[narrator] Previously on Return to Amish...
[Jeremiah] I feel bad for the way I left things
with Dennis last time I saw him.
[Carmela speaking]
I have to leave. I'm sorry.
I often think about inviting him down here to Florida.
[Jethro] When Sabrina called me and said she had a pregnancy scare,
I was on the next flight headed back to Florida.
-I wanna get married. -[Sabrina] Then prove it.
-[Jethro] I love you. -[Sabrina] I love you.
Hi, I'm Fannie.
-[man] Fannie? -Yes.
[Sabrina] We've got a live one here.
This girl is super Amish.
So how are you doing, Maureen?
I'm doing really good.
What about Daniel?
You guys still engaged? Getting married?
Well, yes. Just not right now.
[Jeremiah] They were crazy about each other,
and something's just not adding up.
Yes, sir, you looking for Ada?
And my sister, Rosanna.
I knew Rose's brother, Ray, was in town with his friends,
so I should have known better.
That he's gonna stop by to check on his sister.
You guys sleep together?
And just sleeping with my friend now.
[Rosanna speaking]
I was very startled when I walked in the room
and I see Johnny and Rosanna on the bed.
She told me she was living with Ada,
and then it was all these guys that I didn't know about.
It was like, "Wow, okay. What is this?"
That could really ruin her reputation.
As Rosanna's big brother, my job is to look over her and keep her safe
and protect our family name.
So, where's Ada?
[clears throat]
I brought someone I want you guys to meet.
He's my brother, Ray.
He came up here.
You guys look alike.
-[Rosanna] Yeah, we hear that a lot. -A lot.
So, um...
Are you Ada?
[Ada] Yes.
I was down here with some friends, actually,
and I just stopped by to check on my sister.
You didn't know he was coming?
[Rosanna] No.
So, you're... you're the mom of the house. You...
You watch over everybody? You're taking care of my sister?
Yeah, I have authority of this house, so...
[Ray] You let them sleep together?
What kind of house you running here?
Well, that's the first time I've ever seen Ada go silent.
She knows she did something wrong.
Ada allowed this in spite of her age
and her years of experience as an Amish person.
So, now Ray's calling her out,
and I can't say that I blame him.
I mean, he's right. It isn't good for Rosanna.
And Ada is just...
mad and sad and upset
because she knows she's backed into a corner
and she can't do anything about it.
[Ray speaking]
[Ada speaking]
[Fannie] Ray is my cousin, but we don't talk that much.
But one thing I do know about him
is that he's very Amish when it comes to protecting his siblings.
He doesn't back down from doing what he thinks is right.
[Ray] I warned my sister when she came out about this, Ada.
Shouldn't you trust her that she's not gonna do anything stupid?
She has a boyfriend.
Yeah, I don't know. I'm just here
and I'm just trying to protect my sister.
I stopped in to see.
I tell you, she really loves Johnny,
and Johnny is good to her.
Here's the thing, right? If you wanna come in here and... and be here,
you're more than welcome.
But the minute you come in here...
The minute you come in here trying to go off on us,
-judging us on how we run this house... -[Ray] Yes.
-...then there's gonna be an issue. -[Ray] Okay.
That's why I'm coming at you the way I am
because when you came in, you had a look,
cocky attitude...
-[Ray] Yes. -...and that's not gonna fly here.
We're all one big family. We all trust each other.
-We don't... we don't try... -[Ray] I just came to protect my sister.
-I understand... -I'm making sure she's...
...but we don't order each other around here.
[Ray] I don't know what to say to you.
[Kenneth] Damn.
I feel bad for this guy.
I mean, he... he comes down here to check on his sister and Ada
because of their rocky past,
and she's staying in a house full of guys.
Uh, she's sleeping in the same bedroom with her boyfriend.
Uh, you know,
now he's just sort of getting yelled at by everyone.
This house is under sin.
And it's Ada's fault that she let it happen.
And I understand Ray
and I agree with him.
But I wasn't gonna put myself out there and be in the middle of it.
So I just kept my mouth shut.
Ada, you should not fight like you did last year.
