1
00:00:06,363 --> 00:00:10,803
two not-so-secret lovers,
one of whom was playing with fire.
2
00:00:13,563 --> 00:00:15,163
It was certainly known
within the family groups
3
00:00:15,243 --> 00:00:17,683
that he was leading almost a double life.
4
00:00:18,683 --> 00:00:21,043
{\an8}In the mix
of a complicated world,
5
00:00:21,123 --> 00:00:23,483
{\an8}a man shopping in Poundland.
6
00:00:23,563 --> 00:00:28,363
He's buying these items
that are very suspicious.
7
00:00:28,443 --> 00:00:29,883
Passions were running deep
8
00:00:29,963 --> 00:00:31,523
in a multi-partner intrigue.
9
00:00:32,083 --> 00:00:35,283
Caught in the middle,
a teenager under pressure.
10
00:00:35,363 --> 00:00:38,723
I am not going to say
my father killed your lover.
11
00:00:40,803 --> 00:00:44,563
{\an8}A story of sex,
lies, and security tapes,
12
00:00:44,643 --> 00:00:48,523
{\an8}would police uncover the mystery
of the body in the boot?
13
00:00:48,603 --> 00:00:51,803
It was clear to the police that somebody
was lying to them
14
00:00:51,883 --> 00:00:53,323
and probably everyone was.
15
00:01:03,123 --> 00:01:05,803
{\an8}
16
00:01:09,403 --> 00:01:11,483
In 2003, at the age of 20
17
00:01:11,563 --> 00:01:13,803
and after an arranged marriage,
18
00:01:13,883 --> 00:01:16,203
Tanveer Iqbal began family life,
19
00:01:16,283 --> 00:01:18,843
making his home in a quiet
street in Birmingham.
20
00:01:20,363 --> 00:01:23,163
He had settled and married
his wife Nasreen,
21
00:01:23,243 --> 00:01:24,883
{\an8}and they had two children.
22
00:01:26,963 --> 00:01:28,123
He was well-liked.
23
00:01:28,203 --> 00:01:30,123
{\an8}He was doing well in his work,
24
00:01:30,203 --> 00:01:33,203
{\an8}he had status in the music industry.
25
00:01:33,283 --> 00:01:36,083
Tanveer worked
in his family's music shop,
26
00:01:36,163 --> 00:01:38,963
High Tech Music, whilst he
also tried to forge a career
27
00:01:39,043 --> 00:01:41,123
for himself as a DJ and producer.
28
00:01:42,683 --> 00:01:45,923
Five years into his arranged
marriage to wife Nasreen,
29
00:01:46,003 --> 00:01:48,683
a customer walked in
who would change everything.
30
00:01:49,963 --> 00:01:52,003
Her name, Zatoon Bibi.
31
00:01:56,283 --> 00:01:59,403
{\an8}Zatoon Bibi had met Tanveer Iqbal in 2008.
32
00:01:59,483 --> 00:02:02,123
{\an8}She just happened to be
passing by a record store
33
00:02:02,203 --> 00:02:04,123
in Birmingham were he was working.
34
00:02:04,203 --> 00:02:06,123
She popped in, they started chatting,
35
00:02:06,203 --> 00:02:08,283
and eventually they exchanged numbers.
36
00:02:08,363 --> 00:02:12,203
{\an8}I think there are
several characteristics about Tanveer
37
00:02:12,283 --> 00:02:14,083
{\an8}that Zatoon would have found
very attractive.
38
00:02:14,163 --> 00:02:16,443
So, he was a few years younger than her.
39
00:02:16,523 --> 00:02:19,123
He was a pillar of the community.
40
00:02:19,203 --> 00:02:21,043
He was a well-known personality.
41
00:02:21,123 --> 00:02:23,443
He was involved in the music business.
42
00:02:23,523 --> 00:02:25,683
So, all of these things are
quite attractive.
43
00:02:26,763 --> 00:02:28,283
The attraction was mutual.
44
00:02:28,363 --> 00:02:30,883
It wasn't long
before Tanveer and Zatoon met
45
00:02:30,963 --> 00:02:34,083
for what was supposed
to be a one-off fling.
46
00:02:34,163 --> 00:02:38,243
Zatoon and Tanveer had slept together
on one occasion
47
00:02:38,323 --> 00:02:40,683
at a hotel in Birmingham.
48
00:02:41,163 --> 00:02:43,403
The reason it was supposed
to be a one-off?
49
00:02:43,483 --> 00:02:47,243
Zatoon was also married
to a man called Gul Nawaz,
50
00:02:47,323 --> 00:02:49,563
with whom she had four children.
51
00:02:49,643 --> 00:02:51,083
It was an arranged marriage.
52
00:02:51,163 --> 00:02:54,883
He was older than her
and he was from Pakistan,
53
00:02:54,963 --> 00:02:56,963
and he came here after they were married.
54
00:02:57,763 --> 00:03:01,043
{\an8}They'd spent a very short period of time
55
00:03:02,483 --> 00:03:05,243
getting to know each other,
56
00:03:05,323 --> 00:03:08,243
but it was all very superficial
as you can imagine.
57
00:03:08,883 --> 00:03:10,203
For Zatoon at least,
58
00:03:10,283 --> 00:03:13,963
family life back in Oldbury
outside Birmingham was stifling.
59
00:03:15,003 --> 00:03:16,923
Her marriage has gone a bit stale,
60
00:03:17,003 --> 00:03:19,003
so I think to have
the attention of this man,
61
00:03:19,083 --> 00:03:21,843
who's a bit younger, who's popular,
62
00:03:21,923 --> 00:03:25,043
is something that really puts
the spring back in her step.
63
00:03:25,123 --> 00:03:29,443
There must have come
a time when she realized
64
00:03:29,523 --> 00:03:31,603
that she wanted more from life,
65
00:03:31,683 --> 00:03:34,003
and I think that's
when things started to go wrong.
66
00:03:34,083 --> 00:03:36,803
The bored housewife
and her dynamic younger lover,
67
00:03:36,883 --> 00:03:38,243
both with partners and children,
68
00:03:38,323 --> 00:03:42,563
took things beyond a casual fling,
dangerous territory.
69
00:03:42,643 --> 00:03:46,723
This didn't stop them from developing
their relationship together.
70
00:03:46,803 --> 00:03:49,043
They became regular lovers.
71
00:03:49,123 --> 00:03:52,323
In a twist, Tanveer's two partners,
72
00:03:52,403 --> 00:03:54,083
Nasreen, his wife, and Zatoon, the lover,
73
00:03:54,163 --> 00:03:57,203
{\an8}appeared okay with the arrangement.
74
00:03:57,283 --> 00:04:00,123
{\an8}They both had
knowledge of one another.
75
00:04:00,203 --> 00:04:02,003
{\an8}Tanveer's relationship with the two ladies
76
00:04:02,083 --> 00:04:03,563
{\an8}was quite well known.
77
00:04:05,043 --> 00:04:08,723
You've got two individuals
from very traditional communities
78
00:04:08,803 --> 00:04:13,003
with very set ideas of what a family
should look like and what it should be,
79
00:04:13,083 --> 00:04:16,122
especially outwardly
facing to the community.
80
00:04:16,203 --> 00:04:17,923
And then behind closed doors,
81
00:04:18,002 --> 00:04:19,442
you've got all of this going on.
82
00:04:19,523 --> 00:04:23,123
He had a wife and children
with another woman,
83
00:04:23,203 --> 00:04:25,163
and that was just accepted
within the relationship
84
00:04:25,243 --> 00:04:27,083
that that was the setup.
85
00:04:27,163 --> 00:04:29,403
Zatoon's husband, Gul Nawaz,
86
00:04:29,483 --> 00:04:33,003
knew about his wife's romance on the side.
87
00:04:33,123 --> 00:04:37,363
He was aware that Zatoon was having
a relationship with another man.
88
00:04:37,443 --> 00:04:40,843
I think he feels incredibly let down
when he discovers
89
00:04:40,923 --> 00:04:44,523
that Zatoon has been carrying on
with Tanveer behind his back.
90
00:04:46,003 --> 00:04:50,363
You had a complex situation
in which Tanveer and Zatoon
91
00:04:50,443 --> 00:04:53,643
have this odd relationship.
92
00:04:53,723 --> 00:04:59,123
{\an8}They were obviously in love
with each other at some point,
93
00:04:59,203 --> 00:05:04,403
but the fact that each
of them have spouses,
94
00:05:04,483 --> 00:05:09,723
separate spouses, meant that
life was very complicated.
95
00:05:09,803 --> 00:05:12,843
This relationship, it's a pressure cooker.
96
00:05:12,923 --> 00:05:14,963
And it's not an affair
that either of them,
97
00:05:15,043 --> 00:05:17,043
I think, could just walk away from,
98
00:05:17,123 --> 00:05:19,843
because both of them are
quite heavily invested in it.
99
00:05:20,483 --> 00:05:22,283
With a wife
and two children at home
100
00:05:22,363 --> 00:05:24,243
and a steamy affair going on
101
00:05:24,323 --> 00:05:26,083
with an older, married mom-of-four,
102
00:05:26,163 --> 00:05:28,963
Tanveer Iqbal's tangled love life was set
103
00:05:29,043 --> 00:05:31,003
to become even more complicated.
104
00:05:31,083 --> 00:05:34,403
He was about to be a father
with lover Zatoon as the mother.
105
00:05:34,483 --> 00:05:38,323
The couple were playing
with fire and it was escalating.
106
00:05:38,403 --> 00:05:42,963
Zatoon Bibi got pregnant
again with the fifth child.
