1 00:00:04,637 --> 00:00:06,539 (vehicle rumbling, horn honks) 2 00:00:06,606 --> 00:00:11,077 (siren wailing in distance) 3 00:00:19,819 --> 00:00:22,188 (baby crying) 4 00:00:24,724 --> 00:00:27,127 (continues crying) 5 00:00:29,262 --> 00:00:32,298 (singing Russian lullaby) 6 00:00:36,703 --> 00:00:38,705 (crying quiets) 7 00:00:38,772 --> 00:00:42,342 (continues singing Russian lullaby) 8 00:00:49,816 --> 00:00:52,485 She's having a tough night, eh? 9 00:00:52,552 --> 00:00:54,554 My little angel? 10 00:00:54,621 --> 00:00:57,290 She's just teething. 11 00:01:03,430 --> 00:01:05,799 (takes envelope) 12 00:01:06,633 --> 00:01:09,502 I'm short $500. 13 00:01:09,569 --> 00:01:11,671 I'll make it up next month. 14 00:01:11,738 --> 00:01:14,140 You have my word, Ivan. 15 00:01:11,738 --> 00:01:14,140 Shh. 16 00:01:17,143 --> 00:01:20,547 I'll need $200 more. Hmm? 17 00:01:20,613 --> 00:01:22,415 For interest. 18 00:01:34,527 --> 00:01:36,863 (sighs) 19 00:01:36,930 --> 00:01:39,299 (gunshots) 20 00:01:36,930 --> 00:01:39,299 (baby crying) 21 00:01:42,569 --> 00:01:43,670 (grunts) 22 00:01:43,736 --> 00:01:46,539 (baby continues crying) 23 00:01:46,606 --> 00:01:48,775 (train wheels clacking) 24 00:01:51,444 --> 00:01:53,680 MRS. PIERCE: Sweet little baby and her daddy 25 00:01:53,746 --> 00:01:55,381 shot dead in the street. 26 00:01:55,448 --> 00:01:59,219 Nobody deserves that, not even two-bit gangsters. 27 00:02:00,487 --> 00:02:01,554 Creep was fleecing money 28 00:02:01,621 --> 00:02:04,557 from every business in the neighborhood, even mine. 29 00:02:04,624 --> 00:02:06,159 (electronic chiming) 30 00:02:06,226 --> 00:02:08,294 Mm-hmm. 31 00:02:06,226 --> 00:02:08,294 Here you go, Mrs. Pierce. 32 00:02:09,796 --> 00:02:11,297 Excuse me. Morning. 33 00:02:11,364 --> 00:02:13,199 My name's Detective Joe Kaminsky. 34 00:02:13,266 --> 00:02:14,767 Do you happen to know the whereabouts 35 00:02:14,834 --> 00:02:15,835 of an Arthur Craddick? 36 00:02:15,902 --> 00:02:17,504 I'm Arthur Craddick. 37 00:02:17,570 --> 00:02:19,372 Hmm. Is this your son? 38 00:02:19,439 --> 00:02:21,708 Someone we can call to look after him? 39 00:02:21,774 --> 00:02:23,409 Look after my son? Why? 40 00:02:23,476 --> 00:02:25,478 Well, we just want you to come down to the station, 41 00:02:25,545 --> 00:02:28,815 Mr. Craddick, just to answer some questions. 42 00:02:29,649 --> 00:02:30,917 You have my word, 43 00:02:30,984 --> 00:02:32,452 no big deal. 44 00:02:32,519 --> 00:02:33,853 Got a little crazy around here the other night, 45 00:02:33,920 --> 00:02:35,688 and we're talking to lots of people. 46 00:02:35,755 --> 00:02:39,492 Just kind of tough to know how long it's gonna take. 47 00:02:39,559 --> 00:02:41,661 Don't go, Dad. 48 00:02:41,728 --> 00:02:43,463 (sighs) 49 00:02:43,530 --> 00:02:44,731 Hey, Leo. 50 00:02:44,797 --> 00:02:46,733 Don't worry. 51 00:02:46,799 --> 00:02:49,802 Whatever this is, it's, um... 52 00:02:49,869 --> 00:02:52,272 it's just a mistake. 53 00:02:52,338 --> 00:02:55,241 I'll be back before you know it. 54 00:02:57,477 --> 00:03:00,213 Would you do me a favor, Mrs. Pierce? 55 00:03:00,280 --> 00:03:03,950 I have an employee who's coming in about ten minutes 56 00:03:04,017 --> 00:03:05,385 to take over. 57 00:03:05,451 --> 00:03:07,921 Leo and I will keep watch till he gets here. 58 00:03:07,987 --> 00:03:09,956 Thank you. 59 00:03:14,594 --> 00:03:15,962 (sighs) 60 00:03:16,029 --> 00:03:18,431 Why are you looking like that? 61 00:03:18,498 --> 00:03:20,333 You heard the man. 62 00:03:20,400 --> 00:03:22,368 All they want to do is have a little talk. 63 00:03:22,435 --> 00:03:23,903 Isn't that right, Detective? 64 00:03:23,970 --> 00:03:25,572 Just a little talk. 65 00:03:29,976 --> 00:03:32,612 (indistinct police radio transmission) 66 00:03:33,479 --> 00:03:35,348 (door opens) 67 00:03:33,479 --> 00:03:35,348 (electronic chiming) 68 00:03:35,415 --> 00:03:36,649 (knocking) 69 00:03:36,716 --> 00:03:39,252 (door opens) 70 00:03:36,716 --> 00:03:39,252 BULL: Mr. Craddick. 71 00:03:39,319 --> 00:03:40,687 I'm Dr. Jason Bull. 72 00:03:40,753 --> 00:03:43,856 Uh, your attorney said you wanted to see me. 73 00:03:46,426 --> 00:03:48,928 You're the expert witness my attorney hired? 74 00:03:46,426 --> 00:03:48,928 Yeah. 75 00:03:48,995 --> 00:03:50,563 I'm a psychologist. 76 00:03:50,630 --> 00:03:52,832 I'm here to try and get the jury to understand 77 00:03:52,899 --> 00:03:56,402 eyewitness testimony isn't all it's cracked up to be. 78 00:03:56,469 --> 00:03:58,538 He told you I didn't do it, right? 79 00:03:58,605 --> 00:04:00,873 I didn't kill that man and his baby. 80 00:04:00,940 --> 00:04:03,543 Honestly, it didn't really come up. 81 00:04:03,610 --> 00:04:05,845 I'm here to tell the jury 82 00:04:05,912 --> 00:04:07,847 about eyewitness testimony, not you. 83 00:04:07,914 --> 00:04:10,950 Okay, I get what you're doing, but I need you to know... 84 00:04:11,017 --> 00:04:13,252 I'd never kill anybody. 85 00:04:13,319 --> 00:04:14,921 I have a ten-year-old son. 86 00:04:14,988 --> 00:04:16,956 His mom died when he was a toddler. 87 00:04:17,023 --> 00:04:18,725 I'm all he's got. 88 00:04:18,791 --> 00:04:19,959 Sure. 89 00:04:20,026 --> 00:04:22,295 What can I do for you, Mr. Craddick? 90 00:04:22,362 --> 00:04:24,631 You can tell me I'm gonna go home to my boy. 91 00:04:24,697 --> 00:04:26,733 Look, I'm not a lawyer, 92 00:04:26,799 --> 00:04:28,001 but from what I can tell, 93 00:04:28,067 --> 00:04:29,402 they don't really have much of a case. 94 00:04:29,469 --> 00:04:30,970 It's mostly circumstantial evidence. 95 00:04:31,037 --> 00:04:32,438 What they're gonna do is tell a story 96 00:04:32,505 --> 00:04:33,906 about how you're some kind of vigilante 97 00:04:33,973 --> 00:04:36,976 who took matters into his own hands. 98 00:04:37,043 --> 00:04:38,678 But there's nothing in your background 99 00:04:38,745 --> 00:04:40,546 that substantiates that idea. 100 00:04:40,613 --> 00:04:43,650 So all they really have is this one supposed eyewitness, 101 00:04:43,716 --> 00:04:45,284 whose testimony... 102 00:04:45,351 --> 00:04:47,286 really isn't very strong at all. 103 00:04:47,353 --> 00:04:48,855 So you think... 104 00:04:48,921 --> 00:04:50,790 this might go my way? 105 00:04:50,857 --> 00:04:52,325 Mr. Craddick, I believe 106 00:04:52,392 --> 00:04:54,293 that if your attorney picked a decent jury, 107 00:04:54,360 --> 00:04:55,728 a jury of your peers, 108 00:04:55,795 --> 00:04:58,498 then yeah. 109 00:04:58,564 --> 00:05:01,601 KAMINSKY: We got a 911 call. A neighbor said 110 00:05:01,668 --> 00:05:03,670 he was home asleep when two gunshots outside woke him up. 111 00:05:03,736 --> 00:05:06,439 (sighs) 112 00:05:03,736 --> 00:05:06,439 From his third-floor window 113 00:05:06,506 --> 00:05:07,874 he saw a male figure-- the shooter-- 114 00:05:07,940 --> 00:05:10,443 running away from a dead body lying on the sidewalk. 115 00:05:10,510 --> 00:05:12,612 You should object. That's hearsay. 116 00:05:12,679 --> 00:05:14,614 Please. Leave the lawyering to me. 117 00:05:14,681 --> 00:05:16,449 GLOVER: And what happened next, Detective? 118 00:05:16,516 --> 00:05:17,950 The neighbor came into the precinct 119 00:05:18,017 --> 00:05:19,752 to give a more detailed statement. 120 00:05:19,819 --> 00:05:21,721 At that time, I also laid out six photos 121 00:05:21,788 --> 00:05:24,424 of possible suspects for him to review. 122 00:05:24,490 --> 00:05:26,926 He identified the shooter immediately. 123 00:05:26,993 --> 00:05:28,761 Did it with great certainty. 124 00:05:28,828 --> 00:05:31,731 GLOVER: And the person the neighbor identified, 125 00:05:31,798 --> 00:05:34,701 do you see that person in the courtroom today? 126 00:05:34,767 --> 00:05:36,769 I certainly do. 127 00:05:36,836 --> 00:05:39,005 The defendant Arthur Craddick. 