1
00:00:08,408 --> 00:00:12,544
[narrator] a 911 call upends
a small indiana town.
2
00:00:16,950 --> 00:00:18,550
[tom] he was laying in
the middle of the bed
3
00:00:18,619 --> 00:00:21,553
With his feet
hanging off the bottom.
4
00:00:21,555 --> 00:00:24,957
Blood spatter all over
the headboard, the walls.
5
00:00:25,959 --> 00:00:28,160
[narrator] investigators work to
unravel
6
00:00:28,228 --> 00:00:30,895
A web of rumor and hearsay.
7
00:00:31,798 --> 00:00:34,232
There had been a fight at
the party the night before.
8
00:00:34,301 --> 00:00:36,435
By the end of the day,
we had several suspects,
9
00:00:36,503 --> 00:00:39,438
But we had far more questions
than we had answers to.
10
00:00:41,475 --> 00:00:45,411
[narrator] a dangerous dynamic
points to a potential motive...
11
00:00:46,380 --> 00:00:48,147
It was clear there was
a love triangle.
12
00:00:57,758 --> 00:01:00,825
[narrator] but there is more to
this love triangle
13
00:01:00,827 --> 00:01:02,594
Than meets the eye.
14
00:01:02,929 --> 00:01:03,896
[sarah] between the two of 'em,
15
00:01:03,964 --> 00:01:05,296
They gave me everything
that I wanted.
16
00:01:05,366 --> 00:01:07,466
There was quite a bit of
drug use going on.
17
00:01:07,534 --> 00:01:09,134
[beth] nobody was thinking
clearly.
18
00:01:09,202 --> 00:01:11,537
I think it probably just
got outta hand.
19
00:01:16,477 --> 00:01:22,347
[theme music]
20
00:01:27,587 --> 00:01:30,489
[narrator] July 19th, 2017.
21
00:01:31,225 --> 00:01:32,591
It's a quiet summer day
22
00:01:32,659 --> 00:01:34,960
In the rural
midwestern community
23
00:01:35,028 --> 00:01:36,762
Of birdseye, indiana.
24
00:01:37,831 --> 00:01:41,166
It's a little one-horse town,
you'd call it.
25
00:01:41,936 --> 00:01:43,902
It has a post office.
26
00:01:44,572 --> 00:01:47,372
We got a family dollar,
and it's got a gas station.
27
00:01:47,741 --> 00:01:49,708
It's also the home of
the dairy barn.
28
00:01:49,710 --> 00:01:52,511
It won some kind of a prize for
the best ice cream.
29
00:01:53,213 --> 00:01:55,314
There's not much in birdseye.
30
00:01:58,151 --> 00:02:01,920
[narrator] the lazy afternoon
is interrupted at around 2 p.M.
31
00:02:01,988 --> 00:02:06,858
When 40-year-old sarah andry
makes a panicked 911 call.
32
00:02:07,461 --> 00:02:10,328
She asks dispatchers to send
someone to the home of
33
00:02:10,397 --> 00:02:12,731
Her boyfriend, darin atkins.
34
00:02:35,188 --> 00:02:36,989
[narrator] sarah explains
she and her mom
35
00:02:37,057 --> 00:02:40,358
Are parked at an intersection
called bretzville junction,
36
00:02:40,427 --> 00:02:43,295
About 11 miles away from
darin's home.
37
00:02:51,705 --> 00:02:54,439
[tom] several other deputies,
including myself,
38
00:02:54,508 --> 00:02:57,542
Went to where
the deceased male was.
39
00:02:58,145 --> 00:03:00,445
It's a trailer that sits on
a little lot.
40
00:03:00,514 --> 00:03:02,447
There was just
a very short hallway
41
00:03:02,516 --> 00:03:04,917
That opened up into
the master bedroom.
42
00:03:05,519 --> 00:03:07,486
There you saw the body.
43
00:03:10,657 --> 00:03:12,724
It was very clear that there was
44
00:03:12,793 --> 00:03:15,294
Some type of
a blunt-force object used,
45
00:03:15,829 --> 00:03:18,596
Because his whole side of
his face was bashed in
46
00:03:19,032 --> 00:03:20,432
And the amount of blood spatter
47
00:03:20,500 --> 00:03:23,101
All over the headboard,
the walls.
48
00:03:24,137 --> 00:03:26,070
He was laying in the middle of
the bed
49
00:03:26,573 --> 00:03:29,274
With his feet
hanging off the bottom.
50
00:03:30,410 --> 00:03:32,244
They confirmed he was deceased.
51
00:03:32,913 --> 00:03:35,280
They immediately made sure there
was nobody else in there,
52
00:03:35,349 --> 00:03:39,151
And waited to have
crime scene come.
53
00:03:42,522 --> 00:03:45,423
[narrator] as the crime scene
investigation gets underway,
54
00:03:46,092 --> 00:03:49,194
A dubois county deputy meets
sarah and her mother
55
00:03:49,262 --> 00:03:50,929
At bretzville junction.
56
00:03:51,798 --> 00:03:54,266
So, sarah's demeanor at
the bretzville junction
57
00:03:54,334 --> 00:03:56,367
Was kinda all over the place.
58
00:03:56,369 --> 00:03:59,304
She was, she was crying.
She was visibly upset.
59
00:04:00,441 --> 00:04:02,507
I never seen a dead person
before,
60
00:04:02,576 --> 00:04:04,876
And I was just freaked out.
61
00:04:05,212 --> 00:04:06,644
[narrator] the deputy asks sarah
62
00:04:06,714 --> 00:04:09,815
Why she didn't call 911 from
darin's house.
63
00:04:11,017 --> 00:04:12,383
Sarah had active warrants,
64
00:04:12,453 --> 00:04:14,720
And that's why sarah
didn't wanna call the police.
65
00:04:14,788 --> 00:04:18,256
She had two outstanding warrants
for failure to appears.
66
00:04:18,992 --> 00:04:21,058
[sarah] I should've called 911
right there.
67
00:04:21,060 --> 00:04:22,694
But I wasn't thinking.
68
00:04:29,870 --> 00:04:30,969
I was cryin',
69
00:04:31,037 --> 00:04:33,839
And we stopped on the side of
the road and called 911.
70
00:04:37,410 --> 00:04:39,411
[narrator] sarah recounts to
the deputy
71
00:04:39,479 --> 00:04:42,347
What she saw inside
darin's trailer.
72
00:04:43,316 --> 00:04:45,149
[sarah] I tried to go in
the door,
73
00:04:45,151 --> 00:04:45,817
The door was locked.
74
00:04:46,820 --> 00:04:48,853
We always had windows we get in,
you know,
75
00:04:48,855 --> 00:04:50,989
'cause sometimes I would get
locked out
76
00:04:51,057 --> 00:04:52,323
Or he would get locked out.
77
00:04:52,325 --> 00:04:53,992
So, I had to go through
the kitchen window.
78
00:04:54,060 --> 00:04:57,496
I went in the house, and I seen
him layin' in the bed.
79
00:05:08,308 --> 00:05:10,442
I shook him,
and he wouldn't wake up.
80
00:05:10,510 --> 00:05:12,277
I should've called 911
right there
81
00:05:12,345 --> 00:05:13,678
Whenever I was down there,
82
00:05:13,680 --> 00:05:15,780
But I'd never seen a dead body
before.
83
00:05:15,782 --> 00:05:19,851
Nonetheless one that I loved,
so I wasn't thinking.
84
00:05:19,920 --> 00:05:22,688
I can't believe it.
And I was in shock.
85
00:05:27,360 --> 00:05:30,795
[narrator] born on
September 21st, 1967,
86
00:05:30,864 --> 00:05:34,399
Darin atkins grew up on
the outskirts of birdseye.
87
00:05:35,502 --> 00:05:37,568
[cheri] darin was real close
with his family.
