1 00:00:04,308 --> 00:00:05,744 Previously onBull... 2 00:00:05,788 --> 00:00:07,224 [buzzer sounds]Arthur. 3 00:00:07,268 --> 00:00:09,922 Wasn't sure you'd remember me after 12 years. 4 00:00:09,966 --> 00:00:13,448 Have you got any new evidence?How about a signed confession? 5 00:00:13,491 --> 00:00:15,058 BULL: We need these commissioners to grant parole 6 00:00:15,102 --> 00:00:17,669 to a guy who's been convicted of double murder. 7 00:00:17,713 --> 00:00:19,193 My name is Leo Craddick, 8 00:00:19,236 --> 00:00:21,021 and I'm Arthur Craddick's son. 9 00:00:21,064 --> 00:00:23,240 12 years of prison is enough to break most anyone's soul. 10 00:00:23,284 --> 00:00:24,807 Please extend 11 00:00:24,850 --> 00:00:26,939 this opportunity to him. 12 00:00:26,983 --> 00:00:27,853 [crying] 13 00:00:27,897 --> 00:00:29,290 LEO: Hey, Detective Kaminsky, 14 00:00:29,333 --> 00:00:31,335 cops who place innocent people behind bars 15 00:00:31,379 --> 00:00:32,771 need to face consequences. 16 00:00:32,815 --> 00:00:34,469 This young man just threatened me. 17 00:00:34,512 --> 00:00:35,861 [siren wails] 18 00:00:35,905 --> 00:00:37,254 Leonard Craddick, you are under arrest 19 00:00:37,298 --> 00:00:38,690 for the murder of Detective Joseph Kaminsky. 20 00:00:38,734 --> 00:00:42,042 Anything you say...Kaminsky's dead. 21 00:00:43,782 --> 00:00:46,046 [wind whistling, indistinct P.A. announcement] 22 00:00:56,839 --> 00:00:58,884 You gonna miss it? 23 00:00:58,928 --> 00:01:00,799 [crows cawing] 24 00:01:00,843 --> 00:01:03,063 Not even a little. 25 00:01:03,106 --> 00:01:05,326 Bus usually comes on the hour. 26 00:01:05,369 --> 00:01:06,979 You might have to wait a bit. 27 00:01:07,023 --> 00:01:08,546 My son's picking me up. 28 00:01:08,590 --> 00:01:10,418 Guard inside just texted him for me. 29 00:01:10,461 --> 00:01:12,463 Got it all planned out. 30 00:01:12,507 --> 00:01:15,597 Gonna stop at the first open pizza place we see. 31 00:01:15,640 --> 00:01:17,990 Good luck, Craddick. 32 00:01:28,131 --> 00:01:28,914 [sighs] 33 00:01:28,958 --> 00:01:30,220 CHUNK: Says here 34 00:01:30,264 --> 00:01:31,743 Kaminsky was parked across the street 35 00:01:31,787 --> 00:01:33,136 from a 24-hour bodega 36 00:01:33,180 --> 00:01:35,399 when he was shot in his car at close range. 37 00:01:35,443 --> 00:01:39,142 CCTV cam captured a suspect fleeing the scene 38 00:01:39,186 --> 00:01:41,188 who roughly matches Leo's height and weight. 39 00:01:41,231 --> 00:01:43,799 I would think a quarter of the world's population 40 00:01:43,842 --> 00:01:45,540 roughly matches Leo's height and weight. 41 00:01:45,583 --> 00:01:46,932 Oh, boy. 42 00:01:46,976 --> 00:01:48,673 Here's something. According to this, 43 00:01:48,717 --> 00:01:52,155 a palm print was recovered from the roof of the victim's car. 44 00:01:52,199 --> 00:01:54,462 They're saying it's a match to Leo's. 45 00:01:54,505 --> 00:01:56,072 Palm print. 46 00:01:56,116 --> 00:01:58,248 A conscientious grad student spends years 47 00:01:58,292 --> 00:02:01,033 working with his inmate father, pouring over court documents, 48 00:02:01,077 --> 00:02:02,948 filing motions, tracking down witnesses, 49 00:02:02,992 --> 00:02:04,646 and they finally get their day in court, 50 00:02:04,689 --> 00:02:09,041 and suddenly, murder is the only way they can get what they want. 51 00:02:10,347 --> 00:02:13,742 I don't care what they say they found on that guy's car. 52 00:02:13,785 --> 00:02:16,092 I don't buy it. 53 00:02:24,492 --> 00:02:26,363 [horn toots] 54 00:02:34,676 --> 00:02:37,157 Hey, stranger, need a lift? 55 00:02:37,200 --> 00:02:38,593 Mr. Colón. 56 00:02:38,636 --> 00:02:41,117 Mr. Craddick. 57 00:02:42,901 --> 00:02:45,904 I can't. Uh, I'm waiting for Leo. 58 00:02:45,948 --> 00:02:48,037 He should be along any minute. 59 00:02:48,080 --> 00:02:52,302 Actually, uh, Leo has been detained. 60 00:02:52,346 --> 00:02:54,435 [buzzer sounds] 61 00:02:59,831 --> 00:03:01,572 Hey, Leo. 62 00:03:01,616 --> 00:03:04,880 [sighs]Look, I'm trying every trick in the book 63 00:03:04,923 --> 00:03:07,665 to get you out of here, but you are accused of killing a cop, 64 00:03:07,709 --> 00:03:09,754 so the likelihood...I know. 65 00:03:09,798 --> 00:03:11,800 Okay. 66 00:03:11,843 --> 00:03:13,976 By the way, we spoke with your landlord. 67 00:03:14,019 --> 00:03:16,413 Told him your father had been exonerated, 68 00:03:16,457 --> 00:03:20,896 and he said he was fine with letting your dad stay there. 69 00:03:20,939 --> 00:03:23,246 Benny's picking him up at prison right now. 70 00:03:23,290 --> 00:03:24,856 Thank you. 71 00:03:24,900 --> 00:03:26,510 CHUNK: Mr. Craddick, 72 00:03:26,554 --> 00:03:27,859 my name's Chester Palmer. 73 00:03:27,903 --> 00:03:29,731 I'm an attorney in Dr. Bull's office. 74 00:03:29,774 --> 00:03:31,776 He and I will be spearheading your case. 75 00:03:31,820 --> 00:03:34,388 And what ismy case? 76 00:03:35,911 --> 00:03:40,132 On what basis am I being accused of this crime? 77 00:03:40,176 --> 00:03:43,527 What in the world did I have to gain 78 00:03:43,571 --> 00:03:47,139 by killing a police detective?BULL:Well, 79 00:03:47,183 --> 00:03:48,619 Leo, it's only the morning after. 80 00:03:48,663 --> 00:03:49,838 We don't have a lot of answers. 81 00:03:49,881 --> 00:03:52,275 Oh. I'm sorry. 82 00:03:52,319 --> 00:03:55,844 Am I being impatient with the wheels of justice? 83 00:03:55,887 --> 00:03:58,020 I certainly didn't mean to be rude. 84 00:03:58,063 --> 00:03:59,978 It's only my freedom. 85 00:04:00,022 --> 00:04:02,024 It's only my life. 86 00:04:03,765 --> 00:04:05,984 I would like to know. 87 00:04:07,464 --> 00:04:09,249 Why am I here? 88 00:04:09,292 --> 00:04:11,512 You want to know the truth? 89 00:04:11,555 --> 00:04:13,731 You look the part. 90 00:04:13,775 --> 00:04:15,472 Yeah? 91 00:04:15,516 --> 00:04:17,126 Well, so do you. 92 00:04:17,169 --> 00:04:18,954 Kind of.Yeah. Not really. 93 00:04:18,997 --> 00:04:22,174 I aged out of that angry young Black man category 94 00:04:22,218 --> 00:04:26,091 a long time ago, but you-- you fit the profile perfectly. 95 00:04:26,135 --> 00:04:28,093 Which is why the most important thing 96 00:04:28,137 --> 00:04:30,922 that we have to do right now is remind them 97 00:04:30,966 --> 00:04:32,402 that you are not that person. 98 00:04:32,446 --> 00:04:35,840 You are an educated, socially-engaged young citizen. 99 00:04:35,884 --> 00:04:38,582 And that this is an incredible miscarriage of justice. 100 00:04:38,626 --> 00:04:41,193 So we're gonna need you to take it on good faith 101 00:04:41,237 --> 00:04:45,415 that we're doing everything that we can as fast as we can. 102 00:04:47,243 --> 00:04:49,071 Don't have much choice, do I? 103 00:04:49,114 --> 00:04:50,768 BULL: Let's start at the beginning. 104 00:04:50,812 --> 00:04:52,770 They know exactly what time 105 00:04:52,814 --> 00:04:55,599 that detective was shot-- 11:19 p.m. 106 00:04:55,643 --> 00:04:59,429 So we need to know-- where were you two nights ago at 11:19? 107 00:04:59,473 --> 00:05:01,431 [sighs] 108 00:05:01,475 --> 00:05:03,999 I was at home. Asleep. 109 00:05:04,042 --> 00:05:05,305 Is there anyone who can verify that? 110 00:05:05,348 --> 00:05:07,916 Verify that I was asleep?Mm. 111 00:05:07,959 --> 00:05:10,092 No. I live alone. 112 00:05:10,135 --> 00:05:11,441 So you don't have an alibi? 113 00:05:11,485 --> 00:05:13,835 Guess not. Didn't know I'd be needing one. 114 00:05:13,878 --> 00:05:15,837 You know they found your handprint 115 00:05:15,880 --> 00:05:17,317 on Detective Kaminsky's car. 116 00:05:18,927 --> 00:05:21,103 Well... there you go. 117 00:05:21,146 --> 00:05:23,105 That's simply not possible. 118 00:05:23,148 --> 00:05:24,889 Unless the cops planted it, which I'm sure they did. 119 00:05:24,933 --> 00:05:28,110 Okay, well, we'll continue to investigate that possibility. 120 00:05:28,153 --> 00:05:29,981 We'll take nothing for granted, 121 00:05:30,025 --> 00:05:31,548 but why don't we give some thought as to 122 00:05:31,592 --> 00:05:33,507 how that print could have legitimately gotten there? 123 00:05:33,550 --> 00:05:36,553 Hey, man, I didn't even know the man had a car. 124 00:05:36,597 --> 00:05:38,816 I wouldn't know Kaminsky's car if it ran over me. 125 00:05:38,860 --> 00:05:41,950 Okay, but you were seen verbally accosting him at the courthouse. 126 00:05:41,993 --> 00:05:45,345 [sighs] He locked up an innocent man. 127 00:05:45,388 --> 00:05:47,521 He robbed me of my father for over 12 years. 