[distant chatter]
[door opens]
[door slams]
[man] The last thing I want is for Lester Eubanks to die a free man.
[woman] He murdered my sister.
The Bible says...
you take a life, you...
give your life.
[man] To go from death row
to the shopping mall,
and then allow him to escape...
is unfathomable.
I want him caught.
[suspenseful main theme playing]
[car horn toots]
[woman] Well, I've been here since I was three.
It was a great place to live.
Like any small town, just everybody knew everybody.
Mansfield was a very safe place.
I never remember feeling, um, scared or afraid or...
of something happening to me.
Never.
[children giggling]
[birds singing]
[bicycle bell rings]
[Myrtle] Mary Ellen was a...
She was a... uh, you know, just a typical little girl.
Riding bikes and...
hopscotch and...
you know, playing with dolls.
Oh, she had a lot of friends.
She was just a... giggly girl.
That's all I remember her doing,
just giggling with her friends.
There was seven of us.
We all had things that we had to do in the home.
The boys, trash and mopping the floor.
And the girls did, like, the dishes,
and washing, and folding clothes, and, um...
and all that.
[water running]
That's how she came about doing the laundry that night.
Mary Ellen and Brenda had washed all the clothes,
and, um...
they ended up with wet clothes because the dryer broke.
So, they had to get a taxi
to go to take the wet clothes to the laundromat.
Mom felt comfortable sending them there at that time of night
because my grandmother lived right next door to the laundromat,
and they knew they could go there if anything happened.
[dryer whirs]
They got there, and they were... was drying the clothes
and they run out of change.
And, uh, Mary Ellen went to the other laundromat
to get change.
Take five minutes to walk that distance.
[vehicle drives past]
[dog barks]
And then, when she didn't come back...
Brenda went to my grandmother's
and told her that Mary Ellen had went to get change
and she wasn't back yet.
And my grandmother told her to stay there and she'd go...
and, uh...
see if she could find her.
On her way down there, she saw the police.
And she eventually saw
that it was Mary Ellen there...
and what had happened to her.
[man] Mary Ellen had been, uh, shot.
[indistinct radio messages]
The police were able to determine
what caliber of gun that, uh...
she was shot with.
So, they started going to all the gun stores
and hardware stores that sold guns in, uh... Mansfield.
They ended up at the Diamond Hardware up on South Diamond Street,
and they asked to see the books.
They see a weapon that fit the description of the gun
that was used to shoot Mary Ellen.
And it was purchased by Lester Eubanks.
And then they start really beating the bushes,
talking to informants,
and some informant said he saw Lester Eubanks
in that area earlier in the night,
before the crime occurred.
[Myrtle] Lester Eubanks.
He was just a guy that walked down the street,
I never knew who he was.
[birds cry]
But I just always thought he was weird,
and appeared to be a loner.
Always had these nunchucks with him,
those karate sticks.
That's what he'd do with them, walk up and down the street.
[man] Lester Eubanks grew up in Mansfield.
He's a sharp-looking man.
He is well-liked.
Easily...
um, can fit into anywhere.
But he was also what we would consider to...
to label a sexual predator, today.
[John] Lester Eubanks.
He had been arrested two times in the past
for sex offenses.
And at the time of the homicide,
he was out on bond for a rape attempt.
[sighs] This... this guy shouldn't have even been out.
[door closes]
Sunday morning,
officers, uh, picked him up, took him to the police station.
[phone ringing]
They conducted an interview of him.
He confessed.
And...
we had the right man.
[David] His confession was pretty detailed...
in explaining what he did to this little girl.
That night, Lester Eubanks was just hanging in the area.
He sees an opportunity.
He sees this beautiful little girl walk past him.
He grabs her, pulls her behind the house.
She starts to scream.
[muffled screaming]
Shoots her twice.
Um, her screaming stops.
[John] Eubanks left the scene,
went around the corner to his apartment.
Got dressed to go downtown and go dancing.
And on his way downtown,
come back by the scene of the crime,
and Mary Ellen was, uh...
writhing in ag... agony.
She was still alive after being shot,
wanting help,
so he helped her.
[David] "I picked up a brick in the alley
and I went back to where this little girl..."
I can't even read any more.
He went back.
He admitted to it.
He's a monster.
It's disgusting.
[dogs barking]
[birds chirping]
[Myrtle] Sometime during that morning,
the detectives came
and told us why they were there and...
I... Just total shock and...
couldn't believe it.
My mother was hysterical, crying, and...
my sister Brenda was, uh...
She was in shock for a long time.
Yeah, I think it affected her...
up until the time she died.
I can't imagine having to deal with that.
[David] This monster takes her entire family's world
and just crushes it,
and changes their future.
