1 00:00:12,137 --> 00:00:14,515 [phone ringing] 2 00:00:19,228 --> 00:00:20,395 You gonna get that? 3 00:00:22,439 --> 00:00:25,776 They're selling magazines. Whole block's getting calls. 4 00:00:25,776 --> 00:00:27,694 - [slams phone, ringing stops] - [Marlin clears throat] 5 00:00:31,198 --> 00:00:32,866 Did you get my suit? 6 00:00:32,866 --> 00:00:35,244 They said it's ready. I'll pick it up on the way home. 7 00:00:35,244 --> 00:00:36,328 Thanks. 8 00:00:40,707 --> 00:00:41,708 [door closes] 9 00:00:43,794 --> 00:00:45,337 [sighs] 10 00:00:45,337 --> 00:00:47,756 [heart monitor beeps] 11 00:00:48,674 --> 00:00:50,175 [blood pressure cuff deflates] 12 00:00:53,262 --> 00:00:54,096 [Velcro rips] 13 00:00:54,096 --> 00:00:56,849 [staff member speaking indistinctly on PA] 14 00:00:59,768 --> 00:01:03,438 That guy, Stan, called again. I told him you were with a patient. 15 00:01:03,438 --> 00:01:04,982 [phone ringing] 16 00:01:06,441 --> 00:01:09,236 [scoffs] You got to admire his persistence. 17 00:01:15,617 --> 00:01:19,079 Yeah, I don't know, hon. It's-- It's tight. 18 00:01:19,663 --> 00:01:22,207 - Does it look tight to you? - Mmm. 19 00:01:22,708 --> 00:01:23,709 You're not looking. 20 00:01:23,709 --> 00:01:25,961 They said they let it out as much as they could. 21 00:01:25,961 --> 00:01:27,337 [phone ringing] 22 00:01:28,213 --> 00:01:29,715 Ugh. 23 00:01:29,715 --> 00:01:30,799 [scoffs] 24 00:01:30,799 --> 00:01:32,509 Those fucking magazines. 25 00:01:32,509 --> 00:01:33,594 [sniffs] 26 00:01:35,512 --> 00:01:38,098 You screwing someone behind my back, Candy? 27 00:01:40,517 --> 00:01:41,518 [scoffs] 28 00:01:42,853 --> 00:01:44,938 Hello? [inhales sharply] 29 00:01:46,440 --> 00:01:47,441 Hello? 30 00:01:53,864 --> 00:01:55,699 [clears throat] Listen, 31 00:01:55,699 --> 00:01:58,952 I don't want you answering this phone until after the trial is over. 32 00:02:00,037 --> 00:02:01,246 You got me? 33 00:02:06,210 --> 00:02:07,211 Okay. 34 00:02:11,131 --> 00:02:12,132 [sniffs] 35 00:02:16,762 --> 00:02:18,138 [door closes] 36 00:02:52,589 --> 00:02:55,342 [sobbing] 37 00:05:02,803 --> 00:05:05,305 ["Thank You for Sending Me an Angel" playing] 38 00:05:28,453 --> 00:05:30,539 [officer 1] Sullivan, let's go. I don't have all day. 39 00:06:01,695 --> 00:06:04,364 [reporters shouting indistinctly] 40 00:06:23,217 --> 00:06:24,968 [people chattering] 41 00:06:33,727 --> 00:06:36,355 I told her to get you a clip-on. You wanna get those first? 42 00:06:37,272 --> 00:06:39,274 Your Honor, can I just have a moment with my client? 43 00:06:40,859 --> 00:06:41,902 Come here. 44 00:06:41,902 --> 00:06:43,153 It's fine. 45 00:06:43,153 --> 00:06:44,238 It's not. 46 00:06:48,992 --> 00:06:51,203 Okay. Look. 47 00:06:51,954 --> 00:06:57,376 Relax, because there's not a person in this courtroom whose opinion counts. 48 00:06:59,419 --> 00:07:00,838 Not yet, anyway. 49 00:07:02,589 --> 00:07:04,716 Let's flip it. Easier in the mirror. 50 00:07:06,593 --> 00:07:07,594 There. 51 00:07:07,594 --> 00:07:10,347 [inhales sharply] Now you look like an upstanding citizen. 52 00:07:16,562 --> 00:07:18,605 - We're all set, Your Honor. - Bring in the jury. 53 00:07:18,605 --> 00:07:19,690 [bailiff] All rise. 54 00:07:29,950 --> 00:07:32,578 Good morning. My name is Patricia Richards. 55 00:07:33,287 --> 00:07:35,289 I'm a Manhattan assistant district attorney 56 00:07:35,289 --> 00:07:36,915 representing the State of New York. 57 00:07:36,915 --> 00:07:39,084 And as Judge Posner already told you, 58 00:07:39,918 --> 00:07:43,338 the burden of proof in this courtroom is on me. 59 00:07:44,715 --> 00:07:45,757 I welcome it. 60 00:07:46,967 --> 00:07:53,182 I welcome it because the proof in this case is indisputable. 61 00:07:54,224 --> 00:07:55,350 Undeniable. 62 00:07:57,895 --> 00:08:00,647 There is video. There are witnesses. 63 00:08:01,148 --> 00:08:03,775 The only thing there isn't, is doubt. 64 00:08:06,778 --> 00:08:11,241 On May 18th of this year, the defendant, Daniel Sullivan, 65 00:08:11,241 --> 00:08:16,872 aimed a .38-caliber pistol into a crowd and fired six times. 66 00:08:16,872 --> 00:08:19,791 Three people were wounded. The rest were lucky. 67 00:08:20,667 --> 00:08:24,004 Make no mistake, the only reason this isn't a murder trial 68 00:08:24,671 --> 00:08:27,466 is because Daniel Sullivan is a lousy shot. 69 00:08:28,133 --> 00:08:30,344 He belongs behind bars. 70 00:08:31,887 --> 00:08:35,474 But with evidence so provable, so irrefutable, 71 00:08:35,474 --> 00:08:37,308 one wonders, what will the defense do? 72 00:08:38,018 --> 00:08:39,937 They cannot deny the facts, 73 00:08:39,937 --> 00:08:44,650 so they will divert you from them by making unfounded and unproven claims 74 00:08:44,650 --> 00:08:50,614 about a condition they call multiple personality disorder. 75 00:08:52,449 --> 00:08:54,201 Let me be clear, 76 00:08:54,201 --> 00:08:58,330 there is no such thing as multiple personality disorder. 77 00:08:58,330 --> 00:09:02,584 It is a made-up condition from a Sally Field movie, no less. 78 00:09:03,252 --> 00:09:05,587 They might as well claim the defendant is a flying nun. 79 00:09:05,587 --> 00:09:07,381 [people chuckling] 80 00:09:07,381 --> 00:09:12,719 The defense blames Mr. Sullivan's actions on what they call an alter. 81 00:09:14,972 --> 00:09:16,723 Now, I can admit, I get the appeal. 82 00:09:17,432 --> 00:09:20,477 Don't we all wish we could blame our mistakes on someone else? 83 00:09:20,477 --> 00:09:24,189 Run a red light? Blame an alter. Bounce a check? Blame an alter. 84 00:09:25,107 --> 00:09:26,316 Cheat on a spouse? 85 00:09:27,150 --> 00:09:29,278 - Well, let's see how that one flies. - [people chuckling] 86 00:09:29,278 --> 00:09:31,446 [Patricia] But can you imagine our judicial system 87 00:09:31,446 --> 00:09:35,117 if every time someone committed a crime, 88 00:09:36,535 --> 00:09:39,371 they could simply say, "It wasn't me." 89 00:09:42,624 --> 00:09:44,001 That's what's at stake here. 90 00:09:44,585 --> 00:09:48,714 These arguments from the defense, they're more than desperate. 91 00:09:48,714 --> 00:09:50,174 They're dangerous. 92 00:09:51,675 --> 00:09:56,680 Because they undermine a bedrock principle of both our legal system and our society: 93 00:09:58,140 --> 00:10:00,475 personal responsibility. 94 00:10:00,475 --> 00:10:04,980 We are responsible for our actions. 95 00:10:04,980 --> 00:10:10,235 The defendant is guilty, and that guilt demands punishment. 96 00:10:10,235 --> 00:10:14,364 Otherwise, there can be no justice. 97 00:10:15,616 --> 00:10:16,450 [sighs] 98 00:10:16,450 --> 00:10:17,659 [Patricia] Thank you. 99 00:10:21,747 --> 00:10:23,999 Mr. Camisa, for the defense. 