1
00:00:01,748 --> 00:00:04,273
In New York City's
war on crime,
2
00:00:04,351 --> 00:00:06,410
the worst criminal offenders
are pursued
3
00:00:06,486 --> 00:00:09,319
by the detectives
of the Major Case Squad.
4
00:00:09,389 --> 00:00:11,050
These are their stories.
5
00:00:13,393 --> 00:00:17,352
I had those two interviews,
but I haven't heard back.
6
00:00:17,864 --> 00:00:20,628
Well, in the meantime,
we'll keep looking.
7
00:00:20,701 --> 00:00:23,568
The meantime.
It's all the meantime.
8
00:00:24,304 --> 00:00:26,499
Keith, I tell all
my probationers,
9
00:00:26,573 --> 00:00:28,973
whatever's eating
at you, talk it out.
10
00:00:30,077 --> 00:00:32,375
Monsters only
live in the dark.
11
00:00:38,051 --> 00:00:39,951
...phone calls, you don't
make the appointments.
12
00:00:40,020 --> 00:00:42,887
You don't get appointments,
you don't make any money.
13
00:00:42,956 --> 00:00:44,514
Be right there.
14
00:00:55,469 --> 00:00:57,232
Service door, Frank.
15
00:01:05,078 --> 00:01:06,943
No. No, I won't.
16
00:01:09,349 --> 00:01:10,976
I promise. Hello?
17
00:01:20,627 --> 00:01:27,032
Stop it. Stop it.
Stop it. Stop it.
18
00:01:27,834 --> 00:01:29,859
Stop it. Stop it. Stop it.
19
00:01:29,936 --> 00:01:30,960
Stop it.
20
00:01:31,037 --> 00:01:32,163
Phoebe,
don't do this.
21
00:01:32,239 --> 00:01:33,399
Don't.
22
00:01:34,641 --> 00:01:35,801
Phoebe.
23
00:01:35,876 --> 00:01:40,745
Don't act familiar at work. Don't
get to the apartment before 9:00.
24
00:01:40,814 --> 00:01:42,475
Don't let anybody see you.
25
00:01:42,549 --> 00:01:44,073
Not this again.
26
00:01:45,786 --> 00:01:47,754
I want things to change.
27
00:01:49,856 --> 00:01:51,949
You're not
being realistic.
28
00:01:57,264 --> 00:01:58,288
So?
29
00:02:02,702 --> 00:02:03,794
Fine.
30
00:02:23,924 --> 00:02:25,414
911, what is your emergency?
31
00:02:25,492 --> 00:02:27,016
She's not breathing.
32
00:02:27,093 --> 00:02:28,253
What is your
location, sir?
33
00:02:28,328 --> 00:02:30,990
Send someone to 90...
Wait, wait.
34
00:02:32,666 --> 00:02:37,831
Stop! I can't...
Don't kill me.
35
00:02:37,904 --> 00:02:39,701
I don't wanna die.
36
00:02:42,042 --> 00:02:46,103
Now she's not breathing.
So that's 90 Rector Place
37
00:02:46,179 --> 00:02:49,478
in Battery Park City,
Apartment 408.
38
00:02:50,016 --> 00:02:51,881
Phoebe Morton is dead.
39
00:03:42,135 --> 00:03:45,070
The 911 call was made from
her cell. Name's Phoebe Morton.
40
00:03:45,138 --> 00:03:46,264
Whose name
is on the lease?
41
00:03:46,339 --> 00:03:49,638
A Mr. Paul Riddick, with a
business address over on East 15th.
42
00:03:49,709 --> 00:03:51,370
Stove's never been used,
fridge is empty.
43
00:03:51,444 --> 00:03:54,174
I'm guessing hookups are
the specialty of the house.
44
00:03:54,247 --> 00:03:56,408
Any witnesses to the
comings and goings tonight?
45
00:03:56,483 --> 00:03:58,383
Not yet. We're walking on eggshells.
46
00:03:58,451 --> 00:04:00,681
Couple of biggies from City Hall
have their girlfriends stashed here.
47
00:04:00,754 --> 00:04:03,279
Well, break all the eggshells
you want, that's why we're here.
48
00:04:05,091 --> 00:04:06,991
Cheap business suit.
49
00:04:07,060 --> 00:04:09,221
Her lingerie
is more expensive.
50
00:04:09,296 --> 00:04:11,594
She wanted to impress somebody.
51
00:04:11,665 --> 00:04:13,997
Petechial hemorrhaging is severe.
52
00:04:14,701 --> 00:04:16,692
What do you
make of this?
53
00:04:17,304 --> 00:04:18,601
I'm not sure.
54
00:04:18,672 --> 00:04:22,665
Her arms were tied behind her
back, at the elbows and the wrists.
55
00:04:23,610 --> 00:04:26,909
And then there's
this ligature mark.
56
00:04:26,980 --> 00:04:28,379
It's on only one
of her ankles.
57
00:04:28,448 --> 00:04:31,349
He might've tied her leg to
something to keep her in one place.
58
00:04:31,418 --> 00:04:34,319
Yeah, but nothing
is heavy enough.
59
00:04:40,794 --> 00:04:42,193
It's bleach.
60
00:04:42,529 --> 00:04:44,656
Someone cleaned
off a stain.
61
00:04:49,102 --> 00:04:50,535
He sat here.
62
00:04:52,405 --> 00:04:53,963
He watched her
tied up on the floor,
63
00:04:54,040 --> 00:04:59,034
and then when he decided it was
time to kill her, he called 911.
64
00:04:59,112 --> 00:05:00,875
Well, we should go
wake up Mr. Riddick,
65
00:05:00,947 --> 00:05:03,575
see if he enjoyed
the floor show.
66
00:05:07,520 --> 00:05:09,715
Go back to bed, honey.
I'll be up in a minute.
67
00:05:09,789 --> 00:05:11,313
Okay, sweetie.
68
00:05:12,125 --> 00:05:16,494
So you and Phoebe.
69
00:05:17,497 --> 00:05:19,294
How long, how often?
70
00:05:21,034 --> 00:05:24,470
Eight months, once, maybe twice a week.
71
00:05:24,738 --> 00:05:26,569
You see her
last night?
72
00:05:26,640 --> 00:05:31,703
Yes. We ended up arguing.
I left. I didn't kill her.
73
00:05:32,245 --> 00:05:34,372
What'd you
argue about?
74
00:05:34,447 --> 00:05:36,210
She wanted to change
the ground rules.
75
00:05:36,750 --> 00:05:38,012
Was she threatening
to tell your wife?
76
00:05:38,084 --> 00:05:39,984
No. No, it hadn't
come to that.
77
00:05:40,053 --> 00:05:41,680
Anyone else know
about the affair?
78
00:05:41,755 --> 00:05:45,282
No, nobody knew, not even at
work. We were very, very discreet.
79
00:05:45,358 --> 00:05:47,588
Phoebe'd leave first,
then I'd drive over,
80
00:05:47,661 --> 00:05:50,391
and call her when I got there,
to tell her to come up.
81
00:05:50,463 --> 00:05:52,658
You made her wait
out in the cold?
82
00:05:52,732 --> 00:05:57,328
Well, get dressed, Galahad, we're taking
you downtown, get some DNA samples.
83
00:05:58,171 --> 00:06:00,799
She was choked within an
inch of her life several times
84
00:06:00,874 --> 00:06:02,569
before she was finally
choked to death.
85
00:06:02,642 --> 00:06:06,100
We found a piece of blue nylon
rope embedded in her neck.
86
00:06:06,179 --> 00:06:08,511
Nylon makes for
a good slipknot.
87
00:06:10,183 --> 00:06:14,552
Okay. So he was behind her.
88
00:06:16,690 --> 00:06:21,684
Pulling. Now, he would have had to put
a hand or a knee on her to keep her down.
89
00:06:23,830 --> 00:06:26,560
No, but there would have
been marks left on her.
90
00:06:26,633 --> 00:06:28,726
Which aren't here.
91
00:06:28,802 --> 00:06:31,293
Now, what about
this ligature mark?
92
00:06:32,272 --> 00:06:35,469
It pulls in a downward
direction, toward the heel.
