1 00:00:22,288 --> 00:00:24,757 >> WE HAD A BRUTAL MURDER. PLE 2 00:00:24,759 --> 00:00:25,357 PLE PERSONAL TO SO MANY PEOPLE IN 3 00:00:25,359 --> 00:00:25,557 PERSONAL TO SO MANY PEOPLE IN ASPEN. 4 00:00:25,559 --> 00:00:26,859 ASPEN. THAT HOUSE HAS THIS STORY TO 5 00:00:26,861 --> 00:00:29,061 THAT HOUSE HAS THIS STORY TO TELL 6 00:00:29,063 --> 00:00:31,063 TELL ARE WE GOING TO BE ABLE TO 7 00:00:31,065 --> 00:00:32,131 ARE WE GOING TO BE ABLE TO FIGURE OUT WHAT THAT STORY IS? 8 00:00:32,133 --> 00:00:33,132 FIGURE OUT WHAT THAT STORY IS? >> OH, MY GOD, NO! 9 00:00:33,134 --> 00:00:34,266 >> OH, MY GOD, NO! >> I WAS GOING INTO SHOCK, 10 00:00:34,268 --> 00:00:34,833 >> I WAS GOING INTO SHOCK, HYPERVENTILATING 11 00:00:34,835 --> 00:00:37,970 HYPERVENTILATING >> Reporter: HARD TO GET THAT 12 00:00:37,972 --> 00:00:38,971 >> Reporter: HARD TO GET THAT IMAGE OUT OF YOUR MIND 13 00:00:38,973 --> 00:00:40,739 IMAGE OUT OF YOUR MIND >> IT IS 14 00:00:40,741 --> 00:00:41,640 >> IT IS >> THERE ARE NO WORDS FOR IT, 15 00:00:41,642 --> 00:00:43,242 >> THERE ARE NO WORDS FOR IT, YOU KNOW 16 00:00:43,244 --> 00:00:45,878 YOU KNOW NANCY WAS PART OF ASPEN'S 17 00:00:45,880 --> 00:00:47,679 NANCY WAS PART OF ASPEN'S HISTORY. 18 00:00:47,681 --> 00:00:48,280 HISTORY. >> Reporter: THIS APPEARED TO 19 00:00:48,282 --> 00:00:50,082 >> Reporter: THIS APPEARED TO COME OUT OF THE BLUE 20 00:00:50,084 --> 00:00:51,683 COME OUT OF THE BLUE >> YES, A CRIME THAT OCCURRED 21 00:00:51,685 --> 00:00:52,684 >> YES, A CRIME THAT OCCURRED WHILE SHE WAS SLEEPING >> I JUST 22 00:00:52,686 --> 00:00:55,354 WHILE SHE WAS SLEEPING >> I JUST REMEMBER HER HAIR! 23 00:00:55,356 --> 00:00:56,388 REMEMBER HER HAIR! >> THERE'S NO WAY SHE SAW WHAT 24 00:00:56,390 --> 00:00:57,589 >> THERE'S NO WAY SHE SAW WHAT SHE SAID SHE SAW 25 00:00:57,591 --> 00:01:02,194 SHE SAID SHE SAW >> IT LOOKED LIKE A SET-UP 26 00:01:02,196 --> 00:01:04,863 >> IT LOOKED LIKE A SET-UP IT REALLY LOOKED LIKE A SET-UP 27 00:01:04,865 --> 00:01:05,397 IT REALLY LOOKED LIKE A SET-UP >> Reporter: A MURDER IN A 28 00:01:05,399 --> 00:01:06,465 >> Reporter: A MURDER IN A SECLUDED CHALETAE SENDS SHIVERS 29 00:01:06,467 --> 00:01:07,032 SECLUDED CHALETAE SENDS SHIVERS THROUGH A GLAMOROUS SKI TOWN 30 00:01:07,034 --> 00:01:08,233 THROUGH A GLAMOROUS SKI TOWN >> TOOK MY WORLD AND JUST 31 00:01:08,235 --> 00:01:09,101 >> TOOK MY WORLD AND JUST FLIPPED IT UPSIDE DOWN 32 00:01:09,103 --> 00:01:11,703 FLIPPED IT UPSIDE DOWN >> I STARTED PRAYING THAT THE 33 00:01:11,705 --> 00:01:13,305 >> I STARTED PRAYING THAT THE TRUTH WOULD BE REVEALED! 34 00:01:13,307 --> 00:01:13,872 TRUTH WOULD BE REVEALED! >> WE WERE ALL WRONG 35 00:01:13,874 --> 00:01:16,508 >> WE WERE ALL WRONG I MEAN, EVERYBODY WAS WRONG IN 36 00:01:16,510 --> 00:01:17,709 I MEAN, EVERYBODY WAS WRONG IN THIS CASE! 37 00:01:17,711 --> 00:01:22,781 THIS CASE! >> I'M LESTER HOLT AND THIS IS 38 00:01:22,783 --> 00:01:23,015 >> I'M LESTER HOLT AND THIS IS "DATELINE. 39 00:01:33,059 --> 00:01:36,428 "WHILE SHE WAS SLEEPING. >> MY, MY FRIEND, OH MY, MY 40 00:01:36,430 --> 00:01:39,031 >> MY, MY FRIEND, OH MY, MY FRIEND --, OH MY GOD 41 00:01:39,033 --> 00:01:41,700 FRIEND --, OH MY GOD MY, MY FRIEND! 42 00:01:41,702 --> 00:01:42,234 MY, MY FRIEND! >> Reporter: A COLD NIGHT. 43 00:01:42,236 --> 00:01:46,438 >> Reporter: A COLD NIGHT. FEBRUARY, 2014 44 00:01:46,440 --> 00:01:48,040 FEBRUARY, 2014 >> SHE'S NOT 45 00:01:48,042 --> 00:01:48,607 >> SHE'S NOT SHE'S FULL OF BLOOD! 46 00:01:48,609 --> 00:01:50,709 SHE'S FULL OF BLOOD! >> Reporter: 911 CALLERS CAN 47 00:01:50,711 --> 00:01:51,243 >> Reporter: 911 CALLERS CAN OFTEN BE HYSTERICAL. 48 00:01:51,245 --> 00:01:53,545 OFTEN BE HYSTERICAL. THIS ONE WAS ALL BUT 49 00:01:53,547 --> 00:01:53,912 THIS ONE WAS ALL BUT INCOMPREHENSIBLE 50 00:01:53,914 --> 00:01:57,015 INCOMPREHENSIBLE >> I FOUND MY FRIEND IN THE 51 00:01:57,017 --> 00:01:58,450 >> I FOUND MY FRIEND IN THE CLOSET 52 00:01:58,452 --> 00:01:59,118 CLOSET SHE'S DEAD 53 00:01:59,120 --> 00:02:00,652 SHE'S DEAD >> Reporter: BUT THEN, THIS SORT 54 00:02:00,654 --> 00:02:01,753 >> Reporter: BUT THEN, THIS SORT OF THING JUST DOESN'T HAPPEN TO 55 00:02:01,755 --> 00:02:03,522 OF THING JUST DOESN'T HAPPEN TO PEOPLE LIKE THE ONE NOW LYING 56 00:02:03,524 --> 00:02:04,356 PEOPLE LIKE THE ONE NOW LYING DEAD IN THE CLOSET 57 00:02:04,358 --> 00:02:08,560 DEAD IN THE CLOSET >> SHE'S DEAD, FULL OF BLOOD, 58 00:02:08,562 --> 00:02:11,263 >> SHE'S DEAD, FULL OF BLOOD, WRAPPED IN A THING 59 00:02:11,265 --> 00:02:12,865 WRAPPED IN A THING >> Reporter: AND CERTAINLY NOT 60 00:02:12,867 --> 00:02:13,832 >> Reporter: AND CERTAINLY NOT IN THE CALLER'S ZIP CODE 61 00:02:13,834 --> 00:02:16,568 IN THE CALLER'S ZIP CODE >> WE DON'T SEE VERY MANY 62 00:02:16,570 --> 00:02:17,569 >> WE DON'T SEE VERY MANY HOMICIDES IN PITKIN COUNTY 63 00:02:17,571 --> 00:02:18,637 HOMICIDES IN PITKIN COUNTY >> Reporter: BUT THERE ARE 64 00:02:18,639 --> 00:02:19,671 >> Reporter: BUT THERE ARE MOMENTS WHEN NO PLACE IS SAFE. 65 00:02:19,673 --> 00:02:21,273 MOMENTS WHEN NO PLACE IS SAFE. NO PERSON, NOT THE STORIED 66 00:02:21,275 --> 00:02:22,875 NO PERSON, NOT THE STORIED VICTIM, NOT HER SECURE AND 67 00:02:22,877 --> 00:02:23,942 VICTIM, NOT HER SECURE AND PAMPERED SHANGRILA IN THE SNOW 68 00:02:23,944 --> 00:02:25,310 PAMPERED SHANGRILA IN THE SNOW >> THERE ARE NO WORDS FOR IT, 69 00:02:25,312 --> 00:02:28,147 >> THERE ARE NO WORDS FOR IT, YOU KNOW 70 00:02:28,149 --> 00:02:29,515 YOU KNOW WHEN A CHILDHOOD FRIEND DIES - 71 00:02:29,517 --> 00:02:30,782 WHEN A CHILDHOOD FRIEND DIES - >> Reporter: YES, AND NANCY 72 00:02:30,784 --> 00:02:32,885 >> Reporter: YES, AND NANCY PFISTER? 73 00:02:32,887 --> 00:02:34,987 PFISTER? LIFE OF THE PARTY, CONFIDANT OF 74 00:02:34,989 --> 00:02:37,089 LIFE OF THE PARTY, CONFIDANT OF BELL HOPS AND BILLIONAIRES 75 00:02:37,091 --> 00:02:48,667 BELL HOPS AND BILLIONAIRES WHO WOULD WANT TO HARM HER 76 00:02:48,669 --> 00:02:51,870 WHO WOULD WANT TO HARM HER AND WHY? 77 00:02:51,872 --> 00:02:55,007 AND WHY? ASPEN, COLORADO. 78 00:02:55,009 --> 00:02:56,108 ASPEN, COLORADO. THE TINY MUNICIPAL AIRPORT HERE 79 00:02:56,110 --> 00:02:56,708 THE TINY MUNICIPAL AIRPORT HERE TELLS A STORY IN THE LONG LINE 80 00:02:56,710 --> 00:02:57,809 TELLS A STORY IN THE LONG LINE OF PRIVATE JETS, PARKED AND 81 00:02:57,811 --> 00:02:59,278 OF PRIVATE JETS, PARKED AND WAITING FOR THEIR WELL HEELED 82 00:02:59,280 --> 00:03:03,982 WAITING FOR THEIR WELL HEELED OWNERS TO COME DOWN FROM THEIR 83 00:03:03,984 --> 00:03:06,118 OWNERS TO COME DOWN FROM THEIR MOUNTAINSIDE CHALETS 84 00:03:06,120 --> 00:03:07,119 MOUNTAINSIDE CHALETS THEIR "BEGINNER CASTLES," AS THE 85 00:03:07,121 --> 00:03:08,720 THEIR "BEGINNER CASTLES," AS THE LATE NANCY PFISTER USED TO CALL 86 00:03:08,722 --> 00:03:10,289 LATE NANCY PFISTER USED TO CALL THEM 87 00:03:10,291 --> 00:03:12,424 THEM HALF PLAYFULLY, OF COURSE. 88 00:03:12,426 --> 00:03:15,027 HALF PLAYFULLY, OF COURSE. THESE WERE HER FRIENDS 89 00:03:15,029 --> 00:03:17,129 THESE WERE HER FRIENDS AS WERE THE PASSING TOURISTS, 90 00:03:17,131 --> 00:03:19,298 AS WERE THE PASSING TOURISTS, SKI BUMS AND BUSBOYS AND JUST 91 00:03:19,300 --> 00:03:20,332 SKI BUMS AND BUSBOYS AND JUST ABOUT EVERYBODY. 92 00:03:20,334 --> 00:03:22,534 ABOUT EVERYBODY. MARY CONOVER MET NANCY WHEN THEY 93 00:03:22,536 --> 00:03:24,002 MARY CONOVER MET NANCY WHEN THEY WERE BOTH TEENAGERS. 94 00:03:24,004 --> 00:03:26,638 WERE BOTH TEENAGERS. >> YOU CANNOT COME TO THIS TOWN 95 00:03:26,640 --> 00:03:28,040 >> YOU CANNOT COME TO THIS TOWN WITHOUT MEETING NANCY. 96 00:03:28,042 --> 00:03:28,740 WITHOUT MEETING NANCY. >> Reporter: COME ON, REALLY 97 00:03:28,742 --> 00:03:30,309 >> Reporter: COME ON, REALLY >> EVERYBODY MET NANCY AT ONE 98 00:03:30,311 --> 00:03:30,842 >> EVERYBODY MET NANCY AT ONE POINT OR ANOTHER 99 00:03:30,844 --> 00:03:31,910 POINT OR ANOTHER >> I'LL BE SHOWING YOU ALL THE 100 00:03:31,912 --> 00:03:35,614 >> I'LL BE SHOWING YOU ALL THE RICH AND FAMOUS PEOPLE THAT I 101 00:03:35,616 --> 00:03:36,615 RICH AND FAMOUS PEOPLE THAT I KNOW 102 00:03:36,617 --> 00:03:38,250 KNOW >> Reporter: INCLUDING THIS 103 00:03:38,252 --> 00:03:39,251 >> Reporter: INCLUDING THIS FRENCH TV CREW 104 00:03:39,253 --> 00:03:44,556 FRENCH TV CREW NANCY GAVE THEM A TOUR OF ASPEN 105 00:03:44,558 --> 00:03:45,057 NANCY GAVE THEM A TOUR OF ASPEN GLITZ. 106 00:03:45,059 --> 00:03:45,724 GLITZ. >> THIS IS WHERE ALL THE RICH 107 00:03:45,726 --> 00:03:46,658 >> THIS IS WHERE ALL THE RICH AND FAMOUS PEOPLE COME IN THEIR 108 00:03:46,660 --> 00:03:47,226 AND FAMOUS PEOPLE COME IN THEIR PRIVATE JET. 109 00:03:47,228 --> 00:03:48,760 PRIVATE JET. >> I'VE NEVER KNOWN ANOTHER 110 00:03:48,762 --> 00:03:53,565 >> I'VE NEVER KNOWN ANOTHER PERSON LIKE HER. 111 00:03:53,567 --> 00:03:55,667 PERSON LIKE HER. AS JOYFUL AND OUTSIZED 112 00:03:55,669 --> 00:03:57,769 AS JOYFUL AND OUTSIZED PERSONALITY AND ALL OF THAT THAT 113 00:03:57,771 --> 00:04:00,439 PERSONALITY AND ALL OF THAT THAT SHE WAS, SHE HAD A VERY DEEP AND 114 00:04:00,441 --> 00:04:01,473 SHE WAS, SHE HAD A VERY DEEP AND SOULFUL CONNECTION TO THE WORLD. 115 00:04:01,475 --> 00:04:03,575 SOULFUL CONNECTION TO THE WORLD. >> Reporter: SOME SPECIAL SAUCE 116 00:04:03,577 --> 00:04:04,776 >> Reporter: SOME SPECIAL SAUCE IN NANCY PFISTER, AND WHEN SHE 117 00:04:04,778 --> 00:04:06,445 IN NANCY PFISTER, AND WHEN SHE SMILED - 118 00:04:06,447 --> 00:04:07,045 SMILED - >> IT WAS JUST PURE RADIANCE, 119 00:04:07,047 --> 00:04:08,347 >> IT WAS JUST PURE RADIANCE, YOU KNOW 120 00:04:08,349 --> 00:04:09,681 YOU KNOW IT WAS JUST BEAMING. 121 00:04:09,683 --> 00:04:10,983 IT WAS JUST BEAMING. >> Reporter: BILLY CLAYTON WAS 122 00:04:10,985 --> 00:04:14,987 >> Reporter: BILLY CLAYTON WAS PERHAPS CLOSER TO NANCY THAN 123 00:04:14,989 --> 00:04:15,587 PERHAPS CLOSER TO NANCY THAN ANYBODY, ALMOST LIKE A BROTHER 124 00:04:15,589 --> 00:04:16,221 ANYBODY, ALMOST LIKE A BROTHER >> IT WAS LIKE SHE HAD A SECRET 125 00:04:16,223 --> 00:04:17,356 >> IT WAS LIKE SHE HAD A SECRET AND SHE WANTED TO SHARE IT WITH 126 00:04:17,358 --> 00:04:18,690 AND SHE WANTED TO SHARE IT WITH YOU. 127 00:04:18,692 --> 00:04:19,458 YOU. AND THAT SECRET WAS, "LET'S ALL 128 00:04:19,460 --> 00:04:21,560 AND THAT SECRET WAS, "LET'S ALL LIGHTEN UP AND HAVE FUN AND 129 00:04:21,562 --> 00:04:23,128 LIGHTEN UP AND HAVE FUN AND ENJOY LIFE AND BE GRATEFUL." 130 00:04:23,130 --> 00:04:24,196 ENJOY LIFE AND BE GRATEFUL." >> Reporter: NANCY HAD REASON TO 131 00:04:24,198 --> 00:04:26,865 >> Reporter: NANCY HAD REASON TO BE GRATEFUL. 132 00:04:26,867 --> 00:04:27,432 BE GRATEFUL. SHE WAS BORN TO A LEGENDARY 133 00:04:27,434 --> 00:04:30,002 SHE WAS BORN TO A LEGENDARY ASPEN FAMILY, A BIT LIKE LOCAL 134 00:04:30,004 --> 00:04:31,069 ASPEN FAMILY, A BIT LIKE LOCAL ROYALTY. 135 00:04:31,071 --> 00:04:35,807 ROYALTY. HER FATHER, ART PFISTER, MADE A 136 00:04:35,809 --> 00:04:37,376 HER FATHER, ART PFISTER, MADE A FORTUNE WHEN HE TURNED HIS RANCH 137 00:04:37,378 --> 00:04:38,410 FORTUNE WHEN HE TURNED HIS RANCH INTO THE BUTTERMILK SKI RESORT 138 00:04:38,412 --> 00:04:39,478 INTO THE BUTTERMILK SKI RESORT AND HER MOTHER BETTY WAS A WORLD 139 00:04:39,480 --> 00:04:40,512 AND HER MOTHER BETTY WAS A WORLD WAR TWO PILOT WHO, IN LATER 140 00:04:40,514 --> 00:04:42,114 WAR TWO PILOT WHO, IN LATER YEARS, FLEW A HELICOPTER, PARKED 141 00:04:42,116 --> 00:04:44,216 YEARS, FLEW A HELICOPTER, PARKED IT IN HER DRIVEWAY 142 00:04:44,218 --> 00:04:44,783 IT IN HER DRIVEWAY AND NANCY? 143 00:04:44,785 --> 00:04:45,817 AND NANCY? STORIES ABOUT NANCY WOULD FILL A 144 00:04:45,819 --> 00:04:47,919 STORIES ABOUT NANCY WOULD FILL A BOOK 145 00:04:47,921 --> 00:04:51,089 BOOK LIKE THE ONE ABOUT HOW SHE MET 146 00:04:51,091 --> 00:04:51,757 LIKE THE ONE ABOUT HOW SHE MET JACK NICHOLSON 147 00:04:51,759 --> 00:04:52,624 JACK NICHOLSON >> A CONVERTIBLE PULLED UP AND 148 00:04:52,626 --> 00:04:54,226 >> A CONVERTIBLE PULLED UP AND ASKED THEM DIRECTIONS. 149 00:04:54,228 --> 00:04:55,827 ASKED THEM DIRECTIONS. AND NANCY SAID, "WELL, I'LL -- 150 00:04:55,829 --> 00:04:57,929 AND NANCY SAID, "WELL, I'LL -- I'LL TAKE YOU THERE BUT I WANT 151 00:04:57,931 --> 00:04:58,563 I'LL TAKE YOU THERE BUT I WANT TO RIDE IN THAT NICE CAR OF 152 00:04:58,565 --> 00:05:00,599 TO RIDE IN THAT NICE CAR OF YOURS. 153 00:05:00,601 --> 00:05:02,134 YOURS. AND THE NEXT THING YOU KNOW 154 00:05:02,136 --> 00:05:02,901 AND THE NEXT THING YOU KNOW SHE'S -- SHE AND JACK ARE BEST 155 00:05:02,903 --> 00:05:03,235 SHE'S -- SHE AND JACK ARE BEST FRIENDS. 156 00:05:03,237 --> 00:05:04,303 FRIENDS. >> THIS IS THE HOUSE OF JACK 157 00:05:04,305 --> 00:05:05,337 >> THIS IS THE HOUSE OF JACK NICHOLSON. 158 00:05:05,339 --> 00:05:06,705 NICHOLSON. >> Reporter: NANCY COULD AND DID 159 00:05:06,707 --> 00:05:08,507 >> Reporter: NANCY COULD AND DID LIVE ANY WAY SHE WANTED, OUT 160 00:05:08,509 --> 00:05:09,541 LIVE ANY WAY SHE WANTED, OUT LOUD 161 00:05:09,543 --> 00:05:11,143 LOUD >> MANY, MANY TIMES, UM, WHEN I 162 00:05:11,145 --> 00:05:12,744 >> MANY, MANY TIMES, UM, WHEN I JUST THOUGHT WE WERE GOING TO 163 00:05:12,746 --> 00:05:14,313 JUST THOUGHT WE WERE GOING TO HAVE A NORMAL DAY AND DO 164 00:05:14,315 --> 00:05:14,946 HAVE A NORMAL DAY AND DO SOMETHING AROUND HERE, SHE WOULD 165 00:05:14,948 --> 00:05:15,914 SOMETHING AROUND HERE, SHE WOULD SAY, "LET'S GO TO ST. BART'S," 166 00:05:15,916 --> 00:05:16,515 SAY, "LET'S GO TO ST. BART'S," OR, "LET'S GO TO HAWAII," OR, 167 00:05:16,517 --> 00:05:18,817 OR, "LET'S GO TO HAWAII," OR, "LET'S GO SOMEWHERE," AND I'D 168 00:05:18,819 --> 00:05:20,652 "LET'S GO SOMEWHERE," AND I'D GO, "OKAY. 169 00:05:20,654 --> 00:05:21,720 GO, "OKAY. >> Reporter: BUT A RELATIONSHIP 170 00:05:21,722 --> 00:05:22,754 >> Reporter: BUT A RELATIONSHIP WITH THE IMPULSIVE AND 171 00:05:22,756 --> 00:05:23,822 WITH THE IMPULSIVE AND GREGARIOUS NANCY, BILLY HAD TO 172 00:05:23,824 --> 00:05:26,458 GREGARIOUS NANCY, BILLY HAD TO ADMIT, CAME WITH A PRICE 173 00:05:26,460 --> 00:05:27,526 ADMIT, CAME WITH A PRICE YOUR BUSINESS WAS HER BUSINESS, 174 00:05:27,528 --> 00:05:28,560 YOUR BUSINESS WAS HER BUSINESS, YOUR STUFF WAS HER STUFF AND 175 00:05:28,562 --> 00:05:29,127 YOUR STUFF WAS HER STUFF AND SOMETIMES, SHE JUST EXPECTED 176 00:05:29,129 --> 00:05:33,265 SOMETIMES, SHE JUST EXPECTED FRIENDS TO GIVE HER THE STUFF 177 00:05:33,267 --> 00:05:33,832 FRIENDS TO GIVE HER THE STUFF SHE WANTED 178 00:05:33,834 --> 00:05:35,367 SHE WANTED >> IT WAS -- IT WAS QUITE A JOB 179 00:05:35,369 --> 00:05:36,568 >> IT WAS -- IT WAS QUITE A JOB TO LOVE NANCY. 180 00:05:36,570 --> 00:05:38,070 TO LOVE NANCY. >> Reporter: QUITE A JOB TO LOVE 181 00:05:38,072 --> 00:05:38,570 >> Reporter: QUITE A JOB TO LOVE NANCY? 182 00:05:38,572 --> 00:05:41,173 NANCY? >> YEAH. 183 00:05:41,175 --> 00:05:46,478 >> YEAH. SHE WOULD DO THINGS SHE FELT, 184 00:05:46,480 --> 00:05:48,080 SHE WOULD DO THINGS SHE FELT, UH, WERE OKAY AT ANY TIME. 185 00:05:48,082 --> 00:05:50,182 UH, WERE OKAY AT ANY TIME. >> Reporter: SO, AFTER WHAT 186 00:05:50,184 --> 00:05:52,284 >> Reporter: SO, AFTER WHAT HAPPENED TO HER, FLIES ON A 187 00:05:52,286 --> 00:05:53,885 HAPPENED TO HER, FLIES ON A CARCASS, THE TABLOIDS FEASTED ON 188 00:05:53,887 --> 00:05:55,487 CARCASS, THE TABLOIDS FEASTED ON THE GOSSIP AND HALF TRUTHS THAT 189 00:05:55,489 --> 00:05:56,488 THE GOSSIP AND HALF TRUTHS THAT FLEW AROUND TOWN 190 00:05:56,490 --> 00:06:00,192 FLEW AROUND TOWN SHE WAS A SPOILED WILD-CHILD, 191 00:06:00,194 --> 00:06:00,759 SHE WAS A SPOILED WILD-CHILD, THEY HOWLED. 192 00:06:00,761 --> 00:06:01,326 THEY HOWLED. JACK NICHOLSON'S PARTY GIRL, 193 00:06:01,328 --> 00:06:02,361 JACK NICHOLSON'S PARTY GIRL, HUNTER S. THOMPSON'S DRINKING 194 00:06:02,363 --> 00:06:03,395 HUNTER S. THOMPSON'S DRINKING BUDDY. 195 00:06:03,397 --> 00:06:06,565 BUDDY. AN INCURABLE FLIRT ONCE ENGAGED 196 00:06:06,567 --> 00:06:09,501 AN INCURABLE FLIRT ONCE ENGAGED TO MICHAEL DOUGLAS 197 00:06:09,503 --> 00:06:10,035 TO MICHAEL DOUGLAS ALL VERY BREATHLESS, THESE 198 00:06:10,037 --> 00:06:14,506 ALL VERY BREATHLESS, THESE STORIES ABOUT THE, QUOTE, "ASPEN 199 00:06:14,508 --> 00:06:14,773 STORIES ABOUT THE, QUOTE, "ASPEN SOCIALITE. 200 00:06:14,775 --> 00:06:15,507 SOCIALITE. AND INSULTING, SAID HER FRIENDS. 201 00:06:15,509 --> 00:06:18,176 AND INSULTING, SAID HER FRIENDS. DIDN'T PAINT NANCY'S CHARACTER 202 00:06:18,178 --> 00:06:19,211 DIDN'T PAINT NANCY'S CHARACTER ACCURATELY AT ALL. 203 00:06:19,213 --> 00:06:21,079 ACCURATELY AT ALL. >> SOME PEOPLE COLLECT FAMOUS 204 00:06:21,081 --> 00:06:22,414 >> SOME PEOPLE COLLECT FAMOUS PEOPLE AS FRIENDS. 205 00:06:22,416 --> 00:06:25,016 PEOPLE AS FRIENDS. IT'S IMPORTANT TO THEM TO BE 206 00:06:25,018 --> 00:06:27,686 IT'S IMPORTANT TO THEM TO BE ABLE TO, YOU KNOW, TALK ABOUT -- 207 00:06:27,688 --> 00:06:28,720 ABLE TO, YOU KNOW, TALK ABOUT -- >> DEFINITELY NOT HER. 208 00:06:28,722 --> 00:06:29,421 >> DEFINITELY NOT HER. SHE HAD A LOT OF FAMOUS FRIENDS. 209 00:06:29,423 --> 00:06:30,322 SHE HAD A LOT OF FAMOUS FRIENDS. SHE HAD A LOT OF FRIENDS WHO 210 00:06:30,324 --> 00:06:31,923 SHE HAD A LOT OF FRIENDS WHO WERE NOT FAMOUS. 211 00:06:31,925 --> 00:06:34,025 WERE NOT FAMOUS. SHE TREATED EVERYONE THE SAME 212 00:06:34,027 --> 00:06:35,227 SHE TREATED EVERYONE THE SAME WAY. 213 00:06:35,229 --> 00:06:37,229 WAY. SHE HAD A VERY GENUINE 214 00:06:37,231 --> 00:06:38,563 SHE HAD A VERY GENUINE CONNECTION WITH PEOPLE 215 00:06:38,565 --> 00:06:39,331 CONNECTION WITH PEOPLE >> SHE DIDN'T HAVE THE 216 00:06:39,333 --> 00:06:42,000 >> SHE DIDN'T HAVE THE ENTITLEMENT THAT MADE A SNOOTY 217 00:06:42,002 --> 00:06:43,034 ENTITLEMENT THAT MADE A SNOOTY LITTLE RICH KID OR SOMETHING 218 00:06:43,036 --> 00:06:43,602 LITTLE RICH KID OR SOMETHING SHE HAD AN ENTITLEMENT THAT 219 00:06:43,604 --> 00:06:44,636 SHE HAD AN ENTITLEMENT THAT SH -- EVERY DAY OF LIFE WAS 220 00:06:44,638 --> 00:06:48,640 SH -- EVERY DAY OF LIFE WAS PRECIOUS AND -- AND -- AND 221 00:06:48,642 --> 00:06:49,341 PRECIOUS AND -- AND -- AND SHOULD BE LIVED TO THE FULLEST 222 00:06:49,343 --> 00:06:50,942 SHOULD BE LIVED TO THE FULLEST >> Reporter: NANCY WAS A 223 00:06:50,944 --> 00:06:53,612 >> Reporter: NANCY WAS A TRAVELING PHILANTHROPIST 224 00:06:53,614 --> 00:06:54,646 TRAVELING PHILANTHROPIST A DEVOTED ENVIRONMENTALIST 225 00:06:54,648 --> 00:06:56,748 A DEVOTED ENVIRONMENTALIST SHE HAD A DAUGHTER, TOO, 226 00:06:56,750 --> 00:06:58,350 SHE HAD A DAUGHTER, TOO, JULIANA, BORN WHEN NANCY WAS 29. 227 00:06:58,352 --> 00:07:00,452 JULIANA, BORN WHEN NANCY WAS 29. AND SOMETIMES SHE TOOK JULIANA 228 00:07:00,454 --> 00:07:03,155 AND SOMETIMES SHE TOOK JULIANA WITH HER WHEN SHE TRAVELED, BUT 229 00:07:03,157 --> 00:07:03,588 WITH HER WHEN SHE TRAVELED, BUT SOMETIMES SHE DIDN'T 230 00:07:03,590 --> 00:07:07,859 SOMETIMES SHE DIDN'T >> NANCY HAS A LOT OF VERY CLOSE 231 00:07:07,861 --> 00:07:08,560 >> NANCY HAS A LOT OF VERY CLOSE FRIENDS AND PEOPLE WHO LOVED 232 00:07:08,562 --> 00:07:10,462 FRIENDS AND PEOPLE WHO LOVED JULIANA AND, YOU KNOW, WE ALL 233 00:07:10,464 --> 00:07:12,063 JULIANA AND, YOU KNOW, WE ALL RAISED OUR CHILDREN TOGETHER 234 00:07:12,065 --> 00:07:12,497 RAISED OUR CHILDREN TOGETHER >> Reporter: UNUSUAL 235 00:07:12,499 --> 00:07:15,233 >> Reporter: UNUSUAL OH CERTAINLY 236 00:07:15,235 --> 00:07:16,835 OH CERTAINLY BUT -- 237 00:07:16,837 --> 00:07:18,637 BUT -- >> SHE JUST TRULY, DEEPLY LOVED 238 00:07:18,639 --> 00:07:20,472 >> SHE JUST TRULY, DEEPLY LOVED JULIANA AND DID FEEL THAT THIS 239 00:07:20,474 --> 00:07:21,573 JULIANA AND DID FEEL THAT THIS WAS HER GREATEST ROLE OF HER 240 00:07:21,575 --> 00:07:25,277 WAS HER GREATEST ROLE OF HER LIFE WAS -- WAS TO BE A MOTHER 241 00:07:25,279 --> 00:07:26,278 LIFE WAS -- WAS TO BE A MOTHER >> Reporter: THING IS, NANCY 242 00:07:26,280 --> 00:07:29,781 >> Reporter: THING IS, NANCY PFISTER TRUSTED PEOPLE 243 00:07:29,783 --> 00:07:30,382 PFISTER TRUSTED PEOPLE EVEN WITH THE CARE OF HER OWN 244 00:07:30,384 --> 00:07:32,684 EVEN WITH THE CARE OF HER OWN DAUGHTER, WITH HER HOUSE, WITH 245 00:07:32,686 --> 00:07:33,452 DAUGHTER, WITH HER HOUSE, WITH HER MONEY. 246 00:07:33,454 --> 00:07:34,786 HER MONEY. LIKE THE TELLER SHE HAPPENED TO 247 00:07:34,788 --> 00:07:35,253 LIKE THE TELLER SHE HAPPENED TO MEET IN HER LOCAL BANK 248 00:07:35,255 --> 00:07:37,456 MEET IN HER LOCAL BANK >> SHE LOVED PEOPLE, YOU KNOW. 249 00:07:37,458 --> 00:07:38,990 >> SHE LOVED PEOPLE, YOU KNOW. ALL KINDS. 250 00:07:38,992 --> 00:07:40,592 ALL KINDS. IT DIDN'T MATTER WHO YOU WERE. 251 00:07:40,594 --> 00:07:41,660 IT DIDN'T MATTER WHO YOU WERE. >> Reporter: KATHY CARPENTER WAS 252 00:07:41,662 --> 00:07:43,195 >> Reporter: KATHY CARPENTER WAS THAT TELLER. 253 00:07:43,197 --> 00:07:44,296 THAT TELLER. AND ONE DAY SEVEN YEARS AGO, OUT 254 00:07:44,298 --> 00:07:47,466 AND ONE DAY SEVEN YEARS AGO, OUT OF THE BLUE, NANCY ASKED HER TO 255 00:07:47,468 --> 00:07:48,500 OF THE BLUE, NANCY ASKED HER TO LUNCH. 256 00:07:48,502 --> 00:07:49,000 LUNCH. KATHY ACCEPTED 257 00:07:49,002 --> 00:07:53,271 KATHY ACCEPTED AND LEARNED FIRSTHAND ANOTHER OF 258 00:07:53,273 --> 00:07:53,772 AND LEARNED FIRSTHAND ANOTHER OF NANCY'S HALLMARK TRAITS. 259 00:07:53,774 --> 00:07:55,307 NANCY'S HALLMARK TRAITS. >> SHE WAS SOMETIMES BRUTALLY 260 00:07:55,309 --> 00:07:56,308 >> SHE WAS SOMETIMES BRUTALLY HONEST 261 00:07:56,310 --> 00:07:56,875 HONEST >> Reporter: NO EDIT BUTTON? 262 00:07:56,877 --> 00:07:57,442 >> Reporter: NO EDIT BUTTON? >> NO EDIT BUTTON. 263 00:07:57,444 --> 00:07:58,510 >> NO EDIT BUTTON. I LIKE THAT. 264 00:07:58,512 --> 00:08:00,111 I LIKE THAT. YES. 265 00:08:00,113 --> 00:08:01,680 YES. NO EDIT BUTTON 266 00:08:01,682 --> 00:08:02,714 NO EDIT BUTTON SHE ACTUALLY, WHEN I FIRST MET 267 00:08:02,716 --> 00:08:03,782 SHE ACTUALLY, WHEN I FIRST MET HER, TOLD ME THAT I WAS VERY 268 00:08:03,784 --> 00:08:04,816 HER, TOLD ME THAT I WAS VERY FAT. 269 00:08:04,818 --> 00:08:05,884 FAT. >> Reporter: WHAT A THING TO SAY 270 00:08:05,886 --> 00:08:07,118 >> Reporter: WHAT A THING TO SAY TO SOMEBODY WHEN YOU FIRST MEET 271 00:08:07,120 --> 00:08:07,486 TO SOMEBODY WHEN YOU FIRST MEET THEM 272 00:08:07,488 --> 00:08:08,520 THEM >> HI. 273 00:08:08,522 --> 00:08:12,224 >> HI. BE MY FRIEND 274 00:08:12,226 --> 00:08:13,792 BE MY FRIEND YOU'RE FAT 275 00:08:13,794 --> 00:08:16,928 YOU'RE FAT >> Reporter: SO SHE WAS BLUNT. 276 00:08:16,930 --> 00:08:18,096 >> Reporter: SO SHE WAS BLUNT. UNDIPLOMATIC 277 00:08:18,098 --> 00:08:19,030 UNDIPLOMATIC BUT IRRESISTABLE 278 00:08:19,032 --> 00:08:21,700 BUT IRRESISTABLE BY THE TIME LUNCH WAS OVER NANCY 279 00:08:21,702 --> 00:08:25,337 BY THE TIME LUNCH WAS OVER NANCY AND KATHY WERE FAST FRIENDS. 280 00:08:25,339 --> 00:08:25,904 AND KATHY WERE FAST FRIENDS. JUST HOW NANCY WAS 281 00:08:25,906 --> 00:08:26,938 JUST HOW NANCY WAS LIKE WHEN SHE MADE PLANS TO 282 00:08:26,940 --> 00:08:28,039 LIKE WHEN SHE MADE PLANS TO LEAVE TOWN FOR THE WINTER, SHE 283 00:08:28,041 --> 00:08:29,140 LEAVE TOWN FOR THE WINTER, SHE DECIDED TO RENT HER HOUSE TO A 284 00:08:29,142 --> 00:08:30,642 DECIDED TO RENT HER HOUSE TO A RETIRED DOCTOR AND HIS 285 00:08:30,644 --> 00:08:32,244 RETIRED DOCTOR AND HIS HORTICULTURALIST WIFE, TOTAL 286 00:08:32,246 --> 00:08:34,346 HORTICULTURALIST WIFE, TOTAL STRANGERS WHOM SHE BEFRIENDED IN 287 00:08:34,348 --> 00:08:35,447 STRANGERS WHOM SHE BEFRIENDED IN A HEARTBEAT. 288 00:08:35,449 --> 00:08:38,049 A HEARTBEAT. ACTUALLY INVITED THEM TO MOVE IN 289 00:08:38,051 --> 00:08:39,651 ACTUALLY INVITED THEM TO MOVE IN A MONTH EARLY. 290 00:08:39,653 --> 00:08:41,253 A MONTH EARLY. AND SO SHE, DR. TREY STYLER AND 291 00:08:41,255 --> 00:08:42,254 AND SO SHE, DR. TREY STYLER AND HIS WIFE, WHO ALSO HAPPENED TO 292 00:08:42,256 --> 00:08:44,956 HIS WIFE, WHO ALSO HAPPENED TO BE NAMED NANCY, THEY ALL LIVED 293 00:08:44,958 --> 00:08:46,525 BE NAMED NANCY, THEY ALL LIVED TOGETHER LIKE ROOMMATES. 294 00:08:46,527 --> 00:08:48,059 TOGETHER LIKE ROOMMATES. >> SHE KINDA SAID, "I'M GONNA 295 00:08:48,061 --> 00:08:49,160 >> SHE KINDA SAID, "I'M GONNA TAKE YOU UNDER MY WING AND HAVE 296 00:08:49,162 --> 00:08:49,761 TAKE YOU UNDER MY WING AND HAVE YOU MEET ALL MY FRIENDS, AND I 297 00:08:49,763 --> 00:08:53,565 YOU MEET ALL MY FRIENDS, AND I KNOW A LOTTA PEOPLE AROUND 298 00:08:53,567 --> 00:08:54,933 KNOW A LOTTA PEOPLE AROUND HERE." 299 00:08:54,935 --> 00:08:56,535 HERE." >> Reporter: BUT NOW, IN 300 00:08:56,537 --> 00:09:01,139 >> Reporter: BUT NOW, IN FEBRUARY 2014, AT JUST 57, NANCY 301 00:09:01,141 --> 00:09:01,506 FEBRUARY 2014, AT JUST 57, NANCY PFISTER WAS GONE 302 00:09:01,508 --> 00:09:03,875 PFISTER WAS GONE MURDERED, APPARENTLY IN HER OWN 303 00:09:03,877 --> 00:09:05,977 MURDERED, APPARENTLY IN HER OWN BED. 304 00:09:05,979 --> 00:09:08,146 BED. WHILE THE GRIEF WAS STILL VERY 305 00:09:08,148 --> 00:09:09,781 WHILE THE GRIEF WAS STILL VERY FRESH, MUCH OF ASPEN CROWDED 306 00:09:09,783 --> 00:09:12,350 FRESH, MUCH OF ASPEN CROWDED INTO THE STORIED HOTEL JEROME 307 00:09:12,352 --> 00:09:13,885 INTO THE STORIED HOTEL JEROME FOR A MEMORIAL THAT WAS MORE 308 00:09:13,887 --> 00:09:16,054 FOR A MEMORIAL THAT WAS MORE LIKE A GOODBYE PARTY 309 00:09:16,056 --> 00:09:16,655 LIKE A GOODBYE PARTY >> WELL, HOWEVER SHE DIED, WE 310 00:09:16,657 --> 00:09:17,589 >> WELL, HOWEVER SHE DIED, WE NEED TO CELEBRATE HER LIFE 311 00:09:17,591 --> 00:09:18,690 NEED TO CELEBRATE HER LIFE THAT'S WHAT SHE WOULD'VE WANTED 312 00:09:18,692 --> 00:09:21,860 THAT'S WHAT SHE WOULD'VE WANTED BECAUSE HER LIFE WAS A 313 00:09:21,862 --> 00:09:22,894 BECAUSE HER LIFE WAS A CELEBRATION. 314 00:09:22,896 --> 00:09:24,496 CELEBRATION. >> Reporter: EXCEPT ONE PERSON, 315 00:09:24,498 --> 00:09:25,497 >> Reporter: EXCEPT ONE PERSON, NOTABLY ABSENT FROM THE OVERFLOW 316 00:09:25,499 --> 00:09:27,666 NOTABLY ABSENT FROM THE OVERFLOW CROWD IN THE JEROME, WASN'T 317 00:09:27,668 --> 00:09:31,369 CROWD IN THE JEROME, WASN'T CELEBRATING. 318 00:09:31,371 --> 00:09:34,005 CELEBRATING. BUT CERTAINLY COULD HEAR THE 319 00:09:34,007 --> 00:09:34,606 BUT CERTAINLY COULD HEAR THE MUSIC AND LAUGHTER THAT BURST 320 00:09:34,608 --> 00:09:36,107 MUSIC AND LAUGHTER THAT BURST OUT OF HOTEL WINDOWS THAT NIGHT, 321 00:09:36,109 --> 00:09:37,175 OUT OF HOTEL WINDOWS THAT NIGHT, AND DRIFTED DOWN THE STREET AND 322 00:09:37,177 --> 00:09:39,277 AND DRIFTED DOWN THE STREET AND INTO A PARTICULAR CELL IN THE 323 00:09:39,279 --> 00:09:43,615 INTO A PARTICULAR CELL IN THE COUNTY JAIL. 324 00:09:43,617 --> 00:09:44,082 COUNTY JAIL. >> WHEN WE COME BACK - 325 00:09:44,084 --> 00:09:46,484 >> WHEN WE COME BACK - WHAT HAD HAPPENED TO 326 00:09:46,486 --> 00:09:47,218 WHAT HAD HAPPENED TO NANCY PFISTER? 327 00:09:47,220 --> 00:09:52,424 NANCY PFISTER? THE AWFUL DISCOVERY THAT 328 00:09:52,426 --> 00:09:54,292 THE AWFUL DISCOVERY THAT LAUNCHED THIS ASPEN MYSTERY. 329 00:09:54,294 --> 00:09:54,726 LAUNCHED THIS ASPEN MYSTERY. >> OH MY GOD, NO 330 00:09:54,728 --> 00:09:58,229 >> OH MY GOD, NO >> HARD TO GET THAT IMAGE OUT OF 331 00:09:58,231 --> 00:10:00,398 >> HARD TO GET THAT IMAGE OUT OF YOUR MIND. 332 00:10:00,400 --> 00:10:02,500 YOUR MIND. >> IT IS 333 00:10:02,502 --> 00:10:03,535 >> IT IS >> THAT HOUSE HAS A STORY TO 334 00:10:03,537 --> 00:10:26,224 >> THAT HOUSE HAS A STORY TO TELL 335 00:10:26,226 --> 00:10:27,726 TELL ♪ (MÚSICA) ♪ 336 00:10:27,728 --> 00:10:28,994 ♪ (MÚSICA) ♪ FEBRUARY 2014, ANY FEBRUARY, IS 337 00:10:28,996 --> 00:10:30,028 FEBRUARY 2014, ANY FEBRUARY, IS THE CENTER OF THE UNIVERSE, FOR 338 00:10:30,030 --> 00:10:33,231 THE CENTER OF THE UNIVERSE, FOR A CERTAIN CROWD, THAT IS 339 00:10:33,233 --> 00:10:34,799 A CERTAIN CROWD, THAT IS THIS YEAR AS ALWAYS, AN 340 00:10:34,801 --> 00:10:35,834 THIS YEAR AS ALWAYS, AN AVALANCHE OF SKIERS CROWDED ONTO 341 00:10:35,836 --> 00:10:37,435 AVALANCHE OF SKIERS CROWDED ONTO LIFTS AND FILLED THE RESTAURANTS 342 00:10:37,437 --> 00:10:38,503 LIFTS AND FILLED THE RESTAURANTS AND BARS AND SHOPS THAT LINE 343 00:10:38,505 --> 00:10:42,207 AND BARS AND SHOPS THAT LINE ASPEN'S CAREFULLY TENDED 344 00:10:42,209 --> 00:10:44,342 ASPEN'S CAREFULLY TENDED AVENUES. 345 00:10:44,344 --> 00:10:46,411 AVENUES. A LOVELY, IF PRICEY, SKIING 346 00:10:46,413 --> 00:10:47,445 A LOVELY, IF PRICEY, SKIING HEAVEN 347 00:10:47,447 --> 00:10:49,714 HEAVEN EXCEPT, THAT IS, FOR 348 00:10:49,716 --> 00:10:50,048 EXCEPT, THAT IS, FOR NANCY PFISTER. 349 00:10:50,050 --> 00:10:51,816 NANCY PFISTER. >> IT USED TO BE REALLY 350 00:10:51,818 --> 00:10:53,251 >> IT USED TO BE REALLY DIFFERENT IN THE OLD DAYS. 351 00:10:53,253 --> 00:10:55,353 DIFFERENT IN THE OLD DAYS. BUT NOW IT HAS GOTTEN MORE 352 00:10:55,355 --> 00:10:55,820 BUT NOW IT HAS GOTTEN MORE TOWARDS THE CHAMPAGNE. 353 00:10:55,822 --> 00:10:56,955 TOWARDS THE CHAMPAGNE. >> Reporter: DID SHE EVER THINK 354 00:10:56,957 --> 00:10:58,556 >> Reporter: DID SHE EVER THINK OF LEAVING HERE PERMANENTLY? 355 00:10:58,558 --> 00:10:59,557 OF LEAVING HERE PERMANENTLY? I KNOW SHE WAS AWAY A LOT. 356 00:10:59,559 --> 00:11:01,159 I KNOW SHE WAS AWAY A LOT. >> SHE THOUGHT OF IT ALL THE 357 00:11:01,161 --> 00:11:02,227 >> SHE THOUGHT OF IT ALL THE TIME 358 00:11:02,229 --> 00:11:03,261 TIME SHE THOUGHT ABOUT -- BECAUSE 359 00:11:03,263 --> 00:11:03,762 SHE THOUGHT ABOUT -- BECAUSE ASPEN'S CHANGED SO MUCH. 360 00:11:03,764 --> 00:11:05,063 ASPEN'S CHANGED SO MUCH. IT'S NOT THAT SLEEPY LITTLE 361 00:11:05,065 --> 00:11:05,363 IT'S NOT THAT SLEEPY LITTLE TOWN 362 00:11:05,365 --> 00:11:06,431 TOWN THERE'S TRAFFIC. 