128 00:05:40,106 --> 00:05:42,475 GLOVER: Thank you. 129 00:05:46,646 --> 00:05:48,715 BULL: Eyewitness testimony is actually 130 00:05:48,781 --> 00:05:51,050 the oldest category of trial evidence there is. 131 00:05:51,117 --> 00:05:53,119 Ironically, when we look at the data, 132 00:05:53,186 --> 00:05:55,955 it's also the most flawed category 133 00:05:56,022 --> 00:05:58,591 of trial evidence there is. 134 00:05:58,658 --> 00:06:01,527 It has the highest probability for error. 135 00:06:01,594 --> 00:06:02,462 Error? Huh. 136 00:06:02,528 --> 00:06:05,098 Okay, so what would cause a witness to make 137 00:06:05,164 --> 00:06:07,433 a false identification? 138 00:06:07,500 --> 00:06:09,035 Well, let's look at the identification 139 00:06:09,102 --> 00:06:10,937 at the center of this case. 140 00:06:11,003 --> 00:06:13,406 The witness was three stories up, 141 00:06:13,473 --> 00:06:16,476 seeing whatever he saw in the dark of night. 142 00:06:16,542 --> 00:06:19,078 He was roused from sleep. 143 00:06:19,145 --> 00:06:20,813 Clearly not a recipe for precision. 144 00:06:20,880 --> 00:06:24,450 And then he gets taken down to the station house, 145 00:06:24,517 --> 00:06:26,519 and they lay six photographs in front of him. 146 00:06:26,586 --> 00:06:28,521 Six photos all at once. 147 00:06:28,588 --> 00:06:29,889 And what's wrong with that? 148 00:06:29,956 --> 00:06:31,524 Research studies have taught us 149 00:06:31,591 --> 00:06:34,060 that when we present witnesses with a group of choices, 150 00:06:34,127 --> 00:06:35,962 they feel tremendous pressure to pick one. 151 00:06:36,028 --> 00:06:38,498 Whether they actually see the person they're looking for or not, 152 00:06:38,564 --> 00:06:39,966 they feel like they're not doing 153 00:06:40,032 --> 00:06:41,768 their job unless they pick one. 154 00:06:41,834 --> 00:06:45,404 The better practice is to present photos one at a time, 155 00:06:45,471 --> 00:06:48,007 and that way the witness can consider each individually, 156 00:06:48,074 --> 00:06:49,742 thoughtfully, 157 00:06:49,809 --> 00:06:54,013 and they can eliminate or identify candidates as they go. 158 00:06:54,080 --> 00:06:55,748 Then there's familiarity. 159 00:06:55,815 --> 00:06:58,451 And the eyewitness and Mr. Craddick were neighbors. 160 00:06:58,518 --> 00:07:00,753 They apparently didn't know each other, but... 161 00:07:00,820 --> 00:07:02,989 we are reasonably sure that they saw each other 162 00:07:03,055 --> 00:07:06,425 around the neighborhood-- at the park, on the street. 163 00:07:06,492 --> 00:07:09,695 And the point is, the pull of familiarity can be 164 00:07:09,762 --> 00:07:10,596 incredibly powerful. 165 00:07:10,663 --> 00:07:12,999 I mean, it's a force that inclines us 166 00:07:13,065 --> 00:07:15,101 to select the face we've seen before 167 00:07:15,168 --> 00:07:18,037 over the one that's completely new to us. 168 00:07:18,104 --> 00:07:21,207 So, in your expert opinion, Dr. Bull, 169 00:07:21,274 --> 00:07:24,744 can this eyewitness account be trusted? 170 00:07:26,946 --> 00:07:28,514 In my expert opinion, no. 171 00:07:28,581 --> 00:07:31,450 You don't send a man to prison for the rest of his life 172 00:07:31,517 --> 00:07:33,586 based on the word of one lone witness 173 00:07:33,653 --> 00:07:35,755 whose testimony, no matter how well-meaning, 174 00:07:35,822 --> 00:07:41,060 has a far greater probability of being wrong than right. 175 00:07:41,127 --> 00:07:43,696 (gavel bangs) 176 00:07:49,669 --> 00:07:52,805 We, the jury, find the defendant Arthur Craddick... 177 00:07:55,308 --> 00:07:58,578 ...guilty of two counts of murder. 178 00:07:59,946 --> 00:08:01,747 No. 179 00:08:03,816 --> 00:08:05,585 (sobbing, sniffling) 180 00:08:06,219 --> 00:08:09,055 JUDGE: Thank you, jury, for your civic service today. 181 00:08:09,121 --> 00:08:12,558 All parties will reconvene for sentencing in two weeks. 182 00:08:12,625 --> 00:08:13,926 Court is adjourned. 183 00:08:13,993 --> 00:08:16,829 (woman continues crying) 184 00:08:16,896 --> 00:08:19,599 I didn't do it. I had nothing to do with it. 185 00:08:20,800 --> 00:08:23,669 I didn't kill your son, your granddaughter. 186 00:08:23,736 --> 00:08:25,771 (gavel banging) 187 00:08:23,736 --> 00:08:25,771 Miss, I didn't kill your husband. 188 00:08:25,838 --> 00:08:28,107 I-I don't even own a gun! I didn't... I didn't do it! 189 00:08:25,838 --> 00:08:28,107 Order! Order! 190 00:08:28,174 --> 00:08:30,576 I didn't do anything. You don't understand. 191 00:08:28,174 --> 00:08:30,576 Order in this court! 192 00:08:30,643 --> 00:08:32,712 (gavel banging) 193 00:08:30,643 --> 00:08:32,712 I didn't do it! I didn't do it. 194 00:08:32,778 --> 00:08:34,847 I didn't do it! I didn't... 195 00:08:48,961 --> 00:08:50,696 (brakes squeaking) 196 00:08:50,763 --> 00:08:52,231 DRIVER: We're here. 197 00:08:52,298 --> 00:08:55,534 Thanks. I'll probably be a while. 198 00:08:56,235 --> 00:08:58,604 (lock buzzes) 199 00:08:58,671 --> 00:09:00,273 (key rattling in lock) 200 00:09:01,107 --> 00:09:02,842 Arthur. 201 00:09:02,909 --> 00:09:05,912 Wasn't sure you'd remember me after 12 years. 202 00:09:05,978 --> 00:09:08,781 (chuckles) Well, you're looking good. I like the glasses. 203 00:09:08,848 --> 00:09:09,982 Back at you. 204 00:09:10,049 --> 00:09:12,018 (sighs): So... 205 00:09:12,084 --> 00:09:15,221 how's your son? Leo? 206 00:09:15,288 --> 00:09:16,322 (sighs) 207 00:09:16,389 --> 00:09:17,857 He's doing all right. 208 00:09:17,924 --> 00:09:19,792 Graduated from college last year. 209 00:09:19,859 --> 00:09:23,129 In a program now to become a licensed clinical social worker. 210 00:09:23,195 --> 00:09:25,264 Getting into that, uh, "good trouble" 211 00:09:25,331 --> 00:09:27,266 John Lewis talked about. 212 00:09:27,333 --> 00:09:29,602 (chuckles) Fantastic. 213 00:09:29,669 --> 00:09:31,704 When I got sent up, 214 00:09:31,771 --> 00:09:35,074 he went to stay with his great-aunt. 215 00:09:35,141 --> 00:09:36,575 Then she passed, and... 216 00:09:36,642 --> 00:09:38,244 well, he became a ward of the state, 217 00:09:38,311 --> 00:09:39,979 bounced around the foster system... 218 00:09:40,046 --> 00:09:41,080 Yeah. 219 00:09:41,147 --> 00:09:43,049 I'm sorry. 220 00:09:41,147 --> 00:09:43,049 Yeah. 221 00:09:43,115 --> 00:09:44,150 It's been tough. 222 00:09:44,216 --> 00:09:46,185 Got a lot of anger. 223 00:09:46,252 --> 00:09:49,055 But... somehow he survived. 224 00:09:49,121 --> 00:09:50,623 (sighs) 225 00:09:50,690 --> 00:09:53,292 Managed to keep our little family intact, 226 00:09:53,359 --> 00:09:56,329 even though we're not together. 227 00:09:58,898 --> 00:10:00,232 Oh. 228 00:10:01,167 --> 00:10:04,270 You're asking the court to give you a new trial? 229 00:10:04,337 --> 00:10:07,206 And you wrote this motion yourself? 230 00:10:07,273 --> 00:10:09,041 Wrote it and filed it. 231 00:10:09,108 --> 00:10:11,777 And a judge has agreed to hold a hearing. 232 00:10:11,844 --> 00:10:14,113 Impressive. 233 00:10:14,180 --> 00:10:15,648 I taught myself the law. 234 00:10:15,715 --> 00:10:17,783 Became a bona fide jailhouse lawyer. 235 00:10:17,850 --> 00:10:20,219 You know, they even nicknamed me the Counterman, 236 00:10:20,286 --> 00:10:23,789 because I helped folks out with various legal matters. 237 00:10:20,286 --> 00:10:23,789 (chuckles) 238 00:10:23,856 --> 00:10:26,158 Okay, Counterman, why'd you call me? 239 00:10:26,225 --> 00:10:28,060 I'm still not a lawyer. 240 00:10:28,127 --> 00:10:30,930 It's not like I did you much good last time. 241 00:10:30,997 --> 00:10:32,331 It wasn't you. 242 00:10:32,398 --> 00:10:33,966 It was that jury. 243 00:10:35,868 --> 00:10:38,671 I've been reading about you. 244 00:10:39,438 --> 00:10:42,108 Juries are kind of your thing now, right? 245 00:10:42,174 --> 00:10:44,276 Maybe you'll help me with that? 246 00:10:44,343 --> 00:10:47,113 Maybe you can testify 247 00:10:47,179 --> 00:10:48,914 as a character witness? 