1 00:00:02,535 --> 00:00:04,636 - Four of the lures are made from materials including 2 00:00:04,638 --> 00:00:07,139 human remains. - Kade purnell, 3 00:00:07,141 --> 00:00:09,475 office of the inspector general, FBI oversight. 4 00:00:09,477 --> 00:00:11,210 - I'm pleading innocent. 5 00:00:11,212 --> 00:00:14,380 - You'll be found guilty and given the federal death penalty. 6 00:00:14,382 --> 00:00:16,415 - What defense do you think I have? 7 00:00:16,417 --> 00:00:19,018 - You had no control of what you were doing, much less 8 00:00:19,020 --> 00:00:21,320 remember doing it. (Coughing) 9 00:00:21,322 --> 00:00:24,123 - Betrayal was the only thing that felt 10 00:00:24,125 --> 00:00:27,059 real to me. I trusted you. 11 00:00:27,061 --> 00:00:30,562 - Let me help you. - I need your help. 12 00:00:30,564 --> 00:00:33,399 - (Jack): We investigated your claims about Dr. Lecter. 13 00:00:33,401 --> 00:00:37,302 We found nothing. You stood over Cassie boyle's body in that field and 14 00:00:37,304 --> 00:00:41,140 you described yourself to me. - (Will): No, I described Hannibal Lecter. 15 00:00:41,142 --> 00:00:44,143 - (Beverly): You think will is innocent. - I don't know what I think. 16 00:00:44,145 --> 00:00:47,246 - I think he still wants to save lives. That's what I think. 17 00:01:19,512 --> 00:01:22,114 (Electricity buzzing) 18 00:01:43,236 --> 00:01:45,537 (Electricity buzzing) 19 00:01:57,617 --> 00:01:59,618 - (Man): Mr. Graham, it's time. 20 00:01:59,620 --> 00:02:02,821 (Breathing quickly) 21 00:02:10,563 --> 00:02:13,265 (Opera music) 22 00:02:18,838 --> 00:02:22,441 (Opera music) 23 00:02:50,336 --> 00:02:54,406 - Let me tell you the story of a mild-mannered FBI instructor 24 00:02:54,408 --> 00:02:57,809 who was asked to create a psychological profile of a murderer - 25 00:02:57,811 --> 00:03:02,247 garret Jacob hobbs, the Minnesota shrike. 26 00:03:02,249 --> 00:03:04,716 He killed young women that looked 27 00:03:04,718 --> 00:03:07,519 just like his daughter. He killed them 28 00:03:07,521 --> 00:03:10,222 and he ate them. 29 00:03:10,224 --> 00:03:14,226 Will Graham understood the way hobbs thought. That's how he caught him. 30 00:03:14,228 --> 00:03:17,930 He shot hobbs dead while he cut his daughter's throat. 31 00:03:17,932 --> 00:03:20,232 So, will Graham was able to save Abigail 32 00:03:20,234 --> 00:03:22,301 hobbs' life. But 33 00:03:22,303 --> 00:03:24,336 the profile that he created 34 00:03:24,338 --> 00:03:29,241 of her father was so vivid that he couldn't escape it. 35 00:03:29,243 --> 00:03:31,443 - See. 36 00:03:31,445 --> 00:03:32,844 See. 37 00:03:32,846 --> 00:03:37,316 - And in an unconscious state... He killed 38 00:03:37,318 --> 00:03:39,585 four more women. 39 00:03:42,455 --> 00:03:43,922 Cassie boyle. 40 00:03:46,526 --> 00:03:48,560 Marissa schuur. 41 00:03:48,562 --> 00:03:50,529 Georgia madchen. 42 00:03:52,465 --> 00:03:53,799 Abigail hobbs. 43 00:03:53,801 --> 00:03:56,802 He was able to save Abigail hobbs 44 00:03:56,804 --> 00:04:00,372 from her father, but he wasn't able to save her from himself. 45 00:04:00,374 --> 00:04:02,241 He killed her 46 00:04:02,243 --> 00:04:04,243 and he ate her. 47 00:04:04,245 --> 00:04:07,779 At the very least, he ate her ear. What happened 48 00:04:07,781 --> 00:04:11,016 to the rest of Abigail hobbs is locked away 49 00:04:11,018 --> 00:04:14,286 in the recesses of will Graham's traumatized mind, 50 00:04:14,288 --> 00:04:16,355 or so he would have you believe. 51 00:04:16,357 --> 00:04:20,959 Something else you should know about will Graham: He has 52 00:04:20,961 --> 00:04:23,829 remarkable visual memory; 53 00:04:23,831 --> 00:04:27,799 he's keenly insightful to the human condition; And... 54 00:04:27,801 --> 00:04:30,402 I would argue, the smartest person 55 00:04:30,404 --> 00:04:32,304 in this room. 56 00:04:32,306 --> 00:04:34,306 He's capable 57 00:04:34,308 --> 00:04:36,842 of creating a psychological profile 58 00:04:36,844 --> 00:04:40,279 of a completely different kind of murderer. 59 00:04:43,016 --> 00:04:45,751 One that would become his alibi. 60 00:04:57,897 --> 00:05:00,599 - Moment of truth. 61 00:05:00,601 --> 00:05:03,035 - If I only knew what the truth was. 62 00:05:03,037 --> 00:05:05,637 - There's nothing wrong with your instincts. 63 00:05:05,639 --> 00:05:08,040 - My instincts have not yet arrived at conviction. 64 00:05:08,042 --> 00:05:12,311 - Mine have, with the benefit of no previous involvement 65 00:05:12,313 --> 00:05:14,780 and no personal connections to the accused. 66 00:05:14,782 --> 00:05:17,783 - Meaning I can't be impartial? - Of course you can be impartial, 67 00:05:17,785 --> 00:05:21,053 but right now you're not. You have to believe something, 68 00:05:21,055 --> 00:05:25,390 as long as there is reason and evidence to believe. 69 00:05:25,392 --> 00:05:27,826 You've got reason; You've got evidence. 