363 00:11:06,433 --> 00:11:07,465 THERE'S TRAFFIC. I GOT STUCK IN TRAFFIC TODAY, 364 00:11:07,467 --> 00:11:09,567 I GOT STUCK IN TRAFFIC TODAY, YOU KNOW 365 00:11:09,569 --> 00:11:10,635 YOU KNOW >> Reporter: WITH HER DAUGHTER, 366 00:11:10,637 --> 00:11:12,370 >> Reporter: WITH HER DAUGHTER, JULIANA, GROWN AND OUT OF THE 367 00:11:12,372 --> 00:11:13,071 JULIANA, GROWN AND OUT OF THE HOUSE BY THEN NANCY, AT THE PEAK 368 00:11:13,073 --> 00:11:14,339 HOUSE BY THEN NANCY, AT THE PEAK OF SKI SEASON, HAD NO REASON TO 369 00:11:14,341 --> 00:11:15,874 OF SKI SEASON, HAD NO REASON TO WINTER IN ASPEN. 370 00:11:15,876 --> 00:11:17,475 WINTER IN ASPEN. WHICH IS WHY SHE RENTED HER 371 00:11:17,477 --> 00:11:20,078 WHICH IS WHY SHE RENTED HER HOUSE TO THAT RETIRED DOCTOR AND 372 00:11:20,080 --> 00:11:22,180 HOUSE TO THAT RETIRED DOCTOR AND HIS WIFE FROM DENVER 373 00:11:22,182 --> 00:11:24,349 HIS WIFE FROM DENVER WHILE SHE SIPPED HER CHAMPAGNE 374 00:11:24,351 --> 00:11:26,451 WHILE SHE SIPPED HER CHAMPAGNE IN WARMER CLIMES 375 00:11:26,453 --> 00:11:27,485 IN WARMER CLIMES THIS YEAR, AUSTRALIA 376 00:11:27,487 --> 00:11:28,186 THIS YEAR, AUSTRALIA SO IT WAS A SURPRISE WHEN, THIS 377 00:11:28,188 --> 00:11:29,087 SO IT WAS A SURPRISE WHEN, THIS FEBRUARY, SHE NOTIFIED HER 378 00:11:29,089 --> 00:11:30,889 FEBRUARY, SHE NOTIFIED HER FRIENDS SHE WAS COMING HOME 379 00:11:30,891 --> 00:11:31,756 FRIENDS SHE WAS COMING HOME EARLY. 380 00:11:31,758 --> 00:11:33,692 EARLY. SHE ARRIVED IN ASPEN SATURDAY 381 00:11:33,694 --> 00:11:34,893 SHE ARRIVED IN ASPEN SATURDAY THE 22nd OF FEBRUARY 382 00:11:34,895 --> 00:11:37,562 THE 22nd OF FEBRUARY KATHY CARPENTER PICKED HER UP AT 383 00:11:37,564 --> 00:11:39,497 KATHY CARPENTER PICKED HER UP AT THE AIRPORT. 384 00:11:39,499 --> 00:11:40,165 THE AIRPORT. >> I HUNG OUT WITH HER THAT 385 00:11:40,167 --> 00:11:41,199 >> I HUNG OUT WITH HER THAT EVENING, HELPED HER UNPACK, AND 386 00:11:41,201 --> 00:11:42,300 EVENING, HELPED HER UNPACK, AND TO GET ORGANIZED 387 00:11:42,302 --> 00:11:43,301 TO GET ORGANIZED >> Reporter: HOW WAS IT TO HAVE 388 00:11:43,303 --> 00:11:44,269 >> Reporter: HOW WAS IT TO HAVE HER BACK 389 00:11:44,271 --> 00:11:46,004 HER BACK >> IT WAS WONDERFUL. 390 00:11:46,006 --> 00:11:47,605 >> IT WAS WONDERFUL. IT WAS FUN 391 00:11:47,607 --> 00:11:49,174 IT WAS FUN SHE SHARED A LOT OF HER VIDEO 392 00:11:49,176 --> 00:11:50,208 SHE SHARED A LOT OF HER VIDEO CLIPS THAT SHE TOOK ON HER TRIP. 393 00:11:50,210 --> 00:11:51,810 CLIPS THAT SHE TOOK ON HER TRIP. >> Reporter: DID YOU STAY OVER 394 00:11:51,812 --> 00:11:52,310 >> Reporter: DID YOU STAY OVER THE WEEKEND OR - 395 00:11:52,312 --> 00:11:53,378 THE WEEKEND OR - >> I DID 396 00:11:53,380 --> 00:11:54,279 >> I DID SHE ASKED ME IF I WOULD STAY 397 00:11:54,281 --> 00:11:56,014 SHE ASKED ME IF I WOULD STAY WITH HER 398 00:11:56,016 --> 00:11:57,115 WITH HER SO I DID 399 00:11:57,117 --> 00:11:59,217 SO I DID >> Reporter: ON MONDAY MORNING, 400 00:11:59,219 --> 00:12:00,819 >> Reporter: ON MONDAY MORNING, FEBRUARY 24th, KATHY GOT UP 401 00:12:00,821 --> 00:12:01,820 FEBRUARY 24th, KATHY GOT UP EARLY AND LEFT FOR WORK, LEAVING 402 00:12:01,822 --> 00:12:03,421 EARLY AND LEFT FOR WORK, LEAVING NANCY AND HER DOG, GABE, AT THE 403 00:12:03,423 --> 00:12:05,023 NANCY AND HER DOG, GABE, AT THE HOUSE. 404 00:12:05,025 --> 00:12:07,325 HOUSE. KNOWING NANCY WOULD NEED PEACE 405 00:12:07,327 --> 00:12:08,727 KNOWING NANCY WOULD NEED PEACE AND QUIET TO GET OVER HER JET 406 00:12:08,729 --> 00:12:10,328 AND QUIET TO GET OVER HER JET LAG, SHE PUT A NOTE ON THE FRONT 407 00:12:10,330 --> 00:12:11,896 LAG, SHE PUT A NOTE ON THE FRONT DOOR ASKING WOULD-BE VISITORS TO 408 00:12:11,898 --> 00:12:12,931 DOOR ASKING WOULD-BE VISITORS TO LEAVE NANCY ALONE. 409 00:12:12,933 --> 00:12:14,032 LEAVE NANCY ALONE. >> SHE DID NOT WANT TO BE 410 00:12:14,034 --> 00:12:15,266 >> SHE DID NOT WANT TO BE DISTURBED. 411 00:12:15,268 --> 00:12:16,134 DISTURBED. NANCY PFISTER DID -- NEVER 412 00:12:16,136 --> 00:12:17,202 NANCY PFISTER DID -- NEVER WANTED TO BE DISTURBED WHEN SHE 413 00:12:17,204 --> 00:12:18,236 WANTED TO BE DISTURBED WHEN SHE SLEPT. 414 00:12:18,238 --> 00:12:19,838 SLEPT. >> Reporter: RIGHT 415 00:12:19,840 --> 00:12:21,406 >> Reporter: RIGHT >> YOU DO NOT CALL HER 416 00:12:21,408 --> 00:12:22,440 >> YOU DO NOT CALL HER YOU DO NOT WAKE HER. 417 00:12:22,442 --> 00:12:23,508 YOU DO NOT WAKE HER. AND SHE ALWAYS SLEPT WITH HER 418 00:12:23,510 --> 00:12:25,110 AND SHE ALWAYS SLEPT WITH HER EAR PLUGS AND HER EYE MASK 419 00:12:25,112 --> 00:12:27,212 EAR PLUGS AND HER EYE MASK EVERYTHING SHUT, CLOSE THE DOOR, 420 00:12:27,214 --> 00:12:29,547 EVERYTHING SHUT, CLOSE THE DOOR, AND DO NOT DISTURB 421 00:12:29,549 --> 00:12:31,249 AND DO NOT DISTURB >> Reporter: BILLY CLAYTON ALSO 422 00:12:31,251 --> 00:12:31,883 >> Reporter: BILLY CLAYTON ALSO LEFT NANCY ALONE, BUT FELT MUCH 423 00:12:31,885 --> 00:12:34,552 LEFT NANCY ALONE, BUT FELT MUCH BETTER JUST KNOWING SHE WAS 424 00:12:34,554 --> 00:12:35,620 BETTER JUST KNOWING SHE WAS HOME 425 00:12:35,622 --> 00:12:36,654 HOME >> I WORRIED ABOUT HER 426 00:12:36,656 --> 00:12:37,288 >> I WORRIED ABOUT HER CONSTANTLY WHEN SHE WAS AWAY 427 00:12:37,290 --> 00:12:38,757 CONSTANTLY WHEN SHE WAS AWAY FROM ASPEN 428 00:12:38,759 --> 00:12:40,358 FROM ASPEN BUT WHEN SHE RETURNED TO ASPEN, 429 00:12:40,360 --> 00:12:43,361 BUT WHEN SHE RETURNED TO ASPEN, I DIDN'T WORRY ABOUT HER 430 00:12:43,363 --> 00:12:44,062 I DIDN'T WORRY ABOUT HER I WOULD RELAX. 431 00:12:44,064 --> 00:12:45,130 I WOULD RELAX. I SENT HER AN E-MAIL 432 00:12:45,132 --> 00:12:47,732 I SENT HER AN E-MAIL THERE WITH A PHOTO OF MY 433 00:12:47,734 --> 00:12:48,266 THERE WITH A PHOTO OF MY FOUR-YEAR-OLD SON. 434 00:12:48,268 --> 00:12:50,368 FOUR-YEAR-OLD SON. "TO AUNT NANCY, WE'RE SO GLAD 435 00:12:50,370 --> 00:12:50,869 "TO AUNT NANCY, WE'RE SO GLAD YOU'RE HOME. 436 00:12:50,871 --> 00:12:52,270 YOU'RE HOME. BECAUSE WHEN YOU'RE HOME WE 437 00:12:52,272 --> 00:12:56,174 BECAUSE WHEN YOU'RE HOME WE DON'T WORRY ABOUT YOU AND 438 00:12:56,176 --> 00:12:57,242 DON'T WORRY ABOUT YOU AND EVERYTHING'S GOOD. 439 00:12:57,244 --> 00:12:57,842 EVERYTHING'S GOOD. >> Reporter: BUT BILLY DIDN'T 440 00:12:57,844 --> 00:12:59,444 >> Reporter: BUT BILLY DIDN'T HEAR BACK. 441 00:12:59,446 --> 00:12:59,711 HEAR BACK. NOT A WORD 442 00:12:59,713 --> 00:13:00,378 NOT A WORD AND THEN ON WEDNESDAY, THE 443 00:13:00,380 --> 00:13:01,446 AND THEN ON WEDNESDAY, THE PEOPLE WHO'D BEEN RENTING 444 00:13:01,448 --> 00:13:02,480 PEOPLE WHO'D BEEN RENTING NANCY'S HOUSE CALLED KATHY 445 00:13:02,482 --> 00:13:03,581 NANCY'S HOUSE CALLED KATHY THEY'D MOVED OUT QUICKLY ON 446 00:13:03,583 --> 00:13:05,150 THEY'D MOVED OUT QUICKLY ON NANCY'S RETURN AND HAD BEEN 447 00:13:05,152 --> 00:13:06,451 NANCY'S RETURN AND HAD BEEN GOING BACK AND FORTH TO THE 448 00:13:06,453 --> 00:13:07,252 GOING BACK AND FORTH TO THE HOUSE ALL WEEK CLEARING OUT THE 449 00:13:07,254 --> 00:13:08,286 HOUSE ALL WEEK CLEARING OUT THE LAST OF THEIR STUFF. 450 00:13:08,288 --> 00:13:10,455 LAST OF THEIR STUFF. AND THEY FOUND IT ODD THAT THEY 451 00:13:10,457 --> 00:13:12,557 AND THEY FOUND IT ODD THAT THEY HADN'T SEEN NANCY NOT ONCE 452 00:13:12,559 --> 00:13:15,693 HADN'T SEEN NANCY NOT ONCE SO THIS IS MONDAY, TUESDAY, AND 453 00:13:15,695 --> 00:13:17,295 SO THIS IS MONDAY, TUESDAY, AND THEN WEDNESDAY, AND YOU STILL 454 00:13:17,297 --> 00:13:18,863 THEN WEDNESDAY, AND YOU STILL HADN'T SEEN HER. 455 00:13:18,865 --> 00:13:20,999 HADN'T SEEN HER. >> STILL HADN'T SEEN HER 456 00:13:21,001 --> 00:13:22,066 >> STILL HADN'T SEEN HER >> Reporter: BUT THEY DID SEE 457 00:13:22,068 --> 00:13:25,203 >> Reporter: BUT THEY DID SEE NANCY'S DOG, GABE. 458 00:13:25,205 --> 00:13:26,271 NANCY'S DOG, GABE. >> AND THEN I WENT AND CALLED 459 00:13:26,273 --> 00:13:28,406 >> AND THEN I WENT AND CALLED KATHY AND SAID, "THIS DOG HAS 460 00:13:28,408 --> 00:13:28,907 KATHY AND SAID, "THIS DOG HAS BEEN ALONE FOR TWO DAYS. 461 00:13:28,909 --> 00:13:32,710 BEEN ALONE FOR TWO DAYS. IT'S CLEAR THAT SHE HASN'T BEEN 462 00:13:32,712 --> 00:13:33,178 IT'S CLEAR THAT SHE HASN'T BEEN BACK 463 00:13:33,180 --> 00:13:34,212 BACK >> I WAS CONCERNED BECAUSE 464 00:13:34,214 --> 00:13:35,814 >> I WAS CONCERNED BECAUSE NORMALLY THAT'S NOT NANCY'S 465 00:13:35,816 --> 00:13:36,314 NORMALLY THAT'S NOT NANCY'S BEHAVIOR 466 00:13:36,316 --> 00:13:37,916 BEHAVIOR SHE WOULD CALL ME AND ASK ME TO 467 00:13:37,918 --> 00:13:38,917 SHE WOULD CALL ME AND ASK ME TO PICK THE DOG UP. 468 00:13:38,919 --> 00:13:40,518 PICK THE DOG UP. >> Reporter: SO AFTER WORK KATHY 469 00:13:40,520 --> 00:13:41,586 >> Reporter: SO AFTER WORK KATHY DROVE UP TO NANCY'S PLACE ON 470 00:13:41,588 --> 00:13:43,121 DROVE UP TO NANCY'S PLACE ON BUTTERMILK MOUNTAIN TO CHECK ON 471 00:13:43,123 --> 00:13:44,122 BUTTERMILK MOUNTAIN TO CHECK ON HER FRIEND 472 00:13:44,124 --> 00:13:45,223 HER FRIEND WHAT WAS IT LIKE WHEN YOU WENT 473 00:13:45,225 --> 00:13:46,324 WHAT WAS IT LIKE WHEN YOU WENT INSIDE THE HOUSE 474 00:13:46,326 --> 00:13:47,325 INSIDE THE HOUSE >> I CALLED HER NAME OUT, AND 475 00:13:47,327 --> 00:13:48,393 >> I CALLED HER NAME OUT, AND GABE WAS THERE 476 00:13:48,395 --> 00:13:49,994 GABE WAS THERE HE WAS HAPPY TO SEE ME 477 00:13:49,996 --> 00:13:51,830 HE WAS HAPPY TO SEE ME >> Reporter: BUT NANCY WASN'T 478 00:13:51,832 --> 00:13:54,732 >> Reporter: BUT NANCY WASN'T THERE. 479 00:13:54,734 --> 00:13:56,334 THERE. KATHY CHECKED HER BEDROOM. 480 00:13:56,336 --> 00:13:58,937 KATHY CHECKED HER BEDROOM. >> YOU KNOW, STUFF THAT WAS 481 00:13:58,939 --> 00:14:02,640 >> YOU KNOW, STUFF THAT WAS THERE THAT I UNPACKED, YOU KNOW, 482 00:14:02,642 --> 00:14:03,174 THERE THAT I UNPACKED, YOU KNOW, IT WAS CLEAR -- CLEANED UP 483 00:14:03,176 --> 00:14:04,742 IT WAS CLEAR -- CLEANED UP AND WHEN I TURNED, WENT TO THE 484 00:14:04,744 --> 00:14:05,210 AND WHEN I TURNED, WENT TO THE CLOSET, IT WAS LOCKED. 485 00:14:05,212 --> 00:14:06,945 CLOSET, IT WAS LOCKED. >> Reporter: WAS IT USUALLY 486 00:14:06,947 --> 00:14:08,413 >> Reporter: WAS IT USUALLY LOCKED 487 00:14:08,415 --> 00:14:09,447 LOCKED >> NO. 488 00:14:09,449 --> 00:14:11,049 >> NO. NOT -- I MEAN, NOT WITH NANCY 489 00:14:11,051 --> 00:14:12,450 NOT -- I MEAN, NOT WITH NANCY PFISTER HOME 490 00:14:12,452 --> 00:14:13,151 PFISTER HOME >> Reporter: KATHY KNEW THAT 491 00:14:13,153 --> 00:14:14,219 >> Reporter: KATHY KNEW THAT WHEN NANCY RENTED HER HOUSE, SHE 492 00:14:14,221 --> 00:14:15,253 WHEN NANCY RENTED HER HOUSE, SHE KEPT HER PERSONAL BELONGINGS 493 00:14:15,255 --> 00:14:16,855 KEPT HER PERSONAL BELONGINGS LOCKED IN A CLOSET IN THE MASTER 494 00:14:16,857 --> 00:14:19,157 LOCKED IN A CLOSET IN THE MASTER BEDROOM. 495 00:14:19,159 --> 00:14:22,160 BEDROOM. BUT SHE AND KATHY HAD UNLOCKED 496 00:14:22,162 --> 00:14:23,728 BUT SHE AND KATHY HAD UNLOCKED IT WHEN SHE GOT HOME 497 00:14:23,730 --> 00:14:24,395 IT WHEN SHE GOT HOME >> AT THAT POINT, I JUST -- I 498 00:14:24,397 --> 00:14:25,330 >> AT THAT POINT, I JUST -- I WAS NOT FEELING COMFORTABLE. 499 00:14:25,332 --> 00:14:26,564 WAS NOT FEELING COMFORTABLE. SOMETHING WAS NOT RIGHT. 500 00:14:26,566 --> 00:14:27,198 SOMETHING WAS NOT RIGHT. >> Reporter: KATHY WHO OFTEN 501 00:14:27,200 --> 00:14:28,466 >> Reporter: KATHY WHO OFTEN HOUSE SAT FOR NANCY HAD A SPARE 502 00:14:28,468 --> 00:14:29,567 HOUSE SAT FOR NANCY HAD A SPARE KEY. 503 00:14:29,569 --> 00:14:30,134 KEY. BUT IT WAS BACK AT HER HOUSE 504 00:14:30,136 --> 00:14:31,669 BUT IT WAS BACK AT HER HOUSE SHE WENT HOME, GOT THE KEY, 505 00:14:31,671 --> 00:14:32,737 SHE WENT HOME, GOT THE KEY, RETURNED 506 00:14:32,739 --> 00:14:35,940 RETURNED OPENED THE CLOSET DOOR 507 00:14:35,942 --> 00:14:37,976 OPENED THE CLOSET DOOR >> WHEN I OPENED THAT DOOR, THAT 508 00:14:37,978 --> 00:14:39,577 >> WHEN I OPENED THAT DOOR, THAT ODOR IS SO OVERWHELMING, IT HIT 509 00:14:39,579 --> 00:14:42,780 ODOR IS SO OVERWHELMING, IT HIT ME IN THE FACE 510 00:14:42,782 --> 00:14:46,684 ME IN THE FACE AND I LOOKED DOWN, AND I COULD 511 00:14:46,686 --> 00:14:47,552 AND I LOOKED DOWN, AND I COULD SEE THE SHAPE. 512 00:14:47,554 --> 00:14:48,586 SEE THE SHAPE. >> Reporter: A SHAPE HIDDEN 513 00:14:48,588 --> 00:14:50,188 >> Reporter: A SHAPE HIDDEN UNDER A PILE OF BLANKETS AND 514 00:14:50,190 --> 00:14:51,256 UNDER A PILE OF BLANKETS AND COVERINGS. 515 00:14:51,258 --> 00:14:52,790 COVERINGS. BUT WITH ONE GLIMPSE, KATHY JUST 516 00:14:52,792 --> 00:14:55,994 BUT WITH ONE GLIMPSE, KATHY JUST KNEW, SHE SAID 517 00:14:55,996 --> 00:14:57,061 KNEW, SHE SAID IT WAS NANCY PFISTER 518 00:14:57,063 --> 00:15:00,198 IT WAS NANCY PFISTER HARD TO GET THAT IMAGE OUT OF 519 00:15:00,200 --> 00:15:02,300 HARD TO GET THAT IMAGE OUT OF YOUR MIND. 520 00:15:02,302 --> 00:15:02,800 YOUR MIND. >> IT IS 521 00:15:02,802 --> 00:15:05,470 >> IT IS >> Reporter: KIND OF STUCK 522 00:15:05,472 --> 00:15:09,173 >> Reporter: KIND OF STUCK THERE. 523 00:15:09,175 --> 00:15:10,208 THERE. >> IT -- IT -- IS. 524 00:15:10,210 --> 00:15:11,209 >> IT -- IT -- IS. >> Reporter: KATHY FLED THE 525 00:15:11,211 --> 00:15:15,113 >> Reporter: KATHY FLED THE HOUSE, GOT IN HER CAR, CALLED 526 00:15:15,115 --> 00:15:16,714 HOUSE, GOT IN HER CAR, CALLED 911. 527 00:15:16,716 --> 00:15:18,116 911. >> OH MY GOD, NO 528 00:15:18,118 --> 00:15:19,117 >> OH MY GOD, NO IT'S PRETTY DESOLATE UP THERE. 529 00:15:19,119 --> 00:15:19,784 IT'S PRETTY DESOLATE UP THERE. SO, I JUMPED IN THE CAR AND I 530 00:15:19,786 --> 00:15:21,786 SO, I JUMPED IN THE CAR AND I THOUGHT I'LL JUST DRIVE DOWN THE 531 00:15:21,788 --> 00:15:24,923 THOUGHT I'LL JUST DRIVE DOWN THE HILL AND GET TO THE POLICE 532 00:15:24,925 --> 00:15:26,524 HILL AND GET TO THE POLICE DEPARTMENT 533 00:15:26,526 --> 00:15:28,126 DEPARTMENT I -- I -- I DON'T KNOW 534 00:15:28,128 --> 00:15:29,193 I -- I -- I DON'T KNOW >> Reporter: HER HYSTERICS MADE 535 00:15:29,195 --> 00:15:31,829 >> Reporter: HER HYSTERICS MADE IT VERY HARD FOR THE DISPATCHER 536 00:15:31,831 --> 00:15:33,932 IT VERY HARD FOR THE DISPATCHER TO COMPREHEND. 537 00:15:33,934 --> 00:15:34,999 TO COMPREHEND. >> CAN YOU GET NEAR YOUR FRIEND? 538 00:15:35,001 --> 00:15:41,306 >> CAN YOU GET NEAR YOUR FRIEND? >> NO! 539 00:15:41,308 --> 00:15:41,806 >> NO! NO, I CAN'T. 540 00:15:41,808 --> 00:15:42,840 NO, I CAN'T. >> Reporter: THEN, FINALLY 541 00:15:42,842 --> 00:15:44,042 >> Reporter: THEN, FINALLY UNDERSTANDING, THE DISPATCHER 542 00:15:44,044 --> 00:15:44,676 UNDERSTANDING, THE DISPATCHER TOLD KATHY, PULL OVER, WAIT FOR 543 00:15:44,678 --> 00:15:45,043 TOLD KATHY, PULL OVER, WAIT FOR FIRST RESPONDERS 544 00:15:45,045 --> 00:15:46,044 FIRST RESPONDERS >> I WANT YOU TO PULL OVER AND 545 00:15:46,046 --> 00:15:47,245 >> I WANT YOU TO PULL OVER AND PUT YOUR FLASHERS ON 546 00:15:47,247 --> 00:15:48,146 PUT YOUR FLASHERS ON >> OKAY. 547 00:15:48,148 --> 00:15:49,147 >> OKAY. WHEN THE POLICE ARRIVE, THEY - 548 00:15:49,149 --> 00:15:50,748 WHEN THE POLICE ARRIVE, THEY - YOU KNOW, I STEPPED OUT OF THE 549 00:15:50,750 --> 00:15:51,249 YOU KNOW, I STEPPED OUT OF THE VEHICLE. 550 00:15:51,251 --> 00:15:53,918 VEHICLE. I THINK I WAS GOING INTO SHOCK, 551 00:15:53,920 --> 00:15:54,953 I THINK I WAS GOING INTO SHOCK, HYPERVENTILATING 552 00:15:54,955 --> 00:15:56,120 HYPERVENTILATING >> Reporter: DASH CAM VIDEO 553 00:15:56,122 --> 00:15:58,156 >> Reporter: DASH CAM VIDEO SHOWS A DISTRAUGHT KATHY AS SHE 554 00:15:58,158 --> 00:15:59,724 SHOWS A DISTRAUGHT KATHY AS SHE WAS TAKEN TO THE HOSPITAL. 555 00:15:59,726 --> 00:16:03,428 WAS TAKEN TO THE HOSPITAL. AND SHERIFF'S DEPUTIES ARRIVED 556 00:16:03,430 --> 00:16:04,028 AND SHERIFF'S DEPUTIES ARRIVED ON BUTTERMILK MOUNTAIN TO LOOK 557 00:16:04,030 --> 00:16:07,632 ON BUTTERMILK MOUNTAIN TO LOOK IN THAT ROOM AND CONFRONT A 558 00:16:07,634 --> 00:16:08,166 IN THAT ROOM AND CONFRONT A MYSTERY. 559 00:16:08,168 --> 00:16:08,800 MYSTERY. >> THAT HOUSE, AND THAT ROOM IN 560 00:16:08,802 --> 00:16:10,835 >> THAT HOUSE, AND THAT ROOM IN PARTICULAR HAS THIS STORY TO 561 00:16:10,837 --> 00:16:11,869 PARTICULAR HAS THIS STORY TO TELL 562 00:16:11,871 --> 00:16:15,773 TELL AND ARE WE GOING TO BE ABLE TO 563 00:16:15,775 --> 00:16:17,775 AND ARE WE GOING TO BE ABLE TO FIGURE OUT WHAT THAT STORY IS? 564 00:16:17,777 --> 00:16:18,276 FIGURE OUT WHAT THAT STORY IS? >> COMING UP - 565 00:16:18,278 --> 00:16:19,777 >> COMING UP - >> THEY KNEW THEY WERE LOOKING 566 00:16:19,779 --> 00:16:20,845 >> THEY KNEW THEY WERE LOOKING FOR A BODY 567 00:16:20,847 --> 00:16:22,447 FOR A BODY >> THE DISCOVERY IN THE CLOSET 568 00:16:22,449 --> 00:16:23,481 >> THE DISCOVERY IN THE CLOSET WHO WAS BEHIND IT? 569 00:16:23,483 --> 00:16:24,549 WHO WAS BEHIND IT? HARD TO DO THAT ALONE? 570 00:16:24,551 --> 00:16:31,389 HARD TO DO THAT ALONE? >> IT IS AWKWARD AND DIFFICULT 571 00:16:31,391 --> 00:16:31,889 >> IT IS AWKWARD AND DIFFICULT TO MOVE A BODY 572 00:16:31,891 --> 00:16:33,491 TO MOVE A BODY >> MORE THAN ONE SUSPECT 573 00:16:33,493 --> 00:16:49,741 >> MORE THAN ONE SUSPECT AND MAYBE MORE THAN 574 00:16:49,743 --> 00:16:50,341 AND MAYBE MORE THAN >> Reporter: LISA MILLER, THEN 575 00:16:50,343 --> 00:16:50,942 >> Reporter: LISA MILLER, THEN THE DA'S INVESTIGATOR FOR THE 576 00:16:50,944 --> 00:16:51,843 THE DA'S INVESTIGATOR FOR THE COUNTY THAT INCLUDES ASPEN, IS A 577 00:16:51,845 --> 00:16:52,910 COUNTY THAT INCLUDES ASPEN, IS A TALL, RANGY WOMAN WITH AN IMPISH 578 00:16:52,912 --> 00:17:01,352 TALL, RANGY WOMAN WITH AN IMPISH GRIN THAT LOOKS LIKE IT'S HIDING 579 00:17:01,354 --> 00:17:01,853 GRIN THAT LOOKS LIKE IT'S HIDING A SECRET 580 00:17:01,855 --> 00:17:02,920 A SECRET INVESTIGATOR MILLER WAS IN AN 581 00:17:02,922 --> 00:17:03,554 INVESTIGATOR MILLER WAS IN AN UNFAMILIAR SITUATION UP HERE ON 582 00:17:03,556 --> 00:17:05,056 UNFAMILIAR SITUATION UP HERE ON BUTTERMILK MOUNTAIN. 583 00:17:05,058 --> 00:17:06,124 BUTTERMILK MOUNTAIN. MURDER IN ASPEN? 584 00:17:06,126 --> 00:17:06,657 MURDER IN ASPEN? JUST DOESN'T HAPPEN. 585 00:17:06,659 --> 00:17:08,259 JUST DOESN'T HAPPEN. OR HADN'T, AT LEAST, IN MORE 586 00:17:08,261 --> 00:17:09,260 OR HADN'T, AT LEAST, IN MORE THAN A DECADE. 587 00:17:09,262 --> 00:17:10,862 THAN A DECADE. >> I WAS A LITTLE SURPRISED THAT 588 00:17:10,864 --> 00:17:15,266 >> I WAS A LITTLE SURPRISED THAT WE HAD A MURDER IN ASPEN 589 00:17:15,268 --> 00:17:15,867 WE HAD A MURDER IN ASPEN RAILROAD AND BEING CALLED TO A 590 00:17:15,869 --> 00:17:16,367 RAILROAD AND BEING CALLED TO A PERSON'S HOME LIKE NANCY 591 00:17:16,369 --> 00:17:16,868 PERSON'S HOME LIKE NANCY PFISTER, I SHOULD THINK, 592 00:17:16,870 --> 00:17:18,369 PFISTER, I SHOULD THINK, ESPECIALLY SO? 593 00:17:18,371 --> 00:17:19,871 ESPECIALLY SO? >> CORRECT 594 00:17:19,873 --> 00:17:20,471 >> CORRECT >> Reporter: AND YET HERE SHE 595 00:17:20,473 --> 00:17:21,439 >> Reporter: AND YET HERE SHE WAS IN NANCY'S LIVING ROOM, 596 00:17:21,441 --> 00:17:24,075 WAS IN NANCY'S LIVING ROOM, LOOKING OUT THE BIG PICTURE 597 00:17:24,077 --> 00:17:25,643 LOOKING OUT THE BIG PICTURE WINDOW 598 00:17:25,645 --> 00:17:29,347 WINDOW >> THE JUXTAPOSITION OF ARRIVING 599 00:17:29,349 --> 00:17:29,981 >> THE JUXTAPOSITION OF ARRIVING AT THAT HOUSE AND TAKING A LOOK 600 00:17:29,983 --> 00:17:31,983 AT THAT HOUSE AND TAKING A LOOK AT THIS BEAUTIFUL SCENERY AND 601 00:17:31,985 --> 00:17:35,153 AT THIS BEAUTIFUL SCENERY AND THEN KNOWING AN ACT OF TERRIBLE 602 00:17:35,155 --> 00:17:35,787 THEN KNOWING AN ACT OF TERRIBLE VIOLENCE HAD OCCURRED JUST DOWN 603 00:17:35,789 --> 00:17:38,790 VIOLENCE HAD OCCURRED JUST DOWN THE HALLWAY -- 604 00:17:38,792 --> 00:17:39,424 THE HALLWAY -- >> Reporter: THOUGH, IN THE 605 00:17:39,426 --> 00:17:42,493 >> Reporter: THOUGH, IN THE BEDROOM, SHE SAW SURPRISINGLY 606 00:17:42,495 --> 00:17:43,494 BEDROOM, SHE SAW SURPRISINGLY LITTLE EVIDENCE OF IT. 607 00:17:43,496 --> 00:17:44,128 LITTLE EVIDENCE OF IT. >> THERE WAS A SMALL BLOOD SMEAR 608 00:17:44,130 --> 00:17:45,096 >> THERE WAS A SMALL BLOOD SMEAR ON THE HEADBOARD 609 00:17:45,098 --> 00:17:45,696 ON THE HEADBOARD THERE WAS -- COUPLE SMALL 610 00:17:45,698 --> 00:17:48,800 THERE WAS -- COUPLE SMALL DROPLETS OF BLOOD ON THE CARPET 611 00:17:48,802 --> 00:17:52,003 DROPLETS OF BLOOD ON THE CARPET AND A LITTLE BIT OF SPATTER ON 612 00:17:52,005 --> 00:17:53,604 AND A LITTLE BIT OF SPATTER ON THE WALL 613 00:17:53,606 --> 00:17:54,605 THE WALL >> Reporter: AND THE BODY IN THE 614 00:17:54,607 --> 00:17:56,707 >> Reporter: AND THE BODY IN THE CLOSET 615 00:17:56,709 --> 00:17:59,377 CLOSET WELL, WHEN FIRST RESPONDERS 616 00:17:59,379 --> 00:17:59,911 WELL, WHEN FIRST RESPONDERS OPENED THE DOOR -- 617 00:17:59,913 --> 00:18:02,613 OPENED THE DOOR -- >> THEY KNEW THEY WERE LOOKING 618 00:18:02,615 --> 00:18:03,614 >> THEY KNEW THEY WERE LOOKING FOR A BODY 619 00:18:03,616 --> 00:18:04,248 FOR A BODY AND THEY OPEN THE DOOR AND THEY 620 00:18:04,250 --> 00:18:05,183 AND THEY OPEN THE DOOR AND THEY LOOK INSIDE AND THEY DIDN'T 621 00:18:05,185 --> 00:18:06,717 LOOK INSIDE AND THEY DIDN'T IMMEDIATELY RECOGNIZE THE BODY 622 00:18:06,719 --> 00:18:10,988 IMMEDIATELY RECOGNIZE THE BODY YOU JUST LOOKED DOWN AND YOU SAW 623 00:18:10,990 --> 00:18:11,522 YOU JUST LOOKED DOWN AND YOU SAW WHITE COVERINGS. 624 00:18:11,524 --> 00:18:15,093 WHITE COVERINGS. >> Reporter: AND UNDERNEATH 625 00:18:15,095 --> 00:18:15,493 >> Reporter: AND UNDERNEATH THOSE COVERINGS -- 626 00:18:15,495 --> 00:18:17,829 THOSE COVERINGS -- >> MISS PFISTER HAD BEEN BOUND 627 00:18:17,831 --> 00:18:18,930 >> MISS PFISTER HAD BEEN BOUND WITH AN EXTENSION CORD 628 00:18:18,932 --> 00:18:19,931 WITH AN EXTENSION CORD SHE HAD MULTIPLE PLASTIC BAGS 629 00:18:19,933 --> 00:18:22,100 SHE HAD MULTIPLE PLASTIC BAGS OVER HER HEAD THAT HAD BEEN 630 00:18:22,102 --> 00:18:24,035 OVER HER HEAD THAT HAD BEEN BOUND AND SECURED TIGHTLY. 631 00:18:24,037 --> 00:18:25,803 BOUND AND SECURED TIGHTLY. AND THEN ANOTHER LARGE ONE OF 632 00:18:25,805 --> 00:18:32,110 AND THEN ANOTHER LARGE ONE OF THE TEAR-RESISTANT, DARKER 633 00:18:32,112 --> 00:18:32,743 THE TEAR-RESISTANT, DARKER COLORED BAGS OVER HER BODY ALSO. 634 00:18:32,745 --> 00:18:33,277 COLORED BAGS OVER HER BODY ALSO. >> Reporter: WITH BLANKETS 635 00:18:33,279 --> 00:18:35,847 >> Reporter: WITH BLANKETS WRAPPED ALL AROUND THAT. 636 00:18:35,849 --> 00:18:36,848 WRAPPED ALL AROUND THAT. INVESTIGATOR MILLER COULD 637 00:18:36,850 --> 00:18:37,949 INVESTIGATOR MILLER COULD CLEARLY SEE THAT THE KILLER, 638 00:18:37,951 --> 00:18:38,549 CLEARLY SEE THAT THE KILLER, WHOEVER IT WAS, HAD GONE TO A 639 00:18:38,551 --> 00:18:39,517 WHOEVER IT WAS, HAD GONE TO A LOT OF TROUBLE TO HIDE WHAT HE 640 00:18:39,519 --> 00:18:42,920 LOT OF TROUBLE TO HIDE WHAT HE OR SHE HAD DONE BUT THERE WAS NO 641 00:18:42,922 --> 00:18:45,923 OR SHE HAD DONE BUT THERE WAS NO HIDING NOW 642 00:18:45,925 --> 00:18:47,458 HIDING NOW >> WHEN THE CRIME SCENE 643 00:18:47,460 --> 00:18:49,060 >> WHEN THE CRIME SCENE PERSONNEL STARTED TAKING A LOOK, 644 00:18:49,062 --> 00:18:50,061 PERSONNEL STARTED TAKING A LOOK, THEY FLIPPED THE MATTRESS AND 645 00:18:50,063 --> 00:18:55,933 THEY FLIPPED THE MATTRESS AND FOUND, UH -- BLOOD ON THE BOTTOM 646 00:18:55,935 --> 00:18:56,367 FOUND, UH -- BLOOD ON THE BOTTOM PART OF THE MATTRESS 647 00:18:56,369 --> 00:18:57,001 PART OF THE MATTRESS >> Reporter: SO, IT WAS CLEAR -- 648 00:18:57,003 --> 00:18:57,568 >> Reporter: SO, IT WAS CLEAR -- NANCY WAS KILLED ON THE BED, 649 00:18:57,570 --> 00:19:01,172 NANCY WAS KILLED ON THE BED, DRAGGED TO THE CLOSET, STASHED 650 00:19:01,174 --> 00:19:02,773 DRAGGED TO THE CLOSET, STASHED THERE, WRAPPED UP LIKE A MUMMY 651 00:19:02,775 --> 00:19:03,841 THERE, WRAPPED UP LIKE A MUMMY THEN WHOEVER DID IT TOOK THE 652 00:19:03,843 --> 00:19:04,876 THEN WHOEVER DID IT TOOK THE EXTRA TROUBLE TO FLIP THE 653 00:19:04,878 --> 00:19:06,477 EXTRA TROUBLE TO FLIP THE MATTRESS IN AN EFFORT TO HIDE 654 00:19:06,479 --> 00:19:07,678 MATTRESS IN AN EFFORT TO HIDE THE SOAKED-IN POOL OF BLOOD. 655 00:19:07,680 --> 00:19:09,680 THE SOAKED-IN POOL OF BLOOD. DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY ANDREA 656 00:19:09,682 --> 00:19:15,453 DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY ANDREA BRYAN STARTED WORKING THE CASE 657 00:19:15,455 --> 00:19:16,220 BRYAN STARTED WORKING THE CASE ON THE NIGHT NANCY'S BODY WAS 658 00:19:16,222 --> 00:19:17,388 ON THE NIGHT NANCY'S BODY WAS FOUND. 659 00:19:17,390 --> 00:19:18,089 FOUND. >> WE LEARNED THAT SHE HAD DIED 660 00:19:18,091 --> 00:19:20,191 >> WE LEARNED THAT SHE HAD DIED FROM BLUNT FORCE TRAUMA TO THE 661 00:19:20,193 --> 00:19:20,825 FROM BLUNT FORCE TRAUMA TO THE HEAD AND IT APPEARED SHE HAD HAD 662 00:19:20,827 --> 00:19:21,359 HEAD AND IT APPEARED SHE HAD HAD SEVERAL BLOWS TO THE HEAD. 663 00:19:21,361 --> 00:19:22,293 SEVERAL BLOWS TO THE HEAD. >> Reporter: ANY DEFENIVE 664 00:19:22,295 --> 00:19:23,995 >> Reporter: ANY DEFENIVE WOUNDS 665 00:19:23,997 --> 00:19:25,196 WOUNDS >> NO. 666 00:19:25,198 --> 00:19:26,497 >> NO. >> Reporter: SO THIS APPEARED TO 667 00:19:26,499 --> 00:19:27,598 >> Reporter: SO THIS APPEARED TO COME OUT OF THE BLUE FOR HER 668 00:19:27,600 --> 00:19:29,167 COME OUT OF THE BLUE FOR HER >> IT DID APPEAR TO BE, YES, A 669 00:19:29,169 --> 00:19:30,768 >> IT DID APPEAR TO BE, YES, A PRE-MEDITATED CRIME THAT 670 00:19:30,770 --> 00:19:32,403 PRE-MEDITATED CRIME THAT OCCURRED WHILE SHE WAS SLEEPING. 671 00:19:32,405 --> 00:19:33,905 OCCURRED WHILE SHE WAS SLEEPING. >> Reporter: IT LOOKED AS IF IT 672 00:19:33,907 --> 00:19:35,006 >> Reporter: IT LOOKED AS IF IT HAPPENED EARLY MONDAY MORNING. 673 00:19:35,008 --> 00:19:35,606 HAPPENED EARLY MONDAY MORNING. AND THEN, THE BODY LAY IN THE 674 00:19:35,608 --> 00:19:36,574 AND THEN, THE BODY LAY IN THE CLOSET UNDISCOVERED UNTIL 675 00:19:36,576 --> 00:19:37,775 CLOSET UNDISCOVERED UNTIL WEDNESDAY EVENING. 676 00:19:37,777 --> 00:19:38,676 WEDNESDAY EVENING. THE INVESTIGATORS BEGAN 677 00:19:38,678 --> 00:19:40,778 THE INVESTIGATORS BEGAN COMPILING A LIST OF POSSIBLE 678 00:19:40,780 --> 00:19:47,118 COMPILING A LIST OF POSSIBLE SUSPECTS, A LONG LIST. 679 00:19:47,120 --> 00:19:47,752 SUSPECTS, A LONG LIST. >> NONE OF US REALLY LIVED LIKE 680 00:19:47,754 --> 00:19:49,220 >> NONE OF US REALLY LIVED LIKE NANCY, SO OPEN 681 00:19:49,222 --> 00:19:50,288 NANCY, SO OPEN I MEAN SHE WAS TOTALLY OPEN TO 682 00:19:50,290 --> 00:19:51,322 I MEAN SHE WAS TOTALLY OPEN TO STRANGERS. 683 00:19:51,324 --> 00:19:53,491 STRANGERS. >> Reporter: THAT OPENNESS MADE 684 00:19:53,493 --> 00:19:54,492 >> Reporter: THAT OPENNESS MADE NANCY FRIENDS EVERYWHERE SHE 685 00:19:54,494 --> 00:19:55,526 NANCY FRIENDS EVERYWHERE SHE WENT, SAID BILLY 686 00:19:55,528 --> 00:19:56,127 WENT, SAID BILLY BUT THEN AGAIN, WHEN NANCY 687 00:19:56,129 --> 00:20:00,932 BUT THEN AGAIN, WHEN NANCY OPENED HERSELF UP, PEOPLE DIDN'T 688 00:20:00,934 --> 00:20:01,532 OPENED HERSELF UP, PEOPLE DIDN'T ALWAYS LIKE WHAT CAME OUT. 689 00:20:01,534 --> 00:20:02,934 ALWAYS LIKE WHAT CAME OUT. >> SAY WHAT SHE THOUGHT WHEN SHE 690 00:20:02,936 --> 00:20:03,834 >> SAY WHAT SHE THOUGHT WHEN SHE THOUGHT. 691 00:20:03,836 --> 00:20:06,137 THOUGHT. >> Reporter: DID SHE REALIZE SHE 692 00:20:06,139 --> 00:20:07,738 >> Reporter: DID SHE REALIZE SHE WAS GOING TO MAYBE MAKE A 693 00:20:07,740 --> 00:20:09,840 WAS GOING TO MAYBE MAKE A NEGATIVE IMPRESSION SOMETIMES 694 00:20:09,842 --> 00:20:11,409 NEGATIVE IMPRESSION SOMETIMES WHEN SHE DID THAT? 695 00:20:11,411 --> 00:20:12,043 WHEN SHE DID THAT? >> WELL, SHE DEFINITELY [ BLEEP 696 00:20:12,045 --> 00:20:14,645 >> WELL, SHE DEFINITELY [ BLEEP ] PEOPLE OFF THERE'S NO DOUBT 697 00:20:14,647 --> 00:20:15,613 ] PEOPLE OFF THERE'S NO DOUBT ABOUT THAT 698 00:20:15,615 --> 00:20:16,180 ABOUT THAT SHE, YOU KNOW, MANY TIMES I 699 00:20:16,182 --> 00:20:17,748 SHE, YOU KNOW, MANY TIMES I COULD JUST SEE PEOPLE'S, YOU 700 00:20:17,750 --> 00:20:18,816 COULD JUST SEE PEOPLE'S, YOU KNOW, STEAM COMING OUT OF THEIR 701 00:20:18,818 --> 00:20:20,251 KNOW, STEAM COMING OUT OF THEIR EARS AND THEY'RE THINKING, "NO 702 00:20:20,253 --> 00:20:20,818 EARS AND THEY'RE THINKING, "NO ONE'S EVER TALKED TO ME LIKE 703 00:20:20,820 --> 00:20:22,019 ONE'S EVER TALKED TO ME LIKE THAT BEFORE. 704 00:20:22,021 --> 00:20:22,553 THAT BEFORE. >> Reporter: YEAH. 705 00:20:22,555 --> 00:20:23,588 >> Reporter: YEAH. >> BUT HER THINKING WAS, 706 00:20:23,590 --> 00:20:24,222 >> BUT HER THINKING WAS, "SOMEONE SHOULD HAVE A LONG TIME 707 00:20:24,224 --> 00:20:26,257 "SOMEONE SHOULD HAVE A LONG TIME AGO. 708 00:20:26,259 --> 00:20:26,757 AGO. YOU KNOW 709 00:20:26,759 --> 00:20:27,425 YOU KNOW >> Reporter: NO QUESTION NANCY 710 00:20:27,427 --> 00:20:28,359 >> Reporter: NO QUESTION NANCY RUBBED SOME PEOPLE THE WRONG 711 00:20:28,361 --> 00:20:28,859 RUBBED SOME PEOPLE THE WRONG WAY. 712 00:20:28,861 --> 00:20:32,063 WAY. SPOKE HER MIND A BIT TOO OFTEN, 713 00:20:32,065 --> 00:20:32,563 SPOKE HER MIND A BIT TOO OFTEN, MAYBE? 714 00:20:32,565 --> 00:20:33,664 MAYBE? TREATED FRIENDS A LITTLE LIKE 715 00:20:33,666 --> 00:20:37,368 TREATED FRIENDS A LITTLE LIKE HER PERSONAL SERVANTS SOMETIMES. 716 00:20:37,370 --> 00:20:38,369 HER PERSONAL SERVANTS SOMETIMES. LIKE KATHY FOR EXAMPLE 717 00:20:38,371 --> 00:20:39,036 LIKE KATHY FOR EXAMPLE DID SHE TREAT YOU MORE LIKE A 718 00:20:39,038 --> 00:20:40,471 DID SHE TREAT YOU MORE LIKE A FRIEND OR LIKE SHE WAS YOUR 719 00:20:40,473 --> 00:20:42,473 FRIEND OR LIKE SHE WAS YOUR BOSS 720 00:20:42,475 --> 00:20:43,040 BOSS >> YOU KNOW, WE WERE FRIENDS 721 00:20:43,042 --> 00:20:44,742 >> YOU KNOW, WE WERE FRIENDS AND JUST DEPENDING ON THE DAY 722 00:20:44,744 --> 00:20:45,776 AND JUST DEPENDING ON THE DAY AND SOME DAYS, YOU KNOW, SHE 723 00:20:45,778 --> 00:20:47,445 AND SOME DAYS, YOU KNOW, SHE WOULD BOSS ME AROUND 724 00:20:47,447 --> 00:20:51,582 WOULD BOSS ME AROUND AND I WOULD EXPRESS HOW I FELT 725 00:20:51,584 --> 00:20:52,116 AND I WOULD EXPRESS HOW I FELT AND SHE ALWAYS APOLOGIZED. 726 00:20:52,118 --> 00:20:52,683 AND SHE ALWAYS APOLOGIZED. >> Reporter: AND HER FRIENDS 727 00:20:52,685 --> 00:20:53,651 >> Reporter: AND HER FRIENDS FORGAVE. 