107
00:05:43,043 --> 00:05:46,523
This is the point
at which this kind of transforms
108
00:05:46,603 --> 00:05:49,563
from this relationship that
she's having on the side,
109
00:05:49,643 --> 00:05:52,723
that's probably a bit of fun,
that probably kind of brings
110
00:05:52,803 --> 00:05:56,003
a little bit of a sparkle into her life
111
00:05:56,083 --> 00:05:59,203
to something that is very
serious because she's pregnant.
112
00:05:59,283 --> 00:06:01,003
She's going to have this baby,
113
00:06:01,083 --> 00:06:04,323
and this takes it to a whole new level.
114
00:06:04,403 --> 00:06:09,723
That obviously impacted
on Tanveer's relationship with his wife,
115
00:06:09,803 --> 00:06:15,083
and it impacted
on Zatoon's relationship with Gul.
116
00:06:15,163 --> 00:06:19,323
For Tanveer,
things had suddenly got serious.
117
00:06:19,403 --> 00:06:22,043
You've got this parallel
life that he's having.
118
00:06:22,123 --> 00:06:25,523
This isn't just an affair
on the side anymore.
119
00:06:25,603 --> 00:06:29,603
This is a completely kind
of formed family life.
120
00:06:31,963 --> 00:06:34,203
After the baby was born,
Zatoon arranged
121
00:06:34,283 --> 00:06:37,683
for Tanveer to spend time
with his daughter each week.
122
00:06:38,443 --> 00:06:40,963
Tanveer maintained and developed
his relationship
123
00:06:41,043 --> 00:06:43,083
with both Zatoon and his daughter.
124
00:06:43,163 --> 00:06:44,723
They would regularly go out together,
125
00:06:44,803 --> 00:06:46,683
even going to London for a trip together.
126
00:06:47,923 --> 00:06:51,843
Zatoon went to London to meet Tanveer
127
00:06:51,923 --> 00:06:56,283
and to spend some time
with him a few days,
128
00:06:56,363 --> 00:06:58,283
and she took the baby with her.
129
00:06:58,363 --> 00:07:01,963
And they'd taken photographs
130
00:07:02,043 --> 00:07:05,963
at various London attractions,
131
00:07:06,043 --> 00:07:08,843
She was foolish enough
to keep hold of those
132
00:07:08,923 --> 00:07:11,843
and take them back
133
00:07:11,923 --> 00:07:14,763
and leave them in a cupboard in the house.
134
00:07:16,763 --> 00:07:20,763
Gul found a picture
of Zatoon and Tanveer
135
00:07:20,843 --> 00:07:24,723
and their daughter on a little trip
together that they'd taken.
136
00:07:25,763 --> 00:07:28,683
According to Zatoon,
the accidental discovery
137
00:07:28,763 --> 00:07:32,563
at their Oldbury house sparked
a terrifying reaction.
138
00:07:32,643 --> 00:07:36,163
Things turned ugly,
Gul brandishing a kitchen knife
139
00:07:36,243 --> 00:07:39,123
and Zatoon forced to call 999.
140
00:07:40,563 --> 00:07:43,883
Zatoon claims that Gul became violent
141
00:07:43,963 --> 00:07:46,203
when he discovered this picture
142
00:07:46,283 --> 00:07:49,083
and that she had to go
upstairs with her child
143
00:07:49,163 --> 00:07:51,203
and lock herself in the bathroom.
144
00:07:51,283 --> 00:07:53,883
And I think we always have
to take any allegations
145
00:07:53,963 --> 00:07:57,243
of domestic abuse seriously,
but what we also need to do
146
00:07:57,323 --> 00:08:01,643
is take a step back
and look at how helpful
147
00:08:01,723 --> 00:08:04,003
is this particular narrative to Zatoon.
148
00:08:04,083 --> 00:08:06,083
Could she be using this as a way
149
00:08:06,163 --> 00:08:09,923
to paint a picture
of herself, to create herself
150
00:08:10,003 --> 00:08:14,123
as a more sympathetic character
in this story?
151
00:08:14,203 --> 00:08:16,283
By kind of dropping this
in there, we do have to be
152
00:08:16,363 --> 00:08:20,003
quite skeptical
of whether this is true or not.
153
00:08:21,443 --> 00:08:22,803
Whatever really happened
154
00:08:22,883 --> 00:08:26,203
in the Nawaz family home that day,
it was a turning point.
155
00:08:28,883 --> 00:08:31,163
Essentially this kind of contributes
156
00:08:31,243 --> 00:08:33,403
to the breakdown of their relationship.
157
00:08:33,483 --> 00:08:36,123
Gul Decided that's it, I've had enough,
158
00:08:36,202 --> 00:08:38,803
and he had an Islamic divorce from Zatoon.
159
00:08:38,883 --> 00:08:43,763
And in the Islamic tradition,
a divorce is pronounced
160
00:08:43,842 --> 00:08:47,883
by simply repeating the words
I divorce you three times,
161
00:08:47,963 --> 00:08:49,563
and that's what he did.
162
00:08:50,483 --> 00:08:51,843
It may have appeared simple,
163
00:08:51,923 --> 00:08:54,963
but it wasn't the end
of the complications.
164
00:08:55,723 --> 00:08:57,923
The problem with that was that...
165
00:08:59,203 --> 00:09:02,323
in the culture
166
00:09:02,403 --> 00:09:05,883
that they both were brought up in,
167
00:09:06,883 --> 00:09:08,883
divorce is a sin.
168
00:09:08,963 --> 00:09:13,763
And therefore,
it could not be openly discussed,
169
00:09:13,843 --> 00:09:17,283
and the family had to be kept
ignorant of it.
170
00:09:18,683 --> 00:09:20,363
Gul Nawaz agreed with his wife
171
00:09:20,443 --> 00:09:24,083
that they should keep up an appearance
of still being married.
172
00:09:25,203 --> 00:09:29,803
What you then have was
this bizarre pretense
173
00:09:29,883 --> 00:09:34,923
of the family living
together in the same house,
174
00:09:35,003 --> 00:09:36,763
but separate lives.
175
00:09:36,843 --> 00:09:40,643
Instead of ending the relationship,
176
00:09:40,723 --> 00:09:43,563
saying, "I've had enough,
177
00:09:43,643 --> 00:09:44,843
"you've been unfaithful.
178
00:09:44,923 --> 00:09:49,243
I want a divorce in which
we go our separate ways",
179
00:09:49,323 --> 00:09:53,843
he was prepared to, and possibly,
180
00:09:53,923 --> 00:09:59,003
I think, for his own benefit,
for his own pride,
181
00:09:59,083 --> 00:10:02,923
for his own honor, and for hers as well,
182
00:10:03,003 --> 00:10:06,643
to live this lie that
they were still husband and wife.
183
00:10:08,563 --> 00:10:11,083
Trapped in a fake life
with Gul Nawaz,
184
00:10:11,163 --> 00:10:14,083
Zatoon began to figure out an escape plan.
185
00:10:14,763 --> 00:10:18,763
She then went on to have
a second child with Tanveer.
186
00:10:18,843 --> 00:10:23,483
Zatoon feels entitled to
this exclusive relationship with Tanveer.
187
00:10:23,563 --> 00:10:26,643
She feels that she deserves it
because she's invested
188
00:10:26,723 --> 00:10:30,523
so much in terms of time
and in terms of emotional energy.
189
00:10:31,603 --> 00:10:33,563
She may have wanted
to control things
190
00:10:33,643 --> 00:10:35,563
with Tanveer, but their relationship,
191
00:10:35,643 --> 00:10:39,323
rooted in lies from the start,
had problems.
192
00:10:40,163 --> 00:10:41,483
There was a lot of friction,
193
00:10:41,563 --> 00:10:46,523
a huge amount of distrust
between Tanveer and Zatoon.
194
00:10:49,003 --> 00:10:50,403
{\an8}How was Zatoon going to deal
195
00:10:50,483 --> 00:10:52,963
{\an8}with Tanveer's wife Nasreen?
196
00:10:53,043 --> 00:10:57,203
This was an arrangement that was never
going to be a sustainable one.
197
00:10:57,283 --> 00:11:00,563
{\an8}Zatoon realizes that she's pregnant.
198
00:11:00,643 --> 00:11:03,883
{\an8}One man,
two women, six children...
199
00:11:04,563 --> 00:11:06,363
{\an8}it was never going to add up.
200
00:11:06,443 --> 00:11:11,083
It was an ambush.
When Tanveer came in, he was jumped.
201
00:11:18,763 --> 00:11:20,803
Despite his affair and two children
202
00:11:20,883 --> 00:11:23,043
with Zatoon Bibi, Tanveer Iqbal stayed
203
00:11:23,123 --> 00:11:26,043
with his wife Nasreen and their children
204
00:11:26,123 --> 00:11:28,323
at the family home in
Bearwood, Birmingham.
205
00:11:32,843 --> 00:11:35,603
{\an8}Nasreen came from a culture from Pakistan
206
00:11:35,683 --> 00:11:37,763
{\an8}where it was acceptable
in certain circumstances
207
00:11:37,843 --> 00:11:40,443
that her husband could take a second wife.
208
00:11:40,523 --> 00:11:44,803
And somehow she reconciled
herself to this arrangement.
209
00:11:44,883 --> 00:11:47,763
Not only tolerant of it,
she almost embraced it.
210
00:11:48,443 --> 00:11:51,443
{\an8}Tanveer was her husband,
she was his wife, this was her life,
211
00:11:51,523 --> 00:11:53,403
{\an8}and she was going to make it work.
212
00:11:54,283 --> 00:11:56,083
Tanveer seemed
to have established
213
00:11:56,163 --> 00:11:58,643
what was for him
the perfect love triangle.
214
00:11:59,643 --> 00:12:01,563
And so
an extraordinary situation developed
215
00:12:01,643 --> 00:12:03,923
whereby Tanveer had
two children with his own wife
216
00:12:04,003 --> 00:12:05,643
but two children with a woman
217
00:12:05,723 --> 00:12:07,443
with whom he was having an affair.