93
00:06:57,897 --> 00:07:04,700
Well, now it pulls up.
Towards her neck.
94
00:07:05,338 --> 00:07:08,432
He tied the rope to her ankle
and looped it around her neck.
95
00:07:08,508 --> 00:07:11,841
While she kept her leg
tensed up, she'd be all right.
96
00:07:11,911 --> 00:07:15,074
But if she relaxed it,
the rope would tighten.
97
00:07:15,915 --> 00:07:18,349
It would start
choking her.
98
00:07:18,418 --> 00:07:21,148
Till she brought
it back up again.
99
00:07:21,354 --> 00:07:24,619
Back and forth, until she
couldn't hold her leg up anymore.
100
00:07:25,792 --> 00:07:28,488
There's no evidence
of sexual assault,
101
00:07:28,561 --> 00:07:29,755
there's no semen
in or out.
102
00:07:29,829 --> 00:07:34,630
On the other hand, forensics
found seminal fluid in four places
103
00:07:34,701 --> 00:07:37,192
in the living room,
including the couch.
104
00:07:37,270 --> 00:07:39,101
Different individuals?
105
00:07:39,172 --> 00:07:42,369
Well, the samples were
extremely degraded by bleach.
106
00:07:42,442 --> 00:07:46,538
The DNA lab could only develop
5 of 13 loci for identification.
107
00:07:46,613 --> 00:07:53,109
But the samples are all from the same
individual, and it's not your Mr. Riddick.
108
00:07:56,356 --> 00:07:58,984
Semen was found in
each of these locations.
109
00:07:59,058 --> 00:08:03,722
Each position offered the killer
a clear sight line of Phoebe.
110
00:08:03,797 --> 00:08:05,958
While she struggled
to stay alive.
111
00:08:06,032 --> 00:08:07,659
Her struggle
excited him.
112
00:08:07,734 --> 00:08:10,032
He masturbated to orgasm at each spot.
113
00:08:10,103 --> 00:08:12,230
Then cleaned up
with bleach.
114
00:08:12,405 --> 00:08:15,033
He would've made
his last stand here.
115
00:08:16,242 --> 00:08:21,373
After he cleaned up,
he called 911.
116
00:08:22,015 --> 00:08:23,505
911, what is your emergency?
117
00:08:23,583 --> 00:08:25,141
She's not breathing.
118
00:08:25,218 --> 00:08:26,378
What is your
location, sir?
119
00:08:26,452 --> 00:08:28,977
Send someone to 90...
Wait, wait.
120
00:08:30,123 --> 00:08:35,561
Stop! I can't...
Don't kill me.
121
00:08:35,628 --> 00:08:37,152
He revived her.
122
00:08:38,231 --> 00:08:42,725
He wanted the operator
to hear her beg.
123
00:08:43,002 --> 00:08:46,563
Battery Park City,
Apartment 408.
124
00:08:46,639 --> 00:08:48,504
Phoebe Morton is dead.
125
00:08:49,142 --> 00:08:53,044
No panic. He was
proud of himself.
126
00:08:53,213 --> 00:08:57,411
He should be. A five-loci DNA
sample's not enough to convict anyone.
127
00:08:57,483 --> 00:09:00,350
Well, he wanted us
to know how good he is.
128
00:09:00,420 --> 00:09:05,323
If he thinks that we're not
paying attention, he'll contact us.
129
00:09:07,026 --> 00:09:09,187
You suggesting
a leak to the media?
130
00:09:09,262 --> 00:09:11,958
And deprive him
of credit for the kill.
131
00:09:32,819 --> 00:09:34,480
He took the bait.
132
00:09:42,662 --> 00:09:45,028
And that would
be proof of authorship?
133
00:09:45,098 --> 00:09:49,194
It's another girl. New Jersey
license for a Marcia Waverly.
134
00:09:51,738 --> 00:09:56,141
Okay,
DOB is 3l15l67.
135
00:09:57,744 --> 00:09:59,837
"Marcia Waverly,
found murdered
136
00:09:59,913 --> 00:10:03,371
"in her apartment
in Hoboken in June, 1996.
137
00:10:03,449 --> 00:10:06,714
"No arrest made. " There's
a photo of the crime scene.
138
00:10:08,354 --> 00:10:10,117
Same
ligature marks.
139
00:10:13,860 --> 00:10:15,259
It can't be.
140
00:10:17,430 --> 00:10:20,422
BBJ. Type in
"Body By Jake. "
141
00:10:23,736 --> 00:10:27,172
"Body By Jake, nickname
adopted by unknown suspect
142
00:10:27,240 --> 00:10:29,708
"in strangulation murders of
four women in New York City
143
00:10:29,776 --> 00:10:32,711
"between 1989 and 1992.
144
00:10:33,079 --> 00:10:36,014
"The suspect sent a series of
taunting letters to the police.
145
00:10:36,082 --> 00:10:39,609
"His last communication
was in November, 1992."
146
00:10:39,986 --> 00:10:44,480
His first victim was an aerobics
instructor, that's where he got the name.
147
00:10:44,724 --> 00:10:46,624
After the killings stopped,
the investigators assumed
148
00:10:46,693 --> 00:10:49,787
it was because he either
died or went to jail.
149
00:10:50,496 --> 00:10:52,691
Wherever he was,
he's back.
150
00:10:59,205 --> 00:11:01,673
The MO matched
Phoebe Morton's to a T,
151
00:11:01,741 --> 00:11:03,902
right down to the blue nylon rope.
152
00:11:04,410 --> 00:11:08,574
The murder in New Jersey. Why was
it never ascribed to Body By Jake?
153
00:11:09,615 --> 00:11:11,549
Jake didn't take credit
for it at the time.
154
00:11:11,617 --> 00:11:13,380
The folks in Hoboken
never made the connection.
155
00:11:13,453 --> 00:11:15,444
After the second
victim was found,
156
00:11:15,521 --> 00:11:17,955
he sent the police a letter
with the driver's license
157
00:11:18,024 --> 00:11:19,889
of the first victim,
Kelly Erndale.
158
00:11:21,160 --> 00:11:24,288
He also included a Polaroid
of the second victim,
159
00:11:24,364 --> 00:11:26,457
Lisa Welsh,
taken at the scene.
160
00:11:26,532 --> 00:11:29,899
The only known photo of a Jake victim
with gag and ligatures in place.
161
00:11:29,969 --> 00:11:31,561
After each of the next two murders,
162
00:11:31,637 --> 00:11:34,197
he sent a letter with the
victim's driver's license.
163
00:11:34,273 --> 00:11:35,865
But not after
the Hoboken murder.
164
00:11:35,942 --> 00:11:37,603
Why wouldn't he
want credit for it?
165
00:11:37,677 --> 00:11:41,670
To keep it his secret.
It's his favorite kill.
166
00:11:42,181 --> 00:11:44,547
So now we have
six Jake victims.
167
00:11:44,617 --> 00:11:47,313
Do we know why and how
they were targeted?
168
00:11:48,488 --> 00:11:51,582
They're all Caucasian,
slender builds, long dark hair.
169
00:11:51,657 --> 00:11:53,887
But they all lived,
worked and died
170
00:11:53,960 --> 00:11:55,951
in different boroughs,
different neighborhoods.
171
00:11:56,029 --> 00:11:58,862
None of them knew each other
or had people in common.
172
00:11:58,931 --> 00:12:01,024
Any suggestions to find Jake?
173
00:12:01,100 --> 00:12:03,762
Well, he likes
to talk about himself.
174
00:12:03,836 --> 00:12:05,326
"Can you stop me
before I kill again?
175
00:12:05,405 --> 00:12:07,464
"Are you enjoying
this as much as I am?"
176
00:12:07,540 --> 00:12:09,735
We keep him talking with
another leak to the press.
177
00:12:09,809 --> 00:12:12,300
He left ejaculate
at the scene of the crimes.
178
00:12:12,378 --> 00:12:13,777
He was flaunting
his sexual power.
179
00:12:13,846 --> 00:12:18,340
Now, if we suggest he kills because
he can't get a woman to sleep with him,
180
00:12:19,152 --> 00:12:21,143
we'll provoke
a response.
