- In the criminal justice system,
the people are represented
by two separate, yet equally important groups:
the police, who investigate crime,
and the district attorneys, who prosecute the offenders.
These are their stories.
- It's a great opportunity, but these kids are like family.
I believe in loyalty.
I wish I didn't, I swear to God.
Life would be easier.
But this is my life.
You don't get many opportunities like this.
- [whistles] - Hey, I gotta go.
Yeah.
Thanks for listening.
[low suspenseful music]
♪
- Two shots to the chest.
Guy over there said he heard gunshots and called 911.
Didn't see the shooter, though.
Wallet and phone weren't found on his person.
But it's Nick Walsh.
- The coach?
- That's him.
Big fan.
Not easy to go back-to-back in college basketball.
- Kentucky just offered this guy
100 mil for five years.
- One more data point that life ain't fair.
Perp snatched his watch.
- Snatched a lot more than that.
[tense music]
[dramatic music]
♪
- All right. Thanks for your help.
- So the question is, what was a big-time
college coach doing down here anyway?
- Can someone tell me how in 2024
there's not a single camera on one of these buildings?
[phone ringing]
Riley.
Yeah, I'll be there in five.
Hey, man, I got a personal thing.
I'll be back.
- I really appreciate the call, Ray.
- Of course. I wish I knew beforehand.
- Yeah, me too, but here we are.
[sighs] Unbelievable.
- [chuckles] Vinny, how you doing, man?
Hey, they set me up. - Mm.
- What do you call that, entrapment?
- Oh, you're a lawyer now, huh? - Come on, man.
I didn't have a choice, all right?
I need the money. - Oh, you didn't have a choice.
You didn't have a choice but to sell guns.
Is that what you're saying to me?
- All right, I hear you. All right, I messed up.
You're right.
Thanks for coming down. I appreciate it.
Good to see you too.
- My partner and I have been working
that neighborhood for a few weeks,
putting out word we were looking for guns.
- Yeah, and then what? - Matt texted me.
Said he had two heaters he was trying to move.
So we met up earlier today.
I gave him two grand. He gave me two guns.
And we busted him.
- The guy can't get out of his own way.
[sighs]
But he's my brother, and I love him, so...
- I get it, Vince,
but we're talking about guns here.
Hard to make a case like this disappear.
- I understand.
Listen, Matt runs with a colorful crowd--
hustlers, some real criminals.
Maybe he can work it off as an informant.
- Let me run it up the flagpole.
- I owe you one, Ray.
- Selling guns. That is no joke.
What was he thinking? - Man, I--[sighs]
I don't even know where to begin.
- You don't have to. It's not your job.
You're not your brother's keeper.
- Yeah, sometimes I'm not so sure about that.
But he's a good guy--
sometimes. - A good guy who sells guns.
- 95% of the time he's all right, you know?
Like when our dad got sick, he stepped up.
He took care of him, no questions asked.
Wasn't looking for a medal. He just did it.
It's the other 5% with Matt.
And he just has a way of finding trouble, man.
He just digs himself into hole after hole,
and I am always the one that has to dig him out.
Mrs. Walsh, I know how difficult this is,
and I am very sorry for your loss.
You mentioned that you had just spoken to your husband.
Do you know what time that was?
- Around 4:00.
- Do you know where he was?
Who he might have been with?
- No.
We were talking about whether to stay or go.
Kentucky made a really generous offer,
more than double what we're making now, but--
but Nick really loved Hudson
and his coaches and his players.
He's just so damn principled.
It was making everything really hard.
- Ma'am, did your husband wear a watch on his left wrist?
Can you describe it?
- It's a Rolex with a platinum and gold band and a blue face.
- Any inscriptions on it?
- No.
Why?
- The watch was missing, so we're just
collecting information at this point.
- Was anyone harassing or threatening your husband?
- Not that I'm aware of. [sniffles]
But the past few weeks have been crazy.
It felt like the whole city was threatening and harassing us.
People would walk up to us in a restaurant.
You can't leave us, Coach.
My whole world revolves around Hudson basketball.
Actually, I saw him arguing with someone
outside of our building.