218
00:12:07,523 --> 00:12:10,483
Zatoon kept up
a pretense of marriage to Gul,
219
00:12:10,563 --> 00:12:14,323
caring for their four children,
including one, Khashim,
220
00:12:14,403 --> 00:12:17,283
who would play a big
part in her later plans.
221
00:12:17,363 --> 00:12:20,923
{\an8}She also got herself a house
just a few minutes away from her lover.
222
00:12:21,003 --> 00:12:24,363
{\an8}From here, she exerted
control in a new way.
223
00:12:24,443 --> 00:12:26,603
{\an8}This time over Nasreen.
224
00:12:26,683 --> 00:12:29,563
{\an8}The relationship between the two ladies,
225
00:12:29,643 --> 00:12:34,083
{\an8}that's Tanveer's wife and Zatoon Bibi,
226
00:12:34,163 --> 00:12:36,603
{\an8}as you could probably appreciate it,
wasn't a good one.
227
00:12:36,683 --> 00:12:39,443
{\an8}There'd been lots of communication
between the two parties
228
00:12:39,523 --> 00:12:41,243
{\an8}over the telephone.
229
00:12:41,323 --> 00:12:44,403
While things were
understandably frosty
230
00:12:44,483 --> 00:12:46,763
to begin with,
Zatoon gradually wormed her way
231
00:12:46,843 --> 00:12:48,683
into Nasreen's confidence.
232
00:12:48,763 --> 00:12:50,643
Things began to change.
233
00:12:50,723 --> 00:12:53,283
Zatoon managed to get to meet her.
234
00:12:53,363 --> 00:12:57,203
She'd take her for coffee at Cafe's,
they'd sit down, they'd have a natter.
235
00:12:57,283 --> 00:12:59,203
They'd talk about their respective lives
236
00:12:59,283 --> 00:13:00,963
and about the man that they shared.
237
00:13:01,043 --> 00:13:04,923
And slowly but surely
Nasreen began to trust her.
238
00:13:05,803 --> 00:13:10,483
Here was Zatoon, this worldly wise woman
older than Nasreen,
239
00:13:10,563 --> 00:13:13,283
understanding how British society worked.
240
00:13:13,363 --> 00:13:14,683
She befriended her.
241
00:13:16,083 --> 00:13:18,883
And, strangely enough, by some means
242
00:13:18,963 --> 00:13:20,803
she persuaded Nasreen
243
00:13:20,883 --> 00:13:23,163
that this triangular relationship
could actually work.
244
00:13:23,243 --> 00:13:25,363
They appear to become friends,
245
00:13:25,443 --> 00:13:27,843
but I think what's going
on here is that Zatoon
246
00:13:27,923 --> 00:13:30,323
is being quite manipulative.
247
00:13:30,403 --> 00:13:34,563
She wants Tanveer for herself,
and it's always best
248
00:13:34,643 --> 00:13:36,723
to keep your friends close
and your enemies closer.
249
00:13:36,803 --> 00:13:40,563
And I think that is literally
what was going on in this case.
250
00:13:40,643 --> 00:13:43,283
And in order for her to be
able to win her man,
251
00:13:43,363 --> 00:13:45,323
she needed to break that relationship
252
00:13:45,403 --> 00:13:47,443
between him and his wife.
253
00:13:52,043 --> 00:13:54,803
In August 2015,
Tanveer found out
254
00:13:54,883 --> 00:13:56,723
what Zatoon had been up to.
255
00:13:57,523 --> 00:14:00,323
Tanveer finds out that Zatoon and Nasreen
256
00:14:00,403 --> 00:14:03,083
have become friends
and that they are in touch
257
00:14:03,163 --> 00:14:06,563
with one another, and he is
not happy with this whatsoever.
258
00:14:06,643 --> 00:14:09,163
There was a lot
of conflict in the relationship,
259
00:14:09,243 --> 00:14:15,083
{\an8}and she was,
to some extent, creating mischief
260
00:14:15,163 --> 00:14:17,843
as between Tanveer and his wife.
261
00:14:18,523 --> 00:14:21,763
Tanveer asks Nasreen
and Zatoon to stop texting,
262
00:14:21,843 --> 00:14:23,403
{\an8}and there could be a
number of reasons for this.
263
00:14:23,483 --> 00:14:26,323
{\an8}One of the reasons may be with the women
264
00:14:26,403 --> 00:14:28,683
{\an8}developing a relationship
independently of him,
265
00:14:28,763 --> 00:14:31,683
he may have felt that
he didn't have as much control
266
00:14:31,763 --> 00:14:34,283
of the situation
as he did in the beginning.
267
00:14:34,363 --> 00:14:37,643
He doesn't want these two women
in contact with each other.
268
00:14:37,723 --> 00:14:41,083
He wants to keep these two parts
of his life separate.
269
00:14:41,163 --> 00:14:43,683
He wants them compartmentalized.
270
00:14:44,843 --> 00:14:47,603
Elizabeth Yardley is
a professor of criminology
271
00:14:47,683 --> 00:14:48,963
at Birmingham City University.
272
00:14:49,043 --> 00:14:51,523
She believes Zatoon had an ulterior motive
273
00:14:51,603 --> 00:14:54,923
for courting her love rival so carefully.
274
00:14:55,003 --> 00:14:57,323
She wants Nasreen on side.
275
00:14:57,403 --> 00:14:59,963
She wants to be able to manipulate her.
276
00:15:00,043 --> 00:15:01,403
She wants to be able to find out things
277
00:15:01,483 --> 00:15:03,403
that she can use against her.
278
00:15:03,483 --> 00:15:06,523
So, they continue to be in touch
279
00:15:06,603 --> 00:15:08,323
and they actually get mobile phones
280
00:15:08,403 --> 00:15:10,563
and they save each other's numbers
281
00:15:10,643 --> 00:15:13,203
in these phones under pseudonyms.
282
00:15:14,083 --> 00:15:17,803
Zatoon is always looking to the future.
283
00:15:17,883 --> 00:15:21,403
She's wanting a future with Tanveer
284
00:15:21,483 --> 00:15:23,483
which is monogamous
and which is exclusive.
285
00:15:23,563 --> 00:15:26,883
This strange set up took
another bizarre twist.
286
00:15:26,963 --> 00:15:30,963
Zatoon knew that if she was
to have Tanveer all to herself,
287
00:15:31,043 --> 00:15:33,683
she'd need to break
his relationship with his wife.
288
00:15:33,763 --> 00:15:35,923
So this is quite sophisticated.
289
00:15:36,003 --> 00:15:38,003
It's quite a high level of manipulation
290
00:15:38,083 --> 00:15:39,123
that's going on here.
291
00:15:42,123 --> 00:15:43,883
Once Zatoon was confident
292
00:15:43,963 --> 00:15:46,203
that she had Nasreen under her influence,
293
00:15:46,283 --> 00:15:48,523
she began to sow the seeds of suspicion.
294
00:15:48,603 --> 00:15:51,763
{\an8}You can see in the text messages
that pass between them,
295
00:15:51,843 --> 00:15:54,683
he's referring to Zatoon as a psycho.
296
00:15:56,003 --> 00:16:00,003
There was always a ticking time bomb
going off in this situation.
297
00:16:00,083 --> 00:16:02,643
There was never going to be a moment
298
00:16:02,723 --> 00:16:04,323
when she got what she wanted,
299
00:16:04,403 --> 00:16:07,003
because Tanveer was just not
going to give that to her.
300
00:16:08,123 --> 00:16:09,683
Zatoon had tried emotionally
301
00:16:09,763 --> 00:16:12,163
blackmailing Tanveer into leaving Nasreen.
302
00:16:12,243 --> 00:16:16,603
It was time to change strategy
to get Nasreen to dump Tanveer.
303
00:16:17,603 --> 00:16:22,003
At some point,
Zatoon started sending text messages
304
00:16:22,083 --> 00:16:23,523
that contained sexual images
305
00:16:23,603 --> 00:16:25,723
of her and Tanveer together to Nasreen.
306
00:16:25,803 --> 00:16:29,563
Zatoon is becoming increasingly desperate,
307
00:16:29,643 --> 00:16:33,483
and she wants to drive a wedge
between Tanveer and Nasreen.
308
00:16:33,563 --> 00:16:36,603
So, she sends a sexually explicit video
309
00:16:36,683 --> 00:16:38,803
of Tanveer to Nasreen.
310
00:16:41,443 --> 00:16:45,083
The purpose of the video
was clearly to upset Nasreen
311
00:16:45,163 --> 00:16:48,003
and to build some kind of
a division between the couple.
312
00:16:48,083 --> 00:16:50,683
In fact, Zatoon's manipulation
313
00:16:50,763 --> 00:16:52,363
backfired spectacularly.
314
00:16:52,963 --> 00:16:56,603
Tanveer went absolutely mad
when he discovered what had happened.
315
00:16:56,683 --> 00:16:58,523
He banned his wife Nasreen
316
00:16:58,603 --> 00:17:00,403
from ever talking to Zatoon again.
317
00:17:01,203 --> 00:17:04,523
And he says to Zatoon,
I never want to see you again,
318
00:17:04,603 --> 00:17:06,723
that's it, it's done, it's over.
319
00:17:06,803 --> 00:17:10,402
He's had enough
of his relationship with this woman.
320
00:17:12,043 --> 00:17:14,122
Zatoon had underestimated
321
00:17:14,203 --> 00:17:16,483
Tanveer's love for his wife Nasreen
322
00:17:16,563 --> 00:17:19,882
and perhaps overestimated
his affection for her.
323
00:17:19,963 --> 00:17:23,323
With all her efforts falling to nothing,
324
00:17:23,402 --> 00:17:26,323
she realized that
he would never leave his wife.