181
00:12:27,260 --> 00:12:32,425
Hi. Oh, sorry, I had to stay late
at work. My boss spazzed on me.
182
00:12:33,032 --> 00:12:35,398
Oh, wait, I think
the super left a note.
183
00:12:35,468 --> 00:12:37,766
Yeah, he was supposed
to fix the sink.
184
00:12:39,472 --> 00:12:41,372
Listen to what
this creep wrote!
185
00:12:41,441 --> 00:12:44,103
"Oh, Cassandra,
why are you so late?
186
00:12:44,177 --> 00:12:46,577
"Oh, Cassandra, why
do you make me wait?"
187
00:12:46,646 --> 00:12:47,635
I'm not...
188
00:12:51,918 --> 00:12:53,977
I'm usually
home by 7:00.
189
00:12:54,053 --> 00:12:55,543
What if he'd
still been here?
190
00:12:55,621 --> 00:12:57,782
You don't want
to think about that.
191
00:12:57,857 --> 00:13:00,291
You notice anybody following
you or watching your place?
192
00:13:00,359 --> 00:13:02,327
No, no, nothing.
193
00:13:02,395 --> 00:13:06,832
Excuse me, the bra and
panties, are they yours?
194
00:13:06,899 --> 00:13:09,459
Yes. I can't stay here.
195
00:13:09,802 --> 00:13:11,531
Is there somebody
you can call?
196
00:13:11,604 --> 00:13:15,233
My friend in White
Plains, I can go there.
197
00:13:15,308 --> 00:13:17,538
That's good.
Call your friend.
198
00:13:20,480 --> 00:13:22,573
Lucky girl.
199
00:13:24,517 --> 00:13:26,314
"They spread lies.
They spread lies.
200
00:13:26,385 --> 00:13:29,183
"Willing or not,
Jake always has a mate. "
201
00:13:30,123 --> 00:13:33,923
You provoked him all right. That jab in
The Ledger this morning did the trick.
202
00:13:33,993 --> 00:13:36,257
Almost provoked him
into another murder.
203
00:13:36,329 --> 00:13:39,025
Jake doesn't need
provocation for that.
204
00:13:42,401 --> 00:13:45,199
"Willing or not,
Jake always has a mate. "
205
00:13:46,739 --> 00:13:49,173
I wonder if any
of Jake's mates
206
00:13:49,242 --> 00:13:51,608
ever filed a complaint
for sexual assault.
207
00:13:52,945 --> 00:13:54,344
I told that
doctor in the E.R.
208
00:13:54,413 --> 00:13:56,472
That my boyfriend had
nothing to do with it!
209
00:13:56,549 --> 00:13:57,982
It was just
an accident!
210
00:13:58,050 --> 00:14:00,746
I see. You accidentally
dislocated your shoulder.
211
00:14:00,820 --> 00:14:04,813
Same as you accidentally got
ligature marks on your wrist,
212
00:14:04,891 --> 00:14:06,722
your left ankle
and around your neck?
213
00:14:06,792 --> 00:14:07,781
What does it matter?
214
00:14:07,860 --> 00:14:09,885
It was over a year ago, and
all Keith got was probation.
215
00:14:09,962 --> 00:14:11,691
You didn't testify.
216
00:14:14,333 --> 00:14:16,324
Were you too
embarrassed?
217
00:14:16,903 --> 00:14:19,167
The report said
you were at his place,
218
00:14:19,238 --> 00:14:21,103
you'd both taken
ecstasy, and...
219
00:14:21,174 --> 00:14:25,008
This is what we think. He asked
you to pose for him, face down
220
00:14:25,444 --> 00:14:28,140
on the floor in your bra and underwear.
221
00:14:29,582 --> 00:14:31,516
He put a gag
in your mouth,
222
00:14:31,584 --> 00:14:34,314
tied your wrists behind
your back, am I right so far?
223
00:14:34,387 --> 00:14:38,255
Except for the bra. I don't
wear one. He gave me one.
224
00:14:38,791 --> 00:14:42,488
Then he tied your left
ankle with the rope
225
00:14:42,562 --> 00:14:44,462
and he looped it
around your neck.
226
00:14:44,530 --> 00:14:48,261
There was a struggle, and you
dislocated your shoulder, right?
227
00:14:48,334 --> 00:14:50,859
He was begging me
to let him finish.
228
00:14:52,405 --> 00:14:56,739
He kept telling me he wasn't gonna
hurt me, but he was just begging me.
229
00:15:00,746 --> 00:15:03,408
Now you saw him
last week, on a Tuesday.
230
00:15:03,482 --> 00:15:05,973
Did he seem tense
or distracted?
231
00:15:06,919 --> 00:15:10,320
No more than usual. Something's
always eating at him.
232
00:15:11,257 --> 00:15:13,953
He used to remind me of
that guy in the space movie,
233
00:15:14,026 --> 00:15:17,120
where that thing came
popping out of his chest?
234
00:15:18,631 --> 00:15:21,361
Keith get
himself in trouble?
235
00:15:21,434 --> 00:15:25,234
This woman was found murdered
Tuesday night. See the ligature marks?
236
00:15:25,304 --> 00:15:27,829
Same as Keith's girlfriend.
She even looks like her.
237
00:15:27,907 --> 00:15:30,671
He was in the service
from '93 to '96.
238
00:15:30,743 --> 00:15:32,608
That puts him in town
for the Hoboken thing.
239
00:15:32,678 --> 00:15:33,667
There's another one?
240
00:15:33,746 --> 00:15:34,872
There are five other ones.
241
00:15:34,947 --> 00:15:36,539
We wanna bring him in,
search his place,
242
00:15:36,616 --> 00:15:38,550
anything you can
violate him on?
243
00:15:38,618 --> 00:15:42,816
He had a dirty urine sample
six weeks ago for marijuana.
244
00:15:42,888 --> 00:15:44,116
I cut him a break.
245
00:15:44,190 --> 00:15:45,885
Well, his break's over.
246
00:15:45,958 --> 00:15:48,392
We also want you to call
him, check in with him.
247
00:15:48,461 --> 00:15:50,361
We'll be recording you.
248
00:15:50,930 --> 00:15:52,795
What do his activities
from last Tuesday night
249
00:15:52,865 --> 00:15:54,856
have to do with
a positive drug test?
250
00:15:54,934 --> 00:15:56,424
Let's put the cards
on the table, Detectives.
251
00:15:56,502 --> 00:16:00,336
Cards? We can put cards on the
table. You remember these cards?
252
00:16:00,406 --> 00:16:01,430
You gave them
to your girlfriend.
253
00:16:01,507 --> 00:16:04,840
Mr. Durbin no longer engages
in this offense behavior.
254
00:16:04,910 --> 00:16:06,605
Not just a little
fantasizing?
255
00:16:06,679 --> 00:16:08,374
No. It's not healthy.
256
00:16:08,447 --> 00:16:13,908
But keeping these bras and panties in
a box under your bed, that's healthy?
257
00:16:13,986 --> 00:16:15,681
He's admitted
all of this at his allocution.
258
00:16:15,755 --> 00:16:17,985
But he left out
the part about tying
259
00:16:18,057 --> 00:16:20,924
her left ankle to a
rope around her neck.
260
00:16:21,994 --> 00:16:25,430
Is this the effect that you were
going for, something like this?
261
00:16:27,199 --> 00:16:28,188
What is this?
262
00:16:28,267 --> 00:16:30,064
It's what
he finds exciting.
263
00:16:30,136 --> 00:16:31,865
No, it's repulsive.
264
00:16:32,171 --> 00:16:38,110
No, see, she's relaxing her leg, and
the noose is tightening around her neck.
265
00:16:38,177 --> 00:16:40,338
No! I don't
like this at all.
266
00:16:40,413 --> 00:16:42,381
I'm supposed to meet my family
tonight. I have to call them.
267
00:16:55,127 --> 00:16:57,322
I noticed
12 distinct similarities
268
00:16:57,396 --> 00:17:00,422
between the 911 caller and
your voice sample of Mr. Durbin,
269
00:17:00,499 --> 00:17:02,467
the most unique of which
was the manner in which words
270
00:17:02,535 --> 00:17:04,662
with "T's" in the middle
were pronounced.