128 00:05:47,564 --> 00:05:49,131 We're just trying 129 00:05:49,174 --> 00:05:50,698 to give you an idea of what you're up against here. 130 00:05:50,741 --> 00:05:52,177 But I didn't do it. 131 00:05:52,221 --> 00:05:53,788 Again, why would I do it? 132 00:05:53,831 --> 00:05:54,789 How does it help me? 133 00:05:54,832 --> 00:05:56,834 He's a cop, and you're a man 134 00:05:56,878 --> 00:05:58,488 who's shown anger towards the cops 135 00:05:58,532 --> 00:06:00,708 for reasons that make perfect sense to the two of us. 136 00:06:00,751 --> 00:06:02,057 But that anger 137 00:06:02,100 --> 00:06:03,711 in a courtroom 138 00:06:03,754 --> 00:06:07,105 is gonna play right into the district attorney's hands. 139 00:06:07,149 --> 00:06:09,194 BULL:Let's get down to it here. 140 00:06:09,238 --> 00:06:12,676 Leo, you ever attend any demonstrations, 141 00:06:12,720 --> 00:06:16,027 rallies, protests that would be considered anti-police? 142 00:06:16,071 --> 00:06:17,333 What do you think? 143 00:06:17,377 --> 00:06:19,422 You ever speak at any of these rallies? 144 00:06:19,466 --> 00:06:22,077 Lead any of these rallies?I certainly have. 145 00:06:22,120 --> 00:06:24,296 And would the D.A.'s office recognize the name 146 00:06:24,340 --> 00:06:26,951 of any of these groups that you were associated with? 147 00:06:27,735 --> 00:06:29,214 [inhales sharply] 148 00:06:29,258 --> 00:06:31,565 You ever heard of Black Lives Matter? 149 00:06:33,654 --> 00:06:35,438 Say the name. 150 00:06:35,482 --> 00:06:37,397 There is no fear in that name. 151 00:06:37,440 --> 00:06:40,269 It is a simple statement of fact. 152 00:06:40,312 --> 00:06:43,403 Black... Lives... Matter. 153 00:06:43,446 --> 00:06:45,622 No one is disagreeing with you. 154 00:06:45,666 --> 00:06:48,146 We're just trying to figure out how to defend you. 155 00:06:51,498 --> 00:06:53,543 ♪ 156 00:07:00,289 --> 00:07:01,421 Curfew's 10:00 p.m. 157 00:07:01,464 --> 00:07:02,596 Failure to make curfew, 158 00:07:02,639 --> 00:07:04,598 failure of any random drug screening, 159 00:07:04,641 --> 00:07:06,687 failure to secure employment 160 00:07:06,730 --> 00:07:09,429 and/or failure to notify of any change 161 00:07:09,472 --> 00:07:10,908 of employment or residence, 162 00:07:10,952 --> 00:07:12,823 and your parole is subject to revocation. 163 00:07:12,867 --> 00:07:15,565 Understood?Yes, ma'am, I understand. 164 00:07:15,609 --> 00:07:18,786 Officer Schiraldi, my client has a special request. 165 00:07:18,829 --> 00:07:21,484 Now, his son is currently being held at Rikers, 166 00:07:21,528 --> 00:07:24,052 and we were hoping that you would be willing 167 00:07:24,095 --> 00:07:26,184 to authorize such a visit. 168 00:07:26,228 --> 00:07:29,187 I'm sorry, but that is not possible. 169 00:07:29,231 --> 00:07:31,102 Well, you should know 170 00:07:31,146 --> 00:07:33,278 that A.D.A. Glover has filed a motion 171 00:07:33,322 --> 00:07:35,585 to vacate the conviction against my client, 172 00:07:35,629 --> 00:07:38,675 which we are very confident will be granted. 173 00:07:38,719 --> 00:07:40,895 And since my client has been barred from the courtroom 174 00:07:40,938 --> 00:07:43,375 due to COVID restrictions, we were hoping 175 00:07:43,419 --> 00:07:44,942 that you would make an exception. 176 00:07:47,467 --> 00:07:48,946 I understand you have a job to do, 177 00:07:48,990 --> 00:07:53,385 but I have been away from my son for over 12 years, 178 00:07:53,429 --> 00:07:55,910 and now he needs me. 179 00:07:56,911 --> 00:07:59,435 I understand. 180 00:07:59,479 --> 00:08:01,655 But in my experience, 181 00:08:01,698 --> 00:08:06,181 allowing felons to visit prisons is just asking for trouble. 182 00:08:06,224 --> 00:08:07,791 Now, once you're exonerated, 183 00:08:07,835 --> 00:08:09,924 you are free to do what you want. 184 00:08:09,967 --> 00:08:13,057 But in the meantime, I'm sorry, the answer is still no. 185 00:08:13,101 --> 00:08:14,145 Urine sample. 186 00:08:14,189 --> 00:08:15,886 I need to walk him 187 00:08:15,930 --> 00:08:17,018 down to the bathroom. 188 00:08:17,061 --> 00:08:18,323 You mind showing us where it is? 189 00:08:18,367 --> 00:08:21,065 JUDGE: Mr. Palmer, you have 190 00:08:21,109 --> 00:08:23,894 a pretrial motion you'd like the court to hear 191 00:08:23,938 --> 00:08:26,984 with regard to some of the prosecution's evidence? 192 00:08:27,028 --> 00:08:28,377 Yes, Your Honor. 193 00:08:28,420 --> 00:08:30,510 I'm requesting permission to exclude any mention 194 00:08:30,553 --> 00:08:33,556 of my client's involvement with Black Lives Matter 195 00:08:33,600 --> 00:08:36,559 or photographic evidence of affiliation with same. 196 00:08:36,603 --> 00:08:38,082 With the court's permission, 197 00:08:38,126 --> 00:08:41,564 we'd like to direct your attention to the monitors 198 00:08:41,608 --> 00:08:43,479 that are at the front of the courtroom. 199 00:08:45,786 --> 00:08:47,744 Now, I would like to make note 200 00:08:47,788 --> 00:08:51,052 that investigations after the fact proved 201 00:08:51,095 --> 00:08:53,707 that the police car in this photo was set on fire 202 00:08:53,750 --> 00:08:55,709 by people who are not associated with my client 203 00:08:55,752 --> 00:08:58,276 or the Black Lives Matter movement. 204 00:08:58,320 --> 00:09:00,191 Nonetheless, the prosecution would like 205 00:09:00,235 --> 00:09:02,280 to present this photo solely with the purpose 206 00:09:02,324 --> 00:09:04,413 of inflaming the jury. 207 00:09:04,456 --> 00:09:06,589 Now, given the intense media coverage 208 00:09:06,633 --> 00:09:08,112 of this trial 209 00:09:08,156 --> 00:09:11,507 and the current climate with regards to law enforcement, 210 00:09:11,551 --> 00:09:13,640 inclusion of photos like these 211 00:09:13,683 --> 00:09:16,164 would only serve to paint a misleading 212 00:09:16,207 --> 00:09:18,732 and unduly prejudicial portrait of my client. 213 00:09:18,775 --> 00:09:20,777 I don't think it's prejudicial at all. 214 00:09:20,821 --> 00:09:24,172 The defendant has a lengthy and well-documented history 215 00:09:24,215 --> 00:09:25,608 of anti-police sentiment 216 00:09:25,652 --> 00:09:27,871 masquerading as protected speech. 217 00:09:27,915 --> 00:09:30,134 CHUNK: Your Honor, the A.D.A. is clearly 218 00:09:30,178 --> 00:09:31,745 mistaken in this regard. 219 00:09:31,788 --> 00:09:34,312 Black Lives Matter is not opposed to the police. 220 00:09:34,356 --> 00:09:38,969 Black Lives Matter is opposed to police killing Black people. 221 00:09:39,013 --> 00:09:41,624 And the prosecution is trying to paint this organization 222 00:09:41,668 --> 00:09:43,670 and, by extension, my client, 223 00:09:43,713 --> 00:09:47,325 as being extremist and anti-law enforcement. 224 00:09:47,369 --> 00:09:48,979 All for the crime 225 00:09:49,023 --> 00:09:53,114 of simply affirming the value of Black life. 226 00:09:55,116 --> 00:09:57,248 All right, Mr. Palmer. 227 00:09:57,292 --> 00:10:01,688 Your impassioned entreaty has not fallen on deaf ears. 228 00:10:01,731 --> 00:10:03,298 I agree. 229 00:10:03,341 --> 00:10:07,998 I find that the mention of Mr. Craddick's involvement 230 00:10:08,042 --> 00:10:11,001 in Black Lives Matter is irrelevant 231 00:10:11,045 --> 00:10:12,873 and unduly prejudicial, 232 00:10:12,916 --> 00:10:14,831 and I'm granting your motion. 233 00:10:14,875 --> 00:10:16,877 There are to be no references to Black Lives Matter 234 00:10:16,920 --> 00:10:20,228 or the defendant's association therewith. 235 00:10:20,271 --> 00:10:21,533 Is that clear? 236 00:10:21,577 --> 00:10:23,405 Yes, Your Honor. 237 00:10:24,711 --> 00:10:27,061 That was too easy. Why don't I trust it? 238 00:10:27,104 --> 00:10:29,541 Because you're Jason Bull, super smart cynic. 239 00:10:29,585 --> 00:10:31,065 You've been talking to my much better half. 240 00:10:31,108 --> 00:10:32,414 CHUNK: Your Honor, we have 241 00:10:32,457 --> 00:10:34,590 a second motion for the court's consideration. 242 00:10:34,634 --> 00:10:36,113 I ask that we exclude 243 00:10:36,157 --> 00:10:38,725 any reference to the defendant's prior conviction 244 00:10:38,768 --> 00:10:40,378 for criminal mischief. 245 00:10:40,422 --> 00:10:41,858 My client was one 246 00:10:41,902 --> 00:10:43,730 of over 200 people arrested 247 00:10:43,773 --> 00:10:46,776 after a Black Lives Matter demonstration became overrun 248 00:10:46,820 --> 00:10:49,126 with people not associated with his group, 249 00:10:49,170 --> 00:10:51,302 but who were there solely for purpose 250 00:10:51,346 --> 00:10:53,217 of looting and vandalizing. 251 00:10:53,261 --> 00:10:56,003 He couldn't afford counsel, he spent a night in jail. 252 00:10:56,046 --> 00:10:58,832 For these spurious charges to be used against him-- 253 00:10:58,875 --> 00:11:02,270 it seems unjust and unfair, Your Honor. 254 00:11:02,313 --> 00:11:05,055 Ms. Olson, care to respond? 