325
00:17:26,402 --> 00:17:29,163
I think this is the point
at which Zatoon realizes
326
00:17:29,243 --> 00:17:31,803
that she is not a priority for Tanveer.
327
00:17:31,883 --> 00:17:34,283
She has only ever been an option to him.
328
00:17:34,363 --> 00:17:38,003
And now he's decided actually
I'm going to leave this.
329
00:17:38,843 --> 00:17:40,803
Tanveer may have thought
he had the power
330
00:17:40,883 --> 00:17:42,923
to end his relationship with Zatoon Bibi.
331
00:17:43,003 --> 00:17:44,563
She had other ideas.
332
00:17:45,923 --> 00:17:48,803
She could have felt quite sad
at the breakdown of the relationship.
333
00:17:48,883 --> 00:17:50,283
She could have felt quite angry
334
00:17:50,363 --> 00:17:51,803
about the breakdown of the relationship.
335
00:17:51,883 --> 00:17:53,443
She could also have felt quite anxious
336
00:17:53,523 --> 00:17:55,323
about the breakdown of the relationship,
337
00:17:55,403 --> 00:17:58,243
because she was being confronted
with the thing that she's lost.
338
00:17:58,323 --> 00:18:00,283
It was more than she
could tolerate and accept.
339
00:18:01,403 --> 00:18:02,523
She made a plan.
340
00:18:02,603 --> 00:18:04,603
When he decides to leave,
341
00:18:04,683 --> 00:18:08,283
I think this sets off
something incredibly toxic in Zatoon.
342
00:18:10,363 --> 00:18:13,723
Zatoon decides that
if she can't have Tanveer Iqbal,
343
00:18:13,803 --> 00:18:16,283
no one will, he must die.
344
00:18:17,923 --> 00:18:23,923
Once Zatoon had come to the conclusion
345
00:18:24,003 --> 00:18:28,203
that the relationship with
Tanveer was going nowhere
346
00:18:28,283 --> 00:18:31,963
and needed to be ended,
the next question for her
347
00:18:32,043 --> 00:18:35,283
would have been how to end it.
348
00:18:39,763 --> 00:18:42,163
Rather than trying to control Tanveer
349
00:18:42,243 --> 00:18:44,443
by keeping him
in the relationship with her,
350
00:18:44,523 --> 00:18:47,283
she decides to destroy him for leaving it.
351
00:18:49,603 --> 00:18:53,403
Sunday, January 31st, 2016,
352
00:18:53,483 --> 00:18:56,323
the day after Tanveer's 33rd birthday.
353
00:18:56,403 --> 00:18:59,203
{\an8}Zatoon began texting him, begging him.
354
00:18:59,283 --> 00:19:00,683
{\an8}She wanted forgiveness.
355
00:19:01,883 --> 00:19:05,443
She knows what buttons to push,
what things to say to him.
356
00:19:05,523 --> 00:19:07,723
So, she says things like, "I'm sorry.
357
00:19:07,803 --> 00:19:09,723
"I promise that I'll obey you.
358
00:19:09,803 --> 00:19:11,563
"I won't get in touch with Nasreen again,
359
00:19:11,643 --> 00:19:13,523
we'll keep this all separate."
360
00:19:13,603 --> 00:19:14,923
Zatoon invited Tanveer
361
00:19:15,003 --> 00:19:16,603
to her Bartley Green home.
362
00:19:16,683 --> 00:19:19,323
A place that he'd visited
before countless times,
363
00:19:19,403 --> 00:19:21,323
a place where he'd seen the two children
364
00:19:21,403 --> 00:19:24,083
they had together to spend time with them.
365
00:19:24,163 --> 00:19:27,923
She contacted Tanveer and said look,
366
00:19:28,003 --> 00:19:33,403
we haven't celebrated your birthday,
and your two children,
367
00:19:33,483 --> 00:19:37,003
they want you to have a birthday cake
368
00:19:37,083 --> 00:19:39,963
and will you come to my house?
369
00:19:40,043 --> 00:19:42,483
We'll have a little birthday party.
370
00:19:42,563 --> 00:19:44,323
As he left for a shift at work,
371
00:19:44,403 --> 00:19:48,123
Tanveer told Nasreen
he would be going to see Zatoon.
372
00:19:48,203 --> 00:19:50,483
He wouldn't be home until late.
373
00:19:50,563 --> 00:19:52,203
Nasreen wakes up the next day
374
00:19:52,283 --> 00:19:55,403
and discovers that Tanveer
is not in the house.
375
00:19:56,403 --> 00:19:58,043
Family were concerned.
376
00:19:58,123 --> 00:19:59,923
Yeah, it was out of character
for him not to return home.
377
00:20:00,003 --> 00:20:02,843
So the family, his brothers
contacted the police
378
00:20:02,923 --> 00:20:05,163
to report him as a missing person.
379
00:20:05,243 --> 00:20:07,923
No investigation was immediately launched.
380
00:20:08,003 --> 00:20:10,483
When a man in his 30s doesn't come home,
381
00:20:10,563 --> 00:20:12,883
it is rarely a cause for concern.
382
00:20:15,283 --> 00:20:17,163
Our normal protocol is if it's an adult
383
00:20:17,243 --> 00:20:18,923
and there's no suspicious circumstances
384
00:20:19,003 --> 00:20:22,083
and there are no other,
you know, concerning factors,
385
00:20:22,163 --> 00:20:23,523
we will just wait to see what happens
386
00:20:23,603 --> 00:20:25,083
and see if the person returns home
387
00:20:25,163 --> 00:20:27,043
sort of within 24 hours or so.
388
00:20:27,123 --> 00:20:29,163
And in this case,
there was no alarming features.
389
00:20:29,243 --> 00:20:30,483
There was nothing that suggested
390
00:20:30,563 --> 00:20:33,003
that any harm would come to Tanveer.
391
00:20:34,683 --> 00:20:36,003
His wife Nasreen, however,
392
00:20:36,083 --> 00:20:37,643
was getting desperate.
393
00:20:37,723 --> 00:20:41,723
Knowing that Tanveer had intended
to see Zatoon the previous evening,
394
00:20:41,803 --> 00:20:44,163
she dug out her mobile phone.
395
00:20:44,243 --> 00:20:47,083
She phoned Zatoon
and asked her, have you seen him?
396
00:20:47,163 --> 00:20:50,123
Zatoon said "no, he didn't come.
He wasn't here."
397
00:20:50,883 --> 00:20:53,603
And Zatoon says,
"I have no idea where he is.
398
00:20:53,683 --> 00:20:55,083
I haven't seen him."
399
00:20:55,163 --> 00:20:58,523
The evening
of 31st January, 2016,
400
00:20:58,603 --> 00:21:01,123
and Tanveer Iqbal, not home as expected,
401
00:21:01,203 --> 00:21:03,803
the following morning still no sign.
402
00:21:03,883 --> 00:21:05,243
What had happened?
403
00:21:05,363 --> 00:21:09,203
{\an8}The police would soon be
tracking Tanveer's movements.
404
00:21:09,283 --> 00:21:11,803
{\an8}They were able to track Tanveer's car
405
00:21:11,883 --> 00:21:13,803
{\an8}right to Zatoon's door.
406
00:21:13,883 --> 00:21:15,883
{\an8}
Questions were soon being asked.
407
00:21:15,963 --> 00:21:19,203
{\an8}What was the reason
for the unusual behavior of Gul Nawaz?
408
00:21:19,283 --> 00:21:21,963
{\an8}We actually had CCTV imagery of Gul Nawaz
409
00:21:22,043 --> 00:21:26,443
{\an8}buying some cleaning products
in a local Poundland store.
410
00:21:27,203 --> 00:21:29,163
Why would calls reveal
that Zatoon Bibi
411
00:21:29,243 --> 00:21:33,403
was leaning on her son,
Khashim, asking him to lie?
412
00:21:34,363 --> 00:21:38,363
{\an8}What was the truth
behind an intrigue of sex, lies,
413
00:21:38,443 --> 00:21:40,083
{\an8}security tapes,
414
00:21:40,163 --> 00:21:43,283
{\an8}and the mystery of a missing man,
Tanveer Iqbal?
415
00:21:53,963 --> 00:21:57,203
Initially, the police had
not been too disturbed
416
00:21:57,283 --> 00:22:00,123
by Tanveer Iqbal's disappearance.
417
00:22:00,203 --> 00:22:02,403
{\an8}There was no reason
to think that anything untoward
418
00:22:02,483 --> 00:22:04,363
{\an8}had happened to him because he appeared
419
00:22:04,443 --> 00:22:07,683
to be a happy, family man,
part of a family business
420
00:22:07,763 --> 00:22:11,283
with a healthy relationship
with all of his family members.
421
00:22:12,043 --> 00:22:13,363
But as the hours passed,
422
00:22:13,443 --> 00:22:15,443
police became deeply concerned,
423
00:22:15,523 --> 00:22:18,323
more so when family members reported
424
00:22:18,403 --> 00:22:21,283
that they had found Tanveer's car.
425
00:22:21,363 --> 00:22:24,843
His own car was a Renault Clio,
and that was found
426
00:22:24,923 --> 00:22:26,803
not too far away from his home address.
427
00:22:26,883 --> 00:22:30,043
It was found parked on Portland Road
facing the wrong way.
428
00:22:30,123 --> 00:22:31,363
And when they open the car...
429
00:22:32,363 --> 00:22:36,723
It was on the Monday morning
after his disappearance
430
00:22:36,803 --> 00:22:38,803
that the grim discovery was made.
431
00:22:41,243 --> 00:22:45,763
{\an8}Inside the boot was his body
wrapped in a cardboard box.
432
00:22:47,483 --> 00:22:50,723
Really undignified end
to this man's life.
433
00:22:50,803 --> 00:22:53,123
{\an8}It was almost like
dumping a piece of trash.