[Myrtle] I went to the trial daily because I wanted him to know
that she had a lot of people that cared about her and loved her,
and what he had taken from, you know, the world.
I just wanted him to know we cared.
[man] He testified.
He... wanted to get up there
and I think that's really the... uh, a trait of a narcissist.
He didn't seem to show any remorse at all,
other than the fact that he was caught.
[gavel bangs]
Upon his confession in the courtroom,
he was convicted by a jury of his peers. He was sentenced to death.
[Dale] He was sent to the death row
in the Ohio prison system.
[Myrtle] Everybody was happy.
It was wrapped up in a bow.
For a while.
[man] The Ohio Penitentiary was located in downtown Columbus.
And that is where Lester Eubanks was confined
on his conviction from, uh, Richland County.
[man] I knew Lester Eubanks.
I didn't go around him.
I wasn't afraid of him, just that I didn't like him.
I didn't know what he was there for except murder.
Lester was... a tall guy.
Very cocky.
Very opinionated.
Lester was, was... had an attitude.
Was a lot of people he didn't like, a lot of things he didn't like.
He was basically a loner.
Painting or writing, or doing whatever he done, you know?
[David] Eubanks was allowed to have, um, paintbrushes and canvases.
That was not unusual for any prisoner
on death row in the '60s and '70s,
to be able to utilize whatever skills they had.
They were able to eat their time doing something constructive.
Three separate times, his execution was pushed back
for unknown reasons.
And then finally, it was pushed because, 1972,
the death penalty was abolished.
[Ron] The United States Supreme Court in 1972 found
that the death penalty was administered
in an arbitrary and capricious method.
So, Eubanks, along with, uh, other Ohio death row prisoners,
had to have their sentence set aside
and it reverted to a life sentence.
I was angry. I was angry.
And... shocked and...
um... confused.
But if we can't do anything about some things, you have to...
let it go.
Um, that's what we did.
We went on with our lives,
knowing that he was in prison.
[distant voices]
[David] After the death penalty was...
um, abolished,
Lester Eubanks was put into general population.
["Bill"] He could put on a facade, where he looks like a good guy,
but he's not.
[David] He's a smooth talker.
He won the guards over,
and there's no other reasonable explanation than that.
They allowed him to go into this honor program.
[Ron] At the time, there was a national reform kind of movement
to, uh, do things, uh, in a prison with inmates
to help them prepare for life on the outside.
Eubanks became eligible for this honor or trustee program
that allowed him, under certain circumstances,
to, uh... venture outside the prison.
Sometimes they were allowed to drive trucks from prison to prison.
Sometimes they were permitted outside in the presence of a guard
to go run errands.
The rationale was to reward prisoners for good behavior.
That would help them both control the population
as well as incentivize good conduct.
[David] He was in several art shows, um, where he won awards.
You see photographs of him standing there
with these people that don't know who he is, or what he did.
He was a serial sex offender.
Today, we know that he's probably one of the last people you'd wanna...
let in that program because of their recidivism rate.
Or, uh, you know, ability to reoffend.
That was a real bad idea.
[Ron] As part of this furlough program,
four prisoners, along with, uh, Lester Eubanks,
were permitted to go on a Christmas shopping trip.
Merry Christmas!
[David] Money in hand,
and he's in civilian attire.
They're given instructions, of course. "Hey, you go ahead.
Do your shopping for your families.
You have to report back by 2 p.m."
[Ron] And rather than staying together as a group,
uh, they were permitted to leave the presence of the guard
and be on their own, shopping among the public.
It was a period of two to three hours later
where they were gonna meet at a particular place,
and when that time came,
uh, Lester Eubanks did not report back to the agreed meeting place.
[shop bell rings]
[bell rings]
[David] He avoided the electric chair.
He avoided a lifetime in a prison cell.
Lester Eubanks was allowed to walk away.
What were they hoping to accomplish
with this absurd program of taking a...
a child murderer...
to go Christmas shopping,
and not even having a guard stand beside him the entire time?
It... it just is baffling.
[phone rings]
[Myrtle] And my mom called me.
She said sheriff called her and told her that he had escaped.
She was... she was real upset.
I was angry,
and shocked, and...
Christmas shopping is all we could think.
How do you go Christmas shopping from prison?
No one really knows how he escaped from the immediate area,
Great Southern Shopping Center,
but, uh, I don't think he could have done that
if this was a spur-of-the-moment decision by him.
There had to have been planning,
I think he had to have made some kind of arrangements in advance.
[door buzzes]
[David] It was found that when he was in prison,
his visitation list was alarming.
[inaudible speech]
[David] Eubanks had visitors regularly show up at the prison.
But the visitations just prior to his escape
truly escalate.