That's why I stopped in here,
'cause last year my sister called me and told me
-what you... it looked that you was disrespecting-- -It wasn't just me, though!
-I... I didn't say it was just you. -[Ada] It wasn't!
Rosanne and I are on good terms.
Ask her right in front of me.
There was not one issue between Rosanna and I since the day I walked in here!
And that's the truth.
It was, actually, you guys got along really good.
-Thank you. Thank you. -Yeah, I don't know, I wasn't here.
But I'm just, you know, I mean, it's just what I heard last year.
-And I was just... I came to make sure. -That was last year!
-I came to make sure. -We're here this year!
What happened last year,
I will not have an argument.
[Rosanna] Last year we had a fight
because Ada stick her nose in an argument that me and Maureen were having.
Oh, my God. I've never heard anything...
I... I... This is ridiculous.
Rosanne, you are so embarrassing.
Am I right, Rosanna? We're not gonna fight.
[Rosanna] Yeah.
Yeah, I don't want hate.
I didn't come here to make hate.
I came here to check on my sister
and make sure she's not getting disrespected.
-I came to make sure that she's not getting... -You're like the Amish.
I mean, I am Amish.
I want you to know I will protect your sister.
Nobody's gonna do anything to her.
[Ray] You're gonna have to show it to me first.
[Ada] There's nothing wrong with them laying on the bed and having a conversation
-and her having her hat off. -With her cap off.
She had her cap off.
-That was strange. -Big deal.
Do you think her taking her cap off, she's gonna go to hell?
Hell, no!
Made me angry, the way he talked,
and that I'm not, um, being a good example to his sister.
They weren't doing anything wrong.
They were just laying on the bed and talking.
This is a disgrace to the adults of the Amish.
Ada, the bishop would probably be very ashamed of you.
[Ada] You know what, them bishops,
they can shove their manmade rules up their ass.
They're all manmade rules.
No wonder why they turned their backs on you when you left.
[Jeremiah] Ray never should have said that.
I don't know the full story,
but I'm pretty sure that Ada's husband cheated on her,
and it was the community that turned their backs on her
and told her just to be a better wife.
[Ada] I'm done.
-Do you-- -[microphone crackles]
I'm done.
I'm not filming anymore!
-I am going home! -[door slams]
[crying] I am done!
I am going home.
[crying]
[Johnny] I never seen... never seen her that pissed.
Sounded bad here.
[door slams]
It got pretty ugly when Rosanna's brother Ray came
because my husband cheated on me,
and the church thought it was all my fault,
I need to fix this,
but I did not agree with them, so...
Uh, I just told them exactly how I feel
and that it's not right that he cheated on me.
And so, now with Ray,
I just felt he was stepping over his boundaries
and he was saying things to me that a kid his age should never say to me.
-[knocking] -[Ada crying]
[Ada crying]
[Fannie] Ada stayed in the bathroom crying for hours.
And Ray should have never told her
that," No wonder the community turned their backs on her."
[Ada crying]
[Jeremiah] Ray really struck a nerve.
He never should have said that.
[Fannie] It is so awesome.
I feel like everyone's looking at us because we don't have a bikini on.
[Sabrina] So, what's going on?
Are you still gonna get married,
or are you not, or what are you gonna do?
Our relationship is not perfect.
I'm really nervous because I have no idea how this visit's gonna go.
♪ Things have a way Of working out ♪
♪ Ooh-ooh-ooh-ooh-ooh ♪
♪ Things have a way Of working out ♪
[Ray] I'm angry that Ada let this happen,
but at the same time,
I feel bad because I made her cry.
I shouldn't have got personal like that.
I think I need to talk to you about something.
I'm sorry if you thought I was disrespecting you last night.
I... I apologize.
My intention was to come here and see what my sister's doing.
You know, if my family...
Yeah, they could actually get punished for what she does.
There's a lot of talk that goes on around the Amish.
It'll definitely get out there,
and the preachers will find out.
And then my parents would get punished for something that my sister did.
[Sabrina] Everybody's saying that Ray should mind his own business,
and that Rosanna should just be able to do whatever she wants.
But Mennonites and Amish punish their families
for the sins of their children.
