1 00:00:10,410 --> 00:00:13,114 Narrator: A GIRL OBSESSED WITH SOCIAL MEDIA... 2 00:00:13,147 --> 00:00:14,353 Tyler-Ann: HONESTLY, SHE TOOK THE MOST 3 00:00:14,385 --> 00:00:16,764 SELFIES OUT OF ANYONE I'VE EVER KNOWN. 4 00:00:16,797 --> 00:00:19,143 Narrator: MEETS HER DREAM GUY ONLINE. 5 00:00:19,175 --> 00:00:21,522 Haleigh: HE WAS HOT. [ LAUGHS ] 6 00:00:21,555 --> 00:00:23,249 HE WAS HOT. 7 00:00:23,282 --> 00:00:25,073 Narrator: BUT IN A WORLD OF DECEPTION... 8 00:00:25,106 --> 00:00:27,387 Nichole: YEAH, HE'S REALLY CUTE. 9 00:00:27,420 --> 00:00:29,049 Haleigh: THAT WHOLE THING WHERE YOUR PARENTS SAY, 10 00:00:29,082 --> 00:00:30,939 "STRANGER DANGER," 11 00:00:30,972 --> 00:00:32,178 IT'S REAL. 12 00:00:32,210 --> 00:00:33,318 WE DO HAVE TO WORRY. 13 00:00:33,351 --> 00:00:36,317 THAT'S WHY I KNEW THERE WAS SOMETHING WRONG. 14 00:00:36,349 --> 00:00:37,978 Mason: WHERE THE HELL IS SHE? 15 00:00:38,011 --> 00:00:39,706 Narrator: IDENTITIES COLLIDE... 16 00:00:39,739 --> 00:00:42,508 Macomber: SHE WAS A JEALOUS YOUNG GIRL. 17 00:00:42,541 --> 00:00:45,605 Narrator: AND THE PAST CRASHES INTO THE PRESENT. 18 00:00:45,637 --> 00:00:46,729 Kristine: NICHOLE? 19 00:00:46,730 --> 00:00:47,820 I SAID, "WHAT DO I DO, 20 00:00:47,853 --> 00:00:50,622 WHAT AM I SUPPOSED TO DO?" 21 00:00:50,655 --> 00:00:51,632 Nichole: HELLO? 22 00:00:51,665 --> 00:00:53,360 Haleigh: MY STOMACH JUST TURNED. 23 00:00:53,392 --> 00:00:54,533 Nichole: NO! 24 00:01:18,257 --> 00:01:21,092 [ BELL RINGING ] 25 00:01:21,125 --> 00:01:24,678 [ GIRLS LAUGHING, TALKING ] 26 00:01:29,369 --> 00:01:30,998 Narrator: FIFTEEN-YEAR-OLD NICHOLE CABLE 27 00:01:31,031 --> 00:01:34,746 IS A HIGH SCHOOL SOPHOMORE IN OLD TOWN, MAINE. 28 00:01:34,778 --> 00:01:36,310 Nichole: I'M SO GLAD SCHOOL'S OVER. 29 00:01:36,343 --> 00:01:37,582 HEY, TY. 30 00:01:37,614 --> 00:01:39,243 Narrator: AFTER SCHOOL SHE SPENDS MOST OF HER TIME 31 00:01:39,276 --> 00:01:40,970 HANGING OUT WITH BEST FRIENDS HALEIGH 32 00:01:41,003 --> 00:01:42,893 AND TYLER-ANN. 33 00:01:42,926 --> 00:01:45,109 Tyler-Ann: NICHOLE WAS MY BEST FRIEND. 34 00:01:45,141 --> 00:01:47,097 SHE WAS ONE OF THE FUNNIEST PEOPLE I EVER MET. 35 00:01:47,130 --> 00:01:50,648 SHE JUST MADE ME CRACK UP ALL THE TIME. 36 00:01:50,682 --> 00:01:52,409 Haleigh: SHE WAS FRIENDS WITH EVERYBODY. 37 00:01:52,441 --> 00:01:54,788 KIDS THAT NOBODY WAS REALLY FRIENDS WITH, 38 00:01:54,821 --> 00:01:57,621 SHE WOULD GO OUT OF HER WAY TO BE NICE TO THEM. 39 00:01:57,655 --> 00:01:59,481 Narrator: LIKE MOST TEENS IN TOWN, NICHOLE 40 00:01:59,513 --> 00:02:01,173 IS ADDICTED TO FACEBOOK. 41 00:02:01,207 --> 00:02:02,935 SHE KEEPS UP WITH THE GOSSIP AND SHARES 42 00:02:02,967 --> 00:02:05,118 SELFIES WITH HER FRIENDS. 43 00:02:05,150 --> 00:02:06,454 Tyler-Ann: HONESTLY, SHE TOOK THE MOST 44 00:02:06,486 --> 00:02:08,963 SELFIES OUT OF ANYONE I'VE EVER KNOWN. 45 00:02:08,996 --> 00:02:11,342 AND, I MEAN, I DID YELL AT HER A COUPLE OF TIMES. 46 00:02:11,375 --> 00:02:12,451 I WAS LIKE, "PUT YOUR PHONE AWAY!" 47 00:02:12,483 --> 00:02:16,817 Nichole: SCHOOL'S OVER, OH MY GOODNESS. 48 00:02:16,849 --> 00:02:18,153 Narrator: NICHOLE'S PUBLIC POSTS 49 00:02:18,185 --> 00:02:23,497 AND PRETTY PROFILE PICTURE ATTRACT LOTS OF FRIEND REQUESTS. 50 00:02:23,530 --> 00:02:24,898 Haleigh: EVERY DAY SHE HAD SOMEONE 51 00:02:24,931 --> 00:02:28,287 NEW ADDING HER ON FACEBOOK. 52 00:02:28,320 --> 00:02:29,852 Narrator: A LOCAL GUY NAMED KYLE DUBE 53 00:02:29,884 --> 00:02:31,645 ASKS TO FRIEND NICHOLE. 54 00:02:31,677 --> 00:02:34,055 SHE'S NEVER HEARD OF HIM. BUT HE LOOKS COOL. 55 00:02:34,088 --> 00:02:36,337 HE'S GOT A JOB AND HIS OWN TRUCK. 56 00:02:36,369 --> 00:02:39,400 HE MUST BE A COUPLE OF YEARS OLDER. 57 00:02:39,433 --> 00:02:40,736 Haleigh: NO, NO. 58 00:02:40,769 --> 00:02:42,301 Nichole: I THINK I'LL ACCEPT THAT FRIEND REQUEST. 59 00:02:42,333 --> 00:02:44,778 Haleigh: HE'S NOT MY TYPE. DEFINITELY ALL FOR YOU. 60 00:02:44,810 --> 00:02:46,145 Nichole: OH, HE MESSAGED ME. 61 00:02:46,178 --> 00:02:48,263 EXCUSE ME. 62 00:03:03,319 --> 00:03:04,558 Narrator: NICHOLE'S MOM KRISTINE 63 00:03:04,590 --> 00:03:06,578 PICKS HER UP FROM SCHOOL EVERY DAY... 64 00:03:06,611 --> 00:03:07,849 - Nichole: HI, MOM. - Kristine: HEY. 65 00:03:07,882 --> 00:03:09,576 Nichole: I'M GOING TO RIDE IN THE BACK TODAY. 66 00:03:09,608 --> 00:03:13,030 Narrator: FOR THE 15-MINUTE DRIVE HOME TO GLENBURN, 67 00:03:13,064 --> 00:03:17,952 WHERE SHE LIVES WITH HER SISTERS AND STEP-DAD. 68 00:03:17,984 --> 00:03:19,564 Kristine: SO HOW'S SCHOOL? 69 00:03:19,565 --> 00:03:21,144 Nichole: IT WAS ALL RIGHT. 70 00:03:21,178 --> 00:03:22,448 Kristine: SITTING IN THE BACK SEAT, 71 00:03:22,480 --> 00:03:23,980 SHE'D BE GIGGLING, LAUGHING. 72 00:03:24,013 --> 00:03:25,771 WE'D -- TALKING BACK AND FORTH. 73 00:03:25,805 --> 00:03:27,663 ARE ANY OF THE SUBJECTS EASIER THAN OTHERS? 74 00:03:27,695 --> 00:03:30,205 Nichole: UH, YEAH, MATH IS ACTUALLY GOING REALLY WELL. 75 00:03:30,237 --> 00:03:31,965 Kristine: GOOD. 76 00:03:34,734 --> 00:03:37,113 Kristine: AND OF COURSE SHE'S, YOU KNOW, ON HER PHONE 77 00:03:37,145 --> 00:03:39,786 AND TEXTING AT THE SAME TIME. 78 00:03:39,818 --> 00:03:41,772 IT WAS LIKE YOU COULDN'T EVEN TELL 79 00:03:41,805 --> 00:03:43,794 SHE WAS TEXTING BECAUSE SHE WAS 80 00:03:43,826 --> 00:03:45,651 CARRYING A CONVERSATION RIGHT ALONG WITH YOU. 81 00:03:45,683 --> 00:03:46,954 ARE YOU GETTING READY FOR EXAMS? 82 00:03:46,988 --> 00:03:49,040 Nichole: YEAH, THEY'RE COMING UP. 83 00:03:59,011 --> 00:04:00,673 Narrator: IT'S BEEN 2 WEEKS SINCE NICHOLE 84 00:04:00,706 --> 00:04:03,574 STARTED TALKING TO KYLE DUBE ONLINE. 85 00:04:03,606 --> 00:04:05,464 AND NOW HE WANTS TO MEET UP. 86 00:04:05,496 --> 00:04:08,984 BUT NICHOLE'S MOM HAS STRICT RULES ABOUT INTERNET FRIENDS. 87 00:04:09,016 --> 00:04:10,123 Nichole: HEY. 88 00:04:10,157 --> 00:04:11,200 Kristine: HEY, JUST SEEING WHAT'S UP. 89 00:04:11,231 --> 00:04:12,306 Nichole: OH, JUST DOING SOME HOMEWORK. 90 00:04:12,340 --> 00:04:15,272 Kristine: GOT SOME JUICE, YOU WANT SOME? 91 00:04:15,306 --> 00:04:16,968 Nichole: COOL. 92 00:04:16,969 --> 00:04:18,629 Kristine: OKAY. 93 00:04:18,662 --> 00:04:20,616 Narrator: NICHOLE ISN'T ALLOWED TO GO OUT WITH SOMEONE 94 00:04:20,650 --> 00:04:23,974 SHE ONLY KNOWS FROM THE INTERNET. 95 00:04:24,007 --> 00:04:26,418 Kristine: I THINK SHE JUST THOUGHT I WAS BEING MEAN. 96 00:04:26,451 --> 00:04:29,351 AND I COMPLETELY UNDERSTOOD WHERE SHE WAS COMING FROM. 97 00:04:29,383 --> 00:04:32,349 I REMEMBER BEING A KID, BUT SHE'S MY KID. 98 00:04:42,582 --> 00:04:45,091 Narrator: BUT NICHOLE IS DETERMINED TO MEET KYLE, 99 00:04:45,123 --> 00:04:47,894 EVEN IF IT MEANS LYING TO HER MOM. 100 00:04:47,926 --> 00:04:48,968 MOM! 101 00:04:49,001 --> 00:04:50,403 Kristine: SHE WOULD GET VERY DEFENSIVE 102 00:04:50,435 --> 00:04:51,967 IF I TRIED TO LOOK OVER HER SHOULDER. 103 00:04:51,999 --> 00:04:53,954 I'M JUST CHECKING THE TIME. 104 00:04:53,987 --> 00:04:56,431 THAT WAS VERY FRUSTRATING. 105 00:04:56,464 --> 00:04:59,723 Nichole: I'M GOING TO MEET HALEIGH TOMORROW AFTER SCHOOL. 