1
00:00:59,025 --> 00:01:01,068
Mom...

2
00:01:22,358 --> 00:01:24,401
I love you, Libby.

3
00:01:26,192 --> 00:01:28,484
I love you, ladybug.

4
00:01:28,733 --> 00:01:31,026
Don't you ever forget that.

5
00:01:56,025 --> 00:02:01,401
Libby, what you're about to tell us
is very, very important.

6
00:02:02,858 --> 00:02:05,776
Did Ben kill your mom and your sisters?

7
00:02:09,316 --> 00:02:11,442
You were in the house when it happened.

8
00:02:14,441 --> 00:02:19,901
So tell us. It was Ben.
He killed them, right?

9
00:02:24,858 --> 00:02:26,984
<i>I have a meanness inside me.</i>

10
00:02:28,358 --> 00:02:30,234
<i>Real as an organ.</i>

11
00:02:30,858 --> 00:02:32,925
<i>It's the Day blood.</i>

12
00:02:33,025 --> 00:02:35,609
<i>Something's fuckin' wrong with it.</i>

13
00:02:36,941 --> 00:02:40,526
<i>I was eight the night they were killed
and suddenly I was famous.</i>

14
00:02:40,858 --> 00:02:44,692
<i>The little orphan girl
of the Kansas Prairie Massacre.</i>

15
00:02:47,733 --> 00:02:52,067
<i>So, strangers send me money.
Just enough for me to do nothing.</i>

16
00:02:52,525 --> 00:02:54,651
<i>Which was exactly what I did.</i>

17
00:02:56,275 --> 00:02:58,026
How much is left?

18
00:02:58,400 --> 00:03:00,776
Do you read the reports I send you?

19
00:03:02,191 --> 00:03:03,859
Sometimes.

20
00:03:04,025 --> 00:03:06,966
Have you at least listened
to my messages?

21
00:03:07,066 --> 00:03:08,175
How much?

22
00:03:08,275 --> 00:03:12,234
There is $482 and 12 cents
left in your fund.

23
00:03:13,191 --> 00:03:15,359
- Now as I have mentioned before...
- Jesus.

24
00:03:15,691 --> 00:03:19,591
...had you been able to replenish it
with any kind of regular income,

25
00:03:19,691 --> 00:03:21,609
we'd have been able to keep it afloat.

26
00:03:21,733 --> 00:03:24,609
You're also two months behind
on your rent.

27
00:03:30,191 --> 00:03:34,026
What about the book?
That should have made more money.

28
00:03:34,150 --> 00:03:36,425
- I know.
- Any new donations?

29
00:03:36,525 --> 00:03:38,175
Thirtieth anniversary is coming up...
You know, I could...

30
00:03:38,275 --> 00:03:41,026
People have short
attention spans, Libby.

31
00:03:41,191 --> 00:03:44,151
And there's always
a new murder, I'm afraid.

32
00:03:44,275 --> 00:03:45,966
They want to help other little girls.

33
00:03:46,066 --> 00:03:49,484
And the truth is,
you're not a little girl anymore.

34
00:03:59,358 --> 00:04:01,234
I'm not ready for this.

35
00:04:02,400 --> 00:04:04,091
But in a way,

36
00:04:04,191 --> 00:04:08,067
it could turn out to be
a blessing in disguise.

37
00:04:09,150 --> 00:04:12,317
And lead you into an exciting
new phase of your life.

38
00:04:14,775 --> 00:04:16,984
What do you want to be when you grow up?

39
00:04:17,650 --> 00:04:19,692
Are you fucking kidding me?

40
00:04:27,525 --> 00:04:32,026
<i>In the past Jim Jeffries used to hand me
bulging shoe boxes full of mail.</i>

41
00:04:33,108 --> 00:04:36,109
<i>Most of them letters with checks inside.</i>

42
00:04:38,441 --> 00:04:43,359
<i>In return, donors would receive a form
letter in my blocky handwriting that read...</i>

43
00:04:43,650 --> 00:04:45,966
<i>"Thank you for your donation.</i>

44
00:04:46,066 --> 00:04:51,234
<i>"It's people like you who let me
look forward to a brighter future.</i>

45
00:04:51,358 --> 00:04:54,567
<i>"Yours truly, Libby Day."</i>

46
00:05:15,149 --> 00:05:16,692
<i>Hello?</i>

47
00:05:17,691 --> 00:05:20,299
- <i>Hello?</i>
- Is this Lyle Wirth?

48
00:05:20,399 --> 00:05:22,317
<i>Yeah, who's asking?</i>

49
00:05:24,608 --> 00:05:27,067
It's Libby Day, you wrote me.

50
00:05:27,191 --> 00:05:32,109
<i>Oh, holy cow! Really?
Libby Day? Are you in town?</i>

51
00:05:32,983 --> 00:05:34,674
What do you mean, which town?

52
00:05:34,774 --> 00:05:37,359
<i>Well, you're in Kansas City,
that's where you live, right?</i>

53
00:05:39,191 --> 00:05:40,734
<i>Hello?</i>

54
00:05:41,941 --> 00:05:43,484
<i>Hello?</i>

55
00:05:44,899 --> 00:05:49,109
Yeah, I live in Kansas City.
Listen, your offer, is it serious?

56
00:05:54,149 --> 00:05:56,817
<i>Lyle Wirth looked like a serial killer.</i>

57
00:05:57,024 --> 00:05:59,091
<i>Which probably meant he wasn't one.</i>

58
00:05:59,191 --> 00:06:00,817
Lyle?

59
00:06:02,233 --> 00:06:03,692
Libby?

60
00:06:03,816 --> 00:06:06,317
Yeah, what?
You were expecting someone else?

61
00:06:08,358 --> 00:06:10,216
Libby Day.

62
00:06:10,316 --> 00:06:14,025
- I'm so excited to finally meet you...
- Okay, just fucking relax.

63
00:06:16,233 --> 00:06:20,008
- There's no reason to be scared.
- I'm not scared of you.

64
00:06:20,108 --> 00:06:22,900
I'm just trying to figure out what kind
of a person wants to meet in a laundromat

65
00:06:23,024 --> 00:06:25,025
in the middle of the fucking night.

66
00:06:25,149 --> 00:06:27,442
Oh, no, it's not what you think.
I own this place.

67
00:06:27,566 --> 00:06:30,442
I own two of them. I'm an entrepreneur.

68
00:06:31,566 --> 00:06:33,966
- Can I offer you something?
- Like what?

69
00:06:34,066 --> 00:06:36,091
- Detergent?
- I was thinking maybe a coffee...

70
00:06:36,191 --> 00:06:38,775
- Just take a fucking step back, man!
- Sorry.

71
00:06:38,899 --> 00:06:41,525
- What is it with you and personal space?
- All right.

72
00:06:45,483 --> 00:06:47,109
Tell me about this club.

73
00:06:47,233 --> 00:06:49,799
You know how some guys
collect baseball cards?

74
00:06:49,899 --> 00:06:53,591
Or women who read gossip magazines
and know everything about some celebrity.

75
00:06:53,691 --> 00:06:56,174
Like their baby's name or the town
where they grew up?

76
00:06:56,274 --> 00:06:59,275
You know, this is like that,
only it's about murders.

77
00:07:00,441 --> 00:07:02,067
We call it the Kill Club.

78
00:07:03,441 --> 00:07:07,109
- It's not as weird as it sounds.
- It sounds pretty fucking weird.

79
00:07:07,233 --> 00:07:10,758
It's like a bunch of people
who like true crimes and mysteries.

80
00:07:10,858 --> 00:07:13,484
You know, everyone has a case
that they are passionate about.

81
00:07:13,608 --> 00:07:17,442
You and your family are very special.
Huge with the club.

82
00:07:18,941 --> 00:07:21,650
I mean, it's a real tragedy
what happened.

83
00:07:22,149 --> 00:07:25,192
Your brother in jail, going on 28 years.

84
00:07:26,774 --> 00:07:28,216
Look...

85
00:07:28,316 --> 00:07:31,591
if you and your little club
want to convince me that Ben's innocent,

86
00:07:31,691 --> 00:07:35,008
- you're wasting your time.
- Just come along, it's like a...

87
00:07:35,108 --> 00:07:37,109
like a convention.

88
00:07:39,941 --> 00:07:42,424
- How much?
- Five hundred dollars.

89
00:07:42,524 --> 00:07:46,192
And there'll be a lot of collectors there,
so bring any souvenirs from your childhood

90
00:07:46,316 --> 00:07:48,484
I want a thousand.

91
00:07:49,149 --> 00:07:52,650
I can give you 700. And you let us pick
your brain about what happened that day.

92
00:07:59,566 --> 00:08:01,150
Fine.

93
00:08:01,483 --> 00:08:04,984
- Yeah?
- Yeah. Deal.

94
00:08:42,024 --> 00:08:44,317
I betcha can't!

95
00:08:47,274 --> 00:08:49,275
Come on, let's go!

96
00:08:56,191 --> 00:08:59,150
Hey! What about breakfast?

97
00:09:09,607 --> 00:09:12,567
It's a little warm out for that hat,
don't you think?

98
00:09:26,857 --> 00:09:30,525
Settle down, girls. Settle down.

99
00:09:33,107 --> 00:09:34,858
Hey, Ben.

100
00:09:34,982 --> 00:09:37,775
- Hey, Libby.
- I like your salt mountain.

101
00:09:37,899 --> 00:09:39,692
Oh, yeah?

102
00:09:43,107 --> 00:09:45,216
Mom, Ben and Libby are making
a mess at the table.

103
00:09:45,316 --> 00:09:47,716
Sweetie, it's fine. Michelle,
can you make sure everyone has juice.

104
00:09:47,816 --> 00:09:51,424
Mom! Libby took my pancake off my plate.

105
00:09:51,524 --> 00:09:55,067
Libby, Ben... eggs?

106
00:09:55,357 --> 00:09:59,716
Mom, Ben's wearing a hat inside.
It's not even cold. Duh!

107
00:09:59,816 --> 00:10:01,900
Michelle, you're right.
Ben, you need to take off your hat.

108
00:10:02,024 --> 00:10:04,567
It's not polite to wear
a hat at the table.

109
00:10:05,857 --> 00:10:07,442
Ben.

110
00:10:14,399 --> 00:10:18,257
Mom, Ben looks like some ghoul
from one of his metal band posters.

111
00:10:18,357 --> 00:10:19,924
Why?

112
00:10:20,024 --> 00:10:23,067
It's just hair, Mom. Don't freak out.

113
00:10:24,816 --> 00:10:26,192
I'll be back later.

114
00:10:35,274 --> 00:10:39,692
<i>It wasn't the first time I'd been offered
money for conferences or meetings.</i>

115
00:10:43,482 --> 00:10:47,442
<i>I'd been offered all sorts
of twisted deals over the years.</i>

116
00:11:08,982 --> 00:11:11,400
Want some sweets, little girl?

117
00:11:16,107 --> 00:11:17,650
Libby!

118
00:11:18,607 --> 00:11:20,674
- Welcome to our club.
- What?

119
00:11:20,774 --> 00:11:24,716
I said, "Welcome to our club!"
You want me to show you around?

120
00:11:24,816 --> 00:11:26,942
I want my money.

121
00:11:30,232 --> 00:11:33,275
Come on. I'll show you upstairs.

122
00:11:34,232 --> 00:11:36,150
The Kill Club, or "KC," as we call it,

123
00:11:36,274 --> 00:11:39,341
is basically for solvers
and fans of famous murders.

124
00:11:39,441 --> 00:11:42,775
- Everyone from Fanny Adams to the killer...
- Who's Fanny Adams?

125
00:11:42,899 --> 00:11:46,275
She's an eight-year-old who got chopped
to bits in England back in 1867.

126
00:11:46,566 --> 00:11:48,507
That guy you passed
with the sweets downstairs,

127
00:11:48,607 --> 00:11:51,400
he was playing the role
of her murderer, Frederick Baker.

128
00:11:54,899 --> 00:11:57,341
Jesus Christ!
You guys need to get a life.

129
00:11:57,441 --> 00:12:00,549
Yeah, we've been trying to push
the role players out, but...

130
00:12:00,649 --> 00:12:04,275
too many guys are into that. Plus,
it's a good source of income for us.

131
00:12:04,399 --> 00:12:06,358
- Us?
- The solvers.

132
00:12:07,191 --> 00:12:09,007
We're a serious-minded organization.

133
00:12:09,107 --> 00:12:13,567
Among our ranks are ex-cops, private
and insurance investigators, lawyers.

134
00:12:13,691 --> 00:12:17,025
We solve crimes. It's what we do.

135
00:12:22,607 --> 00:12:25,441
Lyle. Who's your young friend?

136
00:12:25,565 --> 00:12:28,525
Bob Bredella, this is Libby Day.

137
00:12:28,815 --> 00:12:33,233
Whose family was at the Kansas
farm house massacre.

138
00:12:34,482 --> 00:12:38,150
If you had a cock you would be
in pieces in my garbage right now.

139
00:12:38,565 --> 00:12:41,066
Parts that I didn't use for chili.

140
00:12:41,274 --> 00:12:43,257
Get your fucking hands off me,
you freak!

141
00:12:43,357 --> 00:12:46,590
- I'm kidding. I'm sorry. I'm only kidding.
- You think that's funny? You fat fuck!

142
00:12:46,690 --> 00:12:48,757
That wouldn't have been
the first fight at Kill Club,

143
00:12:48,857 --> 00:12:50,507
but it would've been the weirdest.

144
00:12:50,607 --> 00:12:52,715
- You know what? I'm outta here.
- No, no, no. Libby, please.

145
00:12:52,815 --> 00:12:54,257
I don't want to do this anymore.

146
00:12:54,357 --> 00:12:57,650
No, no. I can understand
why you wouldn't like it so far.

147
00:12:57,774 --> 00:13:00,424
Okay? But we're not all like that.

148
00:13:00,524 --> 00:13:03,525
Look, just give me a chance.
Look at this in here.

149
00:13:04,607 --> 00:13:08,316
A bunch of PI's who think
they've identified a serial killer.

150
00:13:08,440 --> 00:13:11,275
They're about to catch some guy
who has been crossing states.

151
00:13:11,399 --> 00:13:15,275
You know, Missouri, Kansas,
Oklahoma, to help kill people.

152
00:13:15,399 --> 00:13:18,150
- What do you mean help?
- They call him the Angel of Debt.

153
00:13:18,440 --> 00:13:21,840
They think he's like a Jack Kevorkian
for people with bad credit,

154
00:13:21,940 --> 00:13:24,590
good life insurance and no way out.