So, it is Ray's business what Rosanna's doing
because it affects him and his family.
But no matter how you look at it,
Rosanna lied to her family about what she's doing down here.
It doesn't matter that Rosanna's an adult.
The church controls everything that you do.
[Ada speaking]
[Rosanna] I mean, I understand why Ray was kind of upset.
But, I mean, he's gotta understand,
I'm not, like, I'm a adult now,
and I can take care of myself.
Plus, I'm with Johnny,
and he takes good care of me, so...
I'm good.
[both laugh]
I don't want us to have any problems.
-I wanna see what kind of fun you guys have. -Okay.
[Jeremiah] There's been a lot of tension in the house,
so we figured we'd just take the kids to the beach for the first time.
[Fannie] It is so awesome.
The sound of the ocean,
the smell of it,
just the feel of it.
I've never seen this before.
It honestly looks like snow.
I felt so happy.
I felt like I could cry. It was just...
Everything in me just felt so happy.
So free. So relaxed.
Oh, my gosh.
I feel like everyone's looking at us
-because we don't have a bikini on. -[Rosanna] Yeah.
They're probably thinking, "You look weird."
You know what I think we should do?
What's that?
Change our clothes so everybody stops staring at us.
Yeah, I know.
-We need to match in. We need to... -Blend in?
-...blend in. -Damn.
[Fannie] It's weird how the water runs, like, right into the sky.
It looks like the sky comes right down on top of the water.
[Johnny] The first time being out on the beach,
it was, like, really nice.
We got to go in, like, the ocean,
and it's water just for a long way.
I mean, back in Pennsylvania,
it's just, like, streams and rivers.
And you got lakes. Like, you can see the other side.
And the ocean is just, like...
It just goes and looks like it just goes on and on.
It just looks like it rolls back underneath.
It's just skies and water.
It's [bleep] amazing.
[Kenneth] It's a pretty awesome experience,
just enjoying the water.
And always just that continuous motion.
[Fannie] Some of the people I saw at the beach
were, like, pretty much wearing nothing.
[Kenneth] What do you think about the girls
-and, I mean, how do people dress out here? -I like it.
-It's my type of beach. -Of course, you do.
[laughs]
Why not? You don't like it?
Oh, I... It's okay.
It's okay?
Deep down you wanna say it's awesome, right?
Because I think it's awesome.
It's somethin' I'm not really worried about.
[Kenneth] Yeah, these girls look cute.
But I have basketball on my focus.
Don't stop. Hello.
Uh, yes, it kinda is.
This is how we're supposed to be.
-Our bishop. He tells us what to wear. -[Emily] Okay.
So, we were just coming back from a paddle, actually,
and said, "Wow. Those people just look like
they're a little uncomfortable today."
So, I had to go and ask.
You don't have, like, a beach uniform?
No, I don't. And I think I wanna try.
-[Emily laughs] You wanna try? -I do.
We can switch.
[Johnny] This girl come over,
and she was dressed, half-dressed,
and hardly wearing any clothes.
Uh, no, I think... I think I'm fine [giggles].
This is quite modest for me.
Okay. I mean it's...
I don't know how my bishop would like that.
We're taught to be modest,
and to take off the Amish clothes
and put on the English clothes,
it's a big decision.
It's like the point of no return
for an Amish person.
I'm ready to get out of my Amish clothes,
but I'm not sure if I'm ready to wear something like a bathing suit.
We've got some paddleboards up here.
I don't know if you saw us out there earlier,
but we would love it if you wanted
-to try paddleboarding. -I wanted to try.
-I would try. -Yeah?
-I would, yes. -Yeah, they're right up here.
[Kenneth] I'll watch.
[Rosanna] Johnny seemed a little too interested
in learning to paddleboard from Emily.
I was, like, there's no way she'll go with Johnny.
I wasn't about to let that happen.
-How's Jethro? -He's good.
Well, that's good.
He's a lot better than he was.
He keeps telling me I'm beautiful. [laughs]
That's a nice compliment. And you are beautiful.
And he'll put his hand on my belly,
and the baby will kick wherever his hand is.