88
00:05:37,638 --> 00:05:39,738
[indistinct] and jack
were good parents,
89
00:05:39,806 --> 00:05:43,342
And his brother, david,
you know, they were all close.
90
00:05:47,380 --> 00:05:48,613
[narrator] soon after
high school,
91
00:05:48,682 --> 00:05:50,949
Darin met cheri cravens.
92
00:05:51,618 --> 00:05:53,518
I was workin' at sunoco in
birdseye,
93
00:05:54,054 --> 00:05:57,021
And he used to come in
all the time and flirt.
94
00:05:57,958 --> 00:06:00,492
[narrator] the flirtation
quickly led to more.
95
00:06:01,161 --> 00:06:03,628
[cheri] me and darin, we were
just sittin' there talkin',
96
00:06:03,630 --> 00:06:07,466
And he just leaned over and
he said, "I love you."
97
00:06:08,168 --> 00:06:09,568
I said, "I love you too."
98
00:06:10,837 --> 00:06:13,338
"will you do me the honors of
bein' my wife?"
99
00:06:14,040 --> 00:06:15,607
And I said yes.
100
00:06:20,313 --> 00:06:23,915
[narrator] they married on
April 16th, 1988.
101
00:06:24,518 --> 00:06:27,452
Darin's dad gave us
a acre of land,
102
00:06:27,521 --> 00:06:29,221
That was our wedding present.
103
00:06:29,289 --> 00:06:32,290
And that's where we put
our first home,
104
00:06:32,659 --> 00:06:34,092
In the good old days.
105
00:06:34,561 --> 00:06:39,197
September 1st, 1988,
tiffany leona atkins came along;
106
00:06:39,265 --> 00:06:40,832
Mine and darin's
oldest daughter.
107
00:06:41,334 --> 00:06:42,534
[tammy] they were very happy.
108
00:06:42,803 --> 00:06:45,303
She was a little firecracker.
109
00:06:46,506 --> 00:06:50,142
And then, a year later,
brittany came in February.
110
00:06:51,011 --> 00:06:53,912
His lifelong dream was to be
a truck driver.
111
00:06:54,547 --> 00:06:57,015
He went to truck driving school.
112
00:06:57,017 --> 00:07:01,085
He got a cdl,
and he was very happy.
113
00:07:01,955 --> 00:07:05,256
[narrator] the local hauling
fit darin's family lifestyle.
114
00:07:05,825 --> 00:07:07,125
He was home every night.
115
00:07:07,193 --> 00:07:09,728
He didn't like the idea
of bein' away from home,
116
00:07:10,063 --> 00:07:11,029
Which was good.
117
00:07:14,701 --> 00:07:16,901
[narrator] after nearly
two decades together,
118
00:07:16,970 --> 00:07:20,438
The couple amicably divorced
in 2003.
119
00:07:20,907 --> 00:07:22,707
[cheri] me and darin had
a good relationship.
120
00:07:22,776 --> 00:07:25,977
But there was three people on
our marriage bed.
121
00:07:25,979 --> 00:07:29,414
There was me, there was darin,
and there was his mother.
122
00:07:29,616 --> 00:07:31,783
His mom always meddled.
123
00:07:32,185 --> 00:07:36,154
Just got tired of it.
She won, and I moved on.
124
00:07:36,222 --> 00:07:39,758
It was sad, because me and darin
did have a good relationship.
125
00:07:40,226 --> 00:07:41,159
We did.
126
00:07:42,262 --> 00:07:43,395
[narrator] but the divorce
wouldn't be
127
00:07:43,463 --> 00:07:46,531
The biggest challenge
cheri and darin would face...
128
00:07:47,333 --> 00:07:51,036
Me and darin ended up
losin' both of our daughters.
129
00:07:51,938 --> 00:07:56,808
June 19th, 2006.
Car wreck.
130
00:07:58,178 --> 00:08:01,713
They was out cruisin', you know,
tiffany's boyfriend.
131
00:08:02,816 --> 00:08:06,417
And he was drivin' at
a high rate of speed.
132
00:08:07,120 --> 00:08:09,620
We didn't know they were gone
until we got to the hospital.
133
00:08:10,156 --> 00:08:13,992
It was very hard on our family.
It was just horrible.
134
00:08:14,527 --> 00:08:16,528
[narrator] darin was devastated.
135
00:08:17,163 --> 00:08:20,031
After, you know, he got with
just a bad crowd,
136
00:08:20,033 --> 00:08:22,834
And I know he started probably
doin' drugs.
137
00:08:23,103 --> 00:08:24,636
He just changed, you know?
138
00:08:26,339 --> 00:08:28,507
He wasn't the same darin
anymore.
139
00:08:30,810 --> 00:08:34,746
[narrator] in 2014,
darin met sarah andry,
140
00:08:34,814 --> 00:08:37,682
Who was a salve for
his hurting heart.
141
00:08:39,385 --> 00:08:44,723
She's a bubbly, kinda shy,
but bubbly and, and energetic.
142
00:08:44,791 --> 00:08:46,791
Kinda all-in-one big bundle.
143
00:08:47,960 --> 00:08:52,130
But she was always really
nice to people.
144
00:08:56,836 --> 00:08:59,137
[narrator] born in 1976,
145
00:08:59,205 --> 00:09:00,838
Sarah and her three siblings
146
00:09:00,840 --> 00:09:03,441
Were raised by her mom
and stepfather
147
00:09:03,443 --> 00:09:05,977
In the tiny town of
akron, indiana.
148
00:09:07,347 --> 00:09:11,249
My mom worked at a dairy farm,
and my dad sold insurance.
149
00:09:11,618 --> 00:09:13,617
Me and mom's always been
really close.
150
00:09:13,954 --> 00:09:15,954
I mean, she's my best friend,
I love her.
151
00:09:20,026 --> 00:09:23,761
[narrator] she enjoyed
a carefree small-town childhood
152
00:09:23,763 --> 00:09:26,897
Until she got pregnant as
a high school freshman.
153
00:09:27,734 --> 00:09:29,901
[sarah] he took me and moved to
florida.
154
00:09:31,237 --> 00:09:33,171
I married the first man
I ever kissed.
155
00:09:34,240 --> 00:09:36,841
I was really excited when
my oldest daughter was born.
156
00:09:36,910 --> 00:09:39,344
My boys were born in '93.
157
00:09:39,946 --> 00:09:42,814
The last daughter was
born in '95.
158
00:09:47,020 --> 00:09:52,056
At that time, I was introduced
to weed and cocaine and meth,
159
00:09:52,058 --> 00:09:55,760
And when my kids were
8, 11, and 12,
160
00:09:57,263 --> 00:09:58,396
I lost my kids.
161
00:09:58,464 --> 00:09:59,864
I, they got put into
foster care,
162
00:09:59,933 --> 00:10:01,533
And then they got adopted.
163
00:10:01,601 --> 00:10:03,101
It was a horrible marriage.
164
00:10:03,503 --> 00:10:05,303
He filed for divorce, finally,
165
00:10:05,705 --> 00:10:09,741
And I signed the papers and that
was the end of that.
166
00:10:13,546 --> 00:10:15,513
[narrator] looking for
a fresh start,
167
00:10:15,515 --> 00:10:17,849
Sarah headed back to indiana.
168
00:10:19,085 --> 00:10:21,919
I was really happy to move back
around my family.
169
00:10:22,322 --> 00:10:23,922
I moved in with my mom.
170
00:10:24,324 --> 00:10:25,523
I started working at
171
00:10:25,591 --> 00:10:27,392
The little dairy farm
where my mom worked,
172
00:10:27,761 --> 00:10:29,260
Milked cows.
173
00:10:32,932 --> 00:10:35,466
[narrator] but 37-year-old sarah
was lonely
174
00:10:35,535 --> 00:10:39,704
When she met 46-year-old darin
in 2014.