70 00:05:27,828 --> 00:05:30,829 Will Graham is playing a game. 71 00:05:30,831 --> 00:05:34,333 I understand why that might be hard for you to accept. 72 00:05:34,335 --> 00:05:36,768 - Do you? 73 00:05:36,770 --> 00:05:39,705 - It's easier to be a man who missed his friend's suffering 74 00:05:39,707 --> 00:05:41,873 than it is to be the head of behavioral sciences 75 00:05:41,875 --> 00:05:45,610 at the FBI who missed a killer standing right in front of him. 76 00:05:45,612 --> 00:05:47,713 There's a reason 77 00:05:47,715 --> 00:05:51,350 that you're a witness for the prosecution, agent Crawford. 78 00:05:51,352 --> 00:05:53,485 - Remind me what that reason is. 79 00:05:53,487 --> 00:05:56,421 - If you can't represent your own beliefs, 80 00:05:56,423 --> 00:05:58,757 represent the bureau's. (Door opening) 81 00:05:58,759 --> 00:06:01,626 - (Woman): Agent Crawford? 82 00:06:04,931 --> 00:06:06,798 Let yourself off the hook, Jack. 83 00:06:08,935 --> 00:06:13,071 - How did you meet will Graham? - I met him at the opening of the evil minds 84 00:06:13,073 --> 00:06:16,041 research museum. He didn't agree with what we called it. 85 00:06:16,043 --> 00:06:19,978 He told me that the title mythologized banal and cruel men 86 00:06:19,980 --> 00:06:22,981 who didn't deserve to be thought of as super-villains. 87 00:06:22,983 --> 00:06:26,451 - And what was your first impression? - He was intelligent. 88 00:06:26,453 --> 00:06:27,853 And arrogant. 89 00:06:27,855 --> 00:06:31,022 And very likely on the spectrum. 90 00:06:31,024 --> 00:06:35,527 - Which is why he wasn't real FBI. He didn't pass 91 00:06:35,529 --> 00:06:38,864 the screening procedures. - Yes. 92 00:06:38,866 --> 00:06:42,167 - But you felt that he was qualified to work in the field. - Under my supervision. 93 00:06:42,169 --> 00:06:45,604 - And you believed that he was valuable because he could think like a killer? 94 00:06:45,606 --> 00:06:48,940 - He could think like anybody. - Sounds like a super-villain. 95 00:06:52,011 --> 00:06:54,079 Five horrendous murders, over 40 different 96 00:06:54,081 --> 00:06:56,415 pieces of forensic and physical evidence 97 00:06:56,417 --> 00:06:59,584 that tell us that will Graham can think like a killer because he is one. 98 00:06:59,586 --> 00:07:02,788 Rather than feel tormented by the work he did, 99 00:07:02,790 --> 00:07:07,626 will Graham enjoyed the cover his role at the FBI gave him 100 00:07:07,628 --> 00:07:12,197 to commit his terrible crimes. - I don't believe that to be true. 101 00:07:16,436 --> 00:07:18,804 - Agent Crawford? 102 00:07:18,806 --> 00:07:21,907 - Will hated every second of the work. He hated it. 103 00:07:21,909 --> 00:07:24,142 He didn't fake that. 104 00:07:24,144 --> 00:07:26,611 He hated it and I kept making him do it. 105 00:07:26,613 --> 00:07:29,815 - Why then is it that when you offered him an opportunity to quit, he refused? 106 00:07:29,817 --> 00:07:32,184 - (Firmly): Because he was saving lives. 107 00:07:35,488 --> 00:07:37,889 I had been warned by more than one person 108 00:07:37,891 --> 00:07:40,826 that if I pushed will, I'd break him. 109 00:07:43,763 --> 00:07:47,165 I put those checks and balances in place, then ignored them. 110 00:07:49,235 --> 00:07:50,969 And here we are. 111 00:08:14,026 --> 00:08:16,528 - What does Jack Crawford drink? 112 00:08:16,530 --> 00:08:19,798 Whatever it is, I need to send him a very expensive bottle. 113 00:08:19,800 --> 00:08:22,167 - He said I'm a killer because he drove me insane. 114 00:08:22,169 --> 00:08:24,169 - No, he paved the road for your defense. 115 00:08:24,171 --> 00:08:26,171 - Well, he didn't say I'm innocent. 116 00:08:26,173 --> 00:08:29,808 - Innocence isn't a verdict, Mr. Graham, but "not guilty" is. 117 00:08:29,810 --> 00:08:32,577 This isn't law; It's advertising. 118 00:08:32,579 --> 00:08:35,113 - Advertising trivializes; 119 00:08:35,115 --> 00:08:37,916 it, uh, manipulates; It's vulgar. 120 00:08:37,918 --> 00:08:39,985 - Boo-hoo. So is the law. 121 00:08:39,987 --> 00:08:43,622 We have to create desire to find you "not guilty," 122 00:08:43,624 --> 00:08:46,258 which is nonexistent in this courtroom right now. 123 00:08:46,260 --> 00:08:49,261 We're manipulating people into buying something they don't need. 124 00:08:49,263 --> 00:08:52,097 - Mr. brauer? - They don't want your innocence. Thank you. 125 00:08:52,099 --> 00:08:54,132 Unconsciousness in a pretty package, 126 00:08:54,134 --> 00:08:56,201 that I can sell. 127 00:08:58,137 --> 00:09:02,007 If I take the moral high ground with you, I'll get you killed. 128 00:09:14,720 --> 00:09:16,788 I think I opened your mail. 129 00:09:19,292 --> 00:09:21,860 ♪ 130 00:09:42,315 --> 00:09:45,584 ♪ (Classical piano) 131 00:09:57,730 --> 00:10:00,131 - That was a good and brave thing you did for will today. 132 00:10:00,133 --> 00:10:02,200 - It may have cost me my job. 133 00:10:02,202 --> 00:10:04,769 - The prospect doesn't seem 134 00:10:04,771 --> 00:10:07,072 to trouble you as much as I would have thought. 