-That's so sweet. -Yeah.
Everybody else went to the beach,
but I didn't really want to go
because I didn't want to look like a beached whale on the beach,
so, I stayed home.
So, what's goin' on?
Are you still gonna get married, or are you not?
Or, what are you gonna do?
Danny and I...
Our relationship is not perfect.
Uh, parents. They can't be a part of your relationship.
They are not in control of that.
What do you mean by family getting involved?
Well, when Danny and I first started dating,
my mom wasn't too happy.
My dad wasn't either.
My family didn't like Danny at first
because they thought that was the reason
-that I left the Amish. -Yeah.
[Maureen] The Amish and the Mennonite are very opinionated,
and they're very nosy,
and have to know what's going on in your relationship.
It doesn't matter what you are.
Like, Amish, English, Mennonite, whatever.
I think too many people get into other people's relationships.
And it's just two people to make a relationship work.
Grandma tried to... she got pissed.
Really pissed about it.
She didn't even know Danny.
She's like, "You can't be with him." [mockingly]
Yeah, I remember last year,
when she would talk to me about Danny
and she was like, "I don't like him."
[Maureen] They try to tell me that I can't be with him.
It was kind of tough sometimes,
but I was, like, I'm gonna show 'em
that this relationship is gonna work.
Yeah, when family meddles in relationships,
that's where the problems start.
Before she even met him,
she told me that she doesn't like him.
But she's just tryin' to make so I don't get hurt.
I know that Ada is her grandmother,
and she's just looking out for her,
but she needs to mind her own business.
Just, whatever you do, if Danny is really the one,
don't let anybody break you up.
Don't let your mom, don't let your grandma. Nobody.
Because at the end of the day,
it's you and Danny and it's your relationship.
It's not anybody else's.
And if y'all are happy, that's all that matters.
[Maureen] I love Grandma,
and I don't want to disappoint her,
but when Sabrina said that if Danny's the one,
then don't let anyone stand in the way,
I realized that I need to live the life that I deserve,
which is with Danny.
[screams]
[Fannie] I was just, like, I'm gonna, like, die,
because I don't know how to swim.
-I would try. -Yeah?
-I would, yes. -Let's do it. They're right up here.
Okay.
[Johnny] We were all just here at the beach
and when this girl come over
and offered us to teach us how to paddleboard,
I wanted to go paddleboarding.
-[Emily] You kinda want to turn the handle outside. -Okay.
-[Emily] Keep it so it's vertical. -Like this?
-[Emily] Just like that. -Okay.
-Perfect. You're naturals. -I love it.
-Can you swim, Johnny? -Yeah.
I've never really had a full interaction
or taught a lesson to Amish people,
so, it'll be fun.
I mean, Emily, I was...
She seemed like a really nice woman right at first,
but I do not want Johnny
to enjoy himself around other girls
because that is mine, like,
and there's no stupid girl
gonna come up and flirt with Johnny.
I think Rosanna was a little bit jealous.
Like, when she saw Emily over there and teaching us
and she come out and she wanted to ride too then.
She was dressed, half-dressed, and hardly wearing any clothes.
Like, I mean, I don't care what she's wearing.
I don't care what she's doing.
I just wanted to learn how to paddleboard.
Emily comes out and offers me,
to teach me how to paddleboard.
I mean, what's wrong with that? Can't you have friends?
Like, you brought me out in this English world,
so, let me have my freedom.
Okay, stand, oh, you're going for it.
-Do you want your paddle? -I do.
[Emily] And if you start to fall...
[laughing]
[all laughing]
Ah, this is too funny.
It was way harder than I thought it was gonna be.
The waves, I thought I could, you know, balance myself.
[all laughing]
It was way different than what I expected.
That was good.
[Jeremiah] I'm preoccupied
because Dennis is gonna come visit later on today.
Last time I saw Dennis was when we did the DNA test
where it said that he's not my biological father.
Ever since then, I haven't really spoken to him.
So, I invited Dennis down here to Florida
because there's a few things I need to talk to him about.
You know, I don't want him to be mad at me
for the way I left him last time.
You know, I just hope he talks to me,
but I don't know what to expect.