[suspenseful music]
- When was this? - Two days ago.
- So the wife was home most of the day.
By all appearances, they had a great relationship.
They met in college, got married at 24.
- American dream. - Something like that.
- Yo!
Hey, I found a video of Walsh arguing with somebody.
Check this out.
- Can you zoom in on the other guy?
- That's the best I can do.
- Wait. Freeze it there.
- Mm-hmm. - It's a badge.
- And it's not NYPD.
- Walsh was arguing with an FBI agent.
♪
- I met with Walsh three days ago.
- Looked more like an argument to me.
- Yeah, he ran hot.
Lots of emotion.
- Was this conversation personal or professional?
- Professional.
Some rich alumnus threatened to destroy his life.
- Why?
Because he was thinking about leaving Hudson?
- Crazy, right?
But these boosters take this stuff very seriously.
And according to Walsh, this guy had the resources
and the conviction to pull it off.
He got nervous.
Called an agent down in Atlanta--his cousin, I think.
She asked if I could help out.
- Why was Walsh so mad?
- He changed his mind.
He said he didn't wanna get this booster in trouble.
Said he overreacted.
When I made it clear that it wasn't that easy--
genie's out of the bottle--
he got upset. - Hmm.
This booster got a name?
- I just wrote that stubborn Irish prick
a check for $2 million,
and he's thinking of walking out on me,
heading to Kentucky? - Wait, hold on.
You wrote a check for 2 mil for what?
- A 6'7" point guard from LA
who plays defense like Gary Payton
and shoots like Ray Allen.
Number one recruit in the country.
Kid's agent wanted 3 mil.
I was able to get it done for 2 with a 500,000 kicker
if we win the championship.
- All this money to play college basketball now.
- Yeah, no rules anymore. It's the Wild West.
It's really fun. - Oh, it's fun.
Like getting shot in the chest in a vacant lot kind of fun?
- Yeah, that's--
I can't believe he's really gone.
I've been crying like a baby ever since I found out.
- You've been crying like a baby since he's been gone,
and you've been threatening to ruin his life?
- Correct.
The threat had to do with business.
I pledged 10 million
for a new practice facility this year.
That's on top of the 2 million for the kid from LA
So I'm long 12 mil just this year.
And he's gonna walk out on me?
Hell, no. But as a person, I loved him.
- I mean, where I'm from, you don't try to destroy
the people you love, but-- - I threatened to destroy him.
I was just negotiating.
Look, I wanted to scare him, to keep him in Hudson.
- Where were you the day of the murder at 4:30 p.m.?
- In a meeting here with 20 people.
Look, I didn't kill Coach Walsh.
- Any idea what he was doing on the Lower East Side?
- No.
- Any of his friends live there?
- Not that I know of.
One of his players does, though.
Well, former player, actually.
Coach cut him from the team three days ago.
- The kid get upset about that?
- I'm not sure. His father was, though.
He went crazy.
I can't say I blame him, either.
Cost the kid a million bucks.
- You think the father is capable of violence?
- For a million dollars?
Anyone is.
[tense music]
♪
- We hung out for about an hour.
- Was that typical?
Was there any reason Coach was there?
- I guess he felt bad and wanted to make it right.
If you ask me, that son of a bitch
needed to make it right. - Yeah, I get it.
Cost Malik a lot of money. You too, huh?
- $1 million.
And he just--he didn't care.
Told Malik to go home.
He had no right to do that.
- You feel the same way about that?
- I mean, I was--
I was upset, but--
- What? - It was my fault.
I wasn't as focused as I should have been.
I was late to practice a lot.
I was focusing on things other than basketball,
you know, getting endorsements, doing TikToks, rapping.
So I get it.
- What time did Coach leave the house?
- Around 4:00.
- And that's the last time you guys saw him.
- Yes, sir.
- Did Walsh say anything about where he was going
or if he was meeting anybody?
- Coach came in around 4:15 or so.
He was here for about 20 minutes.
- You happen to see who he was talking to?
- I'm pretty sure he was alone--
most of the time, anyway.
But I gotta be honest.
I wasn't really paying attention.
- Was he alone when he left?