You know, you go from once a month regularly for years
to once a week, and then all of a sudden, you walk away?
That's suspicious.
It was pre-planned.
It makes you believe that those visitors...
had a little bit of culpability.
[Ron] The theory was that someone from his family
that, uh, supported him may have helped him,
or it wouldn't have been so successful.
[David] His family was talked to, his associates were talked to,
and they failed to surrender any information,
um, to where he was at.
I don't know how anyone cannot think
that this was premeditated.
His ability to become an honor inmate,
this is him earning the trust of the guards,
trust of the prison system.
And it's his ability to become that chameleon to fit...
to... to walk outside the walls.
After Eubanks' escape,
Franklin County Sheriff's Office put a local warrant in the system,
and the FBI took out a federal arrest warrant.
This warrant is gonna be a nationwide pickup,
meaning that if he is caught anywhere in the continental United States,
he's gonna be arrested and brought back to Ohio.
[John] In December of '93...
I was a detective bureau commander, I was a captain.
And I'd thought, you know, we haven't heard a lot about, uh, Eubanks.
Maybe he's been apprehended
and they didn't notify anybody, which...
I don't...
might be a little crazy, but, uh...
We checked it in the computer.
I would've expected to see,
"Wanted for an unlawful flight.
Felony escape from the penitentiary
for the state of Ohio."
I discovered...
there were no warrants to be found.
The federal warrant was removed from the database.
[Dale] If no warrant was there when he was encountered
in a field interview situation or a car stop...
uh, with no warrant in the system...
[engine revs]
...he would've been let go.
When I discovered that nothing...
no affirmative steps were being taken by any agency
to try and bring this...
guy to justice...
I thought, "This is unbelievable."
It was just a lack of either required follow-up
or a clerical kind of error.
That is the only explanation I have or that I can come up with.
[John] It should not have happened, but...
it did.
You have to deal with it.
So, that's what we did.
We thought maybe
if we could get him exposed nationwide,
we can get this guy.
That's when we decided to...
try and get him exposed on America's Most Wanted.
Fourteen-year-old Mary Ellen was exceptionally bright and responsible.
What happened that...
[John] The night of the show, get a call from a lady
who watched the show and says, "I know him...
and I used to run around with him
in Los Angeles, back in the '70s."
And according to her,
Eubanks, he ended up, uh, living with Kay Banks,
his cousin's widow.
[man] When the detectives in Ohio gave us the name of Kay Banks...
a pair of detectives met her at her home.
She was fearful that she would somehow be caught up in some trouble herself
for harboring a fugitive,
and, uh, so she wanted to cooperate.
Kay told the detectives that he lived with her in Los Angeles,
that he was no longer there.
She said that she was originally from Ohio.
And Kay was married to Darrell Banks...
Eubanks' cousin.
And he was a pretty popular singer in Detroit back in the '60s.
Darrell got shot and killed up in Detroit,
and she ended up out in California.
[David] She established a relationship with Lester
through the prison walls.
She was his pen pal.
There was a photo of Kay in his jail cell.
Kay had indicated that after Eubanks had walked away
and effected his escape,
he had found his way to Michigan...
and stayed there to see if he was gonna be chased or not,
or how diligently.
He was trying to paint houses
in a local community in Michigan to earn money.
And he stayed there for a couple of weeks.
Someone put him on a bus, 'cause he didn't have any money,
and paid for a trip to California.
[bus engine rumbles]
[bus screeches]
Lester told Kay that when he gets to California,
the bus was pulled over by law enforcement.
He's sitting there thinking,
"This is it, it's over."
He thought he was gonna go back to jail.
Because he's an escaped prisoner,
there is a warrant for his arrest.
Well, these guys were looking for illegal fruit
being brought across state lines.
Lester looked at 'em and smiled.
And as they walked off the bus, he thought to himself, "Hey.
This is it, I'm free.
I got away."
[disco funk music playing]
[whooping and laughing]
-Oh, yeah! -Yeah, Mama!
All right, Mama!
Get down and watch out, yeah!
[T. Conner] Kay Banks was surprised when she answered the door.
She told us that she didn't know he planned to escape.
He was using an assumed name of Victor Young.
[John] He went and got a hunting license
to use as his ID
because you didn't have to give a fingerprint.
And he had it in a... his alias name.
He's smart, he knows what it takes for him to stay out
and he knows that he can.
Kay told us about Lester's love of painting.
I've seen pictures of some of the work that he did while in prison
and he was talented.
Um... he was just evil.
[John] Kay Banks said that Eubanks,
he was a real bully...
and she was intimidated by him.
After so much intimidation,
she decided she's got to come up with something
to get him out of her life.
She says, "Hey, uh, I got a call today from the FBI or the police
asking about you."