255 00:11:05,099 --> 00:11:08,450 Your Honor, as Mr. Palmer is well aware, 256 00:11:08,493 --> 00:11:12,062 if his client chooses to take the stand in his own defense, 257 00:11:12,106 --> 00:11:14,586 he can be cross-examined about prior crimes 258 00:11:14,630 --> 00:11:16,066 that bear on his credibility. 259 00:11:16,110 --> 00:11:19,069 To arbitrarily deny me the opportunity 260 00:11:19,113 --> 00:11:22,246 to share this conviction with the jury seems... 261 00:11:22,290 --> 00:11:23,552 How did you put it? 262 00:11:23,595 --> 00:11:25,380 Unjust and unfair? 263 00:11:25,423 --> 00:11:26,903 And it is. 264 00:11:26,947 --> 00:11:28,905 To the state, which believes Mr. Craddick is guilty 265 00:11:28,949 --> 00:11:31,603 of murdering a police officer in cold blood. 266 00:11:31,647 --> 00:11:33,997 And I would also point out to the court, 267 00:11:34,041 --> 00:11:36,608 violence against police officers seems to be 268 00:11:36,652 --> 00:11:39,437 a common feature of these rallies. 269 00:11:39,481 --> 00:11:41,831 And whether that violence is instigated 270 00:11:41,875 --> 00:11:43,746 by the sponsoring organization 271 00:11:43,790 --> 00:11:46,270 or outsiders who seize the opportunity 272 00:11:46,314 --> 00:11:48,751 to indulge in mayhem is beside the point. 273 00:11:48,795 --> 00:11:51,014 The point-- the only point-- 274 00:11:51,058 --> 00:11:53,451 is that Mr. Craddick has been arrested and convicted 275 00:11:53,495 --> 00:11:55,062 in the past. 276 00:11:55,105 --> 00:11:57,194 And that is something that the jury has a right to know. 277 00:11:57,238 --> 00:11:58,761 Told ya. 278 00:11:58,805 --> 00:12:00,981 The Lord giveth and the Lord taketh way. 279 00:12:01,024 --> 00:12:04,332 Come on, no one's taken away anything yet. 280 00:12:05,376 --> 00:12:09,293 While I still believe Mr. Craddick's association 281 00:12:09,337 --> 00:12:12,993 with Black Lives Matter should remain out of bounds, 282 00:12:13,036 --> 00:12:15,560 if he does choose to take the stand 283 00:12:15,604 --> 00:12:16,910 in his own defense 284 00:12:16,953 --> 00:12:20,478 and personally asserts his innocence, 285 00:12:20,522 --> 00:12:22,959 I believe... 286 00:12:23,003 --> 00:12:25,832 his criminal history should be admissible 287 00:12:25,875 --> 00:12:27,616 to impeach his credibility. 288 00:12:27,659 --> 00:12:29,487 Told ya. 289 00:12:29,531 --> 00:12:31,011 CHUNK: But, Your Honor, 290 00:12:31,054 --> 00:12:33,448 you're essentially taking away his ability to testify 291 00:12:33,491 --> 00:12:34,971 on his own behalf. 292 00:12:35,015 --> 00:12:37,713 I've issued my ruling, Mr. Palmer. 293 00:12:37,757 --> 00:12:39,889 If Mr. Craddick testifies, 294 00:12:39,933 --> 00:12:42,718 the arrest is admissible. 295 00:12:43,980 --> 00:12:45,721 [sighs] 296 00:12:48,158 --> 00:12:49,986 Just got off the phone with Bull. 297 00:12:50,030 --> 00:12:51,771 He was curious what kind of progress 298 00:12:51,814 --> 00:12:53,947 you were making.Actually, I was just staring 299 00:12:53,990 --> 00:12:56,036 at Detective Kaminsky's phone bill as we speak. 300 00:12:56,079 --> 00:12:58,516 For what it's worth, in the weeks leading up to his murder, 301 00:12:58,560 --> 00:12:59,953 he received dozens of calls 302 00:12:59,996 --> 00:13:01,781 from a host of different burner phones. 303 00:13:01,824 --> 00:13:03,913 Well, that sounds promising. 304 00:13:03,957 --> 00:13:06,524 Maybe. Danny told me when she was in the NYPD 305 00:13:06,568 --> 00:13:07,830 they'd give out burner phones 306 00:13:07,874 --> 00:13:09,179 to all the confidential informants. 307 00:13:09,223 --> 00:13:11,051 Gave them out like Handi Wipes, she said. 308 00:13:11,094 --> 00:13:13,357 Veteran cop like Kaminsky, he probably had dozens 309 00:13:13,401 --> 00:13:15,011 of confidential informants. 310 00:13:15,055 --> 00:13:16,665 The thing is, I don't know 311 00:13:16,708 --> 00:13:18,362 who's on the other end of these calls. 312 00:13:18,406 --> 00:13:21,626 I can't see any of the texts. I can't hear any of the calls. 313 00:13:21,670 --> 00:13:23,846 I can't tell any of that from a bill. 314 00:13:23,890 --> 00:13:25,674 Well, it's a start. My guess is 315 00:13:25,717 --> 00:13:27,850 tomorrow we will file a motion for discovery 316 00:13:27,894 --> 00:13:29,721 so that we can get access to the physical phone. 317 00:13:29,765 --> 00:13:31,462 That way, we can read any texts, 318 00:13:31,506 --> 00:13:32,812 listen to any voice mails. 319 00:13:32,855 --> 00:13:34,204 And in the meantime, 320 00:13:34,248 --> 00:13:36,206 Danny'll keep trying to track these burners, 321 00:13:36,250 --> 00:13:38,034 see if we can find out who he gave them to. 322 00:13:38,078 --> 00:13:40,732 There's got to be a record of it somewhere. 323 00:13:40,776 --> 00:13:42,212 [horn honks in distance] 324 00:13:42,256 --> 00:13:44,345 You want to talk juries?BULL: Sure. 325 00:13:44,388 --> 00:13:47,522 I think this morning's gonna be all about belief perseverance. 326 00:13:47,565 --> 00:13:50,003 Belief perseverance? 327 00:13:50,046 --> 00:13:52,222 People who insist on holding on to something they believe in 328 00:13:52,266 --> 00:13:53,876 even in the face of new information 329 00:13:53,920 --> 00:13:56,444 that contradicts that belief. 330 00:13:56,487 --> 00:13:58,576 Where I come from, people just call that "stubborn." 331 00:13:58,620 --> 00:14:00,491 "Stubborn" works, too. 332 00:14:00,535 --> 00:14:05,279 We definitely want to eliminate or least minimize the stubborn. 333 00:14:06,323 --> 00:14:08,369 The job is gonna be to convince our jury 334 00:14:08,412 --> 00:14:11,459 that the police investigation was compromised from the start. 335 00:14:11,502 --> 00:14:13,330 They zeroed right in on Leo. 336 00:14:13,374 --> 00:14:16,029 They barely investigated, 'cause they had their theory. 337 00:14:16,072 --> 00:14:17,769 And they held on to that theory 338 00:14:17,813 --> 00:14:20,990 to the exclusion of any other information or possibilities. 339 00:14:21,034 --> 00:14:22,818 Now, that's the narrative. 340 00:14:24,776 --> 00:14:26,213 For that argument to stick, 341 00:14:26,256 --> 00:14:28,911 we need jurors whose first impressions are malleable 342 00:14:28,955 --> 00:14:31,261 to new information, new evidence. 343 00:14:33,089 --> 00:14:35,309 We need people who aren't stubborn. 344 00:14:37,093 --> 00:14:39,356 Any hopeless romantics here today? 345 00:14:39,400 --> 00:14:40,880 Anyone here believe 346 00:14:40,923 --> 00:14:43,056 in love at first sight? 347 00:14:43,099 --> 00:14:44,318 Oh. 348 00:14:44,361 --> 00:14:45,623 You, ma'am. 349 00:14:45,667 --> 00:14:47,451 Any reason in particular 350 00:14:47,495 --> 00:14:50,280 you don't believe people can fall in love at first sight? 351 00:14:50,324 --> 00:14:54,241 My first date with my now husband was a disaster. 352 00:14:54,284 --> 00:14:56,330 First, he went to the wrong restaurant, 353 00:14:56,373 --> 00:14:58,941 so he was 20 minutes late. 354 00:14:58,985 --> 00:15:00,812 And when he finally got there, he was so nervous, 355 00:15:00,856 --> 00:15:03,554 he dumped a glass of wine on my favorite blouse. 356 00:15:03,598 --> 00:15:04,947 And then, to top it off, 357 00:15:04,991 --> 00:15:07,645 he left his wallet in the cab, 358 00:15:07,689 --> 00:15:09,560 so I had to pay for dinner.Oh. 359 00:15:09,604 --> 00:15:10,866 [chuckles] 360 00:15:10,910 --> 00:15:13,173 But he made me laugh, 361 00:15:13,216 --> 00:15:15,175 so I gave him another chance. 362 00:15:15,218 --> 00:15:16,959 A few more chances, actually. 363 00:15:17,003 --> 00:15:19,483 And all that's to say is that, 364 00:15:19,527 --> 00:15:21,268 even when you think you know, 365 00:15:21,311 --> 00:15:22,573 you don't know. 366 00:15:22,617 --> 00:15:25,489 Lady doesn't go all in on first impressions. 367 00:15:25,533 --> 00:15:26,534 We like it. 368 00:15:26,577 --> 00:15:27,535 Or don't we? 369 00:15:27,578 --> 00:15:29,145 No, I think we do. 370 00:15:29,189 --> 00:15:31,147 She reads websites from all sides of the political spectrum, 371 00:15:31,191 --> 00:15:33,497 is registered as an independent 372 00:15:33,541 --> 00:15:35,021 and she and her husband 373 00:15:35,064 --> 00:15:38,198 just celebrated their 35th anniversary. 374 00:15:38,241 --> 00:15:40,722 From where I'm sitting, she's our dream juror. 375 00:15:41,723 --> 00:15:44,030 CHUNK: Juror number 19. 376 00:15:44,073 --> 00:15:46,162 Love at first sight: you in, you out? 377 00:15:46,206 --> 00:15:48,991 Well, I'm not saying I don't believe in it. 378 00:15:49,035 --> 00:15:50,688 I mean, I like the idea of it. 379 00:15:50,732 --> 00:15:52,995 Who wouldn't like to live in a world where you could be sure 380 00:15:53,039 --> 00:15:54,518 just by looking at someone? 