I'm really nervous about paddleboarding,
because I don't know how to swim.
But I don't wanna be a chicken in front of everybody.
[Fannie] When I got on that paddleboard with Ray,
I was, like, as stiff as a board
and my heart was pounding so hard.
Then he kept tilting it back and forth.
I'm, like, oh, God, please just...
Just hold it still, like, let's just go.
[Emily] Take a breath.
[screams]
The world just stopped.
I thought, this is it,
I'm gonna die.
[spluttering and coughing]
[Fannie] My whole body just got stiff,
and I was just, like, I'm gonna, like, die,
because I don't know how to swim.
I can just still feel myself, like, going under.
That was horrible.
[Kenneth] She's gonna hate water now.
Fannie was drowning in, like, three feet of water.
And if she wanted to save herself, you know,
she could have just stood up.
[Fannie] But when I fell into the ocean,
I was thoughtless, except, someone help me.
[Kenneth] I've seen you took a tumble.
[Fannie] I wanted to learn how to swim,
but since I fell into the ocean, I'm just, like...
I'm good. As long as my feet touch the ground, I'm fine.
-[Dennis] Hi. -Hi.
-Dennis. -I'm Ada.
Hi, good to meet you.
I think there might be a little chemistry between Dennis and Ada.
First impressions, Ada's kinda, like, my kind of lady.
[amusing music playing]
[Jeremiah] Right now, I'm waiting on Dennis to show up.
And I'm really nervous,
because I have no idea how this visit's gonna go.
Is he here yet?
He's gonna be here any minute.
Not sure.
I figured he'd be here by now.
[Jeremiah] Last time I saw Dennis,
was when we did the DNA test
where it said that he's not my biological father,
but he offered to be my father, no matter what.
All these years, I believed in my heart you were mine.
And we don't have to stop that.
Takes more than a sperm donor to be a dad.
I'd like to be a dad, if you want one.
I have to leave.
I'm sorry.
You know, I didn't take him up on it
because I was just overwhelmed.
And now, what if he changed his mind,
and doesn't want me as his son?
It's gonna be okay.
I hear him.
[motorcycle engine]
[Dennis exhales]
Come here, hey, good to see ya!
How you doin'?
-[Jeremiah] Pretty good. -[Dennis exhales]
-Hi, good to see you! -Hey, nice to see you too!
I missed you so much.
You too, you too, you too.
[Dennis exhales]
-Nice and hot. -Nice and hot.
[Dennis] Boy, it's good to see you guys.
[Carmela] Been a while.
Is something up?
[Jeremiah] Well, I do have to say
I feel bad that I walked out on you.
You know, when I got those results.
I was just in major shock.
Yeah, it's just... kind of a blow.
I'm sure it broke your heart, like...
Oh, yeah. My heart sank deep.
It sank deep when I found out
that he wasn't my biological son, it sank deep.
[Jeremiah] Dennis is a really nice and peaceful guy,
and to hear how upset he was,
that really hurt me.
Well, I'm glad you're here.
You wanna go in and meet the rest of the kids?
-Yeah, yeah, sure! -Let's go.
-[Carmela] Have a seat. -[Jeremiah] After you.
-[Dennis] Hi, how you doin'? -[Carmela] We have a special guest.
-Daniel. -Hi, Daniel.
-Nice to meet you. -I'm Kenneth.
Hi, Kenneth. How you doin'?
Yeah, this is Dennis. He's the guy who we thought
was my father for 20 some years.
[Kenneth] Dennis looks nothing like Jeremiah.
Kind of reminds you of Santa Claus.
-[Jeremiah] Let's go find the other ones. -All right.
[Carmela] Ada.
We have a special guest.
-[Dennis] Hi! -Hi.
-Dennis. -I'm Ada.
-Hi, good to meet ya. -Nice to meet you.
That's the mom of the house.
[Dennis] Mom of the house?
[Ada] I heard a lot of good things about you.
Oh, me too.
-Me too. -[Ada] That's good.
I like cleaning, too.
It's a woman after my own heart.
[chuckles]
[Dennis speaking]
I think there might be a little chemistry
between Dennis and Ada.