175
00:10:40,840 --> 00:10:43,808
I met darin on facebook,
was up late.
176
00:10:43,876 --> 00:10:44,809
He came and picked me up,
177
00:10:44,878 --> 00:10:46,911
And I went down there that night
and talked to him.
178
00:10:47,514 --> 00:10:49,848
He said that he'd a hard time
and had a hard life;
179
00:10:49,916 --> 00:10:52,784
His two, two daughters got
killed in a bad car accident.
180
00:10:53,253 --> 00:10:54,852
And I was there for a couple of
days,
181
00:10:54,921 --> 00:10:56,087
And I just never left.
182
00:10:56,722 --> 00:10:58,055
He was a good guy.
183
00:10:58,124 --> 00:11:00,992
I don't know, I just liked
everything about him.
184
00:11:01,894 --> 00:11:03,495
[narrator] sarah moved in,
185
00:11:03,563 --> 00:11:06,865
And the couple looked to bury
their pain in a good time.
186
00:11:08,268 --> 00:11:10,535
The place they was at was just
a big party house.
187
00:11:10,603 --> 00:11:13,071
I mean, it was drugs and
havin' fun.
188
00:11:16,676 --> 00:11:18,542
[narrator] but after
three years,
189
00:11:18,544 --> 00:11:20,278
They were ready for a change.
190
00:11:21,581 --> 00:11:23,848
Me and darin just broke down to
each other,
191
00:11:23,916 --> 00:11:27,885
And we said, you know,
we couldn't do this anymore.
192
00:11:27,954 --> 00:11:29,521
We was living the wrong
kinda life
193
00:11:29,589 --> 00:11:32,223
With all the drugs and
everything else.
194
00:11:33,092 --> 00:11:36,060
[narrator] on July 19th, 2017,
195
00:11:36,329 --> 00:11:40,732
Their dream of a sober future
ends in bloodshed.
196
00:11:42,636 --> 00:11:46,171
A dubois county deputy continue
to speak with sarah
197
00:11:46,506 --> 00:11:49,708
After she discovered
darin's battered body.
198
00:11:56,983 --> 00:11:58,683
Sarah, at that point, was taken
to the,
199
00:11:58,751 --> 00:12:00,185
The sheriff's department.
200
00:12:04,924 --> 00:12:06,057
[narrator] at darin's trailer,
201
00:12:07,327 --> 00:12:10,361
Homicide investigators continue
searching for clues.
202
00:12:11,698 --> 00:12:12,864
[tom] we found the wallet;
203
00:12:14,200 --> 00:12:17,469
It was partially opened,
laying on top of a trash bag.
204
00:12:17,904 --> 00:12:19,804
There was no money
in the wallet.
205
00:12:20,640 --> 00:12:22,573
Somebody either stealing
his money,
206
00:12:22,642 --> 00:12:25,409
Or there was something out of
his wallet that they wanted.
207
00:12:26,212 --> 00:12:28,980
Maybe they made it look like
it's a robbery gone wrong.
208
00:12:29,048 --> 00:12:31,615
When a homicide takes place,
it's kind of a big deal.
209
00:12:31,685 --> 00:12:34,084
Especially a small community
like dubois.
210
00:12:34,086 --> 00:12:36,387
We just don't
have a lot of violent crime.
211
00:12:39,993 --> 00:12:41,425
[narrator] coming up.
212
00:12:41,427 --> 00:12:44,262
Investigators turn to sarah
for answers...
213
00:12:50,636 --> 00:12:53,404
There had been a fight at
the party the night before.
214
00:12:53,840 --> 00:12:55,739
[narrator] and undercover
a grudge.
215
00:12:56,476 --> 00:13:00,979
Darin had burned his trailer.
That was motive.
216
00:13:02,448 --> 00:13:05,683
[music]
217
00:13:09,955 --> 00:13:12,323
[music]
218
00:13:15,595 --> 00:13:18,162
[narrator] July 19th, 2017.
219
00:13:18,832 --> 00:13:21,465
Investigators in birdseye,
indiana
220
00:13:21,534 --> 00:13:26,270
Continue processing the home
of 49-year-old darin atkins,
221
00:13:26,940 --> 00:13:30,275
Who was found beaten to death
in his bedroom.
222
00:13:32,011 --> 00:13:34,178
No murder weapon was located.
223
00:13:34,180 --> 00:13:36,214
We just knew that it was
a blunt-force object.
224
00:13:41,687 --> 00:13:43,921
[rick] you had a pool of blood
in one location on the mattress.
225
00:13:43,990 --> 00:13:47,491
You had mr. Atkins' body in
a different location.
226
00:13:48,494 --> 00:13:50,828
[beth] there was also
a bloody blanket on the floor
227
00:13:51,431 --> 00:13:53,631
And a bloody pillow
on the floor.
228
00:13:54,234 --> 00:13:57,201
It almost appeared
as if somebody had attempted to
229
00:13:57,270 --> 00:13:58,336
Take the body out of there.
230
00:13:58,404 --> 00:14:02,173
But I think they realized that
it was way too difficult.
231
00:14:04,510 --> 00:14:07,645
[narrator] though the attacker
did not remove darin's body,
232
00:14:07,713 --> 00:14:10,581
They did take the contents
of his wallet.
233
00:14:11,884 --> 00:14:15,453
Investigators consider whether
robbery was the motive...
234
00:14:15,655 --> 00:14:17,322
Or an afterthought.
235
00:14:18,591 --> 00:14:22,360
A robbery gone wrong wasn't
necessarily ruled out,
236
00:14:22,428 --> 00:14:25,830
But different pieces of, of that
particular puzzle
237
00:14:25,898 --> 00:14:27,232
Just didn't add up.
238
00:14:28,134 --> 00:14:29,233
[tom] the tv was there,
239
00:14:29,302 --> 00:14:31,469
And then I don't believe there
was a lot in the residence
240
00:14:31,537 --> 00:14:34,739
That someone would've broke in
and stole.
241
00:14:38,878 --> 00:14:41,679
[narrator] investigators head
back to the sheriff's office
242
00:14:41,748 --> 00:14:43,681
To speak with darin's
girlfriend,
243
00:14:43,750 --> 00:14:45,149
Sarah andry.
244
00:14:46,586 --> 00:14:49,086
She says she and darin were
trying to get clean
245
00:14:49,222 --> 00:14:51,322
And build a future together.
246
00:14:52,425 --> 00:14:54,825
He asked me to marry him,
I said yes.
247
00:14:54,894 --> 00:14:56,293
But...
248
00:14:56,362 --> 00:14:58,729
It just, the drugs and
the life we was livin',
249
00:14:58,798 --> 00:15:01,432
It just wasn't happening.
250
00:15:07,507 --> 00:15:10,775
It was determined that there was
a so-called party there
251
00:15:10,843 --> 00:15:12,276
The night before,
252
00:15:12,345 --> 00:15:14,812
With maybe eight individuals
that were at that party.
253
00:15:15,448 --> 00:15:16,880
[sarah] people kept showin' up.
254
00:15:17,316 --> 00:15:19,216
I mean, there was people
in and out.
255
00:15:19,819 --> 00:15:21,653
[tom] sarah said the people at
the party,
256
00:15:21,721 --> 00:15:23,454
They all were gone by midnight.
257
00:15:23,523 --> 00:15:26,524
The only one there past that
was sarah.
258
00:15:29,629 --> 00:15:32,362
[narrator] sarah says she stayed
the night at darin's
259
00:15:32,364 --> 00:15:34,231
And left around 8 a.M.
260
00:15:34,300 --> 00:15:37,535
To go to her friend
jason atkins's house.
261
00:15:38,237 --> 00:15:40,805
Though darin and jason share
the same last name,
262
00:15:40,873 --> 00:15:42,440
They are not related.