271
00:17:04,737 --> 00:17:05,897
"Battery, city"?
272
00:17:05,971 --> 00:17:09,099
Yes, see, most speakers
articulate the "T" as a "D" sound.
273
00:17:09,175 --> 00:17:12,269
But in both samples, the speaker
articulates the "T" sound.
274
00:17:12,345 --> 00:17:15,075
"Battery, city. "
A shibboleth.
275
00:17:15,147 --> 00:17:16,910
It's not
a positive ID,
276
00:17:16,982 --> 00:17:19,883
but the 911 caller and Mr.
Durbin are a probable match.
277
00:17:25,624 --> 00:17:27,148
You do like it.
278
00:17:27,326 --> 00:17:29,794
You haven't taken your eyes
off it since we left the room.
279
00:17:29,862 --> 00:17:31,056
No, that's not true.
280
00:17:31,130 --> 00:17:32,597
Are you cold?
281
00:17:33,699 --> 00:17:35,291
Or are you
hiding something?
282
00:17:35,368 --> 00:17:36,392
Detective.
283
00:17:37,937 --> 00:17:41,304
You're aroused. This
picture, it arouses you.
284
00:17:41,374 --> 00:17:42,636
That's what you're hiding. No.
285
00:17:42,708 --> 00:17:45,700
Is it exciting for you
to see women like this?
286
00:17:47,079 --> 00:17:51,140
And like this, this, this, this, this...
287
00:17:51,217 --> 00:17:54,482
No! It's not me!
I can't...
288
00:17:55,187 --> 00:18:00,784
I can't help the way I feel. I
can't stop it. I can't stop it.
289
00:18:00,860 --> 00:18:02,487
Keith, that's enough. I'll say.
290
00:18:02,561 --> 00:18:05,359
As of now, he's under arrest
on five counts of murder.
291
00:18:05,431 --> 00:18:08,093
No! No!
It's just in my head.
292
00:18:08,434 --> 00:18:11,028
I can't stop it.
I can't...
293
00:18:12,004 --> 00:18:14,939
I can't stop it.
I...
294
00:18:17,510 --> 00:18:20,343
We got a five-point
match on Durbin's DNA.
295
00:18:20,813 --> 00:18:22,303
One in a thousand
chance it's him.
296
00:18:22,381 --> 00:18:25,214
That and a probable voice
match don't impress.
297
00:18:25,284 --> 00:18:27,115
Here's one court-appointed psychologist
298
00:18:27,186 --> 00:18:28,448
whose contract
should be re-examined.
299
00:18:28,521 --> 00:18:31,820
Dr. Elliot Burnhardt told the
court that, in his opinion,
300
00:18:31,891 --> 00:18:35,884
Mr. Durbin presented no danger
to the city's female population.
301
00:18:38,230 --> 00:18:42,223
The court ordered Mr. Durbin to
undergo 12 sessions with Dr. Burnhardt.
302
00:18:43,169 --> 00:18:45,296
But last week, with
three sessions to go,
303
00:18:45,371 --> 00:18:49,364
Burnhardt took Mr. Durbin
on as a private patient.
304
00:18:49,442 --> 00:18:50,966
Meaning everything
that Durbin tells him
305
00:18:51,043 --> 00:18:53,534
is covered by doctor-patient privilege.
306
00:18:53,612 --> 00:18:55,443
Well, this started
with the session
307
00:18:55,514 --> 00:18:59,951
Durbin had two days
after Phoebe's murder.
308
00:19:00,019 --> 00:19:02,385
He might've told the shrink
something about the murder.
309
00:19:02,455 --> 00:19:06,289
Something that contradicted
his rosy psych evaluation.
310
00:19:07,793 --> 00:19:12,389
Maybe Burnhardt turned Keith into a
private patient to protect himself.
311
00:19:12,698 --> 00:19:15,690
I'll ask him. In front
of the grand jury.
312
00:19:20,439 --> 00:19:23,237
After Mr. Durbin pled guilty to assault,
313
00:19:23,309 --> 00:19:26,506
I was asked to prepare
a psychological evaluation.
314
00:19:27,112 --> 00:19:30,639
I felt then that Mr. Durbin
posed no danger to women.
315
00:19:31,350 --> 00:19:33,147
I still believe that.
316
00:19:33,219 --> 00:19:36,450
Let's talk about your session two
days after Phoebe Morton's murder.
317
00:19:36,522 --> 00:19:40,481
I can't. Mr. Durbin became
my private patient that day.
318
00:19:40,993 --> 00:19:42,824
Doctor-patient
privilege attached,
319
00:19:42,895 --> 00:19:45,159
his sessions
became confidential.
320
00:19:46,765 --> 00:19:50,223
Only the patient can waive
privilege, isn't that right?
321
00:19:50,669 --> 00:19:55,231
If he chose to, Mr. Durbin could
tell us what he said to you that day.
322
00:19:58,310 --> 00:19:59,402
Yes.
323
00:19:59,678 --> 00:20:02,977
Lf, in the future, Mr. Durbin
confesses he killed Ms. Morton,
324
00:20:03,048 --> 00:20:05,778
he could reveal he made
an admission to you,
325
00:20:05,851 --> 00:20:08,046
one that makes your evaluation of him
326
00:20:08,120 --> 00:20:11,317
as posing no danger
to women seem incompetent.
327
00:20:11,557 --> 00:20:14,287
Unless, of course, the
information came from you
328
00:20:14,360 --> 00:20:16,521
before Mr. Durbin
confesses.
329
00:20:16,595 --> 00:20:18,256
But I can't
violate privilege.
330
00:20:18,330 --> 00:20:20,195
An argument
can be made
331
00:20:20,266 --> 00:20:24,396
that anything Mr. Durbin told you
is part of court-ordered therapy,
332
00:20:24,770 --> 00:20:27,102
not subject
to confidentiality.
333
00:20:28,741 --> 00:20:29,799
It could be
viewed that way.
334
00:20:29,875 --> 00:20:32,810
I'm asking you
to view it that way.
335
00:20:36,448 --> 00:20:40,009
During that session, two days
after Ms. Morton's murder,
336
00:20:40,653 --> 00:20:44,612
did Mr. Durbin say
anything about Ms. Morton?
337
00:20:48,227 --> 00:20:50,559
He saw the newspaper on my desk
338
00:20:51,030 --> 00:20:54,488
with a photo of Ms. Morton.
He said, "That could be me. "
339
00:20:54,567 --> 00:20:58,469
Did you think he meant he himself
could be the murder victim?
340
00:20:58,537 --> 00:21:01,506
No. I knew right away
he meant the killer.
341
00:21:02,708 --> 00:21:05,370
Keith has always been
filled with foreboding
342
00:21:05,444 --> 00:21:09,403
that his sexual issues would
inevitably lead to serious trouble.
343
00:21:10,649 --> 00:21:13,049
At that moment,
it occurred to me
344
00:21:13,452 --> 00:21:16,819
what he'd been trying to
tell me during our sessions.
345
00:21:17,122 --> 00:21:21,388
That he felt himself
fated to kill.
346
00:21:25,831 --> 00:21:27,628
I never forced Talia.
347
00:21:28,367 --> 00:21:32,827
She freaked out and got caught in
the rope, and wrenched her shoulder.
348
00:21:34,373 --> 00:21:37,672
I never meant to hurt her.
I never hurt anyone.
349
00:21:37,743 --> 00:21:41,839
You tried to put a slipknot around
her neck, but not to choke her?
350
00:21:42,381 --> 00:21:45,646
It's the idea of it.
351
00:21:46,185 --> 00:21:49,552
The idea of choking
a woman excites you.
352
00:21:49,622 --> 00:21:53,615
No, it's just the way
a woman looks like that.
353
00:21:53,692 --> 00:21:56,661
On her stomach, bound and
gagged, in her bra and panties?
354
00:21:56,729 --> 00:21:59,323
White bra and panties,
they should be white.
355
00:21:59,398 --> 00:22:01,263
Right, with her right
ankle tied to her neck...