[Dennis] First impressions,
Ada's kinda like, my kinda lady.
[laughs]
[Jeremiah] You got the shrimp?
[Dennis] Got the shrimp, got the tackle.
[Jeremiah] I love saltwater fishing.
I took Dennis fishing
because I just wanted to have that time with, you know,
just him and I, alone.
[Dennis] Where you wanna try?
Anywhere here.
How's your mom doin'?
Mom's doing good. She's, uh, still kickin'.
Still waitin' on y'all to come by and see her.
[Jeremiah] I know.
I don't know, I mean...
...you know, I wanted to talk to you about,
you know, how we left things off whenever
we left and went to Michigan.
You know, it's...
...it's been stressful for me and you both.
[Dennis] Oh, yeah.
I just wanna thank you for not giving up on me and not walking away.
Even though you didn't have to be,
you were still there.
I can't just throw 23 years down the drain
believing you were my son.
-I can't just walk away from that. -I know, but--
I can't walk away from my other children, either.
Exactly.
But I'm not gonna force me on nobody,
you wanna come around, you come around,
if you don't, you don't.
Yeah, I just wanted to let you know I appreciate it.
[Dennis] Oh, you're welcome. You're worth it.
You know, I can honestly say now,
I feel like a new person.
I feel like I've found where I belong.
[Dennis] Good.
It's given me a lot of peace.
I can say I'm happier now than I've ever been.
[Dennis] Good.
I just want you to know, Dennis,
we might not be blood related,
but you're still my father.
And I'm your son.
[Dennis] That means a lot to me.
I'll be there for you.
The relationship that I have with Jeremiah,
it feels binding.
It feels permanent. It feels...
...it feels good.
-I love you. -I love you, too.
You know, in the past, I've pushed so many people away.
You know, because when somebody starts gettin' close to my heart,
I just don't like being the type of person
who shows emotion and opens up, but...
Dennis just won't leave.
You know? He loves me too much for that.
-I ain't gonna kiss you, I'm gonna go back to fishin'. -[Jeremiah chuckles]
[Rosanna] I'm so excited about my English clothes,
that I can't wait to go and try them on,
and go to the beach.
[Kenneth] Johnny seemed really upset.
[Johnny] I'm not okay with that.
It's too much.
♪ Show up Got something to say♪
Oh, I see something I want.
[Daniel] After being stared at at the beach,
we decided we're not going back in Amish clothes again.
[Fannie] It's a big decision,
when you're getting out of your Amish clothes,
and I'm just not sure
I'm quite ready to make that step yet.
Especially in front of the guys.
♪ Show me how it's done♪
The store, it's a really nice place.
It had surfboards, skateboards,
it had shoes, bathing suits.
It's like everything you needed
to go have a good time.
I mean, how do you use a skateboard? Stand on it?
[Jeremiah] You just jump on and go...
That little fish underneath is gonna make it go better.
In my community, we weren't allowed to have skateboards.
And I think it was just...
Having a skateboard, having fun on it...
It's like, they don't want
you to have that taste outside the community.
'Cause they're...
They're afraid it'll...
You'll want more, and more,
and finally, you'll just wanna leave.
I'm gettin' this one.
I don't care if I never use it, I want one.
Jeremiah.
Do these two go good together?
No. I mean, it looks half decent, but it kinda clashes, too.
I know, I'm not gonna wear these two together.
Just because this has the fish on it, and...
That's fireworks.
It sucks being pregnant, I can't fit in anything.
[Jethro] I wanna get these for the Zekiah
or maybe these ones.
[Sabrina] Jethro and I are going shopping
for clothes for the beach with everyone,
and I'm really glad that Jethro's back.
I just hope that he gets along with everybody.
[Johnny] Whoa, look at these nice shoes.
[Daniel] Yeah, I know, dude.
[Johnny] I want these shoes so bad.
I mean, all I really heard about Jethro was, like,
he left Sabrina and the kids multiple times,
and, like, they fight all the time,
but then I also hear he's a good guy,
he loves taking care of the kids, and taking care of the house.
I need something for skateboarding.
These are ankle top.