155
00:13:24,690 --> 00:13:27,900
You'll like our group.
It's serious, no costumes.

156
00:13:30,732 --> 00:13:33,483
Hi, everyone. It's my honor
to present our special guest,

157
00:13:33,774 --> 00:13:36,400
and the star of this year's Kill Club.

158
00:13:36,524 --> 00:13:38,066
Libby Day.

159
00:13:38,190 --> 00:13:42,882
Around 2:00 a.m.
on October the 13th, 1985,

160
00:13:42,982 --> 00:13:48,049
a person or persons killed
three members of the Day family

161
00:13:48,149 --> 00:13:50,674
in their farm house in Kinnakee, Kansas.

162
00:13:50,774 --> 00:13:54,424
The youngest child, Libby,
escaped the killer

163
00:13:54,524 --> 00:13:56,799
through a window in her mother's room.

164
00:13:56,899 --> 00:14:00,215
The oldest child, Benjamin,
never produced an alibi

165
00:14:00,315 --> 00:14:03,858
and was extremely uncooperative
with the police.

166
00:14:03,982 --> 00:14:07,924
Libby testified,
she saw Ben commit the murders.

167
00:14:08,024 --> 00:14:11,275
Despite Libby's confused testimony,

168
00:14:11,399 --> 00:14:13,441
and young age,

169
00:14:13,565 --> 00:14:17,507
and despite a startling lack
of physical evidence,

170
00:14:17,607 --> 00:14:19,150
Ben Day was convicted.

171
00:14:19,274 --> 00:14:23,441
Based largely on rumors that he
was involved in Devil worship.

172
00:14:25,315 --> 00:14:27,340
- You done?
- I think the general consensus

173
00:14:27,440 --> 00:14:29,590
is that Runner Day, her father, did it.

174
00:14:29,690 --> 00:14:31,924
I mean, he goes to Patty,
tries to bully her for money,

175
00:14:32,024 --> 00:14:34,049
as usual gets nothing,
and he goes haywire.

176
00:14:34,149 --> 00:14:37,941
- I mean, the guy was crazy, right?
- Right. I don't know...

177
00:14:39,190 --> 00:14:41,215
Look, I didn't know him,
he left when I was, like, two.

178
00:14:41,315 --> 00:14:42,775
- Where is he now?
- I don't know.

179
00:14:42,899 --> 00:14:44,941
There was a blood stain
on Michelle's bed sheets.

180
00:14:45,065 --> 00:14:46,924
Different blood type
than anyone in the family.

181
00:14:47,024 --> 00:14:49,816
But since the sheets were from Goodwill,

182
00:14:49,940 --> 00:14:51,924
prosecutor says that blood
could've come from anywhere.

183
00:14:52,024 --> 00:14:55,257
Yeah, we were poor. A lot of our shit
came from Goodwill, okay?

184
00:14:55,357 --> 00:14:58,049
Do you remember anything
out of the ordinary

185
00:14:58,149 --> 00:14:59,757
- happening that day?
- Like what?

186
00:14:59,857 --> 00:15:03,483
Like, how your mother reacted
to the Krissi Cates scandal.

187
00:15:03,607 --> 00:15:05,608
- Who?
- Krissi Cates.

188
00:15:06,940 --> 00:15:08,358
I don't know who that is.

189
00:15:08,524 --> 00:15:11,316
- You mentioned her in your book.
- I didn't write that book.

190
00:15:11,857 --> 00:15:14,507
- I didn't even read it.
- What about Trey Teepano?

191
00:15:14,607 --> 00:15:17,150
What about Ben Day? You want to hear
what I have to say about him?

192
00:15:17,274 --> 00:15:20,007
Please, this is the grossest
miscarriage of justice ever.

193
00:15:20,107 --> 00:15:21,507
What is this woman's deal?

194
00:15:21,607 --> 00:15:23,549
Magda here is very involved
in the effort to free your brother.

195
00:15:23,649 --> 00:15:26,882
He's a wonderful man.
He draws, he writes poetry.

196
00:15:26,982 --> 00:15:29,049
You should get to know him, Libby.

197
00:15:29,149 --> 00:15:33,191
You really should. In three weeks,
that window is going to close.

198
00:15:33,524 --> 00:15:36,090
- What?
- In order to solve this crime,

199
00:15:36,190 --> 00:15:39,340
we need to compile new evidence and...

200
00:15:39,440 --> 00:15:43,798
if you were inclined, you could recant your
testimony when we file for habeas corpus.

201
00:15:43,898 --> 00:15:47,757
- But... time is of the essence.
- What are you talking about?

202
00:15:47,857 --> 00:15:50,524
Oh, because of budget cuts,
they are consolidating departments

203
00:15:50,648 --> 00:15:53,882
and disposing of evidence
from cases older than 10 years.

204
00:15:53,982 --> 00:15:57,941
Which means, in three weeks' time,
Ben's file will be shredded.

205
00:16:01,065 --> 00:16:05,173
You're just a few people who like
murder mysteries and true crimes...

206
00:16:05,273 --> 00:16:08,548
- Libby. Ben is innocent and we're trying...
- He's never even filed for an appeal!

207
00:16:08,648 --> 00:16:12,858
He's had reason enough
for eight appeals but he has lost hope.

208
00:16:12,982 --> 00:16:14,774
Good.

209
00:16:15,107 --> 00:16:17,983
- Please help...
- No. It's not a conspiracy theory.

210
00:16:18,107 --> 00:16:20,173
- Hey, don't be like that!
- Get your hands off me!

211
00:16:20,273 --> 00:16:21,816
At least stay and try and convince us.

212
00:16:21,940 --> 00:16:24,691
I told you she wouldn't bother,
lazy little liar.

213
00:16:26,565 --> 00:16:30,858
Yes, that's what you are
and what you've always been. A liar!

214
00:16:38,107 --> 00:16:40,983
You don't know shit
about what happened that night.

215
00:16:45,273 --> 00:16:47,066
None of you.

216
00:16:49,815 --> 00:16:51,774
Run! Run!

217
00:16:51,898 --> 00:16:53,733
No!

218
00:16:55,940 --> 00:16:58,483
Libby! Libby!

219
00:17:02,607 --> 00:17:04,274
Libby!

220
00:17:24,273 --> 00:17:26,733
They're all dead!

221
00:17:57,523 --> 00:18:00,483
<i>"Once I was in art class
and met a boy named Ben.</i>

222
00:18:00,607 --> 00:18:03,149
<i>"It was his heart I knew I would win.</i>

223
00:18:03,273 --> 00:18:06,399
<i>"He has big blue eyes
and really nice skin.</i>

224
00:18:06,773 --> 00:18:08,608
<i>"Are you 'in'?"</i>

225
00:18:09,440 --> 00:18:13,483
<i>"It's Saturday and I'm thinking of you.
Guess who?"</i>

226
00:18:42,565 --> 00:18:44,816
Hey, do you know someone here?

227
00:18:46,065 --> 00:18:47,608
Him.

228
00:18:48,273 --> 00:18:50,382
Hey. Hey.

229
00:18:50,482 --> 00:18:52,649
Hey, do you know this kid?

230
00:18:54,107 --> 00:18:56,340
No, I don't hang out
with middle-schoolers.

231
00:18:56,440 --> 00:18:58,816
- Fuck off.
- Oh, little guy's pissed.

232
00:18:58,940 --> 00:19:01,173
Okay, dude, what's up?
Do I know you or what?

233
00:19:01,273 --> 00:19:02,774
I'm a friend of Trey's,
I come here all the time.

234
00:19:02,898 --> 00:19:05,923
You liar. That crazy Indian
doesn't have any friends.

235
00:19:06,023 --> 00:19:08,983
Is he even really Indian?
He looks Asian to me.

236
00:19:09,107 --> 00:19:12,358
I think he's... what do they call it?
A mixed blood. He's like two different things.

237
00:19:12,482 --> 00:19:15,298
So, like, his drunken granddad
raped a Chinese whore?

238
00:19:15,398 --> 00:19:19,649
You better watch your mouth, Trey's
into some scary ass shit. Satanic shit.

239
00:19:21,440 --> 00:19:23,423
Yeah, we get into some
pretty dark shit sometimes.

240
00:19:23,523 --> 00:19:26,107
You're one of the guys
that killed the cows?

241
00:19:28,106 --> 00:19:31,340
We have to. It's an order.

242
00:19:31,440 --> 00:19:35,524
Bro, that's a weird order.
That was my hamburger.

243
00:19:35,690 --> 00:19:37,381
Look at his face.

244
00:19:37,481 --> 00:19:40,941
Sometimes things have to die.
We have to kill them.

245
00:19:41,856 --> 00:19:44,566
Just like Jesus requires sacrifice,

246
00:19:45,815 --> 00:19:47,857
so does Satan.

247
00:20:05,731 --> 00:20:09,482
- Mom, is Ben in trouble?
- No, sweetie, Ben's fine.

248
00:20:09,606 --> 00:20:12,149
- Are you sure?
- Michelle, what do you want?

249
00:20:12,565 --> 00:20:15,232
- I heard rumors.
- What kind of rumors?

250
00:20:16,440 --> 00:20:19,857
Mom, there's a car coming!

251
00:20:22,273 --> 00:20:23,316
Who is it?

252
00:20:24,856 --> 00:20:26,357
Morning.

253
00:20:30,398 --> 00:20:32,232
Thank you.

254
00:20:37,190 --> 00:20:39,232
Who's the little spy?

255
00:20:39,356 --> 00:20:41,149
That's Libby.

256
00:20:42,773 --> 00:20:45,048
She's got big blue eyes like her mom.

257
00:20:45,148 --> 00:20:47,423
Where are your people
from originally? Ireland?

258
00:20:47,523 --> 00:20:50,090
Germany. My maiden name was Krause.

259
00:20:50,190 --> 00:20:52,149
There was another
German farmer near Ark City.

260
00:20:52,273 --> 00:20:57,381
Last summer, his hopper went screwy
and dumped 4000 pounds of wheat on him.

261
00:20:57,481 --> 00:21:01,256
Poor fellow drowned in it. He suffocated
before they could get to him.

262
00:21:01,356 --> 00:21:03,774
- I know the story.
- His farm's going under.

263
00:21:04,065 --> 00:21:09,274
He owed us... I mean,
the FHA a lot of money.

264
00:21:09,606 --> 00:21:12,732
Why you working on a Saturday, Joseph?
Is something wrong?

265
00:21:15,940 --> 00:21:17,941
They're going to foreclose.

266
00:21:18,856 --> 00:21:21,840
- Why now?
- Prices aren't what they used to be.

267
00:21:21,940 --> 00:21:25,006
A strong harvest is what brought those
prices down, that could change next year.

268
00:21:25,106 --> 00:21:27,756
There's no way for you
to come out on top.

269
00:21:27,856 --> 00:21:29,840
I could sell the animals,
I'll sell some of the machinery.

270
00:21:29,940 --> 00:21:34,607
The animals aren't worth much.
You already sold most of the machinery.

271
00:21:35,606 --> 00:21:37,607
There's got to be a way.

272
00:21:37,731 --> 00:21:41,191
- Banks said they would back...
- Your bank's going under, too.

273
00:21:41,690 --> 00:21:43,756
I'm sorry.

274
00:21:43,856 --> 00:21:45,691
They're just trying to get rid of us.

275
00:21:47,356 --> 00:21:49,506
I'm not sure who "they" are.

276
00:21:49,606 --> 00:21:51,774
The only way to fix this is money.

277
00:21:53,231 --> 00:21:56,816
I'm talking beg, borrow, steal.

278
00:21:56,940 --> 00:21:59,441
Time for pride is over, Patty.

279
00:22:00,440 --> 00:22:05,857
<i>Libby? What you're about to tell us
is very, very important.</i>

280
00:22:07,231 --> 00:22:10,357
<i>Did Ben kill your mom and your sisters?</i>

281
00:22:14,481 --> 00:22:18,566
<i>You were in the house
when it happened, so tell us.</i>

282
00:22:19,106 --> 00:22:22,941
It was Ben, he killed them, right?

283
00:22:37,273 --> 00:22:39,107
Listen, I've been thinking.

284
00:22:40,106 --> 00:22:42,423
If I were to look into this case
some more, is that something your club

285
00:22:42,523 --> 00:22:45,506
- would be able to finance?
- You changed your mind?

286
00:22:45,606 --> 00:22:48,607
No, as far as I'm concerned
Ben is the killer, but...

287
00:22:49,856 --> 00:22:51,732
I need money.

288
00:22:52,814 --> 00:22:55,732
And I'm willing to offer your club
three weeks of my life in exchange.

289
00:22:58,314 --> 00:23:00,673
- That doesn't sound very noble.
- Whatever.

290
00:23:00,773 --> 00:23:03,024
No, wait. Libby. Libby.

291
00:23:03,564 --> 00:23:05,399
Do you really have
no contact with Runner?

292
00:23:06,481 --> 00:23:07,440
No.

293
00:23:07,564 --> 00:23:09,006
It might be a good idea
to track him down.

294
00:23:09,106 --> 00:23:11,315
Although, personally
I don't think Runner did it.

295
00:23:12,939 --> 00:23:15,756
- What's your theory?
- I'm not quite ready to share that yet.

296
00:23:15,856 --> 00:23:19,482
Come on! If Ben is so innocent,
why doesn't he try to get out?

297
00:23:20,273 --> 00:23:22,381
Maybe you should go talk to him.

298
00:23:22,481 --> 00:23:24,774
No. We start with other people first.

299
00:23:24,898 --> 00:23:28,506
- What is it? Is it a money thing?
- I just don't like wasting my time, okay?

300
00:23:28,606 --> 00:23:32,940
Okay. How about... $300?

301
00:23:35,356 --> 00:23:36,607
Where do you get this money?

302
00:23:36,731 --> 00:23:39,607
As treasurer, I have a certain amount
of discretionary funds.

303
00:23:39,731 --> 00:23:42,482
This is the project
I choose to use them for.

304
00:23:42,606 --> 00:23:45,232
What? What's so funny?

305
00:23:47,356 --> 00:23:49,839
You're a noble embezzler.
That's what's funny.

306
00:23:49,939 --> 00:23:52,506
- That makes you almost likable.
- Thanks.

307
00:23:52,606 --> 00:23:56,714
- I need 500 more. An advance.
- Why?

308
00:23:56,814 --> 00:23:58,839
'Cause I got to get my car
out of the shop.

309
00:23:58,939 --> 00:24:01,690
It's been held hostage
for the last six months.