263
00:15:43,543 --> 00:15:46,344
Darin lived about a mile or so
away from
264
00:15:46,346 --> 00:15:49,013
Where jason atkins'
residence was.
265
00:15:49,549 --> 00:15:53,050
Darin and jason knew each other
for a very long time.
266
00:15:53,119 --> 00:15:54,752
They both grew up in
that community.
267
00:15:55,287 --> 00:15:58,122
Sarah took her laundry basket
and all of her laundry
268
00:15:58,191 --> 00:16:00,058
To jason's to do laundry.
269
00:16:00,126 --> 00:16:02,192
And then, when she returned,
270
00:16:02,194 --> 00:16:05,930
That's when she noticed that
darin was deceased.
271
00:16:20,280 --> 00:16:22,780
[beth] she said that there had
been a fight at the party
272
00:16:22,849 --> 00:16:23,848
The night before.
273
00:16:25,017 --> 00:16:27,751
Somethin' about jason bledsoe
usin' darin's car
274
00:16:27,753 --> 00:16:29,219
And not bringing the car back.
275
00:16:29,289 --> 00:16:31,923
And there was bad blood between
the two of them.
276
00:16:35,562 --> 00:16:38,996
[narrator] before investigators
track down jason bledsoe,
277
00:16:39,565 --> 00:16:42,333
They inform sarah that she will
have to remain at
278
00:16:42,401 --> 00:16:44,402
The dubois county jail.
279
00:16:45,004 --> 00:16:46,938
She had some
minor theft charges.
280
00:16:47,006 --> 00:16:48,873
At the time, she had
an outstanding warrant
281
00:16:48,941 --> 00:16:50,641
When we arrested her for this.
282
00:16:53,679 --> 00:16:55,279
[narrator] investigators are
eager to
283
00:16:55,348 --> 00:16:57,014
Speak with jason bledsoe,
284
00:16:57,083 --> 00:16:59,083
As well as the other partygoer.
285
00:16:59,753 --> 00:17:01,853
[rick] by the end of the day,
on July 19th,
286
00:17:01,921 --> 00:17:03,554
We had several suspects.
287
00:17:04,089 --> 00:17:06,290
People that was at the trailer
that you normally want to
288
00:17:06,292 --> 00:17:08,159
Include in your suspect pool.
289
00:17:08,894 --> 00:17:10,761
But also, at the end of the day,
on July 19th,
290
00:17:10,830 --> 00:17:13,231
We had far more questions than
we had answers to.
291
00:17:16,869 --> 00:17:17,902
[narrator] the following day,
292
00:17:17,970 --> 00:17:20,671
Investigators receive
darin's autopsy.
293
00:17:21,807 --> 00:17:22,807
He died from
294
00:17:22,875 --> 00:17:24,241
A blunt force trauma
to the head.
295
00:17:24,544 --> 00:17:26,543
[rick] darin atkins had
a lot of trauma
296
00:17:26,545 --> 00:17:28,178
To the left side of his face.
297
00:17:28,848 --> 00:17:31,415
It also noted several
small cuts.
298
00:17:31,984 --> 00:17:33,284
In all likelihood that was
299
00:17:33,352 --> 00:17:37,521
The barbwire bat
that was used to kill darin.
300
00:17:38,724 --> 00:17:41,191
They were able to determine that
when he was discovered at noon,
301
00:17:41,261 --> 00:17:44,895
He'd been dead for quite
a period of time before that.
302
00:17:45,631 --> 00:17:48,432
[tom] our pathologist who came
in and performed the autopsy
303
00:17:48,501 --> 00:17:51,535
Stated that it was probably,
presumably,
304
00:17:51,604 --> 00:17:54,205
Sometime between four and
eight o'clock in the morning.
305
00:17:55,341 --> 00:17:57,341
[beth] sarah originally
said that
306
00:17:57,410 --> 00:18:00,277
She had been at darin's
all night,
307
00:18:00,346 --> 00:18:03,047
And that she left around
8 o'clock that morning
308
00:18:03,115 --> 00:18:05,115
To go to jason atkins' to do
some laundry.
309
00:18:05,718 --> 00:18:09,287
So, we had to try
to nail down when he was alive.
310
00:18:13,492 --> 00:18:16,326
[narrator] with new insight
into the crime's timeline,
311
00:18:16,396 --> 00:18:18,295
Investigators next locate
312
00:18:18,364 --> 00:18:22,467
The man sarah named in her
statement, jason bledsoe.
313
00:18:23,436 --> 00:18:25,036
[tom] I met with him in
a parking lot
314
00:18:25,104 --> 00:18:26,604
Of an antique store.
315
00:18:27,907 --> 00:18:30,808
He corroborated some of what
sarah said about the car.
316
00:18:32,178 --> 00:18:34,845
[beth] darin was mad that jason
wasn't bringing his car back,
317
00:18:34,914 --> 00:18:36,880
But I don't think it rose to
the level of violence.
318
00:18:36,949 --> 00:18:39,249
I think it was just,
"hey, I want my car back,"
319
00:18:39,319 --> 00:18:41,652
And jason's
not bringing the car back.
320
00:18:42,722 --> 00:18:45,523
[narrator] jason bledsoe admits
to being at the party,
321
00:18:45,591 --> 00:18:48,392
But says he left sometime
before midnight
322
00:18:48,394 --> 00:18:50,128
And never returned.
323
00:18:51,163 --> 00:18:53,264
He was at his girlfriend's
residence.
324
00:18:53,533 --> 00:18:55,166
There was numerous people there.
325
00:18:55,701 --> 00:18:58,368
So, there were other individuals
that saw them there
326
00:18:58,438 --> 00:19:01,272
And confirmed that they had been
there since around dark
327
00:19:01,340 --> 00:19:02,673
On the night before.
328
00:19:07,413 --> 00:19:09,380
[narrator] investigators begin
moving through
329
00:19:09,448 --> 00:19:11,015
The list of partygoers,
330
00:19:11,083 --> 00:19:13,284
Tracking them down one by one.
331
00:19:13,819 --> 00:19:15,586
[beth] according to everyone
that knew darin,
332
00:19:15,655 --> 00:19:17,621
Darin atkins was
a really nice guy,
333
00:19:17,623 --> 00:19:19,390
And they said
that he would help anybody,
334
00:19:19,458 --> 00:19:21,159
He would do anything for
anybody.
335
00:19:21,961 --> 00:19:25,162
[narrator] they also learn that
darin kept a unique weapon
336
00:19:25,231 --> 00:19:27,531
Inside the trailer for
protection.
337
00:19:28,534 --> 00:19:31,302
There were several different
people that had told us
338
00:19:31,370 --> 00:19:35,539
That darin atkins had had a bat
at one time
339
00:19:35,608 --> 00:19:38,476
That he had wrapped in barbwire.
340
00:19:39,979 --> 00:19:42,713
Darin had a baseball bat that he
always had at that house
341
00:19:42,782 --> 00:19:45,249
That was never located,
that was never recovered.
342
00:19:50,656 --> 00:19:53,056
[narrator] as authorities talk
to the partygoers,
343
00:19:53,058 --> 00:19:57,094
They learn of a conflict betwee
darin and a man at the party
344
00:19:57,162 --> 00:19:58,896
Named stephen clapp.
345
00:19:59,865 --> 00:20:03,400
Stephen clapp's trailer in
birdseye
346
00:20:03,469 --> 00:20:05,903
Had burned at one point in time.
347
00:20:06,706 --> 00:20:10,107
Property that belonged to
stephen prior to the arson
348
00:20:10,776 --> 00:20:13,110
Ended up in the possession of
darin atkins.
349
00:20:13,947 --> 00:20:17,114
Stephen clapp believed that
darin had burned his trailer.