[Johnny] I mean, all those things that I've heard about him,
they might be true, but he's a nice guy to me, so I like him.
These are, like... like, weird to me.
[laughing] Yeah, that's 'cause you've grown up Amish.
Mennonite don't do all this color [bleep].
[Johnny] I'd never be able to wear those.
You would fit this.
I think that would look really good on you.
Oh, that's so nice of you.
-[laughing] -You picked this cute hat out for me.
I will just give you a heads up, it won't fit.
Yeah, it does.
[laughing]
[Daniel] Maybe you're wrecking it.
I think you look good, better in it.
Hmm, you picked out a lot of clothes.
You got a whole handful.
[both chuckle]
All right, so, yeah, let me try these on.
Where's the dressing room?
I definitely don't want these Amish clothes no more.
I wanna have, you know, maybe, like, a tank top and shorts,
and take a good swim, and just, you know,
have a good time, like,
these Amish clothes,
obviously not made for the beach. Just bottom line.
♪ Hey, just like magic♪
♪ This is how we do It's so... ♪
-Holy-schmoly. -Whoa.
-[Ray] What do you think? -[Daniel] I don't know. What do you think?
♪ Just like magic ♪
♪ Hey, just like magic♪
♪ This is how we do It's so ecstatic ♪
♪ Abracadabra Just like magic ♪
You look really good.
-Lot better than your Amish clothes. -Yeah.
Hell, yeah. You look good.
[Carmela] Ray looked very stylish.
Like, he had his shirt unbuttoned,
majority of the time.
Oh, you were looking at his chest?
No! [giggling]
It's awesome to be out of the Amish clothes.
Feels so much lighter.
These Amish clothes are just crazy, they're heavy,
sweaty, they're hot.
And the English clothes, they're awesome.
I like it.
[Sabrina] Kenneth in Amish clothes,
there's nothing to look at, but,
Kenneth in English clothes...
He's not bad lookin'.
[Fannie] The guys are having so much fun.
And I feel like the guys just have a more easy way of dressing.
Let's do this.
[Fannie] Whereas women...
It's so much harder to dress and actually look good.
Fannie, are you okay in there?
Huh?
[Daniel] I completely understand why Fannie
didn't wanna come out of the dressing room,
because her whole life,
she was taught to dress very modestly,
and pretty much no skin showing.
Want me to come in there and take them out?
[Rosanne] [bleep]
No.
And you could kinda tell in her face,
and just by her body language,
that she just didn't feel comfortable.
For Fannie, I think the culture
that she grew up with,
it's just a mental war in your head.
[Rosanna] After Fannie came out,
it was just me and Johnny left.
I'm so excited about my English clothes,
that I can't wait to go and try them on,
and go to the beach.
[Johnny] I mean, growing up Amish,
and always wearing the same clothes,
it's exciting to try on English clothes, it's something different.
♪ Hey ♪
♪ Yeah, yeah ♪
♪ Oh, oh, oh ♪
Rose, that looks good on you.
[Kenneth] Johnny seemed really upset.
I get it. I wouldn't want my girlfriend
dressed like that in front of other men.
[Jeremiah] An Amish man wants his woman to stay covered up.
So naturally, Johnny, being an Amish guy,
you know, his woman coming out
in front of everybody, wearing a bathing suit?
Obviously, he's gonna be upset.
I did not, dude.
I'm okay with us trying out English clothes,
but not Rosanna trying out bikinis and stuff.
I'm not okay with that. It's too much.
It's like, everybody looking at her.
That's not who I wanna be with.
That's not what I want.
[narrator] On the next episode of Return to Amish...
[Jeremiah] If my eyes weren't playing tricks,
he literally came out of Ada's room.
What level are you trying to take this to?
I'd like to play in college.
That is definitely a challenge, man,
It's ballers out there, dog.
Tap, tap, tap, tap, tap.
[trainer] I need better effort, better effort, right?
You can't just come in here, like, it's not how it works.
-[dance music playing] -Our bet is, by the end of the night,
we're gonna have to see how many girls we can kiss.
[Fannie] It's making me physically sick,
that he's acting like that.