728 00:20:53,653 --> 00:20:54,752 FORGAVE. BECAUSE THEY LOVED NANCY FOR WHO 729 00:20:54,754 --> 00:20:56,354 BECAUSE THEY LOVED NANCY FOR WHO SHE WAS. 730 00:20:56,356 --> 00:20:58,456 SHE WAS. BUT INVESTIGATORS NOW HAD TO 731 00:20:58,458 --> 00:20:59,090 BUT INVESTIGATORS NOW HAD TO FIGURE OUT IF SOMEONE IN NANCY'S 732 00:20:59,092 --> 00:21:02,693 FIGURE OUT IF SOMEONE IN NANCY'S LIFE HAD STOPPED LOVING HER. 733 00:21:02,695 --> 00:21:03,728 LIFE HAD STOPPED LOVING HER. OR IF SHE HAD SIMPLY OPENED 734 00:21:03,730 --> 00:21:07,898 OR IF SHE HAD SIMPLY OPENED HERSELF UP TO THE WRONG PERSON 735 00:21:07,900 --> 00:21:09,000 HERSELF UP TO THE WRONG PERSON >> WE'RE WORKING DILIGENTLY AT 736 00:21:09,002 --> 00:21:11,102 >> WE'RE WORKING DILIGENTLY AT THAT POINT TO FOLLOW UP ON OTHER 737 00:21:11,104 --> 00:21:13,204 THAT POINT TO FOLLOW UP ON OTHER LEADS THAT WERE COMING IN. 738 00:21:13,206 --> 00:21:19,577 LEADS THAT WERE COMING IN. >> Reporter: LIKE? 739 00:21:19,579 --> 00:21:21,612 >> Reporter: LIKE? >> LEADS OF OTHER PEOPLE IN THE 740 00:21:21,614 --> 00:21:22,246 >> LEADS OF OTHER PEOPLE IN THE COMMUNITY THAT MAY HAVE HAD SOME 741 00:21:22,248 --> 00:21:22,747 COMMUNITY THAT MAY HAVE HAD SOME RESENTMENT TOWARDS NANCY 742 00:21:22,749 --> 00:21:23,214 RESENTMENT TOWARDS NANCY PFISTER. 743 00:21:23,216 --> 00:21:23,848 PFISTER. >> Reporter: LIKE PERHAPS A 744 00:21:23,850 --> 00:21:24,815 >> Reporter: LIKE PERHAPS A JILTED LOVER 745 00:21:24,817 --> 00:21:26,417 JILTED LOVER MIGHT ONE OF THEM HAVE HARBORED 746 00:21:26,419 --> 00:21:27,985 MIGHT ONE OF THEM HAVE HARBORED SOME HIDDEN RAGE 747 00:21:27,987 --> 00:21:28,586 SOME HIDDEN RAGE HER FRIENDS KNEW THAT THE 748 00:21:28,588 --> 00:21:29,186 HER FRIENDS KNEW THAT THE IRREPRESSIBLE NANCY WAS ALSO A 749 00:21:29,188 --> 00:21:35,026 IRREPRESSIBLE NANCY WAS ALSO A WOMAN WHO FELL IN AND OUT OF 750 00:21:35,028 --> 00:21:35,893 WOMAN WHO FELL IN AND OUT OF LOVE OFTEN 751 00:21:35,895 --> 00:21:37,495 LOVE OFTEN >> USUALLY NANCY'S AFFAIRS OR 752 00:21:37,497 --> 00:21:40,431 >> USUALLY NANCY'S AFFAIRS OR ROMANCES DIDN'T LAST A LONG 753 00:21:40,433 --> 00:21:40,798 ROMANCES DIDN'T LAST A LONG TIME 754 00:21:40,800 --> 00:21:41,699 TIME >> Reporter: YEAH. 755 00:21:41,701 --> 00:21:42,233 >> Reporter: YEAH. >> BECAUSE THERE WAS SOME 756 00:21:42,235 --> 00:21:43,234 >> BECAUSE THERE WAS SOME STORIES ABOUT THERE WAS A JILTED 757 00:21:43,236 --> 00:21:45,336 STORIES ABOUT THERE WAS A JILTED LOVER SOMEWHERE, SOMEBODY I 758 00:21:45,338 --> 00:21:46,937 LOVER SOMEWHERE, SOMEBODY I DIDN'T KNOW. 759 00:21:46,939 --> 00:21:47,638 DIDN'T KNOW. SO WHEN I HEARD THAT I THOUGHT, 760 00:21:47,640 --> 00:21:48,539 SO WHEN I HEARD THAT I THOUGHT, YOU KNOW, THERE'S CRAZY PEOPLE 761 00:21:48,541 --> 00:21:49,607 YOU KNOW, THERE'S CRAZY PEOPLE OUT THERE AND I SAID, "LET'S, 762 00:21:49,609 --> 00:21:50,641 OUT THERE AND I SAID, "LET'S, LET'S FOLLOW IT UP 'CAUSE YOU 763 00:21:50,643 --> 00:21:53,244 LET'S FOLLOW IT UP 'CAUSE YOU NEVER KNOW 764 00:21:53,246 --> 00:21:54,345 NEVER KNOW COULD BE, YOU KNOW." 765 00:21:54,347 --> 00:21:55,346 COULD BE, YOU KNOW." >> Reporter: BUT NO. 766 00:21:55,348 --> 00:21:56,447 >> Reporter: BUT NO. NO ACTUAL JILTED LOVERS IN 767 00:21:56,449 --> 00:21:59,650 NO ACTUAL JILTED LOVERS IN NANCY'S PAST, JUST RUMOR AND 768 00:21:59,652 --> 00:22:01,552 NANCY'S PAST, JUST RUMOR AND UNFOUNDED INNUENDO 769 00:22:01,554 --> 00:22:02,853 UNFOUNDED INNUENDO AND BESIDES, AFTER TAKING IN THE 770 00:22:02,855 --> 00:22:03,854 AND BESIDES, AFTER TAKING IN THE BEDROOM CRIME SCENE, THE 771 00:22:03,856 --> 00:22:08,626 BEDROOM CRIME SCENE, THE INVESTIGATORS DECIDED THEY WERE 772 00:22:08,628 --> 00:22:09,327 INVESTIGATORS DECIDED THEY WERE NOT LOOKING FOR A KILLER 773 00:22:09,329 --> 00:22:10,328 NOT LOOKING FOR A KILLER HARD TO DO THAT ALONE, CARRY A 774 00:22:10,330 --> 00:22:14,932 HARD TO DO THAT ALONE, CARRY A BODY AROUND LIKE THAT? 775 00:22:14,934 --> 00:22:15,466 BODY AROUND LIKE THAT? FLIP A QUEEN-SIZE MATTRESS 776 00:22:15,468 --> 00:22:16,467 FLIP A QUEEN-SIZE MATTRESS >> THE MATTRESS IS DOABLE BUT IT 777 00:22:16,469 --> 00:22:18,069 >> THE MATTRESS IS DOABLE BUT IT WOULD BE AWKWARD FOR A SINGLE 778 00:22:18,071 --> 00:22:21,772 WOULD BE AWKWARD FOR A SINGLE PERSON TO FLIP THE MATTRESS ON 779 00:22:21,774 --> 00:22:22,273 PERSON TO FLIP THE MATTRESS ON THEIR OWN. 780 00:22:22,275 --> 00:22:24,975 THEIR OWN. AND THEY USE THE TERM "DEAD 781 00:22:24,977 --> 00:22:25,476 AND THEY USE THE TERM "DEAD WEIGHT" FOR A REASON 782 00:22:25,478 --> 00:22:28,079 WEIGHT" FOR A REASON I MEAN, IT IS AWKWARD AND 783 00:22:28,081 --> 00:22:30,181 I MEAN, IT IS AWKWARD AND DIFFICULT TO MOVE A BODY 784 00:22:30,183 --> 00:22:32,283 DIFFICULT TO MOVE A BODY >> Reporter: BUT IT SEEMED LIKE 785 00:22:32,285 --> 00:22:33,884 >> Reporter: BUT IT SEEMED LIKE A PRETTY CLEAR INDICATION OF 786 00:22:33,886 --> 00:22:35,453 A PRETTY CLEAR INDICATION OF MORE THAN ONE PERSON 787 00:22:35,455 --> 00:22:36,087 MORE THAN ONE PERSON >> YES, THAT WAS OUR CONCLUSION. 788 00:22:36,089 --> 00:22:37,588 >> YES, THAT WAS OUR CONCLUSION. >> Reporter: SOMETHING ELSE -- 789 00:22:37,590 --> 00:22:39,190 >> Reporter: SOMETHING ELSE -- SINCE THERE WAS NO SIGN OF 790 00:22:39,192 --> 00:22:42,360 SINCE THERE WAS NO SIGN OF FORCED ENTRY, HER KILLER, OR 791 00:22:42,362 --> 00:22:44,995 FORCED ENTRY, HER KILLER, OR KILLERS AS THEY NOW BELIEVED, 792 00:22:44,997 --> 00:22:48,499 KILLERS AS THEY NOW BELIEVED, MUST HAVE HAD A HOUSE KEY. 793 00:22:48,501 --> 00:22:48,999 MUST HAVE HAD A HOUSE KEY. NOW, WHO MIGHT THAT BE 794 00:23:07,652 --> 00:23:08,786 >> Reporter: THE INVESTIGATION WAS LITERALLY CLOSER TO HOME, 795 00:23:08,788 --> 00:23:10,688 WAS LITERALLY CLOSER TO HOME, NOW. 796 00:23:10,690 --> 00:23:11,789 NOW. THAT IS TO SAY, THE DETECTIVES 797 00:23:11,791 --> 00:23:12,857 THAT IS TO SAY, THE DETECTIVES INVESTIGATING THE MURDER OF 798 00:23:12,859 --> 00:23:14,091 INVESTIGATING THE MURDER OF NANCY PFISTER BEGAN LOOKING AT 799 00:23:14,093 --> 00:23:14,959 NANCY PFISTER BEGAN LOOKING AT ANYBODY WHO HAD ACCESS WITHOUT 800 00:23:14,961 --> 00:23:18,662 ANYBODY WHO HAD ACCESS WITHOUT PERMISSION TO NANCY'S HOUSE -- 801 00:23:18,664 --> 00:23:19,697 PERMISSION TO NANCY'S HOUSE -- THAT IS, PEOPLE WITH A KEY 802 00:23:19,699 --> 00:23:20,364 THAT IS, PEOPLE WITH A KEY FOR EXAMPLE, THE COUPLE WHO'D 803 00:23:20,366 --> 00:23:22,299 FOR EXAMPLE, THE COUPLE WHO'D BEEN RENTING THE PLACE WHILE 804 00:23:22,301 --> 00:23:23,601 BEEN RENTING THE PLACE WHILE NANCY WAS IN AUSTRALIA 805 00:23:23,603 --> 00:23:24,201 NANCY WAS IN AUSTRALIA DR. WILLIAM "TREY" STYLER, AND 806 00:23:24,203 --> 00:23:25,703 DR. WILLIAM "TREY" STYLER, AND HIS WIFE, ALSO NAMED NANCY, WERE 807 00:23:25,705 --> 00:23:26,270 HIS WIFE, ALSO NAMED NANCY, WERE HARDLY LIKELY SUSPECT -- BUT 808 00:23:26,272 --> 00:23:27,304 HARDLY LIKELY SUSPECT -- BUT THEY HAD TO START SOMEWHERE. 809 00:23:27,306 --> 00:23:28,572 THEY HAD TO START SOMEWHERE. >> MR. STYLER HE'S AN 810 00:23:28,574 --> 00:23:29,173 >> MR. STYLER HE'S AN ANESTHESIOLOGIST, MRS. STYLER 811 00:23:29,175 --> 00:23:37,615 ANESTHESIOLOGIST, MRS. STYLER FROM ALL ACCOUNTS WAS AN 812 00:23:37,617 --> 00:23:38,682 FROM ALL ACCOUNTS WAS AN INTELLIGENT WOMAN HERSELF. 813 00:23:38,684 --> 00:23:39,717 INTELLIGENT WOMAN HERSELF. >> Reporter: TREY AND NANCY MET 814 00:23:39,719 --> 00:23:41,318 >> Reporter: TREY AND NANCY MET IN THE ANESTHESIOLOGY DEPARTMENT 815 00:23:41,320 --> 00:23:42,920 IN THE ANESTHESIOLOGY DEPARTMENT AT A DENVER HOSPITAL -- HE A 816 00:23:42,922 --> 00:23:43,988 AT A DENVER HOSPITAL -- HE A RESIDENT AND SHE AN 817 00:23:43,990 --> 00:23:49,493 RESIDENT AND SHE AN INSTRUCTOR - 818 00:23:49,495 --> 00:23:50,127 INSTRUCTOR - >> I HEARD HIM GO UP TO A WOMAN 819 00:23:50,129 --> 00:23:52,029 >> I HEARD HIM GO UP TO A WOMAN ON A GURNEY AND SAY "HELLO, I'M 820 00:23:52,031 --> 00:23:52,296 ON A GURNEY AND SAY "HELLO, I'M DR. STYLER 821 00:23:52,298 --> 00:23:52,930 DR. STYLER I'LL TAKE CARE OF YOU AS THOUGH 822 00:23:52,932 --> 00:23:55,599 I'LL TAKE CARE OF YOU AS THOUGH I WERE TAKING CARE OF MY MOTHER 823 00:23:55,601 --> 00:23:56,066 I WERE TAKING CARE OF MY MOTHER AND I LOVE MY MOTHER." 824 00:23:56,068 --> 00:23:57,201 AND I LOVE MY MOTHER." >> Reporter: THE GENTLE DOCTOR 825 00:23:57,203 --> 00:23:57,735 >> Reporter: THE GENTLE DOCTOR CHAIRED HIS ANESTHESIOLOGY 826 00:23:57,737 --> 00:24:01,405 CHAIRED HIS ANESTHESIOLOGY DEPARTMENT BY THE TIME HE 827 00:24:01,407 --> 00:24:02,440 DEPARTMENT BY THE TIME HE RETIRED. 828 00:24:02,442 --> 00:24:03,507 RETIRED. THEY LIVED IN AN UPSCALE AREA OF 829 00:24:03,509 --> 00:24:05,643 THEY LIVED IN AN UPSCALE AREA OF DENVER 830 00:24:05,645 --> 00:24:06,610 DENVER THEIR SHARED HOBBY WAS GROWING 831 00:24:06,612 --> 00:24:09,847 THEIR SHARED HOBBY WAS GROWING THE GASP INDUCING GIANT VICTORIA 832 00:24:09,849 --> 00:24:11,949 THE GASP INDUCING GIANT VICTORIA WATER LILY 833 00:24:11,951 --> 00:24:13,017 WATER LILY THEIR UNUSUAL LEVEL OF SUCCESS 834 00:24:13,019 --> 00:24:14,552 THEIR UNUSUAL LEVEL OF SUCCESS AT THAT -- OR SKILL BROUGHT THEM 835 00:24:14,554 --> 00:24:20,424 AT THAT -- OR SKILL BROUGHT THEM WORLD RENOWN WITHIN THE RAREFIED 836 00:24:20,426 --> 00:24:20,991 WORLD RENOWN WITHIN THE RAREFIED WORLD OF SPECIALIZED BOTANY. 837 00:24:20,993 --> 00:24:21,625 WORLD OF SPECIALIZED BOTANY. >> IN FACT THE TWO OF YOU LIVED 838 00:24:21,627 --> 00:24:22,259 >> IN FACT THE TWO OF YOU LIVED KIND OF A CHARMED EXISTENCE FOR 839 00:24:22,261 --> 00:24:24,061 KIND OF A CHARMED EXISTENCE FOR QUITE A WHILE? 840 00:24:24,063 --> 00:24:25,162 QUITE A WHILE? >> WE DID. 841 00:24:25,164 --> 00:24:26,163 >> WE DID. HAD 25 YEARS OF A LIFE THAT I 842 00:24:26,165 --> 00:24:28,332 HAD 25 YEARS OF A LIFE THAT I USED TO SAY I WOULD NEVER TRADE 843 00:24:28,334 --> 00:24:30,468 USED TO SAY I WOULD NEVER TRADE WITH ANYONE. 844 00:24:30,470 --> 00:24:31,469 WITH ANYONE. >> Reporter: BUT RIGHT AROUND 845 00:24:31,471 --> 00:24:32,536 >> Reporter: BUT RIGHT AROUND THE YEAR 2000, IT ALL BEGAN TO 846 00:24:32,538 --> 00:24:33,671 THE YEAR 2000, IT ALL BEGAN TO FALL APART 847 00:24:33,673 --> 00:24:35,172 FALL APART TREY GOT SICK AND HAD TO QUIT 848 00:24:35,174 --> 00:24:36,774 TREY GOT SICK AND HAD TO QUIT PRACTICING MEDICINE. 849 00:24:36,776 --> 00:24:38,442 PRACTICING MEDICINE. HIS ATTEMPT TO START A MEDICAL 850 00:24:38,444 --> 00:24:39,376 HIS ATTEMPT TO START A MEDICAL SUPPORT BUSINESS FAILED. 851 00:24:39,378 --> 00:24:41,479 SUPPORT BUSINESS FAILED. HE SUED HIS MEDICAL GROUP AND 852 00:24:41,481 --> 00:24:42,580 HE SUED HIS MEDICAL GROUP AND LOST 853 00:24:42,582 --> 00:24:48,185 LOST HE SUED THE LAWYER WHO TOOK HIS 854 00:24:48,187 --> 00:24:48,886 HE SUED THE LAWYER WHO TOOK HIS LIFE SAVINGS --AND GOT NOTHING 855 00:24:48,888 --> 00:24:49,954 LIFE SAVINGS --AND GOT NOTHING HE HAD TO SELL HIS HOUSE 856 00:24:49,956 --> 00:24:52,590 HE HAD TO SELL HIS HOUSE HE MOVED WITH NANCY INTO A 857 00:24:52,592 --> 00:24:53,090 HE MOVED WITH NANCY INTO A RENTAL, WHERE THEY WERE 858 00:24:53,092 --> 00:24:54,124 RENTAL, WHERE THEY WERE POISONED -- SAID NANCY AND VERY 859 00:24:54,126 --> 00:24:55,793 POISONED -- SAID NANCY AND VERY NEARLY FATALLY -- BY CARBON 860 00:24:55,795 --> 00:24:56,861 NEARLY FATALLY -- BY CARBON MONOXIDE 861 00:24:56,863 --> 00:25:00,564 MONOXIDE AGAIN THEY TRIED TO SUE BUT WERE 862 00:25:00,566 --> 00:25:02,099 AGAIN THEY TRIED TO SUE BUT WERE TOO BROKE TO HIRE AN ATTORNEY. 863 00:25:02,101 --> 00:25:03,701 TOO BROKE TO HIRE AN ATTORNEY. >> AND HE WAS BESIDE HIMSELF 864 00:25:03,703 --> 00:25:04,768 >> AND HE WAS BESIDE HIMSELF SUICIDAL, JUST, YOU KNOW, "I 865 00:25:04,770 --> 00:25:06,303 SUICIDAL, JUST, YOU KNOW, "I CAN'T BELIEVE WHAT I DID TO THE 866 00:25:06,305 --> 00:25:07,404 CAN'T BELIEVE WHAT I DID TO THE FAMILY, LOSING ALL THIS INCOME," 867 00:25:07,406 --> 00:25:16,313 FAMILY, LOSING ALL THIS INCOME," AND, AND I SAID, YOU KNOW, "WE 868 00:25:16,315 --> 00:25:17,515 AND, AND I SAID, YOU KNOW, "WE CAN DO THIS. 869 00:25:17,517 --> 00:25:20,017 CAN DO THIS. AND SO I THOUGHT OF ASPEN, THAT 870 00:25:20,019 --> 00:25:20,584 AND SO I THOUGHT OF ASPEN, THAT WE LOVED ASPEN 871 00:25:20,586 --> 00:25:21,118 WE LOVED ASPEN >> Reporter: ASPEN 872 00:25:21,120 --> 00:25:24,288 >> Reporter: ASPEN FRESH MOUNTAIN AIR, A FRESH 873 00:25:24,290 --> 00:25:24,822 FRESH MOUNTAIN AIR, A FRESH START. 874 00:25:24,824 --> 00:25:27,424 START. THEY COULD OPEN A SPA, THEY 875 00:25:27,426 --> 00:25:27,925 THEY COULD OPEN A SPA, THEY DECIDED. 876 00:25:27,927 --> 00:25:29,026 DECIDED. AND THAT'S WHEN NANCY STYLER 877 00:25:29,028 --> 00:25:30,628 AND THAT'S WHEN NANCY STYLER PICKED UP THE PHONE TO ANSWER 878 00:25:30,630 --> 00:25:31,228 PICKED UP THE PHONE TO ANSWER ANOTHER NANCY'S REAL ESTATE AD 879 00:25:31,230 --> 00:25:34,331 ANOTHER NANCY'S REAL ESTATE AD IN THE LOCAL NEWSPAPER 880 00:25:34,333 --> 00:25:35,332 IN THE LOCAL NEWSPAPER NANCY PFISTER'S AD 881 00:25:35,334 --> 00:25:36,000 NANCY PFISTER'S AD >> SHE SAID, "OH, EXCUSE ME, I 882 00:25:36,002 --> 00:25:38,736 >> SHE SAID, "OH, EXCUSE ME, I WAS JUST WATERING MY 883 00:25:38,738 --> 00:25:39,036 WAS JUST WATERING MY GREENHOUSE." 884 00:25:39,038 --> 00:25:42,239 GREENHOUSE." I SAID, YOU KNOW, "I WOULD LOVE 885 00:25:42,241 --> 00:25:42,706 I SAID, YOU KNOW, "I WOULD LOVE TO HAVE A GREENHOUSE." 886 00:25:42,708 --> 00:25:47,511 TO HAVE A GREENHOUSE." AND SO WE WENT UP THERE AND IT 887 00:25:47,513 --> 00:25:48,045 AND SO WE WENT UP THERE AND IT JUST SEEMED PERFECT. 888 00:25:48,047 --> 00:25:49,046 JUST SEEMED PERFECT. >> Reporter: IT SEEMED PERFECT 889 00:25:49,048 --> 00:25:50,014 >> Reporter: IT SEEMED PERFECT TO NANCY PFISTER TOO 890 00:25:50,016 --> 00:25:52,249 TO NANCY PFISTER TOO HER SHARE OF THE FAMILY FORTUNE 891 00:25:52,251 --> 00:25:55,452 HER SHARE OF THE FAMILY FORTUNE WAS DOLED OUT IN REGULAR BUT 892 00:25:55,454 --> 00:25:57,054 WAS DOLED OUT IN REGULAR BUT LIMITED ALLOWANCES AND BY 893 00:25:57,056 --> 00:25:57,688 LIMITED ALLOWANCES AND BY RENTING HER MULTI-MILLION DOLLAR 894 00:25:57,690 --> 00:25:58,289 RENTING HER MULTI-MILLION DOLLAR HOUSE WITH THE BILLION DOLLAR 895 00:25:58,291 --> 00:25:59,156 HOUSE WITH THE BILLION DOLLAR VIEWS -- SHE WOULD HAVE EXTRA 896 00:25:59,158 --> 00:26:01,759 VIEWS -- SHE WOULD HAVE EXTRA CASH FOR HER UPCOMING TRIP TO 897 00:26:01,761 --> 00:26:02,860 CASH FOR HER UPCOMING TRIP TO AUSTRALIA. 898 00:26:02,862 --> 00:26:04,228 AUSTRALIA. SO -- NO FORMAL LEASE --JUST A 899 00:26:04,230 --> 00:26:06,564 SO -- NO FORMAL LEASE --JUST A HANDSHAKE -- THE RENT WAS $4,000 900 00:26:06,566 --> 00:26:07,064 HANDSHAKE -- THE RENT WAS $4,000 A MONTH. 901 00:26:07,066 --> 00:26:10,267 A MONTH. >> IT WAS A LOT OF MONEY BUT NOT 902 00:26:10,269 --> 00:26:10,768 >> IT WAS A LOT OF MONEY BUT NOT FOR ASPEN. 903 00:26:10,770 --> 00:26:12,269 FOR ASPEN. >> Reporter: NANCY ASKED HER 904 00:26:12,271 --> 00:26:12,870 >> Reporter: NANCY ASKED HER GOOD FRIEND KATHY TO HELP THE 905 00:26:12,872 --> 00:26:13,938 GOOD FRIEND KATHY TO HELP THE RENTERS TAKE CARE OF HER DOG 906 00:26:13,940 --> 00:26:15,539 RENTERS TAKE CARE OF HER DOG WHILE SHE WAS AWAY, COLLECT THE 907 00:26:15,541 --> 00:26:18,475 WHILE SHE WAS AWAY, COLLECT THE RENT, AND BE HER GENERAL GO 908 00:26:18,477 --> 00:26:18,709 RENT, AND BE HER GENERAL GO BETWEEN. 909 00:26:18,711 --> 00:26:21,345 BETWEEN. >> SHE REALLY LIKED THESE 910 00:26:21,347 --> 00:26:22,379 >> SHE REALLY LIKED THESE PEOPLE 911 00:26:22,381 --> 00:26:26,784 PEOPLE SHE SAID THAT UM, SHE FELT THAT 912 00:26:26,786 --> 00:26:27,351 SHE SAID THAT UM, SHE FELT THAT THEY HAD REALLY GREAT KARMA. 913 00:26:27,353 --> 00:26:27,985 THEY HAD REALLY GREAT KARMA. >> Reporter: AND THAT'S PART OF 914 00:26:27,987 --> 00:26:28,619 >> Reporter: AND THAT'S PART OF THE REASON WHY SHE INVITED THEM 915 00:26:28,621 --> 00:26:31,355 THE REASON WHY SHE INVITED THEM TO MOVE IN A FULL MONTH BEFORE 916 00:26:31,357 --> 00:26:32,389 TO MOVE IN A FULL MONTH BEFORE SHE LEFT 917 00:26:32,391 --> 00:26:33,991 SHE LEFT BUT IT WASN'T LONG BEFORE THE 918 00:26:33,993 --> 00:26:36,093 BUT IT WASN'T LONG BEFORE THE STYLERS DISCOVERED THAT LIVING 919 00:26:36,095 --> 00:26:37,695 STYLERS DISCOVERED THAT LIVING WITH NANCY PFISTER WAS NOT QUITE 920 00:26:37,697 --> 00:26:38,762 WITH NANCY PFISTER WAS NOT QUITE LIKE THEY THOUGHT IT MIGHT BE. 921 00:26:38,764 --> 00:26:39,330 LIKE THEY THOUGHT IT MIGHT BE. >> AFTER THE FIRST COUPLE OF 922 00:26:39,332 --> 00:26:43,500 >> AFTER THE FIRST COUPLE OF DAYS SHE TREATED ME LIKE A 923 00:26:43,502 --> 00:26:44,001 DAYS SHE TREATED ME LIKE A SLAVE. 924 00:26:44,003 --> 00:26:45,102 SLAVE. LIKE, "GET MY CIGARETTES 925 00:26:45,104 --> 00:26:46,103 LIKE, "GET MY CIGARETTES GET THIS 926 00:26:46,105 --> 00:26:47,204 GET THIS GET MY DRINK." 927 00:26:47,206 --> 00:26:51,909 GET MY DRINK." AND I WAS NOT USED TO BEING SO 928 00:26:51,911 --> 00:26:52,476 AND I WAS NOT USED TO BEING SO DISRESPECTED 929 00:26:52,478 --> 00:26:53,043 DISRESPECTED >> Reporter: TREATED LIKE A 930 00:26:53,045 --> 00:26:54,011 >> Reporter: TREATED LIKE A SLAVE THOUGH 931 00:26:54,013 --> 00:26:56,480 SLAVE THOUGH I MEAN - 932 00:26:56,482 --> 00:26:57,781 I MEAN - >> A SLAVE 933 00:26:57,783 --> 00:26:58,282 >> A SLAVE IT WAS NOT PRETTY. 934 00:26:58,284 --> 00:27:01,418 IT WAS NOT PRETTY. >> YOU KNOW, I TOLD HER, "THAT 935 00:27:01,420 --> 00:27:02,519 >> YOU KNOW, I TOLD HER, "THAT IS HOW NANCY IS. 936 00:27:02,521 --> 00:27:03,520 IS HOW NANCY IS. DON'T TAKE IT PERSONAL 937 00:27:03,522 --> 00:27:05,122 DON'T TAKE IT PERSONAL SHE COMES OFF THIS WAY AND THAT, 938 00:27:05,124 --> 00:27:05,723 SHE COMES OFF THIS WAY AND THAT, YOU KNOW 939 00:27:05,725 --> 00:27:08,325 YOU KNOW SHE, SHE REALLY HAS A GOOD 940 00:27:08,327 --> 00:27:10,427 SHE, SHE REALLY HAS A GOOD HEART. 941 00:27:10,429 --> 00:27:11,495 HEART. >> Reporter: ANYWAY, NANCY LEFT 942 00:27:11,497 --> 00:27:12,529 >> Reporter: ANYWAY, NANCY LEFT SOON ENOUGH FOR AUSTRIALIA - 943 00:27:12,531 --> 00:27:13,897 SOON ENOUGH FOR AUSTRIALIA - BUT THEN THE STYLERS DISCOVERED 944 00:27:13,899 --> 00:27:16,734 BUT THEN THE STYLERS DISCOVERED THE HOUSE WASN'T SO PERFECT 945 00:27:16,736 --> 00:27:17,534 THE HOUSE WASN'T SO PERFECT AFTER ALL. 946 00:27:17,536 --> 00:27:19,937 AFTER ALL. >> SO WHEN I WENT TO CLEAN OUT 947 00:27:19,939 --> 00:27:20,571 >> SO WHEN I WENT TO CLEAN OUT THE MASTER BEDROOM AND BATHROOM, 948 00:27:20,573 --> 00:27:21,505 THE MASTER BEDROOM AND BATHROOM, I REALIZED THE HOT WATER WAS 949 00:27:21,507 --> 00:27:24,141 I REALIZED THE HOT WATER WAS RUSTY. 950 00:27:24,143 --> 00:27:26,744 RUSTY. THE DISHWASHER DIDN'T WORK 951 00:27:26,746 --> 00:27:30,547 THE DISHWASHER DIDN'T WORK THE STOVE DIDN'T WORK. 952 00:27:30,549 --> 00:27:31,548 THE STOVE DIDN'T WORK. >> Reporter: ONCE AGAIN, THE 953 00:27:31,550 --> 00:27:32,616 >> Reporter: ONCE AGAIN, THE STYLERS SOUGHT REDRESS 954 00:27:32,618 --> 00:27:34,718 STYLERS SOUGHT REDRESS THEY DECIDED TO WITHHOLD RENT 955 00:27:34,720 --> 00:27:35,319 THEY DECIDED TO WITHHOLD RENT UNTIL THOSE THINGS WERE FIXED. 956 00:27:35,321 --> 00:27:36,320 UNTIL THOSE THINGS WERE FIXED. NANCY PFISTER, HALF A WORLD 957 00:27:36,322 --> 00:27:41,058 NANCY PFISTER, HALF A WORLD AWAY, WAS NOT HAPPY. 958 00:27:41,060 --> 00:27:43,027 AWAY, WAS NOT HAPPY. WHAT'D SHE SAY 959 00:27:43,029 --> 00:27:43,661 WHAT'D SHE SAY >> THAT SHE FELT THAT THESE 960 00:27:43,663 --> 00:27:46,864 >> THAT SHE FELT THAT THESE PEOPLE WERE CONS, SQUATTERS, AND 961 00:27:46,866 --> 00:27:48,098 PEOPLE WERE CONS, SQUATTERS, AND SHE WANTED THEM OUT. 962 00:27:48,100 --> 00:27:48,966 SHE WANTED THEM OUT. >> Reporter: KATHY WAS CAUGHT IN 963 00:27:48,968 --> 00:27:51,068 >> Reporter: KATHY WAS CAUGHT IN THE MIDDLE, SHE ARRANGED THE 964 00:27:51,070 --> 00:27:53,671 THE MIDDLE, SHE ARRANGED THE REPAIRS -- THE STYLERS PAID THE 965 00:27:53,673 --> 00:27:55,272 REPAIRS -- THE STYLERS PAID THE MONEY THEY OWED -- GAVE KATHY 966 00:27:55,274 --> 00:27:56,340 MONEY THEY OWED -- GAVE KATHY $6,000 IN CASH THAT SHE PUT IN A 967 00:27:56,342 --> 00:27:57,374 $6,000 IN CASH THAT SHE PUT IN A SAFE DEPOSIT BOX FOR NANCY 968 00:27:57,376 --> 00:27:59,643 SAFE DEPOSIT BOX FOR NANCY BUT THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN 969 00:27:59,645 --> 00:28:02,146 BUT THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN LANDLORD AND TENANTS HAD SOURED 970 00:28:02,148 --> 00:28:04,248 LANDLORD AND TENANTS HAD SOURED TO THE POINT THAT NO AMOUNT OF 971 00:28:04,250 --> 00:28:05,883 TO THE POINT THAT NO AMOUNT OF KARMA COULD PRESERVE IT. 972 00:28:05,885 --> 00:28:07,384 KARMA COULD PRESERVE IT. >> AND AT THAT POINT NANCY 973 00:28:07,386 --> 00:28:08,986 >> AND AT THAT POINT NANCY STYLER SAID "I DON'T WANNA STAY. 974 00:28:08,988 --> 00:28:10,087 STYLER SAID "I DON'T WANNA STAY. WE WILL BE OUT FEBRUARY 22ND." 975 00:28:10,089 --> 00:28:13,791 WE WILL BE OUT FEBRUARY 22ND." >> Reporter: HOW DID NANCY 976 00:28:13,793 --> 00:28:14,825 >> Reporter: HOW DID NANCY PFISTER FEEL ABOUT THAT? 977 00:28:14,827 --> 00:28:16,960 PFISTER FEEL ABOUT THAT? >> SHE WAS FINE WITH IT. 978 00:28:16,962 --> 00:28:18,495 >> SHE WAS FINE WITH IT. SHE WANTED THEM OUT. 979 00:28:18,497 --> 00:28:20,097 SHE WANTED THEM OUT. >> Reporter: UNABLE TO FIND NEW 980 00:28:20,099 --> 00:28:22,199 >> Reporter: UNABLE TO FIND NEW TENANTS NOW, NANCY PFISTER WAS 981 00:28:22,201 --> 00:28:24,301 TENANTS NOW, NANCY PFISTER WAS FACED WITH DOING EXACTLY WHAT 982 00:28:24,303 --> 00:28:25,903 FACED WITH DOING EXACTLY WHAT SHE HOPED TO AVOID WHEN SHE WENT 983 00:28:25,905 --> 00:28:29,106 SHE HOPED TO AVOID WHEN SHE WENT TO AUSTRALIA -- SPENDING PEAK 984 00:28:29,108 --> 00:28:30,107 TO AUSTRALIA -- SPENDING PEAK SKI SEASON IN ASPEN. 985 00:28:30,109 --> 00:28:31,709 SKI SEASON IN ASPEN. SHE GOT HOME FEBRUARY 22ND 986 00:28:31,711 --> 00:28:32,309 SHE GOT HOME FEBRUARY 22ND THE VERY DAY THE STYLERS SAID 987 00:28:32,311 --> 00:28:33,811 THE VERY DAY THE STYLERS SAID THEY'D BE DONE MOVING THEIR 988 00:28:33,813 --> 00:28:35,412 THEY'D BE DONE MOVING THEIR STUFF OUT. 989 00:28:35,414 --> 00:28:39,083 STUFF OUT. THE PROBLEM WAS, THEY WEREN'T. 990 00:28:39,085 --> 00:28:40,117 THE PROBLEM WAS, THEY WEREN'T. >> SHE WAS NOT HAPPY 991 00:28:40,119 --> 00:28:43,320 >> SHE WAS NOT HAPPY YOU KNOW, SHE HAD A FEW CHOICE 992 00:28:43,322 --> 00:28:43,854 YOU KNOW, SHE HAD A FEW CHOICE WORDS, BUT SHE ACCEPTED IT 993 00:28:43,856 --> 00:28:44,888 WORDS, BUT SHE ACCEPTED IT SHE WAS TIRED, JET LAG 994 00:28:44,890 --> 00:28:45,456 SHE WAS TIRED, JET LAG >> Reporter: YEAH. 995 00:28:45,458 --> 00:28:47,524 >> Reporter: YEAH. >> SHE WANTED TO COME HOME, SEE 996 00:28:47,526 --> 00:28:49,326 >> SHE WANTED TO COME HOME, SEE HER DOG. 997 00:28:49,328 --> 00:28:49,927 HER DOG. >> Reporter: THE STYLERS ENDED 998 00:28:49,929 --> 00:28:52,830 >> Reporter: THE STYLERS ENDED UP IN A MOTEL IN BASALT -- ABOUT 999 00:28:52,832 --> 00:28:53,897 UP IN A MOTEL IN BASALT -- ABOUT 25 MINUTES AWAY. 1000 00:28:53,899 --> 00:28:54,598 25 MINUTES AWAY. THEY STOPPED BY THE HOUSE AGAIN 1001 00:28:54,600 --> 00:28:55,199 THEY STOPPED BY THE HOUSE AGAIN A FEW TIMES DURING THE WEEK TO 1002 00:28:55,201 --> 00:28:58,635 A FEW TIMES DURING THE WEEK TO GET THEIR THINGS -- SAW THE DOG 1003 00:28:58,637 --> 00:28:59,136 GET THEIR THINGS -- SAW THE DOG BUT NOT NANCY. 1004 00:28:59,138 --> 00:28:59,803 BUT NOT NANCY. AND MADE THAT FIRST, ALARMING 1005 00:28:59,805 --> 00:29:03,407 AND MADE THAT FIRST, ALARMING CALL TO KATHY THAT SOMETHING 1006 00:29:03,409 --> 00:29:04,441 CALL TO KATHY THAT SOMETHING SEEMED WRONG 1007 00:29:04,443 --> 00:29:05,509 SEEMED WRONG AND WHEN KATHY FOUND THE BODY, 1008 00:29:05,511 --> 00:29:06,710 AND WHEN KATHY FOUND THE BODY, KNOWING BETTER THAN ANYONE ABOUT 1009 00:29:06,712 --> 00:29:08,145 KNOWING BETTER THAN ANYONE ABOUT THE TENSION BETWEEN THE STYLERS 1010 00:29:08,147 --> 00:29:13,050 THE TENSION BETWEEN THE STYLERS AND NANCY PFISTER, SHE MADE SURE 1011 00:29:13,052 --> 00:29:13,951 AND NANCY PFISTER, SHE MADE SURE TO CLUE IN INVESTIGATORS 1012 00:29:13,953 --> 00:29:16,053 TO CLUE IN INVESTIGATORS >> SHE HAD SOME PEOPLE LIVING 1013 00:29:16,055 --> 00:29:17,654 >> SHE HAD SOME PEOPLE LIVING THERE, SHE REALLY PISSED THEM 1014 00:29:17,656 --> 00:29:20,257 THERE, SHE REALLY PISSED THEM OFF. 1015 00:29:20,259 --> 00:29:24,228 OFF. AND, UM, SHE MADE THREATS TO 1016 00:29:24,230 --> 00:29:24,962 AND, UM, SHE MADE THREATS TO THEM ABOUT OWING MONEY 1017 00:29:24,964 --> 00:29:26,563 THEM ABOUT OWING MONEY >> Reporter: SO -- TIME FOR 1018 00:29:26,565 --> 00:29:27,664 >> Reporter: SO -- TIME FOR INVESTIGATORS TO VISIT THAT 1019 00:29:27,666 --> 00:29:29,233 INVESTIGATORS TO VISIT THAT MOTEL -- AND MEET THE STYLERS. 1020 00:29:29,235 --> 00:29:30,267 MOTEL -- AND MEET THE STYLERS. >> COMING UP 1021 00:29:30,269 --> 00:29:32,936 >> COMING UP >> I SAID, "I HAVEN'T DONE 1022 00:29:32,938 --> 00:29:33,971 >> I SAID, "I HAVEN'T DONE ANYTHING WRONG." 1023 00:29:33,973 --> 00:29:37,174 ANYTHING WRONG." >> FROM MOTEL ROOM -- TO 1024 00:29:37,176 --> 00:29:38,175 >> FROM MOTEL ROOM -- TO INTERROGATION ROOM 1025 00:29:38,177 --> 00:29:38,776 INTERROGATION ROOM INVESTIGATORS WERE FISHING 1026 00:29:38,778 --> 00:29:58,362 INVESTIGATORS WERE FISHING >> YOU DID THIS, MAN 1027 00:29:58,364 --> 00:30:00,430 >> YOU DID THIS, MAN >> Reporter: BASALT, COLORADO IS 1028 00:30:00,432 --> 00:30:03,066 >> Reporter: BASALT, COLORADO IS JUST DOWN THE HIGHWAY FROM 1029 00:30:03,068 --> 00:30:03,600 JUST DOWN THE HIGHWAY FROM ASPEN. 1030 00:30:03,602 --> 00:30:04,234 ASPEN. YOU CAN SEE THE SAME MOUNTAINS, 1031 00:30:04,236 --> 00:30:07,838 YOU CAN SEE THE SAME MOUNTAINS, BREATHE THE SAME AIR 1032 00:30:07,840 --> 00:30:08,438 BREATHE THE SAME AIR BUT WHEN TREY AND NANCY STYLER 1033 00:30:08,440 --> 00:30:09,039 BUT WHEN TREY AND NANCY STYLER CHECKED INTO THEIR MOTEL THEY 1034 00:30:09,041 --> 00:30:11,508 CHECKED INTO THEIR MOTEL THEY WERE ENTERING A WORLD FAR 1035 00:30:11,510 --> 00:30:12,576 WERE ENTERING A WORLD FAR BENEATH THE RARIFIED HEIGHTS OF 1036 00:30:12,578 --> 00:30:15,212 BENEATH THE RARIFIED HEIGHTS OF NANCY PFISTER'S MOUNTAINSIDE 1037 00:30:15,214 --> 00:30:17,314 NANCY PFISTER'S MOUNTAINSIDE RETREAT. 1038 00:30:17,316 --> 00:30:18,882 RETREAT. NO BILLIONAIRE STARTER CASTLES 1039 00:30:18,884 --> 00:30:19,950 NO BILLIONAIRE STARTER CASTLES HERE 1040 00:30:19,952 --> 00:30:20,584 HERE THIS IS WHERE MANY OF THE PEOPLE 1041 00:30:20,586 --> 00:30:21,051 THIS IS WHERE MANY OF THE PEOPLE WHO WORK IN ASPEN LIVE 1042 00:30:21,053 --> 00:30:21,652 WHO WORK IN ASPEN LIVE HERE THE STYLERS THOUGHT THEY 1043 00:30:21,654 --> 00:30:22,820 HERE THE STYLERS THOUGHT THEY WERE DONE WITH NANCY PFISTER 1044 00:30:22,822 --> 00:30:24,688 WERE DONE WITH NANCY PFISTER MOVING ON. 1045 00:30:24,690 --> 00:30:27,858 MOVING ON. AND THEN THERE WAS A KNOCK AT 1046 00:30:27,860 --> 00:30:28,926 AND THEN THERE WAS A KNOCK AT THE DOOR 1047 00:30:28,928 --> 00:30:31,028 THE DOOR 5:30 AM. 1048 00:30:31,030 --> 00:30:31,628 5:30 AM. IT WAS SHERIFF'S DEPUTIES. 1049 00:30:31,630 --> 00:30:34,731 IT WAS SHERIFF'S DEPUTIES. THEY HAD QUESTIONS, THEY SAID, 1050 00:30:34,733 --> 00:30:35,265 THEY HAD QUESTIONS, THEY SAID, ABOUT A DEAD BODY. 1051 00:30:35,267 --> 00:30:38,502 ABOUT A DEAD BODY. >> AND I SAID "WHAT DEAD BODY? 1052 00:30:38,504 --> 00:30:40,037 >> AND I SAID "WHAT DEAD BODY? AND HE WOULDN'T TELL ME. 1053 00:30:40,039 --> 00:30:43,707 AND HE WOULDN'T TELL ME. "WHO DIED? 1054 00:30:43,709 --> 00:30:44,675 "WHO DIED? WOULDN'T SAY A WORD. 1055 00:30:44,677 --> 00:30:45,209 WOULDN'T SAY A WORD. >> Reporter: THE DEPUTIES 1056 00:30:45,211 --> 00:30:45,843 >> Reporter: THE DEPUTIES ESCORTED THEM TO THE BACK SEATS 1057 00:30:45,845 --> 00:30:46,476 ESCORTED THEM TO THE BACK SEATS OF SEPARATE CARS, BUT SAID NOT A 1058 00:30:46,478 --> 00:30:47,945 OF SEPARATE CARS, BUT SAID NOT A WORD AS THEY DROVE DOWN TO THE 1059 00:30:47,947 --> 00:30:48,478 WORD AS THEY DROVE DOWN TO THE STATION. 1060 00:30:48,480 --> 00:30:52,349 STATION. NANCY LISTENED TO THE CHATTER ON 1061 00:30:52,351 --> 00:30:52,716 NANCY LISTENED TO THE CHATTER ON THE RADIO. 1062 00:30:52,718 --> 00:30:56,420 THE RADIO. >> I HEARD HER SISTERS' NAMES 1063 00:30:56,422 --> 00:30:59,056 >> I HEARD HER SISTERS' NAMES BEING MENTIONED ON THE POLICE 1064 00:30:59,058 --> 00:31:00,624 BEING MENTIONED ON THE POLICE RADIO, NANCY'S SISTERS' NAMES. 1065 00:31:00,626 --> 00:31:02,226 RADIO, NANCY'S SISTERS' NAMES. AND I THOUGHT, "WELL, IT MUST BE 1066 00:31:02,228 --> 00:31:03,227 AND I THOUGHT, "WELL, IT MUST BE SOMETHING TO DO WITH NANCY." 1067 00:31:03,229 --> 00:31:05,362 SOMETHING TO DO WITH NANCY." >> Reporter: AT THE PITKIN 1068 00:31:05,364 --> 00:31:06,430 >> Reporter: AT THE PITKIN COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE, 1069 00:31:06,432 --> 00:31:07,731 COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE, DEPUTIES PUT NANCY AND TREY IN 1070 00:31:07,733 --> 00:31:09,099 DEPUTIES PUT NANCY AND TREY IN DIFFERENT INTERVIEW ROOMS. 1071 00:31:09,101 --> 00:31:13,871 DIFFERENT INTERVIEW ROOMS. >> AND HE HAD READ ME MY MIRANDA 1072 00:31:13,873 --> 00:31:17,541 >> AND HE HAD READ ME MY MIRANDA RIGHTS BEFOREHAND, AND I SAID, 1073 00:31:17,543 --> 00:31:18,075 RIGHTS BEFOREHAND, AND I SAID, "I DON'T NEED AN ATTORNEY. 1074 00:31:18,077 --> 00:31:18,609 "I DON'T NEED AN ATTORNEY. I SAID, "I, I HAVEN'T DONE 1075 00:31:18,611 --> 00:31:19,643 I SAID, "I, I HAVEN'T DONE ANYTHING WRONG." 1076 00:31:19,645 --> 00:31:24,548 ANYTHING WRONG." I SAID, "I'LL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER 1077 00:31:24,550 --> 00:31:24,815 I SAID, "I'LL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER QUESTIONS. 