

657
00:38:01,530 --> 00:38:04,033
‪我在那裡沒有犯罪，沈法官

658
00:38:04,116 --> 00:38:06,076
‪妳該犯罪的
‪好讓我把妳送進少年輔育院

659
00:38:06,160 --> 00:38:07,870
‪我沒有犯任何罪

660
00:38:11,790 --> 00:38:13,751
‪好了，有悧，別哭了

661
00:38:14,460 --> 00:38:17,129
‪-冷靜點，站起來吧
‪-我真的沒有犯罪

662
00:38:17,212 --> 00:38:19,590
‪（友利療養院）

663
00:38:19,673 --> 00:38:20,883
‪沒事的

664
00:38:28,265 --> 00:38:30,559
‪（延和地方法院）

665
00:38:32,811 --> 00:38:34,271
‪妳怎麼可以那麼做？

666
00:38:35,189 --> 00:38:37,066
‪難道妳沒有一點同情心嗎？

667
00:38:38,192 --> 00:38:40,819
‪徐有悧遭父親施暴傷害
‪她是無家可歸的孩子

668
00:38:40,903 --> 00:38:43,781
‪所以她就能偷偷逃家
‪還大膽地加入逃家犯罪集團？

669
00:38:43,864 --> 00:38:45,824
‪重點不是她加入那個集團

670
00:38:45,908 --> 00:38:48,327
‪妳應該先關心她為何會加入吧？

671
00:38:50,287 --> 00:38:52,706
‪沈法官，我之前就有這種感覺

672
00:38:53,332 --> 00:38:55,000
‪我真的很好奇

673
00:38:56,668 --> 00:38:58,170
‪妳為什麼那麼厭惡少年犯？

674
00:38:59,546 --> 00:39:00,381
‪什麼？

675
00:39:00,464 --> 00:39:02,841
‪為什麼不能好好說話
‪一定要傷害他們

676
00:39:02,925 --> 00:39:05,260
‪挑他們毛病和故意找碴呢？

677
00:39:05,344 --> 00:39:08,055
‪妳為什麼總是對他們如此苛刻？

678
00:39:08,138 --> 00:39:09,390
‪因為他們是罪犯

679
00:39:11,725 --> 00:39:14,686
‪因為他們年紀輕輕的，竟敢…

680
00:39:16,814 --> 00:39:18,649
‪犯下罪行

681
00:39:23,195 --> 00:39:24,571
‪那我也問你一件事

682
00:39:25,989 --> 00:39:27,533
‪這種事有需要這麼生氣嗎？

683
00:39:27,616 --> 00:39:29,952
‪你為什麼總是站在孩子那邊
‪替他們著急？

684
00:39:30,577 --> 00:39:32,121
‪難道你被他們抓住把柄了嗎？

685
00:39:32,204 --> 00:39:34,373
‪-沈法官
‪-不然到底是為什麼？

686
00:39:36,458 --> 00:39:38,377
‪你幹嘛老是干涉我的案件？

687
00:39:42,631 --> 00:39:43,674
‪出來啊！

688
00:39:46,510 --> 00:39:49,555
‪出來！我叫你出來，臭小子！

689
00:39:51,348 --> 00:39:52,558
‪給我出來！

690
00:39:52,641 --> 00:39:55,727
‪對，我跟你們老師借了一點錢

691
00:39:55,811 --> 00:39:58,564
‪男人拼事業，難免會需要周轉啊

692
00:39:58,647 --> 00:40:00,399
‪你竟敢對我大呼小叫的？

693
00:40:00,482 --> 00:40:01,942
‪-饒了我吧，爸
‪-給我出來！

694
00:40:02,025 --> 00:40:03,610
‪-出來！臭小子！
‪-我錯了！

695
00:40:03,694 --> 00:40:05,446
‪-我錯了！
‪-出來！

696
00:40:05,529 --> 00:40:06,989
‪給我出來，臭小子！

697
00:40:07,656 --> 00:40:10,367
‪我叫你出來！臭小子！

698
00:40:10,451 --> 00:40:11,869
‪出來啊！臭小子！

699
00:40:11,952 --> 00:40:16,248
‪請饒了我，爸，請放過我，我錯了！

700
00:40:21,128 --> 00:40:22,796
‪因為我一直放心不下

701
00:40:24,423 --> 00:40:27,634
‪明明不是那條路
‪妳卻一直走在錯誤的路上

702
00:40:35,642 --> 00:40:37,728
‪遭受家庭暴力傷害的孩子們

703
00:40:39,021 --> 00:40:40,856
‪在受害之後就不會再長大了

704
00:40:41,356 --> 00:40:43,609
‪即使過了十年、二十年

705
00:40:44,902 --> 00:40:47,488
‪那也只是時間流逝而已

706
00:40:48,322 --> 00:40:51,909
‪而他們會被獨自拘禁在過去的日子裡

