1 00:00:21,526 --> 00:00:23,695 ♪ Beautiful dreamer ♪ 2 00:00:25,030 --> 00:00:27,032 ♪ Wake unto me ♪ 3 00:00:28,658 --> 00:00:30,660 ♪ Starlight and dewdrops ♪ 4 00:00:31,953 --> 00:00:33,955 ♪ Are waiting for thee ♪ 5 00:00:35,665 --> 00:00:38,168 ♪ Sounds of the rude world ♪ 6 00:00:39,627 --> 00:00:41,129 ♪ Heard in the day ♪ 7 00:00:41,212 --> 00:00:42,047 Help! 8 00:00:42,130 --> 00:00:42,964 [whimpers] 9 00:00:43,548 --> 00:00:45,383 ♪ Lulled by the moonlight ♪ 10 00:00:46,926 --> 00:00:49,220 ♪ Have all passed away ♪ 11 00:00:51,097 --> 00:00:53,600 ♪ Beautiful dreamer ♪ 12 00:00:54,601 --> 00:00:56,686 ♪ Queen of my song ♪ 13 00:00:58,063 --> 00:01:00,482 ♪ List' while I woo thee ♪ 14 00:01:01,232 --> 00:01:03,568 ♪ With soft melody ♪ 15 00:01:05,403 --> 00:01:07,405 ♪ Gone are the cares ♪ 16 00:01:08,531 --> 00:01:11,201 ♪ Of life's busy throng ♪ 17 00:01:12,577 --> 00:01:15,080 ♪ Beautiful dreamer ♪ 18 00:01:15,955 --> 00:01:18,333 ♪ Awake unto me ♪ 19 00:01:23,505 --> 00:01:27,383 [construction workers shouting indistinctly] 20 00:01:28,927 --> 00:01:31,596 [machinery running] 21 00:01:31,971 --> 00:01:33,223 [buzzer sounds] 22 00:01:38,269 --> 00:01:39,104 [door closes] 23 00:01:44,192 --> 00:01:45,860 Ah, are you shitting me? 24 00:01:46,736 --> 00:01:48,822 I told you I need more hours. 25 00:01:49,114 --> 00:01:51,741 You only got me on the schedule three days this week. 26 00:01:51,825 --> 00:01:53,827 Joelle has five. What the hell, man? 27 00:01:53,910 --> 00:01:55,995 [man] Joelle smiles when she comes in the door. 28 00:01:56,079 --> 00:01:58,832 Yeah, bet that's not all she does. 29 00:01:59,582 --> 00:02:00,667 [man, quietly] Jeez. 30 00:02:00,750 --> 00:02:01,709 [door opens] 31 00:02:29,237 --> 00:02:33,032 [phone ringing] 32 00:02:33,575 --> 00:02:34,409 Hello? 33 00:02:34,492 --> 00:02:36,494 [woman on phone] Mrs. Gilbert, pick up your daughter. 34 00:02:36,578 --> 00:02:39,038 -She's suspended till Thursday. -What do you mean suspended? 35 00:02:39,122 --> 00:02:41,124 There was an incident in the bathroom. 36 00:02:41,207 --> 00:02:43,668 -Did she hurt anybody? -We'll explain when you come here. 37 00:02:54,262 --> 00:02:55,722 -You take your medicine? -[girl] No. 38 00:02:55,805 --> 00:02:58,183 I don't like that stuff. It makes me sleepy. 39 00:02:59,142 --> 00:03:01,269 It also keeps you from lighting paper towels on fire 40 00:03:01,352 --> 00:03:02,312 in the girls' bathroom. 41 00:03:02,395 --> 00:03:04,022 What the hell were you thinking? 42 00:03:04,105 --> 00:03:05,732 [bell dinging] 43 00:03:07,066 --> 00:03:08,985 We're gonna talk about this later. 44 00:03:09,068 --> 00:03:10,737 There are gonna be consequences. 45 00:03:13,573 --> 00:03:14,616 Not bad. 46 00:03:33,843 --> 00:03:36,054 [man 1 on radio] ...player gets a top salary, 47 00:03:36,137 --> 00:03:38,306 the next player negotiates for even higher. 48 00:03:38,389 --> 00:03:39,849 [man 2] They have to go one direction or another. 49 00:03:39,933 --> 00:03:41,351 You can't be half-pregnant. 50 00:03:41,434 --> 00:03:44,687 You've got a salary cap that you enforce, or you can just go wild. 51 00:03:44,771 --> 00:03:46,773 [man 1] That's true. Well... 52 00:03:46,856 --> 00:03:50,109 [phone line rings] 53 00:03:51,361 --> 00:03:53,071 -[girl on phone] Hey, Mom. -Hey, Shannan. 54 00:03:53,154 --> 00:03:55,073 -Hey. -Oh, glad I finally got you. 55 00:03:55,156 --> 00:03:56,908 -[Shannan] Was thinking about you. -[chuckles] 56 00:03:56,991 --> 00:03:59,619 -How's it going? -You know, just another day in paradise. 57 00:03:59,702 --> 00:04:01,913 -What do you mean? -My boss is a total asshole. 58 00:04:01,996 --> 00:04:04,332 -Gave one of my shifts to the new girl. -What a dick. 59 00:04:04,415 --> 00:04:07,126 -[Mari chuckles] Yeah. -I can find some cash if you need it. 60 00:04:07,210 --> 00:04:09,629 [Mari] Well, that's really nice of you to offer. 61 00:04:09,712 --> 00:04:11,130 -I'll pay you back. -I know you will. 62 00:04:11,214 --> 00:04:14,384 You know, just as soon as I get on the other side of this shit. [laughs] 63 00:04:14,467 --> 00:04:16,094 -Okay. -It's been a couple weeks. 64 00:04:16,177 --> 00:04:17,887 -Can I come up tomorrow night? -Yes! 65 00:04:17,971 --> 00:04:20,348 -Yes, you can come home tomorrow! -Awesome. 66 00:04:20,431 --> 00:04:23,685 -[Mari] Oh, the girls will be so excited. -Me, too. Can't wait. 67 00:04:23,768 --> 00:04:25,228 We'll see you tomorrow, baby. 68 00:04:25,311 --> 00:04:26,521 -Bye. -Great. 69 00:04:27,230 --> 00:04:28,064 [phone snaps shut] 70 00:04:35,905 --> 00:04:39,993 [church bell tolling in the distance] 71 00:04:44,539 --> 00:04:46,541 [objects crashing and clattering] 72 00:04:55,550 --> 00:04:58,636 ♪ Beautiful dreamer ♪ 73 00:04:58,720 --> 00:05:01,389 ♪ Wake unto me ♪ 74 00:05:01,806 --> 00:05:04,642 ♪ Starlight and dewdrops ♪ 75 00:05:04,726 --> 00:05:06,936 ♪ Are waiting for thee ♪ 76 00:05:07,020 --> 00:05:07,854 [door closes] 77 00:05:07,937 --> 00:05:09,355 ♪ Sounds of the rude world... ♪ 78 00:05:09,439 --> 00:05:10,565 -Hey. -Hey, Sherre. 79 00:05:10,648 --> 00:05:12,108 Shannan's coming for dinner. 80 00:05:12,191 --> 00:05:13,609 [singing continues] 81 00:05:13,693 --> 00:05:14,861 If you say so. 82 00:05:16,362 --> 00:05:17,280 [sighs] 83 00:05:20,158 --> 00:05:22,535 ♪ Beautiful dreamer ♪ 84 00:05:22,618 --> 00:05:25,079 ♪ Queen of my song ♪ 85 00:05:25,538 --> 00:05:28,124 ♪ List' while I woo thee... ♪ 86 00:05:28,916 --> 00:05:30,418 [Sherre] Mom, did you ask her to come 87 00:05:30,501 --> 00:05:32,462 -or was it her idea? -[Mari] No one has to ask. 88 00:05:32,545 --> 00:05:34,339 This is still her home. 89 00:05:34,422 --> 00:05:37,050 I'm still her mom and we're still her family. 90 00:05:37,717 --> 00:05:41,554 I'm thinking maybe we'll watch that talent show video after dinner. 91 00:05:42,597 --> 00:05:44,766 I think she'd get a kick out of that. 92 00:05:45,308 --> 00:05:46,184 What? 93 00:05:47,143 --> 00:05:48,102 Nothing. 94 00:05:49,312 --> 00:05:51,356 [Mari] Why can't you be happy for once? 95 00:05:58,529 --> 00:06:02,700 [soft harp music playing] 96 00:06:10,750 --> 00:06:12,251 Maybe she had to work. 97 00:06:16,047 --> 00:06:17,715 She worked last night. 98 00:06:22,845 --> 00:06:23,971 [Mari sighs] 99 00:06:55,128 --> 00:06:55,962 [phone beeps] 100 00:06:59,590 --> 00:07:01,968 [voicemail] This is Shannan. I can't answer my phone now 101 00:07:02,051 --> 00:07:04,262 because I'm doing something way more fun. 102 00:07:04,804 --> 00:07:05,638 [voicemail beeps] 103 00:07:06,097 --> 00:07:06,931 [Sherre] Hey, Diva. 104 00:07:07,849 --> 00:07:11,227 Look, I know you didn't mean it, but I think Mom's really hurt. 105 00:07:11,310 --> 00:07:13,020 Even though she'll never admit it. 106 00:07:13,604 --> 00:07:14,689 [sighs] 107 00:07:15,731 --> 00:07:18,443 You should call her and apologize. 108 00:07:20,736 --> 00:07:22,738 Also, your boyfriend called. 109 00:07:25,032 --> 00:07:26,159 Anyway... 110 00:07:28,161 --> 00:07:29,620 I miss you, Diva. 111 00:07:43,926 --> 00:07:47,722 [indistinct chatter] 112 00:08:04,906 --> 00:08:09,827 -[food sizzles] -[video game beeps] 113 00:08:10,411 --> 00:08:12,413 -[Sherre] Sorry about last night. -[Mari] For what? 114 00:08:13,498 --> 00:08:16,584 Well, I know you were looking forward to Shannan coming home. 115 00:08:16,667 --> 00:08:17,502 It's fine. 116 00:08:17,585 --> 00:08:20,254 -Gonna get your butt in the shower today? -Leave me alone. 117 00:08:20,338 --> 00:08:22,965 -Are you sure you're okay? -For Christ's sakes! 118 00:08:23,049 --> 00:08:25,718 The world's not gonna end 'cause Shannan had a schedule conflict. 119 00:08:27,136 --> 00:08:30,223 [phone rings] 120 00:08:31,182 --> 00:08:32,016 Hello. 121 00:08:33,518 --> 00:08:34,393 Who? 122 00:08:39,815 --> 00:08:40,650 Goddamn it. 123 00:08:42,693 --> 00:08:43,694 Who is this? 124 00:08:43,778 --> 00:08:45,905 [turns on faucet] 125 00:08:45,988 --> 00:08:47,990 Uh, how did you get this number? 126 00:08:48,074 --> 00:08:49,242 [Mari turns off faucet] 127 00:08:49,325 --> 00:08:53,287 Well, I don't know why you're asking me. She hasn't lived here since she's 12. 128 00:08:53,371 --> 00:08:55,873 So, if she owes you money, you're barking up the wrong flagpole. 129 00:08:55,957 --> 00:08:56,791 [hangs up the phone] 130 00:08:57,291 --> 00:08:59,252 -[Sherre] Who is it? -Some doctor. 131 00:08:59,335 --> 00:09:01,254 What time is it? Oh, shit, I'm late. 132 00:09:01,337 --> 00:09:02,964 He wanted to know if I'd seen Shannan. 133 00:09:04,757 --> 00:09:08,594 Shannan's boyfriend called me last night, asking if I knew where she was. 134 00:09:09,011 --> 00:09:10,638 I thought they were just in a fight. 135 00:09:10,721 --> 00:09:14,141 I've tried her five times, and each time it's gone straight to voicemail. 136 00:09:15,393 --> 00:09:16,394 Mom. 137 00:09:18,563 --> 00:09:20,106 He's never called me before. 138 00:09:23,985 --> 00:09:26,529 I'm sure it's fine. Give it a day. [sighs] 139 00:09:27,947 --> 00:09:28,990 She'll call. 140 00:09:30,866 --> 00:09:32,243 What happened to your hand? 141 00:09:34,328 --> 00:09:36,581 -What happened to your hand? -[Mari] I burned it. 142 00:09:44,130 --> 00:09:47,133 [excavator hums] 143 00:09:47,216 --> 00:09:48,301 [engine stops] 144 00:10:04,442 --> 00:10:08,070 [indistinct chatter] 145 00:10:31,177 --> 00:10:34,722 It's been 48 hours. When will you start looking? 146 00:10:36,265 --> 00:10:37,266 For my daughter. 147 00:10:38,601 --> 00:10:40,561 Hello? Hello? 148 00:10:41,103 --> 00:10:43,606 -They hung up. -They're not even looking for her? 149 00:10:44,190 --> 00:10:45,900 They can't find her in the system. 150 00:10:45,983 --> 00:10:47,276 [Sherre] What about that doctor? 151 00:10:47,360 --> 00:10:50,529 -His number should be on the caller ID. -It came up "unknown." 152 00:10:51,822 --> 00:10:53,449 He said he was in Long Island. 153 00:10:53,532 --> 00:10:55,534 Maybe we should start calling the hospitals. 154 00:10:55,618 --> 00:10:57,787 There are hundreds of hospitals on Long Island. 155 00:10:58,704 --> 00:11:00,331 Did something happen to Shannan? 156 00:11:31,362 --> 00:11:32,446 [engine stops] 157 00:11:45,668 --> 00:11:47,461 A doctor on Long Island called me. 158 00:11:47,545 --> 00:11:49,130 [man] I'll put her in the system, ma'am. 159 00:11:54,802 --> 00:11:55,803 [Mari] Come on, girls. 160 00:11:57,722 --> 00:11:59,932 I'm sorry, but unless she's physically here with you, 161 00:12:00,015 --> 00:12:01,434 I can't give you any information. 162 00:12:01,517 --> 00:12:04,645 [Mari] Nobody knows where she is, and the police haven't done a thing. 163 00:12:04,729 --> 00:12:08,190 Now, one way or another, I am leaving with those phone records. 164 00:12:08,274 --> 00:12:11,152 If you're you're not going to help me, go get me someone who will. 165 00:12:15,239 --> 00:12:17,116 -She has five. -[Mari] Five what? 166 00:12:18,284 --> 00:12:19,326 Five cellphones. 167 00:12:20,828 --> 00:12:22,913 Mom, why would Shannan need five phones? 168 00:12:23,497 --> 00:12:25,458 Do you know where this boyfriend lives? 169 00:12:26,500 --> 00:12:29,378 [rap music playing softly] 170 00:12:30,045 --> 00:12:32,131 [Mari] Okay, so when did you last see her? 171 00:12:32,214 --> 00:12:33,090 [exhales] 172 00:12:33,883 --> 00:12:36,719 So, she went to work in Long Island and never came back. 173 00:12:37,303 --> 00:12:39,472 Wanna know more? Ask her driver. 