- Uh, sorry. I didn't notice.
- How about was anybody bothering or harassing him?
- Nah.
People here mind their own business.
- Do you mind if we take a look at your surveillance video?
- Don't have any.
- Nothing?
- Like I said, people here tend to mind their own business.
- All right. Thank you.
- Learn anything new?
- Yeah, that, apparently, college basketball is
now professional basketball.
These kids are literally making millions of dollars.
- Yeah. NIL changed everything.
I grew up going to St. John's games with my dad.
- Well, we're getting closer at least.
Looks like the last place Walsh was seen
was at Clancy's, the bar a few blocks
down the street from the vacant lot where he was shot.
- We're actually closer than you think we are.
Just found video of Walsh from the hardware store
across the street from Clancy's.
And there he is, leaving the bar at 4:34 p.m.,
and he's with another guy.
- Music to my ears.
- Clean angle too. How about that?
- Run it through facial rec.
[suspenseful music]
- No need.
It's my brother.
♪
- I don't get it.
What's everybody so worked up about?
- Well, you see, Matty, we're kind of investigating a murder.
- You might have been the last person seen
with the dead guy prior to him being dead.
So you and Walsh left the bar together.
Why is that?
- Guys, I hope you know I had nothing to do
with Walsh's death. You know that, right?
- Will you just answer the question
for once in your life, please?
- I was having a beer at Clancy's.
I saw the guy heading for the door.
I figured I'd walk over and say hi.
You know, we played against each other in high school.
I had 17 points.
- Fantastic.
- Yeah, he remembered me. No lie.
Said I had one of the prettiest
left-handed jump shots he'd ever seen.
- That's great, Matt, but we're a little more interested
in the murder than your jump shot right now, okay?
- What'd you guys do when you left the bar?
- Walked for a few blocks down by the bridge.
I asked if he was gonna take that Kentucky job.
He didn't really answer me.
Said he was thinking about it, but that he loved Hudson.
- Okay, then what? - And then nothing.
He got a phone call, and he walked away.
That was it.
- Was anybody watching him or waiting for him?
- No, not really.
I mean, other than Jackie.
- You gonna tell us who Jackie is?
- Jackie Costa. He owns Clancy's.
- And what was Jackie Costa doing?
- Standing on a box smoking a cigarette.
- Okay, so you and Walsh part ways,
and Costa is just standing there smoking a cigarette.
That's it?
- Does anybody have a lighter?
- Like I said before, I was here all afternoon working.
- Step outside for a few?
Maybe take a walk? - No.
- Maybe take a little smoke break?
- I gave it up.
I heard a rumor it was bad for your health.
- [chuckles] - Yeah, I heard that one too.
- Why are you guys asking all these questions?
I already told you what I saw, what I know.
- Yeah, yeah.
Well, we talked to someone who said that they saw Walsh
walking down Sixth Street, and they thought
that they maybe saw you too.
So, you know, we're just following up.
- He's wrong.
I was inside the bar all afternoon.
- Got it.
- Thanks for your time. - Mm-hmm.
- He's lying his ass off, about the smoking anyway.
Had a pack of cigarettes in his jacket pocket.
So Costa's alibi checks out.
Talked to the dishwasher, the bartender,
two guys who claimed to be at the bar from 3:00 to 6:00,
and everybody says that Costa was at the bar the entire time,
and they said he quit smoking,
and they were adamant about that.
- Yeah, those guys would say he played shortstop
for the Yankees if he asked them to.
- Mm-hmm. - Costa is no joke.
I pulled his sheet.
He's got priors for racketeering, gambling,
assault, and narcotics.
- Oh, busy boy, huh? - Yeah.
And as suspected, he's a liar.
I found video of him two blocks from the crime scene
three minutes after the 911 call at 4:43.
So Costa was not inside the bar all day,
no matter what his friends say. - I like him for it.
- Yeah, we just gotta find a way to put him
and Walsh together prior to the murder.
- Mm-hmm. - Can you pull more video?
- It's pretty thin down there. Not a lot of cameras.
- All right, well, just-- I don't know--
keep pressing the friends. I mean, you never know.