350
00:20:17,983 --> 00:20:20,151
[tom] but there was some time
that had passed,
351
00:20:20,219 --> 00:20:24,121
So stephen clapp was also in
that group
352
00:20:24,189 --> 00:20:26,691
That went to darin's,
to frequent darin's.
353
00:20:27,893 --> 00:20:29,693
[narrator] according to
several guests,
354
00:20:29,695 --> 00:20:33,264
Stephen left the party in a huf
and walked home.
355
00:20:37,470 --> 00:20:40,504
The partygoers allege stephen
had assaulted
356
00:20:40,506 --> 00:20:42,105
Another man previously
357
00:20:42,708 --> 00:20:45,843
With a weapon that raises
investigators' interest.
358
00:20:47,079 --> 00:20:49,113
[tom] we started looking into it
and found out
359
00:20:49,181 --> 00:20:52,416
Stephen did hit this gentleman
with a baseball bat.
360
00:20:52,752 --> 00:20:54,918
So, we thought it could've been
stephen clapp.
361
00:20:54,987 --> 00:20:57,321
He had motive to do this.
362
00:21:00,492 --> 00:21:01,925
[narrator] coming up.
363
00:21:01,994 --> 00:21:04,962
Investigators learn more
about stephen's night...
364
00:21:05,631 --> 00:21:07,664
Stephen was mad at his
girlfriend,
365
00:21:07,733 --> 00:21:09,132
And he started walking home.
366
00:21:09,735 --> 00:21:13,237
[narrator] and a twist reveals
a romantic rivalry.
367
00:21:19,278 --> 00:21:22,380
[music]
368
00:21:26,718 --> 00:21:28,986
[music]
369
00:21:31,891 --> 00:21:34,591
[narrator] investigators in
birdseye, indiana
370
00:21:34,660 --> 00:21:36,526
Are chasing down leads
371
00:21:36,528 --> 00:21:39,864
In the brutal beating death
of darin atkins.
372
00:21:40,900 --> 00:21:42,966
[rick] stephen clapp was
a suspect.
373
00:21:43,035 --> 00:21:45,536
There was an arson
that took place at his trailer,
374
00:21:45,805 --> 00:21:47,772
And he had suspected
darin atkins of it.
375
00:21:51,877 --> 00:21:53,511
[narrator] stephen is
brought into
376
00:21:53,579 --> 00:21:55,446
The police station
for questioning.
377
00:21:56,515 --> 00:21:59,250
He admits he did storm out
of the party,
378
00:21:59,318 --> 00:22:01,986
But not because he was angry
with darin.
379
00:22:03,589 --> 00:22:05,189
Stephen was mad at his
girlfriend,
380
00:22:05,257 --> 00:22:06,523
And he left darin's trailer,
381
00:22:06,592 --> 00:22:07,791
And he started walking home.
382
00:22:07,860 --> 00:22:09,293
And then she'd picked him up.
383
00:22:09,361 --> 00:22:10,728
But they went back to
384
00:22:10,796 --> 00:22:12,529
Stephen clapp's
mother's trailer,
385
00:22:12,598 --> 00:22:14,565
And they had been there
all night.
386
00:22:15,835 --> 00:22:18,201
[narrator] stephen claims that
the following morning,
387
00:22:18,271 --> 00:22:20,471
He got up early and went to
work.
388
00:22:21,807 --> 00:22:26,210
Darin died early morning hours
on the 19th,
389
00:22:26,278 --> 00:22:28,479
And according to stephen,
390
00:22:28,547 --> 00:22:32,316
He had went to work
early morning hours of the 19th.
391
00:22:36,422 --> 00:22:38,556
[narrator] when stephen's
interview is over,
392
00:22:38,624 --> 00:22:41,826
The first priority is
verifying his alibi.
393
00:22:43,328 --> 00:22:44,761
[tom] we went to his work,
394
00:22:44,830 --> 00:22:47,331
And we got information on
when he punched in.
395
00:22:47,733 --> 00:22:50,567
It wasn't until later on that
morning,
396
00:22:50,636 --> 00:22:53,503
More like towards the 10 o'clock
that he went to work.
397
00:22:53,505 --> 00:22:56,540
So, he was lying to us
about that.
398
00:22:57,843 --> 00:23:00,611
[narrator] investigators track
down stephen's girlfriend.
399
00:23:01,347 --> 00:23:03,080
She confirms stephen's story,
400
00:23:03,148 --> 00:23:06,016
Saying she spent the night
in question with him.
401
00:23:06,852 --> 00:23:08,351
But there is something else
402
00:23:08,353 --> 00:23:11,055
She is eager to share with
detectives.
403
00:23:12,257 --> 00:23:14,325
We found out through her that
404
00:23:14,393 --> 00:23:17,361
Sarah andry was
dating jason atkins.
405
00:23:21,700 --> 00:23:23,434
[narrator] stephen's girlfriend
says that
406
00:23:23,502 --> 00:23:24,802
For the last couple of years,
407
00:23:24,870 --> 00:23:29,440
Sarah switched back and forth
between the two men on a whim.
408
00:23:31,677 --> 00:23:34,277
She lived with jason for
a period of time,
409
00:23:34,347 --> 00:23:36,781
And then she would move down to
darin's.
410
00:23:38,183 --> 00:23:39,816
And darin and jason knew.
411
00:23:39,885 --> 00:23:41,819
People that knew darin
and people that knew jason
412
00:23:41,887 --> 00:23:44,321
Thought sarah was manipulative.
413
00:23:44,924 --> 00:23:47,691
So, whoever was nice to her or
whoever had the, the drugs,
414
00:23:47,760 --> 00:23:50,060
That's where she kinda
gravitated towards.
415
00:23:53,165 --> 00:23:56,833
[narrator] investigators attempt
to sort fact from fiction
416
00:23:56,902 --> 00:24:00,403
By collecting the cell phones
of everyone in the friend circl
417
00:24:00,405 --> 00:24:01,939
Who could be involved.
418
00:24:02,975 --> 00:24:04,508
[beth] all their cell phones
were taken.
419
00:24:04,844 --> 00:24:06,209
Got search warrants on all
those phones,
420
00:24:06,211 --> 00:24:09,146
And then we extracted all
the information off the phones.
421
00:24:10,082 --> 00:24:13,617
[narrator] the love triangle
quickly takes center stage.
422
00:24:14,787 --> 00:24:16,653
[rick] going through
social media records
423
00:24:16,722 --> 00:24:18,755
From jason atkins and
sarah andry,
424
00:24:18,824 --> 00:24:20,991
We found that he
had made comments that,
425
00:24:21,060 --> 00:24:24,427
"as long as darin's around,
I'm never gonna have you."
426
00:24:25,164 --> 00:24:27,398
[jerry] when you read those
facebook messages,
427
00:24:27,466 --> 00:24:30,834
It's very clear to me that jason
wanted sarah
428
00:24:30,836 --> 00:24:32,335
And he didn't wanna lose sarah,
429
00:24:32,405 --> 00:24:35,539
And he was jealous of the love
430
00:24:36,341 --> 00:24:40,044
That she evidently at that
time had for darin.
431
00:24:40,780 --> 00:24:42,646
Jason would have motive to kill
darin.
432
00:24:42,715 --> 00:24:43,614
Because if darin's out of
the picture,
433
00:24:43,682 --> 00:24:46,484
Then he can have sarah,
which is what he wanted.
434
00:24:50,890 --> 00:24:54,725
[narrator] as jason atkins moves
to the top of the suspect list,
435
00:24:54,793 --> 00:24:56,961
Stephen clapp falls off.
436
00:24:58,097 --> 00:25:00,964
[tom] the locations data that we
were able to get
437
00:25:01,033 --> 00:25:02,900
From cell phones
438
00:25:02,968 --> 00:25:06,737
Was proof that stephen clapp was
not at darin's location
439
00:25:06,805 --> 00:25:08,138
At the time of the homicide.