174 00:12:39,555 --> 00:12:41,891 Okay? He was the one that was supposed to bring her back. 175 00:12:41,974 --> 00:12:43,893 What was Shannan doing in Long Island? 176 00:12:43,976 --> 00:12:45,853 [boy] Selling Girl Scout cookies. What you think? 177 00:12:46,395 --> 00:12:48,981 [Mari] Why don't you save time and tell us what you did to her? 178 00:12:49,565 --> 00:12:50,858 I would never hurt her. 179 00:12:50,941 --> 00:12:52,693 Then why'd you hit her so hard she had to have 180 00:12:52,777 --> 00:12:54,570 a titanium plate grafted into her jaw? 181 00:12:55,362 --> 00:12:57,490 [boy] You don't know shit about me, little girl. 182 00:12:57,573 --> 00:13:00,367 And you sure as shit don't know about Shannan. 183 00:13:00,868 --> 00:13:02,995 You take the money and the gifts that she buys you, 184 00:13:03,078 --> 00:13:05,206 and you don't think to ask where it all comes from? 185 00:13:05,790 --> 00:13:09,043 And when she comes home, who do you think she's coming home to? 186 00:13:09,126 --> 00:13:10,169 Hmm? 187 00:13:10,252 --> 00:13:11,629 I was always there for her. 188 00:13:12,213 --> 00:13:13,047 Were you? 189 00:13:14,840 --> 00:13:16,467 Where can I find this driver? 190 00:13:28,604 --> 00:13:29,939 You two wait here. 191 00:13:30,022 --> 00:13:32,191 Mom, I'm not letting you go in there alone. 192 00:13:34,193 --> 00:13:36,237 Lock the doors. We'll only be a minute. 193 00:13:36,320 --> 00:13:37,738 I have my phone. 194 00:13:39,990 --> 00:13:40,991 [doors lock] 195 00:13:45,955 --> 00:13:49,708 -[indistinct chatter] -[muffled music playing] 196 00:13:54,547 --> 00:13:57,049 [hip-hop music playing] 197 00:14:01,929 --> 00:14:03,013 [man laughs] 198 00:14:10,396 --> 00:14:13,357 I'm looking for Shannan Gilbert. I'm her mother. 199 00:14:13,816 --> 00:14:15,818 You're Michael Pak, right? Her driver. 200 00:14:22,324 --> 00:14:23,868 [Pak] You need to relax, lady. 201 00:14:24,743 --> 00:14:25,578 Where is she? 202 00:14:26,579 --> 00:14:27,997 We went out to Oak Beach. 203 00:14:28,080 --> 00:14:31,750 She went in to see a guy. Next thing, she's freaking out, okay? 204 00:14:31,834 --> 00:14:33,002 What happened? 205 00:14:33,085 --> 00:14:34,336 [Pak] I'm just a driver. 206 00:14:34,420 --> 00:14:35,713 I don't go in. 207 00:14:35,796 --> 00:14:38,549 I wait in my car and then I drive her home. That's all I do. 208 00:14:38,632 --> 00:14:40,259 -That's all you do? -[Pak] Yeah. 209 00:14:40,342 --> 00:14:42,303 Yeah, well, you didn't take her home. 210 00:14:42,887 --> 00:14:44,889 Your daughter was hysterical that night. 211 00:14:44,972 --> 00:14:46,223 She ran down the road, 212 00:14:46,307 --> 00:14:48,475 banging on the door of any house with a light on. 213 00:14:49,059 --> 00:14:51,896 She wasn't making any sense, she was shouting all kinds of gibberish. 214 00:14:51,979 --> 00:14:52,980 I tried to help her. 215 00:14:53,856 --> 00:14:56,108 But she wouldn't let me, so I said fuck it. 216 00:14:56,692 --> 00:14:57,860 Oh, fuck. 217 00:14:58,319 --> 00:14:59,403 Oak Beach? 218 00:14:59,486 --> 00:15:01,906 Way down Ocean Parkway, past Jones Beach. 219 00:15:01,989 --> 00:15:04,158 It's a gated community. Miles from anything. 220 00:15:16,170 --> 00:15:17,922 This is the last contact we had. 221 00:15:21,383 --> 00:15:24,595 If you live in Ellenville and your daughter lives in Jersey City, 222 00:15:25,888 --> 00:15:28,057 what the hell are you guys doing here in Suffolk County, hmm? 223 00:15:28,140 --> 00:15:31,393 Well, her phone records are full of calls from a 631 area code. 224 00:15:31,477 --> 00:15:33,270 Have you filed a Missing Persons report? 225 00:15:33,354 --> 00:15:35,648 Just phoned Jersey City, they don't have a record of it. 226 00:15:35,731 --> 00:15:38,984 -Mom, I don't feel so good. -Just a second. 227 00:15:39,068 --> 00:15:40,903 [detective] Just because she didn't come home, 228 00:15:41,487 --> 00:15:43,989 it doesn't mean it's a five-alarm fire now. 229 00:15:44,073 --> 00:15:45,199 Right? 230 00:15:45,282 --> 00:15:47,993 Okay. Then why was her last contact with anyone 231 00:15:48,077 --> 00:15:50,329 a 23-minute phone call to 911? 232 00:15:52,748 --> 00:15:55,960 [911 recording of Shannan panting] 233 00:15:56,043 --> 00:15:57,836 -[911 operator] Hello? -[Pak] Shannan, get in the car! 234 00:15:57,920 --> 00:15:59,380 Come on, what are you doing? 235 00:15:59,463 --> 00:16:01,090 [Shannan panting] 236 00:16:01,173 --> 00:16:03,842 [911 operator] Miss, I can't help if you don't tell me where you are. 237 00:16:03,926 --> 00:16:05,052 [Pak] What's wrong? 238 00:16:05,135 --> 00:16:06,428 [Shannan crying] 239 00:16:06,512 --> 00:16:09,556 [911 operator] I'm having a hard time getting a read on your location. 240 00:16:09,640 --> 00:16:11,642 [Pak] Come on, Shannan! Come back! 241 00:16:11,725 --> 00:16:13,727 [Shannan shouts] Help me! Help! 242 00:16:14,770 --> 00:16:16,981 [Shannan wailing] 243 00:16:17,064 --> 00:16:17,898 [phone beeps] 244 00:16:18,816 --> 00:16:20,734 -[recording clicks off] -[detective clears throat] 245 00:16:22,069 --> 00:16:23,112 All right, um... 246 00:16:23,988 --> 00:16:26,073 The report says the unit arrived at 5:40. 247 00:16:26,156 --> 00:16:28,993 Officers interviewed several residents who said they... 248 00:16:29,076 --> 00:16:31,954 saw your daughter leave on her own with no sign of, um... 249 00:16:33,038 --> 00:16:34,456 suspicious activity. 250 00:16:37,292 --> 00:16:38,711 This is her jacket. 251 00:16:38,794 --> 00:16:40,921 [detective] Yeah, well, as far as the 911 call goes, 252 00:16:41,005 --> 00:16:42,923 the residents say that she was on drugs. 253 00:16:43,007 --> 00:16:45,092 -[tapping sound] -My daughter doesn't do drugs. 254 00:16:45,175 --> 00:16:46,051 [Sarra taps her feet] 255 00:16:46,135 --> 00:16:48,637 [detective] You got a close relationship with her, Ms. Gilbert? 256 00:16:49,346 --> 00:16:50,264 Excuse me? 257 00:16:50,848 --> 00:16:53,350 [detective] What was she doing in a gated community, 258 00:16:54,351 --> 00:16:56,937 100 miles away from home in the middle of the night? 259 00:16:57,021 --> 00:16:58,439 [Sarra continues tapping] 260 00:16:58,522 --> 00:17:01,108 Can I be frank here with you just for a minute, please? 261 00:17:02,526 --> 00:17:05,154 When girls like this go missing, 262 00:17:05,654 --> 00:17:07,114 it's a high-risk environment. 263 00:17:07,990 --> 00:17:11,201 You know, I mean, maybe she ran away, maybe she'll turn up. 264 00:17:11,285 --> 00:17:14,747 Hey. Do you think you could stop that for one second, please, sweetheart? 265 00:17:14,830 --> 00:17:16,040 Just one. 266 00:17:16,123 --> 00:17:17,624 My daughter isn't on drugs. 267 00:17:18,417 --> 00:17:20,586 She didn't run away. She's missing. 268 00:17:21,879 --> 00:17:25,090 Now, I have been hung up on, dismissed, and ignored, 269 00:17:25,174 --> 00:17:27,509 but one thing I won't be is silenced. 270 00:17:27,593 --> 00:17:28,677 [Sarra tapping her feet] 271 00:17:28,761 --> 00:17:30,721 Now, you say she's not missing. Fine. 272 00:17:30,804 --> 00:17:33,057 That's your position, but here's mine. 273 00:17:33,140 --> 00:17:35,476 She called for help at 4:51, 274 00:17:35,559 --> 00:17:37,144 and you arrived at 5:40. 275 00:17:37,227 --> 00:17:41,190 How in the fuck does it take an hour to respond to a call like that? 276 00:17:41,815 --> 00:17:45,944 [muffled rock music playing] 277 00:17:46,695 --> 00:17:47,529 [man] Jesus. 278 00:17:48,906 --> 00:17:50,157 Crack a window. 279 00:18:00,000 --> 00:18:02,961 [music continues] 280 00:18:05,631 --> 00:18:08,050 [indistinct police radio chatter] 281 00:18:14,431 --> 00:18:16,433 [dog barks] 282 00:18:16,975 --> 00:18:18,560 [dog whines] 283 00:18:18,644 --> 00:18:21,355 [dog barks] 284 00:18:26,485 --> 00:18:30,155 [news reporter] Ocean Parkway is shut down between Gilgo Beach and Oak Beach. 285 00:18:30,239 --> 00:18:32,241 Police aren't saying much, but what we do know 286 00:18:32,324 --> 00:18:33,992 is that a police dog picked up a scent 287 00:18:34,076 --> 00:18:37,371 and a canine officer, knowing there was a Missing Persons report, 288 00:18:37,746 --> 00:18:38,997 brought in a search team. 289 00:18:39,498 --> 00:18:40,916 We expect to learn more tonight 290 00:18:40,999 --> 00:18:45,003 when Suffolk County Police Commissioner, Richard Dormer, holds a press conference. 291 00:18:45,087 --> 00:18:47,256 Commissioner Dormer made news earlier this year 292 00:18:47,339 --> 00:18:49,675 after narrowly surviving a vote of dismissal 293 00:18:49,758 --> 00:18:50,968 for staffing level issues 294 00:18:51,051 --> 00:18:54,471 that may have contributed to the deaths of three voters. 295 00:18:54,555 --> 00:18:55,681 -[detective] Hey. -Hey. 296 00:18:57,349 --> 00:18:58,350 There's four in all. 297 00:18:59,560 --> 00:19:00,519 They're skeletal. 298 00:19:01,186 --> 00:19:02,646 They're wrapped in burlap. 299 00:19:03,939 --> 00:19:06,358 And they're, uh... They're spaced evenly apart. 300 00:19:06,441 --> 00:19:08,193 There's... one down there, 301 00:19:08,819 --> 00:19:10,404 here, here, 302 00:19:11,196 --> 00:19:12,114 and over there. 303 00:19:17,327 --> 00:19:20,330 [man on phone] If the press starts to say we got a serial killer on our hands, 304 00:19:20,414 --> 00:19:22,958 this will blow up. Keep this under control, Richard, 305 00:19:23,041 --> 00:19:25,794 or your retirement could come sooner than you planned. You got it? 306 00:19:25,878 --> 00:19:28,046 -Okay, sir. -All right, go handle it. 307 00:19:28,130 --> 00:19:28,964 Thank you. 308 00:19:29,798 --> 00:19:31,675 Jesus fucking Christ. 309 00:19:32,384 --> 00:19:35,596 Commissioner Dormer, sir, they're ready for you. 310 00:19:36,680 --> 00:19:39,975 -[male reporter] Commissioner! -[woman] Sir, over here, please. Thanks. 311 00:19:40,058 --> 00:19:44,229 -[male reporter] Sir, over here. -While searching for a missing prostitute, 312 00:19:44,313 --> 00:19:47,482 one of our officers has located... 313 00:19:48,650 --> 00:19:52,070 four bodies in an area along Ocean Parkway. 314 00:19:52,154 --> 00:19:54,448 Were the bodies all left there by the same person? 315 00:19:54,531 --> 00:19:56,491 [Dormer] I can't say that. 316 00:19:56,575 --> 00:19:59,203 This is an anomaly. There's... 317 00:19:59,870 --> 00:20:01,496 There's no need for panic. 318 00:20:01,580 --> 00:20:02,414 [reporters clamor] 319 00:20:02,497 --> 00:20:05,626 -That's all I have to say. Thank you. -[woman] Sir, we have one more... 320 00:20:05,709 --> 00:20:07,377 [woman on phone] Ellenville Diner. 321 00:20:07,461 --> 00:20:10,047 Hey. I need you to cover for me tonight. 322 00:20:10,130 --> 00:20:12,341 -[woman] Why? What happened? -I gotta go back. 323 00:20:12,424 --> 00:20:14,843 [woman] Where? Long Island, for Shannan? 324 00:20:14,927 --> 00:20:18,263 Yeah, the police station, they found bodies. 325 00:20:18,347 --> 00:20:19,890 [woman] Oh, God. Do the girls know? 326 00:20:19,973 --> 00:20:21,808 Yeah, I'm about to tell them now. 327 00:20:21,892 --> 00:20:23,894 [woman] Of course. Don't worry about it. 328 00:20:24,394 --> 00:20:26,021 I got you. Good luck. 329 00:20:26,104 --> 00:20:28,649 -Okay, thanks. I owe you. -[woman] Bye. 330 00:20:30,317 --> 00:20:32,819 -[Sherre] Hey. -We gotta go back to Suffolk County. 