381 00:15:54,562 --> 00:15:55,867 But... 382 00:15:55,911 --> 00:15:58,261 it's like she just said, you never know. 383 00:15:58,305 --> 00:16:00,872 Sounds like someone willing to hear both sides of an argument. 384 00:16:00,916 --> 00:16:02,352 What are we looking at here, Marissa? 385 00:16:02,396 --> 00:16:03,571 Willard Goss. 386 00:16:03,614 --> 00:16:05,616 24 years old. Family owns Goss Uniforms, 387 00:16:05,660 --> 00:16:09,011 an apparel company that provides clothing and accessories to... 388 00:16:09,055 --> 00:16:11,709 among other organizations, 389 00:16:11,753 --> 00:16:13,015 the NYPD. 390 00:16:13,059 --> 00:16:15,061 Well, that's that, isn't it? 391 00:16:15,844 --> 00:16:17,715 And how about you, miss? 392 00:16:17,759 --> 00:16:19,717 Love at first sight? 393 00:16:19,761 --> 00:16:21,850 I don't think so. 394 00:16:21,893 --> 00:16:23,417 Care to explain? 395 00:16:23,460 --> 00:16:24,809 Because it's a myth, 396 00:16:24,853 --> 00:16:26,550 a fairy tale. 397 00:16:26,594 --> 00:16:27,899 The advertising agencies, 398 00:16:27,943 --> 00:16:30,250 the greeting card companies, Hollywood-- 399 00:16:30,293 --> 00:16:33,557 it's a tale they tell to separate you from your money. 400 00:16:34,384 --> 00:16:36,952 Sounds like someone who doesn't budge once her mind is made up. 401 00:16:36,996 --> 00:16:38,258 You don't know the half of it. 402 00:16:38,301 --> 00:16:40,521 Her social media is scorched earth. 403 00:16:40,564 --> 00:16:41,957 Movies, music, food-- 404 00:16:42,001 --> 00:16:44,220 she's posting 500 words on why you're wrong. 405 00:16:44,264 --> 00:16:46,222 If this woman doesn't like something about Leo, 406 00:16:46,266 --> 00:16:48,050 she'll be a nightmare on the jury. 407 00:16:48,094 --> 00:16:49,399 CHUNK: We'd like to thank 408 00:16:49,443 --> 00:16:51,488 and excuse juror number 30, Your Honor. 409 00:16:51,532 --> 00:16:53,012 OLSON: Your Honor, 410 00:16:53,055 --> 00:16:54,491 before you dismiss this juror, 411 00:16:54,535 --> 00:16:57,059 may we be heard in chambers? 412 00:16:57,103 --> 00:16:59,496 Your Honor, I count six total jurors 413 00:16:59,540 --> 00:17:01,368 eliminated by the defense. 414 00:17:01,411 --> 00:17:02,934 All six are white. 415 00:17:02,978 --> 00:17:04,545 As I'm sure you're aware, 416 00:17:04,588 --> 00:17:07,983 Batson v. Kentuckyexplicitly prohibits jury eliminations 417 00:17:08,027 --> 00:17:09,593 based on race. 418 00:17:09,637 --> 00:17:12,422 CHUNK:Your Honor, as the A.D.A. is well aware, 419 00:17:12,466 --> 00:17:16,252 the Batsonruling was specifically intended to address 420 00:17:16,296 --> 00:17:19,603 the exclusion of Black people from serving as jurors. 421 00:17:19,647 --> 00:17:23,216 Yes. When it was originally issued, that was the case. 422 00:17:23,259 --> 00:17:26,219 But the Supreme Court has since expanded its ruling on Batson 423 00:17:26,262 --> 00:17:28,960 to ensure nocitizen is disqualified 424 00:17:29,004 --> 00:17:30,962 from jury service based on race. 425 00:17:31,006 --> 00:17:32,877 Equal protection, Your Honor. 426 00:17:32,921 --> 00:17:35,097 BULL: That's all well and good, but, 427 00:17:35,141 --> 00:17:37,752 Your Honor, none of these strikes were discriminatory. 428 00:17:37,795 --> 00:17:41,321 Each and every choice was based on scientific analysis 429 00:17:41,364 --> 00:17:43,149 and had nothing whatsoever 430 00:17:43,192 --> 00:17:44,585 to do with race.OLSON: Really? 431 00:17:44,628 --> 00:17:47,457 Hmm. And we're just supposed to accept that 432 00:17:47,501 --> 00:17:48,893 because you assert it? 433 00:17:48,937 --> 00:17:50,765 With all due respect, Dr. Bull, 434 00:17:50,808 --> 00:17:52,332 it may or may not be true. 435 00:17:52,375 --> 00:17:55,161 But what is true, what is unassailable, 436 00:17:55,204 --> 00:17:56,901 is that all of your jury strikes 437 00:17:56,945 --> 00:17:59,208 were exercised against Caucasians. 438 00:17:59,252 --> 00:18:00,992 ARGAWAL: I don't doubt your methods, Dr. Bull, 439 00:18:01,036 --> 00:18:01,993 but it's hard to disagree 440 00:18:02,037 --> 00:18:04,213 with A.D.A. Olson's point. 441 00:18:04,257 --> 00:18:05,780 Out of an abundance of caution, 442 00:18:05,823 --> 00:18:08,261 I'm not going to allow you to strike juror number 30. 443 00:18:08,304 --> 00:18:09,218 Your Honor... 444 00:18:09,262 --> 00:18:11,264 She stays, Mr. Palmer. 445 00:18:18,227 --> 00:18:19,750 OLSON: Mrs. Kaminsky, 446 00:18:19,794 --> 00:18:22,449 did your late husband ever mention 447 00:18:22,492 --> 00:18:23,928 Leo Craddick to you? 448 00:18:23,972 --> 00:18:26,061 Not by name. 449 00:18:26,105 --> 00:18:28,324 Joe never talked about his cases. 450 00:18:29,151 --> 00:18:34,113 So, I-I'm confused when you say "not by name." 451 00:18:34,156 --> 00:18:35,940 Have you ever met Leo Craddick? 452 00:18:35,984 --> 00:18:37,638 Yes, I have. 453 00:18:37,681 --> 00:18:40,728 OLSON:And can you tell us when and where you met the defendant? 454 00:18:40,771 --> 00:18:43,731 It was during the trial involving the father. 455 00:18:43,774 --> 00:18:45,428 Joe went to testify and told me 456 00:18:45,472 --> 00:18:48,866 he ran into the man's son in the hall. 457 00:18:48,910 --> 00:18:50,868 He didn't say so, but... 458 00:18:50,912 --> 00:18:52,435 you could tell it rattled him. 459 00:18:52,479 --> 00:18:55,134 Otherwise, he never would have mentioned it.Hmm. 460 00:18:55,177 --> 00:18:56,918 EMILY:Anyway, since he was in court 461 00:18:56,961 --> 00:18:59,312 that day, he left me the car. 462 00:18:59,355 --> 00:19:00,922 He was going to take the train home 463 00:19:00,965 --> 00:19:02,271 after he was done at the station house, 464 00:19:02,315 --> 00:19:04,404 but I offered to pick him up. 465 00:19:06,057 --> 00:19:08,103 And when I got there, 466 00:19:08,147 --> 00:19:09,974 I went to park in Joe's spot. 467 00:19:10,018 --> 00:19:12,803 And as soon as I did, a man walked over. 468 00:19:12,847 --> 00:19:14,979 OLSON: And do you see 469 00:19:15,023 --> 00:19:18,069 that man in the courtroom? 470 00:19:18,853 --> 00:19:20,985 I do. 471 00:19:21,029 --> 00:19:22,465 It's him. 472 00:19:22,509 --> 00:19:24,902 OLSON:And what happened when he walked over? 473 00:19:24,946 --> 00:19:28,210 He asked me if I knew that this was Detective Kaminsky's spot. 474 00:19:28,254 --> 00:19:29,516 And what did you say? 475 00:19:29,559 --> 00:19:30,995 I said I did. 476 00:19:31,039 --> 00:19:32,432 I mean, there was a sign. 477 00:19:32,475 --> 00:19:35,826 So, did that seem like a strange question to you? 478 00:19:35,870 --> 00:19:38,699 Objection. Counsel is leading the witness. 479 00:19:38,742 --> 00:19:39,787 Objection sustained. 480 00:19:39,830 --> 00:19:41,049 Rephrase the question, please. 481 00:19:41,832 --> 00:19:43,486 Can you describe 482 00:19:43,530 --> 00:19:45,401 what you did when the defendant asked 483 00:19:45,445 --> 00:19:47,751 if the spot belonged to Detective Kaminsky? 484 00:19:47,795 --> 00:19:50,189 I told him it did. 485 00:19:50,972 --> 00:19:53,279 And then I instantly regretted it. 486 00:19:53,322 --> 00:19:54,889 Why? 487 00:19:54,932 --> 00:19:56,369 I don't know. 488 00:19:56,412 --> 00:19:58,675 There was something desperate about him. 489 00:19:58,719 --> 00:20:00,068 About the question. 490 00:20:00,111 --> 00:20:02,026 He said he had gone into the station house 491 00:20:02,070 --> 00:20:04,638 and asked to see Joe, 492 00:20:04,681 --> 00:20:07,467 but they wouldn't even tell him if he was working or not. 493 00:20:07,510 --> 00:20:09,773 Said he had to call and make an appointment. 494 00:20:09,817 --> 00:20:11,340 And what did you say? 495 00:20:11,384 --> 00:20:16,258 I lied and told him I was sure Joe wasn't working. 496 00:20:16,302 --> 00:20:17,825 Otherwise he never would have told me 497 00:20:17,868 --> 00:20:19,870 it was okay to use his spot. 498 00:20:19,914 --> 00:20:21,481 And then what happened? 499 00:20:21,524 --> 00:20:23,265 And then I went into the station house 500 00:20:23,309 --> 00:20:25,572 like I worked there, too. 501 00:20:26,703 --> 00:20:28,183 As soon as I got in the door, 502 00:20:28,227 --> 00:20:30,620 I mentioned it to the watch commander, 503 00:20:30,664 --> 00:20:32,970 and they sent somebody out to take a look. 504 00:20:33,014 --> 00:20:34,581 But... 505 00:20:34,624 --> 00:20:36,060 by then, he was gone. 506 00:20:36,104 --> 00:20:38,149 Okay, so let's just review. 507 00:20:38,193 --> 00:20:40,021 Your husband had an encounter 508 00:20:40,064 --> 00:20:42,023 with Leo Craddick in the courthouse corridor...CHUNK: Objection. 