106 00:04:59,755 --> 00:05:01,026 Kristine: OKAY. 107 00:05:01,058 --> 00:05:02,459 JUST LET ME KNOW IF YOU NEED A RIDE HOME. 108 00:05:02,493 --> 00:05:03,731 - Nichole: COOL. - Kristine: OKAY. 109 00:05:03,763 --> 00:05:07,902 TEENAGERS -- OH MY GOODNESS -- 110 00:05:07,934 --> 00:05:09,173 THEY REBEL. 111 00:05:09,205 --> 00:05:12,824 AND THE MORE YOU PUSH, THE MORE THEY REBEL. 112 00:05:22,600 --> 00:05:24,978 [ BELL RINGING ] 113 00:05:25,010 --> 00:05:27,617 Narrator: NICHOLE FILLS HALEIGH IN ON THE PLAN 114 00:05:27,650 --> 00:05:30,551 AND GETS READY TO MEET KYLE FOR THE FIRST TIME. 115 00:05:30,583 --> 00:05:33,386 Haleigh: NICHOLE AND I -- WE WERE LIKE SISTERS, 116 00:05:33,418 --> 00:05:35,144 SO WE ALWAYS TOOK CARE OF EACH OTHER. 117 00:05:35,177 --> 00:05:37,654 SHE HAD MY BACK AND I HAD HER BACK THROUGH EVERYTHING. 118 00:05:37,687 --> 00:05:38,926 - YOU'RE SURE? - Nichole: YEAH, 119 00:05:38,958 --> 00:05:40,262 AND HE SEEMS REALLY NICE. 120 00:05:40,294 --> 00:05:42,543 Haleigh: SO WHEN SHE MET KYLE, SHE TOLD ME ABOUT IT. 121 00:05:42,575 --> 00:05:43,651 BEAUTIFUL. GO, I'LL SEE YOU TOMORROW. 122 00:05:43,683 --> 00:05:45,020 Nichole: HAVE FUN, BYE. 123 00:05:45,052 --> 00:05:46,584 Narrator: IT WILL BE THE FIRST TIME SHE'S MET UP 124 00:05:46,616 --> 00:05:48,963 WITH SOMEONE SHE'S ONLY MESSAGED ONLINE, 125 00:05:48,995 --> 00:05:52,058 BUT KYLE SEEMS LIKE SOMEONE SHE CAN TRUST. 126 00:05:52,091 --> 00:05:54,112 Haleigh: THAT WHOLE THERE WHERE, LIKE, YOUR PARENTS SAY, 127 00:05:54,144 --> 00:05:57,403 "STRANGER DANGER," IT'S REAL. 128 00:05:57,435 --> 00:05:59,586 BUT WE THOUGHT WE WERE INVINCIBLE. 129 00:06:05,147 --> 00:06:06,744 - Dube: HEY. - Nichole: HEY. 130 00:06:06,777 --> 00:06:08,439 - Dube: NICHOLE? - Nichole: KYLE? 131 00:06:08,471 --> 00:06:09,938 - HEY. - Dube: NICE TO FINALLY MEET YOU. 132 00:06:09,971 --> 00:06:10,979 Nichole: HEY, NICE TO MEET YOU TOO. 133 00:06:11,014 --> 00:06:12,708 - Dube: HOW YOU DOING? - Nichole: GOOD. 134 00:06:12,740 --> 00:06:14,142 - Dube: GOOD. - Nichole: NICE TRUCK. 135 00:06:14,174 --> 00:06:15,885 Dube: THANKS, YEAH. 136 00:06:15,886 --> 00:06:17,595 Nichole: IT'S COOL. 137 00:06:17,627 --> 00:06:19,779 Dube: YOU WANT TO GO FOR A WALK? 138 00:06:19,812 --> 00:06:21,636 - Nichole: YEAH. - Dube: ALL RIGHT. 139 00:06:21,670 --> 00:06:23,625 THIS WAY. 140 00:06:23,657 --> 00:06:27,372 Narrator: NICHOLE THINKS KYLE'S EVEN BETTER LOOKING IN PERSON, 141 00:06:27,405 --> 00:06:29,196 BUT OLDER THAN SHE WAS EXPECTING. 142 00:06:29,230 --> 00:06:31,120 Nichole: SO HOW OLD ARE YOU? 143 00:06:31,152 --> 00:06:33,890 Dube: I'M 19, ALMOST 20. 144 00:06:36,237 --> 00:06:37,898 Nichole: THAT'S PRETTY COOL. 145 00:06:37,930 --> 00:06:41,092 Dube: YEAH... I'M A DAD TOO. 146 00:06:41,125 --> 00:06:43,568 I HAVE A FOUR-YEAR-OLD DAUGHTER AT HOME. 147 00:06:43,601 --> 00:06:44,725 Nichole: WOW. 148 00:06:44,726 --> 00:06:45,849 Dube: YEAH. 149 00:06:45,882 --> 00:06:47,706 Nichole: IS HER MOM THERE? 150 00:06:47,739 --> 00:06:51,650 Dube: UH, NO, WE, UH, WE BROKE UP. 151 00:06:51,682 --> 00:06:53,865 UH, MY DAUGHTER LIVES AT HOME WITH ME. 152 00:06:53,898 --> 00:06:55,788 THE MOM HELPS TO BABYSIT 153 00:06:55,821 --> 00:06:59,927 BECAUSE I'M OUT OF THE HOUSE A LOT, I WORK MOST NIGHTS. 154 00:06:59,959 --> 00:07:01,492 BUT, UH, I'M KIND OF 155 00:07:01,524 --> 00:07:05,337 LIKE A CARE WORKER FOR OLD PEOPLE. 156 00:07:07,389 --> 00:07:09,215 - Nichole: THAT'S PRETTY COOL. - Dube: YEAH. 157 00:07:09,247 --> 00:07:11,299 Narrator: NICHOLE LOVES THAT KYLE IS SO MATURE 158 00:07:11,333 --> 00:07:13,678 AND IS TAKING FATHERHOOD SERIOUSLY. 159 00:07:13,712 --> 00:07:16,286 SHE WANTS TO KNOW MORE ABOUT HIM, 160 00:07:16,318 --> 00:07:17,589 BUT SHE'LL HAVE TO WAIT. 161 00:07:17,622 --> 00:07:18,828 Nichole: UH, MY MOM WANTS TO KNOW WHAT TIME 162 00:07:18,861 --> 00:07:20,490 SHE SHOULD PICK ME UP. 163 00:07:20,522 --> 00:07:23,879 Dube: UM, I COULD PROBABLY GIVE YOU A RIDE IF YOU LIKE? 164 00:07:23,911 --> 00:07:25,280 - Nichole: COOL. - Dube: ALL RIGHT. 165 00:07:25,312 --> 00:07:27,040 LET'S GET OUT OF HERE THEN. 166 00:07:30,201 --> 00:07:31,471 Narrator: KYLE MAKES THE SHORT DRIVE 167 00:07:31,504 --> 00:07:33,556 TO NICHOLE'S HOUSE. 168 00:07:33,590 --> 00:07:34,861 HE PARKS ON THE MAIN ROAD 169 00:07:34,893 --> 00:07:36,980 SO THEY DON'T GET CAUGHT 170 00:07:37,012 --> 00:07:39,946 AND WAITS UNTIL NICHOLE IS SAFELY INSIDE. 171 00:07:47,994 --> 00:07:49,347 [ MOBILE RINGING ] 172 00:07:49,348 --> 00:07:50,699 Nichole: HEY, TY. 173 00:07:50,732 --> 00:07:53,403 Narrator: NICHOLE HAS A HUGE CRUSH ON KYLE ALREADY... 174 00:07:53,435 --> 00:07:55,391 Narrator: AND CAN'T WAIT TO TELL HER FRIENDS. 175 00:07:55,424 --> 00:07:56,858 Nichole: HE LOOKS LIKE A GROWN-UP. 176 00:07:56,891 --> 00:07:59,463 Tyler-Ann: NICHOLE TOLD ME THAT SHE THOUGHT THAT HE WAS FUNNY. 177 00:07:59,497 --> 00:08:02,267 HE WAS MATURE, LIKE, HE WASN'T LIKE THOSE KIDS IN OUR CLASS. 178 00:08:02,300 --> 00:08:03,603 Nichole: AND HE HAS A TRUCK. 179 00:08:03,635 --> 00:08:06,699 Tyler-Ann: HE HAD A CAR, HE HAD A JOB. 180 00:08:06,732 --> 00:08:10,056 Tyler-Ann: SO HE WAS ALMOST LIKE A FULL-GROWN MAN AT THIS POINT 181 00:08:10,088 --> 00:08:11,718 AND THAT'S WHAT SHE REALLY WANTED. 182 00:08:11,750 --> 00:08:13,315 Nichole: OKAY, I'LL SEE YOU TOMORROW. 183 00:08:13,347 --> 00:08:15,075 BYE. 184 00:08:28,109 --> 00:08:30,978 Narrator: KYLE SEEMS SERIOUS ABOUT NICHOLE. 185 00:08:39,711 --> 00:08:41,145 Nichole: MOM? 186 00:08:41,177 --> 00:08:43,621 Narrator: MEETING KYLE'S DAUGHTER IS A HUGE DEAL 187 00:08:43,654 --> 00:08:46,587 AND NICHOLE CAN'T KEEP HIM A SECRET ANY LONGER. 188 00:08:46,619 --> 00:08:47,825 Nichole: CAN I GO FOR A RIDE WITH A FRIEND, 189 00:08:47,857 --> 00:08:49,063 HE'S GOING TO PICK ME UP. 190 00:08:49,096 --> 00:08:50,433 Kristine: NICHOLE HAD ASKED 191 00:08:50,465 --> 00:08:52,811 IF SHE COULD GO FOR A RIDE WITH THIS BOY. 192 00:08:52,843 --> 00:08:53,984 - BOYFRIEND? - Nichole: NO. 193 00:08:54,016 --> 00:08:56,330 HE'S JUST -- HE'S 17, SO HE CAN DRIVE. 194 00:08:56,363 --> 00:08:59,035 Kristine: SHE HAD SAID HE WAS 17 AND HIS NAME 195 00:08:59,067 --> 00:09:02,326 WAS KYLE AND THEY WERE JUST FRIENDS. 196 00:09:02,358 --> 00:09:04,445 OKAY, BUT YOU KNOW THE HOUSE RULES. 197 00:09:04,477 --> 00:09:06,726 - Nichole: YUP, YUP. - Kristine: HE'S GOT TO COME IN. 198 00:09:06,758 --> 00:09:08,062 Nichole: I KNOW. 199 00:09:08,094 --> 00:09:10,017 Kristine: AND WE SAID, "WELL, HE'S GOT TO COME IN, 200 00:09:10,050 --> 00:09:11,842 WE HAVE TO MEET HIM BEFORE, YOU KNOW, 201 00:09:11,874 --> 00:09:14,351 YOU CAN GO ANYWHERE WITH HIM." 202 00:09:14,384 --> 00:09:17,251 Narrator: AS NICHOLE CONFIRMS THE DATE, 203 00:09:17,284 --> 00:09:20,282 AN UNEXPECTED MESSAGE COMES THROUGH. 204 00:09:20,315 --> 00:09:24,323 SOMEONE WANTS TO KNOW WHAT'S UP BETWEEN HER AND KYLE. 205 00:09:24,356 --> 00:09:27,354 BUT IT ISN'T THE FIRST TIME SOMEONE'S BEEN JEALOUS OF HER. 206 00:09:32,230 --> 00:09:35,262 Nichole: SORRY ABOUT THIS, 207 00:09:35,294 --> 00:09:37,835 BUT DO YOU MIND COMING INSIDE AND MEETING MY MOM? 208 00:09:37,868 --> 00:09:39,204 Dube: NO, I DON'T MIND. 209 00:09:39,205 --> 00:09:40,540 Nichole: AWESOME. 