- We can try, but that code of silence thing is real.
These guys are not gonna budge.
It's how they define themselves, you know?
- Maybe we come at this from a different angle.
Maybe we try to get Costa to talk instead.
[tense music]
- So what's going on?
- This morning, I'm making an omelet.
You know, avocado, sausage, peppers, all that.
Doorbell rings, and I'm thinking it's Amazon,
or maybe it's the lady next door with the dementia,
or it's-- - For God's sake, Matty.
- Yeah, sorry. I get a little rattled.
I go to the door, and it's two cops, detectives.
They start asking about Walsh.
- What's that got to do with me?
- They think you're involved.
- Excuse me?
- They, uh, kept asking questions about you.
- So that's why you're here?
To find out if what? If I was involved?
- He's getting suspicious. - No, he's okay.
Matty can handle this.
- Jackie, please.
I'm just trying to help you out.
I mean, I figured it was best if I came
and just told you what happened, you know?
- What kind of questions? - You know, if I--
if I saw you leave the bar together,
if I saw you and Walsh talking, if you guys had any bad blood.
- I appreciate you giving me the heads up.
- Yeah, yeah, like I said, I'm just here to help.
- Hey, look, I know you're a good guy,
but I gotta be honest.
You're making me nervous.
- He's good. He's still good.
- So, what, you wanna search me for a wire?
- It would make me feel better.
♪
- I'm insulted, but, hey, I get it.
These are stressful times, right?
Go ahead.
♪
- Okay. Sorry about that.
- You good? [chuckles]
- I appreciate you looking out.
The truth is, I might need some help with this
down the road if these guys keep sniffing.
- Of course. I'm happy to help.
- Good.
So these cops happen to tell you
if they had any evidence, video,
witnesses, anything like that?
- No, they, uh, they didn't say.
- The funny thing is, I didn't know Walsh.
This former player of his, this kid Crawford,
he owed me 75 grand.
- Now we're cooking. Now we're cooking.
- Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. What happened?
What happened to the feed?
- Hey, no, no. - What did you do?
- I don't know what happened. - I got this.
Where's the camera? - I don't know.
- Where's the button? - I don't know.
Maybe it fell off.
- Do not lie to us, Matt. Do you understand?
Do not lie. Just tell us what happened.
- What happened was--
What happened was I realized I'm not a snitch.
All right, look, I'm not ratting out
a friend of mine, a friend who's been good to me,
who's lent me money, who's helped me find jobs,
unlike some people, by the way. - Oh, here we go.
- I'm just telling the truth here, Vince.
- You can't even help yourself, can you?
- You know what? I did what I had to do.
- You know, I put my name on the line.
- Oh, yeah? - Get out of my face.
- Hey, hey, hey, hey. Watch yourself.
Because I'm not your brother. You feel me?
You look me in the eye right now.
You tell me, did Costa admit to the murder?
Yes or no?
- You know what?
We're done talking.
♪
- What does that mean, his wire malfunctioned?
- I mean, Matty got nervous, so--
- Why?
Because he thought Costa made him?
- I guess so.
Look, we still got some good information.
Costa said that one of Walsh's former players
owed him a bunch of money.
So we know that there's a connection.
So maybe Walsh was there to smooth things over,
you know, ask for leniency for the kid or something.
- Okay, that's good.
I'm still trying to understand
what happened with your brother's wire.
- Like I said-- - I know what you said.
But now I wanna know what happened.
[tense music]
- The button fell off, and Matt stepped on it.
- To protect himself?
- That's what he said.
- And do you believe him?
- No.
- Okay, well, next time, lead with the truth,
and then we'll get along better.
- Got some good news.
Tracked down the former player, Crawford.
Got a work address. Let's go.
- Yeah, that's--that's true.
I owe Costa 75 grand.
More than that, actually,
because the interest he's charging.
- Why do you owe him the money?
- I like to gamble.
- You know why Walsh was going to meet him that day?
Did it have something to do with your debt?
- All right, I needed money, so I reached out to Coach,
and God bless him.
He said he'd take care of it, under one condition,
that I get help for my addiction.
Why?
Y'all don't think Costa was involved?