509 00:20:42,066 --> 00:20:43,633 Counsel's assuming facts that are not in evidence....earlier that day. 510 00:20:43,677 --> 00:20:45,069 And then you encountered him 511 00:20:45,113 --> 00:20:46,810 later that night, skulking around 512 00:20:46,854 --> 00:20:48,116 the station house...Your Honor. 513 00:20:48,159 --> 00:20:49,552 Objection sustained....after he was told 514 00:20:49,596 --> 00:20:50,901 he needed to have an appointment.The jury will... 515 00:20:50,945 --> 00:20:52,163 In your opinion...Ms. Olson... 516 00:20:52,207 --> 00:20:53,556 ...was he lying in wait?I'm ordering you 517 00:20:53,600 --> 00:20:55,515 to stop questioning the witness!Or perhaps planning 518 00:20:55,558 --> 00:20:57,299 to shoot your husband that night?Counsel is ignoring 519 00:20:57,343 --> 00:20:59,258 the order from the bench!Ms. Olson, that's enough! 520 00:21:04,480 --> 00:21:09,137 The jury will disregard the A.D.A.'s... outbursts. 521 00:21:09,180 --> 00:21:10,747 Like hell they will. 522 00:21:10,791 --> 00:21:12,271 ARGAWAL: And you, my dear, 523 00:21:12,314 --> 00:21:13,533 are within a hair's breadth 524 00:21:13,576 --> 00:21:15,752 of being found in contempt of court. 525 00:21:15,796 --> 00:21:17,406 Am I being clear? 526 00:21:17,450 --> 00:21:19,060 Very. 527 00:21:19,103 --> 00:21:20,191 LEO: You were there. 528 00:21:20,235 --> 00:21:22,019 I called him out at the courthouse, 529 00:21:22,063 --> 00:21:24,108 told him there was gonna be a reckoning. 530 00:21:24,152 --> 00:21:25,719 He even said, "Are you threatening me?" 531 00:21:25,762 --> 00:21:27,111 I remember it well. 532 00:21:27,155 --> 00:21:29,157 Now, get to the part where you're stalking him 533 00:21:29,200 --> 00:21:30,419 at the precinct? 534 00:21:30,463 --> 00:21:32,334 I wasn't stalking him at the precinct. 535 00:21:32,378 --> 00:21:34,989 I wasn't stalking him anywhere. 536 00:21:35,032 --> 00:21:36,469 [sighs] 537 00:21:36,512 --> 00:21:39,210 I realized as soon as I saw the look on your face 538 00:21:39,254 --> 00:21:42,779 that I should never have confronted Kaminsky in that way. 539 00:21:42,823 --> 00:21:45,782 That that was no way to get my father out of jail. 540 00:21:45,826 --> 00:21:47,828 So, again, 541 00:21:47,871 --> 00:21:50,744 what were you doing at the precinct that night? 542 00:21:51,745 --> 00:21:53,834 [sighs] 543 00:21:53,877 --> 00:21:56,271 I went there to apologize. 544 00:21:57,620 --> 00:21:59,535 I went there 545 00:21:59,579 --> 00:22:02,712 to try and repair whatever damage I might have done. 546 00:22:02,756 --> 00:22:04,279 But like his wife said, 547 00:22:04,323 --> 00:22:06,368 they wouldn't even tell me if he was there. 548 00:22:06,412 --> 00:22:08,283 So I thought I'd look in the parking lot. 549 00:22:08,327 --> 00:22:10,459 And suddenly, a car pulled into his spot. 550 00:22:10,503 --> 00:22:13,157 I had no idea she was his wife. 551 00:22:13,201 --> 00:22:15,159 I figured she was just another cop 552 00:22:15,203 --> 00:22:16,813 whose space was just further away. 553 00:22:16,857 --> 00:22:19,294 So when she told me that he wasn't working that night, 554 00:22:19,338 --> 00:22:21,514 I took her word for it and went home. 555 00:22:22,384 --> 00:22:24,299 Oh, see, that-that... that's a great answer. 556 00:22:24,343 --> 00:22:26,432 I love that answer. I want to put you on the stand 557 00:22:26,475 --> 00:22:28,521 so you can tell that to the jury. 558 00:22:28,564 --> 00:22:30,653 [chuckling]: Except you can't.Excuse me? 559 00:22:30,697 --> 00:22:32,394 She just set a trap for you, that A.D.A. 560 00:22:32,438 --> 00:22:35,528 She's tough. She's ferocious. 561 00:22:35,571 --> 00:22:37,660 There's nothing she wants more 562 00:22:37,704 --> 00:22:39,401 than for you to put him on the stand 563 00:22:39,445 --> 00:22:40,881 so he can declare his innocence. 564 00:22:40,924 --> 00:22:43,623 And then, she will say, "While I have you up here, 565 00:22:43,666 --> 00:22:45,320 "isn't it true that you are a member 566 00:22:45,364 --> 00:22:46,887 "of the Black Lives Matter movement? 567 00:22:46,930 --> 00:22:50,630 "And isn't it also true that, in connection with a protest 568 00:22:50,673 --> 00:22:53,328 that was staged 14 months ago, you were arrested?" 569 00:22:53,372 --> 00:22:55,852 So, what do we do? 570 00:22:55,896 --> 00:22:57,637 [sighs] 571 00:22:57,680 --> 00:23:00,074 Quite honestly, I don't know. 572 00:23:00,814 --> 00:23:02,032 I think I do. 573 00:23:02,076 --> 00:23:03,338 CHUNK: So let me make sure 574 00:23:03,382 --> 00:23:04,861 that I understand what transpired 575 00:23:04,905 --> 00:23:06,297 that night in the parking lot. 576 00:23:06,341 --> 00:23:07,690 You pulled into your husband's spot, 577 00:23:07,734 --> 00:23:09,779 and then Mr. Craddick approached you. 578 00:23:09,823 --> 00:23:11,041 Yes. 579 00:23:11,085 --> 00:23:13,696 And did he touch your car? 580 00:23:13,740 --> 00:23:15,611 What do you mean? 581 00:23:15,655 --> 00:23:18,527 CHUNK: Well, one of the key pieces of evidence that 582 00:23:18,571 --> 00:23:20,442 the prosecution keeps telling us about 583 00:23:20,486 --> 00:23:24,228 is this palm print on Detective Kaminsky's car. 584 00:23:24,272 --> 00:23:26,796 The same car that you were driving that night. 585 00:23:26,840 --> 00:23:28,450 Okay. 586 00:23:28,494 --> 00:23:30,452 CHUNK: So I'm asking, in your back and forth 587 00:23:30,496 --> 00:23:32,889 with Mr. Craddick, did he have occasion 588 00:23:32,933 --> 00:23:34,717 to put his hand on your car? 589 00:23:34,761 --> 00:23:38,242 Maybe his palm on the driver's side of the roof? 590 00:23:38,286 --> 00:23:39,722 Not that I recall. 591 00:23:39,766 --> 00:23:42,464 Do you recall testifying not 20 minutes ago 592 00:23:42,508 --> 00:23:44,945 that at a point, you left your car, 593 00:23:44,988 --> 00:23:47,556 and you went into the station house?Yes. 594 00:23:47,600 --> 00:23:49,906 And you were so concerned about Mr. Craddick being out there 595 00:23:49,950 --> 00:23:52,518 that, well, you told the watch commander about it. 596 00:23:52,561 --> 00:23:53,867 Yes. 597 00:23:53,910 --> 00:23:55,521 Well, isn't it possible that, during that time, 598 00:23:55,564 --> 00:23:58,088 that Leo inadvertently left his palm print 599 00:23:58,132 --> 00:24:00,569 on the driver's side roof of the vehicle 600 00:24:00,613 --> 00:24:02,702 where the police later discovered it? 601 00:24:03,616 --> 00:24:05,095 I don't know. I didn't see it. 602 00:24:05,139 --> 00:24:07,446 But isn't it possible? 603 00:24:07,489 --> 00:24:08,969 Objection! Asked and answered. 604 00:24:09,012 --> 00:24:11,537 Overruled. The witness will answer the question. 605 00:24:12,929 --> 00:24:15,497 I suppose it's possible. 606 00:24:15,541 --> 00:24:17,586 CHUNK: Are you aware 607 00:24:17,630 --> 00:24:20,937 that a palm imprint, like the one that my client left, 608 00:24:20,981 --> 00:24:24,245 can last for a day, a week, 609 00:24:24,288 --> 00:24:25,551 even years?Objection! 610 00:24:25,594 --> 00:24:27,117 The defense is testifying! 611 00:24:27,161 --> 00:24:30,512 Sustained. The jury will disregard that last statement. 612 00:24:30,556 --> 00:24:32,296 No further questions, Your Honor. 613 00:24:32,340 --> 00:24:34,516 MARISSA: Wow. That was pretty impressive. 614 00:24:34,560 --> 00:24:37,084 Just goes to show you, when life hands you lemons... 615 00:24:37,127 --> 00:24:38,868 You want to make sure there's someone on your team 616 00:24:38,912 --> 00:24:40,696 with lots of tequila and salt. 617 00:24:47,007 --> 00:24:49,792 Answers. We got answers. 618 00:24:49,836 --> 00:24:51,141 Fire when ready. 619 00:24:51,185 --> 00:24:53,404 Okay, well, it turns out all of the owners 620 00:24:53,448 --> 00:24:55,102 of all of the burner phones that Kaminsky gave out 621 00:24:55,145 --> 00:24:57,496 to his confidential informants are either in jail, 622 00:24:57,539 --> 00:24:59,236 alibied out or dead. 623 00:24:59,280 --> 00:25:00,368 How convenient. 624 00:25:00,411 --> 00:25:02,326 All of them... 625 00:25:02,370 --> 00:25:04,546 except for one. 626 00:25:04,590 --> 00:25:06,069 Who, of course, is the person 627 00:25:06,113 --> 00:25:08,637 who texted Kaminsky four times the night of his death. 628 00:25:08,681 --> 00:25:10,334 And that phone would belong to? 629 00:25:10,378 --> 00:25:11,901 I have no idea. 630 00:25:11,945 --> 00:25:13,990 Kaminsky kept records of the others, 631 00:25:14,034 --> 00:25:16,123 but this one's kind of a ghost. 632 00:25:16,166 --> 00:25:17,994 Never officially assigned to anyone. 633 00:25:18,038 --> 00:25:20,301 May not even be one of the ones he gave out. 634 00:25:20,344 --> 00:25:21,563 I mean, 635 00:25:21,607 --> 00:25:23,043 who says every call he gets 636 00:25:23,086 --> 00:25:25,262 from a burner phone has to be from an informant? 637 00:25:25,306 --> 00:25:26,786 Good point. 