210 00:09:40,573 --> 00:09:42,527 Narrator: NICHOLE THINKS HER MOM WILL BUY HER STORY 211 00:09:42,560 --> 00:09:45,102 ABOUT KYLE'S AGE, 212 00:09:45,135 --> 00:09:49,372 BUT HER STEP-DAD MIGHT BE HARDER TO CONVINCE. 213 00:09:49,404 --> 00:09:52,727 NICHOLE'S MOM, KRISTINE, MARRIED JASON WILEY FOUR YEARS 214 00:09:52,761 --> 00:09:55,694 AFTER SPLITTING FROM NICHOLE'S DAD IN 2002, 215 00:09:55,726 --> 00:09:57,811 WHEN NICHOLE WAS JUST FIVE. 216 00:09:59,832 --> 00:10:02,798 Jason: WHEN HE CAME IN, I WAS ACTUALLY IN THE MIDDLE 217 00:10:02,830 --> 00:10:05,601 OF CLEANING MY 9 MILLIMETER GUN. 218 00:10:05,633 --> 00:10:07,980 AND I SAID, "HEY, KYLE. 219 00:10:08,012 --> 00:10:09,772 COME HERE, I WANT TO SHOW YOU SOMETHING." 220 00:10:09,804 --> 00:10:12,313 YOU EVER SEEN ONE OF THESE THINGS? 221 00:10:12,345 --> 00:10:14,301 AND I SHOWED HIM THE GUN... 222 00:10:14,334 --> 00:10:16,191 Dube: YEAH, IT'S A 9 MIL. 223 00:10:16,224 --> 00:10:18,375 Jason: AND I SAID TO HIM, "JUST SO YOU KNOW, 224 00:10:18,408 --> 00:10:19,972 IF YOU HAVE ANY THOUGHTS 225 00:10:20,004 --> 00:10:22,676 OF DOING ANYTHING OTHER THAN FRIENDS 226 00:10:22,709 --> 00:10:24,827 THAT THIS IS HERE ON THE TABLE." 227 00:10:24,859 --> 00:10:26,522 UNDERSTOOD? 228 00:10:26,554 --> 00:10:27,923 Dube: UNDERSTOOD. 229 00:10:27,955 --> 00:10:31,604 Jason: JUST TO LET HIM KNOW THAT I'M A CARING STEP-FATHER. 230 00:10:31,638 --> 00:10:34,668 ALL RIGHT. 231 00:10:34,701 --> 00:10:37,764 Kristine: HEY, SO KYLE, HOW OLD ARE YOU? 232 00:10:37,797 --> 00:10:40,370 HE LOOKED AT ME AND HE'S LIKE, "UM"... 233 00:10:40,404 --> 00:10:43,532 Dube: UM, 18. 234 00:10:43,565 --> 00:10:48,029 Kristine: IT WAS MORE LIKE A QUESTION, NOT A STATEMENT. 235 00:10:48,063 --> 00:10:50,245 Narrator: KRISTINE ISN'T CONVINCED, 236 00:10:50,278 --> 00:10:53,960 SHE KNOWS KYLE IS HIDING SOMETHING... 237 00:10:53,993 --> 00:10:55,654 - Nichole: LET'S GO IN HERE. - Dube: ALL RIGHT. 238 00:10:55,687 --> 00:10:57,820 Narrator: BUT DECIDES TO PUT HER DAUGHTER'S HAPPINESS FIRST. 239 00:10:58,410 --> 00:11:00,170 Jason: MY WIFE SAID, "WELL, GEEZ, WE NEED TO TRUST HER, 240 00:11:00,203 --> 00:11:02,875 WE NEED TO GIVE HER A LITTLE BIT OF FREEDOM." 241 00:11:02,908 --> 00:11:05,449 SO WE MADE THE DECISION TO LET HER GO. 242 00:11:07,959 --> 00:11:11,218 Narrator: IT'S A 20-MINUTE DRIVE TO KYLE'S HOUSE IN ORONO, 243 00:11:11,250 --> 00:11:14,801 AND NICHOLE CANNOT WAIT TO MEET HIS DAUGHTER. 244 00:11:14,835 --> 00:11:18,906 Haleigh: SHE WENT AND HUNG OUT WITH KYLE AT HIS HOUSE. 245 00:11:18,941 --> 00:11:20,440 Dube: JUST, UH, CHILL OUT HERE, 246 00:11:20,473 --> 00:11:22,688 UH, I'LL GO GET HER. 247 00:11:22,721 --> 00:11:25,166 Haleigh: AND HE HAD A DAUGHTER NAMED SAVANNAH 248 00:11:25,198 --> 00:11:28,164 AND SHE WAS LIKE FOUR AT THE TIME. 249 00:11:32,595 --> 00:11:34,354 - Dube: AND THIS IS NICHOLE. - Nichole: HI THERE. 250 00:11:34,387 --> 00:11:35,789 Dube: THIS IS MY FRIEND. 251 00:11:35,790 --> 00:11:37,190 Nichole: IT'S NICE TO MEET YOU. 252 00:11:37,222 --> 00:11:38,624 Dube: THIS IS SAVANNAH. 253 00:11:38,625 --> 00:11:40,024 Nichole: SHE'S SO CUTE. 254 00:11:40,058 --> 00:11:42,208 Haleigh: SHE ABSOLUTELY ADORED SAVANNAH. 255 00:11:42,241 --> 00:11:44,098 Nichole: PRETTY HAIR. 256 00:11:44,131 --> 00:11:46,477 Haleigh: AND SAVANNAH WAS RIGHT IN LOVE WITH NICHOLE. 257 00:11:46,509 --> 00:11:48,563 - Dube: LET'S GO ON THE SWING. - Nichole: THAT SOUNDS FUN. 258 00:11:48,596 --> 00:11:50,192 Narrator: NICHOLE IS HAVING A WONDERFUL TIME 259 00:11:50,225 --> 00:11:53,287 WITH KYLE AND HIS DAUGHTER, WHEN SUDDENLY... 260 00:11:53,321 --> 00:11:54,754 Dube: HEY, UH, MAYBE YOU SHOULD GET GOING? 261 00:11:54,787 --> 00:11:56,221 - Nichole: WHY? - Dube: UM, YOU'RE JUST GOING 262 00:11:56,254 --> 00:11:57,687 TO GET -- UH, THAT'S MY GIRLFRIEND. 263 00:11:57,720 --> 00:11:59,153 - Mason: WHO THE HELL IS SHE? - Nichole: WHAT? 264 00:11:59,186 --> 00:12:00,490 Dube: IT'S COOL SARAH. SARAH. 265 00:12:00,522 --> 00:12:01,631 Mason: YEAH, THE HELL IT'S COOL. 266 00:12:01,663 --> 00:12:02,705 Kristine: I THOUGHT KYLE DUBE WAS THE ONE 267 00:12:02,738 --> 00:12:05,833 I HAD TO WORRY ABOUT HER SEEING, 268 00:12:05,868 --> 00:12:07,529 HOW WRONG WAS I? 269 00:12:16,197 --> 00:12:18,348 Narrator: JUST A WEEK AFTER MEETING 19-YEAR-OLD 270 00:12:18,381 --> 00:12:20,304 KYLE DUBE ONLINE, 271 00:12:20,337 --> 00:12:22,976 NICHOLE IS EXCITED ABOUT BECOMING HIS GIRLFRIEND. 272 00:12:23,008 --> 00:12:24,507 Dube: THIS IS SAVANNAH. 273 00:12:24,539 --> 00:12:27,211 Nichole: BUT SHE'S SHOCKED TO DISCOVER HE ALREADY HAS ONE. 274 00:12:27,244 --> 00:12:29,689 Dube: UM, NO, YOU'RE JUST GOING TO GET -- THAT'S MY GIRLFRIEND. 275 00:12:29,721 --> 00:12:31,221 - Mason: WHO THE HELL IS SHE? - Nichole: WHAT? 276 00:12:31,253 --> 00:12:32,687 Dube: IT'S COOL, SARAH. SARAH. 277 00:12:32,719 --> 00:12:34,152 - Mason: YEAH, THE HELL IT'S COOL. - Dube: I KNOW, YOU KNOW WHAT, 278 00:12:34,186 --> 00:12:36,434 DON'T -- DON'T SWEAR IN FRONT OF SAVANNAH, OKAY, 279 00:12:36,466 --> 00:12:38,226 I TOLD YOU A MILLION TIMES. 280 00:12:38,259 --> 00:12:40,018 Narrator: SIXTEEN-YEAR-OLD SARAH MASON 281 00:12:40,051 --> 00:12:43,180 HAS BEEN DATING KYLE ON AND OFF FOR ALMOST A YEAR 282 00:12:43,212 --> 00:12:45,461 AND SHE HAS A FIERCE REPUTATION. 283 00:12:53,999 --> 00:12:55,270 NICHOLE IS DEVASTATED 284 00:12:55,303 --> 00:12:58,985 THAT KYLE LED HER ON AND IT GETS WORSE. 285 00:12:59,017 --> 00:13:02,473 NEWS OF WHAT HAPPENED SPREADS ACROSS SOCIAL MEDIA. 286 00:13:05,447 --> 00:13:07,110 Kristine: WHAT'S GOING ON? 287 00:13:07,142 --> 00:13:09,195 Nichole: NOTHING. 288 00:13:09,228 --> 00:13:10,987 Kristine: NICHOLE WAS SITTING ON THE COUCH 289 00:13:11,020 --> 00:13:15,485 AND SHE WAS TEXTING ON HER CELL PHONE. 290 00:13:15,517 --> 00:13:16,983 IT DOESN'T LOOK LIKE NOTHING. 291 00:13:17,016 --> 00:13:19,232 I JUST SAID, "WHAT -- YOU KNOW, WHAT'S GOING ON, WHAT'S WRONG?" 292 00:13:19,264 --> 00:13:21,742 SHE LOOKED UPSET. 293 00:13:23,892 --> 00:13:26,597 Nichole: I'M JUST MAD AT KYLE. 294 00:13:26,629 --> 00:13:28,747 Kristine: AND I SAID, "WHY?" 295 00:13:28,780 --> 00:13:30,377 Nichole: HE JUST LIED TO ME, 296 00:13:30,409 --> 00:13:31,714 HE TOLD ME HE DIDN'T HAVE A GIRLFRIEND 297 00:13:31,746 --> 00:13:34,092 AND THEN HE DOES. 298 00:13:34,124 --> 00:13:36,797 Narrator: KYLE'S GIRLFRIEND, SARAH, IS SEETHING WITH ANGER 299 00:13:36,829 --> 00:13:40,122 AND WANTS TO KNOW EXACTLY WHAT'S BEEN GOING ON. 300 00:13:40,154 --> 00:13:42,337 Kristine: KYLE'S GIRLFRIEND WAS MESSAGING NICHOLE 301 00:13:42,370 --> 00:13:45,726 AND ASKING TO SEE TEXT MESSAGES 302 00:13:45,758 --> 00:13:48,919 AND PRIVATE MESSAGES BETWEEN THE TWO OF THEM. 303 00:13:48,952 --> 00:13:50,386 ARE YOU OKAY? 304 00:13:50,418 --> 00:13:52,178 Nichole: YEAH, I'M FINE. 305 00:13:52,211 --> 00:13:54,654 Tyler-Ann: SARAH'S MAD BECAUSE SHE THOUGHT 306 00:13:54,686 --> 00:13:58,272 THAT KYLE WAS CHEATING ON HER. 307 00:13:58,305 --> 00:13:59,999 AND NICHOLE WAS UPSET WITH KYLE 308 00:14:00,032 --> 00:14:02,411 BECAUSE KYLE LIED TO HER. 309 00:14:05,344 --> 00:14:07,331 Narrator: NICHOLE STOPS TEXTING KYLE 310 00:14:07,363 --> 00:14:08,928 AND HOPES SARAH WILL CALM DOWN 311 00:14:08,960 --> 00:14:10,753 WHEN SHE FIGURES OUT NOTHING HAPPENED. 