135 00:10:09,642 --> 00:10:12,644 - Haven't felt better in weeks. 136 00:10:12,646 --> 00:10:14,679 (Glasses touched) - Clarity will do that. 137 00:10:18,184 --> 00:10:19,851 - Mm. 138 00:10:22,388 --> 00:10:24,122 - Tell me, Jack. 139 00:10:24,124 --> 00:10:27,058 Was your testimony meant to be a resignation? 140 00:10:27,060 --> 00:10:30,095 - There is something appealing 141 00:10:30,097 --> 00:10:32,364 about walking away from all of the noise. 142 00:10:36,302 --> 00:10:38,303 I'm... 143 00:10:38,305 --> 00:10:41,840 Content to let the chips fall. 144 00:10:43,776 --> 00:10:47,245 - The magic door is always attractive - 145 00:10:47,247 --> 00:10:49,748 step through and leave all your burdens behind. 146 00:10:53,853 --> 00:10:57,422 - I've given my life... To death. 147 00:10:57,424 --> 00:11:00,258 - And now death has followed you home... 148 00:11:02,194 --> 00:11:04,863 ...come to live in your house. 149 00:11:04,865 --> 00:11:07,065 (Taking a breath) 150 00:11:09,902 --> 00:11:13,438 - Bella has kept our bedroom from looking too much like a sickroom. 151 00:11:13,440 --> 00:11:16,007 There are flowers, but not too many. 152 00:11:16,009 --> 00:11:17,876 You know. 153 00:11:17,878 --> 00:11:20,078 She insists that there are no pills in sight. 154 00:11:22,014 --> 00:11:25,283 So, I've been thinking about taking her to Italy where we met. 155 00:11:27,219 --> 00:11:28,887 We could... 156 00:11:33,893 --> 00:11:35,694 She could die there. 157 00:11:40,900 --> 00:11:42,367 - Jack. 158 00:11:44,303 --> 00:11:45,904 You're not sick. 159 00:11:45,906 --> 00:11:49,107 You don't have to go into the ground with her. 160 00:11:53,379 --> 00:11:57,115 When Bella's lost to you, the FBI could still be there. 161 00:11:59,852 --> 00:12:02,787 - You're telling me not to commit professional suicide? 162 00:12:05,391 --> 00:12:09,394 - As a friend, I'm telling you not to force an issue 163 00:12:09,396 --> 00:12:13,765 for the short-term emotional satisfaction it can have. 164 00:12:22,141 --> 00:12:26,044 (Inaudible) 165 00:12:31,784 --> 00:12:34,252 - ...shrunken capillaries. The ear was cut from a corpse 166 00:12:34,254 --> 00:12:35,920 no more than 48 hours ago. 167 00:12:35,922 --> 00:12:38,323 - Before the trial started. - We fumed it all - 168 00:12:38,325 --> 00:12:41,159 ear's clean, no prints on either of the envelopes, 169 00:12:41,161 --> 00:12:43,194 besides the courier, paralegal, and lawyer. 170 00:12:43,196 --> 00:12:45,764 - We know will Graham didn't do it. 171 00:12:45,766 --> 00:12:48,166 - It wouldn't surprise me. - The timing's deliberate. 172 00:12:48,168 --> 00:12:52,170 It was choreographed to drop the ear at the beginning of will's trial. 173 00:12:54,540 --> 00:12:56,941 - Such a gift has great significance. 174 00:12:56,943 --> 00:12:59,277 - A gift from who? - Will claimed 175 00:12:59,279 --> 00:13:03,214 someone else committed the crimes he's accused of. 176 00:13:03,216 --> 00:13:06,351 - He said that person was you. 177 00:13:06,353 --> 00:13:09,154 - Perhaps he was half right. 178 00:13:13,025 --> 00:13:16,127 - Oh, you've gotta be kidding me. 179 00:13:18,931 --> 00:13:22,133 - It seems you have an admirer. 180 00:13:22,135 --> 00:13:25,036 - You think someone sent me an ear because they admire me? 181 00:13:25,038 --> 00:13:27,438 - The boundaries of what's considered normal 182 00:13:27,440 --> 00:13:30,909 are getting narrower. Outside those boundaries, 183 00:13:30,911 --> 00:13:33,311 this may be intended as a helpful gesture. 184 00:13:33,313 --> 00:13:36,915 - How far would you go to help me? 185 00:13:36,917 --> 00:13:39,851 - It hadn't occurred to me to send you an ear. 186 00:13:42,822 --> 00:13:44,823 But I'm grateful someone has. 187 00:13:44,825 --> 00:13:49,527 - Gratitude has a short half-life. 188 00:13:49,529 --> 00:13:52,330 - So can doubt. 189 00:13:52,332 --> 00:13:54,866 I have new thoughts about who you are. 190 00:13:57,069 --> 00:13:59,404 There may very well be another killer. 191 00:14:01,340 --> 00:14:03,608 - (Softly): I want there to be. 192 00:14:08,080 --> 00:14:10,548 - Some part of you still suspects me. 193 00:14:10,550 --> 00:14:12,984 - I don't know what anyone is 194 00:14:12,986 --> 00:14:15,420 capable of anymore, least of all myself. 195 00:14:15,422 --> 00:14:17,355 But, um... 196 00:14:19,892 --> 00:14:23,061 ...I know there is no evidence against you. 197 00:14:23,063 --> 00:14:24,929 - There never was. 198 00:14:26,866 --> 00:14:29,500 - And accusing you makes me look insane. 199 00:14:33,873 --> 00:14:35,340 I'm not insane. 200 00:14:37,443 --> 00:14:39,110 Not anymore. 201 00:14:41,447 --> 00:14:43,615 - And you may not be guilty. 202 00:14:51,991 --> 00:14:54,192 This ear you were sent 203 00:14:54,194 --> 00:14:57,462 is an opportunity. 