- We don't know yet. We're still investigating.
- So tell me, did Coach actually say
that he was gonna meet with Costa?
- I told him where Costa worked,
and Coach said he'd take care of it.
Now, that's all I know. - He say when?
- No, he just said that he'd handle it.
- Uh-huh.
- Look, this is on me, man.
I should have never gotten him involved.
You know, I was just a role player,
scoring 3 points a game, but he--
- Look, thanks for being straight with us, all right?
- The dots are all starting to connect,
and they all lead back to Costa.
- Yeah, we're still not there yet because of your brother.
Had he not killed the wire, we'd be done by now.
Costa would be in Rikers staring down murder two.
Tell me I'm wrong. - Yeah, man. I get it.
But that's just Matty, all right?
It's just the way he is. - What?
Do you even hear yourself right now?
That's not an excuse.
What, you have some biological urge to cover for his dumb ass?
- Whoa, whoa, whoa. Take it easy.
He's still my brother.
- And what does that mean, Vince?
You gotta protect him until the day he dies?
- What do you want me to do?
I'm supposed to sell him out?
- Let's just--
okay, you're right about one thing.
Crawford's statement is helpful.
It links Costa and Walsh, sort of.
It's good enough for a warrant.
[tense music]
♪
NYPD! Do not move!
- Warrant. - What the hell?
- Keep him there.
♪
- Crowbar.
[tapping]
Uh-huh.
Looky here. Rolex with a blue face.
- Turn around and put your hands behind your back.
- What are you talking about?
- We found a unique and expensive timepiece
in your desk. - What the hell does that mean?
- It means you're under arrest.
- We have the former player's testimony,
the watch, and surveillance footage
of Costa two blocks from the crime scene
a few minutes after the 911 call.
- What about the murder weapon? - Police never recovered it.
- Motive? - I'm not sure.
At the moment, we're assuming it's something to do
with the former player's debt.
Sounds like Walsh was meeting up
with Costa to pay it off.
- Why kill someone who's giving you money?
It doesn't make sense. - I know.
We'll keep digging.
[phone buzzing]
Jalen.
- Look, I found the gun in the trash.
I didn't shoot nobody, I swear.
I saw some dude toss it.
- You saw someone throw the gun into the dumpster?
- Yeah, a white dude.
- Can you describe him, age, height, body type?
- Nah.
- So you've just been walking around
with that gun for three days?
- Yeah, but I never shot it.
I just thought it'd be cool, you know?
- No, I don't know.
Because it's not cool to walk around with a gun.
You hear what I said?
- Yeah, I heard you.
- You remember where you found the gun, exact location?
- This is Costa,
approximately 100 yards from the dumpster
where the young man found the gun.
- How close to the crime scene? - Three blocks.
And the timestamp on the video is helpful as well,
five minutes after the 911 call.
- And we're sure that's the murder weapon?
- Ballistics report just came in.
- Okay, good.
So we can tie Costa to the murder weapon.
- Sort of.
It's not ideal, but it is helpful.
- But still no motive.
- No, but the evidence is strong.
It should be enough to compensate for that.
- Okay, let's move forward.
Charge him with murder two.
- We can tie the defendant, Jack Costa,
to both the murder weapon and the crime scene.
We can also tie him to the victim, Nick Walsh,
and prove he had access to him on the day of the murder.
No, we don't have an eyewitness who saw him
shoot Nick Walsh or video showing him
fleeing the crime, gun in hand, but the evidence we do have
paints a compelling picture of what happened that day,
and it will prove beyond a reasonable doubt
that the defendant murdered Nick Walsh.
- Let me translate what Mr. Price just said.
We have a lousy case,
and we aren't really sure that Jack Costa committed the crime.
Nick Walsh was an animated and fiery coach
with lots of notoriety and lots of enemies.
He was a hometown hero who helped lead Hudson
to unprecedented success,
but he was on the verge of leaving,
chasing bigger, better, shinier dreams at a new school.
He was in the middle of negotiating a contract
that would be worth over $100 million.
The fans were upset.
They thought he was disloyal.
They accused him of using Hudson as a stepping stone.