440
00:25:09,375 --> 00:25:12,676
[narrator] but darin's phone
reveals more than just that.
441
00:25:13,712 --> 00:25:17,047
[beth] there was a text sent
from his phone at 4:12 a.M.,
442
00:25:17,516 --> 00:25:19,416
Using a derogatory name for
sarah,
443
00:25:19,485 --> 00:25:21,585
Saying that
she was still at brain's.
444
00:25:21,653 --> 00:25:23,854
And brain was a nickname
for jason atkins.
445
00:25:24,256 --> 00:25:26,857
So, darin was clearly mad at
that point
446
00:25:26,926 --> 00:25:28,958
That sarah was still at jason's.
447
00:25:29,294 --> 00:25:32,663
So, we knew then that sarah
wasn't at darin's
448
00:25:32,731 --> 00:25:34,397
Like she said she was.
449
00:25:34,399 --> 00:25:38,001
Sarah says that she left about
eight o'clock that morning
450
00:25:38,070 --> 00:25:39,136
To go do laundry.
451
00:25:39,204 --> 00:25:40,738
Clearly, she was lying.
452
00:25:44,076 --> 00:25:48,245
[narrator] after realizing sarah
wasn't being entirely honest,
453
00:25:48,313 --> 00:25:50,814
Detectives meet with her on
July 28th
454
00:25:50,883 --> 00:25:52,515
At the dubois county jail,
455
00:25:52,517 --> 00:25:56,554
Where she remains in custody
on the outstanding warrants.
456
00:25:57,856 --> 00:26:00,190
Sarah admits to
the love triangle.
457
00:26:01,426 --> 00:26:02,660
I started seein' both of 'em.
458
00:26:02,728 --> 00:26:04,427
Like, if I wasn't with
one of 'em,
459
00:26:04,497 --> 00:26:06,063
I was with the other one of 'em.
460
00:26:06,131 --> 00:26:07,330
They knew it.
461
00:26:07,332 --> 00:26:09,299
Ended up choosin' darin.
462
00:26:09,835 --> 00:26:13,203
I had finally told jason,
and he wasn't happy.
463
00:26:36,762 --> 00:26:37,994
[narrator] they confront her
464
00:26:38,063 --> 00:26:40,230
About the text found on
darin's phone.
465
00:27:05,657 --> 00:27:08,492
I thought the were more
after jason,
466
00:27:08,560 --> 00:27:10,594
Or tryin'
to say jason did it than me.
467
00:27:26,712 --> 00:27:27,844
[sarah] I didn't understand.
468
00:27:27,913 --> 00:27:30,948
I thought they were tryin' to
say jason did it, then me.
469
00:27:43,128 --> 00:27:45,128
[narrator] after getting nowhere
with sarah,
470
00:27:45,197 --> 00:27:48,531
Investigators bring jason atkin
into the station
471
00:27:48,601 --> 00:27:50,401
To try their luck with him.
472
00:28:10,155 --> 00:28:12,723
Jason atkins's account of
where he was at that night
473
00:28:12,791 --> 00:28:14,625
Is he's at his house.
474
00:28:14,693 --> 00:28:16,160
He doesn't leave anywhere.
475
00:28:17,663 --> 00:28:21,164
[narrator] with sarah and jason
sticking by their stories,
476
00:28:21,166 --> 00:28:23,333
Investigators get creative...
477
00:28:24,403 --> 00:28:25,668
[tom] birdseye is not that big.
478
00:28:25,670 --> 00:28:30,641
The birdseye library sits
right there on state road 145,
479
00:28:30,709 --> 00:28:32,375
Has a great view.
480
00:28:32,844 --> 00:28:34,845
They do have a camera that
we seen.
481
00:28:38,350 --> 00:28:40,918
[narrator] to travel from
jason's house to darin's
482
00:28:40,986 --> 00:28:43,854
Would require driving past
the library
483
00:28:44,223 --> 00:28:45,622
And the camera.
484
00:28:46,725 --> 00:28:49,793
We were able to get all of
the footage from the library,
485
00:28:49,995 --> 00:28:51,762
And a camera that was basically
486
00:28:51,830 --> 00:28:53,630
One way in and one way out
of town.
487
00:28:54,366 --> 00:28:57,100
[narrator] investigators focus
on the footage from
488
00:28:57,168 --> 00:29:00,037
The early morning hours of
July 19th.
489
00:29:01,206 --> 00:29:04,341
[rick] we see jason atkins's car
at about 4:13,
490
00:29:04,409 --> 00:29:06,710
Going northbound past
the library.
491
00:29:08,180 --> 00:29:10,980
His interviews, he had said
he was staying home all night
492
00:29:11,050 --> 00:29:12,715
And that nobody had taken
his car.
493
00:29:12,985 --> 00:29:15,618
Why is his car going past
the library
494
00:29:15,688 --> 00:29:18,155
If it didn't
leave his house all night?
495
00:29:20,325 --> 00:29:23,326
[narrator] that's not all
the footage has to offer...
496
00:29:24,263 --> 00:29:26,829
[tom] we're able to see that
there's two people in the car.
497
00:29:27,032 --> 00:29:29,166
But we can't see who they are.
498
00:29:29,901 --> 00:29:31,702
[narrator] if jason is
the killer,
499
00:29:31,770 --> 00:29:34,237
It appears he had an accomplice
500
00:29:34,773 --> 00:29:36,639
[tom] so, we're gonna try to
talk to him
501
00:29:36,709 --> 00:29:40,277
And then give an opportunity
one more time to tell the truth
502
00:29:40,345 --> 00:29:44,281
That someone else was involved
in the homicide.
503
00:29:47,986 --> 00:29:49,319
[narrator] coming up.
504
00:29:49,522 --> 00:29:52,055
Investigators confront jason.
505
00:30:05,270 --> 00:30:08,272
[music]
506
00:30:12,810 --> 00:30:14,912
[music]
507
00:30:17,716 --> 00:30:21,017
[narrator] months after
the murder of darin atkins,
508
00:30:21,086 --> 00:30:23,486
Sarah andry has been released
from jail
509
00:30:23,555 --> 00:30:27,357
Where she'd been held on
unrelated outstanding warrants.
510
00:30:28,794 --> 00:30:30,293
She was released,
511
00:30:30,295 --> 00:30:33,430
And she was back into
the birdseye community.
512
00:30:37,369 --> 00:30:40,804
[narrator] with a potential
murder suspect in the community
513
00:30:40,872 --> 00:30:42,772
Investigators waste no time,
514
00:30:42,774 --> 00:30:47,377
And on may 24th, 2018,
they speak with jason again.
515
00:30:47,446 --> 00:30:50,313
This time,
in the pike county jail,
516
00:30:50,382 --> 00:30:53,383
Where he is being held on
unrelated charges.
517
00:30:53,919 --> 00:30:56,753
Jason atkins was in jail for
narcotics charges
518
00:30:56,822 --> 00:30:58,088
In a different county.
519
00:30:58,690 --> 00:31:00,557
[beth] we had what we called
the murder box.
520
00:31:00,625 --> 00:31:04,327
It was this giant box of
everything that we'd collected.
521
00:31:04,329 --> 00:31:05,662
And they just confronted him
522
00:31:05,730 --> 00:31:07,331
With different pieces of
evidence.
523
00:31:22,614 --> 00:31:26,216
But at that time, I wanted him
to also know we believed
524
00:31:26,284 --> 00:31:28,518
There was another player
that helped him out.
525
00:31:51,843 --> 00:31:53,210
[narrator] jason says
526
00:31:53,278 --> 00:31:55,913
That in the early morning hours
of July 19th,
527
00:31:55,981 --> 00:31:58,315
After the party at
darin's place,
528
00:31:58,383 --> 00:32:00,384
Sarah showed up at his house.