331 00:20:33,570 --> 00:20:34,655 Mom, what's going on? 332 00:20:37,074 --> 00:20:38,075 Mom? 333 00:20:38,867 --> 00:20:41,578 [sighs] They don't tell you that over the phone. 334 00:20:57,511 --> 00:20:59,638 [detective] When the units rolled up, she's a ghost. 335 00:20:59,721 --> 00:21:02,975 Residents seemed pretty calm about it. Everything seemed to be kosher. 336 00:21:03,058 --> 00:21:06,520 They figured that it was a domestic disturbance 337 00:21:06,603 --> 00:21:07,771 which resolved itself. 338 00:21:08,522 --> 00:21:10,524 -What do you know about Oak Beach? -I... 339 00:21:11,149 --> 00:21:14,319 I know the guys like to go to parties out there once in a while. 340 00:21:14,403 --> 00:21:16,238 -Why? -What kind of parties? 341 00:21:16,321 --> 00:21:19,658 Oh, come on, Richard, you know. Birthdays, bar mitzvahs, 342 00:21:19,741 --> 00:21:21,827 quinceañeras, come on. You know, come on. 343 00:21:21,910 --> 00:21:24,830 -You think this is some kind of joke? -No. I don't. 344 00:21:25,831 --> 00:21:28,959 Look... she's not in my fucking trunk. 345 00:21:30,585 --> 00:21:33,130 Your real problem is that one out there. 346 00:21:33,922 --> 00:21:34,923 She's feisty. 347 00:21:40,137 --> 00:21:41,013 Okay. 348 00:21:42,222 --> 00:21:43,098 Let me handle it. 349 00:21:47,436 --> 00:21:49,980 [detective] Okay, ladies, come with me, please. This way. 350 00:21:50,063 --> 00:21:51,440 Come on. Let's go. 351 00:22:01,950 --> 00:22:03,327 [Dormer] Mrs. Gilbert. 352 00:22:04,578 --> 00:22:07,289 Thank you for coming so quickly. I'm... 353 00:22:07,789 --> 00:22:09,333 I'm Commissioner Dormer. 354 00:22:11,293 --> 00:22:13,378 -I know it was a long drive-- -Are any of them her? 355 00:22:13,879 --> 00:22:15,630 [Dormer sighs] It appears not. 356 00:22:16,298 --> 00:22:18,675 -[sighs in relief] -[Dormer] But we are working a grid 357 00:22:18,759 --> 00:22:19,801 as we speak. 358 00:22:19,885 --> 00:22:22,804 Tomorrow morning we begin the aerial searches, first thing. 359 00:22:22,888 --> 00:22:26,224 That's assuming she's... You're searching everywhere, right? 360 00:22:26,308 --> 00:22:27,684 Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. 361 00:22:29,936 --> 00:22:33,565 I wanted to ask you some questions about Shannan, if that's okay. 362 00:22:33,648 --> 00:22:37,652 Is there anything that you can tell me about the men in Shannan's life? 363 00:22:38,111 --> 00:22:40,614 She has a boyfriend, Alex Diaz. 364 00:22:41,198 --> 00:22:43,158 Anybody else we should be looking at? 365 00:22:43,241 --> 00:22:45,160 A driver. Pak. Michael Pak. 366 00:22:45,660 --> 00:22:46,787 What about the doctor? 367 00:22:47,871 --> 00:22:49,414 [Dormer] What doctor? 368 00:22:49,498 --> 00:22:52,084 He called me the morning after she went missing. 369 00:22:52,542 --> 00:22:54,419 He said he saw her and he helped her. 370 00:22:54,503 --> 00:22:56,296 He runs a home for wayward girls. 371 00:22:57,005 --> 00:22:58,006 What about her jacket? 372 00:22:58,090 --> 00:23:00,258 We have the jacket and it's being tested. 373 00:23:03,887 --> 00:23:05,847 Can you recall this doctor's name? 374 00:23:07,307 --> 00:23:09,142 [quietly] Fuck. Oh. 375 00:23:09,810 --> 00:23:11,686 Harper? Haskell? 376 00:23:11,770 --> 00:23:14,439 -It's okay. It's okay. It's okay. -I don't remember. 377 00:23:15,774 --> 00:23:19,194 [Dormer] Mrs. Gilbert, there's a lot we don't know at the moment. 378 00:23:20,320 --> 00:23:22,823 Which is why it's really important 379 00:23:23,740 --> 00:23:25,409 that you don't talk to the media. 380 00:23:25,992 --> 00:23:27,035 Let us handle that. 381 00:23:28,036 --> 00:23:30,497 One wrong word, and they'll make a meal out of it. 382 00:23:30,580 --> 00:23:32,165 It's in your best interest. 383 00:23:33,125 --> 00:23:34,042 Sharon's, too. 384 00:23:35,377 --> 00:23:36,378 It's "Shannan." 385 00:23:37,212 --> 00:23:40,132 The beautiful beaches of Long Island, New York 386 00:23:40,215 --> 00:23:42,676 have become the latest backdrop 387 00:23:42,759 --> 00:23:44,094 in a murder mystery. 388 00:23:44,177 --> 00:23:46,805 The victims were engaged in a high-risk business, 389 00:23:46,888 --> 00:23:51,351 and these homicides appear to us to be directly related to that business. 390 00:23:51,435 --> 00:23:54,187 [news reporter] The Medical Examiner determined the cause of death 391 00:23:54,271 --> 00:23:56,690 for the four women to be strangulation. 392 00:23:56,773 --> 00:23:58,817 Each body meticulously placed in bur-- 393 00:23:58,900 --> 00:24:00,569 [male reporter] 24-year-old Shannan Gilbert, 394 00:24:00,652 --> 00:24:02,112 a prostitute from Jersey-- 395 00:24:02,195 --> 00:24:03,155 [turns TV off] 396 00:24:05,532 --> 00:24:07,742 I wish they wouldn't call her a prostitute. 397 00:24:07,826 --> 00:24:10,412 Well, what do you expect them to call her, a lawyer? 398 00:24:11,455 --> 00:24:12,831 I always told you, girls, 399 00:24:12,914 --> 00:24:15,459 the choices you make eventually catch up with you. 400 00:24:15,542 --> 00:24:16,793 You've never said that. 401 00:24:19,546 --> 00:24:21,256 It sounds like you're blaming her. 402 00:24:21,339 --> 00:24:22,674 Maybe I should blame you 403 00:24:22,757 --> 00:24:25,260 for not telling me she's in an abusive relationship. 404 00:24:25,343 --> 00:24:28,013 Like you not telling me she was a prostitute? 405 00:24:29,181 --> 00:24:30,765 Why didn't you do anything? 406 00:24:33,518 --> 00:24:34,394 [Mari sighs] 407 00:24:36,646 --> 00:24:38,273 What else aren't you telling me? 408 00:24:46,823 --> 00:24:49,326 [Pak] I was waiting in the car like usual. 409 00:24:50,243 --> 00:24:52,078 Uh, playing Words with Friends. 410 00:24:52,954 --> 00:24:55,123 And that's when the john... 411 00:24:55,207 --> 00:24:57,709 this fat fuck comes up to the window and he says... 412 00:24:57,792 --> 00:25:00,045 You gotta get her out of my house. 413 00:25:01,213 --> 00:25:02,756 [softly] Fucking kidding me? 414 00:25:02,839 --> 00:25:05,383 So, I went inside and... 415 00:25:05,884 --> 00:25:09,346 Shannan was behind the couch on her hands and knees, shaking. 416 00:25:10,514 --> 00:25:12,724 -And she called 911. -[Shannan over recording] Help me! 417 00:25:12,807 --> 00:25:14,434 -She started screaming. -[Shannan] Help me! 418 00:25:14,518 --> 00:25:17,687 -[Pak] What are you doing? Shannan! Stop! -[Shannan] Help! Somebody! 419 00:25:17,771 --> 00:25:19,105 -[Shannan panting] -[Pak] Shannan! 420 00:25:19,189 --> 00:25:21,858 So then I said, "I'm trying to help you." 421 00:25:22,442 --> 00:25:23,902 [Alex] Finally, I said "Fuck it," 422 00:25:23,985 --> 00:25:26,821 you know, and just drove to Oak Beach to knock on doors myself. 423 00:25:27,822 --> 00:25:29,699 I talked to the john. Um... 424 00:25:30,116 --> 00:25:33,453 Oh, I met this guy with a limp who was actually willing to help. 425 00:25:35,497 --> 00:25:36,998 What was the name of the john? 426 00:25:37,082 --> 00:25:38,166 Brewer. 427 00:25:39,543 --> 00:25:41,503 He must've done something to spook her. 428 00:25:47,133 --> 00:25:49,803 [indistinct police radio chatter] 429 00:25:53,265 --> 00:25:56,184 [news reporter] Suffolk County Police are questioning an Oak Beach resident 430 00:25:56,268 --> 00:25:58,603 in connection with the disappearance of Shannan Gilbert 431 00:25:58,687 --> 00:26:01,481 and have identified the four skeletons along Ocean Parkway 432 00:26:01,565 --> 00:26:04,234 as Maureen Bainard-Barnes, Melissa Barthelemy, 433 00:26:04,317 --> 00:26:06,611 Amber Costello, and Megan Waterman. 434 00:26:06,695 --> 00:26:09,281 All sex workers advertising on Craigslist 435 00:26:09,364 --> 00:26:12,367 who have been missing since as far back as 2007 436 00:26:12,450 --> 00:26:15,036 and as recently as three months ago. Commissioner-- 437 00:26:15,120 --> 00:26:18,123 Why are we learning about this on the goddamned Today show? 438 00:26:18,623 --> 00:26:19,457 [sighs] 439 00:26:20,917 --> 00:26:21,835 What do you think? 440 00:26:26,381 --> 00:26:29,426 -All the other girls have one. -All the other girls are dead. 441 00:26:31,886 --> 00:26:33,346 Their families invited us to a vigil. 442 00:26:33,430 --> 00:26:35,640 -You've been talking to them? -Online. 443 00:26:35,724 --> 00:26:37,434 Oh, we're not going to any vigil. 444 00:26:37,851 --> 00:26:40,103 -Why not? -Because Shannan's not dead. 445 00:26:40,186 --> 00:26:43,440 -[woman on phone] Suffolk County Police. -I'd like to speak to Commissioner Dormer. 446 00:26:44,816 --> 00:26:46,651 Okay, you tell him this is Mari Gilbert calling, 447 00:26:46,735 --> 00:26:49,154 and if I don't hear back within the hour, 448 00:26:49,237 --> 00:26:51,906 I'm gonna drive my car into his front fucking lawn. 449 00:26:51,990 --> 00:26:53,575 Okay, I'll see you at dinner. 450 00:26:58,580 --> 00:27:01,750 [news reporter] Oak Beach resident, Joseph Brewer, who hired Shannan Gilbert, 451 00:27:01,833 --> 00:27:05,545 has been cleared by Suffolk County Police after taking a polygraph, 452 00:27:05,629 --> 00:27:08,298 leaving two questions still unanswered: 453 00:27:08,381 --> 00:27:10,592 who is killing sex workers on Long Island, 454 00:27:10,675 --> 00:27:12,260 and where is Shannan Gilbert? 455 00:27:12,344 --> 00:27:14,012 [male reporter] Police have identified the remains 456 00:27:14,095 --> 00:27:15,805 -of the four women... -Yes, hello. 457 00:27:15,889 --> 00:27:18,350 It's the 20th goddamned time I've called! 458 00:27:19,100 --> 00:27:22,729 What are they doing to find her, and why did they let that fuck go? 459 00:27:22,812 --> 00:27:23,647 He hire... 460 00:27:23,730 --> 00:27:25,523 [female reporter] ...a prostitute who went missing 461 00:27:25,607 --> 00:27:27,776 after apparently meeting a client on Craigslist. 462 00:27:27,859 --> 00:27:31,988 Are dozens more murdered women dumped like trash 463 00:27:32,614 --> 00:27:34,741 on the same strip of beach, 464 00:27:34,824 --> 00:27:36,701 waiting to be uncovered? 465 00:27:36,826 --> 00:27:40,413 We are live at the beach-turned-burial-ground. 466 00:27:40,497 --> 00:27:44,167 [man on TV] The girls are very available. They're very vulnerable. 467 00:27:44,709 --> 00:27:47,671 They have no family, and there's nobody out there looking for them. 468 00:28:11,111 --> 00:28:11,945 [exhales sharply] 469 00:28:29,838 --> 00:28:31,089 What's going on, Mrs. Gilbert? 470 00:28:31,172 --> 00:28:33,550 Either your phone's broke or your secretary's a moron 471 00:28:33,633 --> 00:28:35,885 because I must have left 50 messages for you. 472 00:28:36,928 --> 00:28:40,306 This is my daughter, Shannan Maria Gilbert. 473 00:28:40,390 --> 00:28:43,268 There's one here for every day that she's missing. 474 00:28:43,351 --> 00:28:44,978 and I'm gonna continue posting these 475 00:28:45,061 --> 00:28:47,313 until you either find her or die of paper cuts. 476 00:28:47,897 --> 00:28:51,943 -Do not ignore me. -Nobody is ignoring you, Mrs. Gilbert. 477 00:28:52,819 --> 00:28:55,572 I have a talent for holding grudges and unless you help me, 478 00:28:55,655 --> 00:28:57,991 I'm gonna raise more hell than you can handle. 479 00:28:58,575 --> 00:29:02,579 And don't you ever fucking call my daughter a prostitute again! 