434
00:22:53,203 --> 00:22:55,003
{\an8}You know, I'm getting rid of this.
435
00:22:55,083 --> 00:22:57,883
{\an8}I'm just going to put it in this old box
436
00:22:57,963 --> 00:23:00,803
and tape up this old
box and forget about it.
437
00:23:00,883 --> 00:23:04,323
And that is literally what
they did with this individual.
438
00:23:04,403 --> 00:23:07,243
One of the first steps
as any lead investigator is
439
00:23:07,323 --> 00:23:09,123
to secure and preserve evidence.
440
00:23:11,323 --> 00:23:12,923
That evidence
showed Tanveer found
441
00:23:13,003 --> 00:23:14,923
in a wrapped cardboard box,
442
00:23:15,003 --> 00:23:19,803
tied with a nylon rope
and bound with silver duct tape.
443
00:23:19,883 --> 00:23:22,483
The pathologist's evidence was
that Tanveer
444
00:23:22,563 --> 00:23:26,003
had died because of the use
of a ligature around his neck
445
00:23:26,083 --> 00:23:27,803
and a pressure had been applied.
446
00:23:27,883 --> 00:23:29,963
In other words, in common language,
447
00:23:30,043 --> 00:23:31,523
he'd been strangled to death.
448
00:23:32,683 --> 00:23:34,923
And when we look
at that particular method,
449
00:23:35,003 --> 00:23:37,883
it's a way of watching
the life drain from somebody,
450
00:23:37,963 --> 00:23:41,603
so people who use that method
in killing their victims
451
00:23:41,683 --> 00:23:45,043
are people who enjoy
those feelings of power and control
452
00:23:45,123 --> 00:23:46,963
and being the person who is in charge
453
00:23:47,043 --> 00:23:50,283
of whether this person gets
to live or die.
454
00:23:50,363 --> 00:23:54,083
So, it's very meaningful,
it's very significant as a method.
455
00:23:54,163 --> 00:23:56,603
It appeared
that the same nylon rope
456
00:23:56,683 --> 00:23:58,803
that was used to wrap the cardboard box
457
00:23:58,883 --> 00:24:00,923
was used to kill Tanveer.
458
00:24:01,003 --> 00:24:02,683
It would take a strong assailant
459
00:24:02,763 --> 00:24:05,723
or more than one person to do that.
460
00:24:05,803 --> 00:24:08,963
And the other remarkable feature was
the driver's seat
461
00:24:09,043 --> 00:24:10,963
was really far forward
to the steering wheel,
462
00:24:11,043 --> 00:24:12,883
really close to the steering wheel,
463
00:24:12,963 --> 00:24:14,883
indicating that whoever had disposed
of the vehicle there
464
00:24:14,963 --> 00:24:17,403
was probably small or
quite short in height.
465
00:24:18,483 --> 00:24:21,883
It was a puzzle,
it was a murder investigation.
466
00:24:21,963 --> 00:24:24,363
Tanveer, a man in the prime of his life,
467
00:24:24,443 --> 00:24:27,003
had been overpowered and strangled.
468
00:24:27,083 --> 00:24:29,723
The investigation rapidly scaled up.
469
00:24:31,123 --> 00:24:33,203
We will speak to immediate witnesses,
470
00:24:33,283 --> 00:24:35,323
we'll look for witnesses in the area,
471
00:24:35,403 --> 00:24:37,883
we'll seek to resolve
any forensic opportunities
472
00:24:37,963 --> 00:24:39,963
that can be achieved immediately,
473
00:24:40,043 --> 00:24:43,323
and we'll also look
for any CCTV opportunities that may exist.
474
00:24:44,443 --> 00:24:46,763
{\an8}The focus was very much around the family,
475
00:24:46,843 --> 00:24:49,643
{\an8}around focusing upon
building a good relationship
476
00:24:49,723 --> 00:24:51,843
{\an8}with the family in order
to get as much information
477
00:24:51,923 --> 00:24:53,483
{\an8}from them as we could.
478
00:24:53,563 --> 00:24:57,003
And also then looking
at Tanveer's life in general
479
00:24:57,083 --> 00:24:58,963
and looking at what his lifestyle was
480
00:24:59,043 --> 00:25:00,523
and who his friends were.
481
00:25:00,603 --> 00:25:02,403
And that's when of course we learned
482
00:25:02,483 --> 00:25:04,443
about the relationship with Zatoon Bibi.
483
00:25:05,323 --> 00:25:07,123
Now for any investigating officer,
484
00:25:07,203 --> 00:25:08,803
this is really significant.
485
00:25:08,883 --> 00:25:12,683
This is a distinct flashing beacon
that needs attention.
486
00:25:12,763 --> 00:25:15,963
They will want to see
whether this illicit relationship
487
00:25:16,043 --> 00:25:19,123
has any association with his murder.
488
00:25:19,883 --> 00:25:21,683
When you're dealing with a murder inquiry
489
00:25:21,763 --> 00:25:24,003
and you hear of a second relationship
490
00:25:24,083 --> 00:25:26,643
or a third relationship within a marriage,
491
00:25:26,723 --> 00:25:29,603
you certainly would consider that
to be something that's worthy of interest.
492
00:25:29,683 --> 00:25:31,283
And I would consider it as a red flag,
493
00:25:31,363 --> 00:25:33,323
something that needs closer attention.
494
00:25:34,163 --> 00:25:35,603
Although there were red flags
495
00:25:35,683 --> 00:25:37,563
about Tanveer's two families,
496
00:25:37,643 --> 00:25:40,443
Paul Joyce was treading carefully.
497
00:25:40,523 --> 00:25:44,403
Zatoon Bibi never jumped out
as a suspect immediately
498
00:25:44,483 --> 00:25:46,683
to me as the lead investigator
on this case.
499
00:25:46,763 --> 00:25:49,923
And it was only as we sort of
edged into the investigation,
500
00:25:50,003 --> 00:25:52,603
a number of days, in where my mind
501
00:25:52,683 --> 00:25:54,923
was sort of focused upon Zatoon.
502
00:25:55,003 --> 00:25:57,123
My kind of natural senses were
telling me that
503
00:25:57,203 --> 00:26:01,563
she had more to do with this
than was initially evident.
504
00:26:01,643 --> 00:26:04,083
In the hunt
for the driver of the Renault Clio,
505
00:26:04,163 --> 00:26:05,483
she fitted the bill.
506
00:26:05,563 --> 00:26:07,923
Zatoon is short,
a little over five feet tall,
507
00:26:08,003 --> 00:26:10,883
and the position
of the car seat suggested a short person
508
00:26:10,963 --> 00:26:14,203
had been the last to drive Tanveer's car.
509
00:26:14,283 --> 00:26:16,603
That fact suggested other lines of inquiry
510
00:26:16,683 --> 00:26:19,163
with Zatoon a person of interest.
511
00:26:19,243 --> 00:26:20,803
She couldn't have done this on her own.
512
00:26:20,883 --> 00:26:23,523
And from the very early stages, to me,
513
00:26:23,603 --> 00:26:25,083
it was obvious that
somebody must've helped her.
514
00:26:25,163 --> 00:26:29,203
For example, a very small female
couldn't pick up a 13 stone male,
515
00:26:29,283 --> 00:26:31,563
couldn't probably overpower a young, fit,
516
00:26:31,643 --> 00:26:33,163
healthy male on her own.
517
00:26:34,203 --> 00:26:37,043
{\an8}
Detectives looked for more CCTV footage.
518
00:26:39,963 --> 00:26:43,603
CCTV played a major part
in showing and painting
519
00:26:43,683 --> 00:26:46,283
the picture of exactly
what happened to Tanveer
520
00:26:46,363 --> 00:26:47,603
in the moments leading up to his death.
521
00:26:48,323 --> 00:26:50,603
Police already knew
that Tanveer intended
522
00:26:50,683 --> 00:26:52,843
to visit Zatoon's house
that Sunday afternoon.
523
00:26:52,923 --> 00:26:56,403
They did not know the role
that her teenage son, Khashim,
524
00:26:56,483 --> 00:27:00,283
{\an8}and her husband Gul Nawaz
were about to play in murder.
525
00:27:02,043 --> 00:27:05,323
The CCTV from the neighboring house was
very revealing.
526
00:27:06,003 --> 00:27:10,643
{\an8}5:30 pm Sunday evening,
a Vauxhall Zafira pulls up
527
00:27:10,723 --> 00:27:13,083
{\an8}at the Zatoon Bibi's home.
528
00:27:13,163 --> 00:27:14,723
{\an8}Two males and a female can be seen
529
00:27:14,803 --> 00:27:17,003
{\an8}taking things out of the boot.
530
00:27:17,083 --> 00:27:19,563
{\an8}Who were the two men?
531
00:27:19,643 --> 00:27:22,163
{\an8}It showed that Zatoon had turned up
with her husband
532
00:27:22,243 --> 00:27:26,283
{\an8}and her son not long
before Tanveer arrived.
533
00:27:26,363 --> 00:27:31,843
{\an8}We see on CCTV footage that
Zatoon, Gul Nawaz, and Kashim
534
00:27:31,923 --> 00:27:34,563
{\an8}get out of the car and they go inside.
535
00:27:38,043 --> 00:27:40,203
Kashim, Zatoon's teenage son.
536
00:27:40,283 --> 00:27:43,163
{\an8}An hour later,
Tanveer Iqbal arrives at the property
537
00:27:43,243 --> 00:27:44,683
{\an8}in his Renault Clio.
538
00:27:45,763 --> 00:27:48,043
{\an8}They were able to track Tanveer's car
539
00:27:48,123 --> 00:27:49,483
right to Zatoon's door.
540
00:27:54,243 --> 00:27:56,083
He's probably feeling
quite kind of upbeat.