638 00:25:26,829 --> 00:25:30,093 Can you run this one last number again? 639 00:25:30,137 --> 00:25:31,573 I don't even know if it's possible, 640 00:25:31,617 --> 00:25:33,227 but can you see what the point of purchase was? 641 00:25:33,270 --> 00:25:35,359 Where whoever owns this thing might have gotten it from? 642 00:25:35,403 --> 00:25:38,885 It'll at least give me a... a starting point. 643 00:25:38,928 --> 00:25:40,321 The prosecution would like 644 00:25:40,364 --> 00:25:42,758 to call Ahmaud Coleman to the stand. 645 00:25:42,802 --> 00:25:45,369 [door opens] 646 00:25:47,241 --> 00:25:48,503 CHUNK: Objection. 647 00:25:48,547 --> 00:25:50,418 Your Honor, this man's name does not appear 648 00:25:50,461 --> 00:25:51,898 on any witness list. 649 00:25:51,941 --> 00:25:54,378 This is a blatant violation of the rules of discovery. 650 00:25:54,422 --> 00:25:55,858 OLSON: Apology 651 00:25:55,902 --> 00:25:57,338 to the court, Your Honor. 652 00:25:57,381 --> 00:25:59,558 This witness just came to my attention late last night, 653 00:25:59,601 --> 00:26:01,385 when he was arrested for an unrelated matter. 654 00:26:01,429 --> 00:26:02,604 Your Honor... 655 00:26:02,648 --> 00:26:03,910 You'll be provided with all the time 656 00:26:03,953 --> 00:26:05,346 you require to prepare 657 00:26:05,389 --> 00:26:07,478 to cross-examine the witness, Mr. Palmer. 658 00:26:07,522 --> 00:26:09,045 I'd like to proceed. 659 00:26:09,089 --> 00:26:11,526 Yes, Your Honor. 660 00:26:12,614 --> 00:26:14,964 OLSON: Mr. Coleman, 661 00:26:15,008 --> 00:26:17,271 you and the defendant live in the same apartment complex. 662 00:26:17,314 --> 00:26:18,881 Is that right? 663 00:26:18,925 --> 00:26:19,882 That's right. 664 00:26:19,926 --> 00:26:21,144 And are you and the defendant 665 00:26:21,188 --> 00:26:24,365 close friends? Acquaintances? 666 00:26:24,408 --> 00:26:25,932 Neighbors. 667 00:26:25,975 --> 00:26:28,369 I'd mostly see him at the Housing Authority meetings. 668 00:26:28,412 --> 00:26:30,850 Had to raise hell to get them to fix anything. 669 00:26:30,893 --> 00:26:33,940 Did the defendant ever share his feelings about the police 670 00:26:33,983 --> 00:26:36,072 while the two of you were at one of those meetings? 671 00:26:36,116 --> 00:26:38,335 Yeah. Leo would say how the only reason 672 00:26:38,379 --> 00:26:41,730 his father was in prison was the police railroaded him. 673 00:26:41,774 --> 00:26:43,123 Hmm. 674 00:26:43,166 --> 00:26:45,299 Did he say anything else? 675 00:26:45,342 --> 00:26:47,997 Anything that stood out to you? 676 00:26:49,346 --> 00:26:51,610 One day he asked if I knew anyone 677 00:26:51,653 --> 00:26:53,350 who could help him get a gun. 678 00:26:53,394 --> 00:26:54,961 OLSON: Oh. 679 00:26:56,484 --> 00:26:57,920 Did Leo Craddicksay why 680 00:26:57,964 --> 00:26:59,269 he wanted a gun? 681 00:26:59,313 --> 00:27:00,619 He just wanted to know how long it would take. 682 00:27:00,662 --> 00:27:02,185 Said he needed it fast. 683 00:27:02,229 --> 00:27:03,665 Mm-hmm. Was this before 684 00:27:03,709 --> 00:27:06,625 or after Detective Kaminsky was shot to death? 685 00:27:09,149 --> 00:27:10,890 It was before. 686 00:27:10,933 --> 00:27:14,415 OLSON: Nothing further at this time, Your Honor. 687 00:27:14,458 --> 00:27:16,286 [whispering]: You bought a gun from this guy? 688 00:27:16,330 --> 00:27:18,245 No. Of course not. 689 00:27:18,288 --> 00:27:20,116 There have been a bunch of break-ins in our building. 690 00:27:20,160 --> 00:27:22,249 I thought about getting a gun for protection, 691 00:27:22,292 --> 00:27:23,729 but I never followed through. 692 00:27:30,692 --> 00:27:33,303 So you got picked up for something last night, 693 00:27:33,347 --> 00:27:34,957 and someone suggested to you 694 00:27:35,001 --> 00:27:36,480 that if you come into court this morning 695 00:27:36,524 --> 00:27:38,613 and testify against my client, 696 00:27:38,657 --> 00:27:40,833 that things might go a little easier for you? 697 00:27:40,876 --> 00:27:42,617 Hmm? 698 00:27:43,923 --> 00:27:46,099 The witness will answer the question.CHUNK: No. 699 00:27:46,142 --> 00:27:47,622 That's all right, Your Honor. 700 00:27:47,666 --> 00:27:49,363 We'll give him this one for free. 701 00:27:49,406 --> 00:27:51,495 Mr. Coleman, 702 00:27:51,539 --> 00:27:54,020 did my client ever buy a gun from you? 703 00:27:54,063 --> 00:27:55,195 No. 704 00:27:55,238 --> 00:27:57,240 And did my client ever follow up 705 00:27:57,284 --> 00:27:58,851 with you about buying a gun? 706 00:27:58,894 --> 00:28:00,766 No.So, 707 00:28:00,809 --> 00:28:03,246 my client never bought a gun from you, 708 00:28:03,290 --> 00:28:06,902 and the two of you never discussed the subject again? 709 00:28:06,946 --> 00:28:08,425 No. 710 00:28:08,469 --> 00:28:10,079 I see. 711 00:28:10,123 --> 00:28:13,909 So the totality of your testimony is 712 00:28:13,953 --> 00:28:16,477 that you and my client had a little chat? 713 00:28:16,520 --> 00:28:18,609 I suppose. 714 00:28:18,653 --> 00:28:21,003 And during that chat, did my client tell you 715 00:28:21,047 --> 00:28:23,876 that the reason why he wanted a gun was because 716 00:28:23,919 --> 00:28:25,747 of all of the break-ins in your building, 717 00:28:25,791 --> 00:28:28,445 and that that is why he wanted a gun? 718 00:28:28,489 --> 00:28:30,752 You're under oath, Mr. Coleman. 719 00:28:30,796 --> 00:28:33,668 It came up in the conversation. 720 00:28:33,712 --> 00:28:35,670 I bet it did. 721 00:28:37,019 --> 00:28:40,066 I have nothing further for this... witness. 722 00:28:42,198 --> 00:28:43,765 LEO: That was a nice piece 723 00:28:43,809 --> 00:28:45,375 of lawyering, Mr. Palmer. 724 00:28:45,419 --> 00:28:47,116 Thank you. 725 00:28:47,160 --> 00:28:48,378 I'm just doing my job. 726 00:28:48,422 --> 00:28:51,599 And how do you see this going? 727 00:28:51,642 --> 00:28:53,601 What's that jury thinking? 728 00:28:53,644 --> 00:28:55,734 It's hard to say. 729 00:28:55,777 --> 00:28:59,912 And they need 12 to convict, they need 12 to exonerate. 730 00:28:59,955 --> 00:29:02,697 Anything else, and we have a hung jury. 731 00:29:02,741 --> 00:29:05,134 You go back to prison, and then we go 732 00:29:05,178 --> 00:29:07,789 and do this all over again in eight or nine months. 733 00:29:07,833 --> 00:29:10,444 None of that sounds like an answer. 734 00:29:12,011 --> 00:29:14,056 They believe your motive is revenge. 735 00:29:14,100 --> 00:29:17,625 A witness said they saw you seek out the victim. 736 00:29:17,668 --> 00:29:20,062 And someone else said you wanted to buy a gun. 737 00:29:20,106 --> 00:29:21,281 But I didn't buy one. 738 00:29:21,324 --> 00:29:22,804 But you asked about it. 739 00:29:22,848 --> 00:29:25,067 And we know there's at least one juror 740 00:29:25,111 --> 00:29:27,722 whose mind we are not gonna change about you. 741 00:29:30,769 --> 00:29:32,945 Because I look the part. 742 00:29:33,859 --> 00:29:36,905 [sighs] Put me on the stand. 743 00:29:37,819 --> 00:29:39,603 Let me testify. Let me tell my story. 744 00:29:39,647 --> 00:29:40,953 Leo, we put you on the stand, 745 00:29:40,996 --> 00:29:43,085 and that A.D.A.'s first question is going to be, 746 00:29:43,129 --> 00:29:45,392 "Do you stand with Black Lives Matter?" 747 00:29:45,435 --> 00:29:46,654 And my answer's gonna be, 748 00:29:46,697 --> 00:29:48,221 "Hell yes, I do!" 749 00:29:48,264 --> 00:29:50,876 Black lives matter. Why is that even open for debate? 750 00:29:50,919 --> 00:29:54,749 It shouldn't be, but with this jury, it is. 751 00:29:54,793 --> 00:29:59,362 I want...to testify. 752 00:29:59,406 --> 00:30:01,408 It's my life. 753 00:30:01,451 --> 00:30:04,628 If I'm going to spend the rest of it behind bars, 754 00:30:04,672 --> 00:30:06,108 I want to look the people 755 00:30:06,152 --> 00:30:09,155 who are going to put me in there in the eye. 756 00:30:11,505 --> 00:30:14,247 Okay, Leo. Okay. 757 00:30:14,290 --> 00:30:16,118 Let me think about it.Why? 758 00:30:16,162 --> 00:30:19,121 It's not even your choice.Let me think about it. 759 00:30:19,165 --> 00:30:21,515 You do whatever you want. 760 00:30:23,517 --> 00:30:25,824 I've already made up my mind. 761 00:30:25,867 --> 00:30:27,826 [elevator bell chimes] 762 00:30:27,869 --> 00:30:30,698 Gentlemen, I have an idea. 763 00:30:33,222 --> 00:30:35,311 Dr. Bull. 764 00:30:35,355 --> 00:30:38,575 Arthur wanted to have a word. 765 00:30:38,619 --> 00:30:41,491 Mr. Colón explained the situation to me. 766 00:30:41,535 --> 00:30:43,580 I had a thought. 767 00:30:45,626 --> 00:30:49,195 Make me your first witness. 768 00:30:49,238 --> 00:30:50,761 Excuse me? 769 00:30:50,805 --> 00:30:53,721 Can you tell me where I can find the owner of this bodega? 