480 00:29:05,999 --> 00:29:08,793 [man laughing] 481 00:29:08,877 --> 00:29:09,711 [door bangs shut] 482 00:29:09,794 --> 00:29:11,629 [keyboard clacking] 483 00:29:11,713 --> 00:29:15,049 Okay, tell them we'll do the vigil, but we want to meet them first. 484 00:29:15,133 --> 00:29:18,094 -And make sure everybody comes. -What are you wearing? 485 00:29:23,016 --> 00:29:25,769 [keyboard clacking] 486 00:29:37,322 --> 00:29:40,492 [beeping] 487 00:29:40,575 --> 00:29:42,952 It's a long way to Oak Beach. 488 00:29:44,120 --> 00:29:46,831 -What were you guys talking about? -[Pak] I don't know. I... 489 00:29:48,792 --> 00:29:49,793 work. 490 00:29:51,252 --> 00:29:52,253 The weather... 491 00:29:55,006 --> 00:29:56,758 Her and her boyfriend sneaking Taco Bell 492 00:29:56,841 --> 00:29:59,260 in the new Freddy movie over at the Hudson Mall. 493 00:30:01,387 --> 00:30:03,640 Did she say anything about going to visit her mom? 494 00:30:04,307 --> 00:30:06,059 [beeping continues] 495 00:30:06,726 --> 00:30:08,311 [laughs] 496 00:30:08,770 --> 00:30:10,814 Wait. Are you serious? 497 00:30:11,481 --> 00:30:14,943 [beeping continues] 498 00:30:15,026 --> 00:30:17,028 Do you know anything about her mom? 499 00:30:20,824 --> 00:30:23,743 Oh, my God. These women are so pathetic. 500 00:30:24,577 --> 00:30:25,995 The less we say, the better. 501 00:30:26,079 --> 00:30:28,540 We don't need them knowing our personal business. 502 00:30:30,291 --> 00:30:31,292 What's that for? 503 00:30:31,376 --> 00:30:33,127 My notebook. I'm gonna take notes. 504 00:30:34,754 --> 00:30:35,588 [Mari sighs] 505 00:30:39,759 --> 00:30:41,261 Maybe we should go around? 506 00:30:42,387 --> 00:30:46,349 I'm Missy. I drove in from Connecticut for my sister, Maureen. 507 00:30:47,308 --> 00:30:49,477 It's so good to finally meet all of you in person. 508 00:30:50,687 --> 00:30:51,604 Mom. 509 00:30:53,940 --> 00:30:54,941 Say something. 510 00:30:59,195 --> 00:31:00,071 Uh, Lorraine. 511 00:31:01,573 --> 00:31:03,366 My daughter's Megan. 512 00:31:06,494 --> 00:31:08,705 I sold my TV to be here from Maine, 513 00:31:08,788 --> 00:31:11,499 so I have the cash to stay here until the vigil. 514 00:31:12,834 --> 00:31:14,043 I'm Lynn. 515 00:31:15,587 --> 00:31:18,214 My daughter is Melissa. 516 00:31:19,173 --> 00:31:21,426 This is my other daughter, Amanda. 517 00:31:21,509 --> 00:31:23,052 We came here from Buffalo. 518 00:31:24,429 --> 00:31:25,263 [horn honks] 519 00:31:27,891 --> 00:31:29,267 [Lorraine] Oh. Kim is here. 520 00:31:32,812 --> 00:31:35,064 -[door opens] -[Kim] Sorry, I'm late, y'all. 521 00:31:36,024 --> 00:31:38,234 [Missy] We were just going around introducing ourselves. 522 00:31:38,318 --> 00:31:40,570 Where we're from, who we've lost. 523 00:31:40,653 --> 00:31:41,654 Okay. Kim... 524 00:31:42,488 --> 00:31:44,407 North Carolina. Um... 525 00:31:44,490 --> 00:31:46,534 I like Rocky Road ice cream 526 00:31:46,618 --> 00:31:48,578 and long walks on the beach, 527 00:31:48,661 --> 00:31:50,038 and my sister was Amber. 528 00:31:50,622 --> 00:31:51,456 [sniffs] 529 00:31:53,917 --> 00:31:54,918 Did I miss anything? 530 00:31:57,211 --> 00:32:00,381 [Pak over recording, laughing] Wait. Are you serious? 531 00:32:01,007 --> 00:32:03,092 Do you know anything about her mom? 532 00:32:03,801 --> 00:32:05,720 'Cause she's a real piece of work. 533 00:32:06,721 --> 00:32:09,307 Yeah, abandoned her own daughter when she was just a kid. 534 00:32:10,892 --> 00:32:13,561 Shannan was in and out of foster homes her whole life. 535 00:32:14,520 --> 00:32:16,814 All her mom is good for is taking her money. 536 00:32:18,650 --> 00:32:21,069 Doesn't even care how Shannan made it. 537 00:32:22,487 --> 00:32:24,739 Just as long as she shared the wealth. 538 00:32:26,282 --> 00:32:28,242 [Lorraine] My daughter had three cellphones. 539 00:32:28,910 --> 00:32:30,745 [Lynn] My daughter had three cellphones. 540 00:32:30,828 --> 00:32:34,707 She was working on the... Craigslist. 541 00:32:34,791 --> 00:32:36,542 [Missy] Yes, so did Maureen. 542 00:32:36,626 --> 00:32:38,086 [Lynn] So did Melissa. 543 00:32:38,169 --> 00:32:40,588 They all did. That's why they're all so the same, 544 00:32:40,672 --> 00:32:42,715 because online, you can practically go shopping. 545 00:32:42,799 --> 00:32:44,968 [Lorraine] Sooner or later, they're gonna get this guy. 546 00:32:45,051 --> 00:32:46,302 There's gotta be some... 547 00:32:46,803 --> 00:32:48,513 computer trace they can do. 548 00:32:48,596 --> 00:32:50,556 [Kim]. Mm-mm. They don't get you on email. 549 00:32:50,640 --> 00:32:52,475 You post a number, then they call. 550 00:32:52,558 --> 00:32:56,229 Which is untraceable because the girls work on burner phones. 551 00:32:56,312 --> 00:32:58,064 Look at you, knowing your shit. 552 00:32:58,731 --> 00:33:01,234 They think they're all drug addicts. 553 00:33:01,317 --> 00:33:04,237 -Melissa wasn't even into drugs. -Neither was Maureen. 554 00:33:04,320 --> 00:33:05,196 She drank. 555 00:33:05,279 --> 00:33:08,157 [Kim] Drinking's better than drugs because it's legal. 556 00:33:08,241 --> 00:33:10,785 But coke is the best way to keep a call going. 557 00:33:11,494 --> 00:33:12,745 Make some real bank. 558 00:33:14,080 --> 00:33:17,041 Your girls knew that, whether you want to believe it or not. 559 00:33:19,127 --> 00:33:20,461 [Lorraine sighs] 560 00:33:20,545 --> 00:33:23,214 They told me Megan was where she wants to be. 561 00:33:24,048 --> 00:33:24,882 That, uh... 562 00:33:26,884 --> 00:33:28,177 That she didn't love me. 563 00:33:29,929 --> 00:33:31,097 [sighs, groans] 564 00:33:31,973 --> 00:33:34,684 As sad as it is, I feel some kind of relief. 565 00:33:35,184 --> 00:33:37,270 At least they're finally paying attention. 566 00:33:37,353 --> 00:33:38,271 Are you shitting me? 567 00:33:39,731 --> 00:33:43,192 If you think they give one goddamn about these girls, you're delusional. 568 00:33:44,193 --> 00:33:45,945 They weren't searching for them. 569 00:33:46,988 --> 00:33:50,616 A cop stopped along the side of the road to let his dog take a shit. 570 00:33:51,034 --> 00:33:52,785 He accidentally found them. 571 00:33:52,869 --> 00:33:54,203 What I meant was... 572 00:33:55,496 --> 00:33:59,042 at least it's on the news and people are aware of it. 573 00:34:00,001 --> 00:34:01,669 Have you watched the news? 574 00:34:02,462 --> 00:34:05,631 It's all, "He's a cop," "He's a clammer," he's this, he's that. 575 00:34:05,715 --> 00:34:07,383 It's all "him," "him," "him." 576 00:34:08,217 --> 00:34:10,553 What about our girls? Who's talking about them? 577 00:34:11,387 --> 00:34:15,099 And when they do, it's "prostitute," "hooker," 578 00:34:15,516 --> 00:34:17,518 "sex worker," "escort." 579 00:34:18,061 --> 00:34:20,521 Never "friend," "sister," 580 00:34:21,272 --> 00:34:22,482 "mother," "daughter." 581 00:34:23,816 --> 00:34:24,859 They don't care. 582 00:34:25,610 --> 00:34:26,736 They blame them. 583 00:34:28,362 --> 00:34:30,698 And it's our job, as mothers, 584 00:34:31,199 --> 00:34:32,492 and sisters, 585 00:34:33,367 --> 00:34:35,536 to make sure these girls are not forgotten. 586 00:34:37,205 --> 00:34:38,831 So, should we wait on the vigil? 587 00:34:39,665 --> 00:34:42,460 No, we're doing the vigil. We're going to Oak Beach, 588 00:34:43,044 --> 00:34:44,962 to their front fucking yard. 589 00:35:10,947 --> 00:35:12,365 Who tipped them off? 590 00:35:16,452 --> 00:35:20,289 This is a private community! I'll call the police! 591 00:35:20,373 --> 00:35:22,667 Go ahead. It'll take them an hour to get here. 592 00:35:25,920 --> 00:35:27,797 Speaking of which, can I borrow your phone? 593 00:35:27,880 --> 00:35:29,632 Sure. Why? 594 00:35:29,715 --> 00:35:31,342 They already know my number. 595 00:35:35,972 --> 00:35:38,891 There's a crazy lady about to tear through Oak Beach. 596 00:35:38,975 --> 00:35:40,893 [all giggle] 597 00:35:40,977 --> 00:35:42,270 Come quick. 598 00:36:08,504 --> 00:36:09,589 Who lives here? 599 00:36:10,548 --> 00:36:13,217 [sighs] The son of a bitch who hired her. 600 00:36:35,489 --> 00:36:36,866 [knocking on door] 601 00:37:12,526 --> 00:37:13,361 [exhales] 602 00:37:19,450 --> 00:37:21,035 [Shannan panting] 603 00:37:21,118 --> 00:37:22,036 [Sarra] Mom? 604 00:37:26,791 --> 00:37:27,625 Mom. 605 00:37:27,708 --> 00:37:28,626 [police siren blares] 606 00:37:43,307 --> 00:37:44,308 [Mari] Twelve minutes. 607 00:37:45,476 --> 00:37:49,522 Now we both you know you can show up on time and your secretary's not a retard. 608 00:37:50,356 --> 00:37:53,150 Can we just go back to my office and talk about this? 609 00:37:53,234 --> 00:37:54,443 [Mari] We'll talk right here. 610 00:37:56,320 --> 00:37:57,238 This is a... 611 00:37:57,321 --> 00:37:59,490 This is a private community. 612 00:37:59,573 --> 00:38:01,617 Well, then why don't you arrest me? 613 00:38:01,701 --> 00:38:03,703 Listen, I came here to do you a favor. 614 00:38:03,786 --> 00:38:05,913 I don't want to see you hauled away in handcuffs. 615 00:38:05,997 --> 00:38:08,374 Don't you understand that when the uniforms get here, 616 00:38:08,457 --> 00:38:12,086 -they're gonna cite you for trespassing. -Okay, let me get this straight. 617 00:38:12,169 --> 00:38:15,172 My daughter calls for help but it takes you an hour to get here, 618 00:38:15,256 --> 00:38:16,924 but the Stepford Wives call you 619 00:38:17,008 --> 00:38:19,552 and you show up in less time than it takes to make a sandwich! 620 00:38:19,635 --> 00:38:23,639 Whatever it is that you're looking for, Mrs. Gilbert, it is not here. 621 00:38:24,223 --> 00:38:27,101 Okay, then why did my 14-year-old just find her sister's earring 622 00:38:27,184 --> 00:38:29,437 outside the home of the man that you just set free? 623 00:38:30,479 --> 00:38:33,399 Shannan went screaming through here at 4:51 in the morning, 624 00:38:33,482 --> 00:38:35,276 and no one helped her. 625 00:38:35,359 --> 00:38:37,486 Where is the outrage? Where's the concern? 626 00:38:38,321 --> 00:38:40,489 Four dead bodies show up in my neighborhood, 627 00:38:40,573 --> 00:38:43,242 I'd be shouting from the rooftops to get to the bottom of it. 628 00:38:44,243 --> 00:38:45,328 What are they hiding? 629 00:38:47,580 --> 00:38:49,457 What are you hiding, Mrs. Gilbert? 630 00:38:50,499 --> 00:38:53,336 You never told me that Shannan grew up in foster care. 631 00:38:57,089 --> 00:38:59,383 You never told me you nearly got shit-canned 632 00:38:59,467 --> 00:39:01,302 for mismanaging your department. 633 00:39:03,763 --> 00:39:05,181 Keep up the good work, Commissioner. 634 00:39:16,067 --> 00:39:17,318 [Dormer, quietly] Fuck's sake. 635 00:39:17,401 --> 00:39:20,196 [dog barking] 636 00:39:23,282 --> 00:39:26,118 I wrote down every house number and license plate I saw. 637 00:39:26,202 --> 00:39:29,205 We need to talk to these people and these people. 638 00:39:30,081 --> 00:39:31,248 They might've seen her. 639 00:39:31,332 --> 00:39:33,501 [Mari] No one's gonna talk 'cause they want us out. 640 00:39:34,460 --> 00:39:38,255 These guys are looking out for each other. They all have friends in Suffolk PD. 641 00:39:38,339 --> 00:39:41,842 The police said everybody passed lie detector tests. 642 00:39:41,926 --> 00:39:44,387 [Mari] Yeah, but anybody can pass a lie detector test 643 00:39:44,470 --> 00:39:47,390 if all they ask you is "What's your name, and your favorite color?" 