Like it or not, there were thousands
of irrational and disgruntled fans
who thought Nick Walsh was a traitor,
and any one of them could have pulled that trigger,
including the teenage boy
who just so happens to find the murder weapon
and who just so happens to be a die-hard
Hudson U Basketball fan.
Bottom line, there's no motive here.
Jack Costa is a hardworking businessman
who never met Nick Walsh, so he had absolutely
no reason to kill him.
- Did your husband own a watch?
- Yes. - Can you describe it?
- It was a Rolex, blue face, white markers,
and a platinum-and-gold band.
- Does this watch look like the one your husband owned?
- Yes, definitely.
That's it.
- Let the record reflect the watch Mrs. Walsh
just identified was the watch recovered
from the defendant's office.
- So noted. - Nothing further.
- Your husband's watch wasn't registered, correct?
So there's no way of proving that that's the same watch.
- I'm not sure.
One of Nick's former players gave it to him the day
after he signed a new contract.
- That may be true, but you don't know
that that's the same watch.
- No, that's the watch.
Nick wore it every day.
He said it reminded him what his job really was,
to help kids achieve their dreams.
- The crime lab tested the watch
that the police found in my client's bar
for your husband's DNA.
The test came back negative.
- I didn't know.
- One more thing you probably didn't know,
the watch you just looked at, the Submariner,
it's a very popular watch.
There's literally thousands of them in existence,
the same brand, model, face, color.
The manufacturer released 1,200 of them just this year.
So there's no way of determining
that the watch you just looked at
actually belonged to your husband.
[tense music]
- I--I suppose you're right.
- I know, Sam, we're looking, but I'm telling you,
there's nothing else to move on.
- I get it.
Problem is, the defense is picking us apart,
so we need something else, something new,
preferably something that explains
why Costa actually killed Walsh.
- Look, we have zero evidence that points to motive.
And trust me, Costa's friends, they're not cooperating.
These guys eat, drink, and sleep this omertà nonsense.
- Someone in that crowd has to have a shred of humanity
and realize that when a person kills an innocent man,
he has to pay.
- I'm not so sure about that.
- Sorry, Vin.
All the beer in my fridge actually has alcohol in it.
- Maybe it shouldn't.
- Come on, don't start with all that "bad genes" crap again.
- Listen, Matt, you need to tell me what you know,
all right? What you really know.
And you need to tell me right now.
- Mm-hmm, yeah. I already did.
- Did he confess?
Did he say that he shot Walsh?
- I don't wanna get involved, all right?
It's not my job. - God, what--[stammers]
What is wrong with you, huh?
Walsh had a wife. He had two little girls.
And you don't care that your friend
put two bullets in his chest?
- Of course, I care.
- Matt, if you know something, this is the only way
to get rid of the gun charge. - Oh, please.
There's gotta be 100 ways to make the gun charge go away.
- There's not. There's one.
And this is it.
- I can't do it. I'm not that kind of guy.
- You're not that kind of guy?
The kind of guy that thinks that murderers
should actually go to prison?
- You're my brother,
but we're different.
I look out for my friends, no matter what.
- Are you listening to yourself right now, huh?
You actually believe this crap?
Let me tell you something.
This is not some Scorsese movie
where you and your friends kick it around the neighborhood
spouting off all this tough guy talk with no consequences.
This is real.
And you need to look out for yourself right now.
You understand me?
Not some punk named Costa who doesn't care about you.
This is the moment, Matt.
This is your moment,
and this is your last chance.
♪
- Costa said that Walsh was a good guy, you know,
and that he cared about his players,
and so he thought he had him over a barrel.
- Meaning what?
- Thought he could jam him up.
You know, ask for more money than the kid owed.
- Uh-huh. Can you be more specific?
- Kid owed, like, 75 grand, I think.
Costa was gonna ask for-- I don't know--150.
- [chuckles]
What else did he tell you?
- That when he asked Walsh, he got upset, you know?
Real upset.
[pensive music]
Things got out of hand.
- Did Costa confess to shooting him?
- Like I said, Walsh got angry, threatened to kick his ass.
Costa did what he had to do.
- Those your words or his?