312 00:14:18,737 --> 00:14:20,659 SHE NEEDS A DISTRACTION... 313 00:14:20,692 --> 00:14:24,342 AND SOMEONE NEW TO TALK TO. 314 00:14:24,375 --> 00:14:26,623 THERE ARE PLENTY OF OFFERS, 315 00:14:26,655 --> 00:14:30,371 BUT ONE WHICH STANDS OUT. 316 00:14:30,404 --> 00:14:32,358 BRYAN BUTTERFIELD RECENTLY GRADUATED 317 00:14:32,391 --> 00:14:33,663 FROM NICHOLE'S HIGH SCHOOL 318 00:14:33,695 --> 00:14:35,682 AND THEY HAVE LOTS OF FRIENDS IN COMMON. 319 00:14:35,716 --> 00:14:39,398 HE IS ALSO SERIOUSLY CUTE. 320 00:14:39,431 --> 00:14:42,330 IT IS EXACTLY WHAT NICHOLE NEEDS AFTER EVERYTHING 321 00:14:42,363 --> 00:14:44,090 THAT HAPPENED WITH KYLE. 322 00:15:05,077 --> 00:15:07,781 [ BELL RINGING ] 323 00:15:07,814 --> 00:15:09,345 Nichole: UH, EVERYONE CAN SLEEP OVER. 324 00:15:09,379 --> 00:15:11,399 - Haleigh: SOME S'MORES. - Nichole: WORKING ON MY MOM 325 00:15:11,431 --> 00:15:13,875 TO SEE HOW MANY PEOPLE THAT I CAN INVITE. 326 00:15:13,908 --> 00:15:16,189 OH, BY THE WAY, DID I TELL YOU 327 00:15:16,221 --> 00:15:18,927 THIS CUTIE ADDED ME ON FACEBOOK. 328 00:15:18,959 --> 00:15:20,263 Tyler-Ann: NICHOLE SHOWED ME HIS PICTURE 329 00:15:20,295 --> 00:15:22,610 AND WE WERE BOTH THINKING ABOUT HOW IT WAS REALLY STRANGE 330 00:15:22,642 --> 00:15:25,248 THAT IT WAS LIKE A SURFER WITH A SURFBOARD, 331 00:15:25,281 --> 00:15:27,041 ESPECIALLY BECAUSE WE LIVE IN MAINE. 332 00:15:27,074 --> 00:15:28,898 BUT HE WAS PRETTY CUTE, TO BE HONEST. 333 00:15:28,930 --> 00:15:31,668 HE HAD, LIKE, LONG, BLONDE, CURLY SURFER HAIR. 334 00:15:31,700 --> 00:15:33,591 - Haleigh: HE'S HOT. - Nichole: YEAH, MORE YOUR TYPE? 335 00:15:33,623 --> 00:15:36,361 Haleigh: HE WAS HOT. [ LAUGHS ] HE WAS HOT. 336 00:15:36,394 --> 00:15:37,762 HE'S VERY HOT. 337 00:15:37,795 --> 00:15:39,293 ARE YOU GOING TO MESSAGE HIM? 338 00:15:39,326 --> 00:15:40,923 Nichole: YEAH, WE'VE ALREADY BEEN CHATTING. 339 00:15:40,956 --> 00:15:42,422 - I HAVE TO GO, LADIES. - Haleigh: ALL RIGHT. 340 00:15:42,454 --> 00:15:43,629 - HAVE A GOOD ONE. - Nichole: BYE. - Tyler-Ann: BYE. 341 00:15:44,746 --> 00:15:47,027 Narrator: WITH NEW GUY, BRYAN, ON THE SCENE, 342 00:15:47,060 --> 00:15:51,166 NICHOLE FORGETS ALL ABOUT KYLE. 343 00:15:51,198 --> 00:15:54,327 BUT NOT EVERYONE IS MOVING ON SO FAST. 344 00:16:00,486 --> 00:16:02,669 SARAH'S HATE FOR NICHOLE RUNS DEEP. 345 00:16:02,701 --> 00:16:04,136 Kristine: ARE YOU OKAY? 346 00:16:04,168 --> 00:16:05,864 Nichole: YEAH, I'M FINE. 347 00:16:14,987 --> 00:16:16,780 Narrator: IT'S SATURDAY AFTERNOON 348 00:16:16,812 --> 00:16:19,517 AND BRYAN BUTTERFIELD SENDS AN INVITATION. 349 00:16:19,549 --> 00:16:22,450 FINALLY, SHE'LL GET TO MEET HER MYSTERY MAN. 350 00:16:38,157 --> 00:16:39,363 Nichole: MOM. 351 00:16:39,395 --> 00:16:40,731 Kristine: YEAH? 352 00:16:40,764 --> 00:16:42,099 Nichole: CAN I GO TO A PARTY TONIGHT? 353 00:16:42,133 --> 00:16:43,436 MY FRIEND CAN GIVE ME A RIDE. 354 00:16:43,470 --> 00:16:46,109 Kristine: NICHOLE HAD ASKED IF SHE COULD GO TO A PARTY 355 00:16:46,142 --> 00:16:47,347 WITH A FRIEND. 356 00:16:47,378 --> 00:16:48,714 DO I KNOW THEM? 357 00:16:48,747 --> 00:16:50,605 Nichole: UM, NO, DO YOU HAVE TO MEET HIM? 358 00:16:50,638 --> 00:16:52,007 Kristine: ABSOLUTELY. 359 00:16:52,039 --> 00:16:54,973 YOU CAN KIND OF JUDGE PEOPLE BETTER THAT WAY. 360 00:16:55,006 --> 00:16:56,733 Nichole: OKAY, I'LL LET HIM KNOW. 361 00:17:05,368 --> 00:17:09,246 Narrator: NICHOLE IS DETERMINED TO MAKE THIS DATE A SUCCESS -- 362 00:17:09,279 --> 00:17:12,634 A PARTY IN A FANCY PART OF TOWN CALLS FOR EXTRA EFFORT. 363 00:17:14,330 --> 00:17:17,034 Kristine: SHE WAS PRETTY EXCITED ABOUT GOING. 364 00:17:17,066 --> 00:17:19,055 I THINK SHE CHANGED HER HAIR 365 00:17:19,087 --> 00:17:21,825 LIKE THREE OR FOUR TIMES THAT NIGHT. 366 00:17:21,857 --> 00:17:24,041 SHE'S A KID, SHE'S A TEENAGER, 367 00:17:24,073 --> 00:17:26,322 THEY WANT TO GO AND HAVE FUN. 368 00:17:31,958 --> 00:17:33,556 Narrator: BUT THERE'S A PROBLEM. 369 00:17:40,531 --> 00:17:43,235 BRYAN'S LOST AND RUNNING LATE FOR THE PARTY. 370 00:17:47,275 --> 00:17:49,589 NICHOLE CAN'T BELIEVE IT. 371 00:17:49,622 --> 00:17:51,316 IT'S TOO EMBARRASSING FOR HER PARENTS 372 00:17:51,349 --> 00:17:52,749 TO TAKE HER TO THE PARTY, 373 00:17:52,783 --> 00:17:55,520 BUT THERE IS ONE ALTERNATIVE, 374 00:17:55,553 --> 00:17:57,280 KYLE DUBE. 375 00:18:01,386 --> 00:18:03,895 NOW THAT NICHOLE IS MORE INTERESTED IN BRYAN, 376 00:18:03,927 --> 00:18:05,231 SHE LETS KYLE OFF THE HOOK 377 00:18:05,264 --> 00:18:08,099 FOR LYING HER ABOUT HAVING A GIRLFRIEND 378 00:18:08,132 --> 00:18:10,348 IN RETURN FOR A SMALL FAVOR. 379 00:18:15,334 --> 00:18:18,754 THINGS ARE FINALLY FALLING INTO PLACE. 380 00:18:18,788 --> 00:18:21,493 NICHOLE HAS A REALLY GOOD FEELING ABOUT BRYAN. 381 00:18:25,208 --> 00:18:28,401 KYLE PICKS NICHOLE UP AT 9 P.M. 382 00:18:28,433 --> 00:18:30,487 Nichole: THANKS FOR PICKING ME UP. 383 00:18:30,520 --> 00:18:31,953 Dube: YEAH, SURE. 384 00:18:31,985 --> 00:18:35,928 Narrator: BUT IT'S NOT LONG BEFORE THEY RUN INTO TROUBLE. 385 00:18:35,961 --> 00:18:39,221 Macomber: AS THEY DROVE DOWN THE ROAD, THIS LAKE ROAD, 386 00:18:39,253 --> 00:18:40,817 THEY WEREN'T ABLE TO FIND BRYAN. 387 00:18:40,850 --> 00:18:43,946 AND THEY WEREN'T ABLE TO FIND THE PARTY. 388 00:18:43,978 --> 00:18:46,455 NICHOLE REACHED OUT VIA TEXT MESSAGE 389 00:18:46,487 --> 00:18:48,899 ASKING, "WHERE ARE YOU?" 390 00:18:48,931 --> 00:18:50,234 AND HE DIDN'T RESPOND. 391 00:18:50,267 --> 00:18:51,668 Dube: LET'S FORGET IT. 392 00:18:51,702 --> 00:18:54,537 Nichole: NO WAY. JUST PULL OVER. 393 00:18:59,848 --> 00:19:01,836 Narrator: DETERMINED TO FIND BRYAN, 394 00:19:01,868 --> 00:19:04,997 NICHOLE HEADS TOWARDS THE LAKE ALONE TO LOOK FOR THE PARTY. 395 00:19:11,612 --> 00:19:13,567 [ MOBILE RINGING ] 396 00:19:13,601 --> 00:19:16,534 MEANWHILE, KYLE'S GIRLFRIEND, SARAH, SEEMS TO KNOW 397 00:19:16,566 --> 00:19:18,815 THAT KYLE ISN'T JUST OUT ON HIS OWN. 398 00:19:18,847 --> 00:19:20,542 Dube: HEY, BABY. 399 00:19:20,574 --> 00:19:22,204 NO, NOBODY. 400 00:19:27,776 --> 00:19:29,210 [ RUSTLING ] 401 00:19:29,243 --> 00:19:31,166 Nichole: HELLO? 402 00:19:34,945 --> 00:19:35,840 [ RUSTLING ] 403 00:19:36,617 --> 00:19:37,790 HELLO? 404 00:19:40,659 --> 00:19:42,288 [ NICHOLE SCREAMS ] 405 00:19:49,261 --> 00:19:50,760 Narrator: NICHOLE CABLE IS LOOKING FORWARD 406 00:19:50,794 --> 00:19:53,628 TO MEETING HER NEW FACEBOOK FRIEND, BRYAN BUTTERFIELD, 407 00:19:53,660 --> 00:19:56,038 AT AN EXCLUSIVE PARTY ON PUSHAW LAKE 408 00:19:56,072 --> 00:19:58,028 IN OLD TOWN, MAINE. 409 00:19:58,060 --> 00:20:00,047 BUT AFTER GETTING LOST ALONG THE WAY, 410 00:20:00,080 --> 00:20:02,003 SHE FINDS HERSELF IN THE DARK, 411 00:20:02,036 --> 00:20:04,089 DEEP INTO THE WOODS. 