356
00:22:01,333 --> 00:22:03,563
No, it's her left ankle.
357
00:22:05,971 --> 00:22:09,907
Yes, my mistake. Your way
of doing things is unique.
358
00:22:11,677 --> 00:22:15,340
Dr. Burnhardt testified when you
saw Ms. Morton in the newspaper,
359
00:22:15,414 --> 00:22:17,348
you said,
"That could be me. "
360
00:22:17,416 --> 00:22:21,682
I wanted to explain that I
meant, if I wasn't in therapy,
361
00:22:22,087 --> 00:22:25,113
if I didn't have self-control,
bad things could happen.
362
00:22:25,190 --> 00:22:27,090
You could be that killer.
That's what you meant,
363
00:22:27,159 --> 00:22:28,251
you could lose control.
364
00:22:28,327 --> 00:22:30,192
I won't lose control.
Dr. Burnhardt testified
365
00:22:30,262 --> 00:22:31,820
you were filled
with foreboding,
366
00:22:31,897 --> 00:22:33,888
you felt fated
to kill someday.
367
00:22:33,966 --> 00:22:34,955
I won't ever
let that happen.
368
00:22:35,034 --> 00:22:37,730
Where do you get that sense
of yourself as a killer?
369
00:22:41,907 --> 00:22:43,841
I don't know. Do you have
fantasies about killing?
370
00:22:43,909 --> 00:22:45,035
No, no, I don't.
371
00:22:45,110 --> 00:22:47,738
Then what is the source
of your apprehension?
372
00:22:47,813 --> 00:22:50,577
Mr. Durbin, it must
come from somewhere.
373
00:22:50,683 --> 00:22:54,119
I can't. I don't know, I don't know.
374
00:22:56,188 --> 00:22:58,418
You don't have
to answer anymore.
375
00:22:59,992 --> 00:23:02,859
I don't want to answer
any more questions.
376
00:23:02,928 --> 00:23:05,658
There's no need,
Mr. Durbin. Thank you.
377
00:23:07,266 --> 00:23:09,757
This, his
testimony here,
378
00:23:09,835 --> 00:23:13,566
when he specified the bra
and panties should be white,
379
00:23:13,639 --> 00:23:16,767
none of his victims wore
white bra and panties.
380
00:23:16,842 --> 00:23:17,831
Luck of the draw.
381
00:23:17,910 --> 00:23:20,105
Except he's very rigid
in his preferences.
382
00:23:20,179 --> 00:23:23,774
He made his victims undress. It
wouldn't have required much more effort
383
00:23:23,849 --> 00:23:26,818
to ask them to put on
a white bra and panties.
384
00:23:26,885 --> 00:23:29,752
All the lingerie we found
in his apartment was white.
385
00:23:29,822 --> 00:23:34,657
And here, when you said right
ankle, instead of left, you...
386
00:23:35,094 --> 00:23:37,085
You made a mistake,
and he let it pass.
387
00:23:37,162 --> 00:23:38,925
No, he corrected me.
388
00:23:39,598 --> 00:23:42,761
Without ridiculing you. You
know, the Jake in the letters,
389
00:23:42,835 --> 00:23:45,133
he would have berated
you for incompetence.
390
00:23:46,739 --> 00:23:49,173
Your sense of timing,
Detective...
391
00:23:50,042 --> 00:23:52,237
We might have
made a mistake.
392
00:23:55,147 --> 00:23:59,049
Grand jury disagrees. Indicted
Durbin on five counts of murder.
393
00:24:30,749 --> 00:24:33,741
I just got the "proceed with
caution" signal from the Captain.
394
00:24:33,819 --> 00:24:36,185
Once the DA has a
suspect in their mitts,
395
00:24:36,255 --> 00:24:38,280
they don't like
giving him up.
396
00:24:38,357 --> 00:24:41,451
Look, the third victim,
Christina Paulen,
397
00:24:41,527 --> 00:24:43,461
she changed jobs three
months before her murder.
398
00:24:43,529 --> 00:24:46,965
She used to work on Spring.
She would take the D Train
399
00:24:47,032 --> 00:24:51,469
down to West 4th and
change for the C to Spring.
400
00:24:51,937 --> 00:24:54,929
She changed at the
West 4th Street station.
401
00:24:55,407 --> 00:24:57,170
The same as the first two victims.
402
00:24:57,242 --> 00:25:00,769
But the fourth victim, Darlene
Jorif, she drove to work.
403
00:25:08,353 --> 00:25:11,516
She bought her car a month
before she was killed.
404
00:25:13,058 --> 00:25:15,253
Well, if she used
to take the subway,
405
00:25:15,327 --> 00:25:19,229
she would have been transferring
at West 4th to get to work.
406
00:25:21,266 --> 00:25:24,064
Why Marcia Waverly? She took
the PATH train from New Jersey.
407
00:25:24,136 --> 00:25:26,502
Now, she would have transferred
at West 4th to get up to Lexington.
408
00:25:26,572 --> 00:25:30,668
You see, that's where he picked
up their scent, at West 4th.
409
00:25:31,043 --> 00:25:33,978
He followed them,
he learned their schedules,
410
00:25:34,046 --> 00:25:35,411
and when he was
ready, he struck.
411
00:25:35,480 --> 00:25:38,540
Another commuter
or a Transit Authority worker.
412
00:25:39,017 --> 00:25:40,541
Cassandra Darcy,
our near miss,
413
00:25:40,619 --> 00:25:43,645
she transfers at the 14th
Street station to get to work.
414
00:25:43,722 --> 00:25:46,213
That leaves Phoebe
out in the cold.
415
00:25:46,959 --> 00:25:48,051
But the night
she was killed,
416
00:25:48,126 --> 00:25:49,957
she filled her MetroCard
at the 14th Street station,
417
00:25:50,028 --> 00:25:52,792
and that's how she got to
Battery Park. She took the subway.
418
00:25:52,865 --> 00:25:55,129
West 4th Street,
14th Street,
419
00:25:55,200 --> 00:25:58,727
match up the dates to her work
history, maybe we get a suspect.
420
00:26:01,974 --> 00:26:03,532
Do you have any idea
how many people pass
421
00:26:03,609 --> 00:26:05,600
through this station
any given day? It's a lot.
422
00:26:05,677 --> 00:26:08,475
There was somebody else working
with you that night, a Frank...
423
00:26:08,547 --> 00:26:11,175
McNare, Frank McNare. Frank!
424
00:26:11,750 --> 00:26:15,186
Now, there's one who might
remember. He notices things.
425
00:26:16,288 --> 00:26:19,052
Hey, Frank, they're asking about
a girl murdered in Battery Park
426
00:26:19,124 --> 00:26:21,092
a couple of weeks ago.
She was in the station.
427
00:26:21,159 --> 00:26:23,127
You remember
seeing her?
428
00:26:25,530 --> 00:26:28,829
I was wondering when you'd
get around to talking with us.
429
00:26:28,901 --> 00:26:32,803
Yeah. I recognized her when I
saw her picture in the newspaper.
430
00:26:34,273 --> 00:26:36,400
You noticed her
that night?
431
00:26:36,842 --> 00:26:40,801
There's not much else to do down
here but notice the pretty girls.
432
00:26:40,879 --> 00:26:45,316
I saw her, I said to myself,
"That is a pretty girl. "
433
00:26:45,384 --> 00:26:48,353
Do you remember anybody
talking to her or following her?
434
00:26:48,420 --> 00:26:51,685
No. But she got a phone
call just before she left.
435
00:26:53,425 --> 00:26:55,757
Maybe we should be
writing this down.
436
00:26:55,827 --> 00:26:56,816
Good idea.
437
00:26:59,064 --> 00:27:02,761
You said that she got a phone
call just before she left.
438
00:27:03,268 --> 00:27:04,257
Right.
439
00:27:04,336 --> 00:27:06,270
And did you see
anyone following her?
440
00:27:06,738 --> 00:27:09,332
Your partner already
asked me that.
441
00:27:09,408 --> 00:27:11,501
You know, you should
write down your questions
442
00:27:11,576 --> 00:27:13,840
and mark them off
as you ask them.