1078 00:31:24,817 --> 00:31:27,017 QUESTIONS. >> Reporter: WHICH WERE, AT 1079 00:31:27,019 --> 00:31:27,718 >> Reporter: WHICH WERE, AT LEAST TO BEGIN WITH, PRETTY 1080 00:31:27,720 --> 00:31:28,085 LEAST TO BEGIN WITH, PRETTY BASIC. 1081 00:31:28,087 --> 00:31:28,685 BASIC. >> WHERE DID YOU AND TREY COME 1082 00:31:28,687 --> 00:31:29,119 >> WHERE DID YOU AND TREY COME FROM 1083 00:31:29,121 --> 00:31:29,553 FROM >> WE'RE FROM DENVER 1084 00:31:29,555 --> 00:31:35,959 >> WE'RE FROM DENVER UMM, WE MET AT THE UNIVERSITY OF 1085 00:31:35,961 --> 00:31:44,935 UMM, WE MET AT THE UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO MEDICAL SCHOOL. 1086 00:31:44,937 --> 00:31:48,605 COLORADO MEDICAL SCHOOL. THEY ASKED ME IF I KNEW ANY OF 1087 00:31:48,607 --> 00:31:49,239 THEY ASKED ME IF I KNEW ANY OF THE MEN THAT SHE, YOU KNOW, HAD 1088 00:31:49,241 --> 00:31:51,275 THE MEN THAT SHE, YOU KNOW, HAD DATED, IF I KNEW ANYONE THAT 1089 00:31:51,277 --> 00:31:51,742 DATED, IF I KNEW ANYONE THAT WOULD WANT HER DEAD. 1090 00:31:51,744 --> 00:31:52,376 WOULD WANT HER DEAD. >> Reporter: SHE DIDN'T THINK IT 1091 00:31:52,378 --> 00:31:54,978 >> Reporter: SHE DIDN'T THINK IT WAS THAT SORT OF THING AT ALL, 1092 00:31:54,980 --> 00:31:57,080 WAS THAT SORT OF THING AT ALL, SAID NANCY 1093 00:31:57,082 --> 00:31:59,216 SAID NANCY SHE TOLD THE DETECTIVES SHE WAS 1094 00:31:59,218 --> 00:32:00,284 SHE TOLD THE DETECTIVES SHE WAS PRETTY SURE SHE KNEW EXACTLY 1095 00:32:00,286 --> 00:32:02,386 PRETTY SURE SHE KNEW EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED TO NANCY PFISTER 1096 00:32:02,388 --> 00:32:03,754 WHAT HAPPENED TO NANCY PFISTER >> I SAID, "YOU'RE GONNA FIND 1097 00:32:03,756 --> 00:32:04,988 >> I SAID, "YOU'RE GONNA FIND THE TOX REPORT, YOU'RE GONNA 1098 00:32:04,990 --> 00:32:05,555 THE TOX REPORT, YOU'RE GONNA FIND OUT THAT SHE COMMITTED 1099 00:32:05,557 --> 00:32:06,056 FIND OUT THAT SHE COMMITTED SUICIDE. 1100 00:32:06,058 --> 00:32:07,124 SUICIDE. I WAS ABSOLUTELY SURE THAT 1101 00:32:07,126 --> 00:32:11,328 I WAS ABSOLUTELY SURE THAT THAT'S WHAT HAPPENED 1102 00:32:11,330 --> 00:32:13,463 THAT'S WHAT HAPPENED >> Reporter: BUT OF COURSE 1103 00:32:13,465 --> 00:32:14,097 >> Reporter: BUT OF COURSE INVESTIGATORS KNEW NANCY PFISTER 1104 00:32:14,099 --> 00:32:15,032 INVESTIGATORS KNEW NANCY PFISTER DID NOT COMMIT SUICIDE 1105 00:32:15,034 --> 00:32:15,632 DID NOT COMMIT SUICIDE THEY KNEW SOMEONE BEAT HER TO 1106 00:32:15,634 --> 00:32:16,600 THEY KNEW SOMEONE BEAT HER TO DEATH, ATTACKED HER AS SHE 1107 00:32:16,602 --> 00:32:17,100 DEATH, ATTACKED HER AS SHE SLEPT. 1108 00:32:17,102 --> 00:32:18,135 SLEPT. AND THEY KNEW ALL ABOUT THE 1109 00:32:18,137 --> 00:32:18,769 AND THEY KNEW ALL ABOUT THE RENTAL ARRANGEMENT THAT STARTED 1110 00:32:18,771 --> 00:32:20,070 RENTAL ARRANGEMENT THAT STARTED WELL AND WENT TO HELL. 1111 00:32:20,072 --> 00:32:20,704 WELL AND WENT TO HELL. AND ABOUT THE STYLERS RAPID FALL 1112 00:32:20,706 --> 00:32:21,338 AND ABOUT THE STYLERS RAPID FALL FROM SUCCESS TO RUINATION. 1113 00:32:21,340 --> 00:32:21,972 FROM SUCCESS TO RUINATION. >> THEIR FINANCIAL SITUATION WAS 1114 00:32:21,974 --> 00:32:22,406 >> THEIR FINANCIAL SITUATION WAS DIRE 1115 00:32:22,408 --> 00:32:23,440 DIRE >> Reporter: YEAH. 1116 00:32:23,442 --> 00:32:24,041 >> Reporter: YEAH. >> AND HE WAS TRYIN' TO PAWN A 1117 00:32:24,043 --> 00:32:25,575 >> AND HE WAS TRYIN' TO PAWN A VERY NICE RING 1118 00:32:25,577 --> 00:32:26,209 VERY NICE RING >> Reporter: HE WAS A DESPERATE 1119 00:32:26,211 --> 00:32:26,610 >> Reporter: HE WAS A DESPERATE MAN? 1120 00:32:26,612 --> 00:32:27,244 MAN? >> HE WAS VERY DESPERATE 1121 00:32:27,246 --> 00:32:28,178 >> HE WAS VERY DESPERATE >> Reporter: THEY ALSO KNEW FROM 1122 00:32:28,180 --> 00:32:31,348 >> Reporter: THEY ALSO KNEW FROM KATHY CARPENTER, HOW ANGRY NANCY 1123 00:32:31,350 --> 00:32:31,915 KATHY CARPENTER, HOW ANGRY NANCY STYLER WAS AT NANCY PFISTER. 1124 00:32:31,917 --> 00:32:32,950 STYLER WAS AT NANCY PFISTER. >> WHAT KINDS OF THINGS DID SHE 1125 00:32:32,952 --> 00:32:33,984 >> WHAT KINDS OF THINGS DID SHE SAY? 1126 00:32:33,986 --> 00:32:34,952 SAY? >> JUST THAT "I HATE THAT 1127 00:32:34,954 --> 00:32:36,620 >> JUST THAT "I HATE THAT WOMAN. 1128 00:32:36,622 --> 00:32:38,221 WOMAN. YOU KNOW, NANCY STYLER WAS 1129 00:32:38,223 --> 00:32:39,289 YOU KNOW, NANCY STYLER WAS UPSET. 1130 00:32:39,291 --> 00:32:39,923 UPSET. >> Reporter: "I COULD KILL HER"? 1131 00:32:39,925 --> 00:32:40,857 >> Reporter: "I COULD KILL HER"? >> SHE DID SAY THAT -- 1132 00:32:40,859 --> 00:32:41,925 >> SHE DID SAY THAT -- "OH, I COULD JUST KILL THE 1133 00:32:41,927 --> 00:32:42,960 "OH, I COULD JUST KILL THE WOMAN. 1134 00:32:42,962 --> 00:32:43,560 WOMAN. >> Reporter: DID NANCY STYLER 1135 00:32:43,562 --> 00:32:49,333 >> Reporter: DID NANCY STYLER ADMIT THAT SHE HAD THREATENED 1136 00:32:49,335 --> 00:32:49,833 ADMIT THAT SHE HAD THREATENED NANCY PFISTER? 1137 00:32:49,835 --> 00:32:51,435 NANCY PFISTER? THAT SHE HAD SAID, "YOU KNOW, I, 1138 00:32:51,437 --> 00:32:51,902 THAT SHE HAD SAID, "YOU KNOW, I, I'D LIKE TO KILL HER"? 1139 00:32:51,904 --> 00:32:53,303 I'D LIKE TO KILL HER"? >> SHE WAS I -- I THINK PRETTY 1140 00:32:53,305 --> 00:32:54,604 >> SHE WAS I -- I THINK PRETTY OPEN ABOUT HER FEELINGS FOR 1141 00:32:54,606 --> 00:32:56,173 OPEN ABOUT HER FEELINGS FOR NANCY PFISTER. 1142 00:32:56,175 --> 00:32:57,741 NANCY PFISTER. AND SHE MADE SOME STATEMENTS 1143 00:32:57,743 --> 00:33:00,410 AND SHE MADE SOME STATEMENTS THAT WERE CERTAINLY CONSISTENT 1144 00:33:00,412 --> 00:33:02,546 THAT WERE CERTAINLY CONSISTENT WITH THAT. 1145 00:33:02,548 --> 00:33:03,547 WITH THAT. >> I SAID, YOU KNOW, I WOULD 1146 00:33:03,549 --> 00:33:05,682 >> I SAID, YOU KNOW, I WOULD LIKE TO WRING HER NECK 1147 00:33:05,684 --> 00:33:08,318 LIKE TO WRING HER NECK BECAUSE SHE IS SUCH A, A DRUNK, 1148 00:33:08,320 --> 00:33:09,353 BECAUSE SHE IS SUCH A, A DRUNK, AND MAKING ME SO CRAZY 1149 00:33:09,355 --> 00:33:10,954 AND MAKING ME SO CRAZY >> Reporter: NANCY STYLER'S 1150 00:33:10,956 --> 00:33:12,022 >> Reporter: NANCY STYLER'S PERSONAL OPINION OF NANCY 1151 00:33:12,024 --> 00:33:13,056 PERSONAL OPINION OF NANCY PFISTER HAD SOURED TO SUCH A 1152 00:33:13,058 --> 00:33:14,658 PFISTER HAD SOURED TO SUCH A DEGREE THAT SHE DID NOT HESITATE 1153 00:33:14,660 --> 00:33:19,997 DEGREE THAT SHE DID NOT HESITATE TO SPEAK ILL OF THE DEAD, 1154 00:33:19,999 --> 00:33:20,430 TO SPEAK ILL OF THE DEAD, WHETHER TRUE OR NOT. 1155 00:33:20,432 --> 00:33:22,566 WHETHER TRUE OR NOT. >> THERE'S NOT ONE PERSON WHO 1156 00:33:22,568 --> 00:33:23,133 >> THERE'S NOT ONE PERSON WHO SAID A NICE THING ABOUT HER. 1157 00:33:23,135 --> 00:33:24,668 SAID A NICE THING ABOUT HER. >> UH-HUH. 1158 00:33:24,670 --> 00:33:25,168 >> UH-HUH. >> NOT ONE PERSON. 1159 00:33:25,170 --> 00:33:28,338 >> NOT ONE PERSON. >> Reporter: INVESTIGATORS PUT 1160 00:33:28,340 --> 00:33:28,939 >> Reporter: INVESTIGATORS PUT DR. STYLER IN A SEPARATE ROOM. 1161 00:33:28,941 --> 00:33:29,573 DR. STYLER IN A SEPARATE ROOM. THEY'D PUT HIM IN AN ORANGE JUMP 1162 00:33:29,575 --> 00:33:32,542 THEY'D PUT HIM IN AN ORANGE JUMP SUIT, EVEN THOUGH HE WASN'T 1163 00:33:32,544 --> 00:33:33,076 SUIT, EVEN THOUGH HE WASN'T UNDER ARREST 1164 00:33:33,078 --> 00:33:35,746 UNDER ARREST AND THEY ASKED A FEW SOFTBALL 1165 00:33:35,748 --> 00:33:36,279 AND THEY ASKED A FEW SOFTBALL QUESTIONS. 1166 00:33:36,281 --> 00:33:37,881 QUESTIONS. >> AND DO YOU LIKE WILLIAM OR 1167 00:33:37,883 --> 00:33:38,482 >> AND DO YOU LIKE WILLIAM OR WOULD YOU RATHER HAVE TREY OR? 1168 00:33:38,484 --> 00:33:40,917 WOULD YOU RATHER HAVE TREY OR? >> FRANKLY, I'LL ANSWER TO 1169 00:33:40,919 --> 00:33:41,151 >> FRANKLY, I'LL ANSWER TO ANYTHING 1170 00:33:41,153 --> 00:33:41,785 ANYTHING >> Reporter: BUT IT WASN'T LONG 1171 00:33:41,787 --> 00:33:45,255 >> Reporter: BUT IT WASN'T LONG BEFORE THE TONE CHANGED AND THE 1172 00:33:45,257 --> 00:33:45,789 BEFORE THE TONE CHANGED AND THE ACCUSATIONS BEGAN. 1173 00:33:45,791 --> 00:33:48,425 ACCUSATIONS BEGAN. >> WHY DID YOU GO IN THERE AND 1174 00:33:48,427 --> 00:33:48,959 >> WHY DID YOU GO IN THERE AND HURT NANCY 1175 00:33:48,961 --> 00:33:49,760 HURT NANCY MAYBE YOU DON'T EVEN KNOW BUT I 1176 00:33:49,762 --> 00:33:52,662 MAYBE YOU DON'T EVEN KNOW BUT I KNOW IT'S TRUE 1177 00:33:52,664 --> 00:33:53,697 KNOW IT'S TRUE I KNOW IT'S TRUE 1178 00:33:53,699 --> 00:33:54,197 I KNOW IT'S TRUE >> Reporter: THE SHERIFF 1179 00:33:54,199 --> 00:33:55,298 >> Reporter: THE SHERIFF HIMSELF, A CLOSE FRIEND OF THE 1180 00:33:55,300 --> 00:33:56,900 HIMSELF, A CLOSE FRIEND OF THE LATE NANCY PFISTER - 1181 00:33:56,902 --> 00:33:57,934 LATE NANCY PFISTER - TRIED TO GET TREY STYLER TO 1182 00:33:57,936 --> 00:34:00,070 TRIED TO GET TREY STYLER TO ADMIT THAT IN A DESPERATE RAGE, 1183 00:34:00,072 --> 00:34:01,638 ADMIT THAT IN A DESPERATE RAGE, HE KILLED NANCY. 1184 00:34:01,640 --> 00:34:02,706 HE KILLED NANCY. >> YOU DID THIS, MAN 1185 00:34:02,708 --> 00:34:04,274 >> YOU DID THIS, MAN YOU DID IT 1186 00:34:04,276 --> 00:34:05,342 YOU DID IT AND THE QUICKER YOU START SAYING 1187 00:34:05,344 --> 00:34:07,978 AND THE QUICKER YOU START SAYING THAT, THE BETTER THIS IS GONNA 1188 00:34:07,980 --> 00:34:08,512 THAT, THE BETTER THIS IS GONNA BE 1189 00:34:08,514 --> 00:34:09,579 BE >> Reporter: BUT TREY INSISTED 1190 00:34:09,581 --> 00:34:11,248 >> Reporter: BUT TREY INSISTED THEY WERE GOING AFTER THE WRONG 1191 00:34:11,250 --> 00:34:11,715 THEY WERE GOING AFTER THE WRONG GUY. 1192 00:34:11,717 --> 00:34:12,749 GUY. HE WAS INNOCENT. 1193 00:34:12,751 --> 00:34:15,385 HE WAS INNOCENT. >> HOW CAN YOU KNOW IT'S TRUE 1194 00:34:15,387 --> 00:34:16,453 >> HOW CAN YOU KNOW IT'S TRUE WHEN IT'S NOT TRUE 1195 00:34:16,455 --> 00:34:18,555 WHEN IT'S NOT TRUE >> Reporter: OVER AND OVER, TREY 1196 00:34:18,557 --> 00:34:19,589 >> Reporter: OVER AND OVER, TREY STRESSED AND DEMONSTRATED HOW 1197 00:34:19,591 --> 00:34:21,691 STRESSED AND DEMONSTRATED HOW HIS 65-YEAR-OLD BODY, RAVAGED BY 1198 00:34:21,693 --> 00:34:22,759 HIS 65-YEAR-OLD BODY, RAVAGED BY DISEASE, WAS FAR TOO FRAIL TO 1199 00:34:22,761 --> 00:34:26,096 DISEASE, WAS FAR TOO FRAIL TO HAVE DONE WHAT WAS DONE TO 1200 00:34:26,098 --> 00:34:26,997 HAVE DONE WHAT WAS DONE TO NANCY. 1201 00:34:26,999 --> 00:34:29,599 NANCY. >> AS YOU CAN SEE I'D BE A 1202 00:34:29,601 --> 00:34:31,768 >> AS YOU CAN SEE I'D BE A FORMIDABLE ADVERSARY IN A FIGHT. 1203 00:34:31,770 --> 00:34:33,837 FORMIDABLE ADVERSARY IN A FIGHT. >> Reporter: BUT IT HAD ALREADY 1204 00:34:33,839 --> 00:34:34,871 >> Reporter: BUT IT HAD ALREADY DAWNED ON DETECTIVES 1205 00:34:34,873 --> 00:34:37,541 DAWNED ON DETECTIVES THE MORE TREY CLAIMED TO BE 1206 00:34:37,543 --> 00:34:38,008 THE MORE TREY CLAIMED TO BE PHYSICALLY INCAPABLE - 1207 00:34:38,010 --> 00:34:39,109 PHYSICALLY INCAPABLE - >> MY CONDITION IS SUCH THAT I 1208 00:34:39,111 --> 00:34:41,178 >> MY CONDITION IS SUCH THAT I DON'T THINK THAT I COULD BEAT UP 1209 00:34:41,180 --> 00:34:41,778 DON'T THINK THAT I COULD BEAT UP A KID. 1210 00:34:41,780 --> 00:34:44,414 A KID. >> Reporter: -- THE WORSE IT 1211 00:34:44,416 --> 00:34:46,550 >> Reporter: -- THE WORSE IT LOOKED FOR HIS WIFE. 1212 00:34:46,552 --> 00:34:47,184 LOOKED FOR HIS WIFE. >> WE DEFINITELY HAD TO LOOK AT 1213 00:34:47,186 --> 00:34:49,719 >> WE DEFINITELY HAD TO LOOK AT THE FACT THAT HE HAD ASSISTANCE, 1214 00:34:49,721 --> 00:34:50,253 THE FACT THAT HE HAD ASSISTANCE, POTENTIALLY. 1215 00:34:50,255 --> 00:34:51,721 POTENTIALLY. >> MY WIFE DOES EVERYTHING 1216 00:34:51,723 --> 00:34:57,127 >> MY WIFE DOES EVERYTHING I'M [ BLEEP ] DISABLED 1217 00:34:57,129 --> 00:34:58,195 I'M [ BLEEP ] DISABLED I CAN'T DO [ BLEEP ] 1218 00:34:58,197 --> 00:35:00,297 I CAN'T DO [ BLEEP ] INSISTENT, TOOK A POLYGRAPH. 1219 00:35:00,299 --> 00:35:00,797 INSISTENT, TOOK A POLYGRAPH. MAYBE HE SHOULDN'T HAVE. 1220 00:35:00,799 --> 00:35:02,132 MAYBE HE SHOULDN'T HAVE. >> Reporter: AND HE FAILS HIS 1221 00:35:02,134 --> 00:35:02,399 >> Reporter: AND HE FAILS HIS POLYGRAPH? 1222 00:35:02,401 --> 00:35:05,836 POLYGRAPH? >> YES 1223 00:35:05,838 --> 00:35:08,705 >> YES HE DID FAIL HIS POLYGRAPH. 1224 00:35:08,707 --> 00:35:10,307 HE DID FAIL HIS POLYGRAPH. >> Reporter: YOU'RE SMILING. 1225 00:35:10,309 --> 00:35:11,341 >> Reporter: YOU'RE SMILING. FAILED IT BADLY, OR WHAT 1226 00:35:11,343 --> 00:35:12,409 FAILED IT BADLY, OR WHAT >> MY UNDERSTANDING FROM THE 1227 00:35:12,411 --> 00:35:13,009 >> MY UNDERSTANDING FROM THE POLYGRAPHER THAT RAN THE TEST, 1228 00:35:13,011 --> 00:35:14,511 POLYGRAPHER THAT RAN THE TEST, HE DID FAIL IT BADLY 1229 00:35:14,513 --> 00:35:15,112 HE DID FAIL IT BADLY >> Reporter: NOT ADMISSIBLE IN 1230 00:35:15,114 --> 00:35:18,715 >> Reporter: NOT ADMISSIBLE IN COURT, BUT AN INVESTIGATIVE 1231 00:35:18,717 --> 00:35:19,483 COURT, BUT AN INVESTIGATIVE TOOL, THEY SAY 1232 00:35:19,485 --> 00:35:20,283 TOOL, THEY SAY DIDN'T LOOK GOOD FOR THE 1233 00:35:20,285 --> 00:35:23,487 DIDN'T LOOK GOOD FOR THE STYLERS. 1234 00:35:23,489 --> 00:35:24,187 STYLERS. BUT, DESPERATION AND ANGER DO 1235 00:35:24,189 --> 00:35:25,055 BUT, DESPERATION AND ANGER DO NOT, BY THEMSELVES, A MURDER 1236 00:35:25,057 --> 00:35:26,656 NOT, BY THEMSELVES, A MURDER CASE MAKE. 1237 00:35:26,658 --> 00:35:27,691 CASE MAKE. AND TO MAKE THINGS A LITTLE 1238 00:35:27,693 --> 00:35:28,792 AND TO MAKE THINGS A LITTLE EXTRA DIFFICULT, INVESTIGATORS 1239 00:35:28,794 --> 00:35:29,826 EXTRA DIFFICULT, INVESTIGATORS KNEW THEY COULDN'T COUNT ON DNA 1240 00:35:29,828 --> 00:35:31,962 KNEW THEY COULDN'T COUNT ON DNA AT THE SCENE TO LINK THE STYLERS 1241 00:35:31,964 --> 00:35:32,996 AT THE SCENE TO LINK THE STYLERS TO THE CRIME 1242 00:35:32,998 --> 00:35:33,630 TO THE CRIME >> IT COULD EASILY BE EXPLAINED 1243 00:35:33,632 --> 00:35:34,865 >> IT COULD EASILY BE EXPLAINED BECAUSE OF WHERE THEY WERE 1244 00:35:34,867 --> 00:35:36,166 BECAUSE OF WHERE THEY WERE LIVING 1245 00:35:36,168 --> 00:35:39,836 LIVING THEY WERE STAYING IN THAT 1246 00:35:39,838 --> 00:35:41,238 THEY WERE STAYING IN THAT BEDROOM. 1247 00:35:41,240 --> 00:35:41,671 BEDROOM. >> Reporter: SO THE 1248 00:35:41,673 --> 00:35:42,472 >> Reporter: SO THE INVESTIGATORS DROVE THE STYLERS 1249 00:35:42,474 --> 00:35:43,507 INVESTIGATORS DROVE THE STYLERS BACK TO THEIR MOTEL, AND WENT ON 1250 00:35:43,509 --> 00:35:47,744 BACK TO THEIR MOTEL, AND WENT ON WITH THE HARD WORK OF A MURDER 1251 00:35:47,746 --> 00:35:48,812 WITH THE HARD WORK OF A MURDER INVESTIGATION. 1252 00:35:48,814 --> 00:35:50,914 INVESTIGATION. THEY'D HAVE TO FIND A PIECE OF 1253 00:35:50,916 --> 00:35:51,448 THEY'D HAVE TO FIND A PIECE OF GOOD SOLID EVIDENCE TO TIE 1254 00:35:51,450 --> 00:35:52,449 GOOD SOLID EVIDENCE TO TIE SOMEONE, MAYBE THE STYLERS, TO 1255 00:35:52,451 --> 00:35:53,550 SOMEONE, MAYBE THE STYLERS, TO THE CRIME. 1256 00:35:53,552 --> 00:35:54,551 THE CRIME. DIDN'T LOOK, SO FAR, AS IF SUCH 1257 00:35:54,553 --> 00:35:56,686 DIDN'T LOOK, SO FAR, AS IF SUCH A THING EXISTED. 1258 00:35:56,688 --> 00:35:57,754 A THING EXISTED. AND THEN 1259 00:35:57,756 --> 00:35:58,822 AND THEN >> OCCASIONALLY SOMETHING 1260 00:35:58,824 --> 00:36:00,957 >> OCCASIONALLY SOMETHING FORTUITOUS HAPPENS TO LAW 1261 00:36:00,959 --> 00:36:04,094 FORTUITOUS HAPPENS TO LAW ENFORCEMENT. 1262 00:36:04,096 --> 00:36:04,661 ENFORCEMENT. >> Reporter: HOW'S THAT OLD 1263 00:36:04,663 --> 00:36:05,695 >> Reporter: HOW'S THAT OLD SAYING GO? 1264 00:36:05,697 --> 00:36:07,998 SAYING GO? ONE MAN'S TRASH IS ANOTHER MAN'S 1265 00:36:08,000 --> 00:36:08,198 ONE MAN'S TRASH IS ANOTHER MAN'S TREASURE 1266 00:36:25,416 --> 00:36:26,383 >> Reporter: SOMETHING WAS WRONG WITH THE EQUATION. 1267 00:36:26,385 --> 00:36:26,950 WITH THE EQUATION. DIDN'T ADD UP. 1268 00:36:26,952 --> 00:36:28,018 DIDN'T ADD UP. HERE IN ASPEN, IN THE HOUSE ON 1269 00:36:28,020 --> 00:36:29,052 HERE IN ASPEN, IN THE HOUSE ON BUTTERMILK MOUNTAIN, THE CRIME 1270 00:36:29,054 --> 00:36:30,120 BUTTERMILK MOUNTAIN, THE CRIME SCENE AROUND NANCY PFISTER'S 1271 00:36:30,122 --> 00:36:32,222 SCENE AROUND NANCY PFISTER'S BODY SPOKE, IN A WAY 1272 00:36:32,224 --> 00:36:35,392 BODY SPOKE, IN A WAY IT TOLD A STORY. 1273 00:36:35,394 --> 00:36:35,959 IT TOLD A STORY. AND WHAT IT SAID WAS THAT AT 1274 00:36:35,961 --> 00:36:40,664 AND WHAT IT SAID WAS THAT AT LEAST TWO ABLE BODIED PEOPLE 1275 00:36:40,666 --> 00:36:42,232 LEAST TWO ABLE BODIED PEOPLE COMMITTED THE MURDER 1276 00:36:42,234 --> 00:36:45,502 COMMITTED THE MURDER HOW ELSE WOULD A HEAVY MATTRESS 1277 00:36:45,504 --> 00:36:46,102 HOW ELSE WOULD A HEAVY MATTRESS GET FLIPPED, AND NANCY'S BODY 1278 00:36:46,104 --> 00:36:46,736 GET FLIPPED, AND NANCY'S BODY GET DRAGGED ACROSS THE ROOM AND 1279 00:36:46,738 --> 00:36:47,537 GET DRAGGED ACROSS THE ROOM AND INTO THE CLOSET AND GET PACKAGED 1280 00:36:47,539 --> 00:36:48,071 INTO THE CLOSET AND GET PACKAGED IN BAGS AND WRAPPED UP IN 1281 00:36:48,073 --> 00:36:50,006 IN BAGS AND WRAPPED UP IN BLANKETS 1282 00:36:50,008 --> 00:36:51,241 BLANKETS AND YET, THEIR SUSPECTS, NANCY'S 1283 00:36:51,243 --> 00:36:52,809 AND YET, THEIR SUSPECTS, NANCY'S FORMER TENANTS, WERE NOT ABLE 1284 00:36:52,811 --> 00:36:56,513 FORMER TENANTS, WERE NOT ABLE BODIED SPRING CHICKENS 1285 00:36:56,515 --> 00:36:58,615 BODIED SPRING CHICKENS ANYTHING BUT ATHLETIC. 1286 00:36:58,617 --> 00:37:00,984 ANYTHING BUT ATHLETIC. AND BESIDES, THERE WAS ZERO 1287 00:37:00,986 --> 00:37:03,386 AND BESIDES, THERE WAS ZERO PHYSICAL EVIDENCE THAT WOULD TIE 1288 00:37:03,388 --> 00:37:04,988 PHYSICAL EVIDENCE THAT WOULD TIE EITHER ONE OF THEM TO THE CRIME. 1289 00:37:04,990 --> 00:37:07,090 EITHER ONE OF THEM TO THE CRIME. >> I THINK WE WERE FACED WITH 1290 00:37:07,092 --> 00:37:07,724 >> I THINK WE WERE FACED WITH THE REALITY THAT THIS WAS ALWAYS 1291 00:37:07,726 --> 00:37:12,028 THE REALITY THAT THIS WAS ALWAYS GOING TO BE A CIRCUMSTANTIAL 1292 00:37:12,030 --> 00:37:12,362 GOING TO BE A CIRCUMSTANTIAL CASE 1293 00:37:12,364 --> 00:37:13,430 CASE >> Reporter: SO THAT BEDROOM WAS 1294 00:37:13,432 --> 00:37:15,532 >> Reporter: SO THAT BEDROOM WAS KEEPING ITS SECRETS. 1295 00:37:15,534 --> 00:37:18,168 KEEPING ITS SECRETS. AND MIGHT BE KEEPING THEM STILL, 1296 00:37:18,170 --> 00:37:21,338 AND MIGHT BE KEEPING THEM STILL, EXCEPT FOR ONE TOTAL FLUKE 1297 00:37:21,340 --> 00:37:22,906 EXCEPT FOR ONE TOTAL FLUKE COUPLE OF DAYS LATER 1298 00:37:22,908 --> 00:37:23,974 COUPLE OF DAYS LATER ONE OF THOSE LITTLE GIFTS THAT 1299 00:37:23,976 --> 00:37:27,110 ONE OF THOSE LITTLE GIFTS THAT CHANCE OR FATE OR SOMETHING JUST 1300 00:37:27,112 --> 00:37:28,178 CHANCE OR FATE OR SOMETHING JUST DROPS AT A FRUSTRATED 1301 00:37:28,180 --> 00:37:33,450 DROPS AT A FRUSTRATED INVESTIGATOR'S FEET, ALL TIED UP 1302 00:37:33,452 --> 00:37:34,484 INVESTIGATOR'S FEET, ALL TIED UP WITH A NEAT LITTLE BOW 1303 00:37:34,486 --> 00:37:38,188 WITH A NEAT LITTLE BOW WHAT DO YOU GOT HERE 1304 00:37:38,190 --> 00:37:38,755 WHAT DO YOU GOT HERE THIS IS NOT JUST A STANDARD 1305 00:37:38,757 --> 00:37:42,959 THIS IS NOT JUST A STANDARD TRASH THING. 1306 00:37:42,961 --> 00:37:43,493 TRASH THING. >> NO. 1307 00:37:43,495 --> 00:37:45,061 >> NO. THIS BROKE THE CASE. 1308 00:37:45,063 --> 00:37:45,862 THIS BROKE THE CASE. >> Reporter: HOW WEIRDLY FLUKEY 1309 00:37:45,864 --> 00:37:49,833 >> Reporter: HOW WEIRDLY FLUKEY WAS THIS 1310 00:37:49,835 --> 00:37:50,867 WAS THIS THE TOWN OF BASALT, WHO KNEW, 1311 00:37:50,869 --> 00:37:51,468 THE TOWN OF BASALT, WHO KNEW, HAD A RULE THAT YOU CAN'T PUT 1312 00:37:51,470 --> 00:37:52,469 HAD A RULE THAT YOU CAN'T PUT PERSONAL GARBAGE IN PUBLIC TRASH 1313 00:37:52,471 --> 00:37:56,673 PERSONAL GARBAGE IN PUBLIC TRASH CANS 1314 00:37:56,675 --> 00:37:57,741 CANS AND A CITY WORKER, A LITTLE 1315 00:37:57,743 --> 00:37:59,843 AND A CITY WORKER, A LITTLE EXTRA DILIGENT, HAPPENED TO BE 1316 00:37:59,845 --> 00:38:00,477 EXTRA DILIGENT, HAPPENED TO BE POKING AROUND IN THE TRASH, JUST 1317 00:38:00,479 --> 00:38:01,444 POKING AROUND IN THE TRASH, JUST RANDOMLY CHECKING, FOR ILLEGAL 1318 00:38:01,446 --> 00:38:02,846 RANDOMLY CHECKING, FOR ILLEGAL GARBAGE DISPOSAL 1319 00:38:02,848 --> 00:38:09,352 GARBAGE DISPOSAL TELL ME WHAT THIS GUY DID AND 1320 00:38:09,354 --> 00:38:10,420 TELL ME WHAT THIS GUY DID AND HOW HE CAME ACROSS THIS STUFF. 1321 00:38:10,422 --> 00:38:12,522 HOW HE CAME ACROSS THIS STUFF. >> HE PULLS THE TRASH AND THEN 1322 00:38:12,524 --> 00:38:14,257 >> HE PULLS THE TRASH AND THEN HE GOES TO ANOTHER LOCATION. 1323 00:38:14,259 --> 00:38:15,158 HE GOES TO ANOTHER LOCATION. AND HE WAS GOING TO ACTUALLY 1324 00:38:15,160 --> 00:38:16,192 AND HE WAS GOING TO ACTUALLY CHECK IT TO SEE IF THERE WAS 1325 00:38:16,194 --> 00:38:17,494 CHECK IT TO SEE IF THERE WAS ANY -- IT -- SOMETHING STOOD OUT 1326 00:38:17,496 --> 00:38:17,727 ANY -- IT -- SOMETHING STOOD OUT ABOUT IT 1327 00:38:17,729 --> 00:38:18,328 ABOUT IT >> Reporter: HE ACTUALLY DOES 1328 00:38:18,330 --> 00:38:18,595 >> Reporter: HE ACTUALLY DOES THIS STUFF 1329 00:38:18,597 --> 00:38:18,962 THIS STUFF >> PEOPLE CHECK. 1330 00:38:18,964 --> 00:38:19,929 >> PEOPLE CHECK. >> Reporter: OPENS THE BAG 1331 00:38:19,931 --> 00:38:20,463 >> Reporter: OPENS THE BAG >> YES, AND HE DID 1332 00:38:20,465 --> 00:38:20,997 >> YES, AND HE DID AND THANK GOODNESS HE DID. 1333 00:38:20,999 --> 00:38:21,631 AND THANK GOODNESS HE DID. BECAUSE WHEN HE OPENED THE BAG, 1334 00:38:21,633 --> 00:38:25,201 BECAUSE WHEN HE OPENED THE BAG, HE LOOKS INSIDE AND HE SEES A 1335 00:38:25,203 --> 00:38:27,070 HE LOOKS INSIDE AND HE SEES A PRESCRIPTION PILL BOTTLE 1336 00:38:27,072 --> 00:38:28,371 PRESCRIPTION PILL BOTTLE AND WHAT WAS SPECIAL ABOUT THIS 1337 00:38:28,373 --> 00:38:31,041 AND WHAT WAS SPECIAL ABOUT THIS PRESCRIPTION PILL BOTTLE IS IT 1338 00:38:31,043 --> 00:38:32,475 PRESCRIPTION PILL BOTTLE IS IT HAD NANCY PFISTER'S NAME ON IT 1339 00:38:32,477 --> 00:38:33,109 HAD NANCY PFISTER'S NAME ON IT >> Reporter: OF COURSE THE CITY 1340 00:38:33,111 --> 00:38:34,144 >> Reporter: OF COURSE THE CITY WORKER RECOGNIZED THE NAME, 1341 00:38:34,146 --> 00:38:35,245 WORKER RECOGNIZED THE NAME, ASPEN, AND THE TOWNS AROUND IT 1342 00:38:35,247 --> 00:38:38,415 ASPEN, AND THE TOWNS AROUND IT WERE BUZZING WITH THE NEWS ABOUT 1343 00:38:38,417 --> 00:38:39,416 WERE BUZZING WITH THE NEWS ABOUT NANCY PFISTER'S MURDER 1344 00:38:39,418 --> 00:38:40,784 NANCY PFISTER'S MURDER IN ADDITION TO THAT PILL BOTTLE, 1345 00:38:40,786 --> 00:38:41,551 IN ADDITION TO THAT PILL BOTTLE, AFTER WHICH HE PHONED THE 1346 00:38:41,553 --> 00:38:42,152 AFTER WHICH HE PHONED THE POLICE, WHAT DID YOU GUYS FIND 1347 00:38:42,154 --> 00:38:43,687 POLICE, WHAT DID YOU GUYS FIND IN THAT BAG? 1348 00:38:43,689 --> 00:38:45,255 IN THAT BAG? >> WELL IN ADDITION TO THE PILL 1349 00:38:45,257 --> 00:38:49,993 >> WELL IN ADDITION TO THE PILL BOTTLE, THE BIG ONE WAS A 1350 00:38:49,995 --> 00:38:52,095 BOTTLE, THE BIG ONE WAS A HAMMER 1351 00:38:52,097 --> 00:38:52,629 HAMMER A BLOODY HAMMER. 1352 00:38:52,631 --> 00:38:53,663 A BLOODY HAMMER. >> Reporter: A BLOODY HAMMER 1353 00:38:53,665 --> 00:38:54,197 >> Reporter: A BLOODY HAMMER FOUND IN THE SAME TRASH AS 1354 00:38:54,199 --> 00:39:00,537 FOUND IN THE SAME TRASH AS MEDICATION BELONGING TO NANCY 1355 00:39:00,539 --> 00:39:01,071 MEDICATION BELONGING TO NANCY PFISTER? 1356 00:39:01,073 --> 00:39:01,604 PFISTER? THAT SIMPLY COULDN'T BE A 1357 00:39:01,606 --> 00:39:02,305 THAT SIMPLY COULDN'T BE A COINCIDENCE. 1358 00:39:02,307 --> 00:39:02,872 COINCIDENCE. POLICE WERE 99% SURE THEY'D 1359 00:39:02,874 --> 00:39:03,473 POLICE WERE 99% SURE THEY'D STUMBLED ON THE MURDER WEAPON. 1360 00:39:03,475 --> 00:39:04,074 STUMBLED ON THE MURDER WEAPON. THEY SENT IT OFF TO THE CRIME 1361 00:39:04,076 --> 00:39:05,775 THEY SENT IT OFF TO THE CRIME LAB TO BE TESTED, ASAP 1362 00:39:05,777 --> 00:39:06,810 LAB TO BE TESTED, ASAP BUT THE TRASH BAG WASN'T DONE 1363 00:39:06,812 --> 00:39:09,479 BUT THE TRASH BAG WASN'T DONE DIVULGING ITS INVESTIGATIVE 1364 00:39:09,481 --> 00:39:10,013 DIVULGING ITS INVESTIGATIVE GIFTS. 1365 00:39:10,015 --> 00:39:13,350 GIFTS. >> ANOTHER THING THAT WE FOUND 1366 00:39:13,352 --> 00:39:14,217 >> ANOTHER THING THAT WE FOUND THAT WAS CONCERNING TO US WAS 1367 00:39:14,219 --> 00:39:15,785 THAT WAS CONCERNING TO US WAS THE VEHICLE REGISTRATION FOR 1368 00:39:15,787 --> 00:39:19,456 THE VEHICLE REGISTRATION FOR WILLIAM AND NANCY STYLER'S 1369 00:39:19,458 --> 00:39:21,024 WILLIAM AND NANCY STYLER'S JAGUAR 1370 00:39:21,026 --> 00:39:25,795 JAGUAR >> Reporter: WHAT'S MORE, THE 1371 00:39:25,797 --> 00:39:26,329 >> Reporter: WHAT'S MORE, THE TRASH BIN WAS LOCATED JUST 1372 00:39:26,331 --> 00:39:26,863 TRASH BIN WAS LOCATED JUST BEHIND THE MOTEL WHERE THE 1373 00:39:26,865 --> 00:39:27,464 BEHIND THE MOTEL WHERE THE STYLERS WERE STAYING, AND THAT 1374 00:39:27,466 --> 00:39:28,565 STYLERS WERE STAYING, AND THAT WAS MILES AND MILES AWAY FROM 1375 00:39:28,567 --> 00:39:30,567 WAS MILES AND MILES AWAY FROM NANCY PFISTER'S HOUSE. 1376 00:39:30,569 --> 00:39:36,906 NANCY PFISTER'S HOUSE. AGAIN, AS WE SAY, A LITTLE GIFT. 1377 00:39:36,908 --> 00:39:37,540 AGAIN, AS WE SAY, A LITTLE GIFT. ACTUALLY, A BIG FAT JUICY GIFT, 1378 00:39:37,542 --> 00:39:38,174 ACTUALLY, A BIG FAT JUICY GIFT, DROPPED RIGHT INTO INVESTIGATORS 1379 00:39:38,176 --> 00:39:38,441 DROPPED RIGHT INTO INVESTIGATORS LAPS 1380 00:39:38,443 --> 00:39:43,346 LAPS AND IT, NO QUESTION, LINKED THE 1381 00:39:43,348 --> 00:39:43,780 AND IT, NO QUESTION, LINKED THE STYLERS TO THE CRIME 1382 00:39:43,782 --> 00:39:46,883 STYLERS TO THE CRIME I CANNOT THINK OF ANY OTHER 1383 00:39:46,885 --> 00:39:47,584 I CANNOT THINK OF ANY OTHER TIME, IN ANY OTHER CASE I'VE 1384 00:39:47,586 --> 00:39:48,151 TIME, IN ANY OTHER CASE I'VE EVER HEARD ABOUT WHERE SUCH 1385 00:39:48,153 --> 00:39:51,421 EVER HEARD ABOUT WHERE SUCH OBVIOUS EVIDENCE IS JUST KIND OF 1386 00:39:51,423 --> 00:39:52,155 OBVIOUS EVIDENCE IS JUST KIND OF THERE. 1387 00:39:52,157 --> 00:39:52,756 THERE. >> THROWN OUT SO CARELESSLY SO 1388 00:39:52,758 --> 00:39:53,323 >> THROWN OUT SO CARELESSLY SO CLOSE TO WHERE SUSPECTS ARE 1389 00:39:53,325 --> 00:39:59,028 CLOSE TO WHERE SUSPECTS ARE STAYING? 1390 00:39:59,030 --> 00:39:59,562 STAYING? YEAH 1391 00:39:59,564 --> 00:40:00,163 YEAH >> Reporter: DEPUTIES HOVERED 1392 00:40:00,165 --> 00:40:01,164 >> Reporter: DEPUTIES HOVERED ROUND THE MOTEL TO KEEP AN EYE 1393 00:40:01,166 --> 00:40:01,798 ROUND THE MOTEL TO KEEP AN EYE ON THE STYLERS TO MAKE SURE THEY 1394 00:40:01,800 --> 00:40:03,266 ON THE STYLERS TO MAKE SURE THEY DIDN'T DO A DISAPPEARING ACT, 1395 00:40:03,268 --> 00:40:04,768 DIDN'T DO A DISAPPEARING ACT, WHILE THEY AND THE D.A. WAITED 1396 00:40:04,770 --> 00:40:05,368 WHILE THEY AND THE D.A. WAITED FOR THE LAB TO TEST THE HAMMER 1397 00:40:05,370 --> 00:40:06,436 FOR THE LAB TO TEST THE HAMMER AND THEN, THREE DAYS LATER, 1398 00:40:06,438 --> 00:40:11,674 AND THEN, THREE DAYS LATER, ANOTHER INSANELY IMPROBABLE 1399 00:40:11,676 --> 00:40:12,742 ANOTHER INSANELY IMPROBABLE DISCOVERY. 1400 00:40:12,744 --> 00:40:14,844 DISCOVERY. >> THIS KEY WAS FOUND ON THE 1401 00:40:14,846 --> 00:40:16,379 >> THIS KEY WAS FOUND ON THE GROUND 1402 00:40:16,381 --> 00:40:17,981 GROUND IT WAS RIGHT BEFORE THE TRASH 1403 00:40:17,983 --> 00:40:19,048 IT WAS RIGHT BEFORE THE TRASH CAN. 1404 00:40:19,050 --> 00:40:20,083 CAN. >> Reporter: RIGHT THERE, JUST A 1405 00:40:20,085 --> 00:40:20,750 >> Reporter: RIGHT THERE, JUST A FEW FEET FROM THE DOOR OF THE 1406 00:40:20,752 --> 00:40:21,317 FEW FEET FROM THE DOOR OF THE STYLERS MOTEL ROOM, WAS THE 1407 00:40:21,319 --> 00:40:22,419 STYLERS MOTEL ROOM, WAS THE OWNER'S KEY TO THE CLOSET IN 1408 00:40:22,421 --> 00:40:27,490 OWNER'S KEY TO THE CLOSET IN WHICH NANCY PFISTER'S BODY WAS 1409 00:40:27,492 --> 00:40:28,525 WHICH NANCY PFISTER'S BODY WAS FOUND. 1410 00:40:28,527 --> 00:40:29,592 FOUND. LYING AROUND AS IF THE STYLERS 1411 00:40:29,594 --> 00:40:30,427 LYING AROUND AS IF THE STYLERS INTENDED TO THROW IT IN THE 1412 00:40:30,429 --> 00:40:30,927 INTENDED TO THROW IT IN THE TRASH, BUT DROPPED IT BY 1413 00:40:30,929 --> 00:40:31,728 TRASH, BUT DROPPED IT BY MISTAKE. 1414 00:40:31,730 --> 00:40:32,228 MISTAKE. JUST LYING ON THE GROUND 1415 00:40:32,230 --> 00:40:33,229 JUST LYING ON THE GROUND >> ON THE GROUND, ON THE LIGHTER 1416 00:40:33,231 --> 00:40:39,669 >> ON THE GROUND, ON THE LIGHTER PORTION OF THE CONCRETE IS WHERE 1417 00:40:39,671 --> 00:40:40,703 PORTION OF THE CONCRETE IS WHERE IT WAS FOUND 1418 00:40:40,705 --> 00:40:41,771 IT WAS FOUND >> Reporter: AND THEN, THAT VERY 1419 00:40:41,773 --> 00:40:42,806 >> Reporter: AND THEN, THAT VERY SAME DAY, AS IF TO PUNCTUATE THE 1420 00:40:42,808 --> 00:40:43,573 SAME DAY, AS IF TO PUNCTUATE THE WHOLE STRANGE AFFAIR, THE DNA 1421 00:40:43,575 --> 00:40:44,407 WHOLE STRANGE AFFAIR, THE DNA RESULTS CAME BACK. 1422 00:40:44,409 --> 00:40:44,941 RESULTS CAME BACK. AND? 1423 00:40:44,943 --> 00:40:45,975 AND? >> NANCY PFISTER'S DNA WAS ON 1424 00:40:45,977 --> 00:40:47,544 >> NANCY PFISTER'S DNA WAS ON THE HAMMER, SO WE WERE ABLE TO 1425 00:40:47,546 --> 00:40:53,349 THE HAMMER, SO WE WERE ABLE TO PRETTY CLEARLY SAY THAT THAT WAS 1426 00:40:53,351 --> 00:40:53,883 PRETTY CLEARLY SAY THAT THAT WAS THE MURDER WEAPON. 1427 00:40:53,885 --> 00:40:55,151 THE MURDER WEAPON. >> Reporter: THE MURDER WEAPON, 1428 00:40:55,153 --> 00:40:56,019 >> Reporter: THE MURDER WEAPON, THE KEY AND A MOTIVE 1429 00:40:56,021 --> 00:40:58,621 THE KEY AND A MOTIVE PRETTY MUCH EVERYTHING THEY 1430 00:40:58,623 --> 00:40:59,222 PRETTY MUCH EVERYTHING THEY NEEDED TO PIN THE CRIME ON THE 1431 00:40:59,224 --> 00:41:00,223 NEEDED TO PIN THE CRIME ON THE STYLERS. 