204 00:14:57,464 --> 00:15:01,232 If someone else is responsible for your crimes, 205 00:15:01,234 --> 00:15:03,234 perhaps he now wants to be seen. 206 00:15:03,236 --> 00:15:07,005 - Why would he want to be seen now? 207 00:15:07,007 --> 00:15:09,974 - He cares what happens to you. 208 00:15:16,649 --> 00:15:19,150 - The prosecution calls Freddie lounds to the stand. 209 00:15:33,465 --> 00:15:37,101 - I swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth. 210 00:15:43,575 --> 00:15:45,176 - Could you please describe 211 00:15:45,178 --> 00:15:47,478 your relationship with Abigail 212 00:15:47,480 --> 00:15:50,415 hobbs? - We were very close. 213 00:15:50,417 --> 00:15:54,252 I was helping her write a book about surviving her father. - Did you ever discuss 214 00:15:54,254 --> 00:15:58,256 will Graham with Abigail? - Abigail told me 215 00:15:58,258 --> 00:16:02,327 she believed will Graham wanted to kill her and cannibalize her 216 00:16:02,329 --> 00:16:04,395 like her father wanted to do. 217 00:16:04,397 --> 00:16:07,165 She was right. 218 00:16:09,101 --> 00:16:12,303 I should've listened to her. 219 00:16:12,305 --> 00:16:14,639 - Do you blame yourself for her death? 220 00:16:18,577 --> 00:16:20,645 - I blame will Graham. 221 00:16:25,417 --> 00:16:27,018 - Thank you. 222 00:16:27,020 --> 00:16:28,486 Your witness. 223 00:16:32,424 --> 00:16:34,092 - Miss lounds. 224 00:16:36,028 --> 00:16:38,262 Could you please... 225 00:16:38,264 --> 00:16:43,101 Remind me how many times you've been sued for libel? 226 00:16:45,704 --> 00:16:47,305 - (Quietly): Six. 227 00:16:47,307 --> 00:16:49,040 - Sorry? 228 00:16:50,776 --> 00:16:53,144 - Six. - Six. 229 00:16:53,146 --> 00:16:57,348 And how many times did you settle? 230 00:16:57,350 --> 00:16:59,784 - Six. 231 00:16:59,786 --> 00:17:01,786 - Six. 232 00:17:01,788 --> 00:17:05,089 Thank you. Nothing further. 233 00:17:07,026 --> 00:17:09,627 - The defense calls Dr. alana bloom. 234 00:17:09,629 --> 00:17:11,763 - I believe will's empathy disorder... 235 00:17:13,699 --> 00:17:16,634 ...combined with the effects of viral encephalitis... 236 00:17:19,171 --> 00:17:21,739 Do we have to do this like this? 237 00:17:21,741 --> 00:17:26,677 - I don't want the first time you do this to be in court. 238 00:17:26,679 --> 00:17:29,313 Dr. bloom, weren't 239 00:17:29,315 --> 00:17:31,649 you and the accused romantically involved? 240 00:17:35,621 --> 00:17:37,722 - How is this relevant to the case? 241 00:17:37,724 --> 00:17:40,425 - It's relevant to your testimony. 242 00:17:40,427 --> 00:17:43,194 In that court, your feelings, your emotions, 243 00:17:43,196 --> 00:17:46,164 your pro-everything-will-Graham will be on trial. 244 00:17:46,166 --> 00:17:48,232 You get all starey and non-blinky like that, 245 00:17:48,234 --> 00:17:50,468 it'll undermine you and me, but mainly him. 246 00:17:50,470 --> 00:17:52,470 - My testimony is based on my professional-- 247 00:17:52,472 --> 00:17:55,306 - you are smitten with the accused, miss bloom, 248 00:17:55,308 --> 00:17:57,442 and it is adorable, but not our brand of defense. 249 00:17:57,444 --> 00:17:59,710 And Ms. vega will smell it on you 250 00:17:59,712 --> 00:18:03,181 like you stepped in young adult and tracked it into the courtroom. 251 00:18:03,183 --> 00:18:07,852 Were you and will Graham involved romantically? 252 00:18:15,327 --> 00:18:17,595 - I have no romantic feelings for will Graham. 253 00:18:17,597 --> 00:18:20,131 I have a professional curiosity. 254 00:18:23,602 --> 00:18:25,837 - I like that. "Professional curiosity." 255 00:18:25,839 --> 00:18:27,605 It seems so... 256 00:18:27,607 --> 00:18:30,374 Heh, it seems so indifferent. 257 00:18:30,376 --> 00:18:33,244 Unless you look like you're lying when you say it. 258 00:18:33,246 --> 00:18:34,846 But you didn't. 259 00:18:49,828 --> 00:18:52,830 - (Jack): You've identified the ear? - (Brian): We identified 260 00:18:52,832 --> 00:18:55,566 the knife that cut it off. - It's will Graham's. 261 00:18:55,568 --> 00:18:58,536 The blade matches the cuts on Abigail hobbs's ear and on this one. 262 00:18:58,538 --> 00:19:01,339 - It was presented in court as evidence, then it was sent 263 00:19:01,341 --> 00:19:03,541 to the courthouse evidence room where it was checked out 264 00:19:03,543 --> 00:19:05,743 by the bailiff in will's trial, Andrew Sykes, 265 00:19:05,745 --> 00:19:10,248 and it never went back. - Pretty good, right? 266 00:19:24,196 --> 00:19:25,663 - (Quietly): Go. 267 00:19:49,788 --> 00:19:51,856 (Siren) 268 00:20:33,665 --> 00:20:35,666 They wanted to give us a warm welcome 269 00:20:35,668 --> 00:20:37,835 and make sure that we found something. 270 00:20:37,837 --> 00:20:40,571 - An arresting piece of theater. 271 00:20:40,573 --> 00:20:43,474 - Our bailiff was mounted on a stag's head. 272 00:20:43,476 --> 00:20:47,478 Glasgow smile. Killer lopped off his ear and set him on fire. 273 00:20:47,480 --> 00:20:48,980 Will Graham's greatest hits. 274 00:20:50,916 --> 00:20:53,551 - Could we have been that wrong? - About will Graham? No. 275 00:20:53,553 --> 00:20:55,886 We could not. He practically takes selfies with his victims. 