529
00:32:01,986 --> 00:32:04,120
[tom] he said that sarah was
telling him
530
00:32:04,189 --> 00:32:05,422
That darin beats her.
531
00:32:06,791 --> 00:32:09,393
And so, they made a pact that
they were gonna go down
532
00:32:09,461 --> 00:32:12,562
And confront him about
the abuse.
533
00:32:13,598 --> 00:32:15,131
[jerry] according to jason,
they left,
534
00:32:15,200 --> 00:32:17,868
He and sarah, in jason's car.
535
00:32:18,470 --> 00:32:23,640
They arrive at the mobile home
and jason remains outside
536
00:32:23,708 --> 00:32:28,411
While sarah allegedly
walks in without jason.
537
00:32:29,214 --> 00:32:32,950
Jason waits a few minutes
and then enters.
538
00:33:15,627 --> 00:33:18,861
He told me that after he hit him
that he was unconscious,
539
00:33:18,931 --> 00:33:20,196
But he was still alive.
540
00:33:20,265 --> 00:33:21,464
They get into the car,
541
00:33:21,533 --> 00:33:24,568
Sarah's driving the car,
and they leave.
542
00:33:52,397 --> 00:33:55,365
The facebook records
and the phone records,
543
00:33:55,433 --> 00:33:58,235
They all indicated a lot of
manipulation on her part,
544
00:33:58,237 --> 00:34:00,403
And she was playing them against
each other.
545
00:34:00,405 --> 00:34:03,673
Sarah would make accusations
against darin to jason,
546
00:34:03,675 --> 00:34:06,977
And she would make accusations
against jason to darin.
547
00:34:07,512 --> 00:34:09,612
She would get them to feel
sorry for her,
548
00:34:09,614 --> 00:34:12,315
And she would just use
that to her advantage.
549
00:34:14,052 --> 00:34:15,451
[narrator] what doesn't match
550
00:34:15,520 --> 00:34:18,855
Is what jason says happened
inside the home.
551
00:34:19,457 --> 00:34:21,791
[bill] there was certainly
multiple blows.
552
00:34:21,860 --> 00:34:22,893
That was clear.
553
00:34:23,996 --> 00:34:25,529
There was nothing about
the crime scene evidence
554
00:34:25,597 --> 00:34:27,764
That was consistent with
the story
555
00:34:28,099 --> 00:34:30,467
That jason atkins had given.
556
00:34:34,873 --> 00:34:38,642
[narrator] investigators know
they don't have the whole story
557
00:34:39,711 --> 00:34:42,211
Five days later,
jason reaches out.
558
00:34:42,714 --> 00:34:46,550
This time, he says he is ready
to tell them everything.
559
00:35:05,737 --> 00:35:09,906
He said that, in his words,
"I hit him in the head.
560
00:35:10,575 --> 00:35:11,841
I know that it knocked him out.
561
00:35:11,910 --> 00:35:14,344
He was out, but I know that
he was still alive
562
00:35:14,412 --> 00:35:16,246
When sarah picked up the bat."
563
00:35:43,141 --> 00:35:46,976
At that point, jason was
arrested for the murder,
564
00:35:47,045 --> 00:35:49,578
And we opted to go and file for
565
00:35:49,580 --> 00:35:52,315
A warrant for the arrest of
sarah.
566
00:35:56,621 --> 00:35:57,887
[narrator] investigators learn
567
00:35:57,956 --> 00:36:00,290
That after sarah's release
from jail
568
00:36:00,358 --> 00:36:01,891
Earlier in the year,
569
00:36:01,960 --> 00:36:04,927
She quickly married
an old high school friend,
570
00:36:04,996 --> 00:36:05,962
Eddie andry.
571
00:36:06,865 --> 00:36:09,099
But sarah's attempt at
domestic life
572
00:36:09,167 --> 00:36:12,569
Comes to an end on
June 11th, 2018,
573
00:36:13,171 --> 00:36:16,640
When deputies arrive at her hoe
with an arrest warrant.
574
00:36:18,376 --> 00:36:19,909
[eddie] we was asleep.
575
00:36:19,978 --> 00:36:23,847
The next thing I know, I've got
three or four officers
576
00:36:23,915 --> 00:36:25,648
Standin' around my couch,
577
00:36:25,717 --> 00:36:30,320
Screamin' with guns drawed,
tellin' us to get up,
578
00:36:30,388 --> 00:36:32,355
"let me see your hands."
579
00:36:33,591 --> 00:36:35,992
They just come in and said,
"you're under arrest."
580
00:36:36,294 --> 00:36:39,329
They handcuffed me and put me in
the car.
581
00:36:39,397 --> 00:36:41,063
Said they was arrestin'
me for murder.
582
00:36:41,700 --> 00:36:45,335
[brock] there was no upset,
there was no "I didn't do it."
583
00:36:46,004 --> 00:36:48,971
All she did was just stand up,
put her arms behind her back,
584
00:36:48,973 --> 00:36:50,006
And said okay.
585
00:36:50,342 --> 00:36:52,274
And never said
another word to us.
586
00:36:52,276 --> 00:36:54,043
I just got caught up in
the drug life,
587
00:36:54,112 --> 00:36:55,779
And this is where it got me.
588
00:36:59,484 --> 00:37:00,550
[narrator] coming up.
589
00:37:00,619 --> 00:37:03,720
Prosecutors zero in on sarah...
590
00:37:04,322 --> 00:37:06,255
[beth] we think she acted
on impulse,
591
00:37:06,325 --> 00:37:09,993
And all these emotions were
fueled by drugs.
592
00:37:10,662 --> 00:37:13,563
[narrator] but sarah sees
freedom within reach.
593
00:37:13,631 --> 00:37:15,232
It was a big roadblock to us
594
00:37:15,300 --> 00:37:17,367
That we never found
the murder weapon.
595
00:37:19,137 --> 00:37:22,205
[music]
596
00:37:26,644 --> 00:37:28,979
[music]
597
00:37:31,783 --> 00:37:33,550
[narrator] dubois county
authorities
598
00:37:33,618 --> 00:37:36,786
Have arrested sarah andry and
jason atkins
599
00:37:36,855 --> 00:37:39,689
For the beating death of
darin atkins.
600
00:37:40,391 --> 00:37:42,792
As prosecutors prepare for
trial,
601
00:37:42,861 --> 00:37:45,562
It becomes apparent that drugs
fueled
602
00:37:45,630 --> 00:37:48,531
This love triangle turned
deadly.
603
00:37:49,067 --> 00:37:51,434
I would tend to say that sarah
didn't go there
604
00:37:51,502 --> 00:37:53,870
With the intentions that darin
was gonna die.
605
00:37:55,473 --> 00:37:58,208
All these emotions were fueled
by drugs,
606
00:37:58,276 --> 00:38:00,577
And nobody was thinking clearly.
607
00:38:02,814 --> 00:38:05,582
I think it probably just got
outta hand.
608
00:38:07,552 --> 00:38:08,418
[brock] it's hard to tell
whether
609
00:38:08,486 --> 00:38:11,154
The first hit when jason
swung the bat killed him,
610
00:38:11,222 --> 00:38:14,490
Or if when sarah steps up,
grabs the baseball bat,
611
00:38:14,559 --> 00:38:16,092
And knocks him two more
times over the head,
612
00:38:16,160 --> 00:38:17,627
If that's what killed him.
613
00:38:20,865 --> 00:38:23,766
[narrator] with one of sarah's
lovers dead,
614
00:38:23,768 --> 00:38:25,902
The other turns against her.
615
00:38:26,705 --> 00:38:29,038
Jason atkins didn't go to trial.
616
00:38:29,474 --> 00:38:33,175
Jason atkins pled guilty
and took a reduced sentence
617
00:38:33,177 --> 00:38:36,078
In exchange for him testifying
against sarah.