100 00:10:31,507 --> 00:10:32,508 [smacks lips] 101 00:10:34,176 --> 00:10:35,677 [sighs] 102 00:10:45,020 --> 00:10:46,021 [inhales sharply] 103 00:10:48,190 --> 00:10:52,069 Indisputable. Undeniable. Irrefutable. 104 00:10:56,198 --> 00:10:58,325 You know, makes a guy wonder, "Why am I even here?" 105 00:10:58,325 --> 00:11:00,077 [people chuckling] 106 00:11:00,077 --> 00:11:02,329 [Stan] That was some opening from the prosecution. 107 00:11:03,747 --> 00:11:05,457 Bedrock principles. 108 00:11:07,918 --> 00:11:10,003 Well, here's a bedrock principle for you. 109 00:11:12,005 --> 00:11:13,006 He's innocent. 110 00:11:13,590 --> 00:11:16,677 He has the presumption of innocence. It is his right. 111 00:11:17,386 --> 00:11:20,681 Now, this bears repeating because of everything that you just heard. 112 00:11:20,681 --> 00:11:26,353 So, let me begin by saying it clearly and as a simple statement of fact. 113 00:11:28,313 --> 00:11:31,775 Danny Sullivan didn't shoot anyone. 114 00:11:32,609 --> 00:11:36,154 He was there. He admits as much. 115 00:11:38,323 --> 00:11:40,033 But he didn't pull the trigger. 116 00:11:40,033 --> 00:11:43,662 Danny's a good kid, but he's a sick kid. 117 00:11:43,662 --> 00:11:49,126 Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, no one is making up a condition. 118 00:11:49,126 --> 00:11:51,545 Now, I g-- [chuckles] I get how it sounds. 119 00:11:53,547 --> 00:11:55,257 Multiple personality disorder. 120 00:11:57,384 --> 00:12:01,722 You know, at first, I had a hard time wrapping my head around it myself. 121 00:12:02,598 --> 00:12:05,934 But instead of making flying nun jokes, which is easy, 122 00:12:07,186 --> 00:12:11,481 I kept an open mind, which is hard. 123 00:12:12,774 --> 00:12:14,401 And that's what I'm asking of you. 124 00:12:16,445 --> 00:12:19,489 To keep an open mind. 125 00:12:19,489 --> 00:12:21,408 Listen to the experts. 126 00:12:21,408 --> 00:12:25,204 Listen to the witnesses, because if you do, 127 00:12:25,204 --> 00:12:27,831 you'll arrive at the same indisputable, 128 00:12:27,831 --> 00:12:30,959 undeniable, irrefutable conclusion that I did, 129 00:12:30,959 --> 00:12:36,381 which is that Danny had no control over his illness or his alters. 130 00:12:36,924 --> 00:12:38,634 Yeah, he's got alters. 131 00:12:38,634 --> 00:12:43,430 He's got alters because he was hurt in unimaginable ways that broke him. 132 00:12:44,139 --> 00:12:45,807 It broke his mind into pieces. 133 00:12:48,852 --> 00:12:51,939 And no, they are not some get-out-of-jail-free card. 134 00:12:51,939 --> 00:12:57,027 They are real, and they are not Danny. 135 00:12:57,778 --> 00:13:01,448 To send Danny to prison for a crime that one of his alters committed 136 00:13:01,448 --> 00:13:05,327 would be the same as you going to jail for a crime that I committed. 137 00:13:07,829 --> 00:13:09,498 Now, Danny's illness is rare, 138 00:13:09,498 --> 00:13:13,043 and it is the result of being exposed to sexual abuse as a child. 139 00:13:13,669 --> 00:13:17,548 Frankly, he's lucky to have survived. This illness is how he survived. 140 00:13:18,298 --> 00:13:22,553 I get it. It's weird. It's hard. 141 00:13:25,055 --> 00:13:28,100 But please, keep an open mind. 142 00:13:28,767 --> 00:13:31,228 Now, the prosecution was right about one thing. 143 00:13:31,937 --> 00:13:38,151 This trial is about responsibility, but it's not personal responsibility, 144 00:13:40,070 --> 00:13:42,072 it's societal responsibility. 145 00:13:42,072 --> 00:13:44,408 I mean, you wanna talk about bedrock principles? 146 00:13:44,408 --> 00:13:47,035 How about how we just take care of each other? 147 00:13:47,035 --> 00:13:49,454 How about how we take care of the most hurt 148 00:13:49,454 --> 00:13:51,915 and the most vulnerable among us? 149 00:13:51,915 --> 00:13:54,084 Everybody has failed this kid. 150 00:13:54,084 --> 00:13:59,131 His parents, his teachers, his neighbors, his friends, his community. 151 00:13:59,131 --> 00:14:01,341 All of us have failed him. 152 00:14:01,842 --> 00:14:05,012 So now it is on us to make it right. 153 00:14:05,637 --> 00:14:10,058 Now, I'm not asking you to set Danny free. 154 00:14:11,810 --> 00:14:14,855 I am only asking that you spare him prison 155 00:14:15,814 --> 00:14:19,151 and instead send him to a hospital to get help. 156 00:14:19,151 --> 00:14:23,447 The help that he needs. That is our responsibility. 157 00:14:28,118 --> 00:14:29,119 Thank you. 158 00:14:30,204 --> 00:14:33,999 [Posner] We'll take a 15-minute recess and then proceed to the State's witnesses. 159 00:14:33,999 --> 00:14:36,043 Officer, escort the jury out please. 160 00:14:36,710 --> 00:14:37,711 [gavel bangs] 161 00:14:42,549 --> 00:14:44,176 [Rya] You were actually pretty good in there. 162 00:14:44,176 --> 00:14:46,011 [Stan] Yeah? Pretty good doesn't matter. 163 00:14:46,678 --> 00:14:49,848 Goddamn it! You know, Candy's not returning my calls, 164 00:14:49,848 --> 00:14:52,351 and she ignored her subpoena, by the way, which is a crime. 165 00:14:52,351 --> 00:14:53,852 She's scared. She's guilty. 166 00:14:53,852 --> 00:14:56,605 There's so much shame, she might not even admit it to herself. 167 00:14:56,605 --> 00:14:59,399 In all fairness, do you think I give a shit how she feels? 168 00:15:00,067 --> 00:15:02,027 This case turns on the diagnosis, 169 00:15:02,027 --> 00:15:05,822 and the diagnosis depends on showing the jury that Danny was abused. 170 00:15:05,822 --> 00:15:07,199 [sighs] 171 00:15:08,075 --> 00:15:09,535 I just said it in there. 172 00:15:09,535 --> 00:15:13,038 If we don't get someone to testify to this in open court, we are done. 173 00:15:13,539 --> 00:15:15,666 And I'm handcuffed, 'cause I can't put my client on the stand 174 00:15:15,666 --> 00:15:17,084 'cause of that bullshit he pulled in the hearing. 175 00:15:17,084 --> 00:15:19,336 - That was Jack. That wasn't Danny. - Whoever it was, 176 00:15:19,336 --> 00:15:21,797 he's going to deny the abuse and admit to the crime... 177 00:15:21,797 --> 00:15:24,091 - [sighs] - ...which would be bad. 178 00:15:24,091 --> 00:15:25,384 I am well aware. 179 00:15:28,637 --> 00:15:30,097 [sighs] You? 180 00:15:30,097 --> 00:15:32,432 You know I can't testify to his abuse. 181 00:15:32,432 --> 00:15:36,895 Technically, Danny never said that he was abused. He never told me that. 182 00:15:36,895 --> 00:15:39,106 - Only Adam? - Only Adam. 183 00:15:41,859 --> 00:15:44,778 I-- [sighs] It's fucking useless. 