276 00:20:55,888 --> 00:20:57,888 - The evidence we found was immediate and almost 277 00:20:57,890 --> 00:20:59,957 presentational. May as well have been gift-wrapped. 278 00:20:59,959 --> 00:21:02,393 - That's what will said about Cassie boyle 279 00:21:02,395 --> 00:21:05,463 when we found her in that field. "Field kabuki." 280 00:21:05,465 --> 00:21:08,466 - There was no evidence before will was apprehended and there hasn't been any since. 281 00:21:08,468 --> 00:21:10,301 - He ate a girl's ear! 282 00:21:10,303 --> 00:21:12,737 It was in his stomach. God knows what else of her was in there. 283 00:21:12,739 --> 00:21:14,805 - We should've taken a stool sample. 284 00:21:14,807 --> 00:21:17,341 - Yes! We should have. - Well, why didn't we? 285 00:21:17,343 --> 00:21:21,612 I was the one that said we should have. - Knock it off. 286 00:21:21,614 --> 00:21:24,048 - What impact could this have on will's trial? 287 00:21:29,554 --> 00:21:31,822 - This murder raises serious doubts about 288 00:21:31,824 --> 00:21:35,660 the case against will Graham. - Your team provided the evidence. 289 00:21:35,662 --> 00:21:38,663 - The overwhelming evidence. - So you understand the significance 290 00:21:38,665 --> 00:21:40,965 of my questioning it. - Agent Crawford, 291 00:21:40,967 --> 00:21:44,669 we all heard your testimony. Are you sure you're not just trying to assuage 292 00:21:44,671 --> 00:21:47,004 your own guilt? - Yes, I'm sure. 293 00:21:47,006 --> 00:21:49,807 - I'm not. - Andrew Sykes was mutilated 294 00:21:49,809 --> 00:21:52,510 in the exact same manner will Graham allegedly 295 00:21:52,512 --> 00:21:54,645 mutilated his victims - ways that have not been 296 00:21:54,647 --> 00:21:57,982 made public. - Will Graham isn't saying he didn't kill those people. 297 00:21:57,984 --> 00:22:00,785 His lawyer is running an unconsciousness defense. 298 00:22:00,787 --> 00:22:04,422 In effect, he's admitting the acts, but just not the responsibility. 299 00:22:04,424 --> 00:22:08,025 - Will's maintained his innocence all along, in spite of memory gaps. 300 00:22:08,027 --> 00:22:11,896 Whatever Mr. brauer's strategy is, this will offer a new line of defense. 301 00:22:11,898 --> 00:22:14,532 - That's for Mr. brauer to tell me, agent Crawford, not you. 302 00:22:17,602 --> 00:22:19,070 - Yes, your honor. 303 00:22:26,345 --> 00:22:28,412 - (Chilton): Will Graham manifests publicly 304 00:22:28,414 --> 00:22:31,082 as an introverted personality. He would like us to believe 305 00:22:31,084 --> 00:22:33,451 he places on the spectrum somewhere 306 00:22:33,453 --> 00:22:35,386 near asperger's and autism. 307 00:22:35,388 --> 00:22:38,823 Yet he also claims an empathy disorder. 308 00:22:38,825 --> 00:22:42,993 - You choose your words very carefully, Dr. chilton. 309 00:22:42,995 --> 00:22:44,995 You chose the word 310 00:22:44,997 --> 00:22:48,532 "claims." - Will Graham has never been diagnosed. 311 00:22:48,534 --> 00:22:50,668 He will not allow anyone to test him. 312 00:22:50,670 --> 00:22:52,670 He has carefully constructed 313 00:22:52,672 --> 00:22:55,506 a persona to hide his real nature from the world. 314 00:22:55,508 --> 00:22:57,375 He wears it so well 315 00:22:57,377 --> 00:22:59,510 even Jack Crawford could not see past it. 316 00:22:59,512 --> 00:23:01,746 - (Vega): But you did? 317 00:23:01,748 --> 00:23:04,915 - Mr. Graham and I had no personal relationship 318 00:23:04,917 --> 00:23:09,053 for him to manipulate. I have objectively examined him 319 00:23:09,055 --> 00:23:11,055 and the crimes of which he is 320 00:23:11,057 --> 00:23:13,457 accused. These murders 321 00:23:13,459 --> 00:23:16,927 were measured and controlled. 322 00:23:16,929 --> 00:23:19,663 The confused man will Graham presents to the world 323 00:23:19,665 --> 00:23:22,533 could not commit those crimes, 324 00:23:22,535 --> 00:23:24,835 because that man is a fiction. 325 00:23:26,838 --> 00:23:28,839 - So, 326 00:23:28,841 --> 00:23:31,609 you discount the encephalitis he was suffering as a cause? 327 00:23:31,611 --> 00:23:35,179 - He managed his illness with the help of his neurologist, 328 00:23:35,181 --> 00:23:37,448 whom he murdered for his trouble. 329 00:23:40,051 --> 00:23:42,620 - Is will Graham an intelligent psychopath? 330 00:23:42,622 --> 00:23:44,955 - There is not yet a name 331 00:23:44,957 --> 00:23:46,924 for whatever will Graham is. 332 00:23:46,926 --> 00:23:49,794 He kills methodically, 333 00:23:49,796 --> 00:23:53,931 and I believe would kill again, given the opportunity. 334 00:23:56,568 --> 00:23:58,569 - Thank you, Dr. chilton. 335 00:23:58,571 --> 00:24:00,638 Your witness. 336 00:24:06,812 --> 00:24:08,579 - Dr. chilton, 337 00:24:08,581 --> 00:24:11,682 will Graham spent his time catching murderers for the FBI. 338 00:24:11,684 --> 00:24:13,751 You don't see a contradiction between that 339 00:24:13,753 --> 00:24:15,820 and your description of a coldblooded killer? 