443
00:27:13,912 --> 00:27:16,403
That way you won't
repeat yourself.
444
00:27:17,916 --> 00:27:19,349
Good idea.
445
00:27:19,418 --> 00:27:21,648
We gotta go.
Shift's changing.
446
00:27:25,390 --> 00:27:27,915
Arrogant would be
an understatement.
447
00:27:30,262 --> 00:27:31,752
"Pretty girls. "
448
00:27:34,399 --> 00:27:38,426
He articulates his "T's,"
just like the 911 caller.
449
00:27:39,471 --> 00:27:42,907
It's a pronunciation
idiosyncrasy.
450
00:27:42,975 --> 00:27:46,672
It's picked up by children
when they learn to talk.
451
00:27:47,879 --> 00:27:49,642
Children like Keith.
452
00:27:49,881 --> 00:27:51,576
Frank, he had
red sideburns,
453
00:27:51,650 --> 00:27:55,518
got brown hair and a red
beard, just like Keith.
454
00:27:57,189 --> 00:27:59,749
It's unusual,
and it's genetic.
455
00:27:59,825 --> 00:28:01,554
It's passed on
from father to son.
456
00:28:02,728 --> 00:28:04,719
We just met
Keith's dad.
457
00:28:10,035 --> 00:28:14,495
Frank McNare divorced Keith's
mother in 1978, when Keith was eight.
458
00:28:14,573 --> 00:28:16,632
They were living
up in New Rochelle.
459
00:28:16,708 --> 00:28:20,269
McNare moved to Queens, he got
a job at the Transit Authority.
460
00:28:20,345 --> 00:28:24,714
Now, by 1988, he was working
at the West 4th Street station.
461
00:28:24,783 --> 00:28:28,879
So far, Mr. McNare seems nothing
more than a victim of coincidence.
462
00:28:28,954 --> 00:28:31,889
We've tracked his history. Not
only was he around for the killings,
463
00:28:31,957 --> 00:28:35,415
we can even explain
why he stopped in 1992.
464
00:28:35,494 --> 00:28:39,692
He got married that year. Now,
if his wife was a true masochist,
465
00:28:39,765 --> 00:28:43,223
someone who would let him act
out his sadistic fantasies,
466
00:28:43,301 --> 00:28:45,201
he wouldn't need
unwilling partners.
467
00:28:45,270 --> 00:28:47,932
But when his wife died
last year of breast cancer,
468
00:28:48,006 --> 00:28:50,031
he would have started
hunting for new partners.
469
00:28:50,108 --> 00:28:53,009
And the '96 murder,
if he was married...
470
00:28:53,078 --> 00:28:56,946
His wife had her first bout
of cancer back then.
471
00:28:57,015 --> 00:29:00,041
She was sick for a year, she
wouldn't have been up for his games.
472
00:29:00,118 --> 00:29:03,610
But if, as you say, Mr.
McNare's a sexual sadist,
473
00:29:03,688 --> 00:29:07,055
that's something he and his
son would have in common.
474
00:29:07,626 --> 00:29:11,585
And sexual sadism is not
an inherited trait, is it?
475
00:29:12,531 --> 00:29:13,555
No.
476
00:29:14,332 --> 00:29:18,496
I don't know why Keith has the same
sexual hard-wiring as his father.
477
00:29:18,570 --> 00:29:22,973
You have no evidence what Mr.
McNare's sexual proclivities are.
478
00:29:23,041 --> 00:29:24,941
His ex-wife would know.
479
00:29:28,346 --> 00:29:30,405
Keith hasn't seen Frank
since he was eight.
480
00:29:30,482 --> 00:29:32,848
Why are you
interested in him?
481
00:29:36,688 --> 00:29:39,782
Frank's sexual interests
when you were married,
482
00:29:40,292 --> 00:29:44,353
did they include bondage
or pain, even in mild forms?
483
00:29:44,429 --> 00:29:46,795
No, our sex life
was very conventional.
484
00:29:46,865 --> 00:29:50,596
Mrs. Durbin, you know
what Keith has admitted to.
485
00:29:51,303 --> 00:29:54,966
Now, his behavior
has a source.
486
00:29:55,040 --> 00:29:56,803
Maybe it was something
in his childhood.
487
00:30:01,746 --> 00:30:03,646
You remember something.
488
00:30:03,882 --> 00:30:06,817
It was such
a childish thing.
489
00:30:08,487 --> 00:30:12,651
And I yelled at him for it,
I shouldn't have. He was seven.
490
00:30:14,192 --> 00:30:15,284
I came into my room
491
00:30:15,360 --> 00:30:19,194
and found that he'd dressed his
teddy bear in my underthings.
492
00:30:19,865 --> 00:30:22,197
It was on the floor
on its stomach.
493
00:30:22,267 --> 00:30:26,033
I know it's normal for
children to be curious, but...
494
00:30:27,973 --> 00:30:29,133
There's something else?
495
00:30:29,207 --> 00:30:33,200
He had tied a string, a blue
string, around the teddy bear's leg.
496
00:30:37,249 --> 00:30:39,979
You remember where
he'd been that day?
497
00:30:40,051 --> 00:30:42,383
With Frank. Frank was
a claims adjuster.
498
00:30:42,454 --> 00:30:46,788
Saturday afternoons he'd take
photos of damaged cars and homes.
499
00:30:46,858 --> 00:30:49,019
Sometimes he'd take
Keith with him.
500
00:30:49,094 --> 00:30:51,085
What kind of camera did he use?
501
00:30:51,163 --> 00:30:52,528
A Polaroid.
502
00:30:53,331 --> 00:30:57,995
And while Frank was with clients,
Keith would wait in the car.
503
00:30:58,703 --> 00:30:59,795
Yes.
504
00:31:01,139 --> 00:31:03,699
Keith might've found
something in his father's car.
505
00:31:03,775 --> 00:31:05,402
Say, a photo.
506
00:31:05,477 --> 00:31:07,468
Something that made
a deep impression,
507
00:31:07,546 --> 00:31:10,913
so deep that he recreated
it with his teddy bear.
508
00:31:10,982 --> 00:31:12,108
Photo of what?
509
00:31:12,184 --> 00:31:16,086
We know Jake likes to take pictures
of his victims bound and gagged.
510
00:31:16,154 --> 00:31:20,887
But in 1977, 12 years before
the first Body By Jake murder?
511
00:31:21,526 --> 00:31:24,120
The first one that
Jake took credit for.
512
00:31:24,196 --> 00:31:25,185
Here.
513
00:31:25,263 --> 00:31:27,163
"Kimberly Lange,
19, disappeared
514
00:31:27,232 --> 00:31:30,133
"from a parking lot
in New Rochelle in 1977."
515
00:31:30,202 --> 00:31:32,727
Her remains were
identified in 1983.
516
00:31:33,638 --> 00:31:35,765
She's slender,
with long dark hair.
517
00:31:35,840 --> 00:31:36,829
Jake's type.
518
00:31:37,108 --> 00:31:39,235
ME found ligature
marks on her left ankle
519
00:31:39,311 --> 00:31:43,179
and two strands of blue and white
polyester embedded in her wrist.
520
00:31:43,248 --> 00:31:45,910
Assuming that 7-year-old Keith
did see a photo of the victim,
521
00:31:45,984 --> 00:31:50,080
from that one instance, he developed
a full-blown sexual obsession?
522
00:31:50,155 --> 00:31:53,318
Well, the image of a
terrified, half-naked woman,
523
00:31:57,028 --> 00:31:58,086
it's shocking.
524
00:31:58,163 --> 00:32:02,395
The boy, he would have known
that it was secret and forbidden.
525
00:32:02,467 --> 00:32:05,368
It would've imprinted
itself on his psyche.
526
00:32:06,037 --> 00:32:07,129
Somehow he figured out
527
00:32:07,205 --> 00:32:10,732
that the photo that he saw was
of a woman about to be murdered.
528
00:32:10,809 --> 00:32:13,903
Well, it was front-page
news when they ID'ed her.
529
00:32:14,913 --> 00:32:18,974
And they describe her as having a
birthmark over her right shoulder blade.