184 00:15:47,489 --> 00:15:48,657 What are we gonna do? 185 00:15:49,992 --> 00:15:51,159 You gotta convince her. 186 00:15:51,994 --> 00:15:54,162 But that's not up to me, Stan. 187 00:15:55,163 --> 00:15:57,416 Doesn't a mother have to love her kid, for Christ's sake? 188 00:15:57,416 --> 00:15:58,500 No. 189 00:16:00,043 --> 00:16:01,879 But in this case, that's what we have going for us. 190 00:16:02,546 --> 00:16:03,380 What? 191 00:16:03,380 --> 00:16:04,631 That she does love him. 192 00:16:08,802 --> 00:16:10,596 [Patricia] The State calls Marlin Reid. 193 00:16:18,854 --> 00:16:20,272 [Marlin sniffs, clears throat] 194 00:16:29,698 --> 00:16:32,743 [Patricia] How would you describe your relationship with your stepson? 195 00:16:32,743 --> 00:16:37,456 [Marlin] Um, strained, it pains me to admit. 196 00:16:37,456 --> 00:16:39,082 L-Look, I'm not perfect. 197 00:16:39,708 --> 00:16:43,420 And, uh, maybe sometimes I've been too hard on him. 198 00:16:43,420 --> 00:16:45,923 Maybe other times, not hard enough. 199 00:16:45,923 --> 00:16:50,177 Uh, the kids I see up at Osterville, most never had a father, not a real one. 200 00:16:50,177 --> 00:16:54,431 And, um, I wanted to be that for Danny. 201 00:16:55,516 --> 00:16:58,393 [clicks tongue] Tell me about Osterville. Tough job? 202 00:16:58,393 --> 00:17:02,439 Rewarding job. [chuckles] These kids have had every disadvantage. 203 00:17:02,439 --> 00:17:05,983 You wouldn't believe, uh, what they've survived in their homes, on the streets. 204 00:17:05,983 --> 00:17:07,319 Sure, they've made mistakes. 205 00:17:07,319 --> 00:17:12,199 Uh, but the thing I love about my job is they're still kids, 206 00:17:12,866 --> 00:17:15,702 and it's not too late for them to find their way back. 207 00:17:17,079 --> 00:17:19,373 [smacks lips] You feel that way about Danny? 208 00:17:19,373 --> 00:17:22,792 Oh, I'll never give up on Danny, but he's not a kid anymore. 209 00:17:23,335 --> 00:17:27,548 Given your relationship with him, you have any idea why he did what he did? 210 00:17:34,888 --> 00:17:35,889 [sighs] 211 00:17:36,640 --> 00:17:37,724 I honestly don't. 212 00:17:38,559 --> 00:17:41,562 Truth is, with Danny, there is no "why." 213 00:17:41,562 --> 00:17:45,232 When he was picking fights at school, or stealing from me, 214 00:17:45,232 --> 00:17:47,985 or dealing drugs or using, the-the "why"-- 215 00:17:49,069 --> 00:17:51,572 [sighs] Why is just Danny. 216 00:17:53,782 --> 00:17:55,951 [Patricia] Just one more question, Mr. Reid. 217 00:17:55,951 --> 00:17:58,287 At any point after you were shot, 218 00:17:59,413 --> 00:18:01,874 did you report your stepson to the authorities? 219 00:18:03,417 --> 00:18:05,335 - No. - [Patricia] Why not? 220 00:18:06,086 --> 00:18:08,255 Because I wanted to protect him. 221 00:18:08,255 --> 00:18:12,009 Um, because in spite of everything... 222 00:18:14,636 --> 00:18:17,055 I love him like my own son. 223 00:18:22,895 --> 00:18:24,271 No further questions. 224 00:18:25,939 --> 00:18:28,984 [newscaster] A dramatic first day in court as nine different witnesses 225 00:18:28,984 --> 00:18:31,486 identified Sullivan as the Rockefeller Center shooter, 226 00:18:31,486 --> 00:18:33,155 including his own stepfather, 227 00:18:33,155 --> 00:18:35,657 Juvenile Correctional Counselor Marlin Reid. 228 00:18:35,657 --> 00:18:36,867 Were you the intended target? 229 00:18:36,867 --> 00:18:39,661 [Marlin] I don't know. But the toughest thing you learn in-- 230 00:18:39,661 --> 00:18:41,955 [door opens, closes] 231 00:18:45,209 --> 00:18:48,295 [sighs, clicks tongue] Smells good. 232 00:18:48,962 --> 00:18:50,923 [inhales deeply] Needs another 20 minutes. 233 00:18:50,923 --> 00:18:52,007 Ah. 234 00:18:53,967 --> 00:18:55,177 H-How did he seem? 235 00:18:57,429 --> 00:19:00,015 Uh. [stammers] Thin. 236 00:19:00,015 --> 00:19:02,351 I don't know. It's not like we talked or anything. 237 00:19:05,395 --> 00:19:08,899 Um, how'd I look? 238 00:19:10,442 --> 00:19:11,693 [Marlin clears throat] 239 00:19:16,615 --> 00:19:17,824 - You're kidding, right? - What? 240 00:19:17,824 --> 00:19:20,953 [sighs] I'm just trying to do the right thing. 241 00:19:20,953 --> 00:19:22,621 The kid shot at me, Candy. 242 00:19:22,621 --> 00:19:24,206 [scoffs] Jesus. 243 00:19:29,086 --> 00:19:31,505 [inhales deeply] Taking a shower. 244 00:19:35,551 --> 00:19:38,262 [salesperson chattering on TV] 245 00:19:39,388 --> 00:19:40,764 [phone ringing] 246 00:19:41,807 --> 00:19:43,725 [salesperson continues indistinctly] 247 00:19:47,312 --> 00:19:49,356 Stop calling here. I'm not testifying. 248 00:19:49,356 --> 00:19:50,440 [Danny] Mom? 249 00:19:51,400 --> 00:19:52,401 [softly] Danny. 250 00:19:56,697 --> 00:19:58,323 [Marlin snoring] 251 00:20:02,452 --> 00:20:03,996 I-I meant to come see you. 252 00:20:05,455 --> 00:20:06,456 It's okay. 253 00:20:11,587 --> 00:20:12,713 I'm sorry. [sniffles] 254 00:20:12,713 --> 00:20:14,214 Baby, this is not your fault. 255 00:20:19,469 --> 00:20:20,470 I'm sorry. [sniffs] 256 00:20:21,513 --> 00:20:22,973 [dial tone] 257 00:20:45,704 --> 00:20:47,789 [witness 1] It isn't even a real diagnosis. 258 00:20:47,789 --> 00:20:51,376 It's just a fringe theory amplified by a TV movie. 259 00:20:51,376 --> 00:20:53,045 Then what do you make of Danny? 260 00:20:53,045 --> 00:20:55,714 Uh, well, I'll tell you the same thing that I told the jury. 261 00:20:55,714 --> 00:20:58,550 That I believe that, uh, Mr. Sullivan is a malingerer. 262 00:20:58,550 --> 00:21:01,303 Acting in bad faith to avoid criminal consequences. 263 00:21:01,303 --> 00:21:04,097 [reporter 1] In layman's terms? For the folks at home. 264 00:21:04,097 --> 00:21:06,975 [witness 1] He's faking it to keep himself out of jail. 265 00:21:09,478 --> 00:21:11,230 [Angelo] I tried to get him to be reasonable. 266 00:21:11,230 --> 00:21:12,648 [Patricia] How'd that go? 267 00:21:12,648 --> 00:21:14,274 [Angelo] Not what you would call ideal. 268 00:21:14,274 --> 00:21:17,903 He blindsided me, broke my nose and stole it anyway. 269 00:21:17,903 --> 00:21:20,030 [Patricia] Did you attempt to retrieve your gun? 270 00:21:20,030 --> 00:21:23,158 [Angelo] Yeah, I did. I went to his house. I was pissed. 271 00:21:23,659 --> 00:21:26,745 But we had history. I figured we could work something out. 272 00:21:28,539 --> 00:21:32,084 Got as far as a hello though before he attacked me with a baseball bat. 273 00:21:32,084 --> 00:21:33,627 Then he shot at me. 274 00:21:33,627 --> 00:21:35,712 [sighs, smacks lips] 275 00:21:36,588 --> 00:21:39,508 - No further questions, Your Honor. - Mr. Camisa. 276 00:21:39,508 --> 00:21:45,180 Yeah, just one question. Mr. Ruiz, you've known Danny for years. 277 00:21:46,682 --> 00:21:48,934 In all that time, has he ever seemed normal? 278 00:21:48,934 --> 00:21:51,478 Normal? [chuckling] 279 00:21:51,478 --> 00:21:54,523 That boy's nuts. Craziest son of a bitch I know. 280 00:21:54,523 --> 00:21:57,609 - [people chuckling, chattering] - [Stan] No further questions. 