1432 00:41:00,225 --> 00:41:01,257 STYLERS. IT WAS MARCH 3rd, 2014, NOT EVEN 1433 00:41:01,259 --> 00:41:03,359 IT WAS MARCH 3rd, 2014, NOT EVEN A WEEK SINCE NANCY PFISTER'S 1434 00:41:03,361 --> 00:41:06,529 A WEEK SINCE NANCY PFISTER'S BODY WAS FOUND 1435 00:41:06,531 --> 00:41:08,097 BODY WAS FOUND >> THEY KNOCKED ON THE DOOR. 1436 00:41:08,099 --> 00:41:09,332 >> THEY KNOCKED ON THE DOOR. I STEPPED OUT OF THE DOOR. 1437 00:41:09,334 --> 00:41:16,739 I STEPPED OUT OF THE DOOR. AND THEY SAID, "WE'RE ARRESTING 1438 00:41:16,741 --> 00:41:17,574 AND THEY SAID, "WE'RE ARRESTING YOU FOR MURDER ONE." 1439 00:41:17,576 --> 00:41:18,208 YOU FOR MURDER ONE." AND SLAPPED THE CUFFS ON ME, AND 1440 00:41:18,210 --> 00:41:19,175 AND SLAPPED THE CUFFS ON ME, AND TOOK ME AWAY 1441 00:41:19,177 --> 00:41:20,443 TOOK ME AWAY THEY LED MY HUSBAND OUT IN MY 1442 00:41:20,445 --> 00:41:21,277 THEY LED MY HUSBAND OUT IN MY BATHROBE 1443 00:41:21,279 --> 00:41:24,948 BATHROBE >> Reporter: WHAT IS IT LIKE FOR 1444 00:41:24,950 --> 00:41:26,549 >> Reporter: WHAT IS IT LIKE FOR A WOMAN WHO HAD LED A VERY 1445 00:41:26,551 --> 00:41:27,584 A WOMAN WHO HAD LED A VERY SUCCESSFUL LIFE, WHO HAD 1446 00:41:27,586 --> 00:41:30,220 SUCCESSFUL LIFE, WHO HAD TRAVELED AROUND, DOING LECTURES 1447 00:41:30,222 --> 00:41:33,890 TRAVELED AROUND, DOING LECTURES ON VICTORIA LILIES TO SOCIETIES 1448 00:41:33,892 --> 00:41:39,162 ON VICTORIA LILIES TO SOCIETIES OF LIKE-MINDED 1449 00:41:39,164 --> 00:41:41,264 OF LIKE-MINDED HORTICULTURALISTS -- 1450 00:41:41,266 --> 00:41:41,798 HORTICULTURALISTS -- >> TO BE IN JAIL 1451 00:41:41,800 --> 00:41:43,900 >> TO BE IN JAIL >> Reporter: TO BE IN JAIL FOR 1452 00:41:43,902 --> 00:41:44,434 >> Reporter: TO BE IN JAIL FOR MURDER 1453 00:41:44,436 --> 00:41:44,968 MURDER >> IT WAS A SHOCK. 1454 00:41:44,970 --> 00:41:45,602 >> IT WAS A SHOCK. >> Reporter: IT WAS A SHOCK FOR 1455 00:41:45,604 --> 00:41:46,236 >> Reporter: IT WAS A SHOCK FOR SOME OF NANCY PFISTER'S FRIENDS, 1456 00:41:46,238 --> 00:41:46,536 SOME OF NANCY PFISTER'S FRIENDS, TOO. 1457 00:41:46,538 --> 00:41:51,274 TOO. LIKE MARY CONOVER. 1458 00:41:51,276 --> 00:41:54,978 LIKE MARY CONOVER. THE STYLERS, REALLY? 1459 00:41:54,980 --> 00:41:57,080 THE STYLERS, REALLY? >> IT WAS JUST A BIG SURPRISE. 1460 00:41:57,082 --> 00:41:59,182 >> IT WAS JUST A BIG SURPRISE. AND NOT KNOWING ANYTHING ABOUT 1461 00:41:59,184 --> 00:42:00,783 AND NOT KNOWING ANYTHING ABOUT THESE PEOPLE, IT JUST SEEMED 1462 00:42:00,785 --> 00:42:02,385 THESE PEOPLE, IT JUST SEEMED OUTRAGEOUS 1463 00:42:02,387 --> 00:42:03,152 OUTRAGEOUS WHY YOU WOULD DO SOMETHING LIKE 1464 00:42:03,154 --> 00:42:04,220 WHY YOU WOULD DO SOMETHING LIKE THAT 1465 00:42:04,222 --> 00:42:04,687 THAT >> Reporter: BUT KATHY 1466 00:42:04,689 --> 00:42:05,221 >> Reporter: BUT KATHY CARPENTER, WHO POINTED HER 1467 00:42:05,223 --> 00:42:05,855 CARPENTER, WHO POINTED HER SUSPICIOUS FINGER AT THE STYLERS 1468 00:42:05,857 --> 00:42:06,356 SUSPICIOUS FINGER AT THE STYLERS RIGHT AFTER THE MURDER, 1469 00:42:06,358 --> 00:42:06,890 RIGHT AFTER THE MURDER, PRACTICALLY JUMPED FOR JOY 1470 00:42:06,892 --> 00:42:07,457 PRACTICALLY JUMPED FOR JOY >> WHEN I HEARD THAT, I WAS 1471 00:42:07,459 --> 00:42:07,991 >> WHEN I HEARD THAT, I WAS JOYFUL THAT THEY FOUND THE 1472 00:42:07,993 --> 00:42:08,591 JOYFUL THAT THEY FOUND THE PERSON WHO MURDERED NANCY AND, 1473 00:42:08,593 --> 00:42:11,361 PERSON WHO MURDERED NANCY AND, YOU KNOW, I JUST FELT THAT THERE 1474 00:42:11,363 --> 00:42:13,429 YOU KNOW, I JUST FELT THAT THERE WAS JUSTICE. 1475 00:42:13,431 --> 00:42:14,030 WAS JUSTICE. >> Reporter: AND SWIFT JUSTICE 1476 00:42:14,032 --> 00:42:16,633 >> Reporter: AND SWIFT JUSTICE AT THAT. 1477 00:42:16,635 --> 00:42:18,201 AT THAT. WHAT A RELIEF TO ALL THOSE SOULS 1478 00:42:18,203 --> 00:42:19,269 WHAT A RELIEF TO ALL THOSE SOULS NANCY COLLECTED, WHO LOVED HER 1479 00:42:19,271 --> 00:42:20,336 NANCY COLLECTED, WHO LOVED HER LIKE FAMILY. 1480 00:42:20,338 --> 00:42:22,405 LIKE FAMILY. >> I WAS RELIEVED THAT, YOU 1481 00:42:22,407 --> 00:42:22,972 >> I WAS RELIEVED THAT, YOU KNOW, THIS IS DONE 1482 00:42:22,974 --> 00:42:23,973 KNOW, THIS IS DONE >> Reporter: BUT COULD ONE OF 1483 00:42:23,975 --> 00:42:25,608 >> Reporter: BUT COULD ONE OF THE BIGGEST CRIMES IN ASPEN 1484 00:42:25,610 --> 00:42:27,176 THE BIGGEST CRIMES IN ASPEN HISTORY REALLY BE SOLVED THAT 1485 00:42:27,178 --> 00:42:29,312 HISTORY REALLY BE SOLVED THAT FAST, WITH SO LITTLE DRAMA 1486 00:42:29,314 --> 00:42:33,616 FAST, WITH SO LITTLE DRAMA OF COURSE NOT. 1487 00:42:33,618 --> 00:42:34,584 OF COURSE NOT. LOOKED LIKE A SETUP TO YOU 1488 00:42:34,586 --> 00:42:37,220 LOOKED LIKE A SETUP TO YOU >> IT LOOKED LIKE A SETUP. 1489 00:42:37,222 --> 00:42:37,854 >> IT LOOKED LIKE A SETUP. IT REALLY DID LOOK LIKE A SETUP. 1490 00:42:37,856 --> 00:42:41,424 IT REALLY DID LOOK LIKE A SETUP. >> COMING UP - 1491 00:42:41,426 --> 00:42:42,458 >> COMING UP - RETHINKING THE CASE. 1492 00:42:42,460 --> 00:42:44,827 RETHINKING THE CASE. SOMETHING DOESN'T ADD UP 1493 00:42:44,829 --> 00:42:45,128 SOMETHING DOESN'T ADD UP >> OH MY GOD 1494 00:42:45,130 --> 00:42:49,832 >> OH MY GOD >> BIZARRE IS THE ONLY WAY I CAN 1495 00:42:49,834 --> 00:42:50,900 >> BIZARRE IS THE ONLY WAY I CAN CHARACTERIZE THAT 911 CALL 1496 00:42:50,902 --> 00:42:51,501 CHARACTERIZE THAT 911 CALL >> A CALL, NOW BECOMES A CLUE. 1497 00:42:51,503 --> 00:42:53,536 >> A CALL, NOW BECOMES A CLUE. >> SHE'S DEAD. 1498 00:42:53,538 --> 00:42:55,104 >> SHE'S DEAD. SHE'S FULL OF BLOOD! 1499 00:42:55,106 --> 00:42:56,172 SHE'S FULL OF BLOOD! >> THERE'S NO WAY SHE SAW WHAT 1500 00:42:56,174 --> 00:43:17,226 >> THERE'S NO WAY SHE SAW WHAT SHE SAID SHE SAW 1501 00:43:17,228 --> 00:43:17,794 SHE SAID SHE SAW >> Reporter: IT WAS A QUICK 1502 00:43:17,796 --> 00:43:18,795 >> Reporter: IT WAS A QUICK BUSINESS HERE IN ASPEN, 1503 00:43:18,797 --> 00:43:19,028 BUSINESS HERE IN ASPEN, COLORADO 1504 00:43:19,030 --> 00:43:19,495 COLORADO NOT EVEN A WEEK AFTER 1505 00:43:19,497 --> 00:43:20,096 NOT EVEN A WEEK AFTER NANCY PFISTER'S BODY WAS FOUND 1506 00:43:20,098 --> 00:43:20,663 NANCY PFISTER'S BODY WAS FOUND DEAD IN HER OWN CLOSET, HER 1507 00:43:20,665 --> 00:43:24,133 DEAD IN HER OWN CLOSET, HER RENTERS WERE LED AWAY IN 1508 00:43:24,135 --> 00:43:26,903 RENTERS WERE LED AWAY IN HANDCUFFS. 1509 00:43:26,905 --> 00:43:29,505 HANDCUFFS. BUT WAS IT TOO QUICK, TOO EASY 1510 00:43:29,507 --> 00:43:32,609 BUT WAS IT TOO QUICK, TOO EASY >> IT LOOKED FISHY TO ME 1511 00:43:32,611 --> 00:43:35,211 >> IT LOOKED FISHY TO ME >> Reporter: FISHY 1512 00:43:35,213 --> 00:43:36,779 >> Reporter: FISHY >> FISHY 1513 00:43:36,781 --> 00:43:38,915 >> FISHY >> Reporter: NANCY STYLER'S 1514 00:43:38,917 --> 00:43:39,415 >> Reporter: NANCY STYLER'S ATTORNEY BETH KRULEWITCH 1515 00:43:39,417 --> 00:43:39,983 ATTORNEY BETH KRULEWITCH FISHY, HOW 1516 00:43:39,985 --> 00:43:41,651 FISHY, HOW >> IN TERMS OF YOU'VE GOT A VERY 1517 00:43:41,653 --> 00:43:44,220 >> IN TERMS OF YOU'VE GOT A VERY WELL-RESPECTED PHYSICIAN WHO'S 1518 00:43:44,222 --> 00:43:50,560 WELL-RESPECTED PHYSICIAN WHO'S NOW BEING ACCUSED OF MURDER. 1519 00:43:50,562 --> 00:43:52,662 NOW BEING ACCUSED OF MURDER. AND IT DIDN'T -- IT WAS 1520 00:43:52,664 --> 00:43:55,832 AND IT DIDN'T -- IT WAS INCONCEIVABLE TO ME THAT HE 1521 00:43:55,834 --> 00:43:56,366 INCONCEIVABLE TO ME THAT HE WOULD HAVE KILLED SOMEBODY 1522 00:43:56,368 --> 00:43:56,966 WOULD HAVE KILLED SOMEBODY >> Reporter: PLUS, THE ELDERLY 1523 00:43:56,968 --> 00:43:57,934 >> Reporter: PLUS, THE ELDERLY MAN THEY LED AWAY WRAPPED IN HIS 1524 00:43:57,936 --> 00:44:00,036 MAN THEY LED AWAY WRAPPED IN HIS WIFE'S BLUE BATHROBE LOOKED FAR 1525 00:44:00,038 --> 00:44:01,070 WIFE'S BLUE BATHROBE LOOKED FAR TOO FRAIL AND WEAK TO BLUDGEON A 1526 00:44:01,072 --> 00:44:03,473 TOO FRAIL AND WEAK TO BLUDGEON A WOMAN TO DEATH, CARRY HER BODY, 1527 00:44:03,475 --> 00:44:05,842 WOMAN TO DEATH, CARRY HER BODY, WRAP IT UP, FLIP A MATTRESS. 1528 00:44:05,844 --> 00:44:07,944 WRAP IT UP, FLIP A MATTRESS. >> AND THEN BEEN STUPID ENOUGH 1529 00:44:07,946 --> 00:44:08,578 >> AND THEN BEEN STUPID ENOUGH TO TAKE THE MURDER WEAPON, SOME 1530 00:44:08,580 --> 00:44:12,148 TO TAKE THE MURDER WEAPON, SOME PILL BOTTLES WITH THE VICTIM'S 1531 00:44:12,150 --> 00:44:13,750 PILL BOTTLES WITH THE VICTIM'S NAME ON THEM, HIS VEHICLE 1532 00:44:13,752 --> 00:44:16,586 NAME ON THEM, HIS VEHICLE REGISTRATION AND INSURANCE, 1533 00:44:16,588 --> 00:44:17,453 REGISTRATION AND INSURANCE, PACKAGED IT ALL UP IN ONE BAG 1534 00:44:17,455 --> 00:44:18,521 PACKAGED IT ALL UP IN ONE BAG AND THEN PUT IT IN A DUMPSTER 1535 00:44:18,523 --> 00:44:19,288 AND THEN PUT IT IN A DUMPSTER THAT WAS CLOSE TO THE MOTEL HE 1536 00:44:19,290 --> 00:44:19,622 THAT WAS CLOSE TO THE MOTEL HE WAS STAYING AT 1537 00:44:19,624 --> 00:44:21,124 WAS STAYING AT MADE ZERO SENSE TO ME. 1538 00:44:21,126 --> 00:44:21,724 MADE ZERO SENSE TO ME. >> Reporter: IT ALSO MADE ZERO 1539 00:44:21,726 --> 00:44:22,725 >> Reporter: IT ALSO MADE ZERO SENSE THAT TREY'S ACCOMPLICE WAS 1540 00:44:22,727 --> 00:44:24,794 SENSE THAT TREY'S ACCOMPLICE WAS HIS DIMINUTIVE 62-YEAR-OLD WIFE, 1541 00:44:24,796 --> 00:44:26,429 HIS DIMINUTIVE 62-YEAR-OLD WIFE, NANCY. 1542 00:44:26,431 --> 00:44:27,397 NANCY. EVEN THOUGH SHE DID ACTUALLY SAY 1543 00:44:27,399 --> 00:44:29,032 EVEN THOUGH SHE DID ACTUALLY SAY SHE COULD JUST KILL THAT NANCY 1544 00:44:29,034 --> 00:44:32,702 SHE COULD JUST KILL THAT NANCY PFISTER. 1545 00:44:32,704 --> 00:44:35,338 PFISTER. BUT THEN, LOTS OF PEOPLE AROUND 1546 00:44:35,340 --> 00:44:38,174 BUT THEN, LOTS OF PEOPLE AROUND TOWN SAID SIMILAR THINGS ABOUT 1547 00:44:38,176 --> 00:44:40,610 TOWN SAID SIMILAR THINGS ABOUT THE OUTSPOKEN MS. PFISTER AT 1548 00:44:40,612 --> 00:44:42,712 THE OUTSPOKEN MS. PFISTER AT SOME POINT OR OTHER, NOT MEANING 1549 00:44:42,714 --> 00:44:43,746 SOME POINT OR OTHER, NOT MEANING IT LITERALLY 1550 00:44:43,748 --> 00:44:44,347 IT LITERALLY >> I COULD SEE WHERE SHE COULD 1551 00:44:44,349 --> 00:44:44,914 >> I COULD SEE WHERE SHE COULD BE SITTING AROUND WITH KATHY 1552 00:44:44,916 --> 00:44:45,481 BE SITTING AROUND WITH KATHY CARPENTER, AND THEY COULD BE 1553 00:44:45,483 --> 00:44:46,349 CARPENTER, AND THEY COULD BE COMMISERATING ABOUT, YOU KNOW, 1554 00:44:46,351 --> 00:44:46,983 COMMISERATING ABOUT, YOU KNOW, WHAT NANCY PFISTER DID OR DIDN'T 1555 00:44:46,985 --> 00:44:47,450 WHAT NANCY PFISTER DID OR DIDN'T DO 1556 00:44:47,452 --> 00:44:48,084 DO OR WHAT SHE HAD SAID OR THE WAY 1557 00:44:48,086 --> 00:44:48,551 OR WHAT SHE HAD SAID OR THE WAY THEY HAD BEEN TREATED. 1558 00:44:48,553 --> 00:44:49,052 THEY HAD BEEN TREATED. AND SHE COULD HAVE SAID 1559 00:44:49,054 --> 00:44:49,585 AND SHE COULD HAVE SAID SOMETHING LIKE, YOU KNOW, 1560 00:44:49,587 --> 00:44:53,790 SOMETHING LIKE, YOU KNOW, "GEE -- YOU KNOW, I'D LIKE TO 1561 00:44:53,792 --> 00:44:58,528 "GEE -- YOU KNOW, I'D LIKE TO KILL HER." 1562 00:44:58,530 --> 00:45:00,096 KILL HER." BUT YOU KNOW, LISTEN, THAT'S - 1563 00:45:00,098 --> 00:45:02,231 BUT YOU KNOW, LISTEN, THAT'S - THAT'S NOT EVIDENCE OF 1564 00:45:02,233 --> 00:45:05,368 THAT'S NOT EVIDENCE OF FIRST-DEGREE MURDER. 1565 00:45:05,370 --> 00:45:08,538 FIRST-DEGREE MURDER. >> Reporter: BESIDES, NANCY 1566 00:45:08,540 --> 00:45:11,741 >> Reporter: BESIDES, NANCY STYLER WAS MORE THAN OPEN ABOUT 1567 00:45:11,743 --> 00:45:15,411 STYLER WAS MORE THAN OPEN ABOUT IT 1568 00:45:15,413 --> 00:45:19,148 IT >> WE'VE ALL SAID THAT ABOUT 1569 00:45:19,150 --> 00:45:22,251 >> WE'VE ALL SAID THAT ABOUT SOMEONE AT SOME OTHER, YOU KNOW, 1570 00:45:22,253 --> 00:45:23,820 SOMEONE AT SOME OTHER, YOU KNOW, "I'D LIKE TO KILL HIM," OR 1571 00:45:23,822 --> 00:45:27,890 "I'D LIKE TO KILL HIM," OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT. 1572 00:45:27,892 --> 00:45:28,991 SOMETHING LIKE THAT. BUT NOT -- NOT EVER THINKING, 1573 00:45:28,993 --> 00:45:31,594 BUT NOT -- NOT EVER THINKING, YOU KNOW, TAKING IT THAT FAR 1574 00:45:31,596 --> 00:45:32,795 YOU KNOW, TAKING IT THAT FAR YES, I DID SAY THAT. 1575 00:45:32,797 --> 00:45:34,897 YES, I DID SAY THAT. BUT, NO, I DIDN'T KILL HER 1576 00:45:34,899 --> 00:45:35,498 BUT, NO, I DIDN'T KILL HER >> Reporter: AND IF IT WASN'T 1577 00:45:35,500 --> 00:45:36,999 >> Reporter: AND IF IT WASN'T NANCY, COULDN'T HAVE BEEN TREY, 1578 00:45:37,001 --> 00:45:37,533 NANCY, COULDN'T HAVE BEEN TREY, EITHER 1579 00:45:37,535 --> 00:45:38,568 EITHER BECAUSE HE WAS FRAIL, YES, SAID 1580 00:45:38,570 --> 00:45:39,435 BECAUSE HE WAS FRAIL, YES, SAID NANCY, BUT ALSO BECAUSE HE WAS 1581 00:45:39,437 --> 00:45:39,869 NANCY, BUT ALSO BECAUSE HE WAS NEVER ALONE TO DO IT 1582 00:45:39,871 --> 00:45:40,403 NEVER ALONE TO DO IT YOU WERE NEVER WITHOUT HIM 1583 00:45:40,405 --> 00:45:40,636 YOU WERE NEVER WITHOUT HIM >> YEAH. 1584 00:45:40,638 --> 00:45:41,237 >> YEAH. I SAID WE WERE ALWAYS TOGETHER 1585 00:45:41,239 --> 00:45:41,871 I SAID WE WERE ALWAYS TOGETHER >> Reporter: WHAT DID MAKE 1586 00:45:41,873 --> 00:45:42,505 >> Reporter: WHAT DID MAKE SENSE, SAID ATTORNEY KRULWITCH, 1587 00:45:42,507 --> 00:45:43,072 SENSE, SAID ATTORNEY KRULWITCH, IS THAT SOMEONE ELSE KILLED 1588 00:45:43,074 --> 00:45:43,673 IS THAT SOMEONE ELSE KILLED NANCY PFISTER AND PLANTED THE 1589 00:45:43,675 --> 00:45:44,307 NANCY PFISTER AND PLANTED THE EVIDENCE AGAINST THE STYLERS IN 1590 00:45:44,309 --> 00:45:44,807 EVIDENCE AGAINST THE STYLERS IN AN ATTEMPT TO FRAME THEM 1591 00:45:44,809 --> 00:45:45,374 AN ATTEMPT TO FRAME THEM >> THE FINAL PIECE OF IT WAS 1592 00:45:45,376 --> 00:45:46,509 >> THE FINAL PIECE OF IT WAS THAT THE OWNER'S CLOSET KEY KIND 1593 00:45:46,511 --> 00:45:47,543 THAT THE OWNER'S CLOSET KEY KIND OF MAGICALLY APPEARS ON THE 1594 00:45:47,545 --> 00:45:50,213 OF MAGICALLY APPEARS ON THE SIDEWALK NEAR THE STYLERS' MOTEL 1595 00:45:50,215 --> 00:45:52,348 SIDEWALK NEAR THE STYLERS' MOTEL ROOM THE DAY THEY GET ARRESTED 1596 00:45:52,350 --> 00:45:53,916 ROOM THE DAY THEY GET ARRESTED >> Reporter: IT WAS A THOUGHT 1597 00:45:53,918 --> 00:45:55,518 >> Reporter: IT WAS A THOUGHT THAT CROSSED INVESTIGATOR'S 1598 00:45:55,520 --> 00:45:56,552 THAT CROSSED INVESTIGATOR'S MINDS AS WELL. 1599 00:45:56,554 --> 00:45:58,121 MINDS AS WELL. >> WE WOULD'VE BEEN AMISS HAD WE 1600 00:45:58,123 --> 00:46:00,256 >> WE WOULD'VE BEEN AMISS HAD WE NOT LOOKED AT THE POSSIBILITY 1601 00:46:00,258 --> 00:46:02,658 NOT LOOKED AT THE POSSIBILITY THAT SOMEONE WAS SETTING THESE 1602 00:46:02,660 --> 00:46:05,027 THAT SOMEONE WAS SETTING THESE PEOPLE UP. 1603 00:46:05,029 --> 00:46:07,630 PEOPLE UP. >> Reporter: AND SO, EVEN WITH 1604 00:46:07,632 --> 00:46:09,165 >> Reporter: AND SO, EVEN WITH THE STYLERS IN JAIL, CHARGED 1605 00:46:09,167 --> 00:46:10,266 THE STYLERS IN JAIL, CHARGED WITH MURDER, INVESTIGATORS WERE 1606 00:46:10,268 --> 00:46:13,603 WITH MURDER, INVESTIGATORS WERE STILL QUIETLY LOOKING FOR OTHER 1607 00:46:13,605 --> 00:46:16,072 STILL QUIETLY LOOKING FOR OTHER SUSPECTS -- FOR SOMEONE WITH 1608 00:46:16,074 --> 00:46:17,540 SUSPECTS -- FOR SOMEONE WITH MOTIVE AND MEANS TO KILL NANCY 1609 00:46:17,542 --> 00:46:20,343 MOTIVE AND MEANS TO KILL NANCY AND THE FORESIGHT TO FRAME THE 1610 00:46:20,345 --> 00:46:21,377 AND THE FORESIGHT TO FRAME THE STYLERS. 1611 00:46:21,379 --> 00:46:22,445 STYLERS. SOMEONE CLOSE TO NANCY, SOMEONE 1612 00:46:22,447 --> 00:46:23,146 SOMEONE CLOSE TO NANCY, SOMEONE NANCY TRUSTED, EVEN LOVED. 1613 00:46:23,148 --> 00:46:24,580 NANCY TRUSTED, EVEN LOVED. LIKE, THE PERSON WHO POINTED THE 1614 00:46:24,582 --> 00:46:30,353 LIKE, THE PERSON WHO POINTED THE FINGER OF BLAME RIGHT IN THE 1615 00:46:30,355 --> 00:46:33,523 FINGER OF BLAME RIGHT IN THE MIDDLE OF THAT 911 CALL. 1616 00:46:33,525 --> 00:46:34,624 MIDDLE OF THAT 911 CALL. >> SHE HAD SOME PEOPLE LIVING 1617 00:46:34,626 --> 00:46:35,224 >> SHE HAD SOME PEOPLE LIVING THERE AND SHE REALLY [ BLEEP ] 1618 00:46:35,226 --> 00:46:37,760 THERE AND SHE REALLY [ BLEEP ] THEM OFF 1619 00:46:37,762 --> 00:46:40,363 THEM OFF >> Reporter: KATHY CARPENTER 1620 00:46:40,365 --> 00:46:43,032 >> Reporter: KATHY CARPENTER SHE SAID SHE WAS NANCY PFISTER'S 1621 00:46:43,034 --> 00:46:45,134 SHE SAID SHE WAS NANCY PFISTER'S DEAR FRIEND. 1622 00:46:45,136 --> 00:46:47,770 DEAR FRIEND. BUT INVESTIGATORS WERE HEARING A 1623 00:46:47,772 --> 00:46:49,906 BUT INVESTIGATORS WERE HEARING A DIFFERENT STORY. 1624 00:46:49,908 --> 00:46:50,940 DIFFERENT STORY. >> THEIR RELATIONSHIP HAD BEEN A 1625 00:46:50,942 --> 00:46:53,042 >> THEIR RELATIONSHIP HAD BEEN A ROLLER COASTER 1626 00:46:53,044 --> 00:46:56,212 ROLLER COASTER SO, WE KNEW THAT THERE HAD BEEN 1627 00:46:56,214 --> 00:46:58,614 SO, WE KNEW THAT THERE HAD BEEN THIS CYCLE OF THE LADIES HAVING 1628 00:46:58,616 --> 00:47:02,018 THIS CYCLE OF THE LADIES HAVING A GOOD RELATIONSHIP, AND THEN 1629 00:47:02,020 --> 00:47:04,153 A GOOD RELATIONSHIP, AND THEN THINGS WOULD GO SOUTH AND THEY 1630 00:47:04,155 --> 00:47:05,188 THINGS WOULD GO SOUTH AND THEY WOULD HAVE A BAD RELATIONSHIP 1631 00:47:05,190 --> 00:47:07,824 WOULD HAVE A BAD RELATIONSHIP FOR A PERIOD OF TIME 1632 00:47:07,826 --> 00:47:08,891 FOR A PERIOD OF TIME >> Reporter: AND SO WITH ALL 1633 00:47:08,893 --> 00:47:09,392 >> Reporter: AND SO WITH ALL THAT IN MIND, DEPUTY D.A 1634 00:47:09,394 --> 00:47:09,992 THAT IN MIND, DEPUTY D.A ANDREA BRYAN WENT BACK TO THAT 1635 00:47:09,994 --> 00:47:10,626 ANDREA BRYAN WENT BACK TO THAT HYSTERICAL PHONE CALL FROM KATHY 1636 00:47:10,628 --> 00:47:11,027 HYSTERICAL PHONE CALL FROM KATHY TO 911 1637 00:47:11,029 --> 00:47:12,595 TO 911 WHAT DID YOU MAKE OF IT? 1638 00:47:12,597 --> 00:47:14,730 WHAT DID YOU MAKE OF IT? >> YOU KNOW, I THINK BIZARRE IS 1639 00:47:14,732 --> 00:47:16,666 >> YOU KNOW, I THINK BIZARRE IS THE ONLY WAY I CAN CHARACTERIZE 1640 00:47:16,668 --> 00:47:18,434 THE ONLY WAY I CAN CHARACTERIZE THAT 911 CALL. 1641 00:47:18,436 --> 00:47:20,536 THAT 911 CALL. IMMEDIATELY IDENTIFYING 1642 00:47:20,538 --> 00:47:22,672 IMMEDIATELY IDENTIFYING SUSPECTS, IT WAS -- IT WAS NOT 1643 00:47:22,674 --> 00:47:24,240 SUSPECTS, IT WAS -- IT WAS NOT GETTING HELP FOR NANCY PFISTER 1644 00:47:24,242 --> 00:47:28,010 GETTING HELP FOR NANCY PFISTER IT WAS -- "OH, YOU SHOULD BE 1645 00:47:28,012 --> 00:47:29,512 IT WAS -- "OH, YOU SHOULD BE LOOKING AT THESE TWO PEOPLE 1646 00:47:29,514 --> 00:47:30,580 LOOKING AT THESE TWO PEOPLE IMMEDIATELY. 1647 00:47:30,582 --> 00:47:31,614 IMMEDIATELY. SO, THAT WAS INTERESTING 1648 00:47:31,616 --> 00:47:34,784 SO, THAT WAS INTERESTING >> Reporter: SO, IT WAS. 1649 00:47:34,786 --> 00:47:37,520 >> Reporter: SO, IT WAS. AND JUST AS INTERESTING? 1650 00:47:37,522 --> 00:47:41,157 AND JUST AS INTERESTING? WHAT KATHY TOLD 911 ABOUT SEEING 1651 00:47:41,159 --> 00:47:42,725 WHAT KATHY TOLD 911 ABOUT SEEING NANCY PFISTER'S BODY 1652 00:47:42,727 --> 00:47:43,359 NANCY PFISTER'S BODY >> THE FACT THAT IMMEDIATELY THE 1653 00:47:43,361 --> 00:47:43,993 >> THE FACT THAT IMMEDIATELY THE DECEASED IS IDENTIFIED AS NANCY 1654 00:47:43,995 --> 00:47:45,094 DECEASED IS IDENTIFIED AS NANCY PFISTER WOULD HAVE BEEN 1655 00:47:45,096 --> 00:47:45,461 PFISTER WOULD HAVE BEEN IMPOSSIBLE TO DO 1656 00:47:45,463 --> 00:47:46,062 IMPOSSIBLE TO DO >> Reporter: IMPOSSIBLE, SAID 1657 00:47:46,064 --> 00:47:46,596 >> Reporter: IMPOSSIBLE, SAID INVESTIGATOR LISA MILLER, 1658 00:47:46,598 --> 00:47:47,096 INVESTIGATOR LISA MILLER, BECAUSE NANCY'S BODY WAS 1659 00:47:47,098 --> 00:47:54,570 BECAUSE NANCY'S BODY WAS COMPLETELY COVERED HEAD TO TOE 1660 00:47:54,572 --> 00:47:57,506 COMPLETELY COVERED HEAD TO TOE WHEN KATHY SAW IT IN THE CLOSET. 1661 00:47:57,508 --> 00:47:59,642 WHEN KATHY SAW IT IN THE CLOSET. >> SHE'S DEAD. 1662 00:47:59,644 --> 00:48:00,176 >> SHE'S DEAD. SHE'S FULL OF BLOOD! 1663 00:48:00,178 --> 00:48:04,714 SHE'S FULL OF BLOOD! >> WE'RE LOOKING AT PHOTOS OF 1664 00:48:04,716 --> 00:48:07,550 >> WE'RE LOOKING AT PHOTOS OF THE CRIME SCENE AND WE KNEW 1665 00:48:07,552 --> 00:48:09,852 THE CRIME SCENE AND WE KNEW THERE'S NO WAY SHE SAW WHAT SHE 1666 00:48:09,854 --> 00:48:10,720 THERE'S NO WAY SHE SAW WHAT SHE SAID SHE SAW 1667 00:48:10,722 --> 00:48:12,855 SAID SHE SAW >> Reporter: THERE WAS MORE. 1668 00:48:12,857 --> 00:48:15,491 >> Reporter: THERE WAS MORE. KATHY, OF COURSE, HAD KEYS TO 1669 00:48:15,493 --> 00:48:16,192 KATHY, OF COURSE, HAD KEYS TO NANCY'S HOUSE, INCLUDING A KEY 1670 00:48:16,194 --> 00:48:17,059 NANCY'S HOUSE, INCLUDING A KEY TO THE CLOSET, WAS THE LAST 1671 00:48:17,061 --> 00:48:17,927 TO THE CLOSET, WAS THE LAST PERSON TO ADMIT SEEING NANCY 1672 00:48:17,929 --> 00:48:18,127 PERSON TO ADMIT SEEING NANCY ALIVE. 1673 00:48:18,129 --> 00:48:18,694 ALIVE. AND WHEN SHE LEFT, PINNED UP 1674 00:48:18,696 --> 00:48:19,295 AND WHEN SHE LEFT, PINNED UP THAT "DO NOT DISTURB" SIGN ON 1675 00:48:19,297 --> 00:48:23,933 THAT "DO NOT DISTURB" SIGN ON NANCY'S DOOR, SUPPOSEDLY BECAUSE 1676 00:48:23,935 --> 00:48:24,533 NANCY'S DOOR, SUPPOSEDLY BECAUSE HER FRIEND NEEDED TO GET OVER 1677 00:48:24,535 --> 00:48:27,069 HER FRIEND NEEDED TO GET OVER HER JET LAG. 1678 00:48:27,071 --> 00:48:27,570 HER JET LAG. >> SHE ENDED UP MAKING A 1679 00:48:27,572 --> 00:48:28,204 >> SHE ENDED UP MAKING A STATEMENT TO ANOTHER INDIVIDUAL 1680 00:48:28,206 --> 00:48:28,838 STATEMENT TO ANOTHER INDIVIDUAL THAT NANCY WOULD BE SLEEPING AND 1681 00:48:28,840 --> 00:48:30,072 THAT NANCY WOULD BE SLEEPING AND RESTING FOR THE NEXT THREE DAYS. 1682 00:48:30,074 --> 00:48:30,673 RESTING FOR THE NEXT THREE DAYS. >> Reporter: AND IT WAS THREE 1683 00:48:30,675 --> 00:48:32,308 >> Reporter: AND IT WAS THREE DAYS LATER THE BODY WAS FOUND? 1684 00:48:32,310 --> 00:48:33,976 DAYS LATER THE BODY WAS FOUND? >> CORRECT 1685 00:48:33,978 --> 00:48:35,544 >> CORRECT >> Reporter: AND THE DAY THAT 1686 00:48:35,546 --> 00:48:37,146 >> Reporter: AND THE DAY THAT CLOSET KEY MAGICALLY APPEARED SO 1687 00:48:37,148 --> 00:48:37,713 CLOSET KEY MAGICALLY APPEARED SO CLOSE TO THE STYLER'S MOTEL 1688 00:48:37,715 --> 00:48:39,749 CLOSE TO THE STYLER'S MOTEL ROOM, KATHY CARPENTER WAS KNOWN 1689 00:48:39,751 --> 00:48:41,350 ROOM, KATHY CARPENTER WAS KNOWN TO BE IN THE VERY SAME 1690 00:48:41,352 --> 00:48:42,418 TO BE IN THE VERY SAME NEIGHBORHOOD RIGHT AROUND THAT 1691 00:48:42,420 --> 00:48:43,486 NEIGHBORHOOD RIGHT AROUND THAT TIME MEETING WITH HER THERAPIST. 1692 00:48:43,488 --> 00:48:47,690 TIME MEETING WITH HER THERAPIST. SO, NEXT QUESTION -- WAS KATHY 1693 00:48:47,692 --> 00:48:49,025 SO, NEXT QUESTION -- WAS KATHY CARPENTER TRULY NANCY'S FRIEND 1694 00:48:49,027 --> 00:48:49,825 CARPENTER TRULY NANCY'S FRIEND AND HELPER 1695 00:48:49,827 --> 00:48:51,928 AND HELPER OR HER MURDERER, TRYING TO PIN 1696 00:48:51,930 --> 00:48:52,428 OR HER MURDERER, TRYING TO PIN THE BLAME ON SOMEONE ELSE? 1697 00:49:11,081 --> 00:49:21,524 >> Reporter: SKI SEASON IN ASPEN IS A TIME TO SEE AND BE SEEN -- 1698 00:49:21,526 --> 00:49:23,626 IS A TIME TO SEE AND BE SEEN -- IN CROWDED WATERING HOLES -- 1699 00:49:23,628 --> 00:49:27,330 IN CROWDED WATERING HOLES -- BENEATH CAREFULLY GROOMED WORLD 1700 00:49:27,332 --> 00:49:31,567 BENEATH CAREFULLY GROOMED WORLD CLASS SLOPES 1701 00:49:31,569 --> 00:49:35,805 CLASS SLOPES BUT IN LATE WINTER, 2014, 1702 00:49:35,807 --> 00:49:39,508 BUT IN LATE WINTER, 2014, ATTENTION WAS DIVERTED FROM THE 1703 00:49:39,510 --> 00:49:41,110 ATTENTION WAS DIVERTED FROM THE FASHIONABLE PERSUITS 1704 00:49:41,112 --> 00:49:43,713 FASHIONABLE PERSUITS NANCY PFISTER ONCE DESCRIBED TO 1705 00:49:43,715 --> 00:49:46,849 NANCY PFISTER ONCE DESCRIBED TO THAT FRENCH TV SHOW. 1706 00:49:46,851 --> 00:49:47,316 THAT FRENCH TV SHOW. >> WE CALL ASPEN ADULT 1707 00:49:47,318 --> 00:49:47,917 >> WE CALL ASPEN ADULT DISNEYLAND 1708 00:49:47,919 --> 00:49:48,484 DISNEYLAND >> Reporter: NOW THE SUBJECT 1709 00:49:48,486 --> 00:49:49,685 >> Reporter: NOW THE SUBJECT WAS -- HER 1710 00:49:49,687 --> 00:49:50,252 WAS -- HER HER MURDER, OF COURSE -- BUT 1711 00:49:50,254 --> 00:49:50,820 HER MURDER, OF COURSE -- BUT ALSO, HER FREE-WHEELING LIFE 1712 00:49:50,822 --> 00:49:51,454 ALSO, HER FREE-WHEELING LIFE AND IN DEATH, HER REPUTATION, TO 1713 00:49:51,456 --> 00:49:52,088 AND IN DEATH, HER REPUTATION, TO THE CONSTERNATION OF HER CLOSEST 1714 00:49:52,090 --> 00:49:52,722 THE CONSTERNATION OF HER CLOSEST FRIENDS, WAS GLEEFULLY AMPLIFIED 1715 00:49:52,724 --> 00:49:53,356 FRIENDS, WAS GLEEFULLY AMPLIFIED BY SOME MEDIA OUTLETS -- NOT IN 1716 00:49:53,358 --> 00:49:53,622 BY SOME MEDIA OUTLETS -- NOT IN A GOOD WAY 1717 00:49:53,624 --> 00:49:55,224 A GOOD WAY >> WHY DO WE NEED TO THROW ROCKS 1718 00:49:55,226 --> 00:49:58,461 >> WHY DO WE NEED TO THROW ROCKS AT HER, YOU KNOW, JUST 1719 00:49:58,463 --> 00:50:00,029 AT HER, YOU KNOW, JUST BECAUSE -- SHE HAD TOO MUCH FUN, 1720 00:50:00,031 --> 00:50:01,097 BECAUSE -- SHE HAD TOO MUCH FUN, REALLY 1721 00:50:01,099 --> 00:50:03,499 REALLY >> Reporter: BILLY AND THE 1722 00:50:03,501 --> 00:50:04,800 >> Reporter: BILLY AND THE OTHERS DEFENDED THEIR 1723 00:50:04,802 --> 00:50:07,970 OTHERS DEFENDED THEIR REMARKABLE, DEPARTED, FRIEND, 1724 00:50:07,972 --> 00:50:11,140 REMARKABLE, DEPARTED, FRIEND, AND DEVOTED THEIR ENERGY TO 1725 00:50:11,142 --> 00:50:14,343 AND DEVOTED THEIR ENERGY TO PLANS FOR A SPECIAL MEMORIAL 1726 00:50:14,345 --> 00:50:18,581 PLANS FOR A SPECIAL MEMORIAL EVENT WHICH, THEY DECIDED, WOULD 1727 00:50:18,583 --> 00:50:19,615 EVENT WHICH, THEY DECIDED, WOULD BE A PARTY -- THE SORT OF THING 1728 00:50:19,617 --> 00:50:20,149 BE A PARTY -- THE SORT OF THING SHE WOULD HAVE LOVED 1729 00:50:20,151 --> 00:50:20,683 SHE WOULD HAVE LOVED WHAT DID SHE MEAN TO YOU, 1730 00:50:20,685 --> 00:50:21,283 WHAT DID SHE MEAN TO YOU, PERSONALLY 1731 00:50:21,285 --> 00:50:21,851 PERSONALLY >> SHE MEANT UM DURATION AND 1732 00:50:21,853 --> 00:50:22,551 >> SHE MEANT UM DURATION AND CONSISTENCY -- SHE WAS THE 1733 00:50:22,553 --> 00:50:23,152 CONSISTENCY -- SHE WAS THE GODMOTHER OF MY CHILDREN AND I 1734 00:50:23,154 --> 00:50:23,753 GODMOTHER OF MY CHILDREN AND I WAS THE GODFATHER OF HER -- OF 1735 00:50:23,755 --> 00:50:23,986 WAS THE GODFATHER OF HER -- OF JULIANA. 1736 00:50:23,988 --> 00:50:24,387 JULIANA. UM SORRY 1737 00:50:24,389 --> 00:50:27,023 UM SORRY I'M TRYING 1738 00:50:27,025 --> 00:50:30,760 I'M TRYING >> Reporter: BUT WHILE BILLY AND 1739 00:50:30,762 --> 00:50:33,562 >> Reporter: BUT WHILE BILLY AND THE OTHERS WORKED THROUGH THEIR 1740 00:50:33,564 --> 00:50:36,532 THE OTHERS WORKED THROUGH THEIR GRIEF, NANCY'S BUDDY KATHY 1741 00:50:36,534 --> 00:50:41,270 GRIEF, NANCY'S BUDDY KATHY CARPENTER WAS AT THE PITKIN 1742 00:50:41,272 --> 00:50:42,838 CARPENTER WAS AT THE PITKIN COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE 1743 00:50:42,840 --> 00:50:43,372 COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE ANSWERING QUESTIONS. 1744 00:50:43,374 --> 00:50:43,906 ANSWERING QUESTIONS. >> WHAT DID YOU SEE? 1745 00:50:43,908 --> 00:50:44,507 >> WHAT DID YOU SEE? >> I JUST REMEMBER OPENING THE 1746 00:50:44,509 --> 00:50:46,008 >> I JUST REMEMBER OPENING THE DOOR 1747 00:50:46,010 --> 00:50:48,110 DOOR >> OKAY. 1748 00:50:48,112 --> 00:50:50,212 >> OKAY. >> AND I SAW, SHE UH WAS -- SHE 1749 00:50:50,214 --> 00:50:51,814 >> AND I SAW, SHE UH WAS -- SHE WAS COVERED. 1750 00:50:51,816 --> 00:50:53,382 WAS COVERED. >> WE WERE STILL GIVING HER THE 1751 00:50:53,384 --> 00:50:54,450 >> WE WERE STILL GIVING HER THE BENEFIT OF THE DOUBT 1752 00:50:54,452 --> 00:50:55,017 BENEFIT OF THE DOUBT SHE THOUGHT SOMETHING WAS UP 1753 00:50:55,019 --> 00:50:59,889 SHE THOUGHT SOMETHING WAS UP SHE HAD BEEN WORRIED ABOUT HER 1754 00:50:59,891 --> 00:51:01,857 SHE HAD BEEN WORRIED ABOUT HER FRIEND 1755 00:51:01,859 --> 00:51:02,925 FRIEND >> Reporter: SO WAS THERE AN 1756 00:51:02,927 --> 00:51:05,761 >> Reporter: SO WAS THERE AN INNOCENT EXPLANATION FOR WHY 1757 00:51:05,763 --> 00:51:09,799 INNOCENT EXPLANATION FOR WHY KATHY SEEMED TO SEE THINGS SHE 1758 00:51:09,801 --> 00:51:10,833 KATHY SEEMED TO SEE THINGS SHE COULD NOT HAVE SEEN? 1759 00:51:10,835 --> 00:51:12,935 COULD NOT HAVE SEEN? WHY SHE KNEW IT WAS NANCY'S 1760 00:51:12,937 --> 00:51:13,536 WHY SHE KNEW IT WAS NANCY'S BLOODIED BODY THAT WAS IN THAT 1761 00:51:13,538 --> 00:51:16,105 BLOODIED BODY THAT WAS IN THAT CLOSET, EVEN THOUGH FIRST 1762 00:51:16,107 --> 00:51:16,806 CLOSET, EVEN THOUGH FIRST RESPONDERS SAW WHAT LOOKED LIKE 1763 00:51:16,808 --> 00:51:17,706 RESPONDERS SAW WHAT LOOKED LIKE JUST A PILE OF BLANKETS WHEN 1764 00:51:17,708 --> 00:51:19,475 JUST A PILE OF BLANKETS WHEN THEY ARRIVED 1765 00:51:19,477 --> 00:51:20,342 THEY ARRIVED COULD SHE HAVE LIFTED UP THOSE 1766 00:51:20,344 --> 00:51:24,013 COULD SHE HAVE LIFTED UP THOSE BLANKETS 1767 00:51:24,015 --> 00:51:25,614 BLANKETS >> SHE COULD'VE. 1768 00:51:25,616 --> 00:51:27,783 >> SHE COULD'VE. >> Reporter: AND SEEN -- 1769 00:51:27,785 --> 00:51:31,287 >> Reporter: AND SEEN -- >> SHE COULD'VE. 1770 00:51:31,289 --> 00:51:32,988 >> SHE COULD'VE. AND DURING THE INTERVIEWS, I 1771 00:51:32,990 --> 00:51:33,756 AND DURING THE INTERVIEWS, I SPECIFICALLY ASKED HER, "DID YOU 1772 00:51:33,758 --> 00:51:34,190 SPECIFICALLY ASKED HER, "DID YOU STEP INTO THE CLOSET 1773 00:51:34,192 --> 00:51:34,690 STEP INTO THE CLOSET DID YOU LIFT ANY OF THE 1774 00:51:34,692 --> 00:51:39,328 DID YOU LIFT ANY OF THE BLANKETS 1775 00:51:39,330 --> 00:51:39,795 BLANKETS DID YOU TOUCH, DID YOU 1776 00:51:39,797 --> 00:51:40,429 DID YOU TOUCH, DID YOU MANIPULATE, IN ANY WAY?" AND HER 1777 00:51:40,431 --> 00:51:41,430 MANIPULATE, IN ANY WAY?" AND HER ANSWERS, REPEATEDLY, WERE, "NO." 1778 00:51:41,432 --> 00:51:42,064 ANSWERS, REPEATEDLY, WERE, "NO." SHE HAD NOT TOUCHED, SHE HAD NOT 1779 00:51:42,066 --> 00:51:42,665 SHE HAD NOT TOUCHED, SHE HAD NOT MOVED, SHE HAD NOT MANIPULATED 1780 00:51:42,667 --> 00:51:43,132 MOVED, SHE HAD NOT MANIPULATED >> I DID NOT TOUCH HER 1781 00:51:43,134 --> 00:51:44,166 >> I DID NOT TOUCH HER I RAN OUT OF THERE SO FAST 1782 00:51:44,168 --> 00:51:44,733 I RAN OUT OF THERE SO FAST >> Reporter: AND YET, AT THE 1783 00:51:44,735 --> 00:51:45,334 >> Reporter: AND YET, AT THE SAME TIME, KATHY GAVE SPECIFIC 1784 00:51:45,336 --> 00:51:45,801 SAME TIME, KATHY GAVE SPECIFIC DETAILS ABOUT THE BODY 1785 00:51:45,803 --> 00:51:46,702 DETAILS ABOUT THE BODY >> I SAW HER -- THE HEAD 1786 00:51:46,704 --> 00:51:48,304 >> I SAW HER -- THE HEAD LIKE I DON'T REMEMBER THE 1787 00:51:48,306 --> 00:51:49,338 LIKE I DON'T REMEMBER THE POSITION BUT I KNEW HER -- THE 1788 00:51:49,340 --> 00:51:50,406 POSITION BUT I KNEW HER -- THE BLONDE HAIR. 1789 00:51:50,408 --> 00:51:53,576 BLONDE HAIR. >> SHE TELLS ME SHE IMMEDIATELY 1790 00:51:53,578 --> 00:51:55,177 >> SHE TELLS ME SHE IMMEDIATELY RECOGNIZED HER FRIEND BECAUSE OF 1791 00:51:55,179 --> 00:52:00,983 RECOGNIZED HER FRIEND BECAUSE OF THE BLONDE HAIR -- AND THE 1792 00:52:00,985 --> 00:52:03,085 THE BLONDE HAIR -- AND THE LENGTH OF THAT HAIR. 1793 00:52:03,087 --> 00:52:04,120 LENGTH OF THAT HAIR. "HOW MUCH HAIR DID YOU SEE?" I 1794 00:52:04,122 --> 00:52:06,255 "HOW MUCH HAIR DID YOU SEE?" I WOULD ASK MISS CARPENTER 1795 00:52:06,257 --> 00:52:11,527 WOULD ASK MISS CARPENTER >> IT SEEMED LIKE MAYBE, MAYBE 1796 00:52:11,529 --> 00:52:13,629 >> IT SEEMED LIKE MAYBE, MAYBE SOMETHING -- I JUST. 1797 00:52:13,631 --> 00:52:14,263 SOMETHING -- I JUST. SHE HAD HIGHLIGHTS 1798 00:52:14,265 --> 00:52:14,897 SHE HAD HIGHLIGHTS >> SO HOW MANY STRANDS WOULD YOU 1799 00:52:14,899 --> 00:52:15,264 >> SO HOW MANY STRANDS WOULD YOU SAY THAT YOU SAW 1800 00:52:15,266 --> 00:52:15,865 SAY THAT YOU SAW SO WOULD IT BE LIKE -- WAS IT 1801 00:52:15,867 --> 00:52:18,367 SO WOULD IT BE LIKE -- WAS IT MATTED WITH BLOOD? 