707
00:40:55,662 --> 00:40:58,290
‪任何人都可以指責少年犯

708
00:40:59,208 --> 00:41:01,168
‪但能給予少年犯機會的人

709
00:41:02,336 --> 00:41:03,879
‪只有法官

710
00:41:06,590 --> 00:41:09,927
‪所以我認為這是
‪極具意義且重要的工作

711
00:41:16,308 --> 00:41:18,185
‪那也是我成為法官的原因

712
00:42:10,362 --> 00:42:12,906
‪-半小時後開庭
‪-好

713
00:42:19,079 --> 00:42:21,415
‪這支遙控器為什麼沒反應？

714
00:42:21,957 --> 00:42:23,375
‪好像沒電了

715
00:42:23,458 --> 00:42:25,043
‪我現在馬上去拿電池

716
00:42:25,127 --> 00:42:27,212
‪-快去快回啊
‪-是

717
00:42:27,296 --> 00:42:29,590
‪-這麼不認真做事嗎？
‪-抱歉

718
00:42:34,970 --> 00:42:37,347
‪車法官，你沒事吧？對不起

719
00:42:37,431 --> 00:42:38,599
‪-我沒事
‪-對不起

720
00:42:38,682 --> 00:42:40,475
‪-沈法官今天開庭吧？
‪-是

721
00:42:40,559 --> 00:42:41,935
‪你要遲到了，快去吧

722
00:42:42,019 --> 00:42:44,396
‪-是，抱歉
‪-對了，那個…

723
00:42:45,147 --> 00:42:48,066
‪有悧今天也會出庭受審嗎？

724
00:42:54,865 --> 00:42:56,950
‪現在開始庭審

725
00:42:57,576 --> 00:43:00,245
‪有悧的審判不是虞犯少年案嗎？

726
00:43:00,996 --> 00:43:03,123
‪你只說對了一半

727
00:43:03,206 --> 00:43:06,752
‪以虞犯少年身分收容徐有悧
‪目的並不是要懲罰她

728
00:43:08,795 --> 00:43:10,047
‪本次庭審

729
00:43:10,756 --> 00:43:13,050
‪將一併審理遭移送檢調的徐有悧父親

730
00:43:13,133 --> 00:43:14,968
‪所涉及的兒童保護案件

731
00:43:15,052 --> 00:43:19,181
‪根據《兒童虐待處分等
‪相關特別條例》第47條第一項規定

732
00:43:20,182 --> 00:43:21,475
‪我將依法官職權

733
00:43:22,517 --> 00:43:24,770
‪進行被害兒童保護令聲請的審理程序

734
00:43:26,480 --> 00:43:28,273
‪-有悧的父親
‪-是

735
00:43:29,107 --> 00:43:31,985
‪你知道你出庭的原因嗎？

736
00:43:32,069 --> 00:43:32,903
‪是

737
00:43:32,986 --> 00:43:34,446
‪你出庭的原因是什麼？

738
00:43:34,529 --> 00:43:36,531
‪說來真是慚愧

739
00:43:37,282 --> 00:43:38,533
‪是因為家庭暴力

740
00:43:38,617 --> 00:43:39,826
‪你本人承認嗎？

741
00:43:40,661 --> 00:43:43,413
‪不是，接受調查時
‪我無可奈何只能承認

742
00:43:43,497 --> 00:43:44,873
‪但這實在是太離譜了

743
00:43:44,956 --> 00:43:48,669
‪我只是在教訓我的孩子
‪法院憑什麼管這麼多？

744
00:43:49,336 --> 00:43:50,671
‪你們為我做了什麼？

745
00:43:50,754 --> 00:43:53,048
‪我所做的行為是在管教她

746
00:43:53,131 --> 00:43:54,841
‪那是我身為她爸應有的權利

747
00:44:05,102 --> 00:44:07,479
‪（徐有悧遭受兒童虐待證據照片）

748
00:44:13,485 --> 00:44:16,571
‪“管”者約束，“教”者訓誨

749
00:44:16,655 --> 00:44:19,408
‪是指在品行或道德方面給予教導

750
00:44:23,370 --> 00:44:27,708
‪所以那就是你所謂的管教嗎？

751
00:44:28,750 --> 00:44:32,337
‪那是你身為爸爸應有的權利？

752
00:44:43,181 --> 00:44:45,142
‪我把妳關起來的理由只有一個

753
00:44:47,394 --> 00:44:48,645
‪就是讓妳站在法庭上

754
00:44:50,897 --> 00:44:52,232
‪我想讓妳看看

755
00:44:52,858 --> 00:44:54,860
‪受害者不會被關起來

756
00:44:55,694 --> 00:44:57,946
‪施暴者才會被關進去

757
00:45:00,198 --> 00:45:01,742