281 00:22:00,571 --> 00:22:01,738 [Annabelle] I was scared. 282 00:22:02,948 --> 00:22:04,783 I'd never seen Danny like that before. 283 00:22:07,244 --> 00:22:08,453 Then I heard the shot. 284 00:22:08,453 --> 00:22:10,706 What did you think when you heard that gunshot? 285 00:22:11,456 --> 00:22:12,916 I thought that he killed him. 286 00:22:13,625 --> 00:22:18,255 [Patricia] You believed Danny Sullivan to be capable of murder? 287 00:22:19,214 --> 00:22:20,424 In that moment, yes. 288 00:22:22,092 --> 00:22:23,760 [Patricia] No further questions, Your Honor. 289 00:22:33,395 --> 00:22:34,396 Hi, Annabelle. 290 00:22:35,272 --> 00:22:38,650 Um, was Danny ever violent with you? 291 00:22:39,151 --> 00:22:40,152 No. 292 00:22:40,152 --> 00:22:42,946 - [Stan] He ever make you feel unsafe? - No. 293 00:22:42,946 --> 00:22:44,448 [Stan] Was he mean? Abusive? 294 00:22:44,448 --> 00:22:46,116 No. Never. 295 00:22:46,658 --> 00:22:49,995 Then what was he like, the Danny you knew? Your friend. 296 00:22:50,746 --> 00:22:51,788 He was sweet. 297 00:22:53,207 --> 00:22:55,626 He was quiet. [stammers] Shy. 298 00:22:56,585 --> 00:22:57,586 Mostly. 299 00:22:58,212 --> 00:23:01,673 - [Stan] Mostly? - He was, yeah, sometimes not so shy. 300 00:23:04,009 --> 00:23:05,552 He was a little all over the place. 301 00:23:05,552 --> 00:23:08,222 I'd like to refer the witness to defense exhibit four. 302 00:23:08,222 --> 00:23:09,306 [Posner] Go ahead. 303 00:23:16,438 --> 00:23:17,606 You recognize this drawing? 304 00:23:19,191 --> 00:23:20,317 Yeah, Danny drew it. 305 00:23:21,235 --> 00:23:22,236 [Stan] It's you? 306 00:23:22,945 --> 00:23:24,029 Yep. 307 00:23:24,029 --> 00:23:25,113 It's good. 308 00:23:25,739 --> 00:23:27,741 Yeah, it's good. 309 00:23:27,741 --> 00:23:29,743 Danny really cared about you, didn't he? 310 00:23:33,622 --> 00:23:34,748 I cared about him too. 311 00:23:35,415 --> 00:23:37,084 [Stan] Earlier in your testimony-- 312 00:23:37,793 --> 00:23:40,087 now I'm referring to the night with Mr. Ruiz-- 313 00:23:40,087 --> 00:23:43,924 you said, "I'd never seen Danny like that." 314 00:23:43,924 --> 00:23:48,846 How do you reconcile that night, that Danny, with the boy that you knew? 315 00:23:48,846 --> 00:23:53,642 The sweet and quiet, never violent, shy but sometimes not. 316 00:23:53,642 --> 00:23:55,227 The boy who drew this picture. 317 00:24:01,233 --> 00:24:03,360 Doesn't seem like the same person, does it? 318 00:24:05,070 --> 00:24:06,071 No. 319 00:24:09,032 --> 00:24:10,492 No further questions, Your Honor. 320 00:24:11,702 --> 00:24:14,621 - [Patricia] State requests a redirect. - [Posner] Proceed. 321 00:24:16,498 --> 00:24:19,042 To the best of your knowledge, in the time you knew him, 322 00:24:19,042 --> 00:24:21,336 was the encounter with Mr. Ruiz 323 00:24:21,336 --> 00:24:24,715 the only occasion that Danny Sullivan was ever violent? 324 00:24:24,715 --> 00:24:26,383 Objection, irrelevant. 325 00:24:26,383 --> 00:24:29,678 [Patricia] The question speaks to the defendant's history of violence. 326 00:24:29,678 --> 00:24:30,762 [Posner] Overruled. 327 00:24:30,762 --> 00:24:34,433 Was the encounter with Mr. Ruiz the only occasion 328 00:24:35,392 --> 00:24:37,644 that Danny Sullivan was ever violent? 329 00:24:38,687 --> 00:24:39,521 No. 330 00:24:40,731 --> 00:24:43,233 Back in high school, I had this boyfriend, Bill. 331 00:24:43,817 --> 00:24:44,943 Danny got jealous. 332 00:24:45,444 --> 00:24:48,655 He beat him pretty bad. He put him in the hospital. 333 00:24:49,531 --> 00:24:50,532 Another kid too. 334 00:24:51,366 --> 00:24:54,161 At the time, I told myself it was this freak thing. 335 00:24:55,996 --> 00:24:57,122 Maybe Bill deserved it. 336 00:24:58,207 --> 00:24:59,458 Now I'm not so sure. 337 00:25:02,211 --> 00:25:03,420 No further questions. 338 00:25:15,140 --> 00:25:16,141 [sniffs] 339 00:25:19,811 --> 00:25:20,896 [sighs] 340 00:25:38,288 --> 00:25:41,416 They're off to stalk your son at the, uh, side exit. 341 00:25:41,416 --> 00:25:45,295 Apparently, perp walks sell papers. Even the same perp walk twice a day. 342 00:25:46,129 --> 00:25:48,006 Do you wanna see him? I can walk you around. 343 00:25:49,174 --> 00:25:51,301 No, not like that. 344 00:25:53,762 --> 00:25:54,763 I'm glad you came. 345 00:25:57,015 --> 00:25:58,475 There's a shitty bar around the corner. 346 00:25:58,475 --> 00:26:00,978 It's mostly lawyers, but at this hour it's not that bad. 347 00:26:04,273 --> 00:26:06,275 I don't know what you people want from me. 348 00:26:09,570 --> 00:26:11,780 [Stan] Please tell me that you convinced her to testify. 349 00:26:11,780 --> 00:26:14,950 [Rya] Uh, she came, didn't she? That's-- That's progress. 350 00:26:14,950 --> 00:26:17,286 - [Stan] Progress is for people with time. - [Rya sighs] 351 00:26:17,286 --> 00:26:18,871 [Stan] They're painting a picture of a kid 352 00:26:18,871 --> 00:26:20,873 who goes after his perfectly nice stepfather, 353 00:26:20,873 --> 00:26:23,417 shoots up a bunch of innocent people in the process, 354 00:26:23,417 --> 00:26:26,253 and now he's pretending that he hears voices so he can get out of jail. 355 00:26:26,253 --> 00:26:27,921 It's pretty compelling stuff if you ask me. 356 00:26:27,921 --> 00:26:29,339 [Rya] Whose side are you on, Stan? 357 00:26:30,007 --> 00:26:31,800 - Right now, the losing one. - [Rya chuckles] 358 00:26:31,800 --> 00:26:33,886 [Stan] Is it too late to switch? [clears throat] 359 00:26:33,886 --> 00:26:39,391 So she sees it today, her kid on trial, and she goes back home to him. 360 00:26:39,391 --> 00:26:40,475 Stays with him. 361 00:26:41,143 --> 00:26:42,811 God, how does that even work? 362 00:26:42,811 --> 00:26:45,355 Maybe we're just not built to survive alone. 363 00:26:45,355 --> 00:26:47,900 I mean, did you know that our brain has these chemical receptors 364 00:26:47,900 --> 00:26:50,360 that light up when we make human connections? 365 00:26:50,360 --> 00:26:52,821 - Oh, yeah? - It literally turns on 366 00:26:52,821 --> 00:26:55,199 - to make us feel like we're safe. - Mmm. 367 00:26:56,241 --> 00:26:59,995 Only, sometimes other people aren't safe. 368 00:26:59,995 --> 00:27:03,582 Yeah, amen to that. [groans] 369 00:27:03,582 --> 00:27:05,751 I feel like you're gonna make an ex-wife joke. 370 00:27:05,751 --> 00:27:08,212 [sighs] I was considering it. 371 00:27:08,754 --> 00:27:10,047 Go on anyway. 372 00:27:10,547 --> 00:27:13,509 There's a whole world of ways that people hurt each other. 373 00:27:13,509 --> 00:27:15,385 Yeah, you don't know the half of it. 374 00:27:19,640 --> 00:27:23,936 Too much pain, in rare cases like Danny's, the mind shatters. 