310
00:24:03,106 --> 00:24:05,315
I'm going to need a car.

311
00:24:07,689 --> 00:24:08,857
All right.

312
00:24:12,773 --> 00:24:15,298
- You better play ball.
- Yeah, yeah, I will.

313
00:24:15,398 --> 00:24:20,232
- Go see Ben. It all starts with him.
- No, it all ends with him. He killed them.

314
00:24:21,773 --> 00:24:24,982
- I'm serious, Libby, go talk to him...
- Fine! I'll talk to him!

315
00:24:25,106 --> 00:24:27,607
Just to prove you freaks wrong.

316
00:24:27,731 --> 00:24:30,232
Make that fat bitch Magda cry.

317
00:24:51,773 --> 00:24:53,506
<i>I think...</i>

318
00:24:53,606 --> 00:24:58,274
<i>I saw Ben as I was standing
at the door of my mom's room.</i>

319
00:24:58,939 --> 00:25:02,565
He was threatening her with our shotgun.

320
00:25:38,523 --> 00:25:41,440
Satan encourages you
to do what feels good.

321
00:25:41,564 --> 00:25:44,173
Because we're all basically animals.

322
00:25:44,273 --> 00:25:46,940
Settle down. Quiet.

323
00:25:47,064 --> 00:25:51,024
Benjamin, you do understand
this is very serious, don't you?

324
00:26:06,939 --> 00:26:09,607
- Hi, Libby.
- Hey, Ben.

325
00:26:10,606 --> 00:26:13,881
- I never thought I'd see you here.
- Yeah, well, I never thought I'd come.

326
00:26:13,981 --> 00:26:16,839
Turns out you got
a couple of fans outside.

327
00:26:16,939 --> 00:26:19,107
People who take you
for the victim, well played.

328
00:26:19,522 --> 00:26:22,398
I thought about you
a lot over the years.

329
00:26:23,356 --> 00:26:26,815
Every once in a while, someone
tells me about you but it's not the same.

330
00:26:29,272 --> 00:26:30,648
How's it in there?

331
00:26:30,772 --> 00:26:34,482
I'm fine. Really, I am.
I have my high school diploma.

332
00:26:34,606 --> 00:26:37,732
I'm even part way
to a college degree. English.

333
00:26:38,314 --> 00:26:40,857
I read fucking Shakespeare now.

334
00:26:45,522 --> 00:26:47,398
Good for you.

335
00:26:50,772 --> 00:26:52,898
Man, Libby, you're so beautiful.

336
00:26:53,481 --> 00:26:56,756
You've got Mom's eyes.
You must hear that all the time.

337
00:26:56,856 --> 00:26:58,940
Who would tell me that?

338
00:26:59,522 --> 00:27:02,482
Runner's gone, don't know where.

339
00:27:02,606 --> 00:27:04,881
Diane's dead. There's no one.

340
00:27:04,981 --> 00:27:07,256
That's not good.
They should've taken better care of you.

341
00:27:07,356 --> 00:27:09,398
You're born again?

342
00:27:10,772 --> 00:27:13,089
You found Jesus in there?
Why are you being so nice to me?

343
00:27:13,189 --> 00:27:16,214
I'm not that nice, Libby.
I got a lot of anger for a lot of people.

344
00:27:16,314 --> 00:27:18,357
Just... you're not one of them.

345
00:27:23,814 --> 00:27:25,065
What?

346
00:27:28,606 --> 00:27:30,482
You're different.

347
00:27:31,647 --> 00:27:34,190
You're different than I imagined.

348
00:27:36,314 --> 00:27:37,773
You know, we don't have
to stay in this room.

349
00:27:37,897 --> 00:27:42,232
This room is designated for death row
inmates. We can be in an open room.

350
00:27:45,314 --> 00:27:47,773
Unless you requested this one?

351
00:27:55,897 --> 00:27:59,232
- Remember that horse, Yellow?
- Yellow?

352
00:27:59,397 --> 00:28:01,773
The famous horse
that refused to be ridden?

353
00:28:01,897 --> 00:28:03,815
- What, did he bite you?
- Nothing that dramatic.

354
00:28:03,939 --> 00:28:06,648
Just thought I had a good hold of him,
he threw me against the fence

355
00:28:06,772 --> 00:28:10,023
and slammed my hand against a nail.

356
00:28:10,647 --> 00:28:14,273
Runner been in here?
You know where he is?

357
00:28:14,397 --> 00:28:19,256
The last letter came care of Bert Nolan's
Group Home for Men somewhere in Oklahoma.

358
00:28:19,356 --> 00:28:24,190
He asked me for $500 to carry on
his research on my behalf.

359
00:28:24,314 --> 00:28:26,315
Good ol' Runner.

360
00:28:26,772 --> 00:28:31,690
- What's the tat on your arm?
- Oh, it's a old flame.

361
00:28:32,439 --> 00:28:34,857
We started out as pen pals.

362
00:28:37,689 --> 00:28:40,690
I thought I loved her.
I thought we'd get married.

363
00:28:41,314 --> 00:28:43,732
How about you? You got a boyfriend?

364
00:28:45,647 --> 00:28:47,565
Don't do that.

365
00:28:47,689 --> 00:28:51,357
How dare you? Don't...
You don't get to do that.

366
00:28:51,897 --> 00:28:53,256
Libby, I'm...

367
00:28:53,356 --> 00:28:56,690
No, you don't get to ask me
fucking questions.

368
00:28:58,606 --> 00:29:01,631
I mean, here comes my little sister
after all these years.

369
00:29:01,731 --> 00:29:05,881
And I'm thinking,
"Maybe this one thing will work out."

370
00:29:05,981 --> 00:29:09,047
Maybe I won't be so fucking lonely.

371
00:29:09,147 --> 00:29:11,297
We can talk about a goddamn horse,

372
00:29:11,397 --> 00:29:14,440
that's all I'm asking for,
something just as tiny as that.

373
00:29:14,981 --> 00:29:17,131
I don't remember the horse.

374
00:29:17,231 --> 00:29:20,065
Yellow? It was a dirty old farm horse.

375
00:29:20,189 --> 00:29:22,339
- But it was your horse.
- How come I can't remember him?

376
00:29:22,439 --> 00:29:24,797
You were pretty young
when Mom had to sell him.

377
00:29:24,897 --> 00:29:27,190
Broke her heart,
but she needed the money.

378
00:29:27,772 --> 00:29:30,232
I can tell you all about him.

379
00:29:37,939 --> 00:29:41,773
- Go ahead, ask the question.
- I don't need to ask.

380
00:29:43,605 --> 00:29:45,630
- I know you killed them.
- No, I did not.

381
00:29:45,730 --> 00:29:46,964
That's not what you said back then.

382
00:29:47,064 --> 00:29:49,172
Of course not, I was a teenage boy
in a house full of girls.

383
00:29:49,272 --> 00:29:52,214
At school I was the kid
that nobody paid attention to.

384
00:29:52,314 --> 00:29:54,315
In that court room,
people were scared of me.

385
00:29:54,439 --> 00:29:57,505
- I was a bad ass.
- A bad ass who killed his family.

386
00:29:57,605 --> 00:30:01,981
Libby, I was a fool, but I did not
kill Mom or Debby or Michelle.

387
00:30:02,105 --> 00:30:05,356
Then why have you never filed
for an appeal?

388
00:30:07,564 --> 00:30:10,398
You like it so much in there,
you want to stay there?

389
00:30:12,064 --> 00:30:15,148
You know what I think?
I think you're full of shit.

390
00:31:02,980 --> 00:31:04,898
You look awesome.

391
00:31:05,439 --> 00:31:07,190
Told ya.

392
00:31:14,730 --> 00:31:17,106
You don't think I might
be too old for you?

393
00:31:17,522 --> 00:31:18,714
What's that mean?

394
00:31:18,814 --> 00:31:21,731
Means that 17 might just be
too old for your taste.

395
00:31:24,022 --> 00:31:25,648
Come on.

396
00:31:40,397 --> 00:31:43,565
Come on, Ben. Focus on me.
Come on, baby.

397
00:31:44,064 --> 00:31:45,523
Is that all you got?

398
00:31:57,439 --> 00:32:00,398
You know, I saw a couple
of friends today at the mall.

399
00:32:01,397 --> 00:32:04,398
You know a little girl
named Krissi Cates?

400
00:32:08,480 --> 00:32:12,523
Yeah. She's in that art class I've been
helping out with after school. Why?

401
00:32:14,064 --> 00:32:16,898
You never told me
about no art class, Ben.

402
00:32:17,480 --> 00:32:19,922
Yeah, well, I'm just helping kids.

403
00:32:20,022 --> 00:32:22,481
One of my old teachers asked me to.

404
00:32:25,147 --> 00:32:27,547
Well, they say the police
are looking for ya.

405
00:32:27,647 --> 00:32:30,672
They say you did some
naughty things to some little girls.

406
00:32:30,772 --> 00:32:33,005
Everyone's calling you a perv.

407
00:32:33,105 --> 00:32:35,440
What are you talking about?

408
00:32:37,689 --> 00:32:39,440
I love you.

409
00:32:46,980 --> 00:32:48,815
The baby's kicking.

410
00:33:02,314 --> 00:33:05,065
It's Aunt Diane!

411
00:33:05,897 --> 00:33:09,315
There are more bags in the car,
with some surprises. Go get them.

412
00:33:13,730 --> 00:33:16,005
- You shouldn't have.
- It's what I do.

413
00:33:16,105 --> 00:33:17,731
Are you okay?

414
00:33:18,605 --> 00:33:20,564
The wolves are at the door.

415
00:33:26,688 --> 00:33:28,523
That's too much.

416
00:33:31,147 --> 00:33:33,106
I love the land.

417
00:33:35,522 --> 00:33:37,606
It's like loving your kids.

418
00:33:38,772 --> 00:33:42,689
I know you probably don't know what I mean,
but it's this overwhelming feeling.

419
00:33:44,147 --> 00:33:48,689
Watching it grow and produce.
And reproduce.

420
00:33:50,063 --> 00:33:54,231
But you can only work so many hours
a day, and so many days a week, Patty.

421
00:33:54,730 --> 00:33:57,797
All by yourself,
you never stood a chance.

422
00:33:57,897 --> 00:33:59,838
You should have done like me
and left this place.

423
00:33:59,938 --> 00:34:01,422
You should have gone to college,
you had the brains.

424
00:34:01,522 --> 00:34:03,898
- It's Mom and Dad's farm.
- I know.

425
00:34:05,480 --> 00:34:07,481
It's time to let it go.

426
00:34:08,147 --> 00:34:09,939
I don't see Ben.

427
00:34:10,688 --> 00:34:14,939
- He left early this morning.
- How are things with him?

428
00:34:16,563 --> 00:34:18,981
- Difficult.
- Where is he?

429
00:34:21,897 --> 00:34:23,439
I don't know, why?

430
00:34:24,605 --> 00:34:27,981
So what do you think,
is it a boy or a girl?

431
00:34:30,355 --> 00:34:32,773
I don't know. How would I know?

432
00:34:32,897 --> 00:34:37,231
- So you're saying you don't care.
- No, I do care.

433
00:34:37,522 --> 00:34:39,922
I was actually thinking
of some names if it's a girl.

434
00:34:40,022 --> 00:34:43,564
- Well, do you care to share?
- Not yet.

435
00:34:45,980 --> 00:34:48,231
Are you sure Michelle hasn't found out?

436
00:34:49,105 --> 00:34:51,005
She hasn't said anything.

437
00:34:51,105 --> 00:34:53,064
That little weasel.

438
00:34:53,563 --> 00:34:55,314
You know, I swear if I ever
get my hands on her...

439
00:34:55,438 --> 00:34:57,231
Shut up.

440
00:34:57,980 --> 00:34:59,939
You know I've promised my Dad, Ben.

441
00:35:00,063 --> 00:35:03,606
He said if he ever found out I wasn't
a virgin anymore he'd shoot me in the head.

442
00:35:07,688 --> 00:35:11,231
So you tell your nosy little sister
to stop talking shit about me at school.

443
00:35:11,605 --> 00:35:13,588
Before he finds out.

444
00:35:13,688 --> 00:35:16,814
Hey, it's Trey! Quit fucking around
and get out of there.

445
00:35:16,938 --> 00:35:19,981
You don't know him, Ben.
You don't know what he's capable of.

446
00:35:27,397 --> 00:35:29,898
You know, I think we should leave town
before our parents get back.

447
00:35:30,272 --> 00:35:31,273
Okay.

448
00:35:31,563 --> 00:35:34,713
Really? That easy.

449
00:35:34,813 --> 00:35:36,898
- What?
- How are you going to support us?

450
00:35:41,522 --> 00:35:45,106
You'll have to get a job or...
I don't know, ask Runner for money.

451
00:35:45,230 --> 00:35:48,398
- Runner? My dad?
- Yeah. He makes money, right?

452
00:36:02,563 --> 00:36:06,523
He does handyman stuff, for work,
labor... he works on farms.

453
00:36:06,647 --> 00:36:09,106
- Are you kidding?
- Well, yeah, what did you expect?

454
00:36:09,730 --> 00:36:12,273
Trey! Ben doesn't know about his dad!

455
00:36:16,647 --> 00:36:18,981
You sorry sack of shit.

456
00:36:19,355 --> 00:36:22,773
You don't know about your dad?
What the fuck, dude?

457
00:36:23,105 --> 00:36:25,981
Hey, Ben. You're smoking
your dad's weed, buddy.

458
00:36:27,063 --> 00:36:29,713
- What are you guys talking about?
- It's crap and he overcharges.

459
00:36:29,813 --> 00:36:33,088
- Said he got it in Texas.
- Let's go find Runner, honey.

460
00:36:33,188 --> 00:36:36,689
So we can get some money.
Get the hell out of here.

461
00:36:37,272 --> 00:36:42,130
<i>Teenagers across America are playing
with a new and frightening game: Satanism.</i>

462
00:36:42,230 --> 00:36:44,856
<i>Their school books are marked up
by Satanic symbols.</i>

463
00:36:44,980 --> 00:36:47,088
<i>They are seduced by heavy metal heroes,</i>

464
00:36:47,188 --> 00:36:51,046
<i>many of whom feature Satanic imagery
in their songs and album covers.</i>

465
00:36:51,146 --> 00:36:53,713
<i>The fixation on violence, evil and death</i>

466
00:36:53,813 --> 00:36:56,046
<i>leads them to commit abominable crimes,</i>

467
00:36:56,146 --> 00:36:59,671
<i>including human sacrifice
and sexual abuse of children.</i>

468
00:36:59,771 --> 00:37:01,939
<i>We're in the very throes
of a new Satanic age...</i>

469
00:37:02,063 --> 00:37:05,338
Everyone at the time. Police, judges,
the psychiatric community,

470
00:37:05,438 --> 00:37:08,380
- they were seeing Satanists everywhere.
- And there weren't?