644 00:39:48,641 --> 00:39:50,768 It sounds like Shannan's running from her driver. 645 00:39:50,851 --> 00:39:53,020 You can hear him in the 911 call. 646 00:39:53,104 --> 00:39:54,271 [Kim] That makes no sense. 647 00:39:54,939 --> 00:39:58,484 I don't care how fucked up I am, my ass is going to that driver 648 00:39:58,567 --> 00:39:59,819 because he's my way out. 649 00:39:59,902 --> 00:40:02,113 He's my safety. That's what you pay him for. 650 00:40:04,865 --> 00:40:07,284 Well, maybe he was mad she didn't pay him. 651 00:40:07,368 --> 00:40:09,412 Why would she all of a sudden not pay her driver? 652 00:40:13,416 --> 00:40:15,626 Maybe because she was bringing money home. 653 00:40:17,586 --> 00:40:20,214 Okay, do you don't know she didn't pay him. You're just guessing. 654 00:40:20,297 --> 00:40:21,715 Well, I'm assuming. 655 00:40:21,799 --> 00:40:25,553 She's probably forced to get stoned, drunk, high-- 656 00:40:25,636 --> 00:40:27,430 -Not forced. -[Mari] Okay, whatever. 657 00:40:27,513 --> 00:40:29,557 [Kim] I'm just saying, I've lived it. 658 00:40:29,640 --> 00:40:31,767 Well, I'm just saying, you're not Shannan. 659 00:40:35,521 --> 00:40:37,231 Mari, I feel for you... 660 00:40:38,399 --> 00:40:39,859 more than I feel for myself 661 00:40:39,942 --> 00:40:43,696 or any of the other ladies here, because Shannan's still missing. 662 00:40:44,989 --> 00:40:46,949 And knowing is better than not knowing. 663 00:40:49,326 --> 00:40:51,120 But you don't really think that... 664 00:41:02,631 --> 00:41:05,968 I'm just saying it might be good to accept that there's another ending to all this. 665 00:41:07,344 --> 00:41:09,889 What's that ending, if you know so goddamned much? 666 00:41:17,146 --> 00:41:18,147 [soda can pops open] 667 00:41:48,010 --> 00:41:48,928 [sighs] 668 00:42:02,942 --> 00:42:04,777 [phone rings] 669 00:42:05,903 --> 00:42:08,030 [ringing continues] 670 00:42:10,282 --> 00:42:11,116 Hello? 671 00:42:12,034 --> 00:42:13,410 [man] Is this Mari Gilbert? 672 00:42:14,119 --> 00:42:14,954 Yes. 673 00:42:15,371 --> 00:42:16,789 My name's Joe Scalise. 674 00:42:16,872 --> 00:42:20,209 I have some information you're gonna want to hear. 675 00:42:21,085 --> 00:42:24,255 [rain patters] 676 00:43:09,466 --> 00:43:11,468 [engine starts] 677 00:43:14,221 --> 00:43:16,765 [Joe] I'm a neighbor of Joe Brewer, the john. 678 00:43:17,891 --> 00:43:21,395 I got your number from one of those fliers you posted. 679 00:43:21,478 --> 00:43:24,315 Suffolk PD don't return my calls no more. 680 00:43:25,691 --> 00:43:28,694 You're gonna learn that the good people of Oak Beach, 681 00:43:29,987 --> 00:43:32,072 if they live by one thing, it's this: 682 00:43:32,156 --> 00:43:34,199 be wary of those who would... 683 00:43:35,993 --> 00:43:38,495 who would ruin a very good thing. 684 00:43:38,579 --> 00:43:43,167 You are, madam, the wayfarer they've been dreading. 685 00:43:44,168 --> 00:43:45,419 [exhales sharply] 686 00:43:45,502 --> 00:43:46,337 [sniffs] 687 00:43:52,676 --> 00:43:54,845 [Sherre] I didn't know Shannan was a prostitute. 688 00:43:55,679 --> 00:43:58,057 I didn't know she was bringing home money. 689 00:44:00,100 --> 00:44:01,894 She doesn't let anyone help her. 690 00:44:03,604 --> 00:44:06,023 I thought we were doing this together. 691 00:44:07,816 --> 00:44:09,610 So fucking annoying. 692 00:44:11,070 --> 00:44:12,363 Sorry. 693 00:44:12,446 --> 00:44:13,947 We weren't following you. 694 00:44:14,031 --> 00:44:15,115 We kind of were. 695 00:44:15,199 --> 00:44:16,492 [chuckles] 696 00:44:18,619 --> 00:44:19,995 What are you two talking about? 697 00:44:20,746 --> 00:44:22,206 Families. 698 00:44:22,748 --> 00:44:23,957 Yeah. 699 00:44:25,084 --> 00:44:26,960 Tell me something nice about Shannan. 700 00:44:29,046 --> 00:44:31,590 She graduated high school two years early. 701 00:44:33,258 --> 00:44:34,510 She was smart. 702 00:44:35,386 --> 00:44:38,222 And she was the first one in our family to go to college. 703 00:44:40,432 --> 00:44:42,267 I called her "Diva." 704 00:44:42,851 --> 00:44:44,019 [Sherre laughs] 705 00:44:44,103 --> 00:44:45,979 Because she's such a little diva. 706 00:44:48,148 --> 00:44:50,275 Amber stood 4'11" 707 00:44:50,359 --> 00:44:52,736 and weighed 100 pounds soaking wet. 708 00:44:52,820 --> 00:44:54,321 [everyone laughs] 709 00:44:54,822 --> 00:44:57,491 Her legs looked like little chicken drumsticks. 710 00:45:01,954 --> 00:45:03,956 I spoke to her the day she went missing. 711 00:45:04,039 --> 00:45:04,873 [sighs] 712 00:45:07,084 --> 00:45:08,043 We were in a fight. 713 00:45:13,757 --> 00:45:14,591 [chuckles wryly] 714 00:45:21,098 --> 00:45:22,433 -[sighs] -[car trunk closes] 715 00:45:29,773 --> 00:45:30,858 [Joe] You're walking through 716 00:45:30,941 --> 00:45:33,068 what used to be the killer's dumping ground. 717 00:45:33,152 --> 00:45:35,028 He only moved the bodies to the road 718 00:45:35,112 --> 00:45:39,032 because this whole area is set to be drained as part of the mosquito project. 719 00:45:42,119 --> 00:45:45,456 That means people poking around, seeing things they shouldn't. 720 00:45:50,377 --> 00:45:51,211 Here. 721 00:45:51,879 --> 00:45:52,755 Look. 722 00:45:54,965 --> 00:45:56,967 This is where he keeps his supplies. 723 00:45:58,177 --> 00:45:59,261 But... where? 724 00:46:01,930 --> 00:46:04,099 [vehicle approaching] 725 00:46:04,183 --> 00:46:05,350 [Joe whispers] Go, go, go. 726 00:46:05,434 --> 00:46:08,187 -[Mari panting] -[Joe shushes] 727 00:46:08,270 --> 00:46:10,647 -[Joe whispers] Shit like that happens. -[whispers] What's up? 728 00:46:11,815 --> 00:46:12,858 Oh, God. 729 00:46:12,941 --> 00:46:14,568 Easy. Just... 730 00:46:18,238 --> 00:46:19,114 [car door closes] 731 00:46:19,615 --> 00:46:20,532 [car door lock beeps] 732 00:46:28,582 --> 00:46:31,084 Joe Brewer didn't kill Shannan. 733 00:46:32,377 --> 00:46:35,255 He may be a sociopath, but he's not the psychopath. 734 00:46:35,339 --> 00:46:37,633 That honor goes to Peter Hackett. 735 00:46:40,177 --> 00:46:41,428 [whispers] Dr. Hackett? 736 00:46:49,102 --> 00:46:51,438 [Dormer] Look, I know you and your buddies don't give a shit. 737 00:46:51,522 --> 00:46:54,107 Don't worry. You're not gonna have to put up with me much longer. 738 00:46:54,191 --> 00:46:56,902 But for the moment, this is my case. Okay? 739 00:46:57,402 --> 00:46:59,738 -I want a suspect. I want a name. -Okay. 740 00:46:59,822 --> 00:47:02,407 [Mari] Peter Hackett. Dr. Peter Hackett. 741 00:47:02,491 --> 00:47:03,992 He lives in Oak Beach. 742 00:47:04,493 --> 00:47:06,245 It's nice to see you again, Ms. Gilbert. 743 00:47:06,328 --> 00:47:08,914 I saw spools of burlap in a shed by his house. 744 00:47:08,997 --> 00:47:12,209 Come on. What are you talking about? Every clammer, contractor, landscaper 745 00:47:12,292 --> 00:47:15,003 -has got burlap by his house. Come on. -But a doctor? 746 00:47:15,712 --> 00:47:18,841 I tell you what, why don't you let the policemen do the police work, honey? 747 00:47:18,924 --> 00:47:20,801 -Why don't you suck my dick? -Classy. 748 00:47:20,884 --> 00:47:22,052 This is the guy who called me 749 00:47:22,135 --> 00:47:24,638 the morning after she disappeared. He said that he helped her. 750 00:47:26,014 --> 00:47:27,558 Come on. Aren't you gonna write it down? 751 00:47:27,641 --> 00:47:29,393 Are you fucking kidding me? Hmm? 752 00:47:30,811 --> 00:47:31,895 Write it down. 753 00:47:31,979 --> 00:47:32,813 What? 754 00:47:33,230 --> 00:47:35,607 I said write it down. 755 00:47:35,691 --> 00:47:38,235 [man speaking indistinctly on TV] 756 00:47:55,752 --> 00:47:56,587 [door opens] 757 00:47:58,589 --> 00:47:59,423 [door shuts] 758 00:48:01,967 --> 00:48:04,344 [brushing teeth] 759 00:48:10,183 --> 00:48:12,102 I googled Sarra's medication. 760 00:48:12,185 --> 00:48:14,354 So I know it's a mood stabilizer. 761 00:48:18,358 --> 00:48:20,944 She told me you took her to a psychiatrist. 762 00:48:21,361 --> 00:48:22,529 Why didn't you tell me? 763 00:48:23,655 --> 00:48:24,907 There's nothing to tell. 764 00:48:25,949 --> 00:48:28,702 It takes six weeks for the medication to have any effect, 765 00:48:28,785 --> 00:48:29,995 so we'll know more then. 766 00:49:18,543 --> 00:49:21,004 [man] Hello. Can I help you? 767 00:49:24,007 --> 00:49:26,093 [hens clucking] 768 00:49:26,176 --> 00:49:28,887 [man] Peter Hackett's the best neighbor you can have. 769 00:49:28,971 --> 00:49:32,307 Ever there's a problem, he's always the first one to call. 770 00:49:32,391 --> 00:49:34,768 Do you remember anything from that night? 771 00:49:35,602 --> 00:49:37,771 Yeah, that girl was pretty well drugged up. 772 00:49:37,854 --> 00:49:40,107 -What? -She couldn't hardly stand. 773 00:49:40,649 --> 00:49:42,693 -Excuse me? -She almost fell down twice 774 00:49:42,776 --> 00:49:45,278 -when I was talking to her. -Wait, you saw her? 775 00:49:45,362 --> 00:49:47,531 -Why didn't you call the police? -I did. 776 00:49:48,949 --> 00:49:51,618 -What was she saying? -It wasn't making sense. 777 00:49:52,202 --> 00:49:54,496 "Help me. Help me. They're going to kill me." 778 00:49:55,080 --> 00:49:56,999 So I sat her down on the porch, 779 00:49:57,082 --> 00:49:59,376 and I said, "Relax." 780 00:49:59,459 --> 00:50:02,754 I told her that I called the police and they were on their way. 781 00:50:03,547 --> 00:50:05,882 As soon as I said that, she ran. 782 00:50:06,550 --> 00:50:07,551 Anyhow... 783 00:50:08,510 --> 00:50:10,887 -What? -...she fell down the stairs and... 784 00:50:11,805 --> 00:50:12,848 she ran that way. 785 00:50:15,892 --> 00:50:18,395 [Mari] Wait, do those security cameras work? 786 00:50:37,748 --> 00:50:39,958 [Mari] Is this where they keep the security footage? 787 00:50:40,500 --> 00:50:41,835 Are you from the news? 788 00:50:41,918 --> 00:50:44,546 We, unfortunately, don't have it from that night. 789 00:50:44,629 --> 00:50:47,883 It gets taped over automatically. It runs on a loop. I'm sorry. 790 00:50:47,966 --> 00:50:49,634 But the police got a copy, right? 791 00:50:50,594 --> 00:50:52,679 [woman] We found it odd they never asked. 792 00:50:55,891 --> 00:50:57,392 I'm sorry, who are you? 793 00:51:00,062 --> 00:51:01,480 Why didn't you give it to them? 794 00:51:01,938 --> 00:51:03,523 Why don't I get my husband? 795 00:51:03,607 --> 00:51:05,233 He oversees all that. 796 00:51:05,317 --> 00:51:07,319 I just came by to drop off his lunch. 797 00:51:08,153 --> 00:51:11,198 [breathes deeply] 798 00:51:28,548 --> 00:51:31,218 How can I help you? Dr. Peter Hackett. 799 00:51:32,344 --> 00:51:34,763 My wife tells me you're a reporter. 800 00:51:35,263 --> 00:51:36,515 I've lived here for 30 years. 801 00:51:36,598 --> 00:51:38,600 There's not a thing I don't know about Oak Beach. 802 00:51:39,309 --> 00:51:43,814 We're like a miniature government here, and I pound the gavel. [laughs] 803 00:51:47,692 --> 00:51:49,986 Barbara, why don't you put on some coffee? 804 00:51:50,403 --> 00:51:51,404 It's on, dear. 805 00:51:52,489 --> 00:51:54,074 Then why don't you refresh it? 806 00:51:59,204 --> 00:52:03,708 I, uh... recognize you from the news. 807 00:52:04,459 --> 00:52:05,585 I'm so sorry. 808 00:52:07,254 --> 00:52:09,047 -What happened? -[Dr. Hackett laughs] 809 00:52:09,673 --> 00:52:12,801 Well, that's the $64,000 question. 