375 00:27:23,936 --> 00:27:25,604 But most people, they-- 376 00:27:25,604 --> 00:27:27,981 they find conventional ways of avoiding the pain, 377 00:27:27,981 --> 00:27:32,945 like booze and drugs, sex, that light up those receptors. 378 00:27:33,529 --> 00:27:36,532 - Those things work. - And also being with the wrong person, 379 00:27:36,532 --> 00:27:39,451 because a-at least the pain is familiar to them. 380 00:27:41,912 --> 00:27:47,376 If you ask me, I think that if a relationship can break you, 381 00:27:47,376 --> 00:27:51,380 then sometimes a relationship can also heal you. 382 00:27:51,964 --> 00:27:53,715 Please tell me you're not saying love is the answer. 383 00:27:53,715 --> 00:27:56,552 [chuckles] I actually am. 384 00:27:56,552 --> 00:27:57,678 Mmm. 385 00:27:59,513 --> 00:28:02,516 It's like that arrow story that Jack told Danny. 386 00:28:02,516 --> 00:28:05,978 Fear of pain is worse than the pain ever was. 387 00:28:07,145 --> 00:28:08,939 Jack? You mean make-believe Jack? 388 00:28:09,565 --> 00:28:10,566 Yeah. 389 00:28:11,775 --> 00:28:12,943 [chuckles] 390 00:28:15,028 --> 00:28:16,446 We've all been hurt. 391 00:28:16,446 --> 00:28:17,739 Some more than others. 392 00:28:20,492 --> 00:28:24,162 And we can have a tendency to stay in relationships that are bad. 393 00:28:24,162 --> 00:28:28,750 Those receptors are firing, telling us not to risk losing what we have. 394 00:28:29,418 --> 00:28:32,254 - [gasps, groans] - [Marlin] Whoa, whoa, whoa. Come here. 395 00:28:32,254 --> 00:28:37,050 Even if it's to find something better for us, healthier for us. 396 00:28:37,634 --> 00:28:41,555 We stay with the hurt we know rather than risk being hurt again. 397 00:28:42,639 --> 00:28:44,141 But we have a choice. 398 00:28:45,976 --> 00:28:47,728 The truth is, we always have. 399 00:28:48,312 --> 00:28:50,939 We just have to remember to try to keep making it. 400 00:28:52,316 --> 00:28:55,194 To remember that other people can hurt us, 401 00:28:56,236 --> 00:28:57,779 but they can also help us. 402 00:28:58,780 --> 00:29:02,451 That to reach out, to let someone reach back, 403 00:29:03,660 --> 00:29:05,120 is a way out of pain. 404 00:29:08,624 --> 00:29:09,958 That doesn't mean it's easy. 405 00:29:12,211 --> 00:29:13,295 {\an8}It's hard. 406 00:29:15,172 --> 00:29:16,173 Terrifying. 407 00:29:19,885 --> 00:29:22,137 We need to be brave like Danny was brave, 408 00:29:23,055 --> 00:29:24,348 and ask for help. 409 00:29:25,974 --> 00:29:27,309 We don't have to be alone. 410 00:29:29,811 --> 00:29:30,812 [prison guard] Lights out. 411 00:29:40,864 --> 00:29:43,283 [Jerome] We met at Danceteria, this club on 37th. 412 00:29:43,784 --> 00:29:45,702 Tell me about her. What was she like? 413 00:29:46,495 --> 00:29:50,165 [Jerome sighs] Ariana was... [chuckles] ...something else. 414 00:29:50,999 --> 00:29:53,710 The way she moved. The way she smiled. 415 00:29:54,628 --> 00:29:55,879 Iridescent. 416 00:29:55,879 --> 00:29:57,422 Everyone wanted to be with her. 417 00:29:57,422 --> 00:29:58,966 The boys, the girls. 418 00:29:58,966 --> 00:30:01,218 [chuckles] And she knew it. She worked it. 419 00:30:01,218 --> 00:30:05,305 [Stan] Uh, Mr. Williams, do you see Ariana in this courtroom? 420 00:30:09,268 --> 00:30:10,435 No. 421 00:30:10,435 --> 00:30:11,520 [Stan] No? 422 00:30:12,229 --> 00:30:16,567 The thing is, he's not her. N-Not anymore. 423 00:30:17,067 --> 00:30:18,151 [Stan] How can you tell? 424 00:30:18,652 --> 00:30:20,112 [Jerome] Everything about him is different. 425 00:30:20,112 --> 00:30:23,907 Like the way he sits, curled in so small. 426 00:30:23,907 --> 00:30:28,078 And-- And his eyes, which... [chuckles] ...give up everything. 427 00:30:29,121 --> 00:30:32,124 Ariana had a resting poker face. 428 00:30:32,124 --> 00:30:34,251 Girl was a brick wall. 429 00:30:35,043 --> 00:30:37,254 Uh, not to mention, Danny's straight. 430 00:30:38,005 --> 00:30:40,048 [Stan] So you know Danny? You've met Danny? 431 00:30:40,048 --> 00:30:42,301 I met him at Rikers a few weeks ago. 432 00:30:42,301 --> 00:30:45,596 I saw the story in the paper, and, uh, I went over there. 433 00:30:45,596 --> 00:30:48,098 I was just-- I was looking to understand, I guess. 434 00:30:48,098 --> 00:30:50,017 And what'd you find at Rikers? 435 00:30:53,770 --> 00:30:54,771 A stranger. 436 00:31:00,235 --> 00:31:03,238 [Patricia] Mr. Williams, did you have a sexual relationship with the defendant? 437 00:31:04,198 --> 00:31:05,741 [Jerome] I had a relationship with Ariana. 438 00:31:05,741 --> 00:31:07,659 I didn't ask you what the defendant called himself. 439 00:31:07,659 --> 00:31:10,579 - I asked if you had a sexual-- - [Stan] Uh, objection. Asked and answered. 440 00:31:10,579 --> 00:31:11,830 [Posner] Overruled. 441 00:31:12,414 --> 00:31:15,626 I could put the question to you in more graphic terms, if you'd like. 442 00:31:15,626 --> 00:31:16,710 [sighs] 443 00:31:17,920 --> 00:31:19,421 Yes, we did. 444 00:31:19,421 --> 00:31:21,673 - [Patricia] Where? - Objection, irrelevant. 445 00:31:21,673 --> 00:31:24,384 The question speaks to the true nature of their relationship. 446 00:31:25,052 --> 00:31:26,345 Overruled. 447 00:31:26,345 --> 00:31:27,513 [Patricia] Where? 448 00:31:28,972 --> 00:31:29,973 The men's room. 449 00:31:30,933 --> 00:31:32,226 The men's room. 450 00:31:33,143 --> 00:31:35,479 Hmm. How romantic. 451 00:31:35,479 --> 00:31:37,439 Couldn't anyone have just walked in? 452 00:31:38,065 --> 00:31:40,317 Were your encounters in full public view? 453 00:31:40,317 --> 00:31:41,777 We used a stall. 454 00:31:41,777 --> 00:31:45,239 [Patricia] Mr. Williams, you never shared a meal with the defendant. 455 00:31:45,239 --> 00:31:47,449 - Never saw his home, did you? - [Jerome] No. 456 00:31:47,449 --> 00:31:49,159 - [Patricia] Ever meet his friends? - No. 457 00:31:49,159 --> 00:31:50,869 - [Patricia] Family? - No. 458 00:31:50,869 --> 00:31:54,456 Your most intimate moments were in a bathroom stall. 459 00:31:56,208 --> 00:31:58,544 How well could you possibly have known this man? 460 00:31:58,544 --> 00:32:00,212 There was no "this man." 461 00:32:00,212 --> 00:32:03,298 There was only Ariana, and I knew her. 462 00:32:03,298 --> 00:32:07,636 [Patricia] These clubs you frequent, are there ever closeted gay men there? 463 00:32:08,136 --> 00:32:09,972 - Men with something to hide. - Sure. 464 00:32:09,972 --> 00:32:14,935 So how could you know that Ariana wasn't just an alias? 465 00:32:14,935 --> 00:32:16,728 A cover. A lie. 466 00:32:29,992 --> 00:32:30,993 It's on me. 467 00:32:30,993 --> 00:32:32,202 [stammers] Mr. Camisa-- 468 00:32:32,202 --> 00:32:34,705 Stan. And please, I-I got a tab here. Tell her, Sam. 469 00:32:35,372 --> 00:32:36,456 He does owe me money. 470 00:32:36,456 --> 00:32:39,084 [chuckles] I come here a lot. It's nothing. Please. Please. 