340 00:24:15,822 --> 00:24:17,688 - No, I do not. 341 00:24:17,690 --> 00:24:21,592 Will Graham is driven by vanity and his own whims. 342 00:24:21,594 --> 00:24:24,695 He has a very high opinion of his intelligence. 343 00:24:24,697 --> 00:24:27,231 Ergo, he caught the other killers 344 00:24:27,233 --> 00:24:29,099 simply to prove 345 00:24:29,101 --> 00:24:31,769 he was smarter than all of them too. 346 00:24:33,972 --> 00:24:37,842 Saving lives is just as arousing as ending them. 347 00:24:37,844 --> 00:24:39,910 He likes to play God. 348 00:24:54,192 --> 00:24:57,061 (Keypad beeping) 349 00:24:57,063 --> 00:25:00,264 (Door buzzer) 350 00:25:35,534 --> 00:25:37,868 - My admirer? - Yes. 351 00:25:43,141 --> 00:25:46,677 The forensic report from the crime scene. 352 00:25:46,679 --> 00:25:49,146 What do you see? 353 00:26:19,878 --> 00:26:23,647 (Soft ambient pulse) 354 00:26:29,721 --> 00:26:32,790 (Steady heartbeat) 355 00:26:47,105 --> 00:26:50,641 (Door opening and closing) 356 00:26:57,015 --> 00:26:59,683 - I shoot Mr. Sykes once, 357 00:26:59,685 --> 00:27:01,352 collapsing lungs, 358 00:27:01,354 --> 00:27:05,189 tearing through his heart's aorta and pulmonary arteries. 359 00:27:05,191 --> 00:27:07,691 (Silenced gunshot) 360 00:27:11,029 --> 00:27:14,098 He will die believing we were friends. 361 00:27:16,034 --> 00:27:17,868 It is his last thought. 362 00:27:23,708 --> 00:27:25,776 (Will panting) 363 00:27:30,382 --> 00:27:32,650 His death isn't personal. 364 00:27:44,663 --> 00:27:49,266 He is merely the ink from which flows my poem. 365 00:28:03,815 --> 00:28:05,282 My tribute. 366 00:28:08,186 --> 00:28:09,987 This is my design. 367 00:28:11,923 --> 00:28:13,924 It's not the same killer. 368 00:28:16,361 --> 00:28:19,730 He murdered his victim first, and then mutilated him. 369 00:28:22,967 --> 00:28:26,437 Cassie boyle's lungs were removed when she was still breathing. 370 00:28:26,439 --> 00:28:29,239 Georgia madchen was burned alive. What I... 371 00:28:29,241 --> 00:28:31,041 What... what I found 372 00:28:31,043 --> 00:28:34,411 of Abigail was cut off while her heart was beating. 373 00:28:36,815 --> 00:28:40,818 - Then this... Is blunt reproduction? 374 00:28:40,820 --> 00:28:42,920 - You knew that already. 375 00:28:44,989 --> 00:28:46,990 - Would've liked to have been wrong. 376 00:28:46,992 --> 00:28:49,293 - Occam's broom. 377 00:28:51,229 --> 00:28:54,331 You intentionally ignored facts that refute your argument 378 00:28:54,333 --> 00:28:57,401 hoping nobody'd notice. - You noticed. 379 00:28:57,403 --> 00:28:59,837 - Mm-hmm. 380 00:29:04,743 --> 00:29:07,144 - I wanted to dispel your doubts once and for all. 381 00:29:09,514 --> 00:29:11,281 - My doubts about what? 382 00:29:11,283 --> 00:29:13,817 - Me. 383 00:29:17,922 --> 00:29:21,492 I want you to believe in the best of me, 384 00:29:21,494 --> 00:29:24,061 just as I believe in the best of you. 385 00:29:26,397 --> 00:29:28,899 This crime offered us both reasonable doubt. 386 00:29:28,901 --> 00:29:31,168 - It offered us a distraction. 387 00:29:33,104 --> 00:29:35,939 - Maybe this acolyte is giving you your path to freedom. 388 00:29:35,941 --> 00:29:38,008 Even Jack is ready to believe, will. 389 00:29:47,185 --> 00:29:48,986 - It would be a lie. 390 00:29:56,327 --> 00:29:58,929 - I don't want you to be here. - I don't want me to be here 391 00:29:58,931 --> 00:30:01,031 either. - Then you have a choice. 392 00:30:01,033 --> 00:30:03,500 This killer wrote you a poem. 393 00:30:07,906 --> 00:30:10,374 Are you going to let his love go to waste? 394 00:30:21,152 --> 00:30:22,886 - I'm confused. 395 00:30:22,888 --> 00:30:26,390 You're going to abandon your defense strategy, 396 00:30:26,392 --> 00:30:29,860 the entire case you've built, mid-trial. 397 00:30:29,862 --> 00:30:32,129 - Exciting, isn't it? 398 00:30:32,131 --> 00:30:34,398 - And this seems reasonable to you? 399 00:30:34,400 --> 00:30:36,867 - It's not only reasonable; 400 00:30:36,869 --> 00:30:38,869 it's fashionable. 401 00:30:38,871 --> 00:30:41,071 There's a killer on the loose, 402 00:30:41,073 --> 00:30:43,173 demonstrating all the hallmarks of will Graham's 403 00:30:43,175 --> 00:30:45,876 alleged murders. - Do you think this killer 404 00:30:45,878 --> 00:30:48,879 committed the crimes that you're accused of? - Don't answer that, 405 00:30:48,881 --> 00:30:50,948 not in front of me. It's inconsequential. 406 00:30:50,950 --> 00:30:54,084 - But is it true? - You're being awfully high and mighty, Dr. bloom. 407 00:30:54,086 --> 00:30:56,086 Very ivory tower, very reductive. 408 00:30:56,088 --> 00:31:00,290 Very far from the point, which is the exoneration of your friend 409 00:31:00,292 --> 00:31:02,359 will Graham. - And the point you're trying 410 00:31:02,361 --> 00:31:04,528 to make is reasonable doubt. - That's a win, yes. 411 00:31:04,530 --> 00:31:07,531 - The best you can hope for is mistrial. - That's also a win. 412 00:31:07,533 --> 00:31:10,167 - You won't be able to plead unconsciousness again. 