810 00:52:13,927 --> 00:52:15,512 But you called me. 811 00:52:17,180 --> 00:52:18,140 I beg your pardon? 812 00:52:21,518 --> 00:52:23,228 [indistinct chatter on police radio] 813 00:52:23,353 --> 00:52:26,523 [dispatch officer on radio] Unit report to mile marker 10.46, Ocean Parkway 814 00:52:26,606 --> 00:52:28,441 for possible remains sighting. 815 00:52:31,278 --> 00:52:33,446 [officer] Just arriving. Going to check it out. Stand by. 816 00:52:59,139 --> 00:53:03,476 We got a 10-54 on Ocean Parkway near Cedar Beach. 817 00:53:06,021 --> 00:53:06,897 Fuck. 818 00:53:12,694 --> 00:53:13,945 [scanner beeps] 819 00:53:21,494 --> 00:53:24,998 [Mari] Last place Shannan was seen was in clear view of a video camera, 820 00:53:25,081 --> 00:53:27,417 and Hackett's in charge of the footage! 821 00:53:27,500 --> 00:53:29,502 Okay. I'll look into it. 822 00:53:29,586 --> 00:53:30,754 He erased it. 823 00:53:31,755 --> 00:53:33,381 What? Did you find something? 824 00:53:33,465 --> 00:53:35,133 Mrs. Gilbert, you really shouldn't be here. 825 00:53:35,217 --> 00:53:37,469 -Can you take her to the road? -[Mari] What did you find? 826 00:53:38,803 --> 00:53:39,888 Let go of me. 827 00:53:40,513 --> 00:53:41,681 What's in the bag? 828 00:53:42,265 --> 00:53:44,100 [officer] This one's not like the other four. 829 00:53:44,184 --> 00:53:46,019 Those were in the bramble a mile away. 830 00:53:46,561 --> 00:53:49,481 There's no burlap on this one, either, or hyoid bones. 831 00:53:52,025 --> 00:53:54,236 [Dormer] Any indication of a jaw plate? 832 00:53:54,319 --> 00:53:55,278 [officer] No, sir. 833 00:53:57,739 --> 00:53:59,199 [Dormer] Right. Let's go. 834 00:54:21,763 --> 00:54:25,767 [news reporter] Two dozen police recruits expanded the search for bodies today 835 00:54:25,850 --> 00:54:27,435 from the thicket to the beach. 836 00:54:27,519 --> 00:54:30,397 Suffolk County Police also expanded the total search area. 837 00:54:31,147 --> 00:54:34,859 This platoon of recruits conducted a grid-pattern search on Cedar Beach. 838 00:54:35,360 --> 00:54:38,905 It's between Gilgo and Oak Beach, where the previous bodies were found. 839 00:54:39,489 --> 00:54:41,574 Since last year, the search has been hampered 840 00:54:41,658 --> 00:54:43,827 by the harsh conditions in the thicket. 841 00:54:43,910 --> 00:54:48,081 Hard, wiry brush called Virginia Weepers and Bittersweet so thick, 842 00:54:48,164 --> 00:54:50,875 you cannot see a person or dog just ten feet away. 843 00:54:58,258 --> 00:54:59,884 [Mari] Dr. Peter Hackett. 844 00:55:03,054 --> 00:55:03,888 [door closes] 845 00:55:05,390 --> 00:55:06,391 Kim's working again. 846 00:55:07,392 --> 00:55:10,437 "Carolina" is her street name. She posted this an hour ago. 847 00:55:11,521 --> 00:55:12,856 [Mari] Oh, Kim. 848 00:55:12,939 --> 00:55:14,316 What is she thinking? 849 00:55:19,154 --> 00:55:20,322 [Dr. Hackett] I'm a busy guy. 850 00:55:20,780 --> 00:55:22,866 I make and take a lot of calls. 851 00:55:22,949 --> 00:55:26,328 But how would I call a woman I don't even know? 852 00:55:26,870 --> 00:55:27,912 I'm a doctor... 853 00:55:28,913 --> 00:55:30,040 not a magician. 854 00:55:33,626 --> 00:55:36,046 [sighs] She said that... 855 00:55:36,755 --> 00:55:39,716 that you told her that you helped her daughter. 856 00:55:39,799 --> 00:55:40,675 [Dr. Hackett chuckles] 857 00:55:41,217 --> 00:55:43,053 I hope she doesn't blame herself 858 00:55:44,179 --> 00:55:45,972 for the life her daughter led. 859 00:55:46,931 --> 00:55:48,099 But... 860 00:55:49,434 --> 00:55:51,770 apples don't fall far from the tree. 861 00:55:52,270 --> 00:55:53,605 [laughing] Am I right? 862 00:55:53,688 --> 00:55:54,647 [groans] 863 00:55:55,565 --> 00:55:56,399 [sighs] 864 00:55:57,067 --> 00:56:00,945 So, what do you remember from that night? 865 00:56:02,030 --> 00:56:06,117 I think that's when Barbara and I were in Florida. 866 00:56:07,243 --> 00:56:09,245 -[Dormer] Oh. -You ever been marlin fishing? 867 00:56:09,996 --> 00:56:10,997 But you were here. 868 00:56:11,748 --> 00:56:16,002 Because when the daughter's boyfriend came the next morning to look for her, 869 00:56:17,212 --> 00:56:19,589 didn't you offer to help search for her? 870 00:56:21,091 --> 00:56:23,426 Florida might have been... 871 00:56:24,677 --> 00:56:26,679 -the week before. -Oh, okay. 872 00:56:26,763 --> 00:56:30,016 That's right. I saw this kid tooling around, 873 00:56:30,100 --> 00:56:33,603 and he told me his story and I couldn't turn him away. 874 00:56:33,686 --> 00:56:36,189 That's what we do around here, we help people. 875 00:56:38,149 --> 00:56:41,778 [scoffs] With all due respect, Dr. Hackett, 876 00:56:42,862 --> 00:56:45,949 you're living in a gated community with a sign that says: 877 00:56:46,032 --> 00:56:47,826 "Be nice or leave." 878 00:56:49,077 --> 00:56:52,622 I don't know that that sends that particular message. 879 00:56:52,705 --> 00:56:55,083 Look... the police came. 880 00:56:55,166 --> 00:56:57,001 They said everything was kosher. 881 00:56:57,085 --> 00:56:57,919 Right. 882 00:56:59,671 --> 00:57:00,505 But... 883 00:57:02,132 --> 00:57:05,135 why didn't you show them the security footage? 884 00:57:05,718 --> 00:57:06,928 Why didn't they ask for it? 885 00:57:08,221 --> 00:57:10,682 This is not my investigation, kemosabe. 886 00:57:11,266 --> 00:57:12,851 You're the head honcho. 887 00:57:14,727 --> 00:57:16,563 Maybe you ought to teach your cops better. 888 00:57:18,565 --> 00:57:19,691 A girl goes missing 889 00:57:20,358 --> 00:57:21,526 and you have a tape. 890 00:57:23,862 --> 00:57:27,866 [scoffs] Are you telling me that you didn't at least watch it? 891 00:57:30,160 --> 00:57:32,245 That would be tampering with evidence. 892 00:57:33,997 --> 00:57:35,039 Am I right? 893 00:58:07,322 --> 00:58:09,949 [Joe] Peter Hackett is a self-important blowhard. 894 00:58:10,533 --> 00:58:13,578 The very fact that he's not leading the charge in this 895 00:58:13,661 --> 00:58:16,498 is all the evidence you need to point a finger. 896 00:58:17,040 --> 00:58:18,374 [Mari] Okay, if that's true, 897 00:58:18,458 --> 00:58:21,211 why wasn't Shannan found with the other girls? 898 00:58:21,294 --> 00:58:23,838 [Joe] 'Cause the attack on her didn't go as planned. 899 00:58:23,922 --> 00:58:25,173 She'd gone off running. 900 00:58:25,632 --> 00:58:27,759 People had seen her. The police came. 901 00:58:27,842 --> 00:58:29,844 It just became too risky. 902 00:58:29,928 --> 00:58:33,306 He tells people that he runs a home for wayward girls. 903 00:58:33,389 --> 00:58:36,017 That he rehabs them. That he saves them. 904 00:58:36,100 --> 00:58:38,353 What he really means is he buries them. 905 00:58:39,187 --> 00:58:41,898 He's got an examination table in his living room. 906 00:58:42,732 --> 00:58:45,026 And his "home for wayward girls" 907 00:58:45,109 --> 00:58:48,530 is really just code for "graveyard." 908 00:58:49,113 --> 00:58:50,031 Then where is Shannan? 909 00:58:51,908 --> 00:58:53,451 In his backyard. 910 00:58:54,118 --> 00:58:55,286 The marsh. 911 00:59:08,216 --> 00:59:10,510 It's the one place they haven't searched. 912 00:59:21,104 --> 00:59:22,605 [knocking on door, door opens] 913 00:59:26,859 --> 00:59:27,902 [detective clears throat] 914 00:59:28,444 --> 00:59:29,821 We found another one. 915 00:59:30,405 --> 00:59:32,490 Pieces, dismembered. 916 00:59:32,949 --> 00:59:35,034 Forensics says it matches a pair of severed legs 917 00:59:35,118 --> 00:59:36,703 found in a plastic bag in '96. 918 00:59:38,871 --> 00:59:40,748 -'96? -[detective] Yeah, '96. 919 00:59:41,791 --> 00:59:45,336 [scoffs] Are you telling me that somebody's been dumping bodies 920 00:59:45,420 --> 00:59:48,381 in Ocean Parkway for 15 fucking years? 921 00:59:48,965 --> 00:59:49,799 Well... 922 00:59:50,383 --> 00:59:51,759 it looks like it. 923 00:59:51,843 --> 00:59:53,720 Hey, what is this? 924 00:59:53,803 --> 00:59:56,514 Shannan Gilbert's medical records? Come on, seriously? 925 00:59:56,598 --> 01:00:00,059 You really think you're gonna find any answers in these medical records? 926 01:00:01,185 --> 01:00:04,480 Look, if she was still around, we would have found her by now. 927 01:00:05,315 --> 01:00:06,190 I mean, honestly, 928 01:00:06,274 --> 01:00:09,110 who spends this much time looking for a missing hooker? 929 01:00:18,828 --> 01:00:21,331 If you're here to give me some big speech, save it. 930 01:00:22,206 --> 01:00:23,791 I already heard it from the others. 931 01:00:26,002 --> 01:00:27,337 Kim, I know you're strong, 932 01:00:27,420 --> 01:00:30,632 and you think you can handle whatever comes your way, but... 933 01:00:31,674 --> 01:00:33,384 this is just plain stupid. 934 01:00:35,803 --> 01:00:37,805 Everyone has their destiny. 935 01:00:38,723 --> 01:00:41,434 Maybe Amber's was Amber's, and maybe this is mine. 936 01:00:44,854 --> 01:00:46,481 You don't really believe that. 937 01:00:49,525 --> 01:00:53,279 You're only doing this because deep down, you think that's all you're worth, 938 01:00:53,363 --> 01:00:55,573 -but that's not true. -[chuckles] 939 01:00:59,160 --> 01:01:00,453 You tell that to Shannan? 940 01:01:04,374 --> 01:01:07,627 [Mari sighs deeply] 941 01:01:10,004 --> 01:01:11,714 I got Amber into this, you know? 942 01:01:17,679 --> 01:01:18,554 You tried, Mari. 943 01:01:27,730 --> 01:01:29,732 -Here. -Thank you. 944 01:01:29,816 --> 01:01:33,069 Lynn's boyfriend knew a guy. We're all wearing them to the vigil. 945 01:01:36,030 --> 01:01:36,864 [door opens] 946 01:01:38,157 --> 01:01:39,784 -Turn on the TV. -Why? 947 01:01:40,910 --> 01:01:42,120 [Lorraine sighs shakily] 948 01:01:42,203 --> 01:01:44,789 [Dormer on TV] ...there's also no evidence to suggest 949 01:01:44,872 --> 01:01:47,625 that it's the work of a single killer. 950 01:01:48,167 --> 01:01:50,253 Although Shannan GIlbert 951 01:01:50,962 --> 01:01:54,173 coincidentally went missing at the same time in the same place, 952 01:01:54,257 --> 01:01:56,217 she doesn't fit the victim profile. 953 01:01:56,300 --> 01:01:59,011 She was the only one who didn't come to Oak Beach alone 954 01:01:59,095 --> 01:02:00,388 because she had a driver. 955 01:02:00,930 --> 01:02:01,764 [Sarra] Oh, God. 956 01:02:01,848 --> 01:02:04,142 [Dormer] We will continue to look for her, but... 957 01:02:04,225 --> 01:02:06,811 until we find evidence of foul play, 958 01:02:07,311 --> 01:02:10,189 Miss Gilbert will no longer be considered 959 01:02:10,273 --> 01:02:12,400 a part of this larger case. 960 01:02:12,483 --> 01:02:13,443 [reporter] Commissioner... 961 01:02:13,526 --> 01:02:15,278 -[Dormer] That's all for the moment. -Fuck! 962 01:02:20,783 --> 01:02:22,660 Yeah, this is Mari Gilbert... 963 01:02:24,454 --> 01:02:26,038 [Sherre] Hey, you okay? 964 01:02:27,623 --> 01:02:31,085 They stopped looking for Shannan. They're not looking for her anymore. 965 01:02:32,170 --> 01:02:34,088 -It's okay. -What are we gonna do? 966 01:02:34,881 --> 01:02:36,382 -Hey. -Why did they... 967 01:02:36,966 --> 01:02:38,092 That's why we're here. 968 01:02:39,844 --> 01:02:40,678 Okay? 969 01:02:41,721 --> 01:02:42,722 Yeah, right. 970 01:02:47,852 --> 01:02:49,687 -[Sarra sobs] -You're okay. 971 01:02:49,812 --> 01:02:51,355 [Sarra sobs quietly] 972 01:03:02,033 --> 01:03:03,284 [Dormer] I'll just be a minute. 