471 00:32:43,630 --> 00:32:45,007 We're gonna lose, Candy. 472 00:32:45,007 --> 00:32:48,635 Multiple personality disorder is only ever caused by one thing, 473 00:32:49,428 --> 00:32:51,638 and we can't prove that it ever happened. 474 00:32:51,638 --> 00:32:54,308 And worse, Danny denies it ever happened. 475 00:32:54,308 --> 00:32:56,393 It's like arguing a guy is shell-shocked 476 00:32:56,393 --> 00:32:58,645 and he swears that he's never even seen a war. 477 00:32:58,645 --> 00:33:00,814 Our entire defense is built around this. 478 00:33:00,814 --> 00:33:02,608 Well, then you've got the wrong defense. 479 00:33:02,608 --> 00:33:04,860 - Candy-- - A-And you should have seen it coming. 480 00:33:04,860 --> 00:33:07,196 Well, why do you think I've been calling you, repeatedly? 481 00:33:07,196 --> 00:33:09,865 Calling me is not an actual legal strategy. 482 00:33:09,865 --> 00:33:12,201 [stammers] I also subpoenaed you, which is. 483 00:33:12,701 --> 00:33:13,994 - And you ignored it. - [sniffs] 484 00:33:14,995 --> 00:33:17,164 I can ask the judge to find you in contempt, you know. 485 00:33:20,292 --> 00:33:24,254 Look, please take the stand. 486 00:33:24,254 --> 00:33:25,964 Just tell 'em what happened to Danny. 487 00:33:27,382 --> 00:33:31,136 Are you even aware of the accusation that you're making right now? 488 00:33:31,136 --> 00:33:34,515 - Well, your husband's a sick man, Can-- - Not against my husband, against me. 489 00:33:37,434 --> 00:33:39,645 Find me in fucking contempt. 490 00:33:49,112 --> 00:33:54,910 [Rya] The mind is an extraordinary thing, capable of extraordinary transformations. 491 00:33:54,910 --> 00:33:58,497 Not just voices, but bodies. Skills. 492 00:33:58,497 --> 00:34:00,707 Playing an instrument, mastering chess, 493 00:34:00,707 --> 00:34:03,210 speaking a foreign language, lighting up a room. 494 00:34:03,210 --> 00:34:05,504 These aren't things that people can just fake. 495 00:34:05,504 --> 00:34:08,090 And these are people who come from every walk of life. 496 00:34:08,090 --> 00:34:10,050 Every race. Every age. 497 00:34:10,050 --> 00:34:11,635 They're people who have nothing to gain 498 00:34:11,635 --> 00:34:14,388 from a diagnosis that carries social stigma. 499 00:34:14,388 --> 00:34:15,973 MPD is real. 500 00:34:15,973 --> 00:34:21,103 And patients with MPD have suffered in ways that most of us cannot comprehend. 501 00:34:22,521 --> 00:34:27,317 - They deserve empathy and compassion. - [Stan] And how have they suffered? 502 00:34:27,317 --> 00:34:30,152 Can't anyone just claim to have other personalities inside them? 503 00:34:30,152 --> 00:34:31,530 [Rya] The literature is clear. 504 00:34:31,530 --> 00:34:33,657 For the diagnosis to apply, 505 00:34:33,657 --> 00:34:37,661 the patients must have experienced severe childhood trauma, 506 00:34:38,370 --> 00:34:39,454 usually sexual. 507 00:34:40,038 --> 00:34:42,248 At a point in their lives when they are the most vulnerable-- 508 00:34:42,248 --> 00:34:43,667 the most in need of protection-- 509 00:34:43,667 --> 00:34:47,462 they are betrayed, usually by somebody that they trusted. 510 00:34:47,963 --> 00:34:51,592 A child's mind isn't equipped to handle this. 511 00:34:51,592 --> 00:34:54,178 It can't manage all the contradictions. 512 00:34:55,344 --> 00:34:59,266 So the psyche fractures and that's the first alter. 513 00:34:59,766 --> 00:35:00,934 The child goes away. 514 00:35:01,518 --> 00:35:02,978 Somebody new comes in. 515 00:35:02,978 --> 00:35:07,816 Someone better equipped to navigate a terrifying world. 516 00:35:09,484 --> 00:35:10,944 And that's how it begins. 517 00:35:11,570 --> 00:35:16,200 It's a defense mechanism against horrific, unfathomable pain. 518 00:35:17,910 --> 00:35:19,161 [Stan] Can you tell me about Danny? 519 00:35:21,663 --> 00:35:24,291 I first met Danny at the police station after his arrest. 520 00:35:24,291 --> 00:35:25,834 Only it wasn't Danny, it was Jonny. 521 00:35:25,834 --> 00:35:27,127 And who's Jonny? 522 00:35:27,127 --> 00:35:30,881 Jonny is one of Danny's alters. He's a literal escape artist. 523 00:35:31,548 --> 00:35:34,551 So when the shackles came out, so did Jonny. 524 00:35:36,803 --> 00:35:38,680 [Patricia] So are these descriptions 525 00:35:38,680 --> 00:35:43,685 of Danny's so-called personalities facts or speculations? 526 00:35:43,685 --> 00:35:45,479 They're my clinical judgments. 527 00:35:45,479 --> 00:35:48,482 Did Danny ever tell you he thought he had multiple personalities? 528 00:35:48,482 --> 00:35:49,399 No, but it doesn't-- 529 00:35:49,399 --> 00:35:52,861 In fact, wasn't it you who first introduced the idea to him? 530 00:35:52,861 --> 00:35:55,906 Yes, because his symptoms supported the diagnosis. 531 00:35:55,906 --> 00:35:57,074 So you say. 532 00:35:57,658 --> 00:35:59,451 But then you have a lot riding on this, don't you? 533 00:36:00,035 --> 00:36:01,036 [Rya] I'm not sure what you mean. 534 00:36:01,036 --> 00:36:03,455 [Patricia] Who pays for your research? How do you make a living? 535 00:36:04,122 --> 00:36:06,750 Most of my work is funded through grants. 536 00:36:06,750 --> 00:36:08,877 - Grants like the Reiling Grant? - [Rya] Yes. 537 00:36:08,877 --> 00:36:10,921 - Which expired last year. - [Rya] Yes. 538 00:36:10,921 --> 00:36:14,508 [Patricia] And is it true the university just turned down a request from you 539 00:36:14,508 --> 00:36:15,801 for additional funding? 540 00:36:15,801 --> 00:36:19,429 There's only so much to go around, but I'm going to reapply in the spring. 541 00:36:19,429 --> 00:36:21,640 - You have tenure? - I'm up for it next year. 542 00:36:21,640 --> 00:36:23,600 [Patricia] So, with your funding drying up, 543 00:36:23,600 --> 00:36:26,979 your major grant expiring and with tenure on the line, 544 00:36:26,979 --> 00:36:30,440 would it be fair to say that this is a make-or-break moment in your career? 545 00:36:30,440 --> 00:36:32,526 - Objection. - Withdraw the question. 546 00:36:32,526 --> 00:36:36,613 Would it be fair to say that a high-profile case like this one 547 00:36:36,613 --> 00:36:38,907 could be a real opportunity for you? 548 00:36:39,908 --> 00:36:41,577 Chance for you to make a name for yourself. 549 00:36:42,536 --> 00:36:45,247 - I don't see my patients as opportunities. - [Patricia] Don't you? 550 00:36:45,247 --> 00:36:47,916 I mean, why else did you walk into that police station? 551 00:36:48,417 --> 00:36:51,837 Was it because you were having a sexual relationship with the detective 552 00:36:51,837 --> 00:36:53,630 - who leaked Danny's case to you? - [Stan] Objection. 553 00:36:53,630 --> 00:36:55,674 - [Posner] Sustained. Take care, Counselor. - [scoffs] 554 00:36:56,258 --> 00:36:57,426 Withdrawn. 