248 00:10:48,981 --> 00:10:50,049 Sure. 249 00:10:50,116 --> 00:10:53,219 But, Arthur, you're still a ways from picking a jury. 250 00:10:53,285 --> 00:10:55,221 You did get a judge 251 00:10:55,287 --> 00:10:57,690 to agree to a new hearing. 252 00:10:57,757 --> 00:10:59,358 But now you have to get that judge 253 00:10:59,425 --> 00:11:01,227 to agree to a new trial. 254 00:11:01,293 --> 00:11:04,764 And you know the first question that judge is gonna ask? 255 00:11:04,830 --> 00:11:07,933 "Have you got any new evidence?" 256 00:11:08,000 --> 00:11:10,002 So, do you? 257 00:11:11,437 --> 00:11:13,406 How about a signed confession from the man 258 00:11:13,472 --> 00:11:16,909 who really did kill Ivan and that little baby? 259 00:11:18,444 --> 00:11:20,846 ♪ ♪ 260 00:11:28,154 --> 00:11:30,356 (indistinct chatter) 261 00:11:30,423 --> 00:11:32,858 Dr. Bull? 262 00:11:33,225 --> 00:11:34,960 Ms. Morgan. 263 00:11:35,795 --> 00:11:37,196 Thanks for coming. 264 00:11:37,263 --> 00:11:39,231 I know it must seem odd getting a call from a stranger 265 00:11:39,298 --> 00:11:40,699 while you're out of town at a convention... 266 00:11:40,766 --> 00:11:42,902 I work for Homeland Security. 267 00:11:42,968 --> 00:11:44,904 Trust me, before I came down here to meet you, 268 00:11:44,970 --> 00:11:47,473 I made it my business to know far more about you 269 00:11:47,540 --> 00:11:49,275 than you're probably comfortable with. 270 00:11:49,341 --> 00:11:51,444 Well, let's hope that's a good thing. 271 00:11:51,510 --> 00:11:53,079 Now what can I do for you? 272 00:11:53,145 --> 00:11:55,481 Well, as you probably know, I'm a psychologist, 273 00:11:55,548 --> 00:11:57,917 and as it happens, 274 00:11:57,983 --> 00:12:00,019 I am here in town for a trial. 275 00:12:00,086 --> 00:12:01,987 The last few years I've been 276 00:12:02,054 --> 00:12:03,923 doing a lot of work as a... 277 00:12:03,989 --> 00:12:05,291 Expert witness. 278 00:12:05,357 --> 00:12:06,792 It's in the file. 279 00:12:06,859 --> 00:12:09,829 And I realized that this convention was in town... 280 00:12:09,895 --> 00:12:11,330 I figured that. 281 00:12:11,397 --> 00:12:13,799 Yeah, so coincidentally I've been reading a lot about you 282 00:12:13,866 --> 00:12:15,968 and your theories, and I came by the hotel here 283 00:12:16,035 --> 00:12:18,771 to pick up the convention journal, and lo and behold, 284 00:12:18,838 --> 00:12:20,473 there you were. 285 00:12:20,539 --> 00:12:22,741 Lo and behold. 286 00:12:22,808 --> 00:12:24,210 Look... 287 00:12:24,276 --> 00:12:25,478 I'm a fan. 288 00:12:25,544 --> 00:12:27,346 Of what? 289 00:12:27,413 --> 00:12:28,914 Of yours. 290 00:12:28,981 --> 00:12:30,349 Near as I can tell, you are the leading figure 291 00:12:30,416 --> 00:12:32,251 in the science of predictive behavior. 292 00:12:32,318 --> 00:12:34,954 As a matter of fact, you may be the only figure 293 00:12:35,020 --> 00:12:37,056 in the science of predictive behavior. 294 00:12:37,123 --> 00:12:38,524 Okay. 295 00:12:38,591 --> 00:12:40,993 And why do you care? 296 00:12:43,829 --> 00:12:46,265 I have an idea for a business. 297 00:12:46,332 --> 00:12:48,100 Oh, my God. 298 00:12:48,167 --> 00:12:50,269 You are not gonna pitch me your vision 299 00:12:50,336 --> 00:12:52,104 for a cutting-edge matchmaking service, 300 00:12:52,171 --> 00:12:54,340 are you, because I have heard that one five times 301 00:12:54,406 --> 00:12:56,142 in the last two years. Although to be honest, 302 00:12:56,208 --> 00:12:57,843 those guys bought me drinks and dinner 303 00:12:57,910 --> 00:12:59,979 before they brought it up. 304 00:13:00,579 --> 00:13:02,515 Let me start over. 305 00:13:02,581 --> 00:13:04,850 Before I flew to Ohio, I was involved 306 00:13:04,917 --> 00:13:06,452 in a trial in New York. 307 00:13:06,519 --> 00:13:07,820 Guy was innocent. 308 00:13:07,887 --> 00:13:09,421 The thing is... 309 00:13:09,488 --> 00:13:10,890 he had the wrong jury. 310 00:13:10,956 --> 00:13:12,224 'Cause, you see, picking 311 00:13:12,291 --> 00:13:13,993 a jury is easy. 312 00:13:14,059 --> 00:13:16,562 You just do your homework-- you follow the demographic 313 00:13:16,629 --> 00:13:19,064 and socioeconomic indicators. 314 00:13:19,131 --> 00:13:22,168 But a trial, once you've picked those people, 315 00:13:22,234 --> 00:13:24,203 well, that trial is a living, breathing thing, 316 00:13:24,270 --> 00:13:27,306 and sometimes it starts out being about one thing 317 00:13:27,373 --> 00:13:29,542 and ends up being about something else entirely. 318 00:13:29,608 --> 00:13:31,544 And you have no way of knowing 319 00:13:31,610 --> 00:13:34,146 how all this testimony and this evidence 320 00:13:34,213 --> 00:13:37,049 is affecting that group of people you've selected. 321 00:13:37,116 --> 00:13:39,385 You're in the dark. 322 00:13:41,053 --> 00:13:42,922 But what if you weren't? 323 00:13:42,988 --> 00:13:44,823 What if you had a window 324 00:13:44,890 --> 00:13:46,392 into how they were feeling? 325 00:13:46,458 --> 00:13:48,227 What they were thinking. 326 00:13:48,294 --> 00:13:50,996 And what if you could use that information 327 00:13:51,063 --> 00:13:53,532 to adjust your trial strategy 328 00:13:53,599 --> 00:13:55,301 accordingly? 329 00:13:55,367 --> 00:13:56,569 What if 330 00:13:56,635 --> 00:13:59,972 you could... 331 00:13:56,635 --> 00:13:59,972 Predict their behavior. 332 00:14:01,373 --> 00:14:04,843 Now would be a really good time to buy me that drink. 333 00:14:04,910 --> 00:14:07,112 (elevator bell dings) 334 00:14:14,954 --> 00:14:16,322 Excuse me? 335 00:14:16,388 --> 00:14:17,990 Morning. 336 00:14:18,057 --> 00:14:21,060 My name's Leo Craddick. I'm Arthur Craddick's son. 337 00:14:22,094 --> 00:14:23,929 This is what we call the mock courtroom. 338 00:14:23,996 --> 00:14:25,531 When there's no pandemic, what we do is 339 00:14:25,598 --> 00:14:28,067 we recruit people to come down here and pretend to be jurors. 340 00:14:28,133 --> 00:14:31,437 We also audition trial strategies. 341 00:14:31,503 --> 00:14:33,872 Closing arguments. 342 00:14:33,939 --> 00:14:35,941 Sometimes we rehearse witnesses. 343 00:14:36,008 --> 00:14:38,911 Get 'em used to the idea of offering testimony. 344 00:14:38,978 --> 00:14:41,880 I didn't even know places like this existed. 345 00:14:43,282 --> 00:14:44,483 Listen... 346 00:14:44,550 --> 00:14:48,120 truth is, we have no money for any of this. 347 00:14:48,187 --> 00:14:50,155 Well, isn't that serendipitous? 348 00:14:50,222 --> 00:14:53,158 I don't want any money for any of this. 349 00:14:54,126 --> 00:14:56,662 Look... in a lot of ways, your dad 350 00:14:56,729 --> 00:14:59,231 was the inspiration for all this. 351 00:14:59,298 --> 00:15:01,267 I remember sitting there at his trial, 352 00:15:01,333 --> 00:15:03,435 realizing there was nothing I could do, 353 00:15:03,502 --> 00:15:05,404 and it... (sighs) 354 00:15:05,471 --> 00:15:08,173 well, it made me feel so helpless. 355 00:15:08,240 --> 00:15:10,376 And I suddenly thought to myself... 356 00:15:10,442 --> 00:15:13,379 maybe it's time to try something different. 357 00:15:13,445 --> 00:15:15,114 I'm just saying... 358 00:15:15,180 --> 00:15:16,615 we've got a written confession. 359 00:15:16,682 --> 00:15:19,251 I'm not sure we're going to be needing any of this. 360 00:15:19,318 --> 00:15:21,520 Trust me, you're gonna need all the help you can get. 361 00:15:21,587 --> 00:15:24,356 If you want to win the motion for a new trial, 362 00:15:24,423 --> 00:15:26,058 that judge is going to have to find 363 00:15:26,125 --> 00:15:27,459 that the confession is admissible. 364 00:15:27,526 --> 00:15:29,295 That the witness is credible. 365 00:15:29,361 --> 00:15:31,597 Signing a piece of paper is one thing, but getting up there 366 00:15:31,664 --> 00:15:33,465 in court, saying it out loud, convincingly, 367 00:15:33,532 --> 00:15:36,268 under the pressure of a tough cross-exam, 368 00:15:36,335 --> 00:15:38,470 that is a whole nother ball of wax. 369 00:15:39,438 --> 00:15:41,974 Is there any way I can see the confession? 