471
00:37:08,480 --> 00:37:11,005
A few lost, frustrated kids
take those lyrics too literally?

472
00:37:11,105 --> 00:37:14,231
Yes, but real criminal Satanists?

473
00:37:14,688 --> 00:37:17,647
- What did the investigation say?
- The crime scene was contaminated.

474
00:37:17,771 --> 00:37:19,647
People traipsing in and out
of the house all day

475
00:37:19,771 --> 00:37:22,272
was against all the rules of police
procedure, but no one cared.

476
00:37:22,396 --> 00:37:25,880
They had the perfect culprit, a strange
teenage boy that no one in town liked much

477
00:37:25,980 --> 00:37:29,772
and listened to heavy metal.
You know, it was convenient.

478
00:37:30,980 --> 00:37:34,189
I've got the files
so you can take a look.

479
00:37:36,730 --> 00:37:38,838
Libby, it's not a request.
It's part of the job.

480
00:37:38,938 --> 00:37:40,481
Seriously?

481
00:37:40,605 --> 00:37:44,147
It's like you guys want Ben out
more than he does. It's ridiculous.

482
00:37:44,271 --> 00:37:46,588
- What did you think of him?
- I don't know, Lyle.

483
00:37:46,688 --> 00:37:49,981
Did you ever hear about him
with his serious girlfriend?

484
00:37:50,730 --> 00:37:53,880
Molly or Polly? Something like that.

485
00:37:53,980 --> 00:37:55,772
No. It doesn't ring a bell.

486
00:37:56,938 --> 00:37:58,897
It's probably nothing.

487
00:37:59,730 --> 00:38:04,064
He had a tattoo of it on his arm.
It's probably another Magda.

488
00:38:04,646 --> 00:38:06,689
Will you just tell me?

489
00:38:07,730 --> 00:38:09,772
Just tell me, who do you think did it?

490
00:38:10,855 --> 00:38:14,439
I think Lou Cates did it.
Krissi Cates' father.

491
00:38:14,730 --> 00:38:18,064
Found out he had a history of violence,
went to jail for aggravated battery.

492
00:38:20,688 --> 00:38:23,064
You still have no idea
who Krissi Cates is, do you?

493
00:38:24,021 --> 00:38:25,838
- No.
- Libby...

494
00:38:25,938 --> 00:38:28,647
Come on, I know you hate doing this,
but could you try?

495
00:38:28,771 --> 00:38:31,046
You're stuck with us anyway, just try.

496
00:38:31,146 --> 00:38:34,421
You're smart, you'll see for yourself
that something's not right.

497
00:38:34,521 --> 00:38:37,272
Just... just take a look at the folder.

498
00:38:38,438 --> 00:38:41,897
Come on, you'll see. Please.

499
00:38:47,813 --> 00:38:51,522
<i>Since I was seven
I'd only seen flashes of Ben.</i>

500
00:38:52,105 --> 00:38:56,064
<i>Like some evil entity
in a haunted house.</i>

501
00:38:57,521 --> 00:39:00,647
<i>But I'd forgotten
there was once just Ben.</i>

502
00:39:01,938 --> 00:39:03,713
<i>My brother.</i>

503
00:39:03,813 --> 00:39:06,981
<i>Shy. Serious.</i>

504
00:39:08,730 --> 00:39:11,022
<i>Couldn't have done what they said.</i>

505
00:39:11,313 --> 00:39:13,147
<i>What I said.</i>

506
00:39:16,105 --> 00:39:21,421
<i>The molestation of Krissi Cates and
the murders weren't legally linked, but...</i>

507
00:39:21,521 --> 00:39:25,606
<i>everyone had heard the rumors and the jury
was surely poisoned against him.</i>

508
00:39:26,313 --> 00:39:27,856
<i>Oddly,</i>

509
00:39:28,521 --> 00:39:33,064
<i>all the little girls backed down
and the Cates family never pressed charges.</i>

510
00:39:34,688 --> 00:39:39,046
<i>The Kill Club found Krissi Cates' mother
in Emporia, Kansas, but...</i>

511
00:39:39,146 --> 00:39:41,772
<i>she'd never returned their calls.</i>

512
00:39:43,855 --> 00:39:48,088
<i>You never leave a message
for someone you really want to reach.</i>

513
00:39:48,188 --> 00:39:53,564
<i>You keep calling and calling
until somebody picks up.</i>

514
00:39:54,105 --> 00:39:58,814
<i>Out of anger, curiosity or just fear.</i>

515
00:39:58,938 --> 00:40:00,522
<i>Hello?</i>

516
00:40:02,480 --> 00:40:04,046
Hello?

517
00:40:04,146 --> 00:40:08,314
I'm so sorry, did I just wake you up?
I didn't realize how late it was.

518
00:40:08,438 --> 00:40:11,397
- I can call back later.
- <i>Who is this?</i>

519
00:40:12,563 --> 00:40:16,480
My name is Stephanie Adams,
I'm an old friend of Krissi's,

520
00:40:16,604 --> 00:40:19,105
- I was just looking for her...
- <i>Christ! You people won't stop calling</i>

521
00:40:19,229 --> 00:40:20,546
<i>until I give you what you want, right?</i>

522
00:40:20,646 --> 00:40:22,671
I have no idea what you're
talking about, ma'am.

523
00:40:22,771 --> 00:40:26,814
I'm just an old friend looking for her,
I thought maybe you could help me.

524
00:40:28,771 --> 00:40:32,147
- <i>What was your name? Sally?</i>
- Yeah, my name is Sally Adams.

525
00:40:32,271 --> 00:40:37,105
<i>Listen, Sally, I've remarried and I have
very little contact with my previous family.</i>

526
00:40:37,229 --> 00:40:41,504
Got it. You don't by chance
have a number for Lou...

527
00:40:41,604 --> 00:40:43,855
or know where I can find him?

528
00:40:45,521 --> 00:40:49,105
<i>Well, Lou would be in some bar
in Kansas, I'd guess.</i>

529
00:40:49,688 --> 00:40:55,213
<i>As for Krissi, drive west on I-70.
Just past Columbia.</i>

530
00:40:55,313 --> 00:40:58,647
<i>Take a left into the giant strip club.</i>

531
00:40:58,771 --> 00:41:00,314
<i>You'll find her.</i>

532
00:41:00,438 --> 00:41:02,522
<i>Don't call again.</i>

533
00:41:17,104 --> 00:41:18,379
Mrs. Day,

534
00:41:18,479 --> 00:41:22,064
I've called you down to the precinct due
to some serious allegations about your son.

535
00:41:22,438 --> 00:41:25,730
How's he regarded in school?
Is he a popular kid?

536
00:41:25,854 --> 00:41:28,046
He has lots of friends.

537
00:41:28,146 --> 00:41:30,272
From what we understand,
he's a bit of a loner.

538
00:41:30,396 --> 00:41:32,397
So what does that prove?

539
00:41:32,729 --> 00:41:35,296
- You have four children, correct?
- Yes.

540
00:41:35,396 --> 00:41:38,647
- Same father?
- Yes.

541
00:41:39,604 --> 00:41:41,439
Mrs. Day,

542
00:41:41,813 --> 00:41:47,004
we've got four little girls who say that Ben
touched them in their private areas.

543
00:41:47,104 --> 00:41:50,230
That he took them to some farm
and performed certain...

544
00:41:50,688 --> 00:41:55,980
acts associated
with ritualistic Devil worship.

545
00:41:56,854 --> 00:41:58,647
Some farm?

546
00:41:58,771 --> 00:42:02,230
- Ben doesn't even have a car.
- You don't know Ben.

547
00:42:05,188 --> 00:42:08,754
Satanic worship is not uncommon.

548
00:42:08,854 --> 00:42:11,105
It's made its way into all areas
of the community,

549
00:42:11,229 --> 00:42:14,421
and part of their rituals
involve the degradation of children.

550
00:42:14,521 --> 00:42:18,272
Do you have any evidence? Any witnesses?
Besides some 12-year-old girls...

551
00:42:18,396 --> 00:42:22,064
We got the note Ben left
in Krissi Cates' locker.

552
00:42:22,729 --> 00:42:24,546
We need to speak to a lawyer.

553
00:42:24,646 --> 00:42:28,230
You do realize that abuse
usually starts at home.

554
00:42:29,313 --> 00:42:30,939
Mrs. Day,

555
00:42:31,438 --> 00:42:33,897
with three little girls,

556
00:42:34,313 --> 00:42:37,564
if I were you, I'd want
the truth out more than anyone.

557
00:42:42,604 --> 00:42:44,713
- Mrs. Cates?
- Yes?

558
00:42:44,813 --> 00:42:47,480
I'm Patty Day. Ben Day's mother.

559
00:42:50,479 --> 00:42:52,564
It's Ben Day's mother.

560
00:42:54,938 --> 00:42:59,564
Can you take these and show me
exactly what happened?

561
00:43:06,271 --> 00:43:08,064
Thank you.

562
00:43:11,729 --> 00:43:13,314
Krissi?

563
00:43:14,688 --> 00:43:16,897
Krissi, I'm Patty Day.

564
00:43:17,896 --> 00:43:19,939
I'm Ben's mom.

565
00:43:20,979 --> 00:43:22,980
I don't want her here.

566
00:43:23,313 --> 00:43:25,147
- I don't want her here! You promised!
- Okay. Okay.

567
00:43:25,271 --> 00:43:27,397
We're not safe!

568
00:43:28,063 --> 00:43:31,772
We've heard of you. Got four kids
at home, can't afford one of them!

569
00:43:31,896 --> 00:43:36,213
Their daddy's a drunk, if not worse.
You're on welfare!

570
00:43:36,313 --> 00:43:41,272
Your meals come from a food bank and
Jesus Christ, you've let your son do this!

571
00:43:41,396 --> 00:43:44,772
I hope you're not hiding him.
Police are looking for him.

572
00:43:44,896 --> 00:43:48,938
- I'm trying to find him, I swear.
- Ben is going to hell!

573
00:44:01,937 --> 00:44:03,605
Krissi?

574
00:44:04,937 --> 00:44:06,879
- Yeah?
- Do you have time for a little chat?

575
00:44:06,979 --> 00:44:10,105
- About what?
- To be frank, it's about Ben Day.

576
00:44:10,229 --> 00:44:12,980
- Buy me a drink.
- Sure.

577
00:44:17,271 --> 00:44:18,688
Who's this?

578
00:44:18,812 --> 00:44:22,855
This is Libby. She's with me.
What can I get you?

579
00:44:23,229 --> 00:44:26,212
- Vodka cranberry, double.
- Make it two.

580
00:44:26,312 --> 00:44:29,938
So... Ben Day?

581
00:44:30,229 --> 00:44:32,296
He really fucked up my life.

582
00:44:32,396 --> 00:44:35,897
So... you maintain
you were molested by him?

583
00:44:37,354 --> 00:44:40,962
I was 11 and he was 16.

584
00:44:41,062 --> 00:44:43,897
He started hanging around
with me after school.

585
00:44:44,021 --> 00:44:47,962
I got that a lot. I was a cute kid.
And we had lots of money.

586
00:44:48,062 --> 00:44:50,980
- Go on.
- He would take me into the closet

587
00:44:51,104 --> 00:44:55,938
and make me perform oral sex on him
while making me pledge allegiance to Satan.

588
00:44:57,104 --> 00:44:59,772
Hey, baby, let me get a bag of chips.

589
00:45:01,187 --> 00:45:03,230
You don't mind, do you?

590
00:45:03,604 --> 00:45:08,087
Anyway, Ben was pretty sneaky with me.
I mean, he had an altar in there.

591
00:45:08,187 --> 00:45:12,605
Upside-down cross. Some dead animals.
Sacrificed things.

592
00:45:12,729 --> 00:45:15,438
That's why I thought that he was
working his way up to killing me,

593
00:45:15,562 --> 00:45:17,712
but he killed his family instead.

594
00:45:17,812 --> 00:45:20,480
His whole family was devil worshiping.

595
00:45:21,729 --> 00:45:25,504
How did your dad react when you told him
what Ben had done to you?

596
00:45:25,604 --> 00:45:28,605
God, he was so over-protective.
He went totally ballistic.

597
00:45:28,896 --> 00:45:31,171
Sometimes I think,
had my dad had found Ben,

598
00:45:31,271 --> 00:45:33,980
he would have killed him
and Ben's family would still be alive.

599
00:45:34,271 --> 00:45:37,522
- Your dad live around here?
- No, we lost touch.

600
00:45:38,437 --> 00:45:40,147
Hey, can you lend me 20 bucks?

601
00:45:40,271 --> 00:45:43,879
- Can we get your dad's address?
- I just told you. That we're out of touch.

602
00:45:43,979 --> 00:45:47,980
- Yeah, I know, but I'm sure there's a way...
- Lyle... take care of the check.

603
00:45:50,521 --> 00:45:52,563
How much did you say?

604
00:45:53,396 --> 00:45:56,272
You know what? Make it 50.
I'll totally pay you back.

605
00:45:56,396 --> 00:46:00,772
I'll give you a pen, you can...
write down your name and address.

606
00:46:02,271 --> 00:46:03,897
Here.

607
00:46:05,437 --> 00:46:07,855
<i>Libby Day.</i>

608
00:46:08,812 --> 00:46:12,504
<i>My name is Libby Day, you lying whore.</i>

609
00:46:12,604 --> 00:46:14,563
Don't lose that.

610
00:46:19,812 --> 00:46:21,522
<i>Burt Nolan Home.</i>

611
00:46:21,646 --> 00:46:26,438
I was looking a Runner,
or a Ronald Day. Is he staying with you?

612
00:46:26,562 --> 00:46:30,855
<i>Well, he's been in and out.
But I'd be happy to give him a message.</i>

613
00:46:30,979 --> 00:46:33,921
Could you ask him to call me back?
My name's Libby Day.

614
00:46:34,021 --> 00:46:36,230
It's kind of important.

615
00:46:37,437 --> 00:46:41,587
Would you tell him I need to talk to him
about Ben and what happened that night?