1802 00:52:18,369 --> 00:52:21,003 MATTED WITH BLOOD? OR JUST A LITTLE BLOOD 1803 00:52:21,005 --> 00:52:23,105 OR JUST A LITTLE BLOOD >> I -- I JUST REMEMBER THE 1804 00:52:23,107 --> 00:52:25,741 >> I -- I JUST REMEMBER THE HAIR 1805 00:52:25,743 --> 00:52:29,445 HAIR >> IF YOU'VE SEEN THE CRIME 1806 00:52:29,447 --> 00:52:33,349 >> IF YOU'VE SEEN THE CRIME SCENE PHOTOGRAPHS OF HOW THAT 1807 00:52:33,351 --> 00:52:35,251 SCENE PHOTOGRAPHS OF HOW THAT BODY WAS FOUND AND THAT -- THAT 1808 00:52:35,253 --> 00:52:36,285 BODY WAS FOUND AND THAT -- THAT BODY WAS IN THE CLOSET, SHE DID 1809 00:52:36,287 --> 00:52:36,819 BODY WAS IN THE CLOSET, SHE DID NOT SEE THAT 1810 00:52:36,821 --> 00:52:37,620 NOT SEE THAT >> Reporter: THE MORE KATHY 1811 00:52:37,622 --> 00:52:37,820 >> Reporter: THE MORE KATHY TALKED 1812 00:52:37,822 --> 00:52:38,420 TALKED >> HOW MUCH -- HOW MUCH BLOOD 1813 00:52:38,422 --> 00:52:38,888 >> HOW MUCH -- HOW MUCH BLOOD DID YOU SEE? 1814 00:52:38,890 --> 00:52:43,659 DID YOU SEE? HOW MUCH BLOOD WOULD YOU SAY YOU 1815 00:52:43,661 --> 00:52:48,931 HOW MUCH BLOOD WOULD YOU SAY YOU SAW? 1816 00:52:48,933 --> 00:52:49,999 SAW? >> I SAW HER HAIR ON THE HEAD. 1817 00:52:50,001 --> 00:52:53,702 >> I SAW HER HAIR ON THE HEAD. >> OK. 1818 00:52:53,704 --> 00:52:57,740 >> OK. >> I JUST REMEMBER ON THE HEAD 1819 00:52:57,742 --> 00:53:00,543 >> I JUST REMEMBER ON THE HEAD >> Reporter: THE MORE SUSPICIOUS 1820 00:53:00,545 --> 00:53:04,213 >> Reporter: THE MORE SUSPICIOUS THE INVESTIGATOR BECAME. 1821 00:53:04,215 --> 00:53:07,383 THE INVESTIGATOR BECAME. >> SHE'S DESCRIBING, IN THE 1822 00:53:07,385 --> 00:53:09,451 >> SHE'S DESCRIBING, IN THE INTERVIEWS, HOW -- WHERE THE 1823 00:53:09,453 --> 00:53:10,052 INTERVIEWS, HOW -- WHERE THE INJURIES WERE TO THE FOREHEAD. 1824 00:53:10,054 --> 00:53:10,586 INJURIES WERE TO THE FOREHEAD. I WENT AND I REVIEWED THE 1825 00:53:10,588 --> 00:53:11,053 I WENT AND I REVIEWED THE AUTOPSY PHOTOS 1826 00:53:11,055 --> 00:53:12,688 AUTOPSY PHOTOS AND SHE WAS EXACTLY, SPOT ON TO 1827 00:53:12,690 --> 00:53:13,289 AND SHE WAS EXACTLY, SPOT ON TO WHERE SHE INDICATED THE INJURY 1828 00:53:13,291 --> 00:53:13,656 WHERE SHE INDICATED THE INJURY TO THE FOREHEAD. 1829 00:53:13,658 --> 00:53:15,024 TO THE FOREHEAD. >> Reporter: BUT IT WASN'T JUST 1830 00:53:15,026 --> 00:53:16,825 >> Reporter: BUT IT WASN'T JUST KATHY'S WORDS, SAID INVESTIGATOR 1831 00:53:16,827 --> 00:53:20,529 KATHY'S WORDS, SAID INVESTIGATOR MILLER, LOOKED TO HER LIKE 1832 00:53:20,531 --> 00:53:23,165 MILLER, LOOKED TO HER LIKE KATHY'S GRIEF WAS MORE ACT THAN 1833 00:53:23,167 --> 00:53:25,301 KATHY'S GRIEF WAS MORE ACT THAN REAL 1834 00:53:25,303 --> 00:53:27,403 REAL >> I DON'T --I DON'T REMEMBER. 1835 00:53:27,405 --> 00:53:28,971 >> I DON'T --I DON'T REMEMBER. >> GRAB THE KLEENEX. 1836 00:53:28,973 --> 00:53:30,372 >> GRAB THE KLEENEX. >> OH, YEAH, FOR THE TEARS 1837 00:53:30,374 --> 00:53:33,209 >> OH, YEAH, FOR THE TEARS >> Reporter: AND A BAD ACT AT 1838 00:53:33,211 --> 00:53:33,742 >> Reporter: AND A BAD ACT AT THAT 1839 00:53:33,744 --> 00:53:34,643 THAT >> THERE WAS NO TEARS DURING THE 1840 00:53:34,645 --> 00:53:35,211 >> THERE WAS NO TEARS DURING THE TIME THAT SHE WAS TRYING TO 1841 00:53:35,213 --> 00:53:35,744 TIME THAT SHE WAS TRYING TO PORTRAY HERSELF AS CRYING. 1842 00:53:35,746 --> 00:53:36,312 PORTRAY HERSELF AS CRYING. >> Reporter: SOME PEOPLE CRY 1843 00:53:36,314 --> 00:53:36,779 >> Reporter: SOME PEOPLE CRY WITHOUT TEARS, SURELY? 1844 00:53:36,781 --> 00:53:37,379 WITHOUT TEARS, SURELY? >> OH, I'M SURE SOME PEOPLE DO 1845 00:53:37,381 --> 00:53:37,980 >> OH, I'M SURE SOME PEOPLE DO >> Reporter: WHAT CAN YOU TELL 1846 00:53:37,982 --> 00:53:38,447 >> Reporter: WHAT CAN YOU TELL FROM A THING LIKE THAT 1847 00:53:38,449 --> 00:53:39,081 FROM A THING LIKE THAT >> IT'S JUST ALWAYS INTERESTING 1848 00:53:39,083 --> 00:53:39,715 >> IT'S JUST ALWAYS INTERESTING WHEN, YOU KNOW, SOMEONE IS GOING 1849 00:53:39,717 --> 00:53:47,456 WHEN, YOU KNOW, SOMEONE IS GOING TO SUCH LENGTHS TO ACT LIKE 1850 00:53:47,458 --> 00:53:51,126 TO SUCH LENGTHS TO ACT LIKE THEY'RE EMOTIONALLY DISTRAUGHT 1851 00:53:51,128 --> 00:53:52,728 THEY'RE EMOTIONALLY DISTRAUGHT AND THE BODY DOESN'T RESPOND - 1852 00:53:52,730 --> 00:53:54,296 AND THE BODY DOESN'T RESPOND - >> Reporter: AND THEN SHE 1853 00:53:54,298 --> 00:53:55,864 >> Reporter: AND THEN SHE DISCOVERED WHAT KATHY DID THE 1854 00:53:55,866 --> 00:53:56,966 DISCOVERED WHAT KATHY DID THE DAY AFTER SHE SAID SHE FOUND 1855 00:53:56,968 --> 00:53:58,000 DAY AFTER SHE SAID SHE FOUND NANCY'S BODY 1856 00:53:58,002 --> 00:53:58,567 NANCY'S BODY SHE WENT TO THE BANK, WHERE 1857 00:53:58,569 --> 00:53:59,134 SHE WENT TO THE BANK, WHERE NANCY HAD TRUSTED KATHY WITH 1858 00:53:59,136 --> 00:54:00,236 NANCY HAD TRUSTED KATHY WITH ACCESS TO HER SAFETY DEPOSIT 1859 00:54:00,238 --> 00:54:00,402 ACCESS TO HER SAFETY DEPOSIT BOX. 1860 00:54:00,404 --> 00:54:01,170 BOX. AND KATHY TOOK FROM THAT BOX THE 1861 00:54:01,172 --> 00:54:02,238 AND KATHY TOOK FROM THAT BOX THE STYLER'S LAST RENT PAYMENT - 1862 00:54:02,240 --> 00:54:03,806 STYLER'S LAST RENT PAYMENT - 6 THOUSAND DOLLARS IN CASH, AND 1863 00:54:03,808 --> 00:54:04,873 6 THOUSAND DOLLARS IN CASH, AND AN HEIRLOOM RING NANCY HAD 1864 00:54:04,875 --> 00:54:05,908 AN HEIRLOOM RING NANCY HAD INHERITED FROM HER MOTHER. 1865 00:54:05,910 --> 00:54:08,844 INHERITED FROM HER MOTHER. >> WITHIN 24 HOURS OR ACTUALLY 1866 00:54:08,846 --> 00:54:12,781 >> WITHIN 24 HOURS OR ACTUALLY IT WAS A LITTLE LESS THAN 1867 00:54:12,783 --> 00:54:13,849 IT WAS A LITTLE LESS THAN 24 HOURS OF HER FRIEND BEING 1868 00:54:13,851 --> 00:54:18,621 24 HOURS OF HER FRIEND BEING FOUND BY HER, SHE'S GOING INTO 1869 00:54:18,623 --> 00:54:19,255 FOUND BY HER, SHE'S GOING INTO THAT SAFETY DEPOSIT BOX, TAKING 1870 00:54:19,257 --> 00:54:21,357 THAT SAFETY DEPOSIT BOX, TAKING $6,000 AND JEWELRY FROM IT 1871 00:54:21,359 --> 00:54:21,957 $6,000 AND JEWELRY FROM IT >> Reporter: SO INVESTIGATORS 1872 00:54:21,959 --> 00:54:22,558 >> Reporter: SO INVESTIGATORS NOW HAD AN IDEA FAST GATHERING 1873 00:54:22,560 --> 00:54:24,927 NOW HAD AN IDEA FAST GATHERING STRENGTH - 1874 00:54:24,929 --> 00:54:32,334 STRENGTH - THAT KATHY CARPENTER WAS FAR 1875 00:54:32,336 --> 00:54:34,436 THAT KATHY CARPENTER WAS FAR MORE INVOLVED THAN SHE CLAIMED 1876 00:54:34,438 --> 00:54:37,072 MORE INVOLVED THAN SHE CLAIMED TO HAVE BEEN 1877 00:54:37,074 --> 00:54:40,242 TO HAVE BEEN >> SHE JUST MADE SOME VERY 1878 00:54:40,244 --> 00:54:43,412 >> SHE JUST MADE SOME VERY DETAILED DESCRIPTIONS OF THAT 1879 00:54:43,414 --> 00:54:44,480 DETAILED DESCRIPTIONS OF THAT BODY THAT SHE COULDN'T HAVE MADE 1880 00:54:44,482 --> 00:54:45,080 BODY THAT SHE COULDN'T HAVE MADE UNLESS SHE HAD SEEN HER BEFORE 1881 00:54:45,082 --> 00:54:45,648 UNLESS SHE HAD SEEN HER BEFORE SHE WAS PUT IN THAT CLOSET, 1882 00:54:45,650 --> 00:54:46,215 SHE WAS PUT IN THAT CLOSET, MEANING RIGHT AFTER SHE WAS 1883 00:54:46,217 --> 00:54:46,615 MEANING RIGHT AFTER SHE WAS ACTUALLY MURDERED. 1884 00:54:46,617 --> 00:54:50,286 ACTUALLY MURDERED. >> Reporter: DID SHE PROVIDE A 1885 00:54:50,288 --> 00:54:52,388 >> Reporter: DID SHE PROVIDE A RATIONAL EXPLANATION FOR THE 1886 00:54:52,390 --> 00:54:53,455 RATIONAL EXPLANATION FOR THE REASON -- FOR -- 1887 00:54:53,457 --> 00:54:53,989 REASON -- FOR -- FOR BEING ABLE TO DO THAT? 1888 00:54:53,991 --> 00:54:54,490 FOR BEING ABLE TO DO THAT? >> NO. 1889 00:54:54,492 --> 00:54:55,524 >> NO. >> Reporter: THEY BROUGHT KATHY 1890 00:54:55,526 --> 00:54:56,025 >> Reporter: THEY BROUGHT KATHY BACK AGAIN AND AGAIN FOR 1891 00:54:56,027 --> 00:54:57,693 BACK AGAIN AND AGAIN FOR QUESTIONING. 1892 00:54:57,695 --> 00:54:58,727 QUESTIONING. FIVE DAYS, ALMOST 20 HOURS OF 1893 00:54:58,729 --> 00:54:59,261 FIVE DAYS, ALMOST 20 HOURS OF QUESTIONING. 1894 00:54:59,263 --> 00:55:00,896 QUESTIONING. DURING ONE INTERROGATION 1895 00:55:00,898 --> 00:55:01,397 DURING ONE INTERROGATION DETECTIVES READ BACK THE 1896 00:55:01,399 --> 00:55:01,930 DETECTIVES READ BACK THE TRANSCRIPT OF THE 911 CALL 1897 00:55:01,932 --> 00:55:02,931 TRANSCRIPT OF THE 911 CALL >> YOU TALKED ABOUT, "MY FRIEND 1898 00:55:02,933 --> 00:55:03,399 >> YOU TALKED ABOUT, "MY FRIEND IN THE CLOSET IS DEAD. 1899 00:55:03,401 --> 00:55:04,033 IN THE CLOSET IS DEAD. YOUR -- IMPOSSIBLE THAT YOU KNEW 1900 00:55:04,035 --> 00:55:04,433 YOUR -- IMPOSSIBLE THAT YOU KNEW THAT SHE WAS DEAD. 1901 00:55:04,435 --> 00:55:05,067 THAT SHE WAS DEAD. IMPOSSIBLE 1902 00:55:05,069 --> 00:55:08,804 IMPOSSIBLE >> Reporter: THREW HER OWNS 1903 00:55:08,806 --> 00:55:09,338 >> Reporter: THREW HER OWNS WORDS AT HER THE BLOOD SHE 1904 00:55:09,340 --> 00:55:10,372 WORDS AT HER THE BLOOD SHE REPORTED SEEING. 1905 00:55:10,374 --> 00:55:11,573 REPORTED SEEING. >> IN THE DISPATCH YOU SAID 1906 00:55:11,575 --> 00:55:12,508 >> IN THE DISPATCH YOU SAID BLOOD ON THE FOREHEAD. 1907 00:55:12,510 --> 00:55:13,075 BLOOD ON THE FOREHEAD. >> Reporter: AND HOW SHE SO 1908 00:55:13,077 --> 00:55:13,642 >> Reporter: AND HOW SHE SO QUICKLY ACCUSED THE STYLERS. 1909 00:55:13,644 --> 00:55:14,243 QUICKLY ACCUSED THE STYLERS. >> SHE HAD SOME PEOPLE LIVING 1910 00:55:14,245 --> 00:55:19,381 >> SHE HAD SOME PEOPLE LIVING THERE. 1911 00:55:19,383 --> 00:55:20,015 THERE. >> Reporter: AND TOLD HER, THEY 1912 00:55:20,017 --> 00:55:22,017 >> Reporter: AND TOLD HER, THEY JUST KNEW SHE WAS LYING. 1913 00:55:22,019 --> 00:55:25,688 JUST KNEW SHE WAS LYING. >> I BELIEVE THAT YOU KNOW WHAT 1914 00:55:25,690 --> 00:55:27,823 >> I BELIEVE THAT YOU KNOW WHAT HAPPENED AND -- NO LISTEN -- AND 1915 00:55:27,825 --> 00:55:29,391 HAPPENED AND -- NO LISTEN -- AND I AM GOING TO BE ABLE TO PROVE 1916 00:55:29,393 --> 00:55:32,027 I AM GOING TO BE ABLE TO PROVE THAT BECAUSE THAT'S MY JOB 1917 00:55:32,029 --> 00:55:32,494 THAT BECAUSE THAT'S MY JOB >> Reporter: AND KATHY 1918 00:55:32,496 --> 00:55:34,663 >> Reporter: AND KATHY CARPENTER, LIKE TREY STYLER, 1919 00:55:34,665 --> 00:55:36,231 CARPENTER, LIKE TREY STYLER, SUBMITTED TO A POLYGRAPH TEST. 1920 00:55:36,233 --> 00:55:37,833 SUBMITTED TO A POLYGRAPH TEST. BUT IF HE FAILED HIS 1921 00:55:37,835 --> 00:55:39,101 BUT IF HE FAILED HIS >> KATHY CARPENTER FAILED HERS 1922 00:55:39,103 --> 00:55:43,105 >> KATHY CARPENTER FAILED HERS WORSE. 1923 00:55:43,107 --> 00:55:46,241 WORSE. >> YOU ABSOLUTELY BOMBED THE 1924 00:55:46,243 --> 00:55:46,942 >> YOU ABSOLUTELY BOMBED THE POLYGRAPH. 1925 00:55:46,944 --> 00:55:47,543 POLYGRAPH. NOT ONLY THAT, ON THE 911, ON 1926 00:55:47,545 --> 00:55:48,177 NOT ONLY THAT, ON THE 911, ON THE 911, RIGHT HERE, HERE'S ALL 1927 00:55:48,179 --> 00:55:53,615 THE 911, RIGHT HERE, HERE'S ALL THIS DOCUMENTATION, OF DECEIT 1928 00:55:53,617 --> 00:56:07,329 THIS DOCUMENTATION, OF DECEIT AND GUILT. 1929 00:56:07,331 --> 00:56:08,397 AND GUILT. >> Reporter: SO FOR DETECTIVES 1930 00:56:08,399 --> 00:56:08,997 >> Reporter: SO FOR DETECTIVES ONLY QUESTION LEFT WAS -- DID 1931 00:56:08,999 --> 00:56:10,499 ONLY QUESTION LEFT WAS -- DID KATHY CARPENTER KILL NANCY AND 1932 00:56:10,501 --> 00:56:11,567 KATHY CARPENTER KILL NANCY AND TRY TO FRAME THE STYLERS -- OR 1933 00:56:11,569 --> 00:56:12,134 TRY TO FRAME THE STYLERS -- OR WERE THEY ALL IN IT TOGETHER 1934 00:56:12,136 --> 00:56:13,135 WERE THEY ALL IN IT TOGETHER >> I DON'T KNOW WHAT THEY'RE 1935 00:56:13,137 --> 00:56:14,703 >> I DON'T KNOW WHAT THEY'RE SAYING 1936 00:56:14,705 --> 00:56:15,003 SAYING THEY'RE LIARS. 1937 00:56:30,520 --> 00:56:33,055 >>> IN THE DISPATCH YOU SAID BLOOD ON THE FOREHEAD. 1938 00:56:33,057 --> 00:56:34,390 BLOOD ON THE FOREHEAD. >> Reporter: HOUR AFTER HOUR, 1939 00:56:34,392 --> 00:56:35,724 >> Reporter: HOUR AFTER HOUR, KATHY CARPENTER TALKED TO THE 1940 00:56:35,726 --> 00:56:36,291 KATHY CARPENTER TALKED TO THE DETECTIVES INVESTIGATING THE 1941 00:56:36,293 --> 00:56:38,360 DETECTIVES INVESTIGATING THE MURDER OF HER FRIEND, 1942 00:56:38,362 --> 00:56:39,428 MURDER OF HER FRIEND, NANCY PFISTER. 1943 00:56:39,430 --> 00:56:42,264 NANCY PFISTER. >> WHAT DID YOU SEE? 1944 00:56:42,266 --> 00:56:48,570 >> WHAT DID YOU SEE? >> I JUST REMEMBER OPENING THE 1945 00:56:48,572 --> 00:56:51,039 >> I JUST REMEMBER OPENING THE DOOR 1946 00:56:51,041 --> 00:56:51,573 DOOR >> OK. 1947 00:56:51,575 --> 00:56:52,007 >> OK. >> SHE WAS COVERED 1948 00:56:52,009 --> 00:56:55,778 >> SHE WAS COVERED >> Reporter: SHE WAS ALONE WITH 1949 00:56:55,780 --> 00:56:57,880 >> Reporter: SHE WAS ALONE WITH THEM 1950 00:56:57,882 --> 00:56:58,447 THEM SHE COULD HAVE ASKED FOR AN 1951 00:56:58,449 --> 00:56:59,448 SHE COULD HAVE ASKED FOR AN ATTORNEY 1952 00:56:59,450 --> 00:57:00,516 ATTORNEY SHE DID NOT. 1953 00:57:00,518 --> 00:57:02,084 SHE DID NOT. SHE TOLD THE DETECTIVES SHE 1954 00:57:02,086 --> 00:57:03,685 SHE TOLD THE DETECTIVES SHE DIDN'T NEED A LAWYER, BECAUSE 1955 00:57:03,687 --> 00:57:07,890 DIDN'T NEED A LAWYER, BECAUSE SHE WAS INNOCENT 1956 00:57:07,892 --> 00:57:10,526 SHE WAS INNOCENT BUT, AS KATHY WENT ON AND ON, 1957 00:57:10,528 --> 00:57:12,127 BUT, AS KATHY WENT ON AND ON, THOSE DETECTIVES BECAME MORE AND 1958 00:57:12,129 --> 00:57:13,629 THOSE DETECTIVES BECAME MORE AND MORE SURE SHE KILLED HER FRIEND 1959 00:57:13,631 --> 00:57:14,163 MORE SURE SHE KILLED HER FRIEND NANCY. 1960 00:57:14,165 --> 00:57:14,596 NANCY. OR HELPED, AT LEAST. 1961 00:57:14,598 --> 00:57:15,230 OR HELPED, AT LEAST. >> SO RIGHT NOW I'M TELLING YOU, 1962 00:57:15,232 --> 00:57:15,831 >> SO RIGHT NOW I'M TELLING YOU, EVERYTHING IS CRASHING DOWN ON 1963 00:57:15,833 --> 00:57:16,832 EVERYTHING IS CRASHING DOWN ON YOU. 1964 00:57:16,834 --> 00:57:17,933 YOU. I KID YOU NOT, IT'S ABSOLUTELY 1965 00:57:17,935 --> 00:57:18,400 I KID YOU NOT, IT'S ABSOLUTELY COMING DOWN. 1966 00:57:18,402 --> 00:57:19,001 COMING DOWN. >> Reporter: THE QUESTION NOW 1967 00:57:19,003 --> 00:57:19,601 >> Reporter: THE QUESTION NOW WAS KATHY TRYING TO FRAME THE 1968 00:57:19,603 --> 00:57:20,035 WAS KATHY TRYING TO FRAME THE STYLERS? 1969 00:57:20,037 --> 00:57:21,603 STYLERS? AT FIRST BLUSH IT CERTAINLY 1970 00:57:21,605 --> 00:57:22,137 AT FIRST BLUSH IT CERTAINLY LOOKED THAT WAY. 1971 00:57:22,139 --> 00:57:23,172 LOOKED THAT WAY. AND YET THE MORE THEY THOUGHT 1972 00:57:23,174 --> 00:57:24,740 AND YET THE MORE THEY THOUGHT ABOUT IT THE MORE UNLIKELY IT 1973 00:57:24,742 --> 00:57:26,308 ABOUT IT THE MORE UNLIKELY IT SEEMED 1974 00:57:26,310 --> 00:57:27,376 SEEMED WHY? 1975 00:57:27,378 --> 00:57:31,079 WHY? WELL, THE TRASH BAG CONTAINING 1976 00:57:31,081 --> 00:57:31,713 WELL, THE TRASH BAG CONTAINING SO MUCH INCRIMINATING EVIDENCE, 1977 00:57:31,715 --> 00:57:33,715 SO MUCH INCRIMINATING EVIDENCE, FOR EXAMPLE. 1978 00:57:33,717 --> 00:57:35,317 FOR EXAMPLE. THE ONE THE DILIGENT CITY WORKER 1979 00:57:35,319 --> 00:57:36,385 THE ONE THE DILIGENT CITY WORKER JUST HAPPENED TO STUMBLE ON. 1980 00:57:36,387 --> 00:57:39,021 JUST HAPPENED TO STUMBLE ON. >> I REALLY THINK THAT THIS WAS 1981 00:57:39,023 --> 00:57:40,055 >> I REALLY THINK THAT THIS WAS ACTUALLY PURE LUCK 1982 00:57:40,057 --> 00:57:41,123 ACTUALLY PURE LUCK I DON'T THINK ANYONE WANTED THAT 1983 00:57:41,125 --> 00:57:42,157 I DON'T THINK ANYONE WANTED THAT TO BE FOUND. 1984 00:57:42,159 --> 00:57:44,059 TO BE FOUND. I THINK REALLY THE SIMPLE 1985 00:57:44,061 --> 00:57:45,360 I THINK REALLY THE SIMPLE EXPLANATION HERE IS REALLY THE 1986 00:57:45,362 --> 00:57:46,962 EXPLANATION HERE IS REALLY THE RIGHT EXPLANATION, WHICH IS THAT 1987 00:57:46,964 --> 00:57:47,996 RIGHT EXPLANATION, WHICH IS THAT WE HAD A GREAT BREAK IN THE CASE 1988 00:57:47,998 --> 00:57:50,666 WE HAD A GREAT BREAK IN THE CASE AND YOU KNOW, THANK GOODNESS FOR 1989 00:57:50,668 --> 00:57:52,234 AND YOU KNOW, THANK GOODNESS FOR THAT 1990 00:57:52,236 --> 00:57:54,369 THAT >> Reporter: THE ONLY CONSPIRACY 1991 00:57:54,371 --> 00:57:56,505 >> Reporter: THE ONLY CONSPIRACY THEORY ASSISTANT D.A 1992 00:57:56,507 --> 00:57:57,539 THEORY ASSISTANT D.A ANDREA BRYAN WAS BUYING WAS ONE 1993 00:57:57,541 --> 00:57:59,107 ANDREA BRYAN WAS BUYING WAS ONE THAT INVOLVED THE STYLERS AND 1994 00:57:59,109 --> 00:58:00,175 THAT INVOLVED THE STYLERS AND KATHY CARPENTER -- ALL OF THEM 1995 00:58:00,177 --> 00:58:04,947 KATHY CARPENTER -- ALL OF THEM TOGETHER COMMITTING THE MURDER 1996 00:58:04,949 --> 00:58:05,714 TOGETHER COMMITTING THE MURDER THE TWO WOMEN PERHAPS BONDING 1997 00:58:05,716 --> 00:58:06,315 THE TWO WOMEN PERHAPS BONDING OVER THEIR SHARED FRUSTRATION 1998 00:58:06,317 --> 00:58:09,651 OVER THEIR SHARED FRUSTRATION WITH NANCY PFISTER'S BEHAVIORS 1999 00:58:09,653 --> 00:58:10,285 WITH NANCY PFISTER'S BEHAVIORS >> IT APPEARS THAT THEY UM - 2000 00:58:10,287 --> 00:58:11,253 >> IT APPEARS THAT THEY UM - ALMOST BUILT, AT TIMES, A BIT OF 2001 00:58:11,255 --> 00:58:12,955 ALMOST BUILT, AT TIMES, A BIT OF A FRIENDSHIP AROUND THAT MUTUAL 2002 00:58:12,957 --> 00:58:14,923 A FRIENDSHIP AROUND THAT MUTUAL ANGER TOWARD NANCY PFISTER 2003 00:58:14,925 --> 00:58:15,991 ANGER TOWARD NANCY PFISTER >> Reporter: AND TREY, PUSHED TO 2004 00:58:15,993 --> 00:58:16,558 >> Reporter: AND TREY, PUSHED TO HIS FINANCIAL AND EMOTIONAL 2005 00:58:16,560 --> 00:58:20,729 HIS FINANCIAL AND EMOTIONAL LIMITS, WAS MOST LIKELY THE ONE 2006 00:58:20,731 --> 00:58:22,331 LIMITS, WAS MOST LIKELY THE ONE TO WIELD THE HAMMER. 2007 00:58:22,333 --> 00:58:24,967 TO WIELD THE HAMMER. REASONED THE ASSISTANT D.A., 2008 00:58:24,969 --> 00:58:26,568 REASONED THE ASSISTANT D.A., WHILE THE WOMEN HELPED HIDE THE 2009 00:58:26,570 --> 00:58:27,603 WHILE THE WOMEN HELPED HIDE THE BODY AND CLEAN UP THE BEDROOM. 2010 00:58:27,605 --> 00:58:28,203 BODY AND CLEAN UP THE BEDROOM. BUT, IF THAT THEORY WAS RIGHT, 2011 00:58:28,205 --> 00:58:30,038 BUT, IF THAT THEORY WAS RIGHT, SOMETHING WENT WRONG AFTER THE 2012 00:58:30,040 --> 00:58:35,544 SOMETHING WENT WRONG AFTER THE MURDER -- THE CONSPIRACY DID NOT 2013 00:58:35,546 --> 00:58:37,145 MURDER -- THE CONSPIRACY DID NOT HOLD 2014 00:58:37,147 --> 00:58:41,884 HOLD >> WHEN KATHY CARPENTER, 2015 00:58:41,886 --> 00:58:44,553 >> WHEN KATHY CARPENTER, REALIZED THE GRAVITY OF WHAT SHE 2016 00:58:44,555 --> 00:58:45,187 REALIZED THE GRAVITY OF WHAT SHE HAD GOTTEN HERSELF INTO SHE GOT 2017 00:58:45,189 --> 00:58:47,723 HAD GOTTEN HERSELF INTO SHE GOT WORRIED UM AND -- WORRIED THAT 2018 00:58:47,725 --> 00:58:48,190 WORRIED UM AND -- WORRIED THAT SHE WOULD BE FINGERED. 2019 00:58:48,192 --> 00:58:49,825 SHE WOULD BE FINGERED. >> Reporter: SO KATHY STRUCK 2020 00:58:49,827 --> 00:58:51,393 >> Reporter: SO KATHY STRUCK FIRST, THE D.A.'S THEORY WENT -- 2021 00:58:51,395 --> 00:58:51,960 FIRST, THE D.A.'S THEORY WENT -- CALLED 911 AND FINGERED THE 2022 00:58:51,962 --> 00:58:53,529 CALLED 911 AND FINGERED THE STYLERS TO DEFLECT ATTENTION 2023 00:58:53,531 --> 00:58:54,596 STYLERS TO DEFLECT ATTENTION FROM HERSELF 2024 00:58:54,598 --> 00:58:56,532 FROM HERSELF IN THE INTERROGATION ROOM, 2025 00:58:56,534 --> 00:58:57,132 IN THE INTERROGATION ROOM, INVESTIGATORS HAD TRIED TO GET 2026 00:58:57,134 --> 00:58:58,800 INVESTIGATORS HAD TRIED TO GET TREY TO TURN ON HIS WIFE OR 2027 00:58:58,802 --> 00:58:59,835 TREY TO TURN ON HIS WIFE OR KATHY. 2028 00:58:59,837 --> 00:59:00,903 KATHY. >> NANCY YOUR WIFE, DO YOU WANT 2029 00:59:00,905 --> 00:59:03,005 >> NANCY YOUR WIFE, DO YOU WANT HER TO BE INVOLVED IN THIS 2030 00:59:03,007 --> 00:59:03,572 HER TO BE INVOLVED IN THIS SHE'S WRAPPED UP IN THIS MAN 2031 00:59:03,574 --> 00:59:04,573 SHE'S WRAPPED UP IN THIS MAN WE'VE HAD HER HERE AS LONG AS 2032 00:59:04,575 --> 00:59:05,107 WE'VE HAD HER HERE AS LONG AS YOU HAVE 2033 00:59:05,109 --> 00:59:07,242 YOU HAVE SHE'S TELLING US A LOT OF GOOD 2034 00:59:07,244 --> 00:59:07,776 SHE'S TELLING US A LOT OF GOOD STUFF. 2035 00:59:07,778 --> 00:59:09,144 STUFF. >> Reporter: AND THEY ALSO TRIED 2036 00:59:09,146 --> 00:59:10,946 >> Reporter: AND THEY ALSO TRIED TO GET KATHY TO FLIP ON THE 2037 00:59:10,948 --> 00:59:13,048 TO GET KATHY TO FLIP ON THE STYLERS. 2038 00:59:13,050 --> 00:59:14,116 STYLERS. >> SOMEBODY IS GOING TO COME 2039 00:59:14,118 --> 00:59:15,150 >> SOMEBODY IS GOING TO COME CLEAN TO SAY I DID IT, BUT THIS 2040 00:59:15,152 --> 00:59:16,218 CLEAN TO SAY I DID IT, BUT THIS IS WHAT SHE KNEW 2041 00:59:16,220 --> 00:59:17,286 IS WHAT SHE KNEW BUT SHE DIDN'T TELL US THAT. 2042 00:59:17,288 --> 00:59:19,388 BUT SHE DIDN'T TELL US THAT. NOW YOU ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR IT 2043 00:59:19,390 --> 00:59:20,956 NOW YOU ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR IT JUST LIKE THEM 2044 00:59:20,958 --> 00:59:21,723 JUST LIKE THEM BUT YOU'RE GOING TO BE THE ONE 2045 00:59:21,725 --> 00:59:22,524 BUT YOU'RE GOING TO BE THE ONE LEFT OUT THAT DIDN'T TELL THE 2046 00:59:22,526 --> 00:59:24,660 LEFT OUT THAT DIDN'T TELL THE TRUTH. 2047 00:59:24,662 --> 00:59:25,661 TRUTH. >> Reporter: BUT IT DIDN'T WORK. 2048 00:59:25,663 --> 00:59:26,762 >> Reporter: BUT IT DIDN'T WORK. >> I JUST HAVE MY SUSPICIONS 2049 00:59:26,764 --> 00:59:27,296 >> I JUST HAVE MY SUSPICIONS OF - 2050 00:59:27,298 --> 00:59:28,330 OF - >> WHAT YOU SEE, NO, NO, NO, NO 2051 00:59:28,332 --> 00:59:32,534 >> WHAT YOU SEE, NO, NO, NO, NO NO 2052 00:59:32,536 --> 00:59:33,602 NO OKAY, OKAY 2053 00:59:33,604 --> 00:59:34,670 OKAY, OKAY >> BUT I DIDN'T DO ANYTHING TO 2054 00:59:34,672 --> 00:59:36,238 >> BUT I DIDN'T DO ANYTHING TO HER. 2055 00:59:36,240 --> 00:59:37,806 HER. >> Reporter: ON MARCH 14, THREE 2056 00:59:37,808 --> 00:59:39,441 >> Reporter: ON MARCH 14, THREE WEEKS AFTER NANCY PFISTER HAD 2057 00:59:39,443 --> 00:59:40,976 WEEKS AFTER NANCY PFISTER HAD BEEN MURDERED, KATHY CARPENTER, 2058 00:59:40,978 --> 00:59:43,345 BEEN MURDERED, KATHY CARPENTER, LIKE THE STYLERS BEFORE HER, WAS 2059 00:59:43,347 --> 00:59:44,146 LIKE THE STYLERS BEFORE HER, WAS CHARGED WITH FIRST DEGREE MURDER 2060 00:59:44,148 --> 00:59:45,747 CHARGED WITH FIRST DEGREE MURDER AND PUT IN THE COUNTY JAIL 2061 00:59:45,749 --> 00:59:47,316 AND PUT IN THE COUNTY JAIL >> THE NEWEST SUSPECT ARRESTED 2062 00:59:47,318 --> 00:59:48,383 >> THE NEWEST SUSPECT ARRESTED WAS KATHERINE CARPENTER. 2063 00:59:48,385 --> 00:59:48,984 WAS KATHERINE CARPENTER. >> Reporter: BILLY CLAYTON HAD 2064 00:59:48,986 --> 00:59:49,551 >> Reporter: BILLY CLAYTON HAD BEEN ON THE PHONE WITH KATHY 2065 00:59:49,553 --> 00:59:52,054 BEEN ON THE PHONE WITH KATHY JUST THE DAY BEFORE DISCUSSING 2066 00:59:52,056 --> 00:59:54,189 JUST THE DAY BEFORE DISCUSSING NANCY'S MEMORIAL SERVICE 2067 00:59:54,191 --> 00:59:55,757 NANCY'S MEMORIAL SERVICE >> AND I THINK I WAS SUPPOSED TO 2068 00:59:55,759 --> 01:00:00,429 >> AND I THINK I WAS SUPPOSED TO GET SOMETHING FOR HER TO WEAR TO 2069 01:00:00,431 --> 01:00:03,165 GET SOMETHING FOR HER TO WEAR TO THE MEMORIAL 2070 01:00:03,167 --> 01:00:05,267 THE MEMORIAL >> Reporter: AND NOW, SHE WAS 2071 01:00:05,269 --> 01:00:06,835 >> Reporter: AND NOW, SHE WAS BEHIND BARS. 2072 01:00:06,837 --> 01:00:08,437 BEHIND BARS. SEEMED CRAZY, BUT IN A TOWN THAT 2073 01:00:08,439 --> 01:00:10,539 SEEMED CRAZY, BUT IN A TOWN THAT COULD BARELY BELIEVE ONE OF ITS 2074 01:00:10,541 --> 01:00:12,140 COULD BARELY BELIEVE ONE OF ITS OWN HAD BEEN MURDERED, ANYTHING 2075 01:00:12,142 --> 01:00:14,776 OWN HAD BEEN MURDERED, ANYTHING SEEMED POSSIBLE NOW. 2076 01:00:14,778 --> 01:00:17,446 SEEMED POSSIBLE NOW. >> I SHOULD'VE BEEN SURPRISED OR 2077 01:00:17,448 --> 01:00:18,480 >> I SHOULD'VE BEEN SURPRISED OR SHOCKED OR SOMETHING 2078 01:00:18,482 --> 01:00:19,548 SHOCKED OR SOMETHING BUT AT THAT MOMENT I JUST -- I 2079 01:00:19,550 --> 01:00:22,718 BUT AT THAT MOMENT I JUST -- I WAS LIKE, YOU KNOW -- WHO KNOWS? 2080 01:00:22,720 --> 01:00:24,786 WAS LIKE, YOU KNOW -- WHO KNOWS? ANY -- ANYTHING COULD HAPPEN 2081 01:00:24,788 --> 01:00:26,421 ANY -- ANYTHING COULD HAPPEN I JUST -- IT DIDN'T MAKE ANY 2082 01:00:26,423 --> 01:00:29,057 I JUST -- IT DIDN'T MAKE ANY SENSE AT ALL WHY ANYONE WOULD 2083 01:00:29,059 --> 01:00:31,159 SENSE AT ALL WHY ANYONE WOULD KILL HER 2084 01:00:31,161 --> 01:00:34,830 KILL HER >> Reporter: AND SO AS BILLY AND 2085 01:00:34,832 --> 01:00:35,897 >> Reporter: AND SO AS BILLY AND THE OTHERS WENT ON FINALIZING 2086 01:00:35,899 --> 01:00:38,000 THE OTHERS WENT ON FINALIZING MEMORIAL PLANS, KATHY, A BIT 2087 01:00:38,002 --> 01:00:38,634 MEMORIAL PLANS, KATHY, A BIT LATE, GOT A LAWYER - 2088 01:00:38,636 --> 01:00:42,971 LATE, GOT A LAWYER - GREG GREER 2089 01:00:42,973 --> 01:00:43,772 GREG GREER >> THIS HAS BEEN ONE OF THE MORE 2090 01:00:43,774 --> 01:00:45,173 >> THIS HAS BEEN ONE OF THE MORE FRIGHTENING EXPERIENCES OF MY 2091 01:00:45,175 --> 01:00:48,543 FRIGHTENING EXPERIENCES OF MY CAREER, TO REPRESENT A PERSON 2092 01:00:48,545 --> 01:00:51,713 CAREER, TO REPRESENT A PERSON WHO IS SO TOTALLY AND COMPLETELY 2093 01:00:51,715 --> 01:00:52,748 WHO IS SO TOTALLY AND COMPLETELY INNOCENT 2094 01:00:52,750 --> 01:00:54,182 INNOCENT >> Reporter: AS GREER AND THE 2095 01:00:54,184 --> 01:00:55,984 >> Reporter: AS GREER AND THE LAWYERS REPRESENTING THE STYLERS 2096 01:00:55,986 --> 01:00:57,519 LAWYERS REPRESENTING THE STYLERS WADED THROUGH THE EVIDENCE, 2097 01:00:57,521 --> 01:01:02,257 WADED THROUGH THE EVIDENCE, TRYING TO SORT OUT WHO DID WHAT, 2098 01:01:02,259 --> 01:01:22,044 TRYING TO SORT OUT WHO DID WHAT, IT BECAME PRETTY CLEAR, TO THEM 2099 01:01:22,046 --> 01:01:22,644 IT BECAME PRETTY CLEAR, TO THEM >> REPORTER: IT WAS JUST WHERE 2100 01:01:22,646 --> 01:01:23,245 >> REPORTER: IT WAS JUST WHERE SHE WOULD HAVE WANTED HER LAST 2101 01:01:23,247 --> 01:01:24,646 SHE WOULD HAVE WANTED HER LAST PARTY -- ASPEN'S HISTORIC HOTEL 2102 01:01:24,648 --> 01:01:25,714 PARTY -- ASPEN'S HISTORIC HOTEL JEROME 2103 01:01:25,716 --> 01:01:27,816 JEROME AND BY THEIR HUNDREDS, LOCALS 2104 01:01:27,818 --> 01:01:28,383 AND BY THEIR HUNDREDS, LOCALS CROWDED IN OUT OF THE FRIGID 2105 01:01:28,385 --> 01:01:29,918 CROWDED IN OUT OF THE FRIGID MARCH NIGHT TWO AND A HALF WEEKS 2106 01:01:29,920 --> 01:01:30,986 MARCH NIGHT TWO AND A HALF WEEKS AFTER THE MURDER 2107 01:01:30,988 --> 01:01:32,554 AFTER THE MURDER TO TELL CRAZY STORIES, AND 2108 01:01:32,556 --> 01:01:41,029 TO TELL CRAZY STORIES, AND REMEMBER THE AMAZING LIFE OF 2109 01:01:41,031 --> 01:01:41,563 REMEMBER THE AMAZING LIFE OF NANCY PFISTER. 2110 01:01:41,565 --> 01:01:46,868 NANCY PFISTER. >> THERE WERE SO MANY PEOPLE 2111 01:01:46,870 --> 01:01:48,136 >> THERE WERE SO MANY PEOPLE THAT THEY COULDN'T ALL FIT IN 2112 01:01:48,138 --> 01:01:51,606 THAT THEY COULDN'T ALL FIT IN THE JEROME HOTEL BALLROOM. 2113 01:01:51,608 --> 01:01:58,447 THE JEROME HOTEL BALLROOM. THEY WENT OUT THE DOOR INTO THE 2114 01:01:58,449 --> 01:02:00,515 THEY WENT OUT THE DOOR INTO THE HALLWAYS 2115 01:02:00,517 --> 01:02:01,616 HALLWAYS >> Reporter: WHAT DO YOU SAY TO 2116 01:02:01,618 --> 01:02:02,150 >> Reporter: WHAT DO YOU SAY TO A CROWD LIKE THAT? 2117 01:02:02,152 --> 01:02:04,820 A CROWD LIKE THAT? >> I JUST BASICALLY WANTED TO 2118 01:02:04,822 --> 01:02:07,656 >> I JUST BASICALLY WANTED TO CELEBRATE HER LIFE AND HER 2119 01:02:07,658 --> 01:02:08,090 CELEBRATE HER LIFE AND HER SPIRIT OF ADVENTURE. 2120 01:02:08,092 --> 01:02:09,558 SPIRIT OF ADVENTURE. >> Reporter: BILLY CLAYTON GOT 2121 01:02:09,560 --> 01:02:12,160 >> Reporter: BILLY CLAYTON GOT UP TOO, SAID WHAT WAS IN HIS 2122 01:02:12,162 --> 01:02:14,830 UP TOO, SAID WHAT WAS IN HIS HEART. 2123 01:02:14,832 --> 01:02:16,398 HEART. >> I SAID THAT IF YOU'VE KNOWN 2124 01:02:16,400 --> 01:02:17,466 >> I SAID THAT IF YOU'VE KNOWN ME OVER THE LAST 40 YEARS OR SO, 2125 01:02:17,468 --> 01:02:21,169 ME OVER THE LAST 40 YEARS OR SO, YOU KNOW ME BECAUSE OF NANCY 2126 01:02:21,171 --> 01:02:22,738 YOU KNOW ME BECAUSE OF NANCY WHEN YOU SEE ME, YOU THINK OF 2127 01:02:22,740 --> 01:02:25,907 WHEN YOU SEE ME, YOU THINK OF NANCY. 2128 01:02:25,909 --> 01:02:28,043 NANCY. SHE WAS A CONNECTOR. 