‪被害人可以留在家裡

758
00:45:03,368 --> 00:45:05,120
‪加害人會受到懲罰

759
00:45:08,206 --> 00:45:09,541
‪我會讓妳看見的

760
00:45:11,084 --> 00:45:12,252
‪我保證

761
00:45:15,380 --> 00:45:17,674
‪我是被誣陷的

762
00:45:17,758 --> 00:45:20,218
‪妳能證明那是我做的嗎？
‪妳沒有證據啊

763
00:45:25,098 --> 00:45:29,269
‪這是徐有悧在少年分類審查院
‪寫下的家庭暴力受害陳述書

764
00:45:29,352 --> 00:45:32,355
‪陳述內容包括暴力發生時
‪她遭受球棒毆打

765
00:45:32,439 --> 00:45:35,025
‪以及被用腳狠踹

766
00:45:35,567 --> 00:45:37,736
‪還有，證人？

767
00:45:41,114 --> 00:45:43,867
‪我是隸屬延和警察局
‪女青科的高强植刑警

768
00:45:43,950 --> 00:45:45,160
{\an8}‪（警察局）

769
00:45:45,243 --> 00:45:47,162
‪妳打算怎麼處理徐有悧的事？

770
00:45:48,038 --> 00:45:50,332
‪雖然我能撤銷她的逃家通報

771
00:45:51,416 --> 00:45:52,667
‪那你會怎麼做？

772
00:45:52,751 --> 00:45:55,170
‪你既然曾對溺水掙扎的孩子伸出援手

773
00:45:56,546 --> 00:45:57,881
‪你願意再幫她一次嗎？

774
00:45:57,964 --> 00:45:59,341
‪我能幫得上忙嗎？

775
00:45:59,424 --> 00:46:01,718
‪你還記得徐有悧
‪在急診室裡的模樣吧？

776
00:46:01,802 --> 00:46:02,886
‪是

777
00:46:04,721 --> 00:46:06,598
‪請你告發徐有悧的父親

778
00:46:08,934 --> 00:46:12,687
‪請你親自進行調查吧

779
00:46:17,984 --> 00:46:20,904
‪這是徐有悧
‪被送進急診室當天的錄音檔

780
00:46:20,987 --> 00:46:22,948
‪是我在調查家暴案時發現的

781
00:46:27,661 --> 00:46:30,622
‪-錢在哪裡？
‪-我沒錢！

782
00:46:31,122 --> 00:46:34,543
‪-媽的，妳要被痛打一頓才會清醒吧
‪-住手！別打了！

783
00:46:34,626 --> 00:46:37,045
‪-我沒有錢！
‪-我只是跟妳要一點錢

784
00:46:37,128 --> 00:46:38,505
‪你要花錢自己去賺啊！

785
00:46:39,589 --> 00:46:41,633
‪我叫你自己去賺錢！

786
00:46:41,716 --> 00:46:43,802
‪-妳敢再大吼大叫試試看！
‪-夠了！

787
00:46:43,885 --> 00:46:45,762
‪別再打她了，臭小子

788
00:46:46,263 --> 00:46:47,180
‪錢在哪裡？

789
00:46:48,181 --> 00:46:49,391
‪-住手啊！
‪-我沒有錢！

790
00:46:49,474 --> 00:46:51,810
‪-給我閉嘴
‪-天啊，拜託別打了

791
00:46:51,893 --> 00:46:53,353
‪-不准給我跑！
‪-唉唷

792
00:46:53,436 --> 00:46:54,354
‪媽的！

793
00:46:55,313 --> 00:46:56,565
‪我去你媽的！

794
00:46:56,648 --> 00:46:58,358
‪-我叫你住手！
‪-滾一邊去！

795
00:47:00,485 --> 00:47:03,697
‪-妳是想死嗎？
‪-唉唷，臭小子，別再打了

796
00:47:03,780 --> 00:47:05,240
‪-放開我
‪-天啊…

797
00:47:05,323 --> 00:47:06,700
‪-奶奶
‪-喂

798
00:47:06,783 --> 00:47:09,703
‪別以為妳會賺錢就了不起
‪錢在哪裡？

799
00:47:09,786 --> 00:47:11,037
‪我說我沒錢！

800
00:47:11,121 --> 00:47:13,164
‪-不想被打就把錢交出來！
‪-我沒有錢！

801
00:47:13,832 --> 00:47:15,083
‪你直接殺了我吧

802
00:47:15,876 --> 00:47:19,170
‪-乾脆殺了我
‪-媽的，殺了妳？好啊

803
00:47:19,254 --> 00:47:20,922
‪-去死吧！
‪-住手！

804
00:47:21,006 --> 00:47:23,091
‪去死吧，狠毒的女人

805
00:47:23,174 --> 00:47:25,969
‪-住手，別打了
‪-狠毒的女人，乾脆死一死吧

806
00:47:26,928 --> 00:47:29,514
‪妳再說一句試試，妳再說啊！