412 00:20:04,121 --> 00:20:06,305 [ RUSTLING ] 413 00:20:06,337 --> 00:20:08,065 Nichole: HELLO? 414 00:20:10,998 --> 00:20:12,268 AH! 415 00:20:12,300 --> 00:20:14,289 WHAT ARE YOU DOING?! 416 00:20:14,321 --> 00:20:15,949 YOU SCARED THE HELL OUT OF ME. 417 00:20:15,982 --> 00:20:17,580 Dube: I JUST THOUGHT YOU GOT LOST. 418 00:20:17,612 --> 00:20:19,372 COME ON, LET'S GO. 419 00:20:21,751 --> 00:20:23,478 Narrator: WITH NO SIGN OF THE PARTY, 420 00:20:23,511 --> 00:20:26,118 THERE'S NO OPTION BUT TO TURN BACK. 421 00:20:26,150 --> 00:20:28,986 MEETING BRYAN BUTTERFIELD WILL HAVE TO WAIT. 422 00:20:36,578 --> 00:20:39,022 THE NEXT MORNING, IT'S MOTHER'S DAY. 423 00:20:50,559 --> 00:20:52,774 NICHOLE REFUSES TO LET SARAH'S HOSTILITY 424 00:20:52,807 --> 00:20:54,893 SPOIL THE OCCASION. 425 00:20:56,782 --> 00:20:59,162 MOM? 426 00:20:59,194 --> 00:21:02,974 Kristine: I HAD WOKE UP TO NICHOLE COMING INTO MY ROOM... 427 00:21:03,007 --> 00:21:04,735 Nichole: HAPPY MOTHER'S DAY. 428 00:21:06,886 --> 00:21:10,958 Kristine: AND SHE HAD MADE ME A CARD WITH CONSTRUCTION PAPER 429 00:21:10,991 --> 00:21:12,816 THAT SAID, 430 00:21:12,849 --> 00:21:14,544 "HAPPY MOTHER'S DAY" 431 00:21:14,576 --> 00:21:17,835 AND WITH A HEART AND A FLOWER ON THE FRONT. 432 00:21:17,867 --> 00:21:19,595 THIS IS SO SWEET. 433 00:21:19,627 --> 00:21:24,743 I THINK THAT WAS THE FIRST TIME NICHOLE MADE ME A CARD. 434 00:21:24,776 --> 00:21:25,982 THANK YOU. 435 00:21:26,014 --> 00:21:27,773 - Nichole: I LOVE YOU, MOM. - Kristine: I LOVE YOU, TOO. 436 00:21:27,806 --> 00:21:31,750 THAT WAS DEFINITELY A -- A SPECIAL GIFT. 437 00:21:33,770 --> 00:21:34,975 Narrator: NICHOLE CAN'T GET BRYAN 438 00:21:35,008 --> 00:21:37,092 OUT OF HER MIND. 439 00:21:37,126 --> 00:21:39,636 SHE HOPES HE DIDN'T DITCH HER ON PURPOSE. 440 00:21:48,727 --> 00:21:51,790 NICHOLE'S RELIEVED THAT BRYAN STILL WANTS TO MET UP. 441 00:21:55,603 --> 00:21:57,298 AND SINCE BRYAN'S COMING TO HER, 442 00:21:57,331 --> 00:22:00,329 THERE'S NO CHANCE OF THINGS GOING WRONG THIS TIME. 443 00:22:04,955 --> 00:22:07,529 ANOTHER MESSAGE COMES THROUGH. 444 00:22:07,563 --> 00:22:09,063 IT'S KYLE. 445 00:22:11,604 --> 00:22:13,786 AS NICHOLE IS MEETING BRYAN ALONE, 446 00:22:13,819 --> 00:22:16,362 THERE IS NO NEED TO WORRY ABOUT ANY RETRIBUTION 447 00:22:16,394 --> 00:22:18,967 FROM KYLE'S GIRLFRIEND, SARAH. 448 00:22:19,002 --> 00:22:21,152 ALL SHE NEEDS TO DO NOW... 449 00:22:21,185 --> 00:22:23,434 - Kristine: HEY, HON. - Narrator: IS GET PAST HER MOM. 450 00:22:23,466 --> 00:22:25,454 Kristine: I'M EXHAUSTED, I'LL BE IN MY ROOM, OKAY? 451 00:22:25,487 --> 00:22:27,246 - Nichole: OKAY, GOOD NIGHT. - Kristine: GOOD NIGHT. 452 00:22:29,342 --> 00:22:30,613 Narrator: WITH HER MOM IN BED, 453 00:22:30,645 --> 00:22:32,895 IT'S EASY FOR NICHOLE TO SNEAK OUT. 454 00:22:40,618 --> 00:22:42,345 EVERYTHING IS READY, 455 00:22:42,378 --> 00:22:45,831 SHE IS FINALLY GOING TO MEET BRYAN FACE TO FACE. 456 00:23:00,430 --> 00:23:02,483 THE DRIVEWAY IS PITCH BLACK, 457 00:23:02,515 --> 00:23:04,829 SO NICHOLE MAKES SURE TO STAND WHERE SHE CAN BE SEEN. 458 00:23:31,551 --> 00:23:33,215 Nichole: NO! 459 00:23:44,783 --> 00:23:47,422 Kristine: WE WOKE UP AT LIKE QUARTER AFTER SEVEN, 460 00:23:47,454 --> 00:23:50,257 WHICH IS REALLY LATE, BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT TIME NICHOLE 461 00:23:50,290 --> 00:23:52,505 AND I NEED TO BE LEAVING THE HOUSE. 462 00:23:52,538 --> 00:23:54,885 I WENT OUT INTO THE LIVING ROOM, 463 00:23:54,917 --> 00:23:56,580 NO TV ON. 464 00:23:59,642 --> 00:24:03,096 NICHOLE? 465 00:24:03,129 --> 00:24:04,758 IT WAS SO QUIET. 466 00:24:04,791 --> 00:24:07,333 NICHOLE? 467 00:24:07,365 --> 00:24:08,440 NICHOLE? 468 00:24:08,473 --> 00:24:09,973 AND I SAID, "JASON, THERE'S SOMETHING WRONG, 469 00:24:10,005 --> 00:24:11,994 NICHOLE'S NOT HERE, NICHOLE'S GONE." 470 00:24:12,026 --> 00:24:14,111 Jason: MAYBE SHE'S OUT FRONT. DID YOU EVEN LOOK OUTSIDE? 471 00:24:14,143 --> 00:24:17,045 Kristine: NO. 472 00:24:17,077 --> 00:24:20,596 WHILE HE'S LOOKING OUTSIDE, I'M CALLING HER CELL PHONE. 473 00:24:20,629 --> 00:24:23,919 AND IT'S JUST GOING RIGHT TO VOICEMAIL. 474 00:24:23,953 --> 00:24:26,234 I CALLED HER BEST FRIEND, HALEIGH. 475 00:24:26,266 --> 00:24:29,297 HALEIGH! HALEIGH, DID YOU TALK TO NICHOLE LAST NIGHT? 476 00:24:29,330 --> 00:24:32,230 Haleigh: NICHOLE WOULD TEXT ME WHETHER SHE WAS STAYING 477 00:24:32,263 --> 00:24:35,358 AT SOMEONE'S HOUSE OR IF SHE GOT HOME. 478 00:24:35,391 --> 00:24:38,292 BUT THAT'S WHY I KNEW THERE WAS SOMETHING WRONG, 479 00:24:38,324 --> 00:24:42,299 BECAUSE SHE DIDN'T CALL ME AND TELL ME TO COVER FOR HER. 480 00:24:42,831 --> 00:24:46,514 Kristine: AND THAT WAS THE FIRST I KNEW OF BRYAN BUTTERFIELD. 481 00:24:47,884 --> 00:24:49,219 Narrator: HALEIGH WANTS TO KNOW IF THE MEETING 482 00:24:49,252 --> 00:24:52,185 BETWEEN BRYAN AND NICHOLE FINALLY HAPPENED. 483 00:24:52,218 --> 00:24:55,835 Haleigh: I WENT ON FACEBOOK TO ASK HIM WHERE NICHOLE WAS... 484 00:24:57,985 --> 00:24:59,941 AND IT WAS JUST DELETED, LIKE -- 485 00:24:59,974 --> 00:25:02,026 LIKE IT WAS NEVER EVER EVEN THERE. 486 00:25:02,059 --> 00:25:05,708 THE CUTE SURFER GUY DIDN'T EXIST. 487 00:25:05,742 --> 00:25:07,012 Kristine: I CALLED HALEIGH BACK 488 00:25:07,045 --> 00:25:09,033 AND I SAID, "HAVE YOU GOTTEN AHOLD OF HIM? 489 00:25:09,065 --> 00:25:11,705 Haleigh: NO, HIS FACEBOOK IS GONE. 490 00:25:11,737 --> 00:25:12,976 Kristine: AND I SAID, "WHAT DO YOU MEAN IT'S GONE?" 491 00:25:13,009 --> 00:25:14,703 SHE GOES, "HIS FACEBOOK IS GONE." 492 00:25:14,736 --> 00:25:16,462 Haleigh: WE DO HAVE TO WORRY. 493 00:25:16,495 --> 00:25:19,689 MY STOMACH JUST TURNED. 494 00:25:19,721 --> 00:25:20,731 Narrator: KRISTINE HAS HEARD ENOUGH. 495 00:25:20,764 --> 00:25:23,958 SHE PICKS UP THE PHONE AND DIALS 911. 496 00:25:23,990 --> 00:25:25,293 Kristine: MY DAUGHTER WENT OUT LAST NIGHT 497 00:25:25,326 --> 00:25:28,062 AND SHE MET SOMEBODY AND SHE DIDN'T COME HOME. 498 00:25:28,096 --> 00:25:30,443 Jason: WHEN WE FIRST REPORTED THIS, THE POLICE 499 00:25:30,475 --> 00:25:32,985 SAID, "THIS KIND OF STUFF DOESN'T HAPPEN IN MAINE. 500 00:25:33,018 --> 00:25:35,690 UH, JUST WAIT AND SHE'LL BE HOME." 501 00:25:35,722 --> 00:25:37,611 Kristine: NO, YOU DON'T UNDERSTAND. 502 00:25:37,644 --> 00:25:40,317 Jason: AND WE ARGUED WITH THE OFFICER SAYING, 503 00:25:40,349 --> 00:25:41,848 "LISTEN, THIS IS NOT LIKE HER. 504 00:25:41,881 --> 00:25:44,128 THIS KID DOES NOT TURN HER PHONE OFF. 505 00:25:44,162 --> 00:25:47,779 SHE WOULD ANSWER US EVEN IF IT WAS TO TELL US TO GO TO HELL." 506 00:25:47,811 --> 00:25:49,376 Kristine: I SAID, "WHAT DO I DO? 507 00:25:49,409 --> 00:25:51,396 WHAT AM I SUPPOSED TO DO?" 508 00:25:51,428 --> 00:25:53,319 Narrator: OFFICERS TELL KRISTINE TO SIT TIGHT 509 00:25:53,351 --> 00:25:55,339 AND WAIT FOR NICHOLE TO SHOW UP. 510 00:25:55,372 --> 00:25:57,263 BUT KRISTINE KNOWS THERE'S NO WAY 511 00:25:57,295 --> 00:25:58,891 HER DAUGHTER WOULD BE OFF HER CELL PHONE 512 00:25:58,924 --> 00:26:00,945 FOR ALMOST 12 HOURS. 