530
00:32:19,050 --> 00:32:20,039
The photo that Keith
would've seen,
531
00:32:20,118 --> 00:32:23,519
it would've been of her lying
on her stomach, bound and gagged,
532
00:32:23,588 --> 00:32:25,453
birthmark would have been
visible, he would have seen it.
533
00:32:25,523 --> 00:32:29,357
He was 13 when she was found, he
would've remembered the birthmark,
534
00:32:29,427 --> 00:32:31,987
he would've figured out
his father killed her.
535
00:32:32,063 --> 00:32:33,655
If he knows, why not say something?
536
00:32:33,732 --> 00:32:35,495
Well, we'll ask him.
537
00:32:35,934 --> 00:32:39,233
And let his lawyer know we're
looking at other suspects?
538
00:32:39,304 --> 00:32:42,637
Have you even collected DNA
samples from Frank McNare yet?
539
00:32:42,707 --> 00:32:44,197
Get us the paper,
we'll get on it.
540
00:32:44,276 --> 00:32:46,608
It's better to cast
a wider net.
541
00:32:46,945 --> 00:32:50,244
We might not want Frank
knowing that he's a suspect.
542
00:32:51,049 --> 00:32:52,983
They said they're gonna
take about 10 minutes.
543
00:32:53,051 --> 00:32:54,040
Yeah.
544
00:32:54,119 --> 00:32:58,886
Mr. McNare, you here
to volunteer your DNA?
545
00:32:58,957 --> 00:33:00,584
This still about that girl?
546
00:33:00,659 --> 00:33:02,684
We took samples from
every guy at her work,
547
00:33:02,761 --> 00:33:05,924
now we're doing the same
along the route she traveled.
548
00:33:05,997 --> 00:33:08,363
No one's turned us
down yet. How about it?
549
00:33:10,869 --> 00:33:13,736
The big DNA dragnet, huh?
550
00:33:15,607 --> 00:33:18,132
This what you guys do
when you run out of ideas?
551
00:33:18,209 --> 00:33:19,642
Pretty much.
552
00:33:19,978 --> 00:33:23,607
Now, there's a questionnaire
to fill out for every sample.
553
00:33:25,717 --> 00:33:27,742
You have any kids? Why
do you need to know that?
554
00:33:27,819 --> 00:33:29,719
We don't,
the lab does.
555
00:33:31,389 --> 00:33:33,914
Sure. I got one son.
556
00:33:34,192 --> 00:33:35,352
Date of birth?
557
00:33:35,427 --> 00:33:39,921
1971. No, wait, '70.
558
00:33:40,532 --> 00:33:41,794
City of residence?
559
00:33:41,866 --> 00:33:45,063
I'm not sure. He was my
kid from my first wife.
560
00:33:45,136 --> 00:33:47,696
Well, how about the last time
you talked to him, where was he?
561
00:33:47,772 --> 00:33:52,072
He was 13,
he called me.
562
00:33:52,544 --> 00:33:54,239
He was still
in New Rochelle.
563
00:33:54,312 --> 00:33:56,303
Kid's mother was
getting remarried.
564
00:33:56,381 --> 00:33:58,645
Her husband
wanted to adopt him.
565
00:33:58,717 --> 00:34:02,448
He had this crazy idea that
I wouldn't be his dad anymore.
566
00:34:02,520 --> 00:34:03,680
I hope you
set him straight.
567
00:34:03,755 --> 00:34:07,054
I told him that a piece of
paper doesn't mean squat.
568
00:34:08,426 --> 00:34:13,295
He was my flesh and blood, my
DNA, can't run away from it.
569
00:34:14,666 --> 00:34:19,069
He got the best of me the
night I rolled off his mother.
570
00:34:24,175 --> 00:34:25,506
Open wide.
571
00:34:27,045 --> 00:34:29,536
I saw right through
that DNA crap.
572
00:34:29,614 --> 00:34:32,845
If I hadn't volunteered, they'd use it
as an excuse to crawl right up my ass!
573
00:34:32,917 --> 00:34:36,182
Frank, relax. They've
already indicted somebody.
574
00:34:36,254 --> 00:34:38,381
Some guy named
Keith Durbin.
575
00:34:45,897 --> 00:34:48,229
McNare's DNA was
a five-point match
576
00:34:48,299 --> 00:34:50,130
to the sample
from the crime scene.
577
00:34:50,201 --> 00:34:52,567
Same as his son.
What progress.
578
00:34:53,271 --> 00:34:57,833
We now have two suspects, each of whom
create reasonable doubt for the other.
579
00:34:57,909 --> 00:35:01,743
If Durbin told us what he saw
in that photo when he was 7,
580
00:35:02,046 --> 00:35:03,604
maybe we'd get somewhere with McNare.
581
00:35:03,681 --> 00:35:05,239
What are the
chances of that?
582
00:35:05,316 --> 00:35:08,752
When he was 13, he realized
that he was sexually aroused
583
00:35:08,820 --> 00:35:13,519
by the image of a woman being
tortured and murdered by his father.
584
00:35:13,591 --> 00:35:15,889
Now, that's knowledge that
I can't imagine living with.
585
00:35:15,960 --> 00:35:17,587
He's not responsible
for her death.
586
00:35:17,662 --> 00:35:19,994
He believes that he
inherited his father's evil.
587
00:35:20,064 --> 00:35:22,624
And he believes that because
his father told him as much.
588
00:35:22,700 --> 00:35:27,831
He just thinks it's a matter of time until
he becomes the killer that his father is.
589
00:35:27,906 --> 00:35:30,101
It's irrational,
but it's the one thing
590
00:35:30,175 --> 00:35:32,643
that he most deeply
believes about himself.
591
00:35:32,710 --> 00:35:34,302
He probably thinks
if he tells anybody
592
00:35:34,379 --> 00:35:36,472
his father killed
that girl in 1977,
593
00:35:36,548 --> 00:35:38,812
we'll lock him up
along with his dad.
594
00:35:38,883 --> 00:35:42,250
Well, how do we liberate
Mr. Durbin from that belief?
595
00:35:43,621 --> 00:35:46,556
Well, his father may
be the only one who can.
596
00:35:47,559 --> 00:35:49,288
He said all he's gonna
say about the charges.
597
00:35:49,360 --> 00:35:54,423
Well, actually, we were hoping
for information on another case.
598
00:35:55,333 --> 00:35:57,494
If he gives us
some help on this case,
599
00:35:57,569 --> 00:36:01,562
then the DA will give him some
consideration on the other ones.
600
00:36:01,639 --> 00:36:03,436
He's not a suspect
in this new case?
601
00:36:03,508 --> 00:36:07,638
He would have been 7 years old at
the time, that's what I'm saying.
602
00:36:11,382 --> 00:36:12,906
Kimberly Lange.
603
00:36:14,085 --> 00:36:17,384
She's from your old stomping
ground in New Rochelle.
604
00:36:17,755 --> 00:36:22,158
She disappeared in 1977, her
remains were found in 1983.
605
00:36:23,261 --> 00:36:26,287
Is there anything you
can tell me about this?
606
00:36:28,833 --> 00:36:32,360
His flesh, his blood.
You're just like him.
607
00:36:34,539 --> 00:36:37,440
That is what you
believe, isn't it, Keith?
608
00:36:38,109 --> 00:36:39,872
Who's he talking about?
609
00:36:39,944 --> 00:36:41,172
Nothing. Nobody.
610
00:36:41,246 --> 00:36:44,340
If your family ever found out, your
mother, your sister, your stepfather,
611
00:36:44,415 --> 00:36:45,609
they'd write you off,
wouldn't they?
612
00:36:45,683 --> 00:36:46,672
I don't know anything.
613
00:36:46,751 --> 00:36:47,911
'Cause it's just
a matter of time
614
00:36:47,986 --> 00:36:51,786
until you become him,
until you do what he does.
615
00:36:56,027 --> 00:36:58,359
Is that what
you believe, Keith?
616
00:37:01,799 --> 00:37:03,824
You need
to see something.
617
00:37:09,440 --> 00:37:11,169
There he is, Keith.