541
00:27:56,163 --> 00:27:58,843
He thinks he's getting
this little life on the side
542
00:27:58,923 --> 00:28:01,683
back on his terms,
just the way that he wants things.
543
00:28:02,363 --> 00:28:04,163
{\an8}Another hour passes.
544
00:28:04,243 --> 00:28:07,603
{\an8}At around 7:30 pm,
someone emerges from the house,
545
00:28:07,683 --> 00:28:09,883
{\an8}turns Tanveer's Clio around,
546
00:28:09,963 --> 00:28:12,163
{\an8}and reverses it up to the front door.
547
00:28:13,563 --> 00:28:16,563
{\an8}Then you see a large object
being loaded into the boot,
548
00:28:16,643 --> 00:28:19,563
{\an8}and then you've got
the boot being closed by Zatoon,
549
00:28:19,643 --> 00:28:21,163
and then the vehicle is driven off,
550
00:28:21,243 --> 00:28:23,603
{\an8}followed by a family vehicle.
551
00:28:23,683 --> 00:28:26,923
{\an8}And who we believed at the time
was her son and her husband.
552
00:28:28,203 --> 00:28:31,243
{\an8}From that moment onwards
it was clear that Zatoon,
553
00:28:31,323 --> 00:28:34,483
her husband, and the teenage boy
that they had together
554
00:28:34,563 --> 00:28:38,163
{\an8}were going to be
the prime suspects for this murder.
555
00:28:38,243 --> 00:28:40,443
{\an8}The CCTV
from the neighbor's house wasn't
556
00:28:40,523 --> 00:28:42,203
{\an8}the only useful footage
557
00:28:42,283 --> 00:28:44,363
{\an8}that detectives found that night.
558
00:28:44,443 --> 00:28:47,123
{\an8}Street cameras picked up
more vital evidence
559
00:28:47,203 --> 00:28:49,683
{\an8}about Zatoon and the two men.
560
00:28:50,363 --> 00:28:54,883
They left that house in convoy
and took the car to Edgbaston,
561
00:28:54,963 --> 00:28:57,163
{\an8}where Zatoon parked it up
and left it unlocked.
562
00:28:59,083 --> 00:29:03,003
{\an8}We were able to identify
some CCTV that showed a female
563
00:29:03,083 --> 00:29:05,163
{\an8}walking away from the deposition site
564
00:29:05,243 --> 00:29:07,123
{\an8}on the night
of the vehicle being dropped off.
565
00:29:07,683 --> 00:29:10,723
{\an8}And minutes later,
she is captured on camera again.
566
00:29:10,803 --> 00:29:16,083
{\an8}She left the car
on the street and then went off
567
00:29:16,163 --> 00:29:19,203
{\an8}and called Gul Nawaz
to come and pick her up.
568
00:29:19,283 --> 00:29:23,523
{\an8}So he came, picked her up,
and then took her back home.
569
00:29:23,603 --> 00:29:26,443
That was when the investigation
started to come alive for me.
570
00:29:27,683 --> 00:29:31,403
{\an8}We start to build a compelling,
evidential case against Zatoon.
571
00:29:32,683 --> 00:29:34,643
And not just Zatoon.
572
00:29:34,723 --> 00:29:38,563
Her husband Gul
and their 15-year-old son Kashim were
573
00:29:38,643 --> 00:29:42,203
{\an8}the others confirmed
as those on the CCTV footage.
574
00:29:42,283 --> 00:29:44,843
{\an8}Detective Inspector Paul Joyce felt
575
00:29:44,923 --> 00:29:47,603
{\an8}he was getting to the truth
of what had happened
576
00:29:47,683 --> 00:29:50,363
to the man in the boot, Tanveer Iqbal.
577
00:29:51,283 --> 00:29:53,323
The CCTV strategy as well was widened out
578
00:29:53,403 --> 00:29:55,123
to local department stores, shops,
579
00:29:55,203 --> 00:29:56,563
et cetera in the local area.
580
00:29:57,483 --> 00:30:00,163
{\an8}
The trawl for CCTV picks up Gul Nawaz.
581
00:30:00,243 --> 00:30:02,843
{\an8}We actually had CCTV imagery of Gul Nawaz
582
00:30:02,923 --> 00:30:07,363
{\an8}buying some cleaning products
in a local Poundland store.
583
00:30:07,443 --> 00:30:10,683
{\an8}Gul Nawaz bought rope and some duct tape.
584
00:30:10,763 --> 00:30:12,803
He was buying things
like cleaning products,
585
00:30:12,883 --> 00:30:14,283
bleach, rubber gloves.
586
00:30:14,363 --> 00:30:16,803
They see that he's buying these items
587
00:30:16,883 --> 00:30:18,883
that are very suspicious.
588
00:30:18,963 --> 00:30:20,843
And so in that way, the police were able
589
00:30:20,923 --> 00:30:23,363
to build up a picture
of two prime suspects,
590
00:30:23,443 --> 00:30:26,723
and it was only later
that the evidence came out
591
00:30:26,803 --> 00:30:30,163
that Kashim was there
as well from the CCTV.
592
00:30:32,563 --> 00:30:35,363
{\an8}Had the two men been buying
a kill kit?
593
00:30:35,443 --> 00:30:38,003
Did officers have enough
to arrest Zatoon Bibi,
594
00:30:38,083 --> 00:30:43,283
mother to Kashim, wife to Gul,
and lover to Tanveer Iqbal?
595
00:30:43,363 --> 00:30:45,243
And what lengths would Zatoon go to
596
00:30:45,323 --> 00:30:48,123
in order to avoid a conviction for murder?
597
00:30:48,203 --> 00:30:52,083
She was effectively feeding
her son the story
598
00:30:52,163 --> 00:30:55,883
that she wanted him to tell at trial.
599
00:30:55,963 --> 00:30:58,243
Zatoon Bibi continually
throughout the trial
600
00:30:58,323 --> 00:31:00,043
blamed everybody else and never took
601
00:31:00,123 --> 00:31:04,683
any personal responsibility
for any of the plans herself.
602
00:31:04,763 --> 00:31:07,803
I think she simply saw him
as a disposable henchman.
603
00:31:07,883 --> 00:31:10,123
He was a means to an end here.
604
00:31:10,203 --> 00:31:13,963
Was Gul Nawaz
about to be framed for murder?
605
00:31:18,843 --> 00:31:21,203
{\an8}There was plenty
of CCTV footage to back up
606
00:31:21,283 --> 00:31:24,403
{\an8}the investigators' theory
of what had happened to Tanveer.
607
00:31:24,483 --> 00:31:27,283
{\an8}He had been killed sometime
between Sunday afternoon
608
00:31:27,363 --> 00:31:30,963
and 7:30 pm on January 31st
609
00:31:31,043 --> 00:31:34,083
{\an8}and in the house owned by Zatoon Bibi.
610
00:31:34,163 --> 00:31:36,403
{\an8}Forensic evidence came next.
611
00:31:36,483 --> 00:31:39,403
{\an8}We were able to recover some DNA evidence
612
00:31:39,483 --> 00:31:43,883
{\an8}from within the box where Tanveer was
prepared and wrapped
613
00:31:43,963 --> 00:31:46,123
{\an8}after he'd been killed,
and we were able to show
614
00:31:46,203 --> 00:31:48,963
{\an8}and attribute that DNA back to Gul Nawaz.
615
00:31:49,043 --> 00:31:51,883
{\an8}The DNA on that tape showed that both Gul
616
00:31:51,963 --> 00:31:54,803
{\an8}and the teenage son had been involved.
617
00:31:54,883 --> 00:31:58,923
{\an8}This isn't a case of really
criminally sophisticated individuals.
618
00:31:59,003 --> 00:32:01,283
{\an8}This is a case of people
getting involved in something
619
00:32:01,363 --> 00:32:04,483
that they really do not know
how to cover up.
620
00:32:06,163 --> 00:32:08,803
Gul Nawaz, the very man whose life
621
00:32:08,883 --> 00:32:11,603
had been turned
upside down by his wife's affair,
622
00:32:11,683 --> 00:32:15,243
agreed to the plot to kill Tanveer.
623
00:32:15,323 --> 00:32:18,083
Tanveer's mobile phone history
was analyzed.
624
00:32:18,923 --> 00:32:20,323
You know, the last person that he called,
625
00:32:20,403 --> 00:32:22,323
the last contact he had,
the last time he used the internet,
626
00:32:22,403 --> 00:32:23,843
and all these kinds of stuff.
627
00:32:23,923 --> 00:32:25,723
{\an8}It's extremely painstaking
and long winded,
628
00:32:25,803 --> 00:32:27,923
{\an8}but it's very, very successful
in terms of yielding
629
00:32:28,003 --> 00:32:30,003
{\an8}that final product around being able
630
00:32:30,083 --> 00:32:31,243
{\an8}to trace somebody's steps.
631
00:32:31,323 --> 00:32:32,643
It paints quite a compelling picture
632
00:32:32,723 --> 00:32:34,203
of where somebody is at a certain time.
633
00:32:35,003 --> 00:32:38,043
Tanveer's phone placed
him at Zatoon's house.
634
00:32:38,123 --> 00:32:40,203
Meanwhile, the phones
of the other suspects
635
00:32:40,283 --> 00:32:41,963
gave away their movements.
636
00:32:42,563 --> 00:32:47,083
The mobile phone belonging
to her ex-husband Gul and her son,
637
00:32:47,163 --> 00:32:49,763
they happen to be in the same location.
638
00:32:50,523 --> 00:32:51,843
{\an8}On February 8th,
639
00:32:51,923 --> 00:32:54,403
{\an8}a week
after Tanveer Iqbal's body had been found
640
00:32:54,483 --> 00:32:56,403
{\an8}in the boot of his abandoned car,
641
00:32:56,483 --> 00:32:58,723
his lover, Zatoon Bibi, was arrested
642
00:32:58,803 --> 00:33:02,243
and taken to Smethwick police station
for questioning.