616
00:46:41,687 --> 00:46:45,647
<i>Ben and that night. Okay.</i>

617
00:46:48,271 --> 00:46:50,313
<i>That night.</i>

618
00:47:14,187 --> 00:47:15,938
<i>That night.</i>

619
00:47:17,979 --> 00:47:20,004
<i>I'd been a sleepwalker
since I could walk.</i>

620
00:47:20,104 --> 00:47:23,480
<i>My mom usually didn't move
when I got in bed with her.</i>

621
00:47:23,604 --> 00:47:26,129
<i>But... that night,</i>

622
00:47:26,229 --> 00:47:30,063
<i>she turned to me
and told me she loved me.</i>

623
00:47:31,020 --> 00:47:33,980
<i>She hardly ever told us she loved us.</i>

624
00:47:36,395 --> 00:47:38,105
<i>That's why I remember it.</i>

625
00:47:46,645 --> 00:47:49,146
<i>I can't dwell on these thoughts.</i>

626
00:47:49,604 --> 00:47:54,021
<i>I've labeled these memories as if they
were a particularly dangerous region.</i>

627
00:47:55,687 --> 00:47:57,730
<i>Dark place.</i>

628
00:48:12,354 --> 00:48:14,563
<i>Michelle's diary.</i>

629
00:48:15,354 --> 00:48:18,771
<i>I'd forgotten what a rotten
busy-body Michelle was.</i>

630
00:48:19,895 --> 00:48:23,605
<i>In her last pages, she kept writing
about Ben's girlfriend, Diondra,</i>

631
00:48:23,729 --> 00:48:25,771
<i>as an evil whore.</i>

632
00:48:41,437 --> 00:48:44,646
<i>I don't ever remember Ben
ever having a girlfriend.</i>

633
00:48:58,062 --> 00:49:01,063
<i>Diondra Wertzner.</i>

634
00:49:17,354 --> 00:49:19,271
I'm a bad mother.

635
00:49:19,395 --> 00:49:21,521
What are you talking about?

636
00:49:21,937 --> 00:49:24,295
You're Superwoman
as far as I'm concerned.

637
00:49:24,395 --> 00:49:27,920
You keep the farm going, you raise
four kids, get them to school every day

638
00:49:28,020 --> 00:49:30,212
and you don't drink
a gallon of bourbon to do it.

639
00:49:30,312 --> 00:49:32,563
No, that cop was right.

640
00:49:34,062 --> 00:49:38,021
If things weren't bad at home,
Ben wouldn't be in so much trouble.

641
00:49:42,479 --> 00:49:45,021
Fundamentally he's a good boy.

642
00:49:51,645 --> 00:49:54,129
Sometimes I think it'd be better
if I disappeared.

643
00:49:54,229 --> 00:49:56,646
Oh, yeah? And what about the kids?

644
00:49:57,187 --> 00:49:59,396
They could go with you.

645
00:49:59,979 --> 00:50:02,521
They'd be better off in Kansas City.

646
00:50:04,645 --> 00:50:06,896
Father's a nut job...

647
00:50:08,020 --> 00:50:10,063
and I'm a failure.

648
00:50:19,562 --> 00:50:21,563
That's Runner's new car.

649
00:50:25,687 --> 00:50:27,771
Do you want me to come in with you?

650
00:50:27,895 --> 00:50:29,896
No, I'll be okay.

651
00:50:30,229 --> 00:50:32,087
Mommy!

652
00:50:32,187 --> 00:50:36,605
Daddy's here. And he brought doughnuts!

653
00:50:41,853 --> 00:50:46,688
<i>Nothing concentrates the attention more
than an animal that can kill you.</i>

654
00:50:48,228 --> 00:50:50,753
Girls, you know you're not supposed
to let anyone in the house when I'm away.

655
00:50:50,853 --> 00:50:53,545
- But, Mom, it's Daddy.
- And now Daddy needs to leave.

656
00:50:53,645 --> 00:50:55,146
Come on!

657
00:50:55,937 --> 00:50:57,021
Let's talk!

658
00:51:02,853 --> 00:51:06,021
- I'm in no mood, Runner.
- Vern Evelee told me.

659
00:51:06,145 --> 00:51:09,063
- You just sold the tiller.
- Yeah.

660
00:51:09,478 --> 00:51:12,170
And that money's gone.
That money is gone as quick as I get it.

661
00:51:12,270 --> 00:51:16,063
- You should know that.
- You're never as broke as you say.

662
00:51:17,770 --> 00:51:20,938
I just need enough cash to get to Texas.

663
00:51:21,062 --> 00:51:24,938
- I'm sorry, I can't help you.
- Patty, I'm in a real jam here.

664
00:51:25,895 --> 00:51:28,771
- This is life or death stuff.
- Runner...

665
00:51:29,353 --> 00:51:32,271
I am dealing with some really bad stuff.

666
00:51:32,395 --> 00:51:35,271
- Oh, really?
- Ben is in big trouble.

667
00:51:36,062 --> 00:51:38,938
It's bad. He'll need a lawyer.

668
00:51:40,270 --> 00:51:42,854
So you do have money.

669
00:51:43,228 --> 00:51:45,188
No, I don't.

670
00:51:45,437 --> 00:51:47,670
Lawyers cost money.

671
00:51:47,770 --> 00:51:51,837
Okay, you got jewelry, don't you? You got some
jewelry, what about that ring I gave you?

672
00:51:51,937 --> 00:51:53,462
- The engagement ring?
- Yeah, the engagement ring.

673
00:51:53,562 --> 00:51:56,104
If what was worth anything
I would have pawned it off years ago.

674
00:51:56,228 --> 00:51:59,962
What about this? What about this?
Those are real rubies, right?

675
00:52:00,062 --> 00:52:02,587
That is my grandmother's cross and
you know how much that means to me

676
00:52:02,687 --> 00:52:04,396
and that stays in my family.

677
00:52:04,520 --> 00:52:07,979
You're going to be really sorry, Patty.

678
00:52:08,562 --> 00:52:11,104
I've been sorry a long time.

679
00:52:28,728 --> 00:52:30,545
Bye, girls.

680
00:52:30,645 --> 00:52:34,479
Your mom is a cunt!

681
00:52:36,312 --> 00:52:38,563
Thanks for fucking nothing!

682
00:53:07,728 --> 00:53:10,229
We don't open for another hour.

683
00:53:12,312 --> 00:53:16,545
Oh, I'm sorry, honey.
This is a men's hostel.

684
00:53:16,645 --> 00:53:20,545
I'm looking for someone.
Runner Day. Are you the manager?

685
00:53:20,645 --> 00:53:23,212
Manager, accountant, priest.

686
00:53:23,312 --> 00:53:24,920
But he's gone again.

687
00:53:25,020 --> 00:53:28,212
I don't allow drinkers here,
and he just got his third strike.

688
00:53:28,312 --> 00:53:29,771
You know where I could find him?

689
00:53:29,895 --> 00:53:33,188
Well, I would bet anything
he's living at that toxic waste site.

690
00:53:33,312 --> 00:53:36,813
That's an old dumping spot
for grasshopper bait.

691
00:53:36,937 --> 00:53:38,979
Loaded with arsenic.

692
00:53:39,395 --> 00:53:42,229
Just prepare yourself
for some disappointment.

693
00:53:49,728 --> 00:53:51,854
<i>I wonder what it said about me?</i>

694
00:53:54,937 --> 00:53:58,646
<i>That my own father was living
in a toxic waste dump.</i>

695
00:55:11,895 --> 00:55:14,896
- Don't even think about...
- Put the gun down!

696
00:55:15,686 --> 00:55:17,562
It's your daughter!

697
00:55:19,645 --> 00:55:21,396
Prove it.

698
00:55:22,978 --> 00:55:24,354
I can't prove it.

699
00:55:32,561 --> 00:55:35,896
Well, well, come on down.

700
00:55:44,270 --> 00:55:46,229
Come on down!

701
00:56:00,686 --> 00:56:02,479
- No, don't touch me.
- Daddy's got ya.

702
00:56:02,603 --> 00:56:04,461
- Get your hands off me!
- Remember when you were a little girl?

703
00:56:04,561 --> 00:56:07,312
- Runner! No! No!
- Say uncle!

704
00:56:07,436 --> 00:56:09,062
- Let me go! No!
- Say uncle!

705
00:56:09,186 --> 00:56:11,729
- Say uncle!
- Uncle! Fuck!

706
00:56:22,436 --> 00:56:24,104
Jesus.

707
00:56:26,728 --> 00:56:29,437
How long has it been
since I've seen you?

708
00:56:31,061 --> 00:56:34,687
Do you remember
that flamingo ashtray I sent you?

709
00:56:35,395 --> 00:56:38,562
Yeah, when I was 10 years old
and a non-smoker.

710
00:56:38,811 --> 00:56:40,646
Nice?

711
00:56:45,020 --> 00:56:47,187
You know why I'm here, Runner.

712
00:56:49,686 --> 00:56:53,062
It's time you tell the truth
about the murders.

713
00:56:58,020 --> 00:57:00,295
Ben was no babe in the woods.

714
00:57:00,395 --> 00:57:03,937
You hang with the devil and sooner
or later you're going to have to pay.

715
00:57:04,561 --> 00:57:07,771
I should have known it, as soon
as I saw him with that goddamn Injun.

716
00:57:08,103 --> 00:57:11,104
- Who?
- Trey Teepano.

717
00:57:13,270 --> 00:57:15,229
You know what? Boy!

718
00:57:15,353 --> 00:57:18,646
People don't know shit about
what really happened that night.

719
00:57:21,770 --> 00:57:24,187
Who ended up with the money?

720
00:57:25,603 --> 00:57:28,521
- 'Cause it sure as hell wasn't me.
- You know we had no money.

721
00:57:28,645 --> 00:57:32,687
Your mom had money.
Your queen bitch mom!

722
00:57:33,020 --> 00:57:36,604
What happened to Patty's life insurance
money? 'Cause I sure as shit didn't get it.

723
00:57:36,728 --> 00:57:39,104
You know it went to Diane.
She used it to defend Ben.

724
00:57:39,228 --> 00:57:42,604
I worked years on that farm
and I never received a dime!

725
00:57:43,019 --> 00:57:45,020
That bitch even asked me for alimony!

726
00:57:47,269 --> 00:57:49,354
Is that what happened?

727
00:57:51,811 --> 00:57:54,770
You go there that night,
ask her for money?

728
00:57:56,228 --> 00:57:58,229
Get in a fight.

729
00:57:58,561 --> 00:58:03,437
What I'm trying to tell you is that Trey
was a bookie who needed to get paid.

730
00:58:03,728 --> 00:58:07,645
- And what, you owed him money?
- No, no, no.

731
00:58:07,769 --> 00:58:10,229
You want everything for free.

732
00:58:10,603 --> 00:58:13,895
And you wrote that book.
You wrote a book, right?

733
00:58:14,019 --> 00:58:15,895
- So you have got money!
- I don't have...

734
00:58:16,019 --> 00:58:19,479
- You've got money.
- Get your fucking hands off me!

735
00:58:22,394 --> 00:58:23,437
Fuck!

736
00:58:28,228 --> 00:58:30,229
Are you scared of me?

737
00:58:39,978 --> 00:58:42,145
Where were you that night, Runner?

738
00:58:44,019 --> 00:58:46,270
I don't remember a thing.

739
00:59:04,603 --> 00:59:08,187
Hey, did they ever find Diadra?

740
00:59:11,061 --> 00:59:12,336
You mean Diondra?

741
00:59:12,436 --> 00:59:14,770
I always wondered
if they killed her that night.

742
00:59:16,936 --> 00:59:19,020
What are you talking about?

743
00:59:19,519 --> 00:59:21,229
That's what they do, don't they?

744
00:59:21,728 --> 00:59:23,895
Devil worshipers?

745
00:59:24,019 --> 00:59:27,729
They kill pregnant ladies
and their babies.

746
00:59:40,769 --> 00:59:42,520
You are.

747
00:59:44,811 --> 00:59:46,687
Hey, Runner.

748
00:59:49,061 --> 00:59:50,419
Come here.

749
00:59:50,519 --> 00:59:54,711
I don't have it, man.
I tried to scrape it together.

750
00:59:54,811 --> 00:59:56,604
I did, but I just don't.

751
00:59:56,728 --> 00:59:59,395
Hey, honey. You gonna say hi to me?

752
01:00:00,603 --> 01:00:02,628
Diondra. I must be oblivious here,

753
01:00:02,728 --> 01:00:05,628
I'm drinking myself cross-eyed because
I'm so worried about this situation.

754
01:00:05,728 --> 01:00:07,937
See, I don't get it Runner.
You say you don't have any money,

755
01:00:08,061 --> 01:00:10,669
yet you had that giant stack of weed
just a few weeks ago.

756
01:00:10,769 --> 01:00:13,003
I didn't charge you nothin'.

757
01:00:13,103 --> 01:00:16,562
Because you owe me! You guys love
to gamble, but you never want to pay!

758
01:00:16,686 --> 01:00:18,711
I would say
that's an exaggeration, Trey.

759
01:00:18,811 --> 01:00:22,020
I know someone else who needs money.

760
01:00:24,561 --> 01:00:28,503
God. Look at this black hair you have.

761
01:00:28,603 --> 01:00:31,270
I didn't know you knew Trey.
You owe him money?

762
01:00:31,394 --> 01:00:33,211
No, I don't owe him anything.

763
01:00:33,311 --> 01:00:36,479
He wants money for his girl.
Tomorrow night.

764
01:00:36,978 --> 01:00:39,437
Here. Or so help me, Runner...

765
01:00:40,311 --> 01:00:41,395
I will hurt you.

766
01:00:44,519 --> 01:00:46,770
Hey, I want to tell you something.

767
01:00:47,519 --> 01:00:51,770
- What?
- I... I got Diondra... She's...

768
01:00:52,394 --> 01:00:55,229
I got her pregnant. We're having a baby.

769
01:00:58,561 --> 01:01:00,604
Make sure it's yours.

770
01:01:01,186 --> 01:01:03,770
Okay? 'Cause I doubt it is.

771
01:01:05,603 --> 01:01:06,836
Look...

772
01:01:06,936 --> 01:01:11,478
Why would a rich slut like her
hang around a loser like you?

773
01:01:13,269 --> 01:01:15,103
Think about it.

774
01:01:29,227 --> 01:01:31,228
You okay, baby?

775
01:01:33,102 --> 01:01:35,312
Someone should fucking die.

776
01:01:38,644 --> 01:01:40,520
You got anything?

777
01:01:41,936 --> 01:01:43,937
In the glove compartment.