618
00:37:13,177 --> 00:37:18,513
The man whose perversions have haunted
you, overwhelmed you all these years.
619
00:37:19,517 --> 00:37:20,506
My dad?
620
00:37:20,585 --> 00:37:21,882
Came here
to talk about you.
621
00:37:21,953 --> 00:37:24,387
You wanna hear
what he has to say?
622
00:37:27,225 --> 00:37:28,283
What was that?
623
00:37:28,359 --> 00:37:30,589
They're doing renovations next door.
624
00:37:31,896 --> 00:37:35,297
Let's talk about
your son, Keith.
625
00:37:36,834 --> 00:37:39,894
After we got your DNA, we
tracked down his whereabouts...
626
00:37:39,971 --> 00:37:42,132
He's the guy you should
be looking at for this.
627
00:37:42,507 --> 00:37:44,634
Well, it's funny
you should say that.
628
00:37:44,709 --> 00:37:46,904
We talked to his mother.
She told us
629
00:37:46,978 --> 00:37:51,540
she remembered him dressing up his
teddy bear in her bra and panties
630
00:37:51,616 --> 00:37:54,710
and tying a little
string to the bear's foot.
631
00:37:54,786 --> 00:37:57,380
Well,
there you go.
632
00:37:57,455 --> 00:37:59,855
Pantywaist little pervert.
633
00:38:00,959 --> 00:38:03,519
His mother did it to him,
all that mollycoddling.
634
00:38:03,595 --> 00:38:05,085
How do you figure?
635
00:38:05,163 --> 00:38:10,100
She would let little Keith sleep
in the bed with us until he was 5.
636
00:38:11,469 --> 00:38:14,404
That's not normal,
not for a boy.
637
00:38:15,206 --> 00:38:18,300
What I don't
understand, Frank,
638
00:38:18,376 --> 00:38:20,503
didn't you tell him
when he was 13
639
00:38:20,578 --> 00:38:22,842
that everything
he was he owed to you?
640
00:38:23,648 --> 00:38:25,309
The flesh
and blood speech,
641
00:38:25,383 --> 00:38:28,978
how he couldn't run away from the
great genetic gift you gave him?
642
00:38:29,053 --> 00:38:32,022
I just wanted to get him off the phone.
643
00:38:32,757 --> 00:38:34,657
He was all upset
about being adopted.
644
00:38:34,726 --> 00:38:37,957
We heard you were in a
hurry to sign off on that.
645
00:38:38,630 --> 00:38:42,088
Was it because you'd be off
the hook for child support?
646
00:38:43,968 --> 00:38:46,562
These cops,
they're geniuses.
647
00:38:49,474 --> 00:38:53,433
You know, sometimes I'd look
into that mewly little kid's face
648
00:38:54,512 --> 00:38:57,481
and wonder if he even
was my flesh and blood.
649
00:38:59,217 --> 00:39:02,277
That mother of his?
I wouldn't put it past her.
650
00:39:07,825 --> 00:39:10,919
You still think that
you're anything like him?
651
00:39:11,295 --> 00:39:14,059
This cruel
and uncaring man.
652
00:39:14,132 --> 00:39:17,727
He has no guilt and no shame.
You're nothing like him.
653
00:39:19,504 --> 00:39:21,301
Do you think that
you're the first son
654
00:39:21,372 --> 00:39:24,864
that's afraid of becoming
his imperfect father? No.
655
00:39:25,643 --> 00:39:28,976
His flaws, his sins, they're
his, they're not yours!
656
00:39:31,482 --> 00:39:33,416
That image?
That image,
657
00:39:35,053 --> 00:39:38,853
the image that's dominated
your thoughts, he created it!
658
00:39:39,824 --> 00:39:43,487
Keith, it's time, man,
it's time to spit it out.
659
00:39:47,432 --> 00:39:49,229
Tell us what you saw.
660
00:39:53,771 --> 00:39:56,001
Were you in your
father's car?
661
00:39:58,209 --> 00:39:59,972
You find something?
662
00:40:04,682 --> 00:40:06,479
Did you find a photo?
663
00:40:09,120 --> 00:40:10,109
Yeah.
664
00:40:10,188 --> 00:40:11,348
What was in the photo?
665
00:40:15,660 --> 00:40:17,287
There was a girl.
666
00:40:20,098 --> 00:40:25,559
She was tied up,
like the other girls.
667
00:40:27,605 --> 00:40:29,129
She was afraid.
668
00:40:31,843 --> 00:40:36,371
We're gonna need
exact details.
669
00:40:38,182 --> 00:40:45,111
She was wearing a white
bra and white panties.
670
00:40:48,893 --> 00:40:51,623
She had a mark
on her right shoulder.
671
00:40:52,997 --> 00:40:54,430
A birthmark.
672
00:40:55,500 --> 00:40:56,831
What else?
673
00:41:00,037 --> 00:41:02,005
She was tied
with rope.
674
00:41:02,073 --> 00:41:06,703
Around her hands.
And around her ankle.
675
00:41:08,546 --> 00:41:10,013
And her neck.
676
00:41:12,216 --> 00:41:14,081
A blue and white rope.
677
00:41:16,387 --> 00:41:19,322
I didn't know why she
was tied up like that.
678
00:41:20,625 --> 00:41:24,755
Why Dad had her picture
hidden in the glove box.
679
00:41:27,999 --> 00:41:30,559
I knew I wasn't
supposed to look at it,
680
00:41:30,635 --> 00:41:35,732
but I couldn't help it.
I couldn't...
681
00:41:40,978 --> 00:41:44,744
I do have a... Oh, well,
look who's joining the party.
682
00:41:45,049 --> 00:41:47,176
Have you got your
list of questions?
683
00:41:47,251 --> 00:41:48,684
Just answers, Jake.
684
00:41:49,520 --> 00:41:50,646
What was all that
racket out there?
685
00:41:50,721 --> 00:41:53,781
That was the sound of the
hammer coming down on you, Jake.
686
00:41:53,858 --> 00:41:54,950
Stop calling
me that.
687
00:41:55,026 --> 00:41:57,290
Your son.
He gave you up.
688
00:41:57,361 --> 00:41:58,885
Kimberly Lange.
689
00:42:00,298 --> 00:42:03,131
He found your Polaroid
of her in your car.
690
00:42:03,935 --> 00:42:06,199
He hasn't been in my car since he was 8.
691
00:42:06,270 --> 00:42:07,498
You're gonna believe
what a kid saw?
692
00:42:07,572 --> 00:42:10,166
He remembers everything.
693
00:42:10,975 --> 00:42:13,341
Everything that
excited his dad.
694
00:42:13,911 --> 00:42:17,642
Right down to the color of the rope
that you used on her, blue and white?
695
00:42:17,715 --> 00:42:21,412
Same color of the fibers found
embedded in Kimberly's wrist.
696
00:42:21,485 --> 00:42:23,419
I gotta figure
this out for you, huh?
697
00:42:23,487 --> 00:42:25,455
The kid probably read
about it in the papers.
698
00:42:25,523 --> 00:42:27,320
That detail was never made public.
699
00:42:27,391 --> 00:42:29,359
It was never
in the papers.
700
00:42:33,698 --> 00:42:35,461
That little bastard.
701
00:42:35,533 --> 00:42:37,660
He's free of you
now, Frank.
702
00:42:39,403 --> 00:42:44,636
Cast you out of his head.
Out of his head.
703
00:42:45,176 --> 00:42:46,803
Get up, big man,
you're under arrest
704
00:42:46,878 --> 00:42:49,438
for the murder
of Kimberly Lange.
705
00:42:51,249 --> 00:42:52,716
Six counts
of first-degree murder,
706
00:42:52,783 --> 00:42:56,344
and you'll be hearing from
the authorities in New Jersey.
707
00:42:58,756 --> 00:43:00,883
You nosy little deviant.
708
00:43:00,958 --> 00:43:03,222
Your own father,
how could you?
709
00:43:03,294 --> 00:43:04,488
How could you, Dad?
710
00:43:05,763 --> 00:43:09,494
Dad? You're no
son of mine.
711
00:43:12,303 --> 00:43:15,067
That's the nicest thing
he could have said to him.