555 00:36:58,302 --> 00:37:01,555 Why did you follow the defendant to Rikers? 556 00:37:01,555 --> 00:37:06,393 There's a term for lawyers who solicit business like that. 557 00:37:06,393 --> 00:37:07,936 - Ambulance chasers. - [Stan] Objection. 558 00:37:07,936 --> 00:37:10,439 - [Posner] Sustained. - [Patricia] Let me put it another way. 559 00:37:11,023 --> 00:37:15,194 When you walked into that police station, what were you hoping to find? 560 00:37:15,194 --> 00:37:16,904 I wasn't hoping to find anything. 561 00:37:16,904 --> 00:37:20,449 See, I'm sorry, but I find that hard to believe. 562 00:37:21,408 --> 00:37:25,579 You get a tip about a kid. You drop everything. 563 00:37:25,579 --> 00:37:27,664 You run halfway across Manhattan. 564 00:37:27,664 --> 00:37:30,459 - W-What did you take? The bus? The train? - I took the train. 565 00:37:30,459 --> 00:37:33,003 Y-You mean to tell me you're not sitting on that train, 566 00:37:33,003 --> 00:37:35,506 hoping that this is the one? 567 00:37:35,506 --> 00:37:37,174 The one who makes you famous. 568 00:37:37,174 --> 00:37:39,343 The one who puts you on the national stage. 569 00:37:39,343 --> 00:37:40,719 - Absolutely not. - [Stan] Objection. 570 00:37:40,719 --> 00:37:42,137 What do you know, it worked. 571 00:37:42,137 --> 00:37:44,431 [stammers] Your Honor, the witness is not on trial. 572 00:37:44,431 --> 00:37:46,934 [Posner] Sustained. Move on, Counselor. 573 00:37:46,934 --> 00:37:49,770 [Patricia] Okay, Doctor. One last question. 574 00:37:49,770 --> 00:37:51,438 The defense claims-- [sighs] 575 00:37:51,438 --> 00:37:57,903 You claim that the cause of Danny's so-called multiple personalities 576 00:37:59,112 --> 00:38:00,864 was sexual abuse in childhood. 577 00:38:02,616 --> 00:38:05,160 In all of your sessions with the defendant, 578 00:38:06,537 --> 00:38:09,081 has he ever told you he was sexually abused? 579 00:38:13,001 --> 00:38:16,046 [Patricia] Dr. Goodwin, has anyone ever told you 580 00:38:16,046 --> 00:38:20,926 or had the defendant ever claimed he was sexually abused? 581 00:38:22,678 --> 00:38:24,721 It's a yes or no question. 582 00:38:24,721 --> 00:38:25,806 [sighs] 583 00:38:28,976 --> 00:38:30,060 Dr. Goodwin? 584 00:38:36,108 --> 00:38:36,942 No. 585 00:38:40,904 --> 00:38:42,197 No further questions, Your Honor. 586 00:38:43,407 --> 00:38:45,284 [reporter 1] Dr. Goodwin, Dr. Goodwin? 587 00:38:45,284 --> 00:38:47,369 [reporters speaking indistinctly] 588 00:38:48,287 --> 00:38:49,997 What do you have to say for your client? 589 00:38:49,997 --> 00:38:52,374 [reporter 2] Dr. Goodwin, how do you defend yourself? 590 00:39:03,135 --> 00:39:04,136 [sniffles] 591 00:39:22,362 --> 00:39:23,780 So, you were just using him? 592 00:39:26,283 --> 00:39:28,577 Candy, that could not be further from the truth. 593 00:39:28,577 --> 00:39:30,329 And Camisa? He's out of his depth. 594 00:39:30,329 --> 00:39:32,456 - Stan's a good lawyer. - He's Legal Aid. 595 00:39:32,456 --> 00:39:33,832 He's working his ass off. 596 00:39:33,832 --> 00:39:35,459 [chuckles] He's falling apart. 597 00:39:35,459 --> 00:39:36,668 Who isn't? 598 00:39:38,128 --> 00:39:40,255 - Why are you here? - 'Cause I know how this ends. 599 00:39:40,255 --> 00:39:42,007 I know who you'll all blame. 600 00:39:43,300 --> 00:39:45,761 But that's bullshit. You're the ones who let him down. 601 00:39:45,761 --> 00:39:48,388 [chuckles, sighs] 602 00:39:49,348 --> 00:39:50,432 Candy, I-- 603 00:39:51,308 --> 00:39:53,852 I gave your son everything that I have. 604 00:39:55,521 --> 00:39:58,607 My heart is broken. But my conscience is clear. 605 00:39:58,607 --> 00:39:59,525 So is mine. 606 00:39:59,525 --> 00:40:01,985 If that were true, you wouldn't have followed me in here. 607 00:40:03,362 --> 00:40:04,571 And you're wrong. 608 00:40:04,571 --> 00:40:07,908 I would never have blamed you. Never. 609 00:40:09,660 --> 00:40:10,661 Bullshit. 610 00:40:14,540 --> 00:40:15,999 [sighs] 611 00:40:20,712 --> 00:40:25,050 I had this patient, Anna, when I was a first-year resident. 612 00:40:27,636 --> 00:40:31,765 And Anna had been raped six times, by six different men, 613 00:40:31,765 --> 00:40:33,267 over the course of eight years. 614 00:40:33,267 --> 00:40:35,269 And, Candy, she was 19. 615 00:40:35,894 --> 00:40:37,145 How do you explain that? 616 00:40:39,398 --> 00:40:42,693 There's a phenomenon, an awful phenomenon. 617 00:40:44,069 --> 00:40:45,779 Victims of abuse survive. 618 00:40:45,779 --> 00:40:50,450 They-- They get away, only to be abused again by somebody else. 619 00:40:52,160 --> 00:40:58,083 And I think, hearing these stories, "My God, these-- these poor people. 620 00:40:59,084 --> 00:41:01,461 The unluckiest human beings on the planet." 621 00:41:02,796 --> 00:41:04,798 Only it's not luck. 622 00:41:04,798 --> 00:41:07,509 It is a fucked up twist of nature. 623 00:41:09,636 --> 00:41:14,641 Because as children, they are forced to relate sexually. 624 00:41:16,393 --> 00:41:18,937 They are trained to be abused. 625 00:41:19,646 --> 00:41:24,109 Predators are very adept at finding their prey. 626 00:41:24,902 --> 00:41:28,071 They're picking up on cues that nobody else can see. 627 00:41:28,655 --> 00:41:32,701 These cues can be chemical, psychological, behavioral, nonverbal. 628 00:41:34,953 --> 00:41:36,997 To the predator, neon signs. 629 00:41:37,497 --> 00:41:40,626 And here's the thing that I cannot emphasize enough. 630 00:41:43,212 --> 00:41:47,216 None of it is under the victim's control. 631 00:41:49,510 --> 00:41:52,888 None of it is the victim's fault. 632 00:41:56,683 --> 00:41:58,852 You and Danny were prey, 633 00:41:59,811 --> 00:42:02,689 and I suspect Marlin isn't the first predator in your life. 634 00:42:04,274 --> 00:42:05,400 And it's not your fault. 635 00:42:07,653 --> 00:42:09,696 And my heart breaks for you, it does. 636 00:42:11,031 --> 00:42:13,242 Because you did nothing to deserve it. 637 00:42:16,161 --> 00:42:20,040 So, no, I-- I wouldn't blame you. 638 00:42:22,292 --> 00:42:23,293 For anything. 639 00:42:25,838 --> 00:42:30,634 But my hope would be that if you take the stand, 640 00:42:31,301 --> 00:42:37,057 you might finally be able to stop blaming yourself. 641 00:42:45,732 --> 00:42:46,733 Marlin. 642 00:42:49,611 --> 00:42:50,612 [sighs] 643 00:42:54,741 --> 00:42:57,327 [sniffles] Do you understand what you're asking? 644 00:42:59,454 --> 00:43:00,914 Guilt or grief... 645 00:43:03,542 --> 00:43:05,127 which one can you bear? 646 00:43:16,471 --> 00:43:19,474 You make too much bacon. It's not good for me. 647 00:43:21,226 --> 00:43:23,312 I only make it because you like it. 648 00:43:23,312 --> 00:43:25,689 Yeah, well, I like living too. So, cut back. 649 00:43:25,689 --> 00:43:28,317 Let's face it... [chews, smacks lips] ...I could lose a few. 650 00:43:29,651 --> 00:43:31,278 We've got to look out for each other. 