973 01:03:07,622 --> 01:03:08,456 [house door opens] 974 01:03:10,124 --> 01:03:12,126 How can you say Shannan's not connected? 975 01:03:12,210 --> 01:03:14,420 She was last seen three miles from the other girls. 976 01:03:14,504 --> 01:03:16,756 She was in her 20s, just like them. 977 01:03:16,839 --> 01:03:18,341 She was small, just like them. 978 01:03:18,424 --> 01:03:20,927 She was on Craigslist, just like them. 979 01:03:21,010 --> 01:03:23,679 None of those other girls would've been found if it wasn't for her. 980 01:03:23,763 --> 01:03:26,057 It doesn't mean that we're gonna stop looking for her. 981 01:03:26,140 --> 01:03:27,934 -[Sherre] Mom! Mom! -What about Hackett? 982 01:03:28,017 --> 01:03:29,727 Even if he did call you, it... 983 01:03:30,436 --> 01:03:31,813 it's not evidence of guilt. 984 01:03:31,896 --> 01:03:33,397 Lying about it is. 985 01:03:33,481 --> 01:03:36,067 I understand that you're angry, Mrs. Gilbert, but... 986 01:03:36,859 --> 01:03:40,530 a policeman deals in evidence, not anger. 987 01:03:40,613 --> 01:03:42,907 Ha, ha! What fortune cookie did you read that in? 988 01:03:42,990 --> 01:03:44,450 [Sherre] Mom, hurry. They're waiting. 989 01:03:44,534 --> 01:03:45,993 Give me a minute! 990 01:03:48,329 --> 01:03:49,163 [Mari sighs] 991 01:03:54,919 --> 01:03:56,754 [Mari] You have no idea, you know, 992 01:03:57,338 --> 01:03:59,882 no clue what worry really is. 993 01:04:00,466 --> 01:04:03,177 [Dormer] We have Shannan's medical records. 994 01:04:04,470 --> 01:04:05,805 Yeah? What do they say? 995 01:04:10,101 --> 01:04:11,853 I'll tell you what they don't say. 996 01:04:12,979 --> 01:04:16,148 They don't say how she used to shove her fingers down her throat 997 01:04:16,232 --> 01:04:17,984 and puke until her mouth bled. 998 01:04:18,484 --> 01:04:21,153 They don't say how she ran out into the snow one night 999 01:04:21,237 --> 01:04:24,031 with no clothes on and nearly froze half to death 1000 01:04:24,115 --> 01:04:27,785 while I was out working graveyards and doubles just to keep the lights on. 1001 01:04:28,578 --> 01:04:32,665 [Dormer] Yeah. Look, Mari, I know that you gave her away to foster care, 1002 01:04:32,748 --> 01:04:36,085 and I know you think it's your responsibility to bring her home again. 1003 01:04:36,168 --> 01:04:38,170 But this isn't on you. 1004 01:04:39,797 --> 01:04:41,007 I'm her mother. 1005 01:04:42,466 --> 01:04:43,634 It's all on me. 1006 01:04:47,179 --> 01:04:49,181 [door opens and shuts] 1007 01:04:52,768 --> 01:04:54,770 [Mari sighs deeply] 1008 01:04:57,189 --> 01:04:58,566 You gave her away? 1009 01:04:58,649 --> 01:05:02,361 Oh, for fuck's sake, Sherre, can we not do this right now? 1010 01:05:03,696 --> 01:05:04,780 You lied to me. 1011 01:05:05,448 --> 01:05:06,908 I didn't lie. 1012 01:05:06,991 --> 01:05:09,827 You told me the state took her. 1013 01:05:13,581 --> 01:05:15,082 What was I supposed to say? 1014 01:05:16,125 --> 01:05:17,585 "Mommy gave your sister away 1015 01:05:17,668 --> 01:05:19,879 because she couldn't get her the help she needed." 1016 01:05:20,421 --> 01:05:22,465 Do you think I wanted that for Shannan? 1017 01:05:22,548 --> 01:05:25,176 Do you think I didn't try to do everything in my power 1018 01:05:25,259 --> 01:05:26,886 to get her the help she needed? 1019 01:05:29,263 --> 01:05:30,973 Shannan was bipolar. 1020 01:05:31,057 --> 01:05:32,516 She was a mess. 1021 01:05:33,100 --> 01:05:35,353 I took her to doctors I couldn't afford 1022 01:05:35,436 --> 01:05:37,396 who gave her drugs that she wouldn't take 1023 01:05:37,480 --> 01:05:40,566 that had side-effects that I couldn't stand to watch. 1024 01:05:42,234 --> 01:05:43,653 I was just a kid. 1025 01:05:47,406 --> 01:05:48,824 What she needed was love. 1026 01:05:50,451 --> 01:05:52,912 It was the only thing she ever wanted her whole... 1027 01:05:54,038 --> 01:05:55,164 fucking life. 1028 01:05:56,040 --> 01:05:58,292 Okay, but how do you know what she felt? 1029 01:05:58,376 --> 01:06:00,211 [Sherre] Because I feel it too, Mom. 1030 01:06:02,088 --> 01:06:04,966 Shannan may be gone but I'm still here. 1031 01:06:07,551 --> 01:06:08,970 I'm still here. 1032 01:06:11,973 --> 01:06:13,182 Oh, my God. 1033 01:06:13,265 --> 01:06:15,518 These fucking women, they've brainwashed you. 1034 01:06:16,394 --> 01:06:18,854 You wanna know why they're so dead set on this vigil? 1035 01:06:19,689 --> 01:06:20,982 It's their way of denying 1036 01:06:21,065 --> 01:06:23,025 what god-awful mothers and sisters they were. 1037 01:06:23,109 --> 01:06:25,820 They've convinced you that we are like them, but we are not, honey. 1038 01:06:25,903 --> 01:06:27,238 We are nothing like them. 1039 01:06:28,698 --> 01:06:29,573 You're right. 1040 01:06:30,282 --> 01:06:31,367 [gulps] 1041 01:06:33,202 --> 01:06:34,829 No, we're not like them at all. 1042 01:06:36,539 --> 01:06:37,415 They're a family. 1043 01:06:38,207 --> 01:06:39,291 [inhales sharply] 1044 01:06:41,127 --> 01:06:42,503 I wish they were my family. 1045 01:06:42,586 --> 01:06:45,214 Okay. Well, maybe your new family will pay for your college 1046 01:06:45,297 --> 01:06:47,425 because I sure as shit can't afford it. 1047 01:06:50,428 --> 01:06:52,430 Are you gonna give away Sarra next? 1048 01:06:54,348 --> 01:06:55,182 Hmm? 1049 01:07:01,564 --> 01:07:06,402 [vigil members] ♪ Amazing grace ♪ 1050 01:07:06,485 --> 01:07:11,490 ♪ How sweet the sound ♪ 1051 01:07:12,283 --> 01:07:19,123 ♪ That saved a wretch like me ♪ 1052 01:07:21,500 --> 01:07:26,714 ♪ I once was lost ♪ 1053 01:07:26,797 --> 01:07:31,844 ♪ But now I'm found ♪ 1054 01:07:32,511 --> 01:07:35,264 ♪ Was blind ♪ 1055 01:07:35,347 --> 01:07:41,228 ♪ But now I see ♪ 1056 01:07:43,105 --> 01:07:48,319 [humming "Amazing Grace"] 1057 01:07:55,076 --> 01:07:56,202 [sniffles] 1058 01:07:56,911 --> 01:08:01,332 [girl humming "Amazing Grace"] 1059 01:08:14,345 --> 01:08:15,179 [sighs] 1060 01:08:15,763 --> 01:08:17,264 [knocking on door] 1061 01:08:30,486 --> 01:08:31,654 [laughs] 1062 01:08:34,240 --> 01:08:35,241 You're leaving now? 1063 01:08:37,201 --> 01:08:38,035 Yeah. 1064 01:08:43,499 --> 01:08:44,333 Goodbye. 1065 01:08:45,876 --> 01:08:46,836 [sniffs] 1066 01:09:02,476 --> 01:09:03,310 [Kim sniffles] 1067 01:09:06,730 --> 01:09:08,190 [sniffs, laughs] 1068 01:09:08,274 --> 01:09:09,859 Take care of your girls, okay? 1069 01:09:12,403 --> 01:09:14,655 You're lucky, you know? 1070 01:09:20,077 --> 01:09:20,911 [sighs] 1071 01:09:25,875 --> 01:09:27,877 [Mari sighs shakily] 1072 01:09:35,718 --> 01:09:38,179 [voicemail] This is Shannan. I can't answer my phone right now 1073 01:09:38,262 --> 01:09:40,472 because I'm doing something way more fun. 1074 01:09:40,556 --> 01:09:41,390 [voicemail beeps] 1075 01:09:58,657 --> 01:10:01,702 [rain pattering] 1076 01:10:38,113 --> 01:10:39,782 You can be a real asshole, you know that? 1077 01:10:42,326 --> 01:10:44,036 But you're an asshole people listen to. 1078 01:10:45,204 --> 01:10:47,539 And if they don't, you make 'em. 1079 01:10:50,459 --> 01:10:51,794 I don't got what you got. 1080 01:10:55,130 --> 01:10:57,383 Neither does she, or her, or any of us. 1081 01:10:57,925 --> 01:11:00,302 We was never gonna be Mother of the Year, but... 1082 01:11:03,222 --> 01:11:04,848 given the circumstances... 1083 01:11:07,559 --> 01:11:08,686 you get my vote. 1084 01:11:21,949 --> 01:11:25,661 [Sarra sobbing] 1085 01:12:11,665 --> 01:12:14,752 [young Shannan over TV] ♪ Beautiful dreamer ♪ 1086 01:12:14,835 --> 01:12:18,005 ♪ Out on the sea ♪ 1087 01:12:18,088 --> 01:12:23,427 ♪ Mermaids are chanting The wild Lorelei ♪ 1088 01:12:23,844 --> 01:12:26,805 ♪ Over the streamlet ♪ 1089 01:12:26,889 --> 01:12:29,850 ♪ Vapors are born ♪ 1090 01:12:29,933 --> 01:12:36,023 ♪ Waiting to fade At the bright coming morn ♪ 1091 01:12:36,106 --> 01:12:38,525 ♪ Beautiful dreamer ♪ 1092 01:12:38,609 --> 01:12:41,570 ♪ Beam on my heart... ♪ 1093 01:13:30,411 --> 01:13:34,832 [phone ringing] 1094 01:13:34,915 --> 01:13:36,417 -[Mari] Hello? -[man] Is this Mari? 1095 01:13:37,251 --> 01:13:38,752 -Yes. -It's Joe Scalise. 1096 01:13:39,545 --> 01:13:40,629 From Oak Beach. 1097 01:13:41,505 --> 01:13:44,049 Dr. Hackett put his house up for sale. 1098 01:13:44,133 --> 01:13:46,385 [sighs] Well, great. Call Robin Leach. 1099 01:13:47,302 --> 01:13:49,054 [Joe] His car is already packed. 1100 01:13:49,680 --> 01:13:51,056 He's gonna disappear. 1101 01:13:51,974 --> 01:13:55,144 If you ever want to talk to him, this could be your last chance. 1102 01:14:23,046 --> 01:14:24,381 [Dr. Hackett] You wanna talk? 1103 01:14:24,923 --> 01:14:26,091 Talk. 1104 01:14:26,550 --> 01:14:29,386 You've already upended my life. 1105 01:14:30,888 --> 01:14:32,973 You're implying I chased after this girl. 1106 01:14:33,056 --> 01:14:35,517 I can't catch up to myself walking backwards. 1107 01:14:37,269 --> 01:14:41,648 [kettle whistling] 1108 01:14:41,732 --> 01:14:43,650 -Yes, but-- -[Dr. Hackett] When I was young, 1109 01:14:44,276 --> 01:14:47,613 I was... stranded on a skiff... 1110 01:14:49,114 --> 01:14:49,948 in the water... 1111 01:14:50,782 --> 01:14:51,783 in the dark. 1112 01:14:54,578 --> 01:14:55,704 I was all alone 1113 01:14:55,787 --> 01:14:58,749 and scared I was... gonna die. 1114 01:14:59,500 --> 01:15:00,709 Then I saw this boat. 1115 01:15:02,252 --> 01:15:04,546 It was far away, but... 1116 01:15:05,506 --> 01:15:07,007 I sent up a flare, 1117 01:15:08,091 --> 01:15:09,426 and they came to save me. 1118 01:15:11,595 --> 01:15:12,763 The next day, 1119 01:15:13,722 --> 01:15:16,642 I enrolled in emergency medicine. 1120 01:15:17,851 --> 01:15:18,769 [sighs] 1121 01:15:20,562 --> 01:15:23,023 Ever since, my specialty has been... 1122 01:15:24,983 --> 01:15:26,193 saving lives. 1123 01:15:29,112 --> 01:15:31,198 If she's out there, we gotta find her. 1124 01:15:35,911 --> 01:15:37,287 You're the real hero. 1125 01:15:39,206 --> 01:15:41,542 A mother who would go to any lengths 1126 01:15:42,709 --> 01:15:43,752 for her daughter. 1127 01:15:46,922 --> 01:15:49,341 That is true heroism. 1128 01:15:56,223 --> 01:15:57,558 -[door shuts] -[Dormer] Oh. 1129 01:15:58,559 --> 01:15:59,643 Mrs. Gilbert. 1130 01:16:02,229 --> 01:16:03,564 Nice to see you again. 1131 01:16:04,648 --> 01:16:07,109 [Mari] Don't worry. I left my staple gun at home. 1132 01:16:07,192 --> 01:16:08,026 [chuckles] 1133 01:16:08,735 --> 01:16:10,112 So how did you get in my office? 1134 01:16:11,154 --> 01:16:12,781 It's not your office anymore. 1135 01:16:13,448 --> 01:16:15,158 True. True. 1136 01:16:16,785 --> 01:16:20,831 Yeah, they're putting me out to pasture, as they say. 1137 01:16:20,914 --> 01:16:23,333 What do you think you'll be most remembered for? 1138 01:16:24,334 --> 01:16:25,877 What can I help you with? 1139 01:16:29,339 --> 01:16:30,882 Why haven't you searched the marsh? 1140 01:16:31,758 --> 01:16:34,595 It's the only place in Oak Beach you haven't searched. 1141 01:16:34,678 --> 01:16:37,931 Because a grown man can't get through there, 1142 01:16:38,015 --> 01:16:40,559 never mind a 100-pound girl. 1143 01:16:40,642 --> 01:16:43,604 Yeah, but it borders Anchor Way where Shannan was last seen, 1144 01:16:43,687 --> 01:16:46,023 and Larboard Court where Peter Hackett lives. 