513 00:26:00,977 --> 00:26:03,291 Kristine: I GOT OFF THE PHONE AND I IMMEDIATELY TOOK 514 00:26:03,323 --> 00:26:04,855 SOME PHOTOS OF PHOTOS 515 00:26:04,888 --> 00:26:08,896 THAT I HAD OF NICHOLE AND I MADE A POSTER. 516 00:26:08,929 --> 00:26:11,535 Haleigh: WE TRIED GETTING THEM OUT THERE EVERYWHERE WE COULD. 517 00:26:11,568 --> 00:26:13,524 WE WANTED NICHOLE TO COME HOME. 518 00:26:17,680 --> 00:26:19,799 Narrator: IT DOESN'T TAKE LONG FOR KRISTINE'S POSTERS 519 00:26:19,832 --> 00:26:21,297 TO SPREAD ACROSS TOWN, 520 00:26:21,331 --> 00:26:24,621 INSPIRING THE WHOLE COMMUNITY TO JOIN THE SEARCH. 521 00:26:24,654 --> 00:26:26,056 Tyler-Ann: EVERYWHERE YOU WENT YOU COULD SEE 522 00:26:26,088 --> 00:26:27,489 WHERE THEIR FLYERS WERE. 523 00:26:27,523 --> 00:26:30,749 THEY WERE JUST -- FLOODED THE TOWN. 524 00:26:30,781 --> 00:26:33,551 Narrator: WITH NICHOLE NOW MISSING FOR MORE THAN 24 HOURS 525 00:26:33,583 --> 00:26:37,592 AND THE TOWN UP IN ARMS, THE POLICE TAKE ACTION. 526 00:26:37,624 --> 00:26:40,068 Jason: WE HAD THE POLICE COME OUT AND SPEAK WITH US. 527 00:26:40,101 --> 00:26:42,154 AND THEY SAID, "THIS IS SERIOUS." 528 00:26:42,187 --> 00:26:43,685 Deputy: HI, HALEIGH. 529 00:26:43,718 --> 00:26:46,684 Narrator: HALEIGH TELLS THE DETECTIVES EVERYTHING SHE KNOWS. 530 00:26:46,717 --> 00:26:48,313 Deputy: WHAT CAN YOU TELL ME ABOUT THE GUY THAT SHE ARRANGED 531 00:26:48,346 --> 00:26:49,746 TO MEET LAST NIGHT. 532 00:26:49,779 --> 00:26:52,126 Haleigh: UM, I KNOW THAT HIS NAME IS BRYAN BUTTERFIELD 533 00:26:52,158 --> 00:26:54,831 AND THAT THEY MET ON-- ONLINE ON FACEBOOK. 534 00:26:54,863 --> 00:26:56,394 Zainea: THE DEPUTY AT THAT TIME ALSO 535 00:26:56,427 --> 00:26:58,805 SPOKE AT LENGTH WITH HALEIGH 536 00:26:58,839 --> 00:27:01,706 TO DETERMINE WHO BRYAN BUTTERFIELD WAS. 537 00:27:01,740 --> 00:27:02,912 Deputy: DO YOU HAVE ANY IDEA 538 00:27:02,945 --> 00:27:04,150 WHAT HE LOOKS LIKE, WHERE HE MIGHT LIVE? 539 00:27:04,183 --> 00:27:06,595 Haleigh: UM, SHE SENT ME HIS PHOTO. 540 00:27:06,627 --> 00:27:08,320 THAT'S ALL I HAVE. 541 00:27:08,355 --> 00:27:09,723 Narrator: TO POLICE, EVERYTHING 542 00:27:09,755 --> 00:27:13,667 SUGGESTS THE BRYAN BUTTERFIELD FACEBOOK ACCOUNT IS A FAKE. 543 00:27:19,043 --> 00:27:20,770 BUT THEY NEED TO BE SURE. 544 00:27:20,802 --> 00:27:24,420 SO THEY RUN A SEARCH FOR ANYONE BY THAT NAME. 545 00:27:24,453 --> 00:27:26,407 Deputy: WE'RE GOING TO CHECK OUT THESE RECORDS HERE, OKAY? 546 00:27:26,440 --> 00:27:30,611 Macomber: THE DEPUTY THEN CHECKS SOME RECORDS 547 00:27:30,644 --> 00:27:35,923 AND FOUND OUT THAT THERE WAS SOMEONE NAMED BRYAN BUTTERFIELD. 548 00:27:35,956 --> 00:27:38,205 Deputy: CAN YOU GET ME AN ADDRESS FOR BRYAN BUTTERFIELD? 549 00:27:38,237 --> 00:27:39,997 Narrator: AND HE LIVES 15 MINUTES AWAY, 550 00:27:40,029 --> 00:27:42,572 JUST OUTSIDE BANGOR, MAINE. 551 00:27:45,276 --> 00:27:47,948 DETECTIVES HEAD TO BRYAN BUTTERFIELD'S HOUSE. 552 00:27:47,981 --> 00:27:50,034 THEY HOPE THEY'RE NOT TOO LATE. 553 00:28:04,926 --> 00:28:06,654 Deputy: I'M LOOKING FOR BRYAN BUTTERFIELD. 554 00:28:14,093 --> 00:28:15,723 Narrator: NO ONE HAS SEEN NICHOLE CABLE 555 00:28:15,756 --> 00:28:17,645 SINCE SHE LEFT HER HOUSE ON MOTHER'S DAY 556 00:28:17,678 --> 00:28:21,198 TO MEET HER ONLINE SURFER BOYFRIEND, BRYAN BUTTERFIELD. 557 00:28:23,153 --> 00:28:27,553 DETECTIVES RACE TO BUTTERFIELD'S DOORSTEP IN DOWNTOWN BANGOR. 558 00:28:29,768 --> 00:28:31,723 Deputy: I'M LOOKING FOR BRYAN BUTTERFIELD. 559 00:28:31,756 --> 00:28:33,418 Butterfield: THAT'S ME, CAN I HELP? 560 00:28:33,451 --> 00:28:36,416 Macomber: THE BRYAN BUTTERFIELD THAT THE DEPUTY 561 00:28:36,449 --> 00:28:39,479 WAS SPEAKING TO LOOKED ABSOLUTELY NOTHING 562 00:28:39,512 --> 00:28:40,978 LIKE THE BRYAN BUTTERFIELD 563 00:28:41,011 --> 00:28:43,096 THAT NICHOLE HAD BEEN COMMUNICATING WITH. 564 00:28:43,130 --> 00:28:44,694 Deputy: MIND IF I ASK YOU A FEW QUESTIONS? 565 00:28:44,727 --> 00:28:46,225 Butterfield: NO, COME IN. 566 00:28:46,257 --> 00:28:48,147 Macomber: THERE WAS NO RESEMBLANCE WHATSOEVER. 567 00:28:48,180 --> 00:28:49,843 Deputy: YOU MIND IF I TAKE A LOOK AT YOUR COMPUTER? 568 00:28:49,875 --> 00:28:51,308 Butterfield: NO, GO AHEAD. 569 00:28:51,341 --> 00:28:52,938 Macomber: YOU CAN TELL SOMETIMES 570 00:28:52,972 --> 00:28:55,642 WHEN SOMEONE HAS NO IDEA WHAT YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT. 571 00:28:55,675 --> 00:28:58,185 BRYAN BUTTERFIELD KNEW ABSOLUTELY NOTHING 572 00:28:58,217 --> 00:28:59,846 ABOUT WHAT HE WAS REFERRING TO 573 00:28:59,879 --> 00:29:02,812 AND ABOUT HIS COMMUNICATION WITH NICHOLE. 574 00:29:02,845 --> 00:29:04,833 Narrator: BUT DESPITE LOOKING DIFFERENT, 575 00:29:04,865 --> 00:29:07,472 A LOT OF HIS DETAILS MATCHED THE ONLINE PROFILE 576 00:29:07,504 --> 00:29:11,480 THAT NICHOLE HAD SHOWN HER FRIEND HALEIGH. 577 00:29:11,513 --> 00:29:15,228 BOTH LIVE IN BANGOR, BOTH WENT TO OLD TOWN HIGH SCHOOL 578 00:29:15,261 --> 00:29:17,248 AND BOTH ARE 18. 579 00:29:17,281 --> 00:29:22,136 WHOEVER SET UP THE FAKE PROFILE MUST HAVE KNOWN THE REAL BRYAN. 580 00:29:22,169 --> 00:29:23,212 Deputy: CAN YOU THINK OF ANYBODY 581 00:29:23,245 --> 00:29:24,548 THAT WOULD WANT TO GET YOU IN TROUBLE? 582 00:29:24,580 --> 00:29:26,535 Butterfield: YEAH, ACTUALLY. THERE'S AN EX-GIRLFRIEND. 583 00:29:26,569 --> 00:29:28,458 SHE'S BEEN MAKING LIFE HELL RECENTLY. 584 00:29:28,492 --> 00:29:29,665 Deputy: YEAH? WHAT'S HER NAME? 585 00:29:29,698 --> 00:29:33,770 Butterfield: SARAH. SARAH MASON. 586 00:29:33,804 --> 00:29:35,139 Macomber: BRYAN TOLD THE DEPUTY 587 00:29:35,172 --> 00:29:38,300 THAT HE AND SARAH HAD DATED FOR A WHILE. 588 00:29:38,332 --> 00:29:39,538 Deputy: DO YOU KNOW WHERE WE CAN FIND HER? 589 00:29:39,571 --> 00:29:42,308 Butterfield: SHE LIVES IN ORONO WITH HER NEW BOYFRIEND, 590 00:29:42,341 --> 00:29:45,079 SOME GUY NAMED KYLE DUBE. 591 00:29:48,044 --> 00:29:49,249 Narrator: DETECTIVES HEAD STRAIGHT 592 00:29:49,283 --> 00:29:53,943 OVER TO KYLE DUBE'S HOUSE IN NEARBY ORONO. 593 00:29:53,975 --> 00:29:55,897 THEY WANT TO KNOW IF SARAH IS BEHIND 594 00:29:55,931 --> 00:29:59,220 THE FAKE FACEBOOK ACCOUNT. 595 00:29:59,253 --> 00:30:00,949 Deputy: EXCUSE ME, SIR. 596 00:30:00,981 --> 00:30:02,904 Dube: HOW CAN I HELP YOU? 597 00:30:02,937 --> 00:30:05,805 Deputy: LOOKING TO SPEAK TO SARAH MASON, IS SHE IN? 598 00:30:05,837 --> 00:30:07,172 Dube: UH, NO. 599 00:30:07,205 --> 00:30:10,269 I'M NOT EXPECTING HER BACK UNTIL THIS EVENING. 600 00:30:10,301 --> 00:30:12,517 WHAT DO YOU WANT TO TALK TO HER FOR? 601 00:30:12,549 --> 00:30:14,831 Deputy: HERE'S MY CARD. CAN YOU ASK HER 602 00:30:14,863 --> 00:30:16,102 TO CALL ME WHEN SHE GETS BACK? 603 00:30:16,135 --> 00:30:17,829 Dube: YEAH, SURE. 604 00:30:17,861 --> 00:30:19,231 Deputy: OKAY, THANK YOU. 605 00:30:19,263 --> 00:30:20,991 Dube: ALL RIGHT. TAKE CARE. 606 00:30:25,682 --> 00:30:28,420 Narrator: AS INVESTIGATORS WAIT FOR SARAH, 607 00:30:28,452 --> 00:30:30,766 NICHOLE'S COMPUTER IS ANALYZED TO SEE 608 00:30:30,799 --> 00:30:35,916 IF HER ONLINE ACTIVITY CAN HELP EXPLAIN WHAT HAPPENED. 