778
01:01:59,811 --> 01:02:01,502
What is that stuff?

779
01:02:01,602 --> 01:02:04,270
Devil's rush. Ever had it?

780
01:02:13,477 --> 01:02:16,044
- Come on.
- No, man. I don't need it.

781
01:02:16,144 --> 01:02:19,895
You're gonna need it, do it.
Maybe later you become a man?

782
01:02:20,352 --> 01:02:21,544
Maybe.

783
01:02:21,644 --> 01:02:24,520
Come on, baby. Come on.

784
01:02:28,602 --> 01:02:30,228
Yeah!

785
01:02:33,186 --> 01:02:36,728
- No, I want the axe!
- Too heavy for you.

786
01:02:41,686 --> 01:02:44,812
It's sharp, so don't fuck around.

787
01:03:00,519 --> 01:03:04,211
To Satan, we bring our sacrifices.

788
01:03:04,311 --> 01:03:07,395
We bring pain, blood, fear...

789
01:03:08,852 --> 01:03:11,437
rage. Basis of human life.

790
01:03:12,936 --> 01:03:16,336
In your power, we become more powerful.

791
01:03:16,436 --> 01:03:18,228
That one.

792
01:03:18,644 --> 01:03:22,520
In your exaltation, we become exalted.

793
01:03:26,394 --> 01:03:29,770
We're going to make your baby
a fucking warrior tonight, Dio!

794
01:03:36,769 --> 01:03:38,062
Come on, baby!

795
01:03:38,186 --> 01:03:41,645
You can't just fucking stand there,
it's time to get your kill!

796
01:03:43,394 --> 01:03:45,812
This is your chance, dude. Be a man!

797
01:03:46,019 --> 01:03:49,812
I used to be like you. I don't
ever want to go back there again!

798
01:03:50,561 --> 01:03:53,711
Don't be a scared,
dickless boy the rest of your life!

799
01:03:53,811 --> 01:03:56,270
Aren't you tired of being scared?

800
01:03:56,727 --> 01:03:58,478
Come on!

801
01:04:04,602 --> 01:04:07,336
- You trust Runner over me?
- I don't trust anyone.

802
01:04:07,436 --> 01:04:10,270
How much? How much money
are they paying you?

803
01:04:11,269 --> 01:04:13,978
- I don't know what you're talking about.
- You thought I didn't know about that?

804
01:04:14,102 --> 01:04:16,603
Yeah, I got paid.
It's not about that anymore.

805
01:04:16,727 --> 01:04:19,794
What is it about, the truth?
Listen, there's no way you can win this.

806
01:04:19,894 --> 01:04:24,294
If I tell you I'm innocent,
that means you ruined my life, sister.

807
01:04:24,394 --> 01:04:26,770
And if I tell you I'm guilty, that doesn't
make you feel much better now...

808
01:04:26,894 --> 01:04:28,627
- Where's Diondra?
- Oh, let it go. I have.

809
01:04:28,727 --> 01:04:31,353
- What'd you do with the baby, Ben?
- What baby?

810
01:04:31,727 --> 01:04:34,127
- Are you going to keep bullshitting me?
- Let it go, Libby.

811
01:04:34,227 --> 01:04:35,544
What about Trey Teepano?

812
01:04:35,644 --> 01:04:38,603
He said what he had to say
on the witness stand.

813
01:04:38,727 --> 01:04:40,645
That's too easy.

814
01:04:41,394 --> 01:04:43,335
You listen to me.

815
01:04:43,435 --> 01:04:47,145
Today... I can forgive your past lie.

816
01:04:47,560 --> 01:04:49,936
For being confused as a kid.

817
01:04:50,560 --> 01:04:52,728
But god damn it, you're a grown-up now.

818
01:04:53,144 --> 01:04:55,544
Do you really think that our blood
could do something like that?

819
01:04:55,644 --> 01:04:58,228
I totally believe our blood
could do something like that.

820
01:04:58,352 --> 01:05:00,561
I've beaten the shit out of people, Ben.

821
01:05:00,685 --> 01:05:03,895
I've busted in doors and windows,
I've killed things!

822
01:05:06,060 --> 01:05:09,103
Half the time I look down
and my hands are in fists.

823
01:05:10,810 --> 01:05:14,460
- Do you really believe we're that bad?
- I do.

824
01:05:14,560 --> 01:05:16,770
Even with Mom's blood.

825
01:05:18,394 --> 01:05:20,020
Even with.

826
01:05:22,352 --> 01:05:26,103
- Then I'm sad for you, little girl.
- Go fuck yourself!

827
01:05:26,519 --> 01:05:29,669
- Is that funny to you?
- No. It's ironic.

828
01:05:29,769 --> 01:05:31,710
What?

829
01:05:31,810 --> 01:05:34,395
You're just as imprisoned as I am.

830
01:06:10,935 --> 01:06:15,210
- It's okay, sweetie.
- No, it's not. I want Ben back.

831
01:06:15,310 --> 01:06:19,645
Why can't we find him?
Is he in trouble because of his hair?

832
01:06:19,977 --> 01:06:22,395
No, it's because of sex.
Everyone at school knows.

833
01:06:23,894 --> 01:06:25,603
What are you talking about?

834
01:06:27,935 --> 01:06:29,895
Ben is your brother, you don't talk
hateful about your brother.

835
01:06:30,019 --> 01:06:32,294
But, Mom, I don't like Ben!

836
01:06:32,394 --> 01:06:35,145
He's bad, he does bad things!

837
01:06:39,477 --> 01:06:43,544
Has he ever touched you in a strange way
or an unbrotherly way?

838
01:06:43,644 --> 01:06:47,335
The only time he touches me
is when he's pushing me or pulling my hair.

839
01:06:47,435 --> 01:06:48,877
Mom, he's a freak!

840
01:06:48,977 --> 01:06:52,603
It's embarrassing, just go in his room,
he's got all sorts of weird stuff.

841
01:06:53,394 --> 01:06:55,436
You snooped in his room?

842
01:08:17,352 --> 01:08:21,668
- Hello?
- <i>Patty? It's Joseph, from the FHA.</i>

843
01:08:21,768 --> 01:08:25,061
Joseph, I can't find the money.
I've had a rough day.

844
01:08:25,185 --> 01:08:29,269
<i>Yes, I heard about Ben.
I wasn't going to phone you.</i>

845
01:08:29,393 --> 01:08:32,335
<i>But how should I say this.
Patty, I trust you.</i>

846
01:08:32,435 --> 01:08:34,436
<i>I pray for you.</i>

847
01:08:34,727 --> 01:08:37,186
<i>I may have a solution to your problem.</i>

848
01:08:37,310 --> 01:08:39,877
I thought we were out of options.

849
01:08:39,977 --> 01:08:42,019
<i>Not entirely.</i>

850
01:08:43,935 --> 01:08:45,293
- Yeah.
- <i>Libby, Libby.</i>

851
01:08:45,393 --> 01:08:48,728
<i>We found Diondra Sue Wertzner.
Born on March 28th, 1968.</i>

852
01:08:48,852 --> 01:08:53,627
<i>Was officially reported missing on October
19th, 1985, and has never been found.</i>

853
01:08:53,727 --> 01:08:56,061
So what the fuck does that mean?
She's dead?

854
01:08:56,185 --> 01:08:59,519
<i>I don't know, we can't be sure.
But did Ben tell you anything?</i>

855
01:09:01,102 --> 01:09:02,811
Hang on.

856
01:09:16,143 --> 01:09:17,853
Hey.

857
01:09:18,518 --> 01:09:20,353
Told you I'd pay you back.

858
01:09:21,268 --> 01:09:23,769
When I saw your name on that note...

859
01:09:23,893 --> 01:09:28,210
I should have recognized you right away,
but... I kinda followed your story,

860
01:09:28,310 --> 01:09:31,644
- but it's been such a long time ago.
- What do you want?

861
01:09:33,935 --> 01:09:36,811
You're not gonna make this
easy for me, are you?

862
01:09:39,435 --> 01:09:41,269
Fair enough.

863
01:09:43,393 --> 01:09:45,502
<i>I was a pretty girl.</i>

864
01:09:45,602 --> 01:09:47,377
<i>I was good in school.</i>

865
01:09:47,477 --> 01:09:50,543
<i>And Ben... he did volunteer work.</i>

866
01:09:50,643 --> 01:09:52,894
<i>He gave drawing lessons.</i>

867
01:09:53,268 --> 01:09:55,561
<i>I had a big crush on him.</i>

868
01:09:56,018 --> 01:09:58,377
<i>We started hanging out together.</i>

869
01:09:58,477 --> 01:10:01,418
<i>I know we were both kids,
but he was old enough...</i>

870
01:10:01,518 --> 01:10:03,769
<i>to not have encouraged me.</i>

871
01:10:08,060 --> 01:10:11,144
It was my first big grown-up kiss.

872
01:10:11,602 --> 01:10:14,061
It only lasted about a second.

873
01:10:14,185 --> 01:10:18,043
And afterwards, of course, he told me
that we should never do it again,

874
01:10:18,143 --> 01:10:20,228
'cause it was wrong.

875
01:10:21,518 --> 01:10:23,686
But he kept writing me notes.

876
01:10:23,977 --> 01:10:26,853
But he refused to spend
any more time with me.

877
01:10:27,393 --> 01:10:29,478
And I was furious.

878
01:10:29,893 --> 01:10:34,668
Then, about a week later
I went to a slumber party

879
01:10:34,768 --> 01:10:37,353
and I told all the girls
about my high school boyfriend.

880
01:10:38,352 --> 01:10:40,353
All proud.

881
01:10:41,143 --> 01:10:43,519
And I made up things that we did.

882
01:10:43,643 --> 01:10:46,394
And from there it just snowballed.

883
01:10:46,518 --> 01:10:51,228
We made up this whole imaginary world,
where Ben was a devil worshiper.

884
01:10:51,602 --> 01:10:55,686
Kind of stories we saw on the news
every day when we were kids.

885
01:11:21,185 --> 01:11:22,936
Ma'am.

886
01:11:24,810 --> 01:11:27,668
Your son is about to be arrested,
and I know what for.

887
01:11:27,768 --> 01:11:31,835
In this next year you will need some money
so you can keep your children at home.

888
01:11:31,935 --> 01:11:33,644
And you will need a good lawyer...

889
01:11:34,143 --> 01:11:38,210
'cause you don't want your son
going to prison labeled a child molester.

890
01:11:38,310 --> 01:11:39,811
What do you have to offer?

891
01:11:41,060 --> 01:11:45,352
Now I myself was once a farmer.
My dad before me and his dad before him.

892
01:11:46,393 --> 01:11:48,394
But we farmers, we'd been swindled.

893
01:11:48,518 --> 01:11:51,102
"Plant fence post to fence post,"
they said.

894
01:11:51,226 --> 01:11:54,894
"Oh, and then buy more land, because,
well, they ain't making any more of it."

895
01:11:55,310 --> 01:11:59,519
Then, whoops. "We're sorry,
we gave you some bad advice.

896
01:12:00,393 --> 01:12:02,644
"We'll just take your farm."

897
01:12:03,351 --> 01:12:05,852
What does this have to do with my son?

898
01:12:07,810 --> 01:12:10,686
Ma'am. I'm no businessman.

899
01:12:11,685 --> 01:12:13,602
And I'm no judge.

900
01:12:14,101 --> 01:12:16,710
I'm certainly no politician.

901
01:12:16,810 --> 01:12:19,102
But if you're brave enough...

902
01:12:19,226 --> 01:12:21,894
I'll give you a real chance
to help your family.

903
01:13:42,060 --> 01:13:43,710
Your brother needs you, Libby.

904
01:13:43,810 --> 01:13:45,977
He doesn't, and he's been
pretty clear about that.

905
01:13:46,393 --> 01:13:49,460
Now that you've explored the case
with all its inconsistencies,

906
01:13:49,560 --> 01:13:52,561
don't you think that Ben deserves
a new, fair trial?

907
01:13:52,935 --> 01:13:55,144
Based on what evidence?

908
01:13:55,268 --> 01:13:57,769
What do we know for sure?
He's lying about Diondra. Why?

909
01:13:57,893 --> 01:14:01,894
But, everybody's a liar.
I lied to get you to KC.

910
01:14:02,226 --> 01:14:05,668
You lied when you said you saw what happened
that day, it doesn't make us murderers.

911
01:14:05,768 --> 01:14:08,644
What makes you so sure I lied?

912
01:14:11,893 --> 01:14:15,144
Why are you so obsessed with this case?

913
01:14:15,268 --> 01:14:17,852
It's not even your story, it's mine.

914
01:14:19,185 --> 01:14:23,168
It's a fascinating puzzle, a mystery
with lots of different theories.

915
01:14:23,268 --> 01:14:26,936
Most of all, there's you
and Ben and Krissi.

916
01:14:27,060 --> 01:14:31,460
Kids who started events that became bigger
than them and had major repercussions.

917
01:14:31,560 --> 01:14:34,477
- I'm fascinated by that.
- Why?

918
01:14:38,768 --> 01:14:42,269
You ever heard about those wildfires
near San Bernardino in 1999?

919
01:14:42,393 --> 01:14:46,210
They destroyed, like, 80 homes
and about 90,000 acres?

920
01:14:46,310 --> 01:14:48,977
I don't know, seems like California
is always burning.

921
01:14:50,393 --> 01:14:52,936
I was the kid who set that fire.

922
01:14:56,851 --> 01:14:59,061
Then shouldn't you have become
a firefighter or something,

923
01:14:59,185 --> 01:15:01,436
overcome your trauma that way?

924
01:15:07,893 --> 01:15:10,852
- So, did you?
- Did I what?

925
01:15:11,309 --> 01:15:13,352
Did you lie that day in court?

926
01:15:32,726 --> 01:15:34,394
Hello?

927
01:15:40,393 --> 01:15:42,060
Hello?

928
01:15:51,393 --> 01:15:53,102
- Can I help you?
- Hey.

929
01:15:53,226 --> 01:15:55,435
We're looking for Trey Teepano.

930
01:15:55,559 --> 01:15:57,043
That'd be me.

931
01:15:57,143 --> 01:15:59,810
Want to talk to you about Ben Day.
My brother.

932
01:16:13,226 --> 01:16:16,626
You're the one who lived? Debbie?

933
01:16:16,726 --> 01:16:18,269
Libby.

934
01:16:18,809 --> 01:16:21,060
You remember Runner Day?

935
01:16:21,393 --> 01:16:23,560
He said you were a bookie
or something, back then.