770 00:30:54,504 --> 00:30:56,202 I don't know. 771 00:30:56,245 --> 00:30:57,594 What do you want him for? 772 00:30:57,638 --> 00:30:58,944 I'm a private investigator, and I was hoping 773 00:30:58,987 --> 00:31:01,120 he might be able to give me some information. 774 00:31:01,163 --> 00:31:03,035 About what? 775 00:31:03,078 --> 00:31:05,472 Something somebody bought here. 776 00:31:05,515 --> 00:31:07,474 A phone. 777 00:31:07,517 --> 00:31:10,520 And when did you make the decision to take an active role 778 00:31:10,564 --> 00:31:12,783 in securing your freedom from prison? 779 00:31:12,827 --> 00:31:15,395 That's the thing. 780 00:31:15,438 --> 00:31:17,788 It wasn't me. It was Leo. 781 00:31:17,832 --> 00:31:20,922 Whenever he could afford a stamp, he would write to me. 782 00:31:20,966 --> 00:31:22,881 Tell me how things were going in school, 783 00:31:22,924 --> 00:31:24,621 send me his test papers, 784 00:31:24,665 --> 00:31:26,058 beg me to let him come visit. 785 00:31:26,101 --> 00:31:31,541 And, uh, even though I dreaded 786 00:31:31,585 --> 00:31:34,675 him seeing me in that place, 787 00:31:34,718 --> 00:31:36,503 him seeing me that way, I... 788 00:31:36,546 --> 00:31:39,854 I finally said "yes." 789 00:31:39,898 --> 00:31:42,857 And the first thing he said was... 790 00:31:46,252 --> 00:31:51,213 "Pops... we're going to get you out of here. 791 00:31:54,303 --> 00:31:56,697 "You didn't do this. 792 00:31:56,740 --> 00:31:58,873 "The law is the law, 793 00:31:58,917 --> 00:32:02,094 and you didn't break any laws." 794 00:32:05,924 --> 00:32:09,101 All that mattered to him was that I was his father. 795 00:32:10,798 --> 00:32:13,540 [sniffles] And that's how it started. 796 00:32:14,541 --> 00:32:17,500 I went to the prison library. He went to the Bronx library. 797 00:32:17,544 --> 00:32:21,113 And twice a month, he would take the-the bus up to the prison, 798 00:32:21,156 --> 00:32:23,767 and we would compare notes.OLSON: Your Honor, 799 00:32:23,811 --> 00:32:25,030 I object. 800 00:32:25,073 --> 00:32:28,511 While this is all truly... 801 00:32:28,555 --> 00:32:30,035 fascinating, 802 00:32:30,078 --> 00:32:32,037 it's hard to see how any of it 803 00:32:32,080 --> 00:32:33,908 is relevant to the business at hand, 804 00:32:33,952 --> 00:32:36,171 which is the murder of Detective Kaminsky. 805 00:32:36,215 --> 00:32:37,781 CHUNK: Your Honor, apologies. 806 00:32:37,825 --> 00:32:39,914 The witness is simply trying to set the table 807 00:32:39,958 --> 00:32:41,481 and create some context. 808 00:32:41,524 --> 00:32:45,180 That's all well and good, Mr. Palmer, but let's get to it. 809 00:32:46,790 --> 00:32:48,488 [quietly]:Okay. 810 00:32:48,531 --> 00:32:50,359 Mr. Craddick, 811 00:32:50,403 --> 00:32:54,015 do you believe that your son murdered Detective Kaminsky? 812 00:32:54,059 --> 00:32:55,712 No, I do not.OLSON: Objection. 813 00:32:55,756 --> 00:32:57,540 Calls for speculation. 814 00:32:57,584 --> 00:33:00,282 Besides which, this man is a convicted murderer. 815 00:33:00,326 --> 00:33:02,371 CHUNK:Your Honor, the conviction is in the process 816 00:33:02,415 --> 00:33:04,983 of being vacated.OLSON: Not to mention the fact 817 00:33:05,026 --> 00:33:06,201 that on the night in question, 818 00:33:06,245 --> 00:33:07,028 he was behind bars 819 00:33:07,072 --> 00:33:08,247 and could not possibly know 820 00:33:08,290 --> 00:33:09,378 who did or did not 821 00:33:09,422 --> 00:33:10,640 shoot Detective Kaminsky. 822 00:33:10,684 --> 00:33:12,512 But I do. 823 00:33:12,555 --> 00:33:14,122 Objection. 824 00:33:14,166 --> 00:33:16,385 Sustained. The jury will disregard. 825 00:33:16,429 --> 00:33:19,214 But, Your Honor, I really do know who killed the detective. 826 00:33:19,258 --> 00:33:21,173 ARGAWAL:Mr. Craddick, I know you've studied the law, 827 00:33:21,216 --> 00:33:23,523 so I know you know how this works. 828 00:33:23,566 --> 00:33:26,004 You may not speak out of turn. 829 00:33:26,047 --> 00:33:27,744 The attorney will ask 830 00:33:27,788 --> 00:33:30,269 a question, and then you will answer. 831 00:33:31,531 --> 00:33:33,228 [whispers]: Ask me. 832 00:33:38,538 --> 00:33:39,626 ARGAWAL: Mr. Palmer, 833 00:33:39,669 --> 00:33:41,541 this is your witness. 834 00:33:41,584 --> 00:33:44,152 Ask a question. 835 00:33:45,719 --> 00:33:47,416 Mr. Craddick, 836 00:33:47,460 --> 00:33:50,463 do you know who killed Detective Kaminsky? 837 00:33:50,506 --> 00:33:52,552 I do. 838 00:33:52,595 --> 00:33:53,988 Okay. 839 00:33:54,032 --> 00:33:56,164 And how is this possible? 840 00:33:56,208 --> 00:33:59,080 Because I'm the one who paid the man who did it. 841 00:33:59,124 --> 00:34:00,995 [gallery murmuring]ARGAWAL:Order! 842 00:34:01,039 --> 00:34:02,475 [gavel banging] 843 00:34:02,518 --> 00:34:04,520 The jury will restrain itself. 844 00:34:04,564 --> 00:34:06,218 What the hell is he doing? 845 00:34:06,261 --> 00:34:08,220 Your Honor, we move to strike the witness's last statement. 846 00:34:08,263 --> 00:34:10,309 ARGAWAL: Mr. Craddick, are you saying 847 00:34:10,352 --> 00:34:12,659 you were directly involved in the murder 848 00:34:12,702 --> 00:34:14,269 of Detective Kaminsky? 849 00:34:14,313 --> 00:34:17,185 Don't answer that! Your Honor, I am this witness's 850 00:34:17,229 --> 00:34:18,578 attorney.ARTHUR: Your Honor, I knew 851 00:34:18,621 --> 00:34:20,362 Kaminsky was gonna try to keep me in jail, 852 00:34:20,406 --> 00:34:23,931 so I paid someone on the outside $25,000 to have him killed 853 00:34:23,974 --> 00:34:26,064 so that he couldn't block my parole. 854 00:34:26,107 --> 00:34:27,891 Y-Your Honor, uh, I am requesting 855 00:34:27,935 --> 00:34:30,198 a recess to confer, please.OLSON: I object. 856 00:34:30,242 --> 00:34:32,896 The people are entitled to cross-examine this witness. 857 00:34:32,940 --> 00:34:34,550 Particularly in light 858 00:34:34,594 --> 00:34:36,422 of this preposterous 859 00:34:36,465 --> 00:34:38,250 and transparent attempt to create reasonable doubt. 860 00:34:38,293 --> 00:34:40,078 ARGAWAL: All right.[gavel bangs] 861 00:34:41,122 --> 00:34:42,515 I'm sorry, Ms. Olson, 862 00:34:42,558 --> 00:34:44,647 but we are going to adjourn for the day. 863 00:34:44,691 --> 00:34:48,086 And unless Mr. Palmer has any more questions, 864 00:34:48,129 --> 00:34:50,000 when we return, 865 00:34:50,044 --> 00:34:52,264 we will commence with cross-examination. 866 00:34:52,307 --> 00:34:55,354 Court is adjourned.[gavel bangs] 867 00:34:55,397 --> 00:34:57,921 You committed perjury. That's a felony. 868 00:34:57,965 --> 00:34:59,923 You just violated the terms of your parole. 869 00:34:59,967 --> 00:35:02,535 Arthur, what were you thinking? 870 00:35:03,362 --> 00:35:05,146 I was thinking that being innocent 871 00:35:05,190 --> 00:35:06,974 wasn't going to keep my son out of jail. 872 00:35:12,588 --> 00:35:13,981 So, I went to the bodega hoping whoever 873 00:35:14,024 --> 00:35:15,417 sold our man the phone might have a record 874 00:35:15,461 --> 00:35:17,680 of it and that he might be willing 875 00:35:17,724 --> 00:35:19,552 to part with that information 876 00:35:19,595 --> 00:35:21,380 for enough money.And? 877 00:35:21,423 --> 00:35:23,425 DANNY: And he hadn't 878 00:35:23,469 --> 00:35:24,948 actually sold that phone to anyone. 879 00:35:24,992 --> 00:35:26,254 It was his phone. 880 00:35:26,298 --> 00:35:28,387 It belonged to the man who owned the bodega. 881 00:35:28,430 --> 00:35:29,910 Okay, so, now we're saying 882 00:35:29,953 --> 00:35:33,000 that Detective Kaminsky was killed by some bodega guy? 883 00:35:33,043 --> 00:35:34,262 I didn't say that. 884 00:35:34,306 --> 00:35:36,308 I said the phone belonged to the bodega guy. 885 00:35:36,351 --> 00:35:38,397 Cost me 500 bucks, by the way. 886 00:35:38,440 --> 00:35:40,877 [sighs]So, why was Bodega Guy 887 00:35:40,921 --> 00:35:42,488 calling Kaminsky the night of the murder? 888 00:35:42,531 --> 00:35:44,185 Or, for that matter, 889 00:35:44,229 --> 00:35:47,145 any of the other dozens of times they spoke?DANNY: Well, 890 00:35:47,188 --> 00:35:48,755 let's not talk about the night of the murder just yet. 891 00:35:48,798 --> 00:35:50,278 And all the other times that Kaminsky 892 00:35:50,322 --> 00:35:51,671 and the bodega guy talked 893 00:35:51,714 --> 00:35:53,194 was because they were conducting business. 894 00:35:53,238 --> 00:35:54,456 Business? 895 00:35:54,500 --> 00:35:55,762 DANNY: The bodega guy 896 00:35:55,805 --> 00:35:57,416 was supplying Kaminsky with Adderall. 897 00:35:57,459 --> 00:35:59,113 Apparently, he used it to stay up late. 898 00:35:59,157 --> 00:36:00,854 Used it the way people chew gum. 899 00:36:00,897 --> 00:36:03,509 I'm following you, but I have no idea where you're going. 