That was all it took.
And according to her, that's the last she saw of him.
Kay provided us with information
about a location in Gardena
where he had worked or was working
in the manufacturing of mattresses.
We went to that location and checked it.
The former owner put Victor Young there up until...
the mid '80s.
Eighty-five or '86.
We worked the case,
uh, for the better part of two years
until somewhere in '96.
And Eubanks is still running.
But it just got to the point where there was no more to do.
[Michael] I had never really heard about the murder until 2003
when I was tasked with looking into some things.
A superior officer down in Columbus was looking at some older escape cases,
so I was contacted.
Basically told, "Hey, here's the case.
Look into this and see what you can find."
My initial thoughts were, uh, to look at Eubanks' father,
Mose Eubanks.
His father was the only known close relative
that was living in this area at the time.
We went out there just to see if he would talk to us.
He says, "I'll talk about anything you want,
but I'm not gonna talk about Lester."
He went on to explain how he was frequently in the prisons
trying to help inmates to, uh...
turn their life around and that type of thing.
And he says, "Well, you know,
there's nothing I can... nothing anyone can do to bring that girl back."
And, uh, I simply ask him the question, I'm like,
"Well, do you think that justice was done in this case with your... with your son?"
And he specifically...
He looked at me and he says,
"People change and go on and start new lives."
And he says, "And I pray for Lester every day.
That's all I'm gonna say about Lester."
We had a bit more conversation,
then my partner and I, we looked at each other,
and we said, "He knows exactly where Lester's at."
A while later, a detective with Mansfield Police Department
talked to an informant that had told him that that same summer,
she had been out to Mose's house.
Well, the lady said, "When we were there,
the phone rang and Mose excused himself
and actually went into another room."
And when he came back,
he had told the lady that...
he was on the phone with his son in Alabama
who was taking a break from painting a house.
At that time, I'd already tracked down all of the siblings
and, uh, there was none in Alabama at the time.
So, that kinda piqued my interest.
I ended up getting a, uh... a subpoena to get his... Mose's phone records.
And, uh, lo and behold, uh...
there were several calls during that time frame...
that were coming and going to a center for troubled youth.
And there was a Black male
that was near that, you know, description of Lester,
uh, height and... and age, working at this place.
This guy in question did not have a driver's license.
He didn't drive.
Uh, and the social security number was coming back
as a false social security number, too,
so that kind of triggered me thinking, "It might be Lester."
Unfortunately,
the person in question that they were talking about
had actually left there
a couple months prior to... to us kind of digging into it.
I... I remember thinking to myself,
if it was him, if it was Lester,
we were able to... to get pretty close.
But at the same token...
you know, here we are, all these years later.
[Dale] Mose Eubanks was a supposed man of the cloth,
and he was willing to...
forgive and forget.
He was willing to forgive his son for this brutal murder
and he was willing to forget about Mary Ellen Deener, the...
the poor child that he murdered.
It's just tragic.
He got to live his life and she didn't.
[Myrtle] He'd never asked for forgiveness.
He could've asked in court.
And he could've had his dad ask my mom,
"Please forgive him."
Nobody has even said anything to my family...
from that family.
[Dale] I've been a police officer for 40 years.
And...
this is the biggest miscarriage of justice that I've ever seen.
Uh, I just can't forget about it.
I won't forget about it.
[John] This guy needs to be captured.
He needs to be apprehended
and pay for this heinous crime that he committed.
But law enforcement can't do it by themselves.
We have to get the, the... [sighs]
...the profile out for people to see.
[David] Marshals Service, we fight for those who can't fight for themselves.
Mary Ellen Deener cannot fight for herself.
In July of 2018, I started to push forward
with, uh, Lester Eubanks being put on the 15 Most Wanted.
These are the type of cases that...
They're... they're alleged to be the uncatchables.
You make that list,
that means you are the worst of the worst.
Lester Eubanks has friends and associates throughout many states.
Florida,
Texas,
Alabama,
California and Washington.
Someone's gonna identify him,
someone's gonna bring him to justice.
Lester's got a huge scar on his right arm.
It's probably an inch,
and it wraps all the way around his right arm,
and it's pretty thick.
And it's pretty identifiable.
The other thing is he was an extremely...
um, talented painter.
And I still think today
that might be one of the things that could help identify who he is.
The United States Marshals Service is offering a reward for $25,000
for any information that leads to the arrest.
And I would be more than happy
to provide that person with that money.
[Myrtle] It's important that Lester is caught
because he was given a life sentence.
He took my sister's life.
She didn't get an extension.
Her life is over.
And the law said that's what should happen with him.
Living, but still not free.
I want him caught.
[suspenseful main theme playing]