413 00:31:10,169 --> 00:31:12,436 - Your fast, triumphant diagnosis 414 00:31:12,438 --> 00:31:14,538 of unconsciousness was the best play we had. 415 00:31:14,540 --> 00:31:17,407 Now we have a better play. Needless to say, 416 00:31:17,409 --> 00:31:20,077 I won't be calling you to the witness stand. 417 00:31:20,079 --> 00:31:23,213 - Who's taking the stand in my place? 418 00:31:44,135 --> 00:31:46,603 - I swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, 419 00:31:46,605 --> 00:31:49,473 and nothing but the truth, so help me God. 420 00:31:57,248 --> 00:31:59,683 - Good morning, doctor. 421 00:31:59,685 --> 00:32:03,520 Please describe your relationship with will Graham. 422 00:32:03,522 --> 00:32:06,323 - I was asked by Jack Crawford to monitor will's 423 00:32:06,325 --> 00:32:09,026 emotional well-being while he worked on cases. 424 00:32:09,028 --> 00:32:11,328 I was never officially his psychiatrist. 425 00:32:11,330 --> 00:32:13,397 - If you weren't his psychiatrist, what were you? 426 00:32:13,399 --> 00:32:15,465 - I was meant to be his stability. 427 00:32:17,402 --> 00:32:21,004 I failed him in that. - How did you fail him? 428 00:32:23,975 --> 00:32:26,643 - I was unable to determine if will's condition was due 429 00:32:26,645 --> 00:32:30,280 to mental illness or stress from his work at the FBI. 430 00:32:32,283 --> 00:32:35,319 My mistake was never considering his innocence 431 00:32:35,321 --> 00:32:39,589 until the murder of a bailiff from this courthouse. 432 00:32:39,591 --> 00:32:42,559 - And how did you know about that, Dr. Lecter? 433 00:32:42,561 --> 00:32:46,029 - I have been asked to consult on the case by Jack Crawford. 434 00:32:46,031 --> 00:32:49,032 He wanted a profile of the bailiff's killer. 435 00:32:49,034 --> 00:32:51,168 - So, you believe 436 00:32:51,170 --> 00:32:53,570 the bailiff's murder was committed by the same person 437 00:32:53,572 --> 00:32:56,340 guilty of will Graham's alleged crimes, yes? 438 00:32:56,342 --> 00:32:59,509 - Profiles aren't evidence; They're opinion. This is hearsay. 439 00:32:59,511 --> 00:33:02,045 - I will allow it. 440 00:33:02,047 --> 00:33:05,048 - Thank you, your honor. 441 00:33:05,050 --> 00:33:08,552 - I believe there are alarming similarities in the crimes, yes. 442 00:33:08,554 --> 00:33:10,554 - Will Graham accused you 443 00:33:10,556 --> 00:33:13,223 of the crimes for which he now stands trial, and yet 444 00:33:13,225 --> 00:33:16,259 here you are, testifying 445 00:33:16,261 --> 00:33:18,996 on his behalf for the defense. 446 00:33:18,998 --> 00:33:22,532 - Will rightfully couldn't accept these actions to be his. 447 00:33:24,469 --> 00:33:28,138 A mind faced with the possibility of committing such deeds 448 00:33:28,140 --> 00:33:30,607 will find an alternative reality to believe in. 449 00:33:30,609 --> 00:33:33,410 - You don't blame him for that? 450 00:33:33,412 --> 00:33:35,412 - No. 451 00:33:35,414 --> 00:33:38,015 Will Graham is 452 00:33:38,017 --> 00:33:40,550 and will always be my friend. 453 00:33:40,552 --> 00:33:43,153 - Your witness. 454 00:33:43,155 --> 00:33:47,090 - Dr. Lecter, what was the cause 455 00:33:47,092 --> 00:33:49,426 of death in the bailiff's murder? 456 00:33:49,428 --> 00:33:52,429 - A bullet to the heart. 457 00:33:52,431 --> 00:33:54,664 - Mm. And in will Graham's 458 00:33:54,666 --> 00:33:57,100 victims, or alleged victims, what was 459 00:33:57,102 --> 00:34:00,037 their cause of death? 460 00:34:00,039 --> 00:34:02,039 - Mutilation. 461 00:34:02,041 --> 00:34:04,775 - That's very different from a bullet. 462 00:34:04,777 --> 00:34:08,412 - No two crimes of any killer are going to be exactly the same. 463 00:34:08,414 --> 00:34:13,116 The similarities-- - your honor, the witness's personal beliefs and biases 464 00:34:13,118 --> 00:34:15,519 are driving his conclusions. There are clearly 465 00:34:15,521 --> 00:34:17,654 two different killers and two different cases. 466 00:34:17,656 --> 00:34:21,391 - Your honor, there are sufficient similarities to consider this a defense. 467 00:34:23,594 --> 00:34:26,696 - I'm ruling this defense inadmissible, Mr. brauer. 468 00:34:26,698 --> 00:34:29,699 - Thank you, your honor. 469 00:34:29,701 --> 00:34:33,236 - (Judge): All previous testimony on the matter will be stricken from the record. 470 00:34:38,409 --> 00:34:41,478 ♪ (Classical piano) 471 00:36:14,338 --> 00:36:17,307 - (Jack): So, it appears that the judge was murdered in his chambers, 472 00:36:17,309 --> 00:36:20,710 and then he was hauled out here to be put on display. 473 00:36:20,712 --> 00:36:24,614 - Not only is justice blind; It's mindless and heartless. 474 00:36:24,616 --> 00:36:26,883 How did the killer get so close? 