643
00:33:02,323 --> 00:33:04,683
She didn't really cooperate
very much with the officers
644
00:33:04,763 --> 00:33:06,203
and really failed and refused to answer
645
00:33:06,283 --> 00:33:07,923
any of the questions.
646
00:33:08,003 --> 00:33:10,643
Her husband, Gul Nawaz,
was also arrested,
647
00:33:10,723 --> 00:33:13,163
but he denied any involvement
in Tanveer's murder
648
00:33:13,243 --> 00:33:15,003
and was released the next day.
649
00:33:15,803 --> 00:33:18,963
More than two weeks later,
as the evidence mounted,
650
00:33:19,043 --> 00:33:22,683
Gul was arrested again,
along with his son Kashim.
651
00:33:22,763 --> 00:33:24,843
Under questioning,
all three had denied any knowledge
652
00:33:24,923 --> 00:33:26,723
of what had happened to Tanveer.
653
00:33:27,603 --> 00:33:28,963
It was clear to the police
654
00:33:29,043 --> 00:33:31,723
that somebody was lying
to them and probably everyone was.
655
00:33:32,723 --> 00:33:34,963
Later that day,
after questioning father and son,
656
00:33:35,043 --> 00:33:38,643
police charged them
and Zatoon Bibi with murder.
657
00:33:40,643 --> 00:33:43,203
She had enlisted
the support of her husband
658
00:33:43,283 --> 00:33:45,083
in order to commit these
horrible acts against Tanveer.
659
00:33:46,763 --> 00:33:48,523
The Crown Prosecution case was
660
00:33:48,603 --> 00:33:52,363
that Zatoon Bibi, a scorned lover,
had set the murder up.
661
00:33:53,123 --> 00:33:57,283
She was intent on getting rid of Tanveer.
662
00:33:58,083 --> 00:34:00,363
And there is no doubt
663
00:34:00,443 --> 00:34:03,963
{\an8}that she was the orchestrator
664
00:34:04,043 --> 00:34:09,603
{\an8}of the plan that was then hatched
to kill Tanveer.
665
00:34:09,682 --> 00:34:14,323
There is no way
that she could have killed him by herself.
666
00:34:14,403 --> 00:34:19,963
She's a woman, he's a strapping young man.
667
00:34:20,043 --> 00:34:22,682
She needed to recruit somebody.
668
00:34:22,762 --> 00:34:24,722
And the men she chose for the job,
669
00:34:24,803 --> 00:34:28,282
her school age son
and the husband she had left.
670
00:34:28,363 --> 00:34:31,202
She decided to persuade the very man
671
00:34:31,282 --> 00:34:33,963
whose life had been ruined
by her relationship with Tanveer
672
00:34:34,043 --> 00:34:35,923
to help her to get rid of him.
673
00:34:36,003 --> 00:34:40,083
{\an8}It was Gul
who had collected the murder kit.
674
00:34:40,163 --> 00:34:43,762
I think Zatoon was
very deliberate in sending him out
675
00:34:43,843 --> 00:34:47,923
{\an8}to pick up these things,
because it looks like he is the killer.
676
00:34:48,682 --> 00:34:50,923
Even behind bars,
Zatoon continued
677
00:34:51,003 --> 00:34:55,682
to attempt to manipulate
the situation for her own benefit.
678
00:34:55,762 --> 00:34:57,883
All three were
in different establishments,
679
00:34:57,963 --> 00:34:59,963
Zatoon obviously in a women's prison,
680
00:35:00,043 --> 00:35:03,043
her husband in a adult male prison,
681
00:35:03,123 --> 00:35:06,723
and the son in a teenage place
of incarceration.
682
00:35:06,803 --> 00:35:10,283
What then transpired
over the next few months was that
683
00:35:10,363 --> 00:35:14,563
Zatoon was phoning
her son on a regular basis.
684
00:35:15,283 --> 00:35:17,763
Jo Sidhu represented
Zatoon Bibi in court
685
00:35:17,843 --> 00:35:20,403
at her subsequent trial for murder.
686
00:35:20,483 --> 00:35:23,403
He had a special insight
into her state of mind.
687
00:35:23,483 --> 00:35:25,803
She was excitable and vociferous
688
00:35:25,883 --> 00:35:28,483
in every conversation that I had with her.
689
00:35:28,563 --> 00:35:30,083
It seemed on the face of it
that she was calling him
690
00:35:30,163 --> 00:35:33,403
just to give him
emotional motherly support,
691
00:35:33,483 --> 00:35:35,803
but in fact, those calls were recorded.
692
00:35:35,883 --> 00:35:37,803
At her trial
the transcripts of those calls
693
00:35:37,883 --> 00:35:41,483
were revealed to the jury,
and they told their own story.
694
00:35:41,563 --> 00:35:46,083
There was a huge amount
of telephone traffic
695
00:35:46,163 --> 00:35:50,203
passing between Zatoon and Kashim
696
00:35:50,283 --> 00:35:52,363
in which what she was doing
697
00:35:52,443 --> 00:35:56,003
was trying to persuade her son
698
00:35:56,083 --> 00:35:59,363
to blame his father.
699
00:35:59,443 --> 00:36:02,043
Zatoon's plan was
for her 15-year-old son, Kashim,
700
00:36:02,123 --> 00:36:03,483
to deny that the two of them
701
00:36:03,563 --> 00:36:06,843
had even been in the room
when Tanveer was murdered.
702
00:36:06,923 --> 00:36:08,643
Actually, what Zatoon was doing
703
00:36:08,723 --> 00:36:11,683
was prepping her son
to give a false story.
704
00:36:11,763 --> 00:36:15,003
That false story would make
her look innocent
705
00:36:15,083 --> 00:36:18,643
and the son too,
but would point the finger at Gul Nawaz.
706
00:36:21,723 --> 00:36:27,403
What you see there is
the manipulative Zatoon Bibi
707
00:36:28,403 --> 00:36:33,123
manipulating her son
to come up with a story
708
00:36:33,203 --> 00:36:35,963
in which all of the blame
for what happened
709
00:36:36,043 --> 00:36:39,483
is put on Kashim's father, her ex-husband.
710
00:36:39,563 --> 00:36:41,243
The teenager was
initially reluctant
711
00:36:41,323 --> 00:36:43,243
to go along with his mother's lies.
712
00:36:43,323 --> 00:36:45,803
What you see
in the recorded calls from the prison
713
00:36:45,883 --> 00:36:49,043
is Kashim saying "I'm not going to do it.
714
00:36:49,123 --> 00:36:53,883
I am not going to say
my father killed your lover."
715
00:36:53,963 --> 00:36:56,483
Slowly, mother bent Son to her will.
716
00:36:56,563 --> 00:37:01,323
He was slowly worn down
by his mother manipulating him,
717
00:37:01,403 --> 00:37:06,243
emotionally blackmailing him,
saying, "there is a way
718
00:37:06,323 --> 00:37:11,163
"for you and me to avoid
being convicted of murder.
719
00:37:11,243 --> 00:37:14,243
"Do you want to be convicted of murder?
720
00:37:14,323 --> 00:37:17,603
"If we stick together
and we tell this story,
721
00:37:17,683 --> 00:37:23,003
your father will go
to prison, but not you or me."
722
00:37:23,963 --> 00:37:25,603
The story that Zatoon presented
723
00:37:25,683 --> 00:37:28,283
to the outside world was
that Tanveer's death
724
00:37:28,363 --> 00:37:30,003
was nothing to do with her.
725
00:37:30,563 --> 00:37:33,083
In all my meetings with Zatoon Bibi,
726
00:37:33,163 --> 00:37:36,243
both before the trial and during it,
727
00:37:36,323 --> 00:37:38,243
she vehemently protested her innocence.
728
00:37:38,323 --> 00:37:40,083
She was affronted about the fact
729
00:37:40,163 --> 00:37:42,643
that she was even being accused
of having killed Tanveer.
730
00:37:42,723 --> 00:37:47,003
When this case goes to trial,
everybody is blaming everybody else,
731
00:37:47,083 --> 00:37:49,203
but I think Zatoon has never wanted
732
00:37:49,283 --> 00:37:50,763
to take responsibility for it.
733
00:37:50,843 --> 00:37:55,003
And even in the planning, the run-up
to the murder, that's very evident.
734
00:37:55,083 --> 00:37:57,003
Zatoon fought her corner.
735
00:37:57,083 --> 00:37:59,123
She claimed
that she was being stitched up.
736
00:37:59,203 --> 00:38:00,643
She said that she was an innocent victim
737
00:38:00,723 --> 00:38:01,763
of an abusive husband.
738
00:38:03,443 --> 00:38:06,083
With her son Kashim
backing up the story,
739
00:38:06,163 --> 00:38:08,363
was it possible that Zatoon could succeed
740
00:38:08,443 --> 00:38:11,763
in shifting all the blame
onto her husband Gul?
741
00:38:13,483 --> 00:38:17,243
I represented Gul Nawaz
in this murder trial
742
00:38:17,323 --> 00:38:21,643
that took place at Birmingham Crown Court.
743
00:38:21,723 --> 00:38:24,363
Very rarely did he let his guard down.
744
00:38:24,443 --> 00:38:26,683
It was obvious that there was something
745
00:38:26,763 --> 00:38:29,323
that he was keeping to himself.
746
00:38:29,403 --> 00:38:30,683
And I think that was probably
747
00:38:30,763 --> 00:38:34,123
{\an8}because he knew what had really happened.
748
00:38:34,203 --> 00:38:36,363
{\an8}
So what had really happened at the house
749
00:38:36,443 --> 00:38:39,523
{\an8}in Bartley Green
that night in January 2016?