609 00:30:35,948 --> 00:30:37,545 Macomber: IF YOU HAVE COMPUTER ISSUES 610 00:30:37,577 --> 00:30:39,662 IN PART OF YOUR INVESTIGATION, 611 00:30:39,694 --> 00:30:42,465 BRENT BOLEO AT COMPUTER CRIMES TASK FORCE, 612 00:30:42,498 --> 00:30:45,398 HE'S THE ONE YOU WANT TO TALK TO. 613 00:30:45,430 --> 00:30:49,895 DETECTIVE BOLEO CONTACTED FACEBOOK AND U.S. CELLULAR. 614 00:30:49,928 --> 00:30:52,827 AND THROUGH SUBPOENAS AND SEARCH WARRANTS 615 00:30:52,861 --> 00:30:56,250 WE'RE ABLE TO TRACK DOWN THE TEXT MESSAGES 616 00:30:56,282 --> 00:31:00,519 THAT HAD BEEN EXCHANGED BETWEEN NICHOLE AND BRYAN BUTTERFIELD. 617 00:31:00,552 --> 00:31:03,581 AND REALIZED THAT NICHOLE HAD NOT SENT ANY MESSAGES 618 00:31:03,615 --> 00:31:06,874 OR MADE ANY CALLS SINCE THE 12th. 619 00:31:13,879 --> 00:31:15,151 Narrator: IT'S BEEN THREE DAYS 620 00:31:15,184 --> 00:31:18,898 SINCE NICHOLE HAS USED HER CELL PHONE. 621 00:31:18,930 --> 00:31:20,626 FEARING FOUL PLAY, 622 00:31:20,658 --> 00:31:24,829 POLICE LAUNCH A GROUND SEARCH FOR THE 15 YEAR OLD. 623 00:31:24,862 --> 00:31:27,990 Kristine: OUR ROAD WAS COMPLETELY BLOCKED OFF. 624 00:31:28,023 --> 00:31:30,434 THE POLICE HAD CRIME SCENE TAPE 625 00:31:30,467 --> 00:31:33,856 ON THE ROAD THAT ADJOINS TO OURS. 626 00:31:33,888 --> 00:31:38,646 THEY HAD CAMERAS, THEY WERE TAKING PICTURES. 627 00:31:38,678 --> 00:31:42,166 Zainea: THERE WAS A WOOD LINE THAT RAN ALONG THE DRIVEWAY 628 00:31:42,198 --> 00:31:45,750 AND THEY FIND ARTICLES THAT SEEMED OUT OF PLACE. 629 00:31:48,260 --> 00:31:51,812 Kristine: I LOOK UP AND I SEE ONE OF NICHOLE'S SOCKS. 630 00:31:53,768 --> 00:31:57,122 AND HER SHOES. 631 00:31:57,157 --> 00:31:59,373 MY HUSBAND'S TRYING TO TELL ME, 632 00:31:59,405 --> 00:32:02,501 "WELL, WE JUST THREW A BUNCH OF CLOTHES OUT LAST WEEK, 633 00:32:02,533 --> 00:32:06,640 IT COULD'VE BEEN BIRDS TAKING IT AWAY." 634 00:32:06,672 --> 00:32:09,343 Narrator: THEN OFFICERS FIND SOMETHING HALF-HIDDEN 635 00:32:09,377 --> 00:32:10,418 IN THE UNDERGROWTH. 636 00:32:11,972 --> 00:32:13,145 Zainea: THERE WAS A SKI MASK 637 00:32:13,178 --> 00:32:16,925 THAT WAS FOUND IN THAT WOODED AREA. 638 00:32:16,958 --> 00:32:18,522 Narrator: UNLIKE THE OTHER ITEMS, 639 00:32:18,555 --> 00:32:21,586 THE SKI MASK DOESN'T BELONG TO NICHOLE. 640 00:32:21,619 --> 00:32:24,779 IN THE WARM MONTH OF MAY, THERE'S ONLY ONE REASON 641 00:32:24,812 --> 00:32:26,636 TO WEAR A MASK, 642 00:32:26,669 --> 00:32:29,863 TO HIDE HIS OR HER IDENTITY. 643 00:32:29,895 --> 00:32:32,959 THEY BAG IT FOR DNA ANALYSIS. 644 00:32:32,991 --> 00:32:37,261 DETECTIVES NOW FEAR NICHOLE'S BEEN ABDUCTED. 645 00:32:37,293 --> 00:32:38,661 Macomber: IF THERE'S ANY CHANCE THAT THEY'RE GOING 646 00:32:38,694 --> 00:32:40,780 TO FIND HER ALIVE, 647 00:32:40,812 --> 00:32:42,964 THEY HAVE TO FIND HER QUICKLY. 648 00:32:45,017 --> 00:32:46,613 Narrator: LAW ENFORCEMENT THROWS EVERYTHING 649 00:32:46,646 --> 00:32:49,383 THEY'VE GOT INTO A SEARCH AND RESCUE OPERATION. 650 00:32:52,739 --> 00:32:56,290 Zainea: THERE WERE MULTIPLE AGENCIES INVOLVED. 651 00:32:56,324 --> 00:32:59,844 DOGS FROM THE MAINE STATE POLICE. 652 00:32:59,876 --> 00:33:04,764 AND A GROUP OF INDIVIDUALS WHO WILL ASSIST WITH THE SEARCH. 653 00:33:04,797 --> 00:33:08,381 THEY DO IT GRID BY GRID. 654 00:33:08,413 --> 00:33:09,587 Kristine: THEY HAD PLANES 655 00:33:09,619 --> 00:33:13,237 UP TRYING TO LOOK THROUGH THE WOODS. 656 00:33:13,270 --> 00:33:17,278 Tyler-Ann: EVERYONE IN THE STATE WAS TOGETHER LOOKING FOR HER. 657 00:33:17,310 --> 00:33:18,548 Narrator: THOUSANDS OF VOLUNTEERS 658 00:33:18,581 --> 00:33:20,373 SCOUR THE VAST WOODLAND AREA 659 00:33:20,406 --> 00:33:23,665 FOR ANY SIGN OF NICHOLE... 660 00:33:23,698 --> 00:33:25,555 Haleigh: WE WERE JUST WAITING, WAITING 661 00:33:25,588 --> 00:33:28,000 FOR SOMEONE TO FIND SOMETHING TO TELL US, 662 00:33:28,031 --> 00:33:31,128 LIKE, SHE'S OKAY. 663 00:33:31,159 --> 00:33:37,972 Narrator: UNTIL FINALLY THEY MAKE A DISCOVERY. 664 00:33:38,004 --> 00:33:40,709 Jason: THEY WENT UP SO FAR AS ABOUT 10 MILES... 665 00:33:44,098 --> 00:33:47,389 AND FOUND NICHOLE'S SWEATSHIRT. 666 00:33:47,422 --> 00:33:49,996 TATTERED, RIPPED DOWN THE CENTER, 667 00:33:50,027 --> 00:33:52,702 AND WE KNEW THAT THERE WAS QUITE A STRUGGLE. 668 00:33:54,656 --> 00:33:57,328 I WAS -- 669 00:33:57,361 --> 00:33:59,316 I WAS SCARED OUT OF MY MIND. 670 00:34:02,314 --> 00:34:06,485 Narrator: AS HOPES OF FINDING NICHOLE ALIVE START TO FADE, 671 00:34:06,518 --> 00:34:08,864 SARAH MASON COMES FORWARD. 672 00:34:08,896 --> 00:34:10,232 Deputy: THANKS FOR COMING IN, SARAH. 673 00:34:10,265 --> 00:34:12,286 I JUST HAVE A FEW QUESTIONS FOR YOU, OKAY? 674 00:34:12,319 --> 00:34:16,294 Narrator: WORD HAS SPREAD ABOUT HOW MUCH SARAH DISLIKES NICHOLE. 675 00:34:16,327 --> 00:34:18,347 Mason: SHE'S DISGUSTING. 676 00:34:18,380 --> 00:34:21,150 Narrator: SHE HAS BEEN HEARD MAKING THREATS AGAINST HER. 677 00:34:21,183 --> 00:34:24,017 Mason: IF I SEE HER AROUND, SHE'S DEAD. 678 00:34:24,050 --> 00:34:26,070 Narrator: BUT DID SHE EVER ACT ON THEM? 679 00:34:26,103 --> 00:34:28,352 Deputy: WHERE WERE YOU ON SUNDAY NIGHT? 680 00:34:28,384 --> 00:34:31,088 Mason: I WAS AT MY MOM'S HOUSE, YOU CAN CHECK. 681 00:34:31,121 --> 00:34:33,370 Deputy: DO YOU OFTEN USE THE COMPUTER AT KYLE'S? 682 00:34:33,403 --> 00:34:35,195 Mason: YEAH, SOMETIMES. 683 00:34:35,227 --> 00:34:36,954 Narrator: SARAH IS ICE COLD, 684 00:34:36,988 --> 00:34:39,302 BUT CAN SHE KEEP HER COMPOSURE? 685 00:34:41,777 --> 00:34:44,614 Deputy: KYLE LIKES NICHOLE, DOESN'T HE? 686 00:34:44,646 --> 00:34:46,372 I MEAN, IT'S OBVIOUS BY THE WAY HE BEHAVES, 687 00:34:46,405 --> 00:34:47,709 THAT THEY'RE AN ITEM. 688 00:34:47,741 --> 00:34:51,424 Mason: IT'S NOT TRUE, IF IT WAS, I WOULD KILL HIM. 689 00:34:51,456 --> 00:34:56,606 Narrator: THE OUTBURST EXPOSES SARAH'S SINISTER SIDE. 690 00:34:56,638 --> 00:34:58,495 BUT INVESTIGATORS NEED HARD EVIDENCE 691 00:34:58,527 --> 00:35:01,526 BEFORE THEY CAN MAKE THEIR MOVE. 692 00:35:01,558 --> 00:35:03,091 AS THEY CHECK OUT HER ALIBI, 693 00:35:03,123 --> 00:35:07,261 ANALYSIS OF THE FAKE BRYAN PROFILE HITS THEIR DESK. 694 00:35:07,294 --> 00:35:11,693 Macomber: THEY WERE ABLE TO TRACE THE IP ADDRESS. 695 00:35:11,725 --> 00:35:13,192 Deputy: IS THIS THE ADDRESS THE BRYAN BUTTERFIELD ACCOUNT 696 00:35:13,225 --> 00:35:15,962 TRACES BACK TO? 697 00:35:15,994 --> 00:35:18,406 GOOD WORK MAN, GOOD WORK. 698 00:35:18,439 --> 00:35:21,046 Narrator: THE ACCOUNT ORIGINATES FROM KYLE DUBE'S HOUSE, 699 00:35:21,078 --> 00:35:23,685 WHERE SARAH HAS ACCESS TO THE COMPUTER. 700 00:35:25,804 --> 00:35:31,246 DETECTIVES ARE CLOSING IN UNTIL NEWS OF HER ALIBI COMES THROUGH. 701 00:35:31,279 --> 00:35:33,657 Macomber: SARAH WAS ABLE TO BE RULED OUT 702 00:35:33,690 --> 00:35:37,894 BECAUSE SHE WAS WITH HER MOTHER ON MOTHER'S DAY. 703 00:35:37,926 --> 00:35:39,816 Narrator: BUT THE RESULTS ARE CLEAR -- 704 00:35:39,848 --> 00:35:43,955 THE BRYAN BUTTERFIELD ACCOUNT WAS CREATED AT KYLE'S HOUSE. 