1145 01:16:46,106 --> 01:16:48,775 Ah, so this is about Hackett. 1146 01:16:49,401 --> 01:16:51,570 We've already cleared him. 1147 01:16:51,653 --> 01:16:53,947 What... You gotta talk to Joe Scalise. 1148 01:16:54,031 --> 01:16:57,868 Joe Scalise is a paranoid conspiracy freak. 1149 01:16:57,951 --> 01:16:59,536 He and Hackett hate each other. 1150 01:16:59,620 --> 01:17:01,830 Some dispute they had years ago over land. 1151 01:17:02,414 --> 01:17:03,665 He wants to bury Hackett. 1152 01:17:03,749 --> 01:17:05,083 Maybe he's giving you the shovel. 1153 01:17:06,001 --> 01:17:07,544 What about her jacket? 1154 01:17:08,170 --> 01:17:11,965 If Hackett had contact with Shannan, her jacket would prove it. 1155 01:17:12,049 --> 01:17:14,926 It would have skin cells or fibers on it or something. 1156 01:17:17,971 --> 01:17:19,306 We don't have the jacket. 1157 01:17:20,557 --> 01:17:23,060 When they first picked it up, Shannan wasn't officially missing 1158 01:17:23,143 --> 01:17:24,853 and it got lost. 1159 01:17:27,731 --> 01:17:31,193 What is this, some kind of cover-up or just incompetence? 1160 01:17:31,777 --> 01:17:33,987 Search the marsh or I'm going on the news. 1161 01:17:39,034 --> 01:17:40,202 [door bangs shut] 1162 01:17:40,285 --> 01:17:44,831 ["Juicy Fruit (Disco Freak)" playing] 1163 01:18:21,785 --> 01:18:24,579 [news reporter] A year ago, the police first discovered the remains 1164 01:18:24,663 --> 01:18:28,625 of three bodies dumped along the side of the road off Ocean Park-- 1165 01:18:29,126 --> 01:18:33,755 [sirens wailing] 1166 01:18:52,566 --> 01:18:54,443 -What's happening? -They're draining the marsh, 1167 01:18:55,110 --> 01:18:56,570 looking for that hooker. 1168 01:18:57,154 --> 01:18:58,572 -[sighs] -[Lorraine] Mari! 1169 01:18:59,448 --> 01:19:00,282 Lorraine. 1170 01:19:02,701 --> 01:19:05,954 -What are you doing here? -I came for the anniversary vigil. 1171 01:19:06,413 --> 01:19:07,956 The others are on their way. 1172 01:19:08,039 --> 01:19:09,124 Hey, don't worry. 1173 01:19:09,708 --> 01:19:12,377 We're not gonna let you go through this alone. All right? 1174 01:19:14,087 --> 01:19:16,089 [news reporter] Heavy equipment, including a backhoe, 1175 01:19:16,173 --> 01:19:18,759 were brought in to dig through the thick brush and marsh. 1176 01:19:18,842 --> 01:19:21,136 The commissioner says the area was too tough 1177 01:19:21,219 --> 01:19:23,305 for the searchers to get through on foot. 1178 01:19:24,473 --> 01:19:27,726 Here in Oak Beach, missing sex worker, Shannan Gilbert, 1179 01:19:27,809 --> 01:19:30,645 was last seen alive leaving a client's house. 1180 01:19:31,021 --> 01:19:33,231 [male reporter] During the search for Shannan Gilbert last year, 1181 01:19:33,315 --> 01:19:35,025 four other bodies were discovered. 1182 01:19:35,108 --> 01:19:39,362 There are now ten sets of remains, half of whom are still unidentified. 1183 01:19:39,446 --> 01:19:41,907 [female reporter] According to the police, Shannan Gilbert's disappearance 1184 01:19:41,990 --> 01:19:43,366 is unrelated to those. 1185 01:19:43,450 --> 01:19:46,036 [Dormer] We believe that Shannan Gilbert ran into that area 1186 01:19:46,119 --> 01:19:47,579 the night she disappeared. 1187 01:19:47,662 --> 01:19:49,039 She's in there someplace, 1188 01:19:49,122 --> 01:19:51,833 and we're going to do everything we can to find her. 1189 01:19:57,756 --> 01:19:59,800 [Mari] Thanks, Missy. Yeah, I owe you. 1190 01:19:59,883 --> 01:20:01,176 [breathes shakily] 1191 01:20:01,259 --> 01:20:02,803 Okay, see you soon. 1192 01:20:02,886 --> 01:20:05,680 [sighs] Missy's gonna pick up the girls on her way. 1193 01:20:07,933 --> 01:20:09,476 Your hands are shaking. 1194 01:20:11,436 --> 01:20:14,689 They say not knowing is worse than knowing, but I'm not so sure. 1195 01:20:16,107 --> 01:20:17,275 And if they find her, 1196 01:20:17,984 --> 01:20:19,236 I know she's gone, 1197 01:20:20,111 --> 01:20:21,446 but I'll still be angry. 1198 01:20:23,824 --> 01:20:25,242 And if they don't find her, 1199 01:20:27,202 --> 01:20:28,036 I have hope. 1200 01:20:31,373 --> 01:20:32,916 Yeah, but you're still angry. 1201 01:20:35,168 --> 01:20:36,795 How do I get rid of the anger? 1202 01:20:38,338 --> 01:20:39,965 Well, you stop blaming yourself. 1203 01:20:41,675 --> 01:20:42,926 It's not your fault. 1204 01:20:43,677 --> 01:20:44,511 Yeah? 1205 01:20:45,011 --> 01:20:47,722 -[man 1] I think we got something! -[man 2] What do you got down there? 1206 01:20:47,806 --> 01:20:48,932 [men shouting] 1207 01:20:49,015 --> 01:20:51,935 -[man 1] Get a camera down here! -[man 2] Rope this off right now! 1208 01:20:52,018 --> 01:20:54,145 -[man 1] Over there. -[man 2] We gonna need a cradle? 1209 01:20:54,229 --> 01:20:56,231 [men shouting indistinctly] 1210 01:21:03,321 --> 01:21:07,033 [panting] 1211 01:21:15,625 --> 01:21:16,668 [Mari] What did they find? 1212 01:21:18,086 --> 01:21:20,171 -I'll call you back. -[Mari] Show me! No... 1213 01:21:20,255 --> 01:21:22,340 -[Dormer] Let her through. -[Mari] Get the fuck out of my way! 1214 01:21:22,424 --> 01:21:24,050 -What did they find? -Let her through. 1215 01:21:24,593 --> 01:21:26,720 What's over there? What's over there? 1216 01:21:26,803 --> 01:21:28,054 What is it? 1217 01:21:28,138 --> 01:21:31,308 Tell me right now, goddamn it! What did you find? 1218 01:21:31,766 --> 01:21:32,893 [crying] Please! 1219 01:21:44,487 --> 01:21:45,363 [Dormer] Officer. 1220 01:21:50,243 --> 01:21:51,369 [Mari inhales sharply] 1221 01:21:54,998 --> 01:21:55,874 [sighs] 1222 01:22:03,214 --> 01:22:04,132 [Mari sighs] 1223 01:22:07,010 --> 01:22:07,844 [sighs] 1224 01:22:54,724 --> 01:22:56,226 -[Mari cries] -Hey... 1225 01:23:01,189 --> 01:23:02,190 [Mari sobs] 1226 01:23:03,066 --> 01:23:03,900 I'm sorry. 1227 01:23:07,779 --> 01:23:08,655 [Mari sobs] 1228 01:23:11,408 --> 01:23:12,784 [sobs] 1229 01:23:15,036 --> 01:23:16,746 [both sobbing] 1230 01:24:05,754 --> 01:24:07,589 [Mari sobs] 1231 01:24:18,099 --> 01:24:19,642 [Mari sobs quietly] 1232 01:24:22,896 --> 01:24:24,439 [sniffles] 1233 01:24:26,399 --> 01:24:27,984 I'm gonna take you home. 1234 01:24:36,242 --> 01:24:37,202 [sniffles] 1235 01:25:13,530 --> 01:25:15,782 [Mari] As much as today is about Shannan, 1236 01:25:15,865 --> 01:25:17,325 it's not just about Shannan. 1237 01:25:17,408 --> 01:25:19,035 It's about all of us... 1238 01:25:19,828 --> 01:25:23,581 every one of us and our friends and family that were affected by this. 1239 01:25:28,878 --> 01:25:30,421 The police failed us. 1240 01:25:31,047 --> 01:25:33,299 They failed every one of our girls. 1241 01:25:34,384 --> 01:25:37,137 They failed to keep them safe when they were at risk. 1242 01:25:37,220 --> 01:25:40,056 They failed to take their disappearances seriously, 1243 01:25:40,140 --> 01:25:43,476 and they failed to go after the people who took advantage of our girls. 1244 01:25:43,560 --> 01:25:45,520 Some of them may even be those people. 1245 01:25:46,646 --> 01:25:47,814 And they ignored me, 1246 01:25:47,897 --> 01:25:50,733 just like they ignored Shannan the night she called for help 1247 01:25:50,817 --> 01:25:52,777 and waited an hour for them to arrive. 1248 01:26:01,077 --> 01:26:06,040 Why are our girls to blame at the exclusion of everybody else? 1249 01:26:08,126 --> 01:26:11,713 It's time for accountability, and I'm starting with myself. 1250 01:26:30,481 --> 01:26:31,316 [sighs] 1251 01:26:37,780 --> 01:26:38,781 Let's go home. 1252 01:26:44,078 --> 01:26:46,080 [engine starts] 1253 01:27:36,923 --> 01:27:39,801 This is why we're here. This is my daughter, Shannan. 1254 01:27:40,468 --> 01:27:43,304 And she won't be forgotten. 1255 01:27:43,388 --> 01:27:45,223 She never will be forgotten. 1256 01:27:45,306 --> 01:27:47,517 And we are gonna continue to fight 1257 01:27:48,768 --> 01:27:50,520 as long as we need to... 1258 01:27:51,896 --> 01:27:52,981 until... 1259 01:27:54,107 --> 01:27:56,442 justice is done for our daughter. 1260 01:27:58,987 --> 01:28:03,616 ♪ Morning calls with whispers in my ears ♪ 1261 01:28:04,659 --> 01:28:09,163 ♪ I believe the spirit is near ♪ 1262 01:28:09,789 --> 01:28:14,544 ♪ Days go quiet and disappear ♪ 1263 01:28:15,753 --> 01:28:19,799 ♪ Darkness knows the truth, I fear ♪ 1264 01:28:20,883 --> 01:28:25,054 ♪ God knows I've tried to stay strong ♪ 1265 01:28:25,680 --> 01:28:30,351 ♪ I swear to God, I swear in vain ♪ 1266 01:28:31,436 --> 01:28:35,982 ♪ Been raging and angry for so long ♪ 1267 01:28:36,983 --> 01:28:41,237 ♪ Alone with all my pain ♪ 1268 01:28:43,281 --> 01:28:47,660 ♪ Only to give you a sweet beginning ♪ 1269 01:28:47,744 --> 01:28:52,749 ♪ But no matter how hard I try ♪ 1270 01:28:54,125 --> 01:28:58,296 ♪ I find myself on the losing end ♪ 1271 01:28:58,379 --> 01:29:04,761 ♪ Of all the trouble I'd in life ♪ 1272 01:29:05,428 --> 01:29:09,515 ♪ You are missing, I am haunted ♪ 1273 01:29:09,599 --> 01:29:14,854 ♪ You're broken, but I am fearless ♪ 1274 01:29:16,481 --> 01:29:20,443 ♪ Are you listening? 'Cause you are wanted ♪ 1275 01:29:20,526 --> 01:29:26,199 ♪ You've spoken, and I have heard ♪ 1276 01:29:48,262 --> 01:29:53,059 ♪ In my dreams, I see you ♪ 1277 01:29:54,519 --> 01:29:58,189 ♪ And it seems you can see me too ♪ 1278 01:29:59,440 --> 01:30:03,903 ♪ In my dreams, I feel you ♪ 1279 01:30:05,363 --> 01:30:09,492 ♪ And it seems you can feel me too ♪ 1280 01:30:10,535 --> 01:30:13,621 ♪ I will search for you ♪ 1281 01:30:13,704 --> 01:30:16,290 ♪ Through the wind and the rain ♪ 1282 01:30:16,374 --> 01:30:21,295 ♪ I may bend, but I will never break ♪ 1283 01:30:22,213 --> 01:30:24,715 ♪ And if it hurts forever ♪ 1284 01:30:24,799 --> 01:30:27,844 ♪ I will live through the pain ♪ 1285 01:30:27,927 --> 01:30:32,890 ♪ I will fall with the burden Stand in its place ♪ 1286 01:30:34,100 --> 01:30:38,729 ♪ I'll look for you on every corner ♪ 1287 01:30:38,813 --> 01:30:43,985 ♪ On every street I walk down ♪ 1288 01:30:45,695 --> 01:30:49,740 ♪ I will never give up hoping ♪ 1289 01:30:49,824 --> 01:30:55,329 ♪ That one day you will be found ♪ 1290 01:30:56,456 --> 01:31:00,793 ♪ I know I made some bad decisions ♪ 1291 01:31:00,877 --> 01:31:05,339 ♪ And I got so much wrong ♪ 1292 01:31:07,592 --> 01:31:11,387 ♪ Now I need your forgiveness ♪ 1293 01:31:11,471 --> 01:31:16,392 ♪ 'Cause I'm coming to take you home ♪ 1294 01:32:23,918 --> 01:32:28,673 ♪ In the shadows of a wicked world ♪ 1295 01:32:28,756 --> 01:32:33,177 ♪ Spinning without a sun ♪ 1296 01:32:34,971 --> 01:32:38,933 ♪ Maybe I was just another lost girl ♪ 1297 01:32:39,559 --> 01:32:44,730 ♪ Dying to be found ♪ 1298 01:32:45,690 --> 01:32:51,028 ♪ In the shadows of a wicked world ♪ 1299 01:32:51,112 --> 01:32:54,073 ♪ Looking for you ♪ 1300 01:32:56,576 --> 01:33:02,790 ♪ Maybe I was just another lost girl too ♪ 1301 01:33:07,545 --> 01:33:12,174 ♪ In the shadows of a wicked world ♪ 1302 01:33:12,258 --> 01:33:16,554 ♪ Spinning without a sun ♪ 1303 01:33:18,389 --> 01:33:23,060 ♪ Maybe I was just another lost girl ♪ 1304 01:33:23,144 --> 01:33:28,065 ♪ Dying to be found ♪ 1305 01:33:29,317 --> 01:33:33,904 ♪ Maybe I was just another lost girl ♪ 1306 01:33:34,822 --> 01:33:39,035 ♪ Dying to be found ♪ 1307 01:33:40,286 --> 01:33:44,874 ♪ Maybe I was just another lost girl ♪ 1308 01:33:45,374 --> 01:33:50,755 ♪ Dying to be found ♪