2129 01:02:28,045 --> 01:02:34,216 SHE WAS A CONNECTOR. THAT WAS HER REAL, MAIN ROLE, I 2130 01:02:34,218 --> 01:02:34,750 THAT WAS HER REAL, MAIN ROLE, I THINK, IN EVERYONE'S LIFE. 2131 01:02:34,752 --> 01:02:36,451 THINK, IN EVERYONE'S LIFE. >> Reporter: AND WHEN YOU LOOKED 2132 01:02:36,453 --> 01:02:39,087 >> Reporter: AND WHEN YOU LOOKED DOWN THERE IN THAT CROWD, HOW 2133 01:02:39,089 --> 01:02:39,621 DOWN THERE IN THAT CROWD, HOW WERE THEY REACTING 2134 01:02:39,623 --> 01:02:40,155 WERE THEY REACTING >> A LOT OF TEARS. 2135 01:02:40,157 --> 01:02:40,689 >> A LOT OF TEARS. A LOT OF LAUGHTER. 2136 01:02:40,691 --> 01:02:41,757 A LOT OF LAUGHTER. CERTAIN STORIES. 2137 01:02:41,759 --> 01:02:42,290 CERTAIN STORIES. AND -- THEY WERE ALL JUST 2138 01:02:42,292 --> 01:02:42,891 AND -- THEY WERE ALL JUST SOLIDLY THERE IN THAT SPACE AT 2139 01:02:42,893 --> 01:02:43,325 SOLIDLY THERE IN THAT SPACE AT THAT MOMENT. 2140 01:02:43,327 --> 01:02:44,025 THAT MOMENT. >> Reporter: BUT AT THAT VERY 2141 01:02:44,027 --> 01:02:44,926 >> Reporter: BUT AT THAT VERY SAME MOMENT, IN A FAR DIFFERENT 2142 01:02:44,928 --> 01:02:45,627 SAME MOMENT, IN A FAR DIFFERENT SPACE JUST DOWN THE STREET FROM 2143 01:02:45,629 --> 01:02:46,995 SPACE JUST DOWN THE STREET FROM THE FINE OLD HOTEL JEROME KATHY 2144 01:02:46,997 --> 01:02:48,096 THE FINE OLD HOTEL JEROME KATHY CARPENTER WEPT IN HER CELL AT 2145 01:02:48,098 --> 01:02:50,198 CARPENTER WEPT IN HER CELL AT THE PITKEN COUNTY JAIL, AND 2146 01:02:50,200 --> 01:02:52,300 THE PITKEN COUNTY JAIL, AND LISTENED 2147 01:02:52,302 --> 01:02:54,436 LISTENED >> COULD HEAR THE MUSIC, THE 2148 01:02:54,438 --> 01:02:57,038 >> COULD HEAR THE MUSIC, THE BAND 2149 01:02:57,040 --> 01:02:59,174 BAND AND UM -- I JUST, I CRIED. 2150 01:02:59,176 --> 01:03:01,810 AND UM -- I JUST, I CRIED. I CRIED A LOT. 2151 01:03:01,812 --> 01:03:03,378 I CRIED A LOT. I WANTED TO BE THERE 2152 01:03:03,380 --> 01:03:09,084 I WANTED TO BE THERE I SHOULD HAVE BEEN THERE 2153 01:03:09,086 --> 01:03:10,752 I SHOULD HAVE BEEN THERE AND IT HURT. 2154 01:03:10,754 --> 01:03:14,456 AND IT HURT. >> Reporter: HOW COULD THEY 2155 01:03:14,458 --> 01:03:16,024 >> Reporter: HOW COULD THEY THINK SHE HAD ANYTHING TO DO 2156 01:03:16,026 --> 01:03:16,558 THINK SHE HAD ANYTHING TO DO WITH IT? 2157 01:03:16,560 --> 01:03:17,592 WITH IT? THERE WAS SOME SUGGESTION THAT 2158 01:03:17,594 --> 01:03:18,059 THERE WAS SOME SUGGESTION THAT YOU HAD A MOTIVE TO -- 2159 01:03:18,061 --> 01:03:18,326 YOU HAD A MOTIVE TO -- HARM NANCY 2160 01:03:18,328 --> 01:03:18,727 HARM NANCY >> ABSOLUTELY NOT. 2161 01:03:18,729 --> 01:03:19,227 >> ABSOLUTELY NOT. WHAT WAS MY MOTIVE 2162 01:03:19,229 --> 01:03:19,761 WHAT WAS MY MOTIVE THERE IS NO MOTIVE 2163 01:03:19,763 --> 01:03:20,228 THERE IS NO MOTIVE >> Reporter: A SHARED 2164 01:03:20,230 --> 01:03:20,929 >> Reporter: A SHARED FRUSTRATION WITH NANCY STYLER 2165 01:03:20,931 --> 01:03:21,396 FRUSTRATION WITH NANCY STYLER ABOUT HOW DIFFICULT -- 2166 01:03:21,398 --> 01:03:22,264 ABOUT HOW DIFFICULT -- >> OH, HEAVENS NO. 2167 01:03:22,266 --> 01:03:27,936 >> OH, HEAVENS NO. NO 2168 01:03:27,938 --> 01:03:28,703 NO NOT AT ALL 2169 01:03:28,705 --> 01:03:29,771 NOT AT ALL >> Reporter: NANCY WAS HER BEST 2170 01:03:29,773 --> 01:03:31,339 >> Reporter: NANCY WAS HER BEST FRIEND, SHE SAID 2171 01:03:31,341 --> 01:03:32,607 FRIEND, SHE SAID >> I LOVED HER 2172 01:03:32,609 --> 01:03:33,475 >> I LOVED HER SHE WAS -- I LOVED NANCY 2173 01:03:33,477 --> 01:03:35,076 SHE WAS -- I LOVED NANCY PFISTER. 2174 01:03:35,078 --> 01:03:36,645 PFISTER. >> Reporter: THAT'S WHY SHE SAT 2175 01:03:36,647 --> 01:03:38,480 >> Reporter: THAT'S WHY SHE SAT THROUGH ALL THOSE HOURS OF 2176 01:03:38,482 --> 01:03:40,348 THROUGH ALL THOSE HOURS OF INTERROGATION WITHOUT A LAWYER, 2177 01:03:40,350 --> 01:03:41,383 INTERROGATION WITHOUT A LAWYER, SHE SAID 2178 01:03:41,385 --> 01:03:42,450 SHE SAID SHE WANTED TO HELP THEM 2179 01:03:42,452 --> 01:03:44,052 SHE WANTED TO HELP THEM UNDERSTAND THE TRUTH 2180 01:03:44,054 --> 01:03:46,154 UNDERSTAND THE TRUTH LIKE, FOR EXAMPLE, HOW IT WASN'T 2181 01:03:46,156 --> 01:03:47,189 LIKE, FOR EXAMPLE, HOW IT WASN'T AT ALL SUSPICIOUS THAT SHE KNEW 2182 01:03:47,191 --> 01:03:48,223 AT ALL SUSPICIOUS THAT SHE KNEW RIGHT AWAY IT WAS NANCY IN THAT 2183 01:03:48,225 --> 01:03:48,423 RIGHT AWAY IT WAS NANCY IN THAT CLOSET 2184 01:03:48,425 --> 01:03:49,057 CLOSET >> YOU KNOW THE ODOR JUST ABOUT 2185 01:03:49,059 --> 01:03:49,424 >> YOU KNOW THE ODOR JUST ABOUT KNOCKED ME OVER. 2186 01:03:49,426 --> 01:03:50,392 KNOCKED ME OVER. AND -- TO ME, IT WAS VERY 2187 01:03:50,394 --> 01:03:52,494 AND -- TO ME, IT WAS VERY APPARENT THAT THAT WASN'T JUST A 2188 01:03:52,496 --> 01:03:53,094 APPARENT THAT THAT WASN'T JUST A PILE OF CLOTHES IN THE CLOSET. 2189 01:03:53,096 --> 01:03:55,096 PILE OF CLOTHES IN THE CLOSET. WHO ELSE BUT NANCY WOULD BE IN 2190 01:03:55,098 --> 01:03:56,698 WHO ELSE BUT NANCY WOULD BE IN THAT CLOSET? 2191 01:03:56,700 --> 01:03:59,334 THAT CLOSET? >> Reporter: YOU WEREN'T A 2192 01:03:59,336 --> 01:04:03,004 >> Reporter: YOU WEREN'T A COMPLETE IDIOT 2193 01:04:03,006 --> 01:04:04,272 COMPLETE IDIOT YOU UNDERSTOOD -- THAT WAS - 2194 01:04:04,274 --> 01:04:08,276 YOU UNDERSTOOD -- THAT WAS - HAD TO BE NANCY -- 2195 01:04:08,278 --> 01:04:15,684 HAD TO BE NANCY -- >> RIGHT, WHO ELSE WOULD IT BE 2196 01:04:15,686 --> 01:04:19,387 >> RIGHT, WHO ELSE WOULD IT BE >> Reporter: AND WHEN SHE SO 2197 01:04:19,389 --> 01:04:20,956 >> Reporter: AND WHEN SHE SO QUICKLY FINGERED THE STYLERS, 2198 01:04:20,958 --> 01:04:21,990 QUICKLY FINGERED THE STYLERS, SHE SAID, IT WAS JUST COMMON 2199 01:04:21,992 --> 01:04:23,592 SHE SAID, IT WAS JUST COMMON SENSE. 2200 01:04:23,594 --> 01:04:24,626 SENSE. >> THEY WERE IN THE HOUSE. 2201 01:04:24,628 --> 01:04:25,660 >> THEY WERE IN THE HOUSE. >> Reporter: YOU KNEW THAT THEY 2202 01:04:25,662 --> 01:04:26,161 >> Reporter: YOU KNEW THAT THEY WERE PRETTY MAD AT NANCY 2203 01:04:26,163 --> 01:04:26,761 WERE PRETTY MAD AT NANCY >> THEY WERE MAD -- THEY WERE 2204 01:04:26,763 --> 01:04:27,095 >> THEY WERE MAD -- THEY WERE UPSET WITH HER 2205 01:04:27,097 --> 01:04:27,662 UPSET WITH HER >> Reporter: BUT WHAT ABOUT 2206 01:04:27,664 --> 01:04:28,296 >> Reporter: BUT WHAT ABOUT THOSE SUSPICIOUS LITTLE DETAILS 2207 01:04:28,298 --> 01:04:28,864 THOSE SUSPICIOUS LITTLE DETAILS LIKE SAYING SHE SAW BLOOD ON 2208 01:04:28,866 --> 01:04:29,464 LIKE SAYING SHE SAW BLOOD ON NANCY'S FOREHEAD WHEN NANCY'S 2209 01:04:29,466 --> 01:04:30,098 NANCY'S FOREHEAD WHEN NANCY'S FOREHEAD WAS COMPLETELY COVERED 2210 01:04:30,100 --> 01:04:30,232 FOREHEAD WAS COMPLETELY COVERED UP 2211 01:04:30,234 --> 01:04:30,799 UP >> IN THE DISPATCH YOU SAID 2212 01:04:30,801 --> 01:04:31,266 >> IN THE DISPATCH YOU SAID BLOOD ON THE FOREHEAD. 2213 01:04:31,268 --> 01:04:31,833 BLOOD ON THE FOREHEAD. >> Reporter: THAT'S EASY TO 2214 01:04:31,835 --> 01:04:32,267 >> Reporter: THAT'S EASY TO EXPLAIN, SAID KATHY. 2215 01:04:32,269 --> 01:04:32,834 EXPLAIN, SAID KATHY. SHE NEVER ACTUALLY SAID THAT 2216 01:04:32,836 --> 01:04:33,602 SHE NEVER ACTUALLY SAID THAT >> THEY SAID THAT I SAW HER 2217 01:04:33,604 --> 01:04:35,203 >> THEY SAID THAT I SAW HER FOREHEAD 2218 01:04:35,205 --> 01:04:37,272 FOREHEAD >> Reporter: YES 2219 01:04:37,274 --> 01:04:38,340 >> Reporter: YES >> I DID NOT SEE HER FOREHEAD. 2220 01:04:38,342 --> 01:04:39,407 >> I DID NOT SEE HER FOREHEAD. I SAW BLOOD ON THE HEADBOARD 2221 01:04:39,409 --> 01:04:40,442 I SAW BLOOD ON THE HEADBOARD >> Reporter: HEADBOARD 2222 01:04:40,444 --> 01:04:41,443 >> Reporter: HEADBOARD IN FACT, CRIME SCENE TECHS DID 2223 01:04:41,445 --> 01:04:42,544 IN FACT, CRIME SCENE TECHS DID FIND BLOOD ON NANCY PFISTER'S 2224 01:04:42,546 --> 01:04:44,145 FIND BLOOD ON NANCY PFISTER'S HEADBOARD, BUT, HEADBOARD IS NOT 2225 01:04:44,147 --> 01:04:44,713 HEADBOARD, BUT, HEADBOARD IS NOT THE WORD THAT APPEARS IN THE 2226 01:04:44,715 --> 01:04:46,248 THE WORD THAT APPEARS IN THE TYPED TRANSCRIPT OF THE 2227 01:04:46,250 --> 01:04:49,417 TYPED TRANSCRIPT OF THE 911 CALL 2228 01:04:49,419 --> 01:04:51,553 911 CALL >> AND ON PAGE THREE OF THAT 2229 01:04:51,555 --> 01:04:53,121 >> AND ON PAGE THREE OF THAT TRANSCRIPT IT SAYS, "I SAW BLOOD 2230 01:04:53,123 --> 01:04:56,858 TRANSCRIPT IT SAYS, "I SAW BLOOD ON HER FOREHEAD. 2231 01:04:56,860 --> 01:05:03,164 ON HER FOREHEAD. I GO HOME AND LISTEN TO THE 2232 01:05:03,166 --> 01:05:04,199 I GO HOME AND LISTEN TO THE TAPE, AND I HEAR HEADBOARD 2233 01:05:04,201 --> 01:05:05,767 TAPE, AND I HEAR HEADBOARD I LISTENED TO IT TEN TIMES BY 2234 01:05:05,769 --> 01:05:09,204 I LISTENED TO IT TEN TIMES BY MYSELF BEFORE I TOLD ANYBODY 2235 01:05:09,206 --> 01:05:10,038 MYSELF BEFORE I TOLD ANYBODY ELSE 2236 01:05:10,040 --> 01:05:12,140 ELSE >> GOD I DON'T KNOW, I SAW BLOOD 2237 01:05:12,142 --> 01:05:13,174 >> GOD I DON'T KNOW, I SAW BLOOD ON THE HEADBOARD 2238 01:05:13,176 --> 01:05:14,776 ON THE HEADBOARD >> Reporter: SURE ENOUGH, KATHY, 2239 01:05:14,778 --> 01:05:16,378 >> Reporter: SURE ENOUGH, KATHY, IN THAT 911 CALL, DID ACTUALLY 2240 01:05:16,380 --> 01:05:17,412 IN THAT 911 CALL, DID ACTUALLY SAY HEADBOARD, NOT FOREHEAD. 2241 01:05:17,414 --> 01:05:19,014 SAY HEADBOARD, NOT FOREHEAD. >> I SAW BLOOD ON HER HEADBOARD 2242 01:05:19,016 --> 01:05:21,116 >> I SAW BLOOD ON HER HEADBOARD AND I, THE CLOSET WAS LOCKED 2243 01:05:21,118 --> 01:05:22,150 AND I, THE CLOSET WAS LOCKED >> Reporter: A TRANSCRIPTION 2244 01:05:22,152 --> 01:05:25,954 >> Reporter: A TRANSCRIPTION ERROR. 2245 01:05:25,956 --> 01:05:27,455 ERROR. AND THOUGH INVESTIGATORS SAID 2246 01:05:27,457 --> 01:05:30,091 AND THOUGH INVESTIGATORS SAID THAT MADE NO REAL DIFFERENCE TO 2247 01:05:30,093 --> 01:05:30,692 THAT MADE NO REAL DIFFERENCE TO THEM, KATHY'S ATTORNEY IS SURE 2248 01:05:30,694 --> 01:05:31,326 THEM, KATHY'S ATTORNEY IS SURE THAT LITTLE ERROR PLANTED 2249 01:05:31,328 --> 01:05:33,795 THAT LITTLE ERROR PLANTED SUSPICION OF KATHY FROM THE VERY 2250 01:05:33,797 --> 01:05:36,965 SUSPICION OF KATHY FROM THE VERY BEGINNING. 2251 01:05:36,967 --> 01:05:38,700 BEGINNING. AND STARTED INVESTIGATORS OFF IN 2252 01:05:38,702 --> 01:05:41,169 AND STARTED INVESTIGATORS OFF IN AN INACCURATE, AND 2253 01:05:41,171 --> 01:05:42,771 AN INACCURATE, AND INAPPROPRIATE, DIRECTION 2254 01:05:42,773 --> 01:05:45,407 INAPPROPRIATE, DIRECTION >> THEY USED EVERY TECHNIQUE IN 2255 01:05:45,409 --> 01:05:46,975 >> THEY USED EVERY TECHNIQUE IN THE BOOK ON HER. 2256 01:05:46,977 --> 01:05:48,143 THE BOOK ON HER. AND HONESTLY, AS I WATCHED THOSE 2257 01:05:48,145 --> 01:05:49,411 AND HONESTLY, AS I WATCHED THOSE INTERROGATIONS, I STARTED 2258 01:05:49,413 --> 01:05:50,145 INTERROGATIONS, I STARTED THINKING I MIGHT'VE CONFESSED TO 2259 01:05:50,147 --> 01:05:51,746 THINKING I MIGHT'VE CONFESSED TO DOING SOMETHING -- JUST TO MAKE 2260 01:05:51,748 --> 01:05:55,617 DOING SOMETHING -- JUST TO MAKE IT STOP. 2261 01:05:55,619 --> 01:05:59,120 IT STOP. >> HERE'S ALL THIS DOCUMENTATION 2262 01:05:59,122 --> 01:06:01,189 >> HERE'S ALL THIS DOCUMENTATION OF DECEIT AND GUILT. 2263 01:06:01,191 --> 01:06:02,424 OF DECEIT AND GUILT. >> Reporter: AND THEY TOLD YOU, 2264 01:06:02,426 --> 01:06:02,691 >> Reporter: AND THEY TOLD YOU, YOU DID IT 2265 01:06:02,693 --> 01:06:04,359 YOU DID IT >> YES 2266 01:06:04,361 --> 01:06:06,461 >> YES >> Reporter: REPEATEDLY? 2267 01:06:06,463 --> 01:06:09,097 >> Reporter: REPEATEDLY? >> YES 2268 01:06:09,099 --> 01:06:13,868 >> YES >> Reporter: AND EACH TIME, WHAT 2269 01:06:13,870 --> 01:06:17,005 >> Reporter: AND EACH TIME, WHAT WOULD YOU SAY? 2270 01:06:17,007 --> 01:06:19,140 WOULD YOU SAY? >> I DID NOT DO IT 2271 01:06:19,142 --> 01:06:21,743 >> I DID NOT DO IT >> Reporter: AND EVEN THOUGH IT 2272 01:06:21,745 --> 01:06:22,811 >> Reporter: AND EVEN THOUGH IT APPEARS FROM THE INTERROGATION 2273 01:06:22,813 --> 01:06:23,411 APPEARS FROM THE INTERROGATION TAPES THAT KATHY DID SAY SOME 2274 01:06:23,413 --> 01:06:23,845 TAPES THAT KATHY DID SAY SOME IMPROBABLE THINGS -- 2275 01:06:23,847 --> 01:06:24,312 IMPROBABLE THINGS -- >> I SAW HER, THE HEAD 2276 01:06:24,314 --> 01:06:24,846 >> I SAW HER, THE HEAD LIKE I DON'T REMEMBER THE 2277 01:06:24,848 --> 01:06:25,413 LIKE I DON'T REMEMBER THE POSITION BUT I KNEW HER, THE 2278 01:06:25,415 --> 01:06:25,981 POSITION BUT I KNEW HER, THE BLONDE HAIR. 2279 01:06:25,983 --> 01:06:27,048 BLONDE HAIR. >> Reporter: SHE WAS ON 2280 01:06:27,050 --> 01:06:27,582 >> Reporter: SHE WAS ON DOCTOR-PRESCRIBED ANXIETY 2281 01:06:27,584 --> 01:06:28,183 DOCTOR-PRESCRIBED ANXIETY MEDICATION THE WHOLE TIME, SHE 2282 01:06:28,185 --> 01:06:29,150 MEDICATION THE WHOLE TIME, SHE SAID 2283 01:06:29,152 --> 01:06:29,884 SAID SO IN HER CONFUSED FOG, AND 2284 01:06:29,886 --> 01:06:31,820 SO IN HER CONFUSED FOG, AND PROMPTED BY THE INVESTIGATORS, 2285 01:06:31,822 --> 01:06:32,854 PROMPTED BY THE INVESTIGATORS, SAID KATHY, HER DESCRIPTIONS 2286 01:06:32,856 --> 01:06:33,388 SAID KATHY, HER DESCRIPTIONS WERE UNCLEAR 2287 01:06:33,390 --> 01:06:34,356 WERE UNCLEAR SHE MAY EVEN HAVE IMAGINED 2288 01:06:34,358 --> 01:06:40,261 SHE MAY EVEN HAVE IMAGINED THINGS SHE COULD NOT HAVE SEEN 2289 01:06:40,263 --> 01:06:40,895 THINGS SHE COULD NOT HAVE SEEN IS IT POSSIBLE THAT YOU WERE LED 2290 01:06:40,897 --> 01:06:41,529 IS IT POSSIBLE THAT YOU WERE LED INTO SAYING SOMETHING LIKE THAT? 2291 01:06:41,531 --> 01:06:45,000 INTO SAYING SOMETHING LIKE THAT? >> ABSOLUTELY. 2292 01:06:45,002 --> 01:06:48,169 >> ABSOLUTELY. UM, ABSOLUTELY 2293 01:06:48,171 --> 01:06:50,305 UM, ABSOLUTELY YOU KNOW SHE WAS IN A PLASTIC 2294 01:06:50,307 --> 01:06:51,873 YOU KNOW SHE WAS IN A PLASTIC BAG, AND I SAW JUST WHAT - 2295 01:06:51,875 --> 01:06:52,507 BAG, AND I SAW JUST WHAT - THROUGH THE TRANSPARENCY OF THE 2296 01:06:52,509 --> 01:06:53,108 THROUGH THE TRANSPARENCY OF THE BAG, I SAW A LITTLE BIT OF HER 2297 01:06:53,110 --> 01:06:56,111 BAG, I SAW A LITTLE BIT OF HER HAIR 2298 01:06:56,113 --> 01:06:59,280 HAIR >> Reporter: SO WHY'D SHE FAIL 2299 01:06:59,282 --> 01:07:00,882 >> Reporter: SO WHY'D SHE FAIL THE POLYGRAPH? 2300 01:07:00,884 --> 01:07:01,916 THE POLYGRAPH? >> I WAS VERY UPSET. 2301 01:07:01,918 --> 01:07:05,086 >> I WAS VERY UPSET. I WAS VERY EMOTIONAL 2302 01:07:05,088 --> 01:07:07,756 I WAS VERY EMOTIONAL THEY DID TELL ME THAT IN ORDER 2303 01:07:07,758 --> 01:07:10,392 THEY DID TELL ME THAT IN ORDER FOR ME TO TAKE THIS TEST 2304 01:07:10,394 --> 01:07:13,561 FOR ME TO TAKE THIS TEST PROPERLY, I COULD NOT FEEL ANY 2305 01:07:13,563 --> 01:07:17,232 PROPERLY, I COULD NOT FEEL ANY EMOTIONS 2306 01:07:17,234 --> 01:07:18,299 EMOTIONS >> Reporter: MM-HMM, MM-HMM. 2307 01:07:18,301 --> 01:07:22,003 >> Reporter: MM-HMM, MM-HMM. >> AND THAT -- JUST HEARING THE 2308 01:07:22,005 --> 01:07:30,912 >> AND THAT -- JUST HEARING THE WORDS -- JUST HEARING HER NAME 2309 01:07:30,914 --> 01:07:32,814 WORDS -- JUST HEARING HER NAME WAS VERY EMOTIONAL 2310 01:07:32,816 --> 01:07:37,285 WAS VERY EMOTIONAL >> Reporter: BUT IT WAS TRUE, 2311 01:07:37,287 --> 01:07:39,921 >> Reporter: BUT IT WAS TRUE, SHE SAID, NO DENYING IT, SHE DID 2312 01:07:39,923 --> 01:07:44,192 SHE SAID, NO DENYING IT, SHE DID TAKE $6,000 IN CASH AND AN 2313 01:07:44,194 --> 01:07:46,761 TAKE $6,000 IN CASH AND AN HEIRLOOM RING FROM NANCY 2314 01:07:46,763 --> 01:07:48,897 HEIRLOOM RING FROM NANCY PFISTER'S SAFE DEPOSIT BOX THE 2315 01:07:48,899 --> 01:07:49,931 PFISTER'S SAFE DEPOSIT BOX THE DAY AFTER SHE FOUND THE BODY 2316 01:07:49,933 --> 01:07:50,732 DAY AFTER SHE FOUND THE BODY BUT IT WASN'T FOR HER, SHE SAID. 2317 01:07:50,734 --> 01:07:52,000 BUT IT WASN'T FOR HER, SHE SAID. RATHER, IT WAS TO FULFILL A 2318 01:07:52,002 --> 01:07:52,367 RATHER, IT WAS TO FULFILL A PROMISE TO NANCY 2319 01:07:52,369 --> 01:07:53,001 PROMISE TO NANCY >> AND SHE OFTEN WOULD SAY, YOU 2320 01:07:53,003 --> 01:07:53,635 >> AND SHE OFTEN WOULD SAY, YOU KNOW, IF ANYTHING HAPPENS TO ME 2321 01:07:53,637 --> 01:07:54,235 KNOW, IF ANYTHING HAPPENS TO ME IN MY TRAVELS, YOU KNOW, MAKE 2322 01:07:54,237 --> 01:07:54,803 IN MY TRAVELS, YOU KNOW, MAKE SURE YOU DO THIS, CAN YOU DO 2323 01:07:54,805 --> 01:07:54,969 SURE YOU DO THIS, CAN YOU DO THAT 2324 01:07:54,971 --> 01:07:55,570 THAT MAKE SURE YOU -- YOU KNOW, MY 2325 01:07:55,572 --> 01:07:55,970 MAKE SURE YOU -- YOU KNOW, MY LITTLE TO-DO LIST. 2326 01:07:55,972 --> 01:08:00,508 LITTLE TO-DO LIST. >> Reporter: AND ON THE TO-DO 2327 01:08:00,510 --> 01:08:02,077 >> Reporter: AND ON THE TO-DO LIST -- THAT RING. 2328 01:08:02,079 --> 01:08:05,246 LIST -- THAT RING. >> SHE -- INHERITED A FAMILY 2329 01:08:05,248 --> 01:08:07,849 >> SHE -- INHERITED A FAMILY RING FROM HER MOTHER 2330 01:08:07,851 --> 01:08:10,485 RING FROM HER MOTHER AND HER SISTERS WANTED IT. 2331 01:08:10,487 --> 01:08:13,655 AND HER SISTERS WANTED IT. AND SHE HAD ASKED ME -- YOU MAKE 2332 01:08:13,657 --> 01:08:16,424 AND SHE HAD ASKED ME -- YOU MAKE SURE THAT JULIANA -- IF ANYTHING 2333 01:08:16,426 --> 01:08:17,859 SURE THAT JULIANA -- IF ANYTHING WOULD HAPPEN TO ME, THAT SHE 2334 01:08:17,861 --> 01:08:19,461 WOULD HAPPEN TO ME, THAT SHE WOULD GET THIS RING. 2335 01:08:19,463 --> 01:08:20,528 WOULD GET THIS RING. THAT WAS MY INTENTION, WAS TO 2336 01:08:20,530 --> 01:08:21,062 THAT WAS MY INTENTION, WAS TO FULFILL HER WISH 2337 01:08:21,064 --> 01:08:25,266 FULFILL HER WISH >> Reporter: TO GIVE IT TO 2338 01:08:25,268 --> 01:08:27,001 >> Reporter: TO GIVE IT TO JULIANA. 2339 01:08:27,003 --> 01:08:27,936 JULIANA. >> TO GIVE IT TO JULIANA 2340 01:08:27,938 --> 01:08:28,970 >> TO GIVE IT TO JULIANA >> Reporter: JUST AS SHE HAD 2341 01:08:28,972 --> 01:08:29,571 >> Reporter: JUST AS SHE HAD EVERY INTENTION OF GIVING THE 2342 01:08:29,573 --> 01:08:30,205 EVERY INTENTION OF GIVING THE MONEY DIRECTLY TO JULIANA TOO -- 2343 01:08:30,207 --> 01:08:30,805 MONEY DIRECTLY TO JULIANA TOO -- SO IT WOULDN'T DISAPPEAR INTO 2344 01:08:30,807 --> 01:08:31,339 SO IT WOULDN'T DISAPPEAR INTO SOME DISPUTED FAMILY TRUST 2345 01:08:31,341 --> 01:08:31,840 SOME DISPUTED FAMILY TRUST BUT THEN, SHE SAID, THE 2346 01:08:31,842 --> 01:08:32,440 BUT THEN, SHE SAID, THE INVESTIGATORS USED EVERYTHING 2347 01:08:32,442 --> 01:08:33,007 INVESTIGATORS USED EVERYTHING SHE SAID AND DID AGAINST HER 2348 01:08:33,009 --> 01:08:34,242 SHE SAID AND DID AGAINST HER >> I JUST THOUGHT, "NO, THIS IS 2349 01:08:34,244 --> 01:08:35,009 >> I JUST THOUGHT, "NO, THIS IS NOT HAPPENING. 2350 01:08:35,011 --> 01:08:35,610 NOT HAPPENING. HOW CAN THEY -- BE SO WRONG, I 2351 01:08:35,612 --> 01:08:36,344 HOW CAN THEY -- BE SO WRONG, I HAD, I HAVE, NOTHING TO DO WITH 2352 01:08:36,346 --> 01:08:36,511 HAD, I HAVE, NOTHING TO DO WITH THIS 2353 01:08:36,513 --> 01:08:36,978 THIS SHE WAS MY DEAR FRIEND 2354 01:08:36,980 --> 01:08:38,446 SHE WAS MY DEAR FRIEND I LOVED HER. 2355 01:08:38,448 --> 01:08:40,582 I LOVED HER. >> Reporter: KATHY'S ATTORNEY 2356 01:08:40,584 --> 01:08:42,684 >> Reporter: KATHY'S ATTORNEY TOLD HER, DON'T WORRY, THE CASE 2357 01:08:42,686 --> 01:08:44,285 TOLD HER, DON'T WORRY, THE CASE WON'T HOLD UP IN COURT 2358 01:08:44,287 --> 01:08:45,887 WON'T HOLD UP IN COURT BUT EVEN IF HE WAS RIGHT, THE 2359 01:08:45,889 --> 01:08:47,455 BUT EVEN IF HE WAS RIGHT, THE TRIAL MIGHT BE YEARS AWAY. 2360 01:08:47,457 --> 01:08:48,523 TRIAL MIGHT BE YEARS AWAY. AND SO SHE DID ALL THAT WAS LEFT 2361 01:08:48,525 --> 01:08:50,091 AND SO SHE DID ALL THAT WAS LEFT TO HER 2362 01:08:50,093 --> 01:08:51,659 TO HER >> AND I STARTED PRAYING, 2363 01:08:51,661 --> 01:08:53,294 >> AND I STARTED PRAYING, PRAYING THAT THE TRUTH WOULD BE 2364 01:08:53,296 --> 01:08:55,363 PRAYING THAT THE TRUTH WOULD BE REVEALED 2365 01:08:55,365 --> 01:08:56,998 REVEALED THAT'S WHAT I WANTED, IS THE 2366 01:08:57,000 --> 01:08:59,067 THAT'S WHAT I WANTED, IS THE TRUTH TO BE REVEALED 2367 01:08:59,069 --> 01:08:59,701 TRUTH TO BE REVEALED >> Reporter: AND THEN, SUDDENLY, 2368 01:08:59,703 --> 01:09:01,202 >> Reporter: AND THEN, SUDDENLY, IT APPEARED THAT IT WAS. 2369 01:09:01,204 --> 01:09:02,770 IT APPEARED THAT IT WAS. TRUTH, THAT IS 2370 01:09:02,772 --> 01:09:03,304 TRUTH, THAT IS BUT WOULD ANYONE BELIEVE IT? 2371 01:09:26,529 --> 01:09:30,999 >> Reporter: IT WENT THE WAY IT OFTEN DOES IN CRIMINAL CASES - 2372 01:09:31,001 --> 01:09:31,599 OFTEN DOES IN CRIMINAL CASES - A PERIOD OF FRENETIC ACTIVITY 2373 01:09:31,601 --> 01:09:32,133 A PERIOD OF FRENETIC ACTIVITY FOLLOWED BY A SORT OF CALM 2374 01:09:32,135 --> 01:09:35,970 FOLLOWED BY A SORT OF CALM STASIS 2375 01:09:35,972 --> 01:09:36,571 STASIS AND SO IT WAS WITH THE MURDER 2376 01:09:36,573 --> 01:09:38,072 AND SO IT WAS WITH THE MURDER CASE OF NANCY PFISTER. 2377 01:09:38,074 --> 01:09:39,174 CASE OF NANCY PFISTER. THE FLURRY OF ACTION LOOSED FROM 2378 01:09:39,176 --> 01:09:39,807 THE FLURRY OF ACTION LOOSED FROM THE MOMENT HER BODY WAS FOUND IN 2379 01:09:39,809 --> 01:09:40,408 THE MOMENT HER BODY WAS FOUND IN FEBRUARY 2014 TO THE ARREST OF 2380 01:09:40,410 --> 01:09:41,776 FEBRUARY 2014 TO THE ARREST OF THE THIRD AND FINAL SUSPECT 2381 01:09:41,778 --> 01:09:43,378 THE THIRD AND FINAL SUSPECT KATHY CARPENTER IN MID-MARCH, 2382 01:09:43,380 --> 01:09:46,080 KATHY CARPENTER IN MID-MARCH, DISSIPATED WITH THE SPRING THAW. 2383 01:09:46,082 --> 01:09:47,048 DISSIPATED WITH THE SPRING THAW. THE CASE NOW SLOUCHED TOWARDS 2384 01:09:47,050 --> 01:09:50,218 THE CASE NOW SLOUCHED TOWARDS SUMMER 2385 01:09:50,220 --> 01:09:51,286 SUMMER NANCY'S FRIEND, BILLY, MISSING 2386 01:09:51,288 --> 01:10:00,762 NANCY'S FRIEND, BILLY, MISSING HER MORE THAN EVER 2387 01:10:00,764 --> 01:10:01,362 HER MORE THAN EVER >> THE LAST TIME I SPOKE WITH 2388 01:10:01,364 --> 01:10:02,363 >> THE LAST TIME I SPOKE WITH HER ALL WE TALKED ABOUT WERE 2389 01:10:02,365 --> 01:10:03,431 HER ALL WE TALKED ABOUT WERE PLANS -- 2390 01:10:03,433 --> 01:10:04,465 PLANS -- EVERYTHING WE WERE GOING TO DO 2391 01:10:04,467 --> 01:10:05,166 EVERYTHING WE WERE GOING TO DO THIS SUMMER, ALL THE DIFFERENT 2392 01:10:05,168 --> 01:10:06,601 THIS SUMMER, ALL THE DIFFERENT IDEAS SHE HAD. 2393 01:10:06,603 --> 01:10:09,237 IDEAS SHE HAD. >> Reporter: BUT THE ONLY THING 2394 01:10:09,239 --> 01:10:10,805 >> Reporter: BUT THE ONLY THING ON THE CALENDAR NOW WAS A 2395 01:10:10,807 --> 01:10:12,907 ON THE CALENDAR NOW WAS A PRELIMINARY HEARING SCHEDULED 2396 01:10:12,909 --> 01:10:14,509 PRELIMINARY HEARING SCHEDULED FOR LATE JUNE ALL THREE 2397 01:10:14,511 --> 01:10:15,577 FOR LATE JUNE ALL THREE DEFENDANTS HAD PLEADED NOT 2398 01:10:15,579 --> 01:10:16,611 DEFENDANTS HAD PLEADED NOT GUILTY AND THEIR RESPECTIVE 2399 01:10:16,613 --> 01:10:18,279 GUILTY AND THEIR RESPECTIVE ATTORNEYS -- BETH KRULEWITCH FOR 2400 01:10:18,281 --> 01:10:18,913 ATTORNEYS -- BETH KRULEWITCH FOR NANCY STYLER AND GREG GREER FOR 2401 01:10:18,915 --> 01:10:23,985 NANCY STYLER AND GREG GREER FOR KATHY CARPENTER -- WERE DECIDING 2402 01:10:23,987 --> 01:10:27,155 KATHY CARPENTER -- WERE DECIDING THEIR STRATEGIES, ANALYZING THE 2403 01:10:27,157 --> 01:10:29,290 THEIR STRATEGIES, ANALYZING THE EVIDENCE 2404 01:10:29,292 --> 01:10:30,858 EVIDENCE >> THE EVIDENCE AS I WAS SEEING 2405 01:10:30,860 --> 01:10:35,096 >> THE EVIDENCE AS I WAS SEEING IT SUGGESTED TO ME VERY STRONGLY 2406 01:10:35,098 --> 01:10:38,600 IT SUGGESTED TO ME VERY STRONGLY THAT KATHY CARPENTER MAY HAVE 2407 01:10:38,602 --> 01:10:40,368 THAT KATHY CARPENTER MAY HAVE DONE THIS AND THAT SHE WAS 2408 01:10:40,370 --> 01:10:42,470 DONE THIS AND THAT SHE WAS SETTING UP THE STYLERS 2409 01:10:42,472 --> 01:10:43,504 SETTING UP THE STYLERS >> KATHY CARPENTER IS INNOCENT, 2410 01:10:43,506 --> 01:10:44,606 >> KATHY CARPENTER IS INNOCENT, INNOCENT, INNOCENT 2411 01:10:44,608 --> 01:10:46,674 INNOCENT, INNOCENT I CAN'T SAY THAT ENOUGH. 2412 01:10:46,676 --> 01:10:47,242 I CAN'T SAY THAT ENOUGH. >> Reporter: BUT DEPUTY D.A. 2413 01:10:47,244 --> 01:10:47,675 >> Reporter: BUT DEPUTY D.A. ANDREA BRYAN AND HER 2414 01:10:47,677 --> 01:10:48,910 ANDREA BRYAN AND HER INVESTIGATOR LISA MILLER WERE 2415 01:10:48,912 --> 01:10:49,477 INVESTIGATOR LISA MILLER WERE PREPARING TO ARGUE IT WAS A 2416 01:10:49,479 --> 01:10:50,111 PREPARING TO ARGUE IT WAS A CONSPRIRACY INVOLVING ALL THREE. 2417 01:10:50,113 --> 01:10:50,712 CONSPRIRACY INVOLVING ALL THREE. AND THEN, LESS THAN TWO WEEKS 2418 01:10:50,714 --> 01:10:51,179 AND THEN, LESS THAN TWO WEEKS BEFORE THAT HEARING -- 2419 01:10:51,181 --> 01:10:51,813 BEFORE THAT HEARING -- IN THE PROCESS OF GETTING ALL OF 2420 01:10:51,815 --> 01:10:52,413 IN THE PROCESS OF GETTING ALL OF YOUR MATERIAL TOGETHER FOR THE 2421 01:10:52,415 --> 01:10:52,947 YOUR MATERIAL TOGETHER FOR THE PRELIMINARY HEARING, WHAT 2422 01:10:52,949 --> 01:10:53,448 PRELIMINARY HEARING, WHAT HAPPENED 2423 01:10:53,450 --> 01:10:55,650 HAPPENED >> I GOT A PHONE CALL FROM MY 2424 01:10:55,652 --> 01:10:56,351 >> I GOT A PHONE CALL FROM MY ASSISTANT DISTRICT ATTORNEY ONE 2425 01:10:56,353 --> 01:10:57,952 ASSISTANT DISTRICT ATTORNEY ONE AFTERNOON. 2426 01:10:57,954 --> 01:10:58,386 AFTERNOON. >> Reporter: SAYING? 2427 01:10:58,388 --> 01:10:59,354 >> Reporter: SAYING? >> SAYING THAT HE HAD SPOKEN 2428 01:10:59,356 --> 01:11:00,388 >> SAYING THAT HE HAD SPOKEN WITH A DEFENSE ATTORNEY, 2429 01:11:00,390 --> 01:11:04,092 WITH A DEFENSE ATTORNEY, SPECIFICALLY WILLIAM STYLER'S 2430 01:11:04,094 --> 01:11:05,159 SPECIFICALLY WILLIAM STYLER'S DEFENSE ATTORNEY, AND THAT 2431 01:11:05,161 --> 01:11:08,363 DEFENSE ATTORNEY, AND THAT WILLIAM STYLER WANTED TO MAKE A 2432 01:11:08,365 --> 01:11:08,863 WILLIAM STYLER WANTED TO MAKE A STATEMENT. 2433 01:11:08,865 --> 01:11:09,897 STATEMENT. >> Reporter: NOW, THAT COULD BE 2434 01:11:09,899 --> 01:11:11,466 >> Reporter: NOW, THAT COULD BE INTERESTING. 2435 01:11:11,468 --> 01:11:13,034 INTERESTING. THE GOOD DOCTOR WAS WHEELED INTO 2436 01:11:13,036 --> 01:11:14,636 THE GOOD DOCTOR WAS WHEELED INTO THE INTERVIEW ROOM WHERE LISA 2437 01:11:14,638 --> 01:11:17,272 THE INTERVIEW ROOM WHERE LISA MILLER WAS WAITING 2438 01:11:17,274 --> 01:11:18,840 MILLER WAS WAITING >> MR. STYLER, I'M GOING TO HAVE 2439 01:11:18,842 --> 01:11:20,975 >> MR. STYLER, I'M GOING TO HAVE YOU RIGHT HERE, SIR. 2440 01:11:20,977 --> 01:11:22,043 YOU RIGHT HERE, SIR. >> OKAY. 2441 01:11:22,045 --> 01:11:22,677 >> OKAY. >> Reporter: OH, BUT IT WAS FAR 2442 01:11:22,679 --> 01:11:23,611 >> Reporter: OH, BUT IT WAS FAR MORE THAN JUST A "STATEMENT. 2443 01:11:23,613 --> 01:11:24,245 MORE THAN JUST A "STATEMENT. TREY STYLER DROPPED A BOMBSHELL. 2444 01:11:24,247 --> 01:11:25,213 TREY STYLER DROPPED A BOMBSHELL. AND IT BLEW THE D.A.'S 2445 01:11:25,215 --> 01:11:27,849 AND IT BLEW THE D.A.'S METICULOUSLY ASSEMBLED CASE WIDE 2446 01:11:27,851 --> 01:11:29,050 METICULOUSLY ASSEMBLED CASE WIDE OPEN 2447 01:11:29,052 --> 01:11:29,984 OPEN >> I LOST MY MIND HERE OR AT 2448 01:11:29,986 --> 01:11:31,519 >> I LOST MY MIND HERE OR AT LEAST, I LOST MY RATIONAL MIND 2449 01:11:31,521 --> 01:11:34,188 LEAST, I LOST MY RATIONAL MIND >> Reporter: IT WAS A 2450 01:11:34,190 --> 01:11:37,325 >> Reporter: IT WAS A CONFESSION 2451 01:11:37,327 --> 01:11:45,700 CONFESSION AFTER MONTHS OF STRENUOUS 2452 01:11:45,702 --> 01:11:47,802 AFTER MONTHS OF STRENUOUS DENIALS, TREY STYLER TOLD 2453 01:11:47,804 --> 01:11:49,404 DENIALS, TREY STYLER TOLD THEM - 2454 01:11:49,406 --> 01:11:50,938 THEM - >> IT ALL WAS ME 2455 01:11:50,940 --> 01:11:53,074 >> IT ALL WAS ME >> Reporter: DETAIL BY DETAIL, 2456 01:11:53,076 --> 01:11:55,243 >> Reporter: DETAIL BY DETAIL, TREY TOOK THEM THROUGH THE 2457 01:11:55,245 --> 01:11:58,346 TREY TOOK THEM THROUGH THE KILLING -- HOW HE SLIPPED OUT OF 2458 01:11:58,348 --> 01:12:01,516 KILLING -- HOW HE SLIPPED OUT OF HIS MOTEL ROOM WHILE HIS WIFE 2459 01:12:01,518 --> 01:12:02,150 HIS MOTEL ROOM WHILE HIS WIFE WAS SLEEPING AND DROVE TO NANCY 2460 01:12:02,152 --> 01:12:02,750 WAS SLEEPING AND DROVE TO NANCY PFISTER'S HOUSE, INTENDING TO 2461 01:12:02,752 --> 01:12:03,051 PFISTER'S HOUSE, INTENDING TO CONFRONT HER 2462 01:12:03,053 --> 01:12:03,651 CONFRONT HER >> I STUCK MY HEAD IN THE DOOR 2463 01:12:03,653 --> 01:12:04,686 >> I STUCK MY HEAD IN THE DOOR FAR ENOUGH TO ASCERTAIN THAT SHE 2464 01:12:04,688 --> 01:12:05,320 FAR ENOUGH TO ASCERTAIN THAT SHE WAS IN FACT IN BED AND I CALLED 2465 01:12:05,322 --> 01:12:08,389 WAS IN FACT IN BED AND I CALLED OUT HER NAME AGAIN 2466 01:12:08,391 --> 01:12:11,025 OUT HER NAME AGAIN >> UH-HUH. 2467 01:12:11,027 --> 01:12:13,161 >> UH-HUH. >> AND SHE DIDN'T RESPOND. 