807
00:47:29,598 --> 00:47:30,432
‪該死的！

808
00:47:30,515 --> 00:47:32,767
‪天啊，我的孩子

809
00:47:47,115 --> 00:47:47,949
‪真是的

810
00:47:48,033 --> 00:47:50,493
‪那女人逃家時我去報警

811
00:47:50,577 --> 00:47:52,370
‪你卻問一堆荒唐的問題處處妨礙

812
00:47:52,454 --> 00:47:54,205
‪原來你們都是一夥的，是吧？

813
00:47:55,123 --> 00:47:57,334
‪喂，你搞什麼？你是刑警嗎？

814
00:47:57,417 --> 00:47:59,586
‪-你還算是刑警嗎？臭小子
‪-請你住手

815
00:47:59,669 --> 00:48:00,754
‪怎樣？

816
00:48:01,379 --> 00:48:03,298
‪你最好坐回位置上

817
00:48:05,342 --> 00:48:07,969
‪真是的，太無言了

818
00:48:09,012 --> 00:48:13,183
‪法官，妳也知道她是出賣身體的女人

819
00:48:13,767 --> 00:48:15,310
‪她還曾經因為那樣被判刑

820
00:48:15,393 --> 00:48:18,355
‪所以我才會打她，讓她清醒一點

821
00:48:18,438 --> 00:48:20,774
‪我是以爸爸的身分管教她

822
00:48:20,857 --> 00:48:22,150
‪難道我做錯了嗎？

823
00:48:33,119 --> 00:48:34,621
‪管教子女並沒有錯

824
00:48:54,557 --> 00:48:55,392
‪可是

825
00:48:56,643 --> 00:48:58,311
‪那並不是管教啊

826
00:49:05,568 --> 00:49:09,280
‪話說在審判進行的同時

827
00:49:11,116 --> 00:49:12,659
‪我一直覺得很納悶

828
00:49:14,244 --> 00:49:15,495
‪我實在無法理解

829
00:49:22,293 --> 00:49:23,378
‪為什麼…

830
00:49:28,550 --> 00:49:30,218
‪你這麼理直氣壯呢？

831
00:49:43,690 --> 00:49:47,110
‪這一切都是我的錯

832
00:49:49,487 --> 00:49:53,074
‪是我沒有教好我兒子

833
00:49:55,618 --> 00:49:57,537
‪有悧的爸爸，我的兒子

834
00:49:58,246 --> 00:50:00,040
‪他都是學他爸爸的

835
00:50:00,915 --> 00:50:05,420
‪他小時候也是被毒打長大的

836
00:50:06,880 --> 00:50:09,716
‪那妳為什麼現在提供這個呢？

837
00:50:09,799 --> 00:50:12,052
‪我根本不知道那是什麼

838
00:50:13,178 --> 00:50:16,598
‪那是有悧準備的，她說她要報警

839
00:50:17,348 --> 00:50:20,060
‪可是我阻止了她

840
00:50:21,061 --> 00:50:24,731
‪我叫她別那麼做
‪是我阻止她說出去的

841
00:50:28,151 --> 00:50:30,737
‪她怎麼能那樣對待她爸爸呢？

842
00:50:33,156 --> 00:50:35,825
‪做錯事的人明明是我

843
00:50:35,909 --> 00:50:37,452
‪一切都是我的錯

844
00:50:38,161 --> 00:50:42,791
‪是我沒教好兒子才會發生這種悲劇

845
00:50:43,625 --> 00:50:46,628
‪應該受到懲罰的人是我

846
00:50:48,922 --> 00:50:50,298
‪所以說

847
00:50:52,217 --> 00:50:53,927
‪原來是老太婆出賣我的

848
00:50:58,515 --> 00:51:00,266
‪天啊，你要做什麼？

849
00:51:00,350 --> 00:51:02,310
‪-奶奶！
‪-你要做什麼？天啊！

850
00:51:02,393 --> 00:51:03,812
‪-你這個瘋子！
‪-閉嘴！

851
00:51:03,895 --> 00:51:05,021
‪住手！

852
00:51:06,648 --> 00:51:08,108
‪你這是在做什麼？

853
00:51:08,900 --> 00:51:10,110
‪-不行！
‪-給我閉嘴！

854
00:51:10,193 --> 00:51:12,320
‪放開她！快點放手！

855
00:51:13,446 --> 00:51:14,405
‪快住手！

856
00:51:38,138 --> 00:51:39,055
‪車泰柱法官！

857
00:53:01,930 --> 00:53:05,391
‪（本影集純屬虛構，劇中人物、事件
‪機關等皆與現實無關，特此告知）

858
00:53:05,475 --> 00:53:08,895
‪字幕翻譯：陳孟聰