750
00:38:39,603 --> 00:38:41,483
The prosecution's case was that this
751
00:38:41,563 --> 00:38:44,403
was entirely a set up,
that the three people,
752
00:38:44,483 --> 00:38:48,323
mother, father,
and teenage son had laid in wait.
753
00:38:48,403 --> 00:38:49,523
It was an ambush.
754
00:38:51,563 --> 00:38:54,043
{\an8}That when Tanveer came in, he was jumped.
755
00:38:56,323 --> 00:39:00,323
We do know that Tanveer was
a young, fit, strong young man.
756
00:39:00,403 --> 00:39:02,123
He wouldn't have easily been overpowered.
757
00:39:02,203 --> 00:39:04,683
He would have certainly fought
to defend himself.
758
00:39:04,763 --> 00:39:07,163
I strongly suspect that
as he walked into the address,
759
00:39:07,243 --> 00:39:09,643
he was probably ambushed
and he was probably strangled
760
00:39:09,723 --> 00:39:14,163
and quite quickly
by the husband and by the son.
761
00:39:14,243 --> 00:39:15,723
It wasn't just the prosecution
762
00:39:15,803 --> 00:39:19,123
that cast doubt
on Zatoon's version of events.
763
00:39:19,203 --> 00:39:23,203
When I cross examined her
on behalf of Gul Nawaz,
764
00:39:23,283 --> 00:39:25,923
it became clear that she was telling lies.
765
00:39:28,723 --> 00:39:31,403
{\an8}This murder trial was a classic cutthroat,
766
00:39:31,483 --> 00:39:35,283
but not just between two people,
but two people on one.
767
00:39:35,363 --> 00:39:37,283
Zatoon stood shoulder to shoulder
768
00:39:37,363 --> 00:39:40,723
with her 15-year-old son against the dad.
769
00:39:40,803 --> 00:39:43,083
They wanted to just blame each other.
770
00:39:44,643 --> 00:39:50,203
I felt sorry for Kashim
because he was this young man,
771
00:39:50,283 --> 00:39:54,283
a child who'd been
effectively recruited by his mother,
772
00:39:54,363 --> 00:39:56,603
and perhaps to a lesser extent
by his father,
773
00:39:56,683 --> 00:39:59,443
to get involved in this killing.
774
00:39:59,523 --> 00:40:01,563
Here he was torn between his parents,
775
00:40:01,643 --> 00:40:03,323
having got himself into a situation
776
00:40:03,403 --> 00:40:05,603
because his mother recruited him.
777
00:40:05,683 --> 00:40:09,163
He'd been manipulated
and told all sorts of lies
778
00:40:09,243 --> 00:40:11,043
in order to get him on board
779
00:40:11,123 --> 00:40:13,683
And there in court he found himself mute,
780
00:40:13,763 --> 00:40:16,203
he couldn't speak. What could he say?
781
00:40:16,283 --> 00:40:17,603
If he went into the witness box,
782
00:40:17,683 --> 00:40:19,483
he'd have to point
the finger at his father,
783
00:40:19,563 --> 00:40:21,323
and he knew that wasn't true.
784
00:40:21,403 --> 00:40:23,403
So, he stayed where he sat in the dock
785
00:40:23,483 --> 00:40:27,043
and listened to his two parents
tearing each other apart.
786
00:40:28,043 --> 00:40:29,763
On September 20th, 2016,
787
00:40:29,843 --> 00:40:33,003
twelve jurors at Birmingham Crown Court
reached their verdict.
788
00:40:36,483 --> 00:40:38,963
Not surprisingly,
789
00:40:39,043 --> 00:40:43,323
the jury did not believe
790
00:40:43,403 --> 00:40:46,643
Zatoon Bibi's account
of what had actually happened.
791
00:40:46,723 --> 00:40:51,883
She demonstrated herself
to be an inveterate liar.
792
00:40:51,963 --> 00:40:53,683
Spurned mistress Zatoon Bibi,
793
00:40:53,763 --> 00:40:56,443
her husband Gul Nawaz,
and their son Kashim
794
00:40:56,523 --> 00:40:59,563
were found guilty
of murdering Tanveer Iqbal.
795
00:41:01,363 --> 00:41:03,443
It's certainly my view
that she was the organizer.
796
00:41:03,523 --> 00:41:06,643
She was able to enlist
the support of her family,
797
00:41:06,723 --> 00:41:10,363
{\an8}of her husband, her son, in order to lure
798
00:41:10,443 --> 00:41:15,283
{\an8}Tanveer to his death, then kill him
in a coldblooded fashion.
799
00:41:15,363 --> 00:41:21,003
In a case like this
where the murder was clearly planned,
800
00:41:21,083 --> 00:41:24,243
somebody was lured to their death,
801
00:41:24,323 --> 00:41:28,243
this was always going to be a sentence
802
00:41:28,323 --> 00:41:30,963
that was a very long sentence.
803
00:41:32,483 --> 00:41:34,723
Zatoon and Gul were jailed for life.
804
00:41:34,803 --> 00:41:38,963
Their son was told he would serve
a minimum of just six years.
805
00:41:39,043 --> 00:41:41,203
There was a definite hierarchy
within this group,
806
00:41:41,283 --> 00:41:43,563
and Zatoon Bibi was at the top of it.
807
00:41:43,643 --> 00:41:46,043
The sentence was determined
by law for murder,
808
00:41:46,123 --> 00:41:48,683
it's life imprisonment
with a minimum term.
809
00:41:48,763 --> 00:41:51,123
The judge decided that in Zatoon's case,
810
00:41:51,203 --> 00:41:54,243
he would give her a minimum of 27 years.
811
00:41:56,283 --> 00:41:59,123
What we had here
with Zatoon Bibi was
812
00:41:59,203 --> 00:42:02,083
an individual that was
extremely calculated.
813
00:42:02,163 --> 00:42:04,923
She was extremely manipulative
in her approach
814
00:42:05,003 --> 00:42:07,843
to the planning
and preparation of this murder.
815
00:42:08,603 --> 00:42:11,843
{\an8}She was certainly behind luring Tanveer
816
00:42:11,923 --> 00:42:15,163
{\an8}to his death on the Sunday night.
817
00:42:15,243 --> 00:42:17,163
During sentencing,
the judge singled out
818
00:42:17,243 --> 00:42:20,203
Zatoon's callousness for special mention.
819
00:42:20,763 --> 00:42:24,163
His observation as a judge was
that her selfishness
820
00:42:24,243 --> 00:42:27,923
and manipulative nature
were truly breathtaking.
821
00:42:28,003 --> 00:42:31,083
{\an8}He said that one
of the most appalling features of the case
822
00:42:31,163 --> 00:42:34,523
{\an8}was the fact that she had
recruited her 15-year-old son.
823
00:42:34,603 --> 00:42:37,123
He said that was particularly awful.
824
00:42:37,203 --> 00:42:40,403
He was effectively taken in by his parents
825
00:42:40,483 --> 00:42:45,243
and influenced by them--
perhaps had no choice
826
00:42:45,323 --> 00:42:48,323
{\an8}but to go along with it.
827
00:42:48,403 --> 00:42:51,803
{\an8}
Manipulative, vengeful, and murderous,
828
00:42:51,883 --> 00:42:54,923
Zatoon Bibi made her married lover
pay the ultimate price
829
00:42:55,003 --> 00:42:56,683
for trying to dump her.
830
00:42:56,763 --> 00:42:59,043
It was always clear that
Tanveer wouldn't leave his wife
831
00:42:59,123 --> 00:43:01,843
and his family set-up for Zatoon Bibi,
832
00:43:01,923 --> 00:43:05,883
so my view is that this was
a crime based on her jealousy.
833
00:43:05,963 --> 00:43:09,123
If I can't have him,
nobody's going to have him.
834
00:43:09,203 --> 00:43:12,203
That I think was ultimately the reason
835
00:43:12,283 --> 00:43:18,283
why she took that extreme
step of having him killed.
836
00:43:20,643 --> 00:43:23,443
That was why she planned
and executed this murder.
837
00:43:25,123 --> 00:43:27,443
She claimed that in fact
she was the victim
838
00:43:27,523 --> 00:43:29,803
of a miscarriage of justice.
839
00:43:29,883 --> 00:43:31,763
She's never accepted that she was guilty.
840
00:43:32,483 --> 00:43:34,123
She doesn't feel remorse.
841
00:43:34,203 --> 00:43:36,883
She doesn't feel empathy for other people.
842
00:43:36,963 --> 00:43:39,443
The fact that she's got
her family involved in this
843
00:43:39,523 --> 00:43:42,643
is incredibly telling
about this individual.
844
00:43:43,603 --> 00:43:45,403
Tanveer Iqbal wasn't the only victim
845
00:43:45,483 --> 00:43:47,723
of Zatoon Bibi's crime.
846
00:43:47,803 --> 00:43:50,003
Not only has she murdered her lover,
847
00:43:50,083 --> 00:43:52,803
the person she's been having
a relationship with for years,
848
00:43:52,883 --> 00:43:56,043
but this man is the father
of some of her children.
849
00:43:56,123 --> 00:44:00,203
So, she has deprived
some of her children of their father.
850
00:44:00,283 --> 00:44:03,283
And the very act
of doing that, in itself, is
851
00:44:03,363 --> 00:44:05,523
such a huge, significant thing.
852
00:44:07,443 --> 00:44:09,283
She was able to mobilize
her family members
853
00:44:09,363 --> 00:44:11,723
{\an8}in order to make it happen
854
00:44:11,803 --> 00:44:14,963
{\an8}and to try and bring everybody together
to commit the gruesome act
855
00:44:15,043 --> 00:44:16,683
{\an8}of luring somebody to their death,
856
00:44:16,763 --> 00:44:19,243
killing them in cold blood,
and then disposing of their body.