370 00:15:42,041 --> 00:15:45,577 Any way my people could meet this fella? 371 00:15:45,644 --> 00:15:48,414 So the confession is from a contract killer? 372 00:15:48,480 --> 00:15:50,049 A mob hit man? 373 00:15:50,115 --> 00:15:52,551 Yep. Turns out everybody had it wrong. 374 00:15:52,618 --> 00:15:54,687 They all figured it to be one of the business owners 375 00:15:54,753 --> 00:15:57,122 that killed Ivan to put a stop to the shakedowns. 376 00:15:57,189 --> 00:15:59,124 Turns out it was about territory. 377 00:15:59,191 --> 00:16:01,226 The mob wanted a piece of Ivan's action, 378 00:16:01,293 --> 00:16:03,462 and Ivan wasn't down with that. 379 00:16:03,529 --> 00:16:04,596 So they killed him. 380 00:16:04,663 --> 00:16:06,131 Sure did. 381 00:16:06,198 --> 00:16:07,566 And his baby. 382 00:16:07,633 --> 00:16:09,668 And exactly why is this contract killer confessing? 383 00:16:09,735 --> 00:16:13,038 I mean, according to this file, he's only 42 years old. 384 00:16:13,105 --> 00:16:14,340 Doesn't he get that he'll probably 385 00:16:14,406 --> 00:16:16,141 spend the rest of his life in prison? 386 00:16:16,208 --> 00:16:17,710 Did I not mention 387 00:16:17,776 --> 00:16:19,745 he's dying? 388 00:16:19,812 --> 00:16:23,282 KIRIL: 47 men. 389 00:16:23,349 --> 00:16:25,384 47... 390 00:16:26,352 --> 00:16:29,288 But Ivan was easy to track. 391 00:16:29,355 --> 00:16:31,390 Careless. 392 00:16:33,692 --> 00:16:36,595 Bravado with no brains. 393 00:16:36,662 --> 00:16:39,565 I remember thinking... 394 00:16:39,631 --> 00:16:42,267 that killing Ivan Kovolchuk 395 00:16:42,334 --> 00:16:45,571 would be the easiest $25,000 396 00:16:45,637 --> 00:16:47,206 I would ever make. 397 00:16:47,272 --> 00:16:49,775 So let's talk about the murders. 398 00:16:49,842 --> 00:16:52,077 No. Not murders. 399 00:16:52,144 --> 00:16:53,712 Murder. 400 00:16:53,779 --> 00:16:56,248 One-- Ivan. 401 00:16:56,315 --> 00:16:59,752 The baby girl wasn't... 402 00:16:59,818 --> 00:17:02,187 I didn't know she was there. 403 00:17:02,254 --> 00:17:05,424 She was an accident. 404 00:17:06,492 --> 00:17:07,760 A mistake. 405 00:17:07,826 --> 00:17:10,129 I don't deny 406 00:17:10,195 --> 00:17:12,598 pulling the trigger, but... 407 00:17:14,299 --> 00:17:18,103 ...there is no greater insult to God 408 00:17:18,170 --> 00:17:21,140 than to kill one of his babies. 409 00:17:21,206 --> 00:17:24,376 No matter how much I try 410 00:17:24,443 --> 00:17:28,414 to atone for that child's death... 411 00:17:28,480 --> 00:17:31,116 God always 412 00:17:31,183 --> 00:17:33,719 gets the last word. 413 00:17:33,786 --> 00:17:36,588 Myeloma. 414 00:17:37,856 --> 00:17:40,592 Blood cancer. 415 00:17:50,569 --> 00:17:51,603 Mr. Colón? 416 00:17:51,670 --> 00:17:53,071 Any idea when 417 00:17:53,138 --> 00:17:54,773 your witness plans on making an appearance? 418 00:17:54,840 --> 00:17:57,242 We've been sitting here for half an hour. 419 00:17:57,309 --> 00:17:59,144 (clears throat) 420 00:17:59,211 --> 00:18:01,413 Uh, yes, yes, of course, Your Honor. 421 00:18:01,480 --> 00:18:04,283 Well, we are doing everything we can 422 00:18:04,349 --> 00:18:05,384 to locate him. 423 00:18:05,451 --> 00:18:07,286 I do apologize 424 00:18:07,352 --> 00:18:09,121 for the delay. 425 00:18:12,157 --> 00:18:14,560 (clears throat) 426 00:18:14,626 --> 00:18:16,295 I don't understand. 427 00:18:16,361 --> 00:18:17,696 You said you hired 428 00:18:17,763 --> 00:18:18,831 an ambulance to bring him here. 429 00:18:17,763 --> 00:18:18,831 (phone buzzing) 430 00:18:18,897 --> 00:18:20,866 How do you lose an ambulance? 431 00:18:23,902 --> 00:18:25,704 (whispering): Danny, where the hell are you? 432 00:18:25,771 --> 00:18:28,273 I've been waiting... 433 00:18:25,771 --> 00:18:28,273 DANNY: He's dead, Bull. 434 00:18:28,340 --> 00:18:29,875 We were going through the Midtown Tunnel and he just 435 00:18:29,942 --> 00:18:32,478 started gasping for breath and... 436 00:18:32,544 --> 00:18:34,279 then he just died. 437 00:18:34,346 --> 00:18:36,515 Even with rush hour traffic with the siren on, 438 00:18:36,582 --> 00:18:38,183 we couldn't get out of the tunnel. 439 00:18:38,250 --> 00:18:40,486 I-I couldn't get cell service and... 440 00:18:40,552 --> 00:18:43,655 We need to talk to the judge. 441 00:18:44,490 --> 00:18:47,326 I don't deny pulling the trigger, 442 00:18:47,392 --> 00:18:50,529 but... there is no greater 443 00:18:50,596 --> 00:18:52,631 insult to God than to kill 444 00:18:52,698 --> 00:18:54,700 one of his babies. 445 00:18:54,766 --> 00:18:57,469 No matter how much I try 446 00:18:57,536 --> 00:19:00,339 to atone for that child's 447 00:19:00,405 --> 00:19:01,707 death... 448 00:19:01,773 --> 00:19:04,877 God always gets 449 00:19:04,943 --> 00:19:07,479 the last word. 450 00:19:07,546 --> 00:19:10,549 Myeloma. 451 00:19:10,616 --> 00:19:13,485 Blood cancer. 452 00:19:13,552 --> 00:19:16,688 Ms. Glover, I'll hear you next. 453 00:19:18,423 --> 00:19:20,192 Thank you. 454 00:19:20,259 --> 00:19:22,394 Your Honor, the People urge you 455 00:19:22,461 --> 00:19:25,264 to deny this motion on the grounds that this new evidence 456 00:19:25,330 --> 00:19:28,433 is-- despite what Mr. Craddick's attorneys may say-- 457 00:19:28,500 --> 00:19:30,369 rank hearsay. 458 00:19:30,435 --> 00:19:32,371 We were not given the opportunity to be present 459 00:19:32,437 --> 00:19:34,773 when the declarant gave his so-called confession. 460 00:19:34,840 --> 00:19:37,309 And consequently we were not able 461 00:19:37,376 --> 00:19:38,877 to cross-examine him. 462 00:19:38,944 --> 00:19:41,914 Your Honor... (scoffs) no one wishes that Mr. Sidorenko 463 00:19:41,980 --> 00:19:45,384 was alive and here today more than we do. 464 00:19:45,450 --> 00:19:48,887 These are obviously extenuating circumstances. 465 00:19:48,954 --> 00:19:50,722 I... 466 00:19:51,823 --> 00:19:54,192 Even setting that aside, 467 00:19:54,259 --> 00:19:58,297 this alleged new evidence is less a dying declaration 468 00:19:58,363 --> 00:20:00,232 and more like a deathbed fairy tale, 469 00:20:00,299 --> 00:20:03,268 replete with melodrama and a third act reversal. 470 00:20:03,335 --> 00:20:06,271 We're expected to take the word of a criminal? 471 00:20:06,338 --> 00:20:09,341 An accomplished liar? A professional killer? 472 00:20:09,408 --> 00:20:12,411 This man was paid to murder people-- he could just 473 00:20:12,477 --> 00:20:14,313 as easily have been paid to lie on that video. 474 00:20:14,379 --> 00:20:15,948 And given his illness, 475 00:20:16,014 --> 00:20:18,283 Mr. Sidorenko had nothing to lose. 476 00:20:18,350 --> 00:20:20,319 For that reason alone, 477 00:20:20,385 --> 00:20:21,720 we beseech Your Honor 478 00:20:21,787 --> 00:20:23,755 to dismiss this motion for a new trial. 479 00:20:23,822 --> 00:20:26,458 There is no new evidence here. 480 00:20:26,525 --> 00:20:28,560 Just new distractions. 481 00:20:28,627 --> 00:20:31,430 New... distortions. 482 00:20:31,496 --> 00:20:32,831 Thank you, Counselor. 483 00:20:32,898 --> 00:20:35,567 The court would like to take a brief recess 484 00:20:35,634 --> 00:20:38,837 to consider both the legal briefs and this new evidence. 485 00:20:38,904 --> 00:20:41,940 Let's reconvene in 30 minutes. 486 00:20:42,007 --> 00:20:44,676 Call it. 487 00:20:42,007 --> 00:20:44,676 Can't. We made a compelling argument, 488 00:20:44,743 --> 00:20:46,311 but so did the A.D.A. 489 00:20:46,378 --> 00:20:48,313 I hear you. I wish I had a better sense of the judge. 490 00:20:48,380 --> 00:20:49,414 You guys are crazy. 491 00:20:49,481 --> 00:20:50,882 It's done. It's over. 492 00:20:50,949 --> 00:20:52,751 My father is coming home. 493 00:20:52,818 --> 00:20:54,886 People know the truth when they hear it. 494 00:20:54,953 --> 00:20:57,489 Did you see the look on the face of his widow? 