475 00:36:26,885 --> 00:36:29,886 - No sign of a struggle. Mutilation was post-mortem. 476 00:36:29,888 --> 00:36:32,522 - He was shot in the chest just like the bailiff. 477 00:36:32,524 --> 00:36:35,525 Can't see the, uh, entry wound because he removed the heart. 478 00:36:35,527 --> 00:36:39,362 - But there is an exit wound. No slug - must have taken it with him. 479 00:36:39,364 --> 00:36:41,565 - A trophy. 480 00:36:41,567 --> 00:36:43,300 - Doctor. 481 00:36:46,237 --> 00:36:49,339 With this judge's death, there will be no verdict. 482 00:36:49,341 --> 00:36:51,608 No ending. It'll start again, 483 00:36:51,610 --> 00:36:53,877 like the trial never happened. 484 00:36:53,879 --> 00:36:56,346 But why? 485 00:36:56,348 --> 00:37:00,217 - Psychopathic violence is predominantly goal-oriented, 486 00:37:00,219 --> 00:37:02,886 a means to a very particular end. 487 00:37:02,888 --> 00:37:06,489 - So, the killer wanted a mistrial? 488 00:37:06,491 --> 00:37:10,493 - It's an elegant, if rather unorthodox, solution. 489 00:37:10,495 --> 00:37:13,630 - He spares will a guilty verdict and his life for the moment. 490 00:37:13,632 --> 00:37:16,233 - Yes. - The question is, 491 00:37:16,235 --> 00:37:18,468 is it the same killer? 492 00:37:18,470 --> 00:37:20,670 Is will still on trial, in your mind? 493 00:37:20,672 --> 00:37:22,672 - The use of a gun; 494 00:37:22,674 --> 00:37:25,375 death first, mutilation last. 495 00:37:27,311 --> 00:37:30,981 I feel like St. Peter ready to deny will for the third time. 496 00:37:30,983 --> 00:37:33,650 I'm not sure this is the same killer, Jack. 497 00:37:37,955 --> 00:37:40,423 - Excuse me. 498 00:37:45,796 --> 00:37:49,332 The killer exerted careful control of the environment. 499 00:37:49,334 --> 00:37:52,469 He left very little evidence behind. 500 00:37:52,471 --> 00:37:54,337 - Jeez, Jack. 501 00:37:54,339 --> 00:37:56,740 The trial was supposed to put an end to this. 502 00:37:56,742 --> 00:37:59,276 Instead, the circus has just added another ring. 503 00:37:59,278 --> 00:38:02,412 - And we're the clowns. - Who's "we," 504 00:38:02,414 --> 00:38:04,881 Jack? 505 00:38:04,883 --> 00:38:07,017 - I got off track. 506 00:38:07,019 --> 00:38:11,288 - You have to force yourself out of this train of thought. 507 00:38:11,290 --> 00:38:13,290 The trial was going wrong 508 00:38:13,292 --> 00:38:15,925 before this murder. The trial was going wrong 509 00:38:15,927 --> 00:38:18,695 because you wanted to believe will Graham. 510 00:38:18,697 --> 00:38:21,865 Who is he to you that makes you want to risk everything for him? 511 00:38:21,867 --> 00:38:25,969 - A very cogent reminder of the pitfalls of having faith in one's fellow man, thank you. 512 00:38:25,971 --> 00:38:30,740 - Everyone at one point or another has to leave somebody behind. 513 00:38:30,742 --> 00:38:32,742 You've got to cut him loose. 514 00:38:32,744 --> 00:38:34,744 Otherwise, the someone being left behind, 515 00:38:34,746 --> 00:38:37,580 today or tomorrow... 516 00:38:37,582 --> 00:38:39,482 Is gonna be you. 517 00:39:04,342 --> 00:39:06,509 (Door buzzer) 518 00:39:06,511 --> 00:39:08,712 (Door opening) 519 00:39:08,714 --> 00:39:10,780 (Footsteps) 520 00:39:29,500 --> 00:39:31,768 (Footsteps) 521 00:39:44,382 --> 00:39:46,649 (Footsteps) 522 00:40:04,135 --> 00:40:06,035 - (Hannibal): Will. 523 00:40:16,514 --> 00:40:21,718 - I was hoping the verdict would have helped focus your mind to get better; 524 00:40:21,720 --> 00:40:26,122 make what happened to you less terrifying and confusing. 525 00:40:28,793 --> 00:40:31,528 I can't exactly blame your lawyer. 526 00:40:31,530 --> 00:40:34,063 - Faith in any sort of legal justice has never been 527 00:40:34,065 --> 00:40:36,166 any more comforting than a nightlight. 528 00:40:38,669 --> 00:40:41,671 - There are so many miscarriages of justice 529 00:40:41,673 --> 00:40:45,675 when it comes to identifying a psychopath. 530 00:40:45,677 --> 00:40:48,144 You could easily have been misdiagnosed. 531 00:40:48,146 --> 00:40:52,015 - I've already been misdiagnosed. 532 00:40:52,017 --> 00:40:54,484 - Not by the court. 533 00:40:54,486 --> 00:40:58,021 - No. Not yet. 534 00:41:03,494 --> 00:41:07,497 I walked out of that courtroom, and I could hear my blood, 535 00:41:07,499 --> 00:41:09,132 like, uh... 536 00:41:11,068 --> 00:41:13,736 ...a hollow drumming of wings. 537 00:41:13,738 --> 00:41:16,873 And I had the... 538 00:41:16,875 --> 00:41:19,175 Absurd feeling 539 00:41:19,177 --> 00:41:21,845 that whoever this killer is... 540 00:41:24,515 --> 00:41:27,116 ...he walked out of that courtroom with me. 541 00:41:32,790 --> 00:41:35,658 He's gonna reach out to me. 542 00:41:37,595 --> 00:41:39,596 - What does he want? 543 00:41:45,803 --> 00:41:47,871 - He wants to know me. 544 00:41:55,145 --> 00:41:57,213 What do you want? 545 00:42:02,086 --> 00:42:04,153 - I want to save you. 546 00:42:33,050 --> 00:42:36,119 Closed captioning by sette inc.