2468 01:12:13,163 --> 01:12:16,297 >> AND SHE DIDN'T RESPOND. >> Reporter: THEN, HE SAID, AS 2469 01:12:16,299 --> 01:12:19,033 >> Reporter: THEN, HE SAID, AS HE STOOD OVER THE STILL SLEEPING 2470 01:12:19,035 --> 01:12:23,705 HE STOOD OVER THE STILL SLEEPING NANCY PFISTER, ALL THE RAGE THAT 2471 01:12:23,707 --> 01:12:25,807 NANCY PFISTER, ALL THE RAGE THAT BUILT UP INSIDE HIM DURING HIS 2472 01:12:25,809 --> 01:12:26,974 BUILT UP INSIDE HIM DURING HIS DREADFUL PHYSICAL AND FINANCIAL 2473 01:12:26,976 --> 01:12:27,575 DREADFUL PHYSICAL AND FINANCIAL DECLINE SUDDENLY FOCUSED ON A 2474 01:12:27,577 --> 01:12:31,079 DECLINE SUDDENLY FOCUSED ON A SINGULAR IDEA. 2475 01:12:31,081 --> 01:12:32,113 SINGULAR IDEA. >> THERE SHE WAS, VULNERABLE, 2476 01:12:32,115 --> 01:12:33,181 >> THERE SHE WAS, VULNERABLE, HELPLESS 2477 01:12:33,183 --> 01:12:34,248 HELPLESS >> Reporter: SO HE WENT DOWN THE 2478 01:12:34,250 --> 01:12:35,316 >> Reporter: SO HE WENT DOWN THE STAIRS, GOT A HAMMER, CLIMBED 2479 01:12:35,318 --> 01:12:35,783 STAIRS, GOT A HAMMER, CLIMBED BACK UP TO THE BEDROOM 2480 01:12:35,785 --> 01:12:36,417 BACK UP TO THE BEDROOM >> I WENT, GOT THE HAMMER, CAME 2481 01:12:36,419 --> 01:12:37,018 >> I WENT, GOT THE HAMMER, CAME BACK, UM -- AND STRUCK HER IN 2482 01:12:37,020 --> 01:12:37,518 BACK, UM -- AND STRUCK HER IN THE HEAD WITH THE HAMMER 2483 01:12:37,520 --> 01:12:38,152 THE HEAD WITH THE HAMMER >> Reporter: THEN, STRENGTHENED 2484 01:12:38,154 --> 01:12:38,720 >> Reporter: THEN, STRENGTHENED BY A RUSH OF ADRENALINE, HE 2485 01:12:38,722 --> 01:12:39,320 BY A RUSH OF ADRENALINE, HE SINGLE-HANDEDLY WRAPPED NANCY 2486 01:12:39,322 --> 01:12:39,954 SINGLE-HANDEDLY WRAPPED NANCY PFISTER UP, DRAGGED HER INTO THE 2487 01:12:39,956 --> 01:12:40,688 PFISTER UP, DRAGGED HER INTO THE CLOSET, COVERED HER UP 2488 01:12:40,690 --> 01:12:41,656 CLOSET, COVERED HER UP >> I WASN'T AS STRONG AS I USED 2489 01:12:41,658 --> 01:12:42,690 >> I WASN'T AS STRONG AS I USED TO BE. 2490 01:12:42,692 --> 01:12:45,893 TO BE. NONETHELESS, I WAS ABLE TO DO 2491 01:12:45,895 --> 01:12:46,961 NONETHELESS, I WAS ABLE TO DO THAT 2492 01:12:46,963 --> 01:12:49,063 THAT >> Reporter: HE THEN GRABBED 2493 01:12:49,065 --> 01:12:58,606 >> Reporter: HE THEN GRABBED SOME OF NANCY'S BELONGINGS TO 2494 01:12:58,608 --> 01:13:00,675 SOME OF NANCY'S BELONGINGS TO MAKE IT LOOK LIKE SHE WAS GONE 2495 01:13:00,677 --> 01:13:02,777 MAKE IT LOOK LIKE SHE WAS GONE >> HE WAS VERY CLEAR ABOUT WHAT 2496 01:13:02,779 --> 01:13:05,947 >> HE WAS VERY CLEAR ABOUT WHAT HE DID, HOW HE DID IT, AND WHEN 2497 01:13:05,949 --> 01:13:07,515 HE DID, HOW HE DID IT, AND WHEN HE DID IT IN -- IN VERY SPECIFIC 2498 01:13:07,517 --> 01:13:09,650 HE DID IT IN -- IN VERY SPECIFIC DETAIL 2499 01:13:09,652 --> 01:13:10,685 DETAIL >> AND SO YOU DO WHAT? 2500 01:13:10,687 --> 01:13:11,252 >> AND SO YOU DO WHAT? >> I HIT HER WITH THE HAMMER 2501 01:13:11,254 --> 01:13:13,855 >> I HIT HER WITH THE HAMMER >> WHERE 2502 01:13:13,857 --> 01:13:18,059 >> WHERE IN THE HEAD, WHERE 2503 01:13:18,061 --> 01:13:21,229 IN THE HEAD, WHERE >> IN, IN, IN, IN WHAT WAS - 2504 01:13:21,231 --> 01:13:22,797 >> IN, IN, IN, IN WHAT WAS - WHEN SHE WAS IN THAT POSITION, 2505 01:13:22,799 --> 01:13:25,433 WHEN SHE WAS IN THAT POSITION, THE TOP OF HER HEAD. 2506 01:13:25,435 --> 01:13:27,535 THE TOP OF HER HEAD. WHICH WOULD HAVE -- IF YOU DON'T 2507 01:13:27,537 --> 01:13:29,137 WHICH WOULD HAVE -- IF YOU DON'T MIND 2508 01:13:29,139 --> 01:13:31,239 MIND >> I DO MIND YOU TOUCHING ME, 2509 01:13:31,241 --> 01:13:31,773 >> I DO MIND YOU TOUCHING ME, QUITE FRANKLY. 2510 01:13:31,775 --> 01:13:32,306 QUITE FRANKLY. >> THIS. 2511 01:13:32,308 --> 01:13:32,940 >> THIS. >> Reporter: AS FOR HIS WIFE OR 2512 01:13:32,942 --> 01:13:36,544 >> Reporter: AS FOR HIS WIFE OR KATHY CARPENTER -- 2513 01:13:36,546 --> 01:13:39,714 KATHY CARPENTER -- >> NEITHER ONE OF THEM WERE 2514 01:13:39,716 --> 01:13:41,315 >> NEITHER ONE OF THEM WERE INVOLVED IN ANY WAY. 2515 01:13:41,317 --> 01:13:42,917 INVOLVED IN ANY WAY. >> Reporter: AND UNTIL THIS 2516 01:13:42,919 --> 01:13:45,019 >> Reporter: AND UNTIL THIS MOMENT, HE INSISTED, HE HADN'T 2517 01:13:45,021 --> 01:13:47,121 MOMENT, HE INSISTED, HE HADN'T TOLD EITHER ONE OF THEM A SINGLE 2518 01:13:47,123 --> 01:13:48,723 TOLD EITHER ONE OF THEM A SINGLE THING ABOUT WHAT HE DID. 2519 01:13:48,725 --> 01:13:52,427 THING ABOUT WHAT HE DID. HE NOT ONLY LIMITED HIS WIFE'S 2520 01:13:52,429 --> 01:13:55,062 HE NOT ONLY LIMITED HIS WIFE'S PARTICIPATION IN THAT STATEMENT. 2521 01:13:55,064 --> 01:13:55,663 PARTICIPATION IN THAT STATEMENT. HE SAID SHE WASN'T INVOLVED AT 2522 01:13:55,665 --> 01:13:56,230 HE SAID SHE WASN'T INVOLVED AT ALL AND THAT KATHY CARPENTER 2523 01:13:56,232 --> 01:13:56,864 ALL AND THAT KATHY CARPENTER WASN'T INVOLVED AT ALL, THAT HE 2524 01:13:56,866 --> 01:13:57,432 WASN'T INVOLVED AT ALL, THAT HE DID THE WHOLE THING HIMSELF. 2525 01:13:57,434 --> 01:13:58,032 DID THE WHOLE THING HIMSELF. THAT HE HAD A BURST OF ENERGY 2526 01:13:58,034 --> 01:13:58,599 THAT HE HAD A BURST OF ENERGY AND HE WAS ABLE TO DO ALL OF 2527 01:13:58,601 --> 01:13:59,100 AND HE WAS ABLE TO DO ALL OF THOSE THINGS ON HIS OWN. 2528 01:13:59,102 --> 01:14:00,868 THOSE THINGS ON HIS OWN. YOU HAVE A SKEPTICAL LOOK ON 2529 01:14:00,870 --> 01:14:03,504 YOU HAVE A SKEPTICAL LOOK ON YOUR FACE? 2530 01:14:03,506 --> 01:14:04,539 YOUR FACE? >> THAT'S WHAT HE TOLD ME, YES 2531 01:14:04,541 --> 01:14:08,242 >> THAT'S WHAT HE TOLD ME, YES >> Reporter: WHAT DID YOU THINK? 2532 01:14:08,244 --> 01:14:10,912 >> Reporter: WHAT DID YOU THINK? HAVING HEARD THAT INVESTIGATOR 2533 01:14:10,914 --> 01:14:12,747 HAVING HEARD THAT INVESTIGATOR MILLER TOLD DR. STYLER EXACTLY 2534 01:14:12,749 --> 01:14:16,184 MILLER TOLD DR. STYLER EXACTLY WHAT SHE THOUGHT - 2535 01:14:16,186 --> 01:14:17,218 WHAT SHE THOUGHT - >> I DON'T WANT YOU TO WALK OUT 2536 01:14:17,220 --> 01:14:17,785 >> I DON'T WANT YOU TO WALK OUT OF HERE THINKING THAT I HAVE 2537 01:14:17,787 --> 01:14:18,352 OF HERE THINKING THAT I HAVE BELIEVED YOU HOOK, LINE AND 2538 01:14:18,354 --> 01:14:18,953 BELIEVED YOU HOOK, LINE AND SINKER, 'CAUSE I WILL BE VERY 2539 01:14:18,955 --> 01:14:19,320 SINKER, 'CAUSE I WILL BE VERY FRANK. 2540 01:14:19,322 --> 01:14:19,921 FRANK. REMEMBER, I TOLD YOU I CALL IT 2541 01:14:19,923 --> 01:14:21,756 REMEMBER, I TOLD YOU I CALL IT LIKE I SEE IT. 2542 01:14:21,758 --> 01:14:22,323 LIKE I SEE IT. I DON'T BUY EVERYTHING THAT 2543 01:14:22,325 --> 01:14:22,824 I DON'T BUY EVERYTHING THAT YOU'RE SELLING ME TODAY. 2544 01:14:22,826 --> 01:14:22,990 YOU'RE SELLING ME TODAY. OKAY 2545 01:14:22,992 --> 01:14:23,558 OKAY >> OKAY. 2546 01:14:23,560 --> 01:14:26,194 >> OKAY. >> Reporter: BY THIS TIME, 2547 01:14:26,196 --> 01:14:27,762 >> Reporter: BY THIS TIME, INVESTIGATOR MILLER WAS 2548 01:14:27,764 --> 01:14:31,466 INVESTIGATOR MILLER WAS CONVINCED ALL THREE WERE IN IT 2549 01:14:31,468 --> 01:14:36,204 CONVINCED ALL THREE WERE IN IT TOGETHER 2550 01:14:36,206 --> 01:14:37,271 TOGETHER SHE LOOKED STRAIGHT AT TREY 2551 01:14:37,273 --> 01:14:37,805 SHE LOOKED STRAIGHT AT TREY STYLER AND CONFRONTED HIM. 2552 01:14:37,807 --> 01:14:38,840 STYLER AND CONFRONTED HIM. HE WAS A FRAIL OLD MAN 2553 01:14:38,842 --> 01:14:39,674 HE WAS A FRAIL OLD MAN SURELY, HE DIDN'T EXPECT SHE'D 2554 01:14:39,676 --> 01:14:40,374 SURELY, HE DIDN'T EXPECT SHE'D BELIEVE HE DID IT ALL ALONE. 2555 01:14:40,376 --> 01:14:40,942 BELIEVE HE DID IT ALL ALONE. >> AND YOU TELL ME YOU CAN'T 2556 01:14:40,944 --> 01:14:41,175 >> AND YOU TELL ME YOU CAN'T STAND UP 2557 01:14:41,177 --> 01:14:41,776 STAND UP HOWEVER, YOU ARE GIVING ME AN 2558 01:14:41,778 --> 01:14:42,410 HOWEVER, YOU ARE GIVING ME AN ACCOUNTING OF A STORY WHERE YOU 2559 01:14:42,412 --> 01:14:43,044 ACCOUNTING OF A STORY WHERE YOU WERE SAYING YOU WERE UP AND DOWN 2560 01:14:43,046 --> 01:14:43,511 WERE SAYING YOU WERE UP AND DOWN STAIRS MULTIPLE TIMES. 2561 01:14:43,513 --> 01:14:44,679 STAIRS MULTIPLE TIMES. MOVING DEAD WEIGHT IS NOT EASY 2562 01:14:44,681 --> 01:14:45,213 MOVING DEAD WEIGHT IS NOT EASY WORK MR. STYLER. 2563 01:14:45,215 --> 01:14:46,781 WORK MR. STYLER. >> WHEN I'VE THOUGHT ABOUT IT 2564 01:14:46,783 --> 01:14:50,485 >> WHEN I'VE THOUGHT ABOUT IT SINCE THEN, UM, I'M REMINDED OF 2565 01:14:50,487 --> 01:14:51,118 SINCE THEN, UM, I'M REMINDED OF THE STORIES UM, OF WOMEN LIFTING 2566 01:14:51,120 --> 01:14:51,652 THE STORIES UM, OF WOMEN LIFTING CARS OFF OF THEIR CHILDREN 2567 01:14:51,654 --> 01:14:52,587 CARS OFF OF THEIR CHILDREN >> MR. STYLER, I WILL DO A LOT 2568 01:14:52,589 --> 01:14:53,654 >> MR. STYLER, I WILL DO A LOT OF THINGS IN AN INTERVIEW ROOM, 2569 01:14:53,656 --> 01:14:55,756 OF THINGS IN AN INTERVIEW ROOM, BUT I AM NOT GOING TO COMPARE A 2570 01:14:55,758 --> 01:14:56,357 BUT I AM NOT GOING TO COMPARE A MOTHER SAVING A CHILD WITH YOU 2571 01:14:56,359 --> 01:14:58,960 MOTHER SAVING A CHILD WITH YOU MURDERING NANCY PFISTER, SO 2572 01:14:58,962 --> 01:15:02,396 MURDERING NANCY PFISTER, SO LET'S DON'T GO THERE 2573 01:15:02,398 --> 01:15:04,732 LET'S DON'T GO THERE >> Reporter: BUT TREY REMAINED 2574 01:15:04,734 --> 01:15:07,902 >> Reporter: BUT TREY REMAINED RESOLUTE 2575 01:15:07,904 --> 01:15:08,970 RESOLUTE HE WAS THE LONE KILLER 2576 01:15:08,972 --> 01:15:10,471 HE WAS THE LONE KILLER >> THE -- THE ESSENTIAL TRUTHS 2577 01:15:10,473 --> 01:15:11,606 >> THE -- THE ESSENTIAL TRUTHS ARE THAT KATHY CARPENTER REALLY 2578 01:15:11,608 --> 01:15:15,309 ARE THAT KATHY CARPENTER REALLY AND TRULY HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH 2579 01:15:15,311 --> 01:15:15,843 AND TRULY HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH THIS 2580 01:15:15,845 --> 01:15:16,444 THIS NANCY STYLER REALLY AND TRULY 2581 01:15:16,446 --> 01:15:17,011 NANCY STYLER REALLY AND TRULY HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH THIS. 2582 01:15:17,013 --> 01:15:17,612 HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH THIS. I HAVE DONE MY BEST TO HIDE IT 2583 01:15:17,614 --> 01:15:18,446 I HAVE DONE MY BEST TO HIDE IT FROM EVEN MYSELF, MUCH LESS THEM 2584 01:15:18,448 --> 01:15:29,857 FROM EVEN MYSELF, MUCH LESS THEM AND UH -- YOU KNOW, IT ALL WAS 2585 01:15:29,859 --> 01:15:30,124 AND UH -- YOU KNOW, IT ALL WAS ME 2586 01:15:30,126 --> 01:15:32,760 ME >> Reporter: HOW CONCERNED ARE 2587 01:15:32,762 --> 01:15:33,794 >> Reporter: HOW CONCERNED ARE YOU THAT HE DECIDED THAT HE WAS 2588 01:15:33,796 --> 01:15:38,032 YOU THAT HE DECIDED THAT HE WAS GOING DOWN ANYWAY, HE MIGHT AS 2589 01:15:38,034 --> 01:15:42,236 GOING DOWN ANYWAY, HE MIGHT AS WELL GET THEM OFF THE HOOK AND 2590 01:15:42,238 --> 01:15:44,338 WELL GET THEM OFF THE HOOK AND THAT'S REALLY WHAT WAS GOING ON 2591 01:15:44,340 --> 01:15:45,406 THAT'S REALLY WHAT WAS GOING ON HERE 2592 01:15:45,408 --> 01:15:46,474 HERE >> THAT'S A CONCERN IN ANY CASE 2593 01:15:46,476 --> 01:15:48,809 >> THAT'S A CONCERN IN ANY CASE LIKE THIS. 2594 01:15:48,811 --> 01:15:49,644 LIKE THIS. >> Reporter: SO, NOW IT WAS 2595 01:15:49,646 --> 01:15:50,278 >> Reporter: SO, NOW IT WAS DECISION TIME -- TAKE TREY'S 2596 01:15:50,280 --> 01:15:50,845 DECISION TIME -- TAKE TREY'S CONFESSION AT FACE VALUE AND 2597 01:15:50,847 --> 01:15:51,445 CONFESSION AT FACE VALUE AND RELEASE BOTH NANCY STYLER AND 2598 01:15:51,447 --> 01:15:52,313 RELEASE BOTH NANCY STYLER AND KATHY CARPENTER OR SEND HIM BACK 2599 01:15:52,315 --> 01:15:53,347 KATHY CARPENTER OR SEND HIM BACK TO HIS CELL AND PROCEED WITH THE 2600 01:15:53,349 --> 01:15:53,814 TO HIS CELL AND PROCEED WITH THE PROSECUTION OF ALL THREE 2601 01:16:13,902 --> 01:16:19,140 >>> I GOT THE HAMMER, CAME BACK. >> Reporter: A FULL CONFESSION, 2602 01:16:19,142 --> 01:16:20,708 >> Reporter: A FULL CONFESSION, THE BEST POSSIBLE SOLUTION FOR A 2603 01:16:20,710 --> 01:16:21,208 THE BEST POSSIBLE SOLUTION FOR A MURDER CASE. 2604 01:16:21,210 --> 01:16:22,777 MURDER CASE. IF THEY COULD BELIEVE IT, THAT 2605 01:16:22,779 --> 01:16:23,844 IF THEY COULD BELIEVE IT, THAT IS 2606 01:16:23,846 --> 01:16:24,912 IS >> I LOST MY MIND HERE, OR AT 2607 01:16:24,914 --> 01:16:26,747 >> I LOST MY MIND HERE, OR AT LEAST I LOST MY RATIONAL MIND. 2608 01:16:26,749 --> 01:16:27,381 LEAST I LOST MY RATIONAL MIND. >> Reporter: ARE YOU COMFORTABLE 2609 01:16:27,383 --> 01:16:27,982 >> Reporter: ARE YOU COMFORTABLE WITH THAT EXPLANATION OF THIS 2610 01:16:27,984 --> 01:16:29,116 WITH THAT EXPLANATION OF THIS CRIME? 2611 01:16:29,118 --> 01:16:30,184 CRIME? ARE YOU COMFORTABLE THAT THAT IS 2612 01:16:30,186 --> 01:16:31,752 ARE YOU COMFORTABLE THAT THAT IS THE WHOLE THING? 2613 01:16:31,754 --> 01:16:32,353 THE WHOLE THING? >> I DON'T KNOW IF WE'LL EVER 2614 01:16:32,355 --> 01:16:39,694 >> I DON'T KNOW IF WE'LL EVER KNOW THE WHOLE THING 2615 01:16:39,696 --> 01:16:41,796 KNOW THE WHOLE THING >> Reporter: AROUND THE PITKIN 2616 01:16:41,798 --> 01:16:43,397 >> Reporter: AROUND THE PITKIN COUNTY D.A.'S OFFICE WAS A 2617 01:16:43,399 --> 01:16:44,966 COUNTY D.A.'S OFFICE WAS A NAGGING WORRY. 2618 01:16:44,968 --> 01:16:46,033 NAGGING WORRY. DR. TREY STYLER DEMANDED, AND 2619 01:16:46,035 --> 01:16:48,369 DR. TREY STYLER DEMANDED, AND THE D.A. APPROVED, A QUID PRO 2620 01:16:48,371 --> 01:16:58,179 THE D.A. APPROVED, A QUID PRO QUO. 2621 01:16:58,181 --> 01:17:09,757 QUO. HIS FULL CONFESSION IN EXCHANGE 2622 01:17:09,759 --> 01:17:10,324 HIS FULL CONFESSION IN EXCHANGE FOR HIS WIFE'S UNCONDITIONAL 2623 01:17:10,326 --> 01:17:10,825 FOR HIS WIFE'S UNCONDITIONAL RELEASE. 2624 01:17:10,827 --> 01:17:11,392 RELEASE. >> AND I HAVE IN GOOD FAITH 2625 01:17:11,394 --> 01:17:12,426 >> AND I HAVE IN GOOD FAITH FULFILLED MY PART OF THE 2626 01:17:12,428 --> 01:17:12,660 FULFILLED MY PART OF THE BARGAIN. 2627 01:17:12,662 --> 01:17:13,294 BARGAIN. >> Reporter: BUT WHAT IF HE WAS 2628 01:17:13,296 --> 01:17:13,928 >> Reporter: BUT WHAT IF HE WAS LYING, HOW WOULD THEY EVER PROVE 2629 01:17:13,930 --> 01:17:16,664 LYING, HOW WOULD THEY EVER PROVE IT 2630 01:17:16,666 --> 01:17:25,106 IT >> WE HAD NO FACTS TO REFUTE 2631 01:17:25,108 --> 01:17:25,606 >> WE HAD NO FACTS TO REFUTE HIS, HIS STATEMENT TO ME 2632 01:17:25,608 --> 01:17:26,173 HIS, HIS STATEMENT TO ME WE WEREN'T IN THAT ROOM THAT 2633 01:17:26,175 --> 01:17:26,741 WE WEREN'T IN THAT ROOM THAT NIGHT THAT NANCY PFISTER WAS 2634 01:17:26,743 --> 01:17:27,375 NIGHT THAT NANCY PFISTER WAS MURDERED, SO WE HAD NO FACTS TO 2635 01:17:27,377 --> 01:17:27,975 MURDERED, SO WE HAD NO FACTS TO REFUTE WHAT WILLIAM STYLER WAS 2636 01:17:27,977 --> 01:17:28,175 REFUTE WHAT WILLIAM STYLER WAS SAYING 2637 01:17:28,177 --> 01:17:28,809 SAYING >> Reporter: SO YOU'RE SAYING TO 2638 01:17:28,811 --> 01:17:29,377 >> Reporter: SO YOU'RE SAYING TO ME THAT KATHY CARPENTER AND 2639 01:17:29,379 --> 01:17:29,977 ME THAT KATHY CARPENTER AND NANCY STYLER ARE BOTH INNOCENT 2640 01:17:29,979 --> 01:17:31,412 NANCY STYLER ARE BOTH INNOCENT NEITHER ONE PARTICIPATED IN THIS 2641 01:17:31,414 --> 01:17:31,946 NEITHER ONE PARTICIPATED IN THIS CRIME? 2642 01:17:31,948 --> 01:17:36,217 CRIME? >> WILLIAM STYLER SAID THAT. 2643 01:17:36,219 --> 01:17:37,218 >> WILLIAM STYLER SAID THAT. I'M NOT SAYING THAT. 2644 01:17:37,220 --> 01:17:37,785 I'M NOT SAYING THAT. >> Reporter: BUT DESPITE OF 2645 01:17:37,787 --> 01:17:38,819 >> Reporter: BUT DESPITE OF INVESTIGATOR MILLER'S DOUBTS ON 2646 01:17:38,821 --> 01:17:39,453 INVESTIGATOR MILLER'S DOUBTS ON JUNE 17TH, 2014, AFTER THREE AND 2647 01:17:39,455 --> 01:17:40,021 JUNE 17TH, 2014, AFTER THREE AND A HALF MONTHS IN JAIL, NANCY 2648 01:17:40,023 --> 01:17:40,454 A HALF MONTHS IN JAIL, NANCY STYLER WAS RELEASED. 2649 01:17:40,456 --> 01:17:41,055 STYLER WAS RELEASED. >> AND MY ATTORNEY, BETH, WAS 2650 01:17:41,057 --> 01:17:41,455 >> AND MY ATTORNEY, BETH, WAS THERE. 2651 01:17:41,457 --> 01:17:41,956 THERE. AND SHE SAID, "GOOD NEWS 2652 01:17:41,958 --> 01:17:42,523 AND SHE SAID, "GOOD NEWS YOU'RE GETTIN' OUT." 2653 01:17:42,525 --> 01:17:43,024 YOU'RE GETTIN' OUT." AND I SAID, "GREAT 2654 01:17:43,026 --> 01:17:44,125 AND I SAID, "GREAT YOU KNOW, THEY FIGURED IT OUT. 2655 01:17:44,127 --> 01:17:44,759 YOU KNOW, THEY FIGURED IT OUT. AND THEN SHE SAID, "BUT THERE'S 2656 01:17:44,761 --> 01:17:44,992 AND THEN SHE SAID, "BUT THERE'S A CATCH. 2657 01:17:44,994 --> 01:17:45,593 A CATCH. >> Reporter: SHE GAVE NANCY A 2658 01:17:45,595 --> 01:17:45,793 >> Reporter: SHE GAVE NANCY A LETTER 2659 01:17:45,795 --> 01:17:48,863 LETTER IT WAS A PRIVATE NOTE FROM TREY. 2660 01:17:48,865 --> 01:17:51,465 IT WAS A PRIVATE NOTE FROM TREY. >> AND IN THIS LETTER, HE TELLS 2661 01:17:51,467 --> 01:17:52,566 >> AND IN THIS LETTER, HE TELLS ME ABOUT THE PLEA BARGAIN THAT 2662 01:17:52,568 --> 01:17:54,168 ME ABOUT THE PLEA BARGAIN THAT HE TOOK. 2663 01:17:54,170 --> 01:17:57,838 HE TOOK. AND ONE OF THE SENTENCES THAT 2664 01:17:57,840 --> 01:17:59,440 AND ONE OF THE SENTENCES THAT I'VE READ A MILLION TIMES OVER 2665 01:17:59,442 --> 01:18:01,008 I'VE READ A MILLION TIMES OVER SAID, "I KNOW YOU'RE INNOCENT. 2666 01:18:01,010 --> 01:18:02,109 SAID, "I KNOW YOU'RE INNOCENT. AND YOU SHOULD BELIEVE I AM, 2667 01:18:02,111 --> 01:18:03,644 AND YOU SHOULD BELIEVE I AM, TOO. 2668 01:18:03,646 --> 01:18:05,212 TOO. >> Reporter: TREY WROTE THAT WAS 2669 01:18:05,214 --> 01:18:05,780 >> Reporter: TREY WROTE THAT WAS ONLY PLEADING GUILTY TO SAVE 2670 01:18:05,782 --> 01:18:06,814 ONLY PLEADING GUILTY TO SAVE HER. 2671 01:18:06,816 --> 01:18:07,882 HER. HE DIDN'T ACTUALLY KILL NANCY 2672 01:18:07,884 --> 01:18:10,017 HE DIDN'T ACTUALLY KILL NANCY PFISTER, HE WROTE. 2673 01:18:10,019 --> 01:18:11,585 PFISTER, HE WROTE. HE WAS FALLING ON HIS SWORD FOR 2674 01:18:11,587 --> 01:18:12,620 HE WAS FALLING ON HIS SWORD FOR LOVE 2675 01:18:12,622 --> 01:18:15,256 LOVE >> I CRIED THAT WHOLE DAY, EVEN 2676 01:18:15,258 --> 01:18:17,391 >> I CRIED THAT WHOLE DAY, EVEN THOUGH I WAS GETTING OUT 2677 01:18:17,393 --> 01:18:18,426 THOUGH I WAS GETTING OUT IT SHOULD'VE BEEN A, A GREAT 2678 01:18:18,428 --> 01:18:20,528 IT SHOULD'VE BEEN A, A GREAT TIME 2679 01:18:20,530 --> 01:18:22,697 TIME I CAN'T BELIEVE HE'S HAVING TO 2680 01:18:22,699 --> 01:18:24,532 I CAN'T BELIEVE HE'S HAVING TO DO THIS. 2681 01:18:24,534 --> 01:18:27,535 DO THIS. THIS SYSTEM IS SICK. 2682 01:18:27,537 --> 01:18:28,469 THIS SYSTEM IS SICK. IT'S, YOU KNOW, MESSED UP. 2683 01:18:28,471 --> 01:18:30,571 IT'S, YOU KNOW, MESSED UP. >> Reporter: THREE DAYS LATER, 2684 01:18:30,573 --> 01:18:32,173 >> Reporter: THREE DAYS LATER, JUNE 20TH, DR. TREY STYLER 2685 01:18:32,175 --> 01:18:33,574 JUNE 20TH, DR. TREY STYLER FORMALLY PLEADED GUILTY TO 2686 01:18:33,576 --> 01:18:34,275 FORMALLY PLEADED GUILTY TO SECOND DEGREE MURDER AND WAS 2687 01:18:34,277 --> 01:18:35,342 SECOND DEGREE MURDER AND WAS SENTENCED TO TWENTY YEARS IN 2688 01:18:35,344 --> 01:18:36,944 SENTENCED TO TWENTY YEARS IN PRISON 2689 01:18:36,946 --> 01:18:38,779 PRISON CONSIDERING HIS HEALTH AND AGE, 2690 01:18:38,781 --> 01:18:39,780 CONSIDERING HIS HEALTH AND AGE, IT WAS ALMOST CERTAINLY WAS A 2691 01:18:39,782 --> 01:18:40,114 IT WAS ALMOST CERTAINLY WAS A LIFE SENTENCE. 2692 01:18:40,116 --> 01:18:40,715 LIFE SENTENCE. THAT SAME DAY THE D.A. DROPPED 2693 01:18:40,717 --> 01:18:41,348 THAT SAME DAY THE D.A. DROPPED CHARGES AGAINST KATHY CARPENTER 2694 01:18:41,350 --> 01:18:41,916 CHARGES AGAINST KATHY CARPENTER AND SHE WALKED OUT OF JAIL A 2695 01:18:41,918 --> 01:18:42,183 AND SHE WALKED OUT OF JAIL A FREE WOMAN 2696 01:18:42,185 --> 01:18:44,685 FREE WOMAN >> I WAS VERY GRATEFUL, VERY 2697 01:18:44,687 --> 01:18:46,454 >> I WAS VERY GRATEFUL, VERY THANKFUL 2698 01:18:46,456 --> 01:18:51,726 THANKFUL AND I FELT GOD ANSWERED MY 2699 01:18:51,728 --> 01:18:52,259 AND I FELT GOD ANSWERED MY PRAYERS. 2700 01:18:52,261 --> 01:18:53,027 PRAYERS. AND UM, BUT AT THE SAME TIME, IT 2701 01:18:53,029 --> 01:18:53,828 AND UM, BUT AT THE SAME TIME, IT WAS STILL SCARY. 2702 01:18:53,830 --> 01:18:57,531 WAS STILL SCARY. I'M LEAVING JAIL AFTER BEING 2703 01:18:57,533 --> 01:18:58,065 I'M LEAVING JAIL AFTER BEING LOCKED UP. 2704 01:18:58,067 --> 01:19:01,936 LOCKED UP. WHAT WILL PEOPLE THINK 2705 01:19:01,938 --> 01:19:02,369 WHAT WILL PEOPLE THINK HOW WILL I BE JUDGED 2706 01:19:02,371 --> 01:19:07,508 HOW WILL I BE JUDGED >> Reporter: SHE IS GRATEFUL, 2707 01:19:07,510 --> 01:19:07,875 >> Reporter: SHE IS GRATEFUL, SCARED, ALSO SAD 2708 01:19:07,877 --> 01:19:08,442 SCARED, ALSO SAD >> BUT THERE WAS SORROW FOR 2709 01:19:08,444 --> 01:19:12,279 >> BUT THERE WAS SORROW FOR STILL THINKING OF THE LOSS OF 2710 01:19:12,281 --> 01:19:13,948 STILL THINKING OF THE LOSS OF NANCY. 2711 01:19:13,950 --> 01:19:14,548 NANCY. AND THAT HE DID SOMETHIN' LIKE 2712 01:19:14,550 --> 01:19:23,390 AND THAT HE DID SOMETHIN' LIKE THIS, THAT HE DID IT, YOU KNOW, 2713 01:19:23,392 --> 01:19:23,858 THIS, THAT HE DID IT, YOU KNOW, THAT WAS STILL HURTFUL 2714 01:19:23,860 --> 01:19:24,458 THAT WAS STILL HURTFUL >> Reporter: BUT NANCY STYLER 2715 01:19:24,460 --> 01:19:25,025 >> Reporter: BUT NANCY STYLER ADDED A BITTER ANGER TO HER 2716 01:19:25,027 --> 01:19:25,626 ADDED A BITTER ANGER TO HER WHIRLWIND OF GRIEF AND RELIEF. 2717 01:19:25,628 --> 01:19:28,129 WHIRLWIND OF GRIEF AND RELIEF. IF TREY WAS INNOCENT, AS HE TOLD 2718 01:19:28,131 --> 01:19:30,765 IF TREY WAS INNOCENT, AS HE TOLD HIS WIFE HE WAS, THEN HAD THE 2719 01:19:30,767 --> 01:19:31,799 HIS WIFE HE WAS, THEN HAD THE REAL KILLER JUST WALKED FREE 2720 01:19:31,801 --> 01:19:34,435 REAL KILLER JUST WALKED FREE >> I HAD KATHY CARPENTER PEGGED 2721 01:19:34,437 --> 01:19:39,173 >> I HAD KATHY CARPENTER PEGGED IN MY OWN LITTLE COURTROOM 2722 01:19:39,175 --> 01:19:39,707 IN MY OWN LITTLE COURTROOM AND EVERY LITTLE PIECE OF 2723 01:19:39,709 --> 01:19:41,308 AND EVERY LITTLE PIECE OF EVIDENCE THAT WAS GIVEN TO ME 2724 01:19:41,310 --> 01:19:43,410 EVIDENCE THAT WAS GIVEN TO ME CORROBORATED THAT. 2725 01:19:43,412 --> 01:19:47,114 CORROBORATED THAT. >> Reporter: AND THEN, IT WAS 2726 01:19:47,116 --> 01:19:48,716 >> Reporter: AND THEN, IT WAS JUST OVER TWO WEEKS LATER NANCY 2727 01:19:48,718 --> 01:19:50,284 JUST OVER TWO WEEKS LATER NANCY TOOK A CALL. 2728 01:19:50,286 --> 01:19:51,118 TOOK A CALL. TREY HAD SOMETHING TO TELL HER 2729 01:19:51,120 --> 01:19:51,852 TREY HAD SOMETHING TO TELL HER HIS LETTER WASN'T QUITE TRUE HE 2730 01:19:51,854 --> 01:19:52,353 HIS LETTER WASN'T QUITE TRUE HE SAID 2731 01:19:52,355 --> 01:19:57,158 SAID IN FACT, HE AND HE ALONE 2732 01:19:57,160 --> 01:19:57,892 IN FACT, HE AND HE ALONE MURDERED NANCY PFISTER 2733 01:19:57,894 --> 01:19:59,794 MURDERED NANCY PFISTER KATHY CARPENTER HAD NOTHING TO 2734 01:19:59,796 --> 01:20:00,361 KATHY CARPENTER HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH IT 2735 01:20:00,363 --> 01:20:01,896 DO WITH IT >> IT WAS, TOOK MY WORLD AND 2736 01:20:01,898 --> 01:20:03,464 >> IT WAS, TOOK MY WORLD AND JUST FLIPPED IT UPSIDE DOWN, 2737 01:20:03,466 --> 01:20:16,677 JUST FLIPPED IT UPSIDE DOWN, FELT LIKE MY WHOLE LIFE HAD BEEN 2738 01:20:16,679 --> 01:20:18,279 FELT LIKE MY WHOLE LIFE HAD BEEN A LIE. 2739 01:20:18,281 --> 01:20:19,313 A LIE. YOU KNOW, MY WHOLE LIFE WITH HIM 2740 01:20:19,315 --> 01:20:21,649 YOU KNOW, MY WHOLE LIFE WITH HIM HAD BEEN A LIE 2741 01:20:21,651 --> 01:20:23,017 HAD BEEN A LIE >> Reporter: SHE IS TRYING TO 2742 01:20:23,019 --> 01:20:26,187 >> Reporter: SHE IS TRYING TO REBUILD LIFE NOW 2743 01:20:26,189 --> 01:20:27,254 REBUILD LIFE NOW HAS MOVED BACK TO THE EAST COAST 2744 01:20:27,256 --> 01:20:33,060 HAS MOVED BACK TO THE EAST COAST WHERE SHE GREW UP AND RECLAIMED 2745 01:20:33,062 --> 01:20:33,627 WHERE SHE GREW UP AND RECLAIMED HER MAIDEN NAME, FILING FOR 2746 01:20:33,629 --> 01:20:34,295 HER MAIDEN NAME, FILING FOR DIVORCE FROM TREY AFTER 2747 01:20:34,297 --> 01:20:34,862 DIVORCE FROM TREY AFTER THIRTY-TWO YEARS OF MARRIAGE 2748 01:20:34,864 --> 01:20:46,774 THIRTY-TWO YEARS OF MARRIAGE DO YOU LOVE HIM AT ALL ANYMORE 2749 01:20:46,776 --> 01:20:47,308 DO YOU LOVE HIM AT ALL ANYMORE >> I LOVE HIM. 2750 01:20:47,310 --> 01:20:47,942 >> I LOVE HIM. I LOVE HIM, I LOVE THE MAN THAT 2751 01:20:47,944 --> 01:20:48,375 I LOVE HIM, I LOVE THE MAN THAT WAS. 2752 01:20:48,377 --> 01:20:48,909 WAS. I DON'T LOVE THIS MONSTER. 2753 01:20:48,911 --> 01:20:55,216 I DON'T LOVE THIS MONSTER. >> Reporter: IT WAS THEN THAT 2754 01:20:55,218 --> 01:20:55,783 >> Reporter: IT WAS THEN THAT NANCY STYLER'S ATTORNEY BETH 2755 01:20:55,785 --> 01:20:56,450 NANCY STYLER'S ATTORNEY BETH AND SHE'S LOST HER VERY BEST 2756 01:20:56,452 --> 01:20:57,384 AND SHE'S LOST HER VERY BEST FRIEND SHE SAID. 2757 01:20:57,386 --> 01:20:57,918 FRIEND SHE SAID. AND SHE TOLD US SHE FEELS 2758 01:20:57,920 --> 01:20:59,987 AND SHE TOLD US SHE FEELS GUILTY 2759 01:20:59,989 --> 01:21:00,621 GUILTY >> THAT'S WHY I SAY I WISH THAT 2760 01:21:00,623 --> 01:21:01,555 >> THAT'S WHY I SAY I WISH THAT I COULD HAVE HELPED HER AND HAVE 2761 01:21:01,557 --> 01:21:02,089 I COULD HAVE HELPED HER AND HAVE BEEN THERE 2762 01:21:02,091 --> 01:21:08,963 BEEN THERE WHAT COULD I HAVE DONE 2763 01:21:08,965 --> 01:21:13,133 WHAT COULD I HAVE DONE DIFFERENTLY? 2764 01:21:13,135 --> 01:21:13,734 DIFFERENTLY? TALKED HER INTO STAYIN' THERE, 2765 01:21:13,736 --> 01:21:14,201 TALKED HER INTO STAYIN' THERE, NOT COMIN' HOME. 2766 01:21:14,203 --> 01:21:17,872 NOT COMIN' HOME. >> Reporter: NOTHING CAN KNOW 2767 01:21:17,874 --> 01:21:21,075 >> Reporter: NOTHING CAN KNOW THE FUTURE 2768 01:21:21,077 --> 01:21:22,643 THE FUTURE >> RIGHT 2769 01:21:22,645 --> 01:21:24,778 >> RIGHT BUT I DO BLAME MYSELF. 2770 01:21:24,780 --> 01:21:26,881 BUT I DO BLAME MYSELF. YOU KNOW, THAT'S SOMETHING THAT 2771 01:21:26,883 --> 01:21:27,948 YOU KNOW, THAT'S SOMETHING THAT I'LL HAVE TO -- TO WORK THROUGH 2772 01:21:27,950 --> 01:21:29,516 I'LL HAVE TO -- TO WORK THROUGH BUT, UM -- 2773 01:21:29,518 --> 01:21:30,084 BUT, UM -- >> Reporter: ONE PERSON WITH 2774 01:21:30,086 --> 01:21:30,718 >> Reporter: ONE PERSON WITH WHOM KATHY HAS NOT SPOKEN SINCE 2775 01:21:30,720 --> 01:21:35,322 WHOM KATHY HAS NOT SPOKEN SINCE ALL THIS HAPPENED IS NANCY 2776 01:21:35,324 --> 01:21:35,890 ALL THIS HAPPENED IS NANCY PFISTER'S DAUGHTER, JULIANA. 2777 01:21:35,892 --> 01:21:36,457 PFISTER'S DAUGHTER, JULIANA. WHAT WOULD YOU WANNA SAY TO 2778 01:21:36,459 --> 01:21:36,924 WHAT WOULD YOU WANNA SAY TO JULIANA? 2779 01:21:36,926 --> 01:21:45,332 JULIANA? >> THAT I JUST HOPE THAT SHE 2780 01:21:45,334 --> 01:21:49,036 >> THAT I JUST HOPE THAT SHE KNOWS THE TRUTH. 2781 01:21:49,038 --> 01:21:50,104 KNOWS THE TRUTH. I HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH THE 2782 01:21:50,106 --> 01:21:51,171 I HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH THE MURDER OF HER MOTHER 2783 01:21:51,173 --> 01:21:52,740 MURDER OF HER MOTHER I NEVER WOULD STEAL, AND I JUST 2784 01:21:52,742 --> 01:21:54,508 I NEVER WOULD STEAL, AND I JUST I WAS LOOKING OUT FOR HER AND 2785 01:21:54,510 --> 01:21:55,376 I WAS LOOKING OUT FOR HER AND HER MOTHER'S WISHES. 2786 01:21:55,378 --> 01:21:58,012 HER MOTHER'S WISHES. AND THAT, UM -- I JUST HOPE THAT 2787 01:21:58,014 --> 01:22:00,147 AND THAT, UM -- I JUST HOPE THAT SHE WOULD FIND FORGIVENESS IN 2788 01:22:00,149 --> 01:22:02,750 SHE WOULD FIND FORGIVENESS IN HER HEART AND KNOW THAT I LOVE 2789 01:22:02,752 --> 01:22:04,351 HER HEART AND KNOW THAT I LOVE HER AND HER MOTHER VERY MUCH 2790 01:22:04,353 --> 01:22:05,920 HER AND HER MOTHER VERY MUCH >> Reporter: WHAT DOES SHE HAVE 2791 01:22:05,922 --> 01:22:07,755 >> Reporter: WHAT DOES SHE HAVE TO FORGIVE YOU FOR 2792 01:22:07,757 --> 01:22:10,758 TO FORGIVE YOU FOR >> I DON'T KNOW. 2793 01:22:10,760 --> 01:22:12,259 >> I DON'T KNOW. I -- NOTHING REALLY. 2794 01:22:12,261 --> 01:22:13,861 I -- NOTHING REALLY. BUT THERE'S JUST -- YOU KNOW, 2795 01:22:13,863 --> 01:22:14,461 BUT THERE'S JUST -- YOU KNOW, WHAT SHE'S HAD TO GO THROUGH, 2796 01:22:14,463 --> 01:22:24,405 WHAT SHE'S HAD TO GO THROUGH, AND I -- I DON'T KNOW WHY I 2797 01:22:24,407 --> 01:22:25,673 AND I -- I DON'T KNOW WHY I WOULD EVEN SAY FORGIVE, BUT -- 2798 01:22:25,675 --> 01:22:27,041 WOULD EVEN SAY FORGIVE, BUT -- >> Reporter: CURIOUS, HUH? 2799 01:22:27,043 --> 01:22:34,448 >> Reporter: CURIOUS, HUH? >> YEAH. 2800 01:22:34,450 --> 01:22:35,616 >> YEAH. IT'S JUST, I'VE BEEN PORTRAYED 2801 01:22:35,618 --> 01:22:42,323 IT'S JUST, I'VE BEEN PORTRAYED AS THIS THIEF, THIS BAD PERSON, 2802 01:22:42,325 --> 01:22:42,957 AS THIS THIEF, THIS BAD PERSON, UNTRUSTING AND I DON'T KNOW WHY. 2803 01:22:42,959 --> 01:22:44,458 UNTRUSTING AND I DON'T KNOW WHY. >> Reporter: TRUST, SOMETHING 2804 01:22:44,460 --> 01:22:52,866 >> Reporter: TRUST, SOMETHING NANCY PFISTER WAS KNOWN FOR. 2805 01:22:52,868 --> 01:22:53,434 NANCY PFISTER WAS KNOWN FOR. NOT SO MUCH OF IT THESE DAYS 2806 01:22:53,436 --> 01:22:54,501 NOT SO MUCH OF IT THESE DAYS >> ASPEN WILL NEVER BE THE SAME. 2807 01:22:54,503 --> 01:22:58,906 >> ASPEN WILL NEVER BE THE SAME. MY LIFE WILL NEVER BE THE SAME 2808 01:22:58,908 --> 01:22:59,506 MY LIFE WILL NEVER BE THE SAME >> Reporter: SO WHAT HAS ASPEN 2809 01:22:59,508 --> 01:23:01,942 >> Reporter: SO WHAT HAS ASPEN LOST 2810 01:23:01,944 --> 01:23:02,543 LOST >> A LOST OF HISTORY, YOU KNOW 2811 01:23:02,545 --> 01:23:03,077 >> A LOST OF HISTORY, YOU KNOW NANCY WAS PART OF ASPEN'S 2812 01:23:03,079 --> 01:23:04,044 NANCY WAS PART OF ASPEN'S HISTORY. 2813 01:23:04,046 --> 01:23:05,079 HISTORY. IT'S A HUGE LOSS FOR THE 2814 01:23:05,081 --> 01:23:05,612 IT'S A HUGE LOSS FOR THE COMMUNITY. 2815 01:23:05,614 --> 01:23:06,914 COMMUNITY. >> Reporter: SOME MEMBERS OF 2816 01:23:06,916 --> 01:23:08,248 >> Reporter: SOME MEMBERS OF WHICH BE TELLING STORIES ABOUT 2817 01:23:08,250 --> 01:23:16,724 WHICH BE TELLING STORIES ABOUT NANCY PFISTER FOR A VERY LONG 2818 01:23:16,726 --> 01:23:17,224 NANCY PFISTER FOR A VERY LONG TIME 2819 01:23:17,226 --> 01:23:17,925 TIME >> NANCY LIVED A FANTASTIC LIFE. 2820 01:23:17,927 --> 01:23:22,496 >> NANCY LIVED A FANTASTIC LIFE. AND UH, I -- I THINK -- I THINK 2821 01:23:22,498 --> 01:23:23,263 AND UH, I -- I THINK -- I THINK WE ALL NEED A LITTLE MORE 2822 01:23:23,265 --> 01:23:23,897 WE ALL NEED A LITTLE MORE DREAMING LIKE THAT, YOU KNOW, A 2823 01:23:23,899 --> 01:23:24,631 DREAMING LIKE THAT, YOU KNOW, A LITTLE, LITTLE MORE -- 2824 01:23:24,633 --> 01:23:25,232 LITTLE, LITTLE MORE -- >> Reporter: LITTLE MORE NANCY 2825 01:23:25,234 --> 01:23:25,666 >> Reporter: LITTLE MORE NANCY IN US? 2826 01:23:25,668 --> 01:23:30,938 IN US? >> LITTLE MORE NANCY IN US, 2827 01:23:30,940 --> 01:23:31,405 >> LITTLE MORE NANCY IN US, YEAH 2828 01:23:31,407 --> 01:23:32,539 YEAH >> THAT'S ALL FOR THIS EDITION 2829 01:23:32,541 --> 01:23:33,774 >> THAT'S ALL FOR THIS EDITION OF "DATELINE." 2830 01:23:33,776 --> 01:23:34,375 OF "DATELINE." WE WILL SEE YOU NEXT FRIDAY AT 2831 01:23:34,377 --> 01:23:38,645 WE WILL SEE YOU NEXT FRIDAY AT 9:00, 8:00 CENTRAL 2832 01:23:38,647 --> 01:23:42,082 9:00, 8:00 CENTRAL AND OF COURSE, I'LL SEE YOU EACH 2833 01:23:42,084 --> 01:23:42,616 AND OF COURSE, I'LL SEE YOU EACH WEEKNIGHT FOR "NBC NIGHTLY 2834 01:23:42,618 --> 01:23:43,117 WEEKNIGHT FOR "NBC NIGHTLY NEWS". 2835 01:23:43,119 --> 01:23:44,184 NEWS". I'M LESTER HOLT. 2836 01:23:44,186 --> 01:23:48,855 I'M LESTER HOLT. FOR ALL OF US AT NBC NEWS, GOOD