495 00:20:57,556 --> 00:20:58,790 On his mother? 496 00:20:58,857 --> 00:21:00,525 Leo, they're not the ones 497 00:21:00,592 --> 00:21:01,860 deciding whether we get a new trial. 498 00:21:01,927 --> 00:21:04,029 (elevator bell dings) 499 00:21:06,765 --> 00:21:10,402 LEO: Hey, Detective Kaminsky. 500 00:21:12,604 --> 00:21:14,940 I'm sorry. One of you call my name? 501 00:21:15,007 --> 00:21:17,442 I did. My name's Leo Craddick. 502 00:21:17,509 --> 00:21:18,543 No. Leo... 503 00:21:18,610 --> 00:21:19,878 I'm Arthur Craddick's son. 504 00:21:19,945 --> 00:21:21,947 The little boy whose father you locked up 505 00:21:22,014 --> 00:21:23,548 for something he didn't do? 506 00:21:23,615 --> 00:21:24,916 Today's the day, Kaminsky. 507 00:21:24,983 --> 00:21:27,019 There's gonna be a reckoning. 508 00:21:27,085 --> 00:21:29,287 A reckoning? 509 00:21:27,085 --> 00:21:29,287 You heard me. 510 00:21:29,354 --> 00:21:31,790 Cops who put innocent people behind bars need 511 00:21:31,857 --> 00:21:34,359 to face consequences-- professional consequences, 512 00:21:34,426 --> 00:21:37,329 financial consequences, legal consequences-- 513 00:21:37,396 --> 00:21:38,563 and you're going to. 514 00:21:38,630 --> 00:21:39,998 You gentlemen heard that, right? 515 00:21:40,065 --> 00:21:44,403 This young man just threatened me. 516 00:21:44,469 --> 00:21:45,537 The judge is back. 517 00:21:45,604 --> 00:21:47,873 Judge is back. 518 00:21:47,939 --> 00:21:50,809 Nice to see you again, Leo. 519 00:21:53,078 --> 00:21:54,646 (whispering): What the hell was that? 520 00:21:54,713 --> 00:21:56,815 Uh... 521 00:21:54,713 --> 00:21:56,815 That cannot happen again. 522 00:21:57,849 --> 00:22:00,085 CONWAY: A.D.A. Glover, Mr. Colón, 523 00:22:00,152 --> 00:22:03,388 I've read your briefs and heard the arguments. 524 00:22:03,455 --> 00:22:06,758 (quietly): Hey. 525 00:22:03,455 --> 00:22:06,758 On reflection, I find 526 00:22:06,825 --> 00:22:08,727 Mr. Sidorenko's statement highly troubling. 527 00:22:08,794 --> 00:22:12,864 Frankly, it begs many more questions than it answers. 528 00:22:12,931 --> 00:22:15,434 But given the People's lack of access 529 00:22:15,500 --> 00:22:16,968 to the witness when he was available, 530 00:22:17,035 --> 00:22:18,870 I find the evidence falls short 531 00:22:18,937 --> 00:22:21,940 of meeting the court's definition of "substantial." 532 00:22:22,007 --> 00:22:23,508 And so, the motion 533 00:22:23,575 --> 00:22:25,877 for a new trial is denied without prejudice. 534 00:22:25,944 --> 00:22:27,879 If any more evidence 535 00:22:27,946 --> 00:22:30,515 comes to light, you can file a new motion. 536 00:22:34,152 --> 00:22:36,722 Move for a sentence review. Argue substantial assistance. 537 00:22:36,788 --> 00:22:37,989 Do it now. 538 00:22:38,056 --> 00:22:41,126 (clears throat) Uh, Your Honor, I ask 539 00:22:41,193 --> 00:22:43,562 that the court please consider a reduction 540 00:22:43,628 --> 00:22:45,430 of Mr. Craddick's sentence. 541 00:22:45,497 --> 00:22:47,432 On what grounds? 542 00:22:47,499 --> 00:22:50,469 Well, Mr. Sidorenko's sworn testimony details other murders 543 00:22:50,535 --> 00:22:53,138 he committed, murders never solved by the police. 544 00:22:53,205 --> 00:22:57,075 By tracking down Mr. Sidorenko, Mr. Craddick has, in effect, 545 00:22:57,142 --> 00:22:59,444 offered substantial assistance to law enforcement. 546 00:22:59,511 --> 00:23:00,979 And as I'm sure you're aware, 547 00:23:01,046 --> 00:23:04,049 that qualifies him for a reduced sentence. 548 00:23:04,116 --> 00:23:06,918 Your Honor, the People strenuously object. 549 00:23:06,985 --> 00:23:09,087 This is obviously a cheap ploy 550 00:23:09,154 --> 00:23:10,922 by Mr. Craddick's lawyers. Just... 551 00:23:14,826 --> 00:23:18,396 The motion for a new trial was actually a very close call. 552 00:23:18,463 --> 00:23:21,733 So I will allow your motion, Mr. Colón, 553 00:23:21,800 --> 00:23:24,836 and reduce Mr. Craddick's sentence from 25 years to life, 554 00:23:24,903 --> 00:23:28,140 down to 18 years to 25 years. 555 00:23:28,206 --> 00:23:31,543 Ladies and gentlemen, this court is adjourned. 556 00:23:33,211 --> 00:23:34,746 (Benny chuckles) 557 00:23:33,211 --> 00:23:34,746 BULL: All right. 558 00:23:34,813 --> 00:23:36,748 Why does everyone look so happy? 559 00:23:36,815 --> 00:23:38,650 Pops is still locked up for years. 560 00:23:38,717 --> 00:23:40,986 Actually, if I remember my penal code correctly, 561 00:23:41,052 --> 00:23:43,054 18 to 25 means I... 562 00:23:43,121 --> 00:23:46,858 Could be immediately released from prison on parole. 563 00:23:46,925 --> 00:23:48,760 (laughs softly) 564 00:23:52,864 --> 00:23:54,032 Back in my law clinic days, 565 00:23:54,099 --> 00:23:55,934 I helped some inmates prep for parole. 566 00:23:56,001 --> 00:23:57,636 Saw the system from the inside. 567 00:23:57,702 --> 00:23:58,837 It's not pretty. 568 00:23:58,904 --> 00:24:00,172 How do you mean? 569 00:23:58,904 --> 00:24:00,172 Well, 570 00:24:00,238 --> 00:24:04,876 the decisions tend to be really random, inconsistent. 571 00:24:04,943 --> 00:24:08,480 And from what I saw, a Black inmate is twice as likely 572 00:24:08,547 --> 00:24:10,482 as a white one to be denied parole, 573 00:24:10,549 --> 00:24:12,617 and that's for the exact same crime. 574 00:24:13,819 --> 00:24:16,154 Uh, any more good news? 575 00:24:16,221 --> 00:24:18,523 Well, for starters, 576 00:24:18,590 --> 00:24:21,893 everything that we're doing here is completely irrelevant. 577 00:24:21,960 --> 00:24:25,597 There's no voir dire, there's no cross-examining anyone, 578 00:24:25,664 --> 00:24:27,199 there's no rebuttal of witnesses. 579 00:24:27,265 --> 00:24:29,935 Parole decisions are not subject to due process, 580 00:24:30,001 --> 00:24:32,470 which means the inmates can't even appeal. 581 00:24:32,537 --> 00:24:35,540 Look, I'm sorry, but I'm worried 582 00:24:35,607 --> 00:24:39,110 that we're bringing trial science to a knife fight. 583 00:24:39,945 --> 00:24:41,780 Should we talk about the three parole commissioners 584 00:24:41,847 --> 00:24:43,181 Bull, Benny and Arthur will be facing? 585 00:24:43,248 --> 00:24:46,484 I got these names from the prison administrator 586 00:24:46,551 --> 00:24:47,953 about an hour ago. 587 00:24:48,019 --> 00:24:50,655 You are looking at a former prosecutor, 588 00:24:50,722 --> 00:24:55,227 a retired family court judge, and a retired police captain. 589 00:24:55,293 --> 00:24:57,262 Oh, my people. (laughs) 590 00:24:57,329 --> 00:24:58,797 N-No. 591 00:25:00,065 --> 00:25:03,235 How in the hell is Arthur gonna get two of these three folks 592 00:25:03,301 --> 00:25:04,669 to be on his side? 593 00:25:04,736 --> 00:25:06,671 Come on. It is not as bad as all that. 594 00:25:06,738 --> 00:25:09,507 Arthur has a clean disciplinary record, 595 00:25:09,574 --> 00:25:12,711 a near-perfect score on the recidivism risk exam, 596 00:25:12,777 --> 00:25:15,080 and an impressive parole plan. 597 00:25:15,146 --> 00:25:17,883 Marissa, we're talking about a Black man 598 00:25:17,949 --> 00:25:20,952 who has already been found guilty of a double murder. 599 00:25:21,019 --> 00:25:23,655 The chance of these three telling him 600 00:25:23,722 --> 00:25:24,890 he can go home early? 601 00:25:24,956 --> 00:25:27,158 I'm thinking slim to none. 602 00:25:28,894 --> 00:25:30,562 You ever been to one of these? 603 00:25:30,629 --> 00:25:31,696 A parole hearing? 604 00:25:30,629 --> 00:25:31,696 Mm. 605 00:25:31,763 --> 00:25:33,231 Yup, I've testified. 606 00:25:33,298 --> 00:25:35,100 But only as a prosecutor. 607 00:25:35,166 --> 00:25:37,802 And I was in and out. Said my piece, and I left. 608 00:25:37,869 --> 00:25:39,170 Oh, I've been doing a lot of research, 609 00:25:39,237 --> 00:25:40,305 talking to a lot of people. 610 00:25:40,372 --> 00:25:42,173 It's a weird beast. 