936
01:16:24,393 --> 01:16:27,060
Yeah. Runner owed me a lot of money.

937
01:16:28,476 --> 01:16:30,810
Still does, I guess.

938
01:16:32,184 --> 01:16:34,894
It doesn't mean I know what happened
in your house that night.

939
01:16:35,268 --> 01:16:38,834
- You were into devil worshiping?
- I'm reformed now.

940
01:16:38,934 --> 01:16:41,769
I'm a good God-fearin' Indian.

941
01:16:44,226 --> 01:16:47,019
You remember Diondra Wertzner?

942
01:16:47,893 --> 01:16:49,668
Your brother...

943
01:16:49,768 --> 01:16:52,001
Your brother was crazy about that girl.

944
01:16:52,101 --> 01:16:55,668
Parents neglected her,
so she was always creating drama.

945
01:16:55,768 --> 01:16:59,584
She'd run away, come back home.
Total soap opera.

946
01:16:59,684 --> 01:17:01,685
This time, I guess,
she just ran away for good?

947
01:17:01,851 --> 01:17:05,501
She's been listed
as a missing person for 25 years.

948
01:17:05,601 --> 01:17:08,852
Yeah, she was one of them girls
who was always trying to be someone else.

949
01:17:08,976 --> 01:17:13,477
Yeah, she'd talk in an English accent
one day and next day it'd be Southern.

950
01:17:14,059 --> 01:17:15,626
She liked to use her porn name, too.

951
01:17:15,726 --> 01:17:19,418
- She did porn?
- No. It was that game.

952
01:17:19,518 --> 01:17:21,977
What was the name of your childhood pet?

953
01:17:24,351 --> 01:17:25,293
Crazy.

954
01:17:25,393 --> 01:17:26,751
What was the name of the street
you grew up on?

955
01:17:26,851 --> 01:17:28,935
Rural Route 2.

956
01:17:30,226 --> 01:17:33,834
Well, that's not going to work.
It's supposed to sound slutty.

957
01:17:33,934 --> 01:17:36,293
You know, like Bambi Evergreen.

958
01:17:36,393 --> 01:17:39,810
What was Diondra's...
It was... Polly something...

959
01:17:41,643 --> 01:17:42,977
Polly Palm.

960
01:17:44,559 --> 01:17:47,168
What was the name your brother
had tattooed on his arm?

961
01:17:47,268 --> 01:17:49,894
- Oh, my God!
- It was Polly, right?

962
01:17:51,476 --> 01:17:53,769
I got her. Polly Palm
in Kearney, Missouri.

963
01:17:53,893 --> 01:17:57,602
The only one listed in the whole country
apart for a nail boutique in Shreveport.

964
01:18:12,309 --> 01:18:15,102
<i>Something like me,
with open arms, I tell you...</i>

965
01:18:17,518 --> 01:18:21,310
I don't feel good.
I think I need something to eat.

966
01:18:26,226 --> 01:18:27,769
What?

967
01:18:29,476 --> 01:18:31,310
You're fucked.

968
01:18:32,184 --> 01:18:34,834
<i>Hey, Dio, it's Megan.
I'm totally freaked out about Ben Day.</i>

969
01:18:34,934 --> 01:18:37,060
<i>Did you hear he molested
all those girls?</i>

970
01:18:38,851 --> 01:18:41,893
<i>Hey, Diondra, it's Jenny.
I hear Ben's running from the cops.</i>

971
01:18:42,017 --> 01:18:44,852
<i>You're not with him, are you?
Please tell me you're not with him.</i>

972
01:18:54,726 --> 01:18:58,602
- I guess I should go home.
- Okay, and what?

973
01:18:58,726 --> 01:19:00,393
Leave me here while you go to jail?

974
01:19:00,726 --> 01:19:02,935
- What do you want me to do?
- We're leaving town tonight.

975
01:19:03,059 --> 01:19:06,810
I have like $200 left from my parents.
How much do you have at your place?

976
01:19:08,059 --> 01:19:12,209
I've got some saved up. My mom...
she's got, like, 500 or 600 lying around.

977
01:19:12,309 --> 01:19:15,560
- But I don't know where.
- Yeah, all right, we'll go there. Okay.

978
01:19:15,684 --> 01:19:18,501
If we don't see a cop car outside,
we'll go inside, we'll get the cash,

979
01:19:18,601 --> 01:19:21,667
we'll pack a bag and we'll get
the fuck out of here, okay?

980
01:19:21,767 --> 01:19:25,060
And then what?
What fucking planet are you on?

981
01:19:25,767 --> 01:19:28,060
Are you even sure this kid's mine?

982
01:19:28,559 --> 01:19:31,227
How dare you!

983
01:19:39,892 --> 01:19:41,477
Ben.

984
01:19:42,934 --> 01:19:46,102
Ben, baby, I love you, you know.

985
01:19:46,601 --> 01:19:48,209
And I swear to God this child's yours.

986
01:19:48,309 --> 01:19:50,459
I swear to God, but you got
to get me out of town, okay?

987
01:19:50,559 --> 01:19:53,727
And we gotta head west otherwise...
otherwise you're in jail.

988
01:19:54,934 --> 01:19:58,477
You're in jail and I'm dead from my daddy.
He'll make me have the baby...

989
01:19:58,976 --> 01:20:00,977
and then he'll kill me.

990
01:20:35,059 --> 01:20:36,310
Yeah?

991
01:20:38,226 --> 01:20:40,143
You know who I am?

992
01:20:43,226 --> 01:20:46,268
Holy crap! Libby.

993
01:20:46,809 --> 01:20:49,060
I always thought you'd find me someday.

994
01:20:49,559 --> 01:20:51,393
Smart girl.

995
01:20:53,351 --> 01:20:54,977
Stay!

996
01:20:55,351 --> 01:20:57,584
So this is out of the blue.

997
01:20:57,684 --> 01:21:01,643
I mean, why come looking for me now?
Did Ben say something to you?

998
01:21:02,601 --> 01:21:04,167
No, that's why I'm here.

999
01:21:04,267 --> 01:21:09,102
So you think that once you know
the truth... you'll find peace?

1000
01:21:09,392 --> 01:21:12,227
Like, somehow that will fix you?

1001
01:21:17,142 --> 01:21:19,310
I was with Ben that night.

1002
01:21:20,559 --> 01:21:22,727
We were going to skip town.

1003
01:21:22,851 --> 01:21:25,792
And he went to his house
to get some money.

1004
01:21:25,892 --> 01:21:28,477
An hour goes by, two hours.

1005
01:21:28,684 --> 01:21:31,393
Finally, I thought he lost his nerve.

1006
01:21:32,267 --> 01:21:34,893
Cried myself to sleep that night.

1007
01:21:37,101 --> 01:21:38,893
In the morning...

1008
01:21:39,767 --> 01:21:41,352
when I heard about the murders.

1009
01:21:42,601 --> 01:21:44,602
Packed my bags,

1010
01:21:44,726 --> 01:21:48,935
left a note for my father telling him
I was not his little girl anymore.

1011
01:21:49,601 --> 01:21:51,667
Skipped town for good.

1012
01:21:51,767 --> 01:21:54,810
Ben never gave my name to the police.

1013
01:21:57,101 --> 01:21:59,393
After all these years...

1014
01:22:00,101 --> 01:22:02,268
he protected me.

1015
01:22:08,267 --> 01:22:11,435
So, no one but him knows
what happened that night.

1016
01:22:11,892 --> 01:22:16,185
I do think you that you could find
this peace that you're looking for

1017
01:22:16,309 --> 01:22:18,226
if you accept that.

1018
01:22:18,350 --> 01:22:20,060
Look, I hate to say this,

1019
01:22:20,184 --> 01:22:24,518
but whatever happened,
and as much as I loved Ben...

1020
01:22:26,225 --> 01:22:28,667
he needed to be in that prison.

1021
01:22:28,767 --> 01:22:33,893
There was something inside your brother
that was not right for the outside world.

1022
01:22:41,392 --> 01:22:43,226
You were pregnant.

1023
01:22:48,559 --> 01:22:50,810
What happened to the baby?

1024
01:22:51,392 --> 01:22:53,393
I'm here.

1025
01:23:34,267 --> 01:23:37,351
What are you doing?
I told you to wait in the car.

1026
01:23:39,559 --> 01:23:41,726
I know you did, but...

1027
01:23:42,934 --> 01:23:46,000
- Baby, I'm hearing voices in my head.
- Hey, you got to be quiet, okay.

1028
01:23:46,100 --> 01:23:48,625
- I don't want to be alone.
- I know.

1029
01:23:48,725 --> 01:23:51,601
It's just the drugs.
They'll wear off, okay.

1030
01:23:53,392 --> 01:23:54,726
I like your house.

1031
01:24:02,600 --> 01:24:03,685
Be quiet.

1032
01:24:14,725 --> 01:24:16,560
What's going on?

1033
01:24:17,225 --> 01:24:19,393
Somebody's been in my room.

1034
01:24:20,392 --> 01:24:22,101
Oh, God. You don't...

1035
01:24:23,225 --> 01:24:25,709
You don't think it's the cops, do you?

1036
01:24:25,809 --> 01:24:27,226
I don't know.

1037
01:24:28,559 --> 01:24:30,893
I got a present for you, for the baby.

1038
01:24:34,225 --> 01:24:36,560
- You got me a present?
- Yeah, but it's not here.

1039
01:24:41,059 --> 01:24:42,768
Who is that?

1040
01:24:42,892 --> 01:24:46,435
It's okay, it's just Libby,
she's going into Mom's room.

1041
01:25:03,642 --> 01:25:05,351
There's less than I thought.

1042
01:25:06,309 --> 01:25:08,893
I fucking know it was Michelle.

1043
01:25:10,434 --> 01:25:14,018
It was Michelle that stole
my fucking present, that nosy little bitch.

1044
01:25:19,559 --> 01:25:21,685
This doesn't feel right.

1045
01:25:31,559 --> 01:25:34,518
- I knew it! I heard everything!
- Come here!

1046
01:25:35,725 --> 01:25:37,685
Get out of my way.

1047
01:25:38,433 --> 01:25:40,393
You don't say another word,
you little bitch!

1048
01:25:40,517 --> 01:25:43,708
- Stop! Stop! She's not gonna say anything.
- Ben, get off me.

1049
01:25:43,808 --> 01:25:45,268
Come here.

1050
01:25:50,933 --> 01:25:53,184
Diondra, stop it! Stop!

1051
01:25:55,058 --> 01:25:57,268
Dio, stop. You'll wake up
the whole fucking house.

1052
01:25:57,392 --> 01:25:58,958
If you think I'm going to spend
my entire fucking life

1053
01:25:59,058 --> 01:26:01,208
worrying about this little bitch,
you're wrong, Ben!

1054
01:26:01,308 --> 01:26:04,125
Get off of her. Dio, stop. Listen to me.

1055
01:26:04,225 --> 01:26:06,476
We'll talk to her, okay?
She'll understand. Stop.

1056
01:26:08,017 --> 01:26:09,684
Ben?

1057
01:26:10,058 --> 01:26:12,851
Hey! It's okay. Okay?

1058
01:26:21,933 --> 01:26:24,643
I was never supposed to meet you.

1059
01:26:26,183 --> 01:26:28,309
I'm a secret, you know.

1060
01:26:31,267 --> 01:26:33,518
A secret love child.

1061
01:26:34,267 --> 01:26:36,101
That's right, baby.

1062
01:26:36,225 --> 01:26:39,143
Crystal knows the whole story.
I tell her everything.

1063
01:26:39,558 --> 01:26:41,434
We're best friends.

1064
01:26:41,725 --> 01:26:43,309
I read your book, too.

1065
01:26:44,767 --> 01:26:48,226
I even have a little scrapbook
of photos of all of you.

1066
01:26:48,892 --> 01:26:53,393
Clipped out of magazines and stuff.
It's like a fake family photo album.

1067
01:26:58,100 --> 01:26:59,934
Can I call you Aunt Libby?

1068
01:27:03,058 --> 01:27:07,101
I know, I know that this
is a lot to take in.

1069
01:27:09,267 --> 01:27:11,559
You want a drink?

1070
01:27:12,392 --> 01:27:17,018
- I need to use your bathroom.
- It's just up the stairs.

1071
01:27:35,975 --> 01:27:37,250
- Yeah?
- <i>Libby.</i>

1072
01:27:37,350 --> 01:27:39,518
I know the whole story now.
You need to hear this.

1073
01:27:39,767 --> 01:27:41,958
- What are you talking about?
- <i>You remember the theory</i>

1074
01:27:42,058 --> 01:27:45,000
the Kill Club had about the serial killer
they called the Angel of Debt?

1075
01:27:45,100 --> 01:27:48,042
- Yeah?
- <i>They got him, I mean, we got him.</i>

1076
01:27:48,142 --> 01:27:52,333
One of our members posed as a bankrupt
hedge fund manager in a suburb of Chicago

1077
01:27:52,433 --> 01:27:55,333
and this guy Calvin Diehl,
tried to help him stage his death.

1078
01:27:55,433 --> 01:27:58,667
<i>Diehl used to be a farmer who lost everything
to the banks in the Soviet embargo.</i>

1079
01:27:58,767 --> 01:28:01,393
- So what?
- He's been at it since the '80s.

1080
01:28:01,517 --> 01:28:04,143
Making suicides look like
accidents or murders.

1081
01:28:04,642 --> 01:28:06,393
What the fuck are you talking about?

1082
01:28:07,308 --> 01:28:09,893
Your mother had hired him
for that night.

1083
01:28:13,308 --> 01:28:14,934
Are you sure?

1084
01:28:18,058 --> 01:28:21,583
Listen, Lyle, can you come get me?

1085
01:28:21,683 --> 01:28:23,393
<i>Okay.</i>

1086
01:28:23,767 --> 01:28:25,042
- Libby?
- Yeah?

1087
01:28:25,142 --> 01:28:29,059
- Is everything okay?
- Yeah, I'm fine. I just need a second.

1088
01:28:29,975 --> 01:28:34,434
- I'm sorry, but I really need to go.
- I'll be out in a second, okay?

1089
01:28:40,350 --> 01:28:41,934
Fuck!

1090
01:29:11,516 --> 01:29:13,351
Libby?

1091
01:29:13,933 --> 01:29:17,434
Yeah. Yeah, I'm coming.

1092
01:29:28,808 --> 01:29:30,666
You okay?

1093
01:29:30,766 --> 01:29:32,767
Yeah, I'm fine.