900 00:36:03,552 --> 00:36:04,684 Oh, Danny, put them out of their misery. 901 00:36:04,727 --> 00:36:06,207 Get to the good stuff. 902 00:36:06,251 --> 00:36:09,341 It turns out the bodega guy got busted by two cops 903 00:36:09,384 --> 00:36:11,343 five days before Kaminsky's murder. 904 00:36:11,386 --> 00:36:13,954 But instead of arresting him, the cops took all his money, 905 00:36:13,997 --> 00:36:17,262 his drugs and his burner phone. 906 00:36:17,305 --> 00:36:19,046 Okay, so, wait. Now you're saying 907 00:36:19,089 --> 00:36:21,222 you think that the people that were calling Kaminsky 908 00:36:21,266 --> 00:36:23,877 the night of his murder were cops? 909 00:36:23,920 --> 00:36:25,879 We know they were cops. And now that Taylor 910 00:36:25,922 --> 00:36:28,534 has broken the encryption on Kaminsky's phone, 911 00:36:28,577 --> 00:36:32,102 I think we have enough to prove they killed him. 912 00:36:33,321 --> 00:36:35,889 [door opens] 913 00:36:39,284 --> 00:36:42,156 Well, thank you for agreeing to meet us so early in the morning. 914 00:36:42,200 --> 00:36:43,592 [sighs] 915 00:36:43,636 --> 00:36:45,812 This better be good. 916 00:36:45,855 --> 00:36:47,553 So, when Kaminsky wanted to buy more Adderall, 917 00:36:47,596 --> 00:36:48,858 he couldn't get his connect on the phone, 918 00:36:48,902 --> 00:36:50,904 so he went to see him in person. 919 00:36:50,947 --> 00:36:52,775 BULL: And that's when he discovered the two detectives he knew 920 00:36:52,819 --> 00:36:56,170 were shaking down small-time drug dealers, including his. 921 00:36:56,997 --> 00:37:00,000 So you think he threatened to go to Internal Affairs? 922 00:37:01,001 --> 00:37:02,307 I know he did. 923 00:37:02,350 --> 00:37:05,484 Our technical team unencrypted their conversations. 924 00:37:05,527 --> 00:37:06,746 They said 925 00:37:06,789 --> 00:37:08,051 they would kill him 926 00:37:08,095 --> 00:37:10,445 if he threatened to destroy their lives. 927 00:37:11,664 --> 00:37:12,882 Our first witness this morning 928 00:37:12,926 --> 00:37:14,623 is scheduled to be the bodega owner. 929 00:37:14,667 --> 00:37:15,929 The drug dealer. 930 00:37:15,972 --> 00:37:17,060 Who will identify 931 00:37:17,104 --> 00:37:18,801 the two detectives who shook him down 932 00:37:18,845 --> 00:37:20,499 in exchange for leniency 933 00:37:20,542 --> 00:37:23,153 because he is unmasking two corrupt cops. 934 00:37:23,197 --> 00:37:26,766 Unless, of course, you'd rather he didn't testify for us 935 00:37:26,809 --> 00:37:28,768 but instead testified for you 936 00:37:28,811 --> 00:37:31,727 when you bring charges against these two detectives. 937 00:37:46,525 --> 00:37:48,440 As the, uh, people 938 00:37:48,483 --> 00:37:50,616 and the defense were in agreement, 939 00:37:50,659 --> 00:37:53,271 I was expecting to enter a finding of "not guilty" 940 00:37:53,314 --> 00:37:54,794 in this matter. 941 00:37:54,837 --> 00:37:57,231 However, Judge Argawal informed me 942 00:37:57,275 --> 00:38:00,103 of Mr. Craddick's recent outburst in her courtroom. 943 00:38:00,147 --> 00:38:02,802 Can you explain your actions, Mr. Craddick? 944 00:38:02,845 --> 00:38:05,935 If I may, Your Honor, my client's actions 945 00:38:05,979 --> 00:38:09,025 were not born out of any contempt for the law 946 00:38:09,069 --> 00:38:12,028 but were those, simply, of a desperate father 947 00:38:12,072 --> 00:38:13,639 trying to protect his son. 948 00:38:13,682 --> 00:38:17,773 Now, Mr. Craddick deeply regrets his outburst. 949 00:38:17,817 --> 00:38:20,733 But, in light of the unusual circumstances of this case, 950 00:38:20,776 --> 00:38:23,779 I ask that the court show some mercy 951 00:38:23,823 --> 00:38:27,522 and rule favorably on our petition. 952 00:38:33,311 --> 00:38:35,356 Your Honor, 953 00:38:35,400 --> 00:38:38,838 Mr. Craddick has endured 12 years in prison 954 00:38:38,881 --> 00:38:42,755 for a crime he did not commit, and... 955 00:38:42,798 --> 00:38:46,715 the people will not compound his suffering by pressing charges 956 00:38:46,759 --> 00:38:47,847 at this time. 957 00:38:47,890 --> 00:38:49,022 The people 958 00:38:49,065 --> 00:38:50,415 likewise request 959 00:38:50,458 --> 00:38:53,243 that the court enter a finding of "not guilty." 960 00:38:54,114 --> 00:38:57,291 Mr. Craddick, if I could ask you to stand. 961 00:39:03,166 --> 00:39:06,518 Mr. Craddick, some wrongs are impossible to make right. 962 00:39:06,561 --> 00:39:09,477 But occasionally, we are given the opportunity 963 00:39:09,521 --> 00:39:12,001 to offer a small correction 964 00:39:12,045 --> 00:39:14,047 to the grotesque cruelties 965 00:39:14,090 --> 00:39:17,485 that are suffered in the name of justice. 966 00:39:19,226 --> 00:39:23,056 I'm going to rule in favor of you, the petitioner. 967 00:39:23,099 --> 00:39:26,494 A verdict of "not guilty" will be entered into the record 968 00:39:26,538 --> 00:39:29,976 along with the apologies of the court. 969 00:39:30,019 --> 00:39:34,023 Mr. Craddick, you're free to go. 970 00:39:34,067 --> 00:39:35,547 [gavel bangs] 971 00:39:45,600 --> 00:39:47,515 [indistinct whispering] 972 00:39:48,995 --> 00:39:50,388 [door opens] 973 00:39:59,484 --> 00:40:01,050 [sighs] So, what do you know? 974 00:40:01,094 --> 00:40:03,357 Is the A.D.A. gonna play ball?BULL:Well, 975 00:40:03,401 --> 00:40:04,532 she hasn't said anything yet. 976 00:40:04,576 --> 00:40:06,316 All I know is people 977 00:40:06,360 --> 00:40:08,449 with D.A. medallions hanging from their necks 978 00:40:08,493 --> 00:40:11,670 keep showing up and speaking passionately with her.OFFICER: All rise. 979 00:40:17,850 --> 00:40:19,025 All right, then. 980 00:40:19,068 --> 00:40:21,288 I believe it's now 981 00:40:21,331 --> 00:40:23,290 the prosecution's turn to cross-examine 982 00:40:23,333 --> 00:40:25,205 Mr. Arthur Craddick. 983 00:40:25,248 --> 00:40:27,250 Could we please have Mr. Craddick take his place 984 00:40:27,294 --> 00:40:29,470 in the witness box?OLSON: Your Honor, 985 00:40:29,514 --> 00:40:31,820 before we continue, there's a matter 986 00:40:31,864 --> 00:40:34,475 we'd very much like to bring to the court's attention. 987 00:40:34,519 --> 00:40:36,608 A few moments ago, I was able 988 00:40:36,651 --> 00:40:38,044 to confirm that an arrest warrant 989 00:40:38,087 --> 00:40:40,786 had been issued for Detective Ryan Pierson. 990 00:40:40,829 --> 00:40:43,963 Just this morning, investigators uncovered evidence 991 00:40:44,006 --> 00:40:45,181 implicating Pierson 992 00:40:45,225 --> 00:40:47,314 in the murder of Detective Joe Kaminsky. 993 00:40:47,357 --> 00:40:49,447 In light of this, 994 00:40:49,490 --> 00:40:50,926 and other evidence provided 995 00:40:50,970 --> 00:40:53,451 in conjunction with an ongoing investigation 996 00:40:53,494 --> 00:40:54,669 with Internal Affairs, 997 00:40:54,713 --> 00:40:58,281 the people are informing the court 998 00:40:58,325 --> 00:40:59,805 that we are dismissing 999 00:40:59,848 --> 00:41:02,503 all charges against Leo Craddick. 1000 00:41:03,678 --> 00:41:05,506 And, Mr. Craddick, 1001 00:41:05,550 --> 00:41:08,944 I'm so sorry for all that you've been through. 1002 00:41:08,988 --> 00:41:10,816 ARGAWAL: Ladies and gentlemen, 1003 00:41:10,859 --> 00:41:14,384 the court thanks the jury for its service. 1004 00:41:14,428 --> 00:41:17,039 This case is dismissed. 1005 00:41:27,136 --> 00:41:29,399 [crying] 1006 00:41:33,316 --> 00:41:34,622 You were right. 1007 00:41:34,666 --> 00:41:35,971 About which thing? 1008 00:41:36,015 --> 00:41:37,407 Belief perseverance. 1009 00:41:37,451 --> 00:41:38,670 People get an idea in their head, 1010 00:41:38,713 --> 00:41:40,846 and they see the world in a certain way. 1011 00:41:40,889 --> 00:41:42,021 Yeah. 1012 00:41:45,241 --> 00:41:48,506 I'll meet you guys outside. 1013 00:41:52,901 --> 00:41:54,860 Excuse me. 1014 00:41:54,903 --> 00:41:56,426 Um, 1015 00:41:56,470 --> 00:41:58,646 sorry to bother you, but I... I couldn't help but notice 1016 00:41:58,690 --> 00:42:00,430 when the judge dismissed the case, 1017 00:42:00,474 --> 00:42:02,737 you looked upset. 1018 00:42:03,608 --> 00:42:06,001 No. No big deal. 1019 00:42:06,045 --> 00:42:07,786 I'm just... 1020 00:42:08,830 --> 00:42:11,267 [sighs] What can I say? 1021 00:42:11,311 --> 00:42:14,401 I was absolutely convinced 1022 00:42:14,444 --> 00:42:16,185 that the man was guilty. 1023 00:42:16,229 --> 00:42:17,622 Hmm. 1024 00:42:17,665 --> 00:42:20,146 Guess I was wrong. 1025 00:42:20,189 --> 00:42:22,452 It happens. 1026 00:42:44,562 --> 00:42:50,524 Captioning sponsored by CBS 1027 00:42:50,568 --> 00:42:52,570 Captioned by Media Access Group at WGBH access.wgbh.org