611 00:25:40,372 --> 00:25:42,173 How do you mean? 612 00:25:42,240 --> 00:25:43,875 There's this unspoken rule. 613 00:25:43,942 --> 00:25:46,111 Turns out parole is premised on guilt 614 00:25:46,177 --> 00:25:48,713 and contingent on expressing remorse. 615 00:25:48,780 --> 00:25:50,215 I'm not following. 616 00:25:50,282 --> 00:25:52,317 Well, the trap a lot of inmates fall into is 617 00:25:52,384 --> 00:25:53,852 they try to relitigate their crime. 618 00:25:53,919 --> 00:25:55,887 They deny that they did it, and apparently 619 00:25:55,954 --> 00:25:57,255 the second the commissioners hear that, 620 00:25:57,322 --> 00:26:00,158 they instantly deny the petitioner parole. 621 00:26:00,225 --> 00:26:01,593 So wait a second. 622 00:26:01,660 --> 00:26:03,094 So, when Arthur gets up there to speak, 623 00:26:03,161 --> 00:26:05,563 what's he supposed to say-- "I did it"? 624 00:26:05,630 --> 00:26:06,865 Well, based on what I'm hearing, 625 00:26:06,932 --> 00:26:08,867 these commissioners are expecting an apology 626 00:26:08,934 --> 00:26:10,602 for a crime our client didn't commit. 627 00:26:10,669 --> 00:26:11,903 So what do we do? 628 00:26:11,970 --> 00:26:14,105 Advise him to lie so he can get out of prison, 629 00:26:14,172 --> 00:26:17,309 or tell the truth and kill his chances for parole? 630 00:26:17,375 --> 00:26:18,944 Neither. I think what we have 631 00:26:19,010 --> 00:26:21,146 to do is construct a permission structure. 632 00:26:21,212 --> 00:26:22,314 A what? 633 00:26:22,380 --> 00:26:23,615 (lock buzzes, latch clicks) 634 00:26:23,682 --> 00:26:24,849 Permission structure. 635 00:26:24,916 --> 00:26:26,284 It's a way of giving people permission 636 00:26:26,351 --> 00:26:27,752 to embrace a decision that, 637 00:26:27,819 --> 00:26:29,187 on its face, seems counterintuitive. 638 00:26:29,254 --> 00:26:31,957 A decision that they think they came to on their own, 639 00:26:32,023 --> 00:26:34,592 even though we placed the seeds to make it possible. 640 00:26:34,659 --> 00:26:35,961 (lock buzzes) 641 00:26:38,229 --> 00:26:39,831 Good afternoon. 642 00:26:39,898 --> 00:26:43,034 My name is Leo Craddick, and I'm Arthur Craddick's son. 643 00:26:43,101 --> 00:26:47,072 Before my father was arrested, I played baseball as a kid, 644 00:26:47,138 --> 00:26:49,841 and my dad was my Little League coach. 645 00:26:49,908 --> 00:26:52,043 Before every game, he'd gather us 646 00:26:52,110 --> 00:26:56,014 around and say "Swing hard, boys, swing hard." 647 00:26:56,081 --> 00:26:59,050 That's what he's done behind bars. 648 00:26:59,117 --> 00:27:01,052 Never stopped being a parent, 649 00:27:01,119 --> 00:27:03,888 never stopped loving me. 650 00:27:01,119 --> 00:27:03,888 Do you see Kovolchuk's widow here? 651 00:27:03,955 --> 00:27:06,291 12 years of prison is enough to break most anyone's soul. 652 00:27:06,358 --> 00:27:07,792 No. 653 00:27:07,859 --> 00:27:09,361 But my father's never broke. 654 00:27:09,427 --> 00:27:11,730 He taught himself the law. 655 00:27:11,796 --> 00:27:14,265 He made it his business to finish college. 656 00:27:14,332 --> 00:27:16,034 And upon his release, 657 00:27:16,101 --> 00:27:19,871 he plans to attend night classes at Hudson University Law School 658 00:27:19,938 --> 00:27:22,340 while working part-time as a warehouse clerk. 659 00:27:22,407 --> 00:27:25,710 I've asked him to come live with me, become part of my household. 660 00:27:25,777 --> 00:27:30,682 Maybe even make up for some of the 12 years that we've lost. 661 00:27:30,749 --> 00:27:32,384 I hope you'll agree that our parole plan includes 662 00:27:32,450 --> 00:27:35,920 every necessary element for a successful transition. 663 00:27:35,987 --> 00:27:38,156 Work, family, ambition. 664 00:27:38,223 --> 00:27:41,860 I'm taking it on faith that you're sitting there 665 00:27:41,926 --> 00:27:43,028 because you believe in the power 666 00:27:43,094 --> 00:27:44,429 of second chances. 667 00:27:44,496 --> 00:27:47,265 That you believe in the power of redemption. 668 00:27:47,332 --> 00:27:49,167 That you believe that a man's ability 669 00:27:49,234 --> 00:27:51,770 to make a contribution to society lasts 670 00:27:51,836 --> 00:27:54,039 as long as he draws breath. 671 00:27:54,839 --> 00:27:57,242 My father's ready. 672 00:27:57,308 --> 00:28:02,147 Please extend this opportunity to him. 673 00:28:02,213 --> 00:28:04,149 You will not regret it. 674 00:28:04,215 --> 00:28:07,385 Society will not regret it. 675 00:28:09,521 --> 00:28:12,057 Thank you for your time. 676 00:28:13,892 --> 00:28:15,760 Thank you, Mr. Craddick. 677 00:28:27,806 --> 00:28:31,876 (Karine sniffles) 678 00:28:31,943 --> 00:28:33,878 (clears throat) 679 00:28:33,945 --> 00:28:38,183 Ivan was a happy little boy 680 00:28:38,249 --> 00:28:42,821 who maybe went wild as a teenager. 681 00:28:42,887 --> 00:28:45,824 Did bad things, yes. 682 00:28:45,890 --> 00:28:47,826 But was a wonderful father. 683 00:28:47,892 --> 00:28:50,261 His little girl Galina, 684 00:28:50,328 --> 00:28:54,165 my Galishka, should have turned 13 this month. 685 00:28:54,232 --> 00:28:57,235 Eighth grade. Sleepovers, school dances. 686 00:28:57,302 --> 00:29:01,506 All of it destroyed... 687 00:29:01,573 --> 00:29:03,141 by Arthur Craddick. 688 00:29:03,208 --> 00:29:06,077 He took my son. 689 00:29:06,144 --> 00:29:08,313 He took my granddaughter. 690 00:29:08,379 --> 00:29:11,049 The dead don't get a voice. 691 00:29:11,116 --> 00:29:14,085 So it's for them that I beg you. 692 00:29:14,152 --> 00:29:19,124 Do not release the man who assassinated Ivan and Galina. 693 00:29:35,573 --> 00:29:37,008 (crying quietly) 694 00:29:37,075 --> 00:29:38,810 BULL: Marissa? 695 00:29:38,877 --> 00:29:41,146 Listen, do me a favor. 696 00:29:41,212 --> 00:29:44,282 Ivan's wife, the little girl's mother-- 697 00:29:44,349 --> 00:29:48,286 Zasha Kovolchuk-- she didn't show up today. 698 00:29:48,353 --> 00:29:51,256 That's odd. She attended every day of the original trial 699 00:29:51,322 --> 00:29:52,957 and the motion hearing, didn't she? 700 00:29:53,024 --> 00:29:54,325 She sure did. 701 00:29:54,392 --> 00:29:56,361 So, what's more important to her 702 00:29:56,427 --> 00:29:58,963 than testifying against Arthur's release? 703 00:29:59,030 --> 00:30:01,132 I'll ask Taylor to look into it. 704 00:30:01,199 --> 00:30:05,036 Hate to admit it, but this contract killer, 705 00:30:05,103 --> 00:30:08,373 Kiril Sidorenko, was very good at his job. 706 00:30:08,439 --> 00:30:10,441 I love a good inspirational success story. 707 00:30:10,508 --> 00:30:11,576 How do you mean? 708 00:30:11,643 --> 00:30:13,978 Well, the guy never established a signature pattern 709 00:30:14,045 --> 00:30:15,046 that the cops could latch onto. 710 00:30:15,113 --> 00:30:17,448 Never did the same thing twice. 711 00:30:17,515 --> 00:30:19,984 I have been through every murder he's been accused of, 712 00:30:20,051 --> 00:30:22,020 including the ones he admitted to in his taped confession, 713 00:30:22,086 --> 00:30:24,055 and there's nothing concrete that ties those killings 714 00:30:24,122 --> 00:30:25,557 to the Kovolchuk murders. 715 00:30:25,623 --> 00:30:26,591 Any news from the front? 716 00:30:26,658 --> 00:30:28,359 Bull is suddenly very interested 717 00:30:28,426 --> 00:30:31,129 in Zasha Kovolchuk, Ivan's widow. 718 00:30:31,196 --> 00:30:33,064 Why? What did she do to get his attention? 719 00:30:33,131 --> 00:30:35,200 She was not at the hearing today, 720 00:30:35,266 --> 00:30:37,969 and Bull wants to know why. 721 00:30:38,036 --> 00:30:39,170 Maybe she had to work. 722 00:30:39,237 --> 00:30:41,940 Let's find out. 723 00:30:42,006 --> 00:30:44,943 According to the background file I've been compiling on her, 724 00:30:45,009 --> 00:30:47,111 at the time of the murders, and for years after, 725 00:30:47,178 --> 00:30:48,379 she worked as a cashier 726 00:30:48,446 --> 00:30:50,481 at a Russian bakery in Little Ukraine. 