1094
01:29:32,891 --> 01:29:35,392
Listen, I'm gonna wait outside,
my friend is coming for me.

1095
01:29:35,516 --> 01:29:39,208
I really need you to keep this
a secret, okay? I can't risk it.

1096
01:29:39,308 --> 01:29:41,559
Them thinking I'm an accomplice,
you understand?

1097
01:29:41,850 --> 01:29:45,892
Why would they think that?
Were you at the house that night?

1098
01:29:52,891 --> 01:29:54,392
No!

1099
01:30:35,850 --> 01:30:39,226
Don't worry, it'll all be over
in about 30 seconds.

1100
01:30:42,725 --> 01:30:43,958
Go tell Mom.

1101
01:30:44,058 --> 01:30:46,934
- Come here!
- Get the fuck off her!

1102
01:30:52,016 --> 01:30:55,625
- What the hell?
- Mom, they're hurting Michelle!

1103
01:30:55,725 --> 01:30:57,809
Run! Run!

1104
01:31:01,683 --> 01:31:04,476
No! No, please don't! No!

1105
01:31:07,350 --> 01:31:08,500
Why'd you make me do this?

1106
01:31:08,600 --> 01:31:11,309
- No! No, please. No!
- This wasn't the plan.

1107
01:31:13,266 --> 01:31:14,809
Get the fuck off of her.

1108
01:31:26,600 --> 01:31:28,684
Oh, my God!

1109
01:32:00,433 --> 01:32:03,791
Mom, I'm sorry. I saw the cross
was gone and I panicked.

1110
01:32:03,891 --> 01:32:07,934
It's okay, sweetie.
Go get the gun. It's in the cabinet.

1111
01:32:10,391 --> 01:32:13,875
- Where is it? I can't find it!
- It's in the box on the left side.

1112
01:32:13,975 --> 01:32:15,226
I'm looking there, Mom, it's not there.

1113
01:32:15,350 --> 01:32:17,392
- Well, look harder!
- I am looking!

1114
01:32:26,016 --> 01:32:28,267
What did you do to her?

1115
01:32:29,433 --> 01:32:31,875
- I'm calling the police.
- Wait. Wait, listen.

1116
01:32:31,975 --> 01:32:36,226
She wouldn't shut up, all right?
It's her fault, she wouldn't shut up!

1117
01:32:37,641 --> 01:32:41,434
- Where's the little one?
- Oh, shit! Libby!

1118
01:32:41,808 --> 01:32:43,684
Libby!

1119
01:32:44,558 --> 01:32:46,184
It's gotta be in here!

1120
01:32:51,724 --> 01:32:55,642
Stop yelling at me! How am I supposed
to find anything in this crap?

1121
01:32:55,766 --> 01:32:58,166
- I see it, it's right there.
- Okay, where are the bullets?

1122
01:32:58,266 --> 01:33:00,934
- Where are the bullets?
- No, it's loaded, it's fine!

1123
01:33:01,058 --> 01:33:02,475
Mom! Mom!

1124
01:33:11,391 --> 01:33:12,934
Libby?

1125
01:33:59,349 --> 01:34:02,059
Hey! Let me do it! Let me do it!

1126
01:34:03,058 --> 01:34:05,350
Bitch blocked the door!

1127
01:34:05,808 --> 01:34:07,434
Christ!

1128
01:34:08,224 --> 01:34:10,142
Can you squeeze through?

1129
01:34:24,308 --> 01:34:26,850
- Oh, my God! She got out!
- Grab the gun!

1130
01:34:35,849 --> 01:34:37,642
Damn it!

1131
01:34:40,433 --> 01:34:42,083
Libby! Libby!

1132
01:34:42,183 --> 01:34:44,791
Ben, if she saw something,
we got a problem!

1133
01:34:44,891 --> 01:34:48,208
Ben, baby... Don't you see
how this isn't a coincidence?

1134
01:34:48,308 --> 01:34:49,874
We need money, then we do
the ritual and then, pow!

1135
01:34:49,974 --> 01:34:53,225
- Someone kills your entire family!
- What are you talking about?

1136
01:34:53,391 --> 01:34:56,434
You inherit all your mom's life insurance.
Whatever you want to do, baby,

1137
01:34:56,558 --> 01:34:59,958
you want to go to California, you want
to live on the beach, we can do it!

1138
01:35:00,058 --> 01:35:01,725
Together.

1139
01:35:04,224 --> 01:35:07,392
If you want me to,
I can take care of her myself.

1140
01:35:09,516 --> 01:35:11,392
No, I'll get her.

1141
01:36:20,224 --> 01:36:23,975
Mom, we're not going to find her.
She could be anywhere by now.

1142
01:36:24,516 --> 01:36:25,791
She can't be far.

1143
01:36:25,891 --> 01:36:28,832
Her friend is coming.
What if he called the cops?

1144
01:36:28,932 --> 01:36:30,975
We have to go.

1145
01:36:32,599 --> 01:36:34,725
What if they find us?

1146
01:36:50,557 --> 01:36:55,350
Libby? Stay where you are,
sweetheart, okay. Stay there.

1147
01:37:48,766 --> 01:37:50,350
Libby!

1148
01:37:55,266 --> 01:37:57,100
Libby!

1149
01:38:06,224 --> 01:38:08,683
I love you, Libby.

1150
01:38:10,057 --> 01:38:12,392
I love you, ladybug.

1151
01:38:12,516 --> 01:38:15,183
Don't you ever forget that.

1152
01:38:18,474 --> 01:38:20,308
Libby!

1153
01:38:23,557 --> 01:38:25,433
Libby!

1154
01:38:29,432 --> 01:38:32,975
- Libby, you okay? What happened?
- Where are they?

1155
01:38:33,266 --> 01:38:35,517
There's no one here,
I checked the house.

1156
01:38:36,099 --> 01:38:39,350
It's okay. Everything's okay.

1157
01:38:46,141 --> 01:38:50,624
<i>Diondra Wertzner, also known as Polly Palm
was arrested last night in Amarillo, Texas.</i>

1158
01:38:50,724 --> 01:38:55,207
<i>This is the latest development
in the 1985 Kansas Prairie Massacre case.</i>

1159
01:38:55,307 --> 01:38:58,874
<i>Ms. Wertzner was wanted in relation
to the murder of Michelle Day</i>

1160
01:38:58,974 --> 01:39:03,124
<i>for which Ben Day, her brother,
has been in prison for the last 28 years.</i>

1161
01:39:03,224 --> 01:39:07,041
<i>She denies any involvement
while DNA analysis is pending.</i>

1162
01:39:07,141 --> 01:39:08,957
<i>But it was announced
this morning that Ben Day</i>

1163
01:39:09,057 --> 01:39:11,183
<i>will be released from prison shortly.</i>

1164
01:39:11,307 --> 01:39:14,058
<i>Their daughter, Crystal,
is still at large.</i>

1165
01:39:14,182 --> 01:39:17,041
<i>As a reminder, this is
the latest twist in a larger case,</i>

1166
01:39:17,141 --> 01:39:21,332
<i>that of serial killer Calvin Diehl,
aka the Angel of Debt</i>

1167
01:39:21,432 --> 01:39:24,957
<i>who has killed, or as he claims,
"Helped to die in dignity,"</i>

1168
01:39:25,057 --> 01:39:28,499
<i>more than 50 people
since the early 1980s.</i>

1169
01:39:28,599 --> 01:39:32,874
<i>He had each of his victims sign
what he termed a "permission to kill" form</i>

1170
01:39:32,974 --> 01:39:35,392
<i>along with a letter to loved ones.</i>

1171
01:39:39,307 --> 01:39:42,558
<i>Dear Ben, Michelle, Libby and Debby.</i>

1172
01:39:42,682 --> 01:39:45,207
<i>I don't think this letter
will ever reach you.</i>

1173
01:39:45,307 --> 01:39:47,957
<i>But Mr. Diehl said he'd hold it for me.</i>

1174
01:39:48,057 --> 01:39:50,766
<i>And I guess that gives me some comfort.</i>

1175
01:39:51,349 --> 01:39:55,058
<i>Your grandparents always told me,
"Make a useful life."</i>

1176
01:39:55,182 --> 01:39:57,374
<i>I don't think I've really done that,</i>

1177
01:39:57,474 --> 01:39:59,957
<i>but I can make a useful death.</i>

1178
01:40:00,057 --> 01:40:03,725
<i>My life has been determined
so much by accidents.</i>

1179
01:40:03,849 --> 01:40:08,933
<i>It seems nice now that an accident
on purpose will make things right again.</i>

1180
01:40:09,974 --> 01:40:12,225
<i>I hope you all forgive me.</i>

1181
01:40:13,557 --> 01:40:15,891
<i>Take care of yourselves.</i>

1182
01:40:16,224 --> 01:40:19,058
<i>I know Diane will do right by you.</i>

1183
01:40:19,182 --> 01:40:23,891
<i>I'm only sad... I won't get to see
the wonderful people you've become.</i>

1184
01:40:24,349 --> 01:40:26,457
<i>Although I don't need to.</i>

1185
01:40:26,557 --> 01:40:29,308
<i>That's how sure I am of my kids.</i>

1186
01:40:56,349 --> 01:40:59,058
Diondra was always sure you'd find her.
She was sure of it.

1187
01:41:00,432 --> 01:41:02,350
Guess she was right.

1188
01:41:05,557 --> 01:41:07,308
So you met my daughter.

1189
01:41:12,724 --> 01:41:15,308
I've heard different things. Is she...

1190
01:41:15,724 --> 01:41:18,516
Is she like Diondra? Is she bad?

1191
01:41:20,224 --> 01:41:22,100
I don't know.

1192
01:41:23,640 --> 01:41:26,665
How does a girl deal with the fact
that she knows her mother is a murderer?

1193
01:41:26,765 --> 01:41:30,225
She can't disappear for long,
I can find her.

1194
01:41:30,682 --> 01:41:33,183
She's not going to go
to jail because of me.

1195
01:41:36,349 --> 01:41:37,790
You'd really give her a pass?

1196
01:41:37,890 --> 01:41:42,624
I know a little bit about people trying to do
the right thing and completely fucking up.

1197
01:41:42,724 --> 01:41:46,725
- Are you talking about me or Mom?
- I'm talking about me.

1198
01:41:47,432 --> 01:41:49,725
You could've been talking
about any of us.

1199
01:41:50,015 --> 01:41:53,058
28 years I've been shutting up
and taking it.

1200
01:41:54,307 --> 01:41:57,391
28 years I've been protecting
a kid that I never met.

1201
01:41:58,099 --> 01:41:59,933
By leaving her
with your sister's murderer?

1202
01:42:00,057 --> 01:42:03,391
I never said I did the right thing, but
I made a choice and I had to live with it.

1203
01:42:03,515 --> 01:42:05,891
Yeah, I had to live with it, too.

1204
01:42:07,140 --> 01:42:10,891
But I do wish there was something
I could say to make it better.

1205
01:42:11,807 --> 01:42:14,016
There's nothing left to say.

1206
01:42:15,682 --> 01:42:19,391
You lied. I lied.

1207
01:42:21,765 --> 01:42:23,641
We're even.

1208
01:42:30,599 --> 01:42:32,433
What about us?

1209
01:42:35,599 --> 01:42:37,766
You don't know me, Ben.

1210
01:42:38,474 --> 01:42:41,016
You think you do, but you don't.

1211
01:42:42,224 --> 01:42:44,308
Just like I don't know you.

1212
01:42:46,807 --> 01:42:50,475
Or Mom. Or Debby, or Michelle.

1213
01:42:53,015 --> 01:42:57,100
Whatever sliver of a memory I had
of them died with them that night.

1214
01:43:03,182 --> 01:43:06,225
I'm so angry at you.

1215
01:43:13,265 --> 01:43:15,516
But you're still my brother.

1216
01:43:17,432 --> 01:43:19,474
You're still my blood.

1217
01:43:20,890 --> 01:43:24,058
I won't let what happened that night,
drive my life anymore.

1218
01:43:27,473 --> 01:43:29,933
I just want to be normal.

1219
01:43:34,807 --> 01:43:36,516
I'm sorry.

1220
01:43:36,932 --> 01:43:40,349
I'm sorry, Libby. I'm sorry.

1221
01:43:55,973 --> 01:43:58,123
You know that horse
you were talking about, Yellow?

1222
01:43:58,223 --> 01:43:59,891
Yeah, what about him?

1223
01:44:01,807 --> 01:44:03,599
I don't get it.

1224
01:44:05,140 --> 01:44:06,974
Why Yellow?

1225
01:44:08,973 --> 01:44:10,957
<i>I don't know. Mom named him.</i>

1226
01:44:11,057 --> 01:44:13,933
<i>It's not like he was
a yellow horse or anything.</i>

1227
01:44:15,640 --> 01:44:18,391
<i>I guess she'll keep
that secret with her?</i>

1228
01:44:18,765 --> 01:44:20,808
<i>There's a lot of other stories, Libby.</i>

1229
01:44:21,307 --> 01:44:23,183
Beautiful ones.

1230
01:44:23,557 --> 01:44:25,808
Wasn't all bad, you know.

1231
01:44:31,682 --> 01:44:33,891
<i>I didn't get straight on the highway.</i>

1232
01:44:34,265 --> 01:44:37,849
<i>But slowly drove to where
our farm had once been.</i>

1233
01:44:39,890 --> 01:44:41,933
<i>Still standing.</i>

1234
01:44:43,182 --> 01:44:45,683
<i>That unsafe place.</i>

1235
01:44:47,723 --> 01:44:52,599
<i>That blanked-out space where my mother
so desperately invited death.</i>

1236
01:45:02,765 --> 01:45:04,224
<i>Maybe Ben was right.</i>

1237
01:45:07,848 --> 01:45:09,891
<i>It wasn't all bad.</i>

1238
01:45:19,598 --> 01:45:23,433
<i>Ben learned something in his prison
that I never learned in mine.</i>

1239
01:45:31,640 --> 01:45:33,266
<i>Forgiveness.</i>

1240
01:45:40,098 --> 01:45:42,290
<i>My mom told us</i>

1241
01:45:42,390 --> 01:45:44,724
<i>to make a useful life.</i>

1242
01:45:47,890 --> 01:45:49,641
<i>Nothing big.</i>

1243
01:45:54,807 --> 01:45:56,641
<i>Nothing grand.</i>

1244
01:45:58,515 --> 01:46:00,474
<i>Just a start.</i>

1245
01:46:04,807 --> 01:46:07,849
<i>Finally, a start.</i>