651 00:43:32,821 --> 00:43:33,822 See ya. 652 00:43:38,577 --> 00:43:39,578 [door closes] 653 00:43:42,998 --> 00:43:43,999 [car engine starts] 654 00:44:45,561 --> 00:44:46,812 [car engine starts] 655 00:45:00,117 --> 00:45:01,118 [grunts] 656 00:45:02,619 --> 00:45:03,620 Hi, honey. 657 00:45:04,246 --> 00:45:08,125 [sighs] Thought I'd come by. See you up there. 658 00:45:10,752 --> 00:45:14,631 [sighs] I'm not a stupid man, Candy. I know why you're here. 659 00:45:14,631 --> 00:45:16,133 I know what you're gonna say. 660 00:45:16,133 --> 00:45:18,427 I'm not even going to tell you not to say it. 661 00:45:18,427 --> 00:45:19,887 You do what you want. 662 00:45:20,596 --> 00:45:24,391 But I wouldn't be doing my duty as your husband if I didn't tell you 663 00:45:24,391 --> 00:45:26,435 that the words you say-- 664 00:45:26,435 --> 00:45:32,441 that this terrible lie will change the world you live in overnight. 665 00:45:33,650 --> 00:45:37,487 [Marlin] I mean, people staring at the A&P and whispers all over town. 666 00:45:37,487 --> 00:45:39,573 "What kind of mother would allow such a thing?" 667 00:45:40,282 --> 00:45:42,284 Well, you'll lose your husband, of course. 668 00:45:42,284 --> 00:45:45,579 You'll also lose your job and your home, eventually. 669 00:45:46,580 --> 00:45:49,791 Worst of all, you will lose the illusion of who you are. 670 00:45:50,626 --> 00:45:55,214 And without it, all anyone will see is what you allowed and what you admitted. 671 00:45:57,341 --> 00:45:58,759 That's all Danny will see. 672 00:46:00,344 --> 00:46:01,637 So, you'll lose him too. 673 00:46:03,013 --> 00:46:04,681 - [elevator dings] - [clears throat] 674 00:46:09,061 --> 00:46:10,854 [Stan] What was Danny like as a kid? 675 00:46:10,854 --> 00:46:14,399 [Candy] He was a good boy. Sweet boy. 676 00:46:15,192 --> 00:46:17,819 - But he was always different. - Different how? 677 00:46:19,404 --> 00:46:25,410 Too sensitive, I guess. Tender. 678 00:46:27,496 --> 00:46:28,497 [sighs] 679 00:46:29,706 --> 00:46:34,962 The world's a tough place, and we were all each other had. 680 00:46:37,631 --> 00:46:41,426 Ms. Reid, I'm gonna have to ask you some difficult questions now. 681 00:46:41,426 --> 00:46:43,512 You can take your time answering them, okay? 682 00:46:49,726 --> 00:46:53,772 Do you believe your son, Danny, was ever sexually abused? 683 00:46:53,772 --> 00:46:54,857 [Patricia] Objection. 684 00:46:54,857 --> 00:46:59,945 Unless she personally witnessed abuse, any answer will be pure speculation. 685 00:46:59,945 --> 00:47:03,866 Your Honor, most abuse happens in secret without witnesses. 686 00:47:03,866 --> 00:47:06,910 If the mother of a child isn't considered an expert witness 687 00:47:06,910 --> 00:47:09,705 on what happened to her son in her own home, who is? 688 00:47:10,664 --> 00:47:13,166 [smacks lips] Overruled. Proceed. 689 00:47:13,667 --> 00:47:16,795 Ms. Reid, do you believe Danny was ever sexually abused? 690 00:47:31,185 --> 00:47:32,186 No. 691 00:47:33,687 --> 00:47:36,690 - I'm sorry. Let me ask that again. - I don't believe he was abused. 692 00:47:38,609 --> 00:47:43,238 Ms. Reid... [stammers] ...I understand that this is very difficult for you. 693 00:47:43,822 --> 00:47:46,158 I just want to remind you that you are under oath. 694 00:47:48,035 --> 00:47:50,662 Are you sure there wasn't any kind of abuse? 695 00:47:50,662 --> 00:47:51,747 [Patricia] Objection. 696 00:47:51,747 --> 00:47:53,165 [Stan] Are you sure you didn't hear anything? 697 00:47:53,165 --> 00:47:54,291 - Asked and answered. - [gavel bangs] 698 00:47:54,291 --> 00:47:56,502 - Are you sure that you didn't see any-- - [Posner] Sustained. 699 00:48:03,175 --> 00:48:04,176 [Stan] Ms. Reid? 700 00:48:05,385 --> 00:48:06,386 No. 701 00:48:09,932 --> 00:48:10,933 No further questions. 702 00:48:11,850 --> 00:48:12,851 [Posner] Ms. Richards. 703 00:48:14,269 --> 00:48:15,437 No questions, Your Honor. 704 00:48:15,437 --> 00:48:17,314 The witness is excused. 705 00:48:32,579 --> 00:48:34,706 [Posner] We'll adjourn till tomorrow. 706 00:48:34,706 --> 00:48:36,166 Escort the jury out please. 707 00:48:36,708 --> 00:48:38,001 [gavel bangs] 708 00:48:38,001 --> 00:48:39,086 [bailiff] All rise. 709 00:48:47,302 --> 00:48:48,554 [Stan] Danny, stand up. 710 00:48:58,272 --> 00:49:00,274 ["I Remember" playing] 711 00:49:09,241 --> 00:49:12,119 ♪ We tramped the open moorland In the rainy April weather ♪ 712 00:49:12,119 --> 00:49:14,955 [door opens, closes] 713 00:49:16,039 --> 00:49:20,961 ♪ And came upon the little inn That we had found together ♪ 714 00:49:20,961 --> 00:49:22,045 [Marlin exhales deeply] 715 00:49:22,045 --> 00:49:28,302 ♪ The landlord gave us toast and tea And stopped to share a joke ♪ 716 00:49:29,636 --> 00:49:33,223 ♪ And I remember firelight ♪ 717 00:49:33,223 --> 00:49:34,433 [clearing throat] 718 00:49:36,602 --> 00:49:41,315 ♪ I remember firelight ♪ 719 00:49:41,315 --> 00:49:44,484 ♪ And you remember smoke ♪ 720 00:49:48,572 --> 00:49:53,702 ♪ We ran about the meadow grass With all the harebells bending ♪ 721 00:49:56,955 --> 00:50:02,419 ♪ And shaking in the summer wind A summer never-ending ♪ 722 00:50:03,462 --> 00:50:08,926 ♪ We wandered to the little stream Among the river flats ♪ 723 00:50:09,510 --> 00:50:13,555 ♪ And I remember willow trees ♪ 724 00:50:13,555 --> 00:50:20,729 ♪ I remember willow trees ♪ 725 00:50:21,355 --> 00:50:24,399 ♪ And you remember gnats ♪ 726 00:50:29,363 --> 00:50:35,285 ♪ We strolled the Spanish marketplace At 90 in the shade ♪ 727 00:50:36,036 --> 00:50:40,999 ♪ With all the fruit and vegetables So temptingly arrayed ♪ 728 00:50:42,209 --> 00:50:45,379 ♪ And we can share a memory ♪ 729 00:50:45,921 --> 00:50:49,383 ♪ As every lover must ♪ 730 00:50:49,967 --> 00:50:53,387 ♪ And I remember oranges ♪ 731 00:50:53,387 --> 00:51:00,227 ♪ I remember oranges ♪ 732 00:51:00,727 --> 00:51:03,647 ♪ And you remember dust ♪ 733 00:51:03,647 --> 00:51:05,524 [inhales sharply, breathing shakily] 734 00:51:05,524 --> 00:51:10,404 ♪ The autumn leaves are tumbling down And winter's almost here ♪ 735 00:51:11,446 --> 00:51:16,201 ♪ But through the spring and summertime We laughed away the year ♪ 736 00:51:17,369 --> 00:51:19,162 [grunts, breathing shakily] 737 00:51:24,251 --> 00:51:25,252 [swallows] 738 00:51:27,129 --> 00:51:29,339 [grunts, breathing heavily] 739 00:51:30,591 --> 00:51:34,887 ♪ Two happy hearts that beat as one ♪ 740 00:51:35,554 --> 00:51:41,018 ♪ When I had thought that we were "we" ♪ 741 00:51:43,020 --> 00:51:49,985 ♪ But we were "you and me" ♪