705 00:35:43,987 --> 00:35:46,072 Macomber: AND AT THAT POINT THE INVESTIGATION TOOK 706 00:35:46,106 --> 00:35:47,703 A COMPLETELY DIFFERENT TURN. 707 00:35:58,000 --> 00:35:59,727 Narrator: ALMOST A WEEK AFTER NICHOLE CABLE 708 00:35:59,760 --> 00:36:03,443 DISAPPEARED FROM HER HOME IN GLENBURN, MAINE. 709 00:36:03,475 --> 00:36:05,300 INVESTIGATORS DISCOVER THE CREATOR 710 00:36:05,332 --> 00:36:06,930 OF THE FAKE FACEBOOK PROFILE 711 00:36:06,962 --> 00:36:11,393 SHE WAS COMMUNICATING WITH JUST BEFORE SHE VANISHED. 712 00:36:11,426 --> 00:36:14,783 Macomber: DETECTIVE BOLEO TRACED THE BRYAN BUTTERFIELD ACCOUNT 713 00:36:14,816 --> 00:36:18,628 TO KYLE DUBE. 714 00:36:18,660 --> 00:36:21,300 Narrator: DETECTIVES HAVE PROOF THAT IT WAS KYLE'S SMART PHONE 715 00:36:21,333 --> 00:36:24,689 THAT COMMUNICATED WITH NICHOLE ON THE NIGHT SHE DISAPPEARED. 716 00:36:27,524 --> 00:36:31,369 EVIDENCE SUGGESTS THAT KYLE HAS ABDUCTED NICHOLE, 717 00:36:31,403 --> 00:36:33,683 BUT DETECTIVES NEED A CONFESSION. 718 00:36:36,356 --> 00:36:39,941 THE FOLLOWING MORNING, HE IS BROUGHT IN FOR QUESTIONING. 719 00:36:44,438 --> 00:36:46,914 DETECTIVES START BY SCRUTINIZING HIS MOVEMENTS 720 00:36:46,947 --> 00:36:48,805 THE NIGHT NICHOLE WENT MISSING. 721 00:36:55,289 --> 00:36:56,788 Macomber: KYLE SAID THAT HE PICKED UP 722 00:36:56,821 --> 00:36:58,743 HIS GIRLFRIEND SARAH AT HER HOUSE 723 00:36:58,776 --> 00:37:02,622 APPROXIMATELY 11:00 ON THE NIGHT OF THE 12th. 724 00:37:08,716 --> 00:37:12,268 BUT CELL PHONE RECORDS INDICATED THAT HE HAD LEFT WORK 725 00:37:12,300 --> 00:37:14,580 SOMETIME BETWEEN 8:00 AND 9:00 726 00:37:14,614 --> 00:37:19,990 AND WERE IN THE OLD TOWN AREA BETWEEN 9:00 AND 11:00. 727 00:37:20,023 --> 00:37:23,282 WHAT KYLE WAS TELLING THEM WASN'T TRUE. 728 00:37:41,018 --> 00:37:44,114 Narrator: BUT KYLE IS STEADFAST IN HIS DENIAL. 729 00:37:47,666 --> 00:37:51,152 ONLY THEN DO THE DETECTIVES PLAY THEIR TRUMP CARD. 730 00:37:51,186 --> 00:37:52,717 Macomber: AT THE VERY END OF THE INTERVIEW 731 00:37:52,749 --> 00:37:54,932 THEY SHOWED HIM THE MASK. 732 00:38:01,873 --> 00:38:03,731 Narrator: THE DNA ON THE MASK 733 00:38:03,764 --> 00:38:07,512 MATCHES A SAMPLE POLICE ALREADY HAVE ON RECORD FOR KYLE. 734 00:38:09,434 --> 00:38:11,390 NOW DETECTIVES DESPERATELY NEED HIM 735 00:38:11,422 --> 00:38:15,007 TO LEAD THEM TO NICHOLE, DEAD OR ALIVE. 736 00:38:23,121 --> 00:38:25,727 THEY GET NOTHING FROM KYLE. 737 00:38:25,760 --> 00:38:28,237 BUT AFTER HE IS RELEASED TO HIS FAMILY, 738 00:38:28,269 --> 00:38:30,552 HE MAKES A SHOCKING ADMISSION. 739 00:38:36,797 --> 00:38:38,493 Macomber: KYLE ADMITTED TO SARAH 740 00:38:38,525 --> 00:38:42,207 THAT HE HAD KILLED NICHOLE. 741 00:38:42,239 --> 00:38:44,358 AND HE TOLD HER WHAT HE HAD DONE 742 00:38:44,391 --> 00:38:48,627 WITH NICHOLE'S BODY AND WHERE THE BODY WAS LOCATED. 743 00:38:48,660 --> 00:38:50,452 Narrator: STUNNED BY THE INFORMATION, 744 00:38:50,485 --> 00:38:52,342 SARAH GIVES KYLE UP, 745 00:38:52,374 --> 00:38:57,165 AND A SEARCH TEAM IS IMMEDIATELY DISPATCHED TO FIND NICHOLE. 746 00:38:57,863 --> 00:38:59,754 Macomber: GAME WARDENS AND DETECTIVES 747 00:38:59,786 --> 00:39:02,099 WENT TO THAT LOCATION. 748 00:39:02,132 --> 00:39:05,228 THEY FOUND AN UNUSUAL-LOOKING MOUND 749 00:39:05,261 --> 00:39:09,302 COVERED WITH LEAVES, TWIGS AND BRANCHES. 750 00:39:09,334 --> 00:39:12,040 AND THAT'S WHEN THEY KNEW THAT THEY HAD FOUND NICHOLE CABLE 751 00:39:12,072 --> 00:39:13,799 AT LAST. 752 00:39:13,831 --> 00:39:16,112 Narrator: NICHOLE'S BODY IS UNCOVERED 753 00:39:16,145 --> 00:39:19,046 10 MILES FROM HER HOME, BY THE RIVER IN OLD TOWN, 754 00:39:19,078 --> 00:39:21,099 8 DAYS AFTER SHE WENT MISSING. 755 00:39:23,119 --> 00:39:26,507 NOW ALL THAT'S LEFT IS FOR INVESTIGATORS TO BREAK THE NEWS 756 00:39:26,541 --> 00:39:28,138 TO HER FAMILY. 757 00:39:28,970 --> 00:39:33,467 Kristine: JASON HAD GOT A PHONE CALL FROM THE POLICE... 758 00:39:33,500 --> 00:39:35,488 Jason: THE POLICE ARE OUTSIDE, OKAY? 759 00:39:37,606 --> 00:39:41,484 Kristine: HE WENT OUT AND TALKED WITH THEM. 760 00:39:43,505 --> 00:39:45,167 THEY HAD COME UP 761 00:39:45,199 --> 00:39:47,415 AND JASON HAD PUT HIS ARM AROUND ME. 762 00:39:47,447 --> 00:39:49,793 AND I LOOKED AT THEM. 763 00:39:49,826 --> 00:39:53,085 AND I SAID, "DID YOU FIND HER?" 764 00:39:55,529 --> 00:39:57,224 AND THEY JUST NODDED. 765 00:39:57,257 --> 00:40:00,939 BUT THE WAY -- 766 00:40:00,971 --> 00:40:06,087 THE WAY THEY NODDED, I KNEW. 767 00:40:06,120 --> 00:40:08,694 HE DIDN'T HAVE TO SAY ANYTHING. 768 00:40:17,548 --> 00:40:18,818 Narrator: KYLE DUBE IS CHARGED 769 00:40:18,851 --> 00:40:20,807 WITH KIDNAPPING AND FIRST-DEGREE MURDER, 770 00:40:20,839 --> 00:40:25,466 TO WHICH HE PLEADS NOT GUILTY. 771 00:40:25,499 --> 00:40:29,215 DURING HIS TRIAL, THE FULL STORY IS REVEALED. 772 00:40:31,137 --> 00:40:33,254 AFTER NICHOLE FOUND OUT ABOUT SARAH, 773 00:40:33,287 --> 00:40:37,687 SHE ENDED ANY HOPE OF A RELATIONSHIP WITH KYLE. 774 00:40:37,719 --> 00:40:39,871 BUT KYLE COULDN'T LET NICHOLE GO 775 00:40:39,903 --> 00:40:42,217 AND BECAME OBSESSED WITH HAVING HER. 776 00:40:44,726 --> 00:40:48,930 POSING AS BRYAN, HE LURES HER OUT OF HER HOME. 777 00:40:49,963 --> 00:40:52,666 Macomber: HE WAS GOING TO HIDE HER 778 00:40:52,699 --> 00:40:56,610 AND THEN JOIN THE SEARCH PARTY AS HIMSELF. 779 00:40:56,643 --> 00:40:58,827 HE WAS GOING TO BE THE ONE 780 00:40:58,859 --> 00:41:01,889 TO FIND HER SO HE COULD BE THE HERO. 781 00:41:01,922 --> 00:41:04,138 Narrator: BUT HIS PLAN GOES WRONG. 782 00:41:04,170 --> 00:41:05,734 Nichole: STOP! STOP! 783 00:41:05,767 --> 00:41:07,038 Macomber: HE DIDN'T ANTICIPATE 784 00:41:07,072 --> 00:41:08,960 THAT NICHOLE WAS GOING TO FIGHT FOR HER LIFE 785 00:41:08,994 --> 00:41:11,536 AS MUCH AS SHE DID. 786 00:41:11,568 --> 00:41:14,436 ONCE SHE RIPPED THE MASK OFF AND SHE KNEW IT WAS HIM, 787 00:41:14,469 --> 00:41:16,978 HE HAD TO ELIMINATE THE THREAT. 788 00:41:21,507 --> 00:41:23,365 AND HE ENDED UP KILLING HER 789 00:41:23,398 --> 00:41:26,429 WHEN HE PROBABLY JUST HAD THE INTENT TO RAPE HER. 790 00:41:30,288 --> 00:41:33,547 Narrator: KYLE DUBE IS FOUND GUILTY OF BOTH CHARGES 791 00:41:33,579 --> 00:41:36,871 AND IS SENTENCED TO 60 YEARS IN PRISON. 792 00:41:36,903 --> 00:41:40,064 IT'S JUSTICE FOR NICHOLE'S FAMILY. 793 00:41:40,096 --> 00:41:42,378 BUT NOTHING WILL BRING HER BACK. 794 00:41:45,473 --> 00:41:49,384 Kristine: NICHOLE'S BEDROOM IS A TYPICAL GIRL'S ROOM. 795 00:41:49,417 --> 00:41:51,762 HER LITTLE SISTERS WANT TO GO IN THERE. 796 00:41:51,795 --> 00:41:56,293 I THINK IT MAKES THEM FEEL CLOSE TO HER. 797 00:41:56,326 --> 00:41:59,160 BUT I COULDN'T HAVE THEM TOUCHING ALL HER STUFF 798 00:41:59,193 --> 00:42:01,245 AND RUINING HER THINGS. 799 00:42:01,279 --> 00:42:05,874 SO I ASKED MY HUSBAND TO SCREW HER BEDROOM DOOR SHUT. 800 00:42:11,649 --> 00:42:15,756 Haleigh: I BASICALLY LOST EVERYTHING THE DAY SHE DIED. 801 00:42:15,788 --> 00:42:20,089 I LAID IN BED IN CRIED. I DIDN'T GO TO SCHOOL. 802 00:42:20,122 --> 00:42:24,066 I DIDN'T DO ANYTHING BECAUSE IT'S JUST TOO HARD. 803 00:42:26,673 --> 00:42:28,431 Kristine: SHE WAS ON THE VERGE OF A WONDERFUL LIFE 804 00:42:28,464 --> 00:42:30,681 AND SHE HAD IT SNATCHED AWAY.