727 00:30:50,548 --> 00:30:51,950 And now? 728 00:30:52,016 --> 00:30:53,518 Give me a sec. 729 00:30:53,585 --> 00:30:56,054 33, never married or had another child. 730 00:30:56,120 --> 00:30:57,989 What about work? 731 00:30:58,056 --> 00:30:59,224 Or maybe she moved away. 732 00:30:59,290 --> 00:31:00,625 What's her current address? 733 00:30:59,290 --> 00:31:00,625 Oh. 734 00:31:00,692 --> 00:31:03,595 Apparently, Zasha Kovolchuk owns a two-bedroom, 735 00:31:03,661 --> 00:31:06,531 two-and-a-half-bath condominium in Syosset, Long Island 736 00:31:06,598 --> 00:31:08,233 for which she paid a lot of money. 737 00:31:08,299 --> 00:31:09,901 How much is a lot? 738 00:31:09,968 --> 00:31:12,003 More than your place is worth. 739 00:31:12,604 --> 00:31:15,573 Sorry. I had to look it up when we were defending you and Greg. 740 00:31:15,640 --> 00:31:17,408 She also owns 741 00:31:17,475 --> 00:31:20,245 a small chain of Russian bakeries in the tristate area. 742 00:31:20,311 --> 00:31:22,247 Uh, a chain? How is that possible? 743 00:31:22,313 --> 00:31:23,548 You just said she was a cashier. 744 00:31:23,615 --> 00:31:25,383 GLOVER: Good morning, commissioners. 745 00:31:25,450 --> 00:31:27,552 This case is tragically simple. 746 00:31:27,619 --> 00:31:30,121 Two people, a young man and his baby, 747 00:31:30,188 --> 00:31:32,390 were gunned down in cold blood. 748 00:31:32,457 --> 00:31:35,193 This was a crime for which a judge saw fit 749 00:31:35,260 --> 00:31:37,195 to give Arthur Craddick a life sentence. 750 00:31:37,262 --> 00:31:39,597 And the only reason that we're here today even 751 00:31:39,664 --> 00:31:41,566 entertaining this parole, is because, 752 00:31:41,633 --> 00:31:44,168 through no effort on Arthur Craddick's behalf, 753 00:31:44,235 --> 00:31:46,571 a dying, hired contract killer confessed 754 00:31:46,638 --> 00:31:49,674 to some other unsolved murders that the police were anxious 755 00:31:49,741 --> 00:31:52,443 to get off their dockets. 756 00:31:52,510 --> 00:31:53,678 And as for 757 00:31:53,745 --> 00:31:58,283 Mr. Craddick's parole plan, let's review it one more time. 758 00:31:58,349 --> 00:32:01,552 As it turns out, Hudson University Law School 759 00:32:01,619 --> 00:32:03,488 has just informed us that they are 760 00:32:03,554 --> 00:32:05,390 withdrawing Arthur Craddick's acceptance 761 00:32:05,456 --> 00:32:07,625 upon learning of his conviction for double murder. 762 00:32:07,692 --> 00:32:11,262 We've also been informed that the warehouse manager 763 00:32:11,329 --> 00:32:12,597 who had offered a job to Mr. Craddick 764 00:32:12,664 --> 00:32:14,565 is likewise withdrawing the offer 765 00:32:14,632 --> 00:32:17,468 after learning that he was convicted of killing a child. 766 00:32:17,535 --> 00:32:20,571 And here, Leo's landlord, 767 00:32:20,638 --> 00:32:22,507 with a duty to protect his other tenants 768 00:32:22,573 --> 00:32:26,444 from a convicted murderer, has now changed his mind. 769 00:32:26,511 --> 00:32:30,581 And will evict Leo if, in fact, Arthur moves in. 770 00:32:31,416 --> 00:32:33,418 Let there be no ambiguity. 771 00:32:33,484 --> 00:32:35,620 Mr. Craddick is a remorseless killer 772 00:32:35,687 --> 00:32:38,122 who, without a home or a job or a purpose, 773 00:32:38,189 --> 00:32:42,393 is not at all poised to successfully reenter society. 774 00:32:46,731 --> 00:32:48,266 I don't understand. 775 00:32:48,333 --> 00:32:49,701 Why are they doing this? 776 00:32:49,767 --> 00:32:52,036 Who are they protecting? 777 00:32:52,103 --> 00:32:53,571 Themselves. 778 00:32:58,276 --> 00:33:00,211 So, last night, while I was trying to find out 779 00:33:00,278 --> 00:33:01,546 everything I could about Zasha Kovolchuk 780 00:33:01,612 --> 00:33:03,281 and how she could afford such a nice home 781 00:33:03,348 --> 00:33:06,984 and so many businesses, I discovered the damnedest thing. 782 00:33:07,051 --> 00:33:09,220 Starting right after the murders, Zasha received 783 00:33:09,287 --> 00:33:12,056 monthly cash payments in amounts ranging from $4,000 784 00:33:12,123 --> 00:33:13,991 to $6,000 from... 785 00:33:14,058 --> 00:33:15,360 You're gonna love this. 786 00:33:15,426 --> 00:33:17,095 ...her husband's assassin, 787 00:33:17,161 --> 00:33:18,996 the late Kiril Sidorenko. 788 00:33:19,063 --> 00:33:20,665 Excuse me? 789 00:33:21,499 --> 00:33:24,102 So, what did he say on that tape? 790 00:33:24,168 --> 00:33:27,672 "No matter how much I have tried to atone for Galina's death..." 791 00:33:27,739 --> 00:33:31,542 He didn't say "repent," he said "atone," which... 792 00:33:31,609 --> 00:33:36,547 is a debt of forgiveness that can never truly be repaid. 793 00:33:36,614 --> 00:33:40,418 So... Kiril Sidorenko tried, in his own way, 794 00:33:40,485 --> 00:33:42,420 to buy her forgiveness. 795 00:33:42,487 --> 00:33:45,156 Yeah. We have to get her to that parole hearing. 796 00:33:45,223 --> 00:33:46,758 Uh, what do you mean? 797 00:33:46,824 --> 00:33:48,626 Well, Arthur isn't allowed to testify 798 00:33:48,693 --> 00:33:50,695 to his own innocence. 799 00:33:50,762 --> 00:33:52,630 But she can. 800 00:33:57,335 --> 00:33:58,703 Can I help you? 801 00:33:58,770 --> 00:34:01,305 I'm looking for a messenger. 802 00:34:01,372 --> 00:34:02,673 I need to sign something. 803 00:34:02,740 --> 00:34:04,442 (chuckles): Yeah. I'm sorry. That's my fault. 804 00:34:04,509 --> 00:34:06,677 There's no messenger. I mean, I was the one who called you. 805 00:34:06,744 --> 00:34:08,379 I work for Arthur Craddick. 806 00:34:09,280 --> 00:34:11,549 Did you know he wasn't guilty before the hearing? 807 00:34:11,616 --> 00:34:13,584 Before you saw the tape? You didn't, did you? 808 00:34:13,651 --> 00:34:15,520 That's why you stopped showing up for the hearings. 809 00:34:15,586 --> 00:34:17,488 You realized after all these years 810 00:34:17,555 --> 00:34:19,223 you'd been wrong. 811 00:34:19,290 --> 00:34:21,659 Who do you think the man was sending you money every month? 812 00:34:23,494 --> 00:34:25,329 Ms. Kovolchuk, I need you to come with me 813 00:34:25,396 --> 00:34:26,697 and testify on Arthur's behalf. 814 00:34:26,764 --> 00:34:28,666 Leave me alone, or I'm going to call the police. 815 00:34:28,733 --> 00:34:30,334 Believe me, the police are the last people 816 00:34:30,401 --> 00:34:32,203 you want in your life right now. 817 00:34:32,270 --> 00:34:34,472 You pocketed $700,000, all of it undeclared. 818 00:34:34,539 --> 00:34:36,474 You know what that's called? Tax fraud. 819 00:34:36,541 --> 00:34:38,342 Then you funneled that blood money 820 00:34:38,409 --> 00:34:39,644 into business transactions. 821 00:34:39,710 --> 00:34:41,078 That's called money laundering. 822 00:34:41,145 --> 00:34:42,814 But from the second that you knew 823 00:34:42,880 --> 00:34:46,651 Arthur didn't kill your husband and you kept it to yourself... 824 00:34:46,717 --> 00:34:48,753 that's obstruction of justice. 825 00:34:48,820 --> 00:34:51,355 So you come with me, and I will do everything I can 826 00:34:51,422 --> 00:34:52,657 to make that stuff go away. 827 00:34:52,723 --> 00:34:57,728 But I need you to talk to the parole board. 828 00:34:57,795 --> 00:35:00,498 ♪ ♪ 829 00:35:02,767 --> 00:35:05,436 You know where our friend Detective Kaminsky is? 830 00:35:05,503 --> 00:35:06,771 I have no idea. 831 00:35:06,838 --> 00:35:08,639 SCHUSTER: Mr. Craddick, 832 00:35:08,706 --> 00:35:11,776 you're now invited to speak on your own behalf. 833 00:35:11,843 --> 00:35:14,312 Well, if it pleases the parole board, 834 00:35:14,378 --> 00:35:17,114 we would like to call one last support witness. 835 00:35:17,181 --> 00:35:19,317 We would not ask for the additional time 836 00:35:19,383 --> 00:35:23,387 if we didn't believe the witness to be vitally important. 837 00:35:23,454 --> 00:35:24,722 Certainly. 838 00:35:24,789 --> 00:35:26,557 Go ahead. 