618
00:38:36,915 --> 00:38:38,681
I never believed that he could
even do it
619
00:38:38,750 --> 00:38:40,684
'til I actually heard it come
out of his mouth.
620
00:38:43,888 --> 00:38:46,088
[narrator] in September 2020,
621
00:38:46,325 --> 00:38:48,391
Sarah sees her day in court.
622
00:38:49,060 --> 00:38:53,029
The prosecution's case
hinges on a star witness.
623
00:38:54,265 --> 00:38:58,868
Jason testifies that sarah urge
him to confront darin...
624
00:39:00,104 --> 00:39:03,139
Sarah told jason that she was
gettin' beat by darin,
625
00:39:03,208 --> 00:39:06,276
And he was gonna go down there
and confront him about it.
626
00:39:07,279 --> 00:39:11,447
[narrator] allegations
prosecutors argue are unfounded
627
00:39:11,850 --> 00:39:13,950
As far as darin atkins
committing
628
00:39:14,018 --> 00:39:15,651
Any type of assault on,
on sarah andry,
629
00:39:15,720 --> 00:39:18,388
There was never any
police reports.
630
00:39:18,456 --> 00:39:20,256
Going through the different
social medias,
631
00:39:20,324 --> 00:39:21,424
There was never
anything that we found
632
00:39:21,493 --> 00:39:24,828
Where she was telling people
that darin was beating on her.
633
00:39:28,633 --> 00:39:31,367
[narrator] prosecutors believe
sarah's true motive
634
00:39:31,436 --> 00:39:33,970
May never be entirely clear.
635
00:39:35,440 --> 00:39:38,274
[beth] other than jason saying
sarah was there,
636
00:39:38,710 --> 00:39:41,177
I think the biggest piece of
evidence
637
00:39:41,246 --> 00:39:42,979
That we had against sarah
638
00:39:43,548 --> 00:39:46,516
Was all these
wildly inconsistent stories.
639
00:39:47,652 --> 00:39:50,453
We got thousands of pages of
facebook records
640
00:39:50,522 --> 00:39:51,554
And phone records.
641
00:39:52,957 --> 00:39:57,293
It was just a consistent pattern
of, over several years' time,
642
00:39:57,361 --> 00:40:01,063
Her manipulating both of them to
get whatever she wanted
643
00:40:01,065 --> 00:40:02,164
Or needed at the time,
644
00:40:02,166 --> 00:40:06,035
Whether that was food or drugs
or a place to live.
645
00:40:06,037 --> 00:40:08,671
It was just the totality of
everything.
646
00:40:08,740 --> 00:40:10,940
It wasn't any one particular
piece of evidence.
647
00:40:11,009 --> 00:40:13,543
Everything pointed in the
direction that sarah was guilty.
648
00:40:18,483 --> 00:40:20,116
[narrator] sarah's defense
points out
649
00:40:20,184 --> 00:40:23,753
That one crucial piece of
evidence is missing.
650
00:40:24,288 --> 00:40:25,588
It was a big roadblock to us
651
00:40:25,656 --> 00:40:27,590
That we never found
the murder weapon.
652
00:40:28,827 --> 00:40:31,794
[narrator] the defense argues
that jason acted alone
653
00:40:31,863 --> 00:40:34,163
To eliminate a romantic rival,
654
00:40:34,499 --> 00:40:36,232
Pointing out that his statement
655
00:40:36,300 --> 00:40:39,135
Is all that places sarah at
the scene.
656
00:40:40,572 --> 00:40:43,173
[jerry] the police clearly made
a big deal out of
657
00:40:43,241 --> 00:40:44,707
The surveillance video.
658
00:40:44,776 --> 00:40:48,644
Without question, jason is
observed in the video,
659
00:40:48,713 --> 00:40:52,182
But at no time during
July 19, 2017,
660
00:40:52,250 --> 00:40:56,586
Was sarah andry observed in
the surveillance video.
661
00:41:00,658 --> 00:41:02,324
[narrator] they also note
a problem
662
00:41:02,326 --> 00:41:05,628
With one important piece
of jason's statement.
663
00:41:06,097 --> 00:41:09,031
He basically said that darin was
coming at him
664
00:41:09,100 --> 00:41:10,300
With a baseball bat
665
00:41:10,368 --> 00:41:11,567
In his bedroom.
666
00:41:12,070 --> 00:41:15,004
That he took the baseball bat
away from darin.
667
00:41:15,807 --> 00:41:19,676
That was not consistent with
the bloodstain pattern analysis.
668
00:41:20,879 --> 00:41:23,613
[bill] the blanket that was
pulled down to the floor,
669
00:41:24,015 --> 00:41:27,617
You could also see these
impact stains which suggest that
670
00:41:27,685 --> 00:41:30,987
Darin was under the covers when
the beating occurred.
671
00:41:32,390 --> 00:41:36,125
And so, how do you reconcile
that with jason's statement
672
00:41:36,194 --> 00:41:38,561
That he's standing up and
he disarms him?
673
00:41:38,629 --> 00:41:39,829
They just don't add up.
674
00:41:41,232 --> 00:41:44,800
And so, it begs the question,
if, if he's lying about that,
675
00:41:44,869 --> 00:41:47,904
Is he being truthful about sarah
being the person
676
00:41:47,972 --> 00:41:50,473
That inflicted
these fatal blows?
677
00:41:56,147 --> 00:41:58,547
[narrator] it's a purely
circumstantial case,
678
00:41:59,283 --> 00:42:01,484
But the judge believes
it's enough.
679
00:42:02,587 --> 00:42:04,620
They found me guilty of murder,
680
00:42:04,956 --> 00:42:07,524
And they sentenced me to
55 years.
681
00:42:09,027 --> 00:42:11,594
They had jason's word against
mine.
682
00:42:11,996 --> 00:42:13,262
I never thought in
a million years
683
00:42:13,331 --> 00:42:15,732
I'd be sittin' in prison
for a murder charge.
684
00:42:16,334 --> 00:42:19,202
Never.
But...
685
00:42:20,739 --> 00:42:22,539
It's what drugs did for me.
686
00:42:23,841 --> 00:42:25,942
Jason atkins received
20 years in prison
687
00:42:26,010 --> 00:42:27,810
Followed by five years on
home detention,
688
00:42:27,879 --> 00:42:30,680
And then 20 years on
probation after that.
689
00:42:35,386 --> 00:42:39,221
[narrator] sarah continues to
stand by her innocence.
690
00:42:40,158 --> 00:42:42,525
[sarah] I want the truth to
come out, too, for real.
691
00:42:43,261 --> 00:42:46,029
I want darin's mom to know that
I didn't do it.
692
00:42:47,031 --> 00:42:49,565
I ain't proud of it,
but that's just...
693
00:42:49,634 --> 00:42:54,170
I was on drugs,
and I wanted everything.
694
00:42:54,505 --> 00:42:55,571
Between the two of 'em,
695
00:42:55,639 --> 00:42:57,040
They gave me everything that
I wanted.
696
00:43:03,047 --> 00:43:05,448
[narrator] but there is
no denying the pain
697
00:43:05,516 --> 00:43:07,983
Darin's family continues to
suffer
698
00:43:07,985 --> 00:43:10,452
Over the loss of a man
they love.
699
00:43:11,455 --> 00:43:14,423
Darin was a good guy.
He didn't do nothin' wrong.
700
00:43:14,692 --> 00:43:17,961
I just don't understand why.
I really don't.
701
00:43:18,662 --> 00:43:19,729
He didn't deserve that.
702
00:43:19,797 --> 00:43:22,398
Nobody deserves, not that.
Nobody.
703
00:43:22,467 --> 00:43:25,768
[music]
704
00:43:26,705 --> 00:43:32,742
[music]