839 00:35:28,326 --> 00:35:29,861 (door opens) 840 00:35:47,378 --> 00:35:49,547 Good afternoon. 841 00:35:49,614 --> 00:35:53,251 For 12 years, the legal system told me, 842 00:35:53,317 --> 00:35:55,486 over and over again, 843 00:35:55,553 --> 00:35:59,924 that Arthur Craddick killed my baby and killed my husband. 844 00:36:00,758 --> 00:36:03,427 It wasn't their opinion, it wasn't their theory, 845 00:36:03,494 --> 00:36:06,797 it was simply the fact. 846 00:36:06,864 --> 00:36:11,369 And that fact has been a rock my grief could always hold onto. 847 00:36:11,435 --> 00:36:16,507 My certainty that that man was in a jail for what he did. 848 00:36:18,342 --> 00:36:19,710 But... 849 00:36:20,545 --> 00:36:25,716 ...at that hearing, watching Kiril Sidorenko's confession 850 00:36:25,783 --> 00:36:27,718 changed all of that. 851 00:36:27,785 --> 00:36:31,689 Robbed me of all of that. 852 00:36:31,756 --> 00:36:35,593 Because when you finally hear the truth... 853 00:36:35,660 --> 00:36:39,864 no matter what people try to insist the facts are, 854 00:36:39,931 --> 00:36:41,465 you know. 855 00:36:41,532 --> 00:36:43,768 You know deep in your heart. 856 00:36:43,834 --> 00:36:45,336 I loved my husband, 857 00:36:45,403 --> 00:36:48,372 but let me tell you something about my husband. 858 00:36:48,439 --> 00:36:50,541 My husband was a criminal. 859 00:36:51,409 --> 00:36:53,311 He threatened people. 860 00:36:53,377 --> 00:36:54,545 He took their money. 861 00:36:54,612 --> 00:36:56,714 And he dared them to call the police. 862 00:36:56,781 --> 00:36:59,951 So trust me, I know about criminals. 863 00:37:00,017 --> 00:37:03,888 So when you ask me, "What do you think, Zasha? 864 00:37:03,955 --> 00:37:06,624 Who shot your baby and your husband?" 865 00:37:06,691 --> 00:37:08,359 A hired killer? 866 00:37:08,426 --> 00:37:11,729 So bigger criminals, tougher criminals, 867 00:37:11,796 --> 00:37:13,664 jealous of your husband's success, 868 00:37:13,731 --> 00:37:16,767 can threaten people, take their money 869 00:37:16,834 --> 00:37:19,570 and dare them to call the police? 870 00:37:20,905 --> 00:37:22,873 Or a local dry cleaner, 871 00:37:22,940 --> 00:37:26,777 bringing up a child alone, with everything to lose 872 00:37:26,844 --> 00:37:28,779 and very little to gain. 873 00:37:30,014 --> 00:37:31,682 I think the answer 874 00:37:31,749 --> 00:37:33,417 is obvious. 875 00:37:33,484 --> 00:37:38,255 As much as I want to believe in Arthur Craddick's guilt... 876 00:37:38,322 --> 00:37:41,258 the terrible truth is... 877 00:37:41,325 --> 00:37:43,594 I know now... 878 00:37:43,661 --> 00:37:46,364 he is innocent. 879 00:37:58,876 --> 00:38:00,578 SCHUSTER: A.D.A. Glover, 880 00:38:00,645 --> 00:38:02,279 your next witness? 881 00:38:04,515 --> 00:38:05,816 Right. 882 00:38:05,883 --> 00:38:09,487 Actually... the original investigator on this case, 883 00:38:09,553 --> 00:38:10,821 Detective Joseph Kaminsky, 884 00:38:10,888 --> 00:38:13,424 was scheduled to testify today, 885 00:38:13,491 --> 00:38:16,293 but as you can see... 886 00:38:16,360 --> 00:38:17,895 he's not here yet. 887 00:38:17,962 --> 00:38:20,731 SCHUSTER: And are you in communication with him? 888 00:38:20,798 --> 00:38:22,033 Is he close? 889 00:38:22,099 --> 00:38:26,504 Actually, I've been unable to reach him. 890 00:38:26,570 --> 00:38:28,572 Frankly, the facts relating 891 00:38:28,639 --> 00:38:32,843 to Detective Kaminsky's investigation some 12 years ago, 892 00:38:32,910 --> 00:38:34,845 all of which are circumstantial, 893 00:38:34,912 --> 00:38:37,815 are already familiar to all of us sitting up here 894 00:38:37,882 --> 00:38:39,917 on the board. 895 00:38:39,984 --> 00:38:42,386 What I'd like to do at this point 896 00:38:42,453 --> 00:38:44,588 is simply move along. 897 00:38:44,655 --> 00:38:46,357 Of course. 898 00:38:47,491 --> 00:38:48,893 (sighs) Well... 899 00:38:48,959 --> 00:38:52,863 what once started as a straightforward parole petition 900 00:38:52,930 --> 00:38:57,668 has suddenly turned into something highly unusual, 901 00:38:57,735 --> 00:39:00,738 something that typically falls outside of our purview: 902 00:39:00,805 --> 00:39:03,507 the question of this inmate's 903 00:39:03,574 --> 00:39:05,876 guilt or innocence. 904 00:39:06,911 --> 00:39:09,413 May I please say something? 905 00:39:12,516 --> 00:39:14,452 A tragedy like this, 906 00:39:14,518 --> 00:39:16,854 it's got a blast radius, 907 00:39:16,921 --> 00:39:20,057 destroying lives in every single direction. 908 00:39:21,792 --> 00:39:24,061 My family... 909 00:39:24,128 --> 00:39:27,098 your family, we're connected by that. 910 00:39:28,733 --> 00:39:33,704 I truly am sorry, Mrs. Kovolchuk, 911 00:39:33,771 --> 00:39:36,741 for all you've been through. 912 00:39:37,575 --> 00:39:39,143 That's all. 913 00:39:39,210 --> 00:39:42,012 I'm sorry for all of it. 914 00:39:42,079 --> 00:39:45,082 For the agony we've all suffered. 915 00:39:57,862 --> 00:40:00,865 (speaking quietly) 916 00:40:00,931 --> 00:40:02,833 If you're through, Mr. Craddick, 917 00:40:02,900 --> 00:40:05,503 we'd like to render our decision. 918 00:40:07,738 --> 00:40:08,939 (clears throat) 919 00:40:09,006 --> 00:40:11,108 In the matter of inmate Arthur Craddick, 920 00:40:11,175 --> 00:40:13,811 it is our unanimous decision that... 921 00:40:13,878 --> 00:40:16,547 parole shall be granted. 922 00:40:16,614 --> 00:40:19,016 (taking deep breaths) 923 00:40:27,758 --> 00:40:29,126 Dr. Bull... 924 00:40:29,193 --> 00:40:30,427 thank you. 925 00:40:30,494 --> 00:40:33,564 You're welcome. Only took 12 years. 926 00:40:41,605 --> 00:40:43,574 (both crying) 927 00:40:44,575 --> 00:40:45,709 (lock buzzes) 928 00:40:45,776 --> 00:40:47,711 I didn't dream that, right? 929 00:40:47,778 --> 00:40:49,213 No, you didn't dream it. 930 00:40:49,280 --> 00:40:50,714 Hot off the presses. 931 00:40:50,781 --> 00:40:52,716 A.D.A. has agreed to file a motion 932 00:40:52,783 --> 00:40:54,652 to vacate Arthur's conviction. 933 00:40:54,718 --> 00:40:56,720 That means full exoneration. 934 00:40:56,787 --> 00:40:58,923 She also says... 935 00:40:58,989 --> 00:41:00,858 he should be out of here tomorrow morning. 936 00:41:00,925 --> 00:41:03,160 Man, I got to buy a bed tonight. 937 00:41:03,227 --> 00:41:05,830 I cannot tell you, I have imagined this moment 938 00:41:05,896 --> 00:41:06,897 hundreds of times. 939 00:41:06,964 --> 00:41:08,599 (siren approaching) 940 00:41:08,666 --> 00:41:10,534 (tires screech) 941 00:41:10,601 --> 00:41:11,936 Leonard Craddick. 942 00:41:12,002 --> 00:41:13,671 I'm Leonard Craddick. 943 00:41:13,737 --> 00:41:16,574 Officers, what's going on here? 944 00:41:13,737 --> 00:41:16,574 I need to know 945 00:41:16,640 --> 00:41:18,976 if any of you have any weapons on your person. 946 00:41:19,043 --> 00:41:20,811 LEO/BULL/BENNY: No. 947 00:41:19,043 --> 00:41:20,811 Everybody keep your hands 948 00:41:20,878 --> 00:41:22,646 on your heads, please. 949 00:41:20,878 --> 00:41:22,646 BULL: We're Mr. Craddick's counsel. 950 00:41:22,713 --> 00:41:25,850 We have a right to know what this is all about. 951 00:41:25,916 --> 00:41:27,151 What the hell? 952 00:41:27,218 --> 00:41:29,086 Leonard Craddick, you are under arrest 953 00:41:29,153 --> 00:41:31,722 for the murder of Detective Joseph Kaminsky. 954 00:41:31,789 --> 00:41:34,225 Anything you say can and will be used against you 955 00:41:31,789 --> 00:41:34,225 Kaminsky's dead? 956 00:41:34,291 --> 00:41:36,260 in a court of law. You have the right... 957 00:41:36,327 --> 00:41:38,762 Leo, it's gonna be all right. Officer, he is to remain 958 00:41:38,829 --> 00:41:40,164 unquestioned until we get there. 959 00:41:40,231 --> 00:41:42,733 Leo, you don't say anything to anybody! 960 00:41:42,800 --> 00:41:44,969 You understand? 961 00:42:06,156 --> 00:42:11,962 Captioning sponsored by CBS 962 00:42:12,029 --> 00:42:13,530 Captioned by Media Access Group at WGBH access.wgbh.org