- His.
- Yeah.
When we're in court, answer the questions
like you did just now.
You're doing the right thing, Matt.
♪
Did you and the defendant ever discuss the circumstances
of Nick Walsh's murder?
- Yeah.
- Did he tell you why he was meeting
Mr. Walsh that afternoon?
- Yeah, he said, uh--
said Walsh was gonna pay off the debt
of one of his former players.
- He say anything else?
- No, not really.
- Did he mention any other reason for meeting
Mr. Walsh that day?
Was he planning to discuss or demand
anything else from Mr. Walsh?
[tense music]
Mr. Riley, did the defendant tell you
what he planned to ask Mr. Walsh
when they met up in person?
- No.
- Never--never told you what they planned to discuss?
- No.
- Did the defendant ever tell you who shot Mr. Walsh?
- No.
- I'd like to request a brief recess.
- What's going on?
You said you were willing to testify.
- I guess I changed my mind.
- Are you serious?
- Guess so.
♪
- What the hell is the matter with you?
This is a murder trial, Matt.
You understand that? You're under oath.
- Yeah, I know.
I thought I could do it, Vin, but, uh...
[chuckles] I can't do it.
- You know that this is your last--
- Your Honor, the witness's answers
are inconsistent with his previous statements.
As such, I'd like to treat him as a hostile witness.
- Yes. I'll allow it.
- Mr. Riley, you presented a sworn affidavit
to me stating that the defendant
planned to exploit Mr. Walsh's compassion
for his former player.
- Objection. Hearsay.
- Your Honor, it was a sworn statement.
I'm offering it for impeachment purposes only.
- Okay, but that's as far as it goes.
Overruled.
- The defendant's plan was to ask Mr. Walsh
for double the amount Jordan Crawford
actually owed, correct?
- I don't know anything about that.
- And because of this, the two men fought.
- Objection.
This is being offered as the truth, not impeachment.
- Sustained.
Mr. Price, for impeachment purposes only.
I won't ask again.
- Your refusal to cooperate here today,
to not answer my questions in a truthful manner
is based on your desire to help the defendant?
- I'm just telling you what I know.
- You think it's a cowardly act to testify against a friend,
regardless of his guilt or innocence.
Isn't that true?
That snitching is a crime unto itself,
that ratting someone out is an unforgivable betrayal.
- I don't know what your point is.
- My point is that you agreed to tell the truth,
but you didn't do it.
You couldn't do it, because in your mind,
it's better to let a killer go free
than testify against a friend.
Am I right? Is that how you think?
Better to be a stand-up guy and keep your mouth shut.
- Yeah. You're damn right it is.
- Even if the consequence of that silence
is to let a killer walk free?
That doesn't bother you?
- Not in the least.
♪
- Nothing further.
- Ms. Gallo?
- No questions.
♪
- Please rise.
In the matter of People versus Costa,
has the jury reached a verdict?
- Yes, we have, Your Honor.
- How do you find?
- We find the defendant guilty.
- Members of the jury, I'd like to thank you for your service.
Court is adjourned.
[gavel bangs]
♪
- Guess it all worked out, huh?
- Yeah.
Just happy for the Walsh family, man.
They really needed the W.
- Yeah, so did you.
You know, Vince, you're a great cop.
People really respect you.
But if Costa had been acquitted...
♪
[knocking]
- Matty, it's Vince.
[pop music playing]
♪
- Yeah, I'll be right back.
[chuckles] What are you doing?
You know, I wish you'd called.
I, uh, I got a lady friend over, you know?
- You and your ladies.
- Yeah, well, at least I'm good at something, right?
- Listen, we gotta take a ride.
- All right. Where?
- The precinct.
- What are you talking about?
- The gun case.
They're gonna charge you.
- Get out of here. What are you talking--
you said you were gonna make a call,
make it go away.
- Yeah, well, I guess I changed my mind.
[tense music]
- Look, Vin, I'm sorry, all right?
But you gotta help me out.
You gotta give me another chance here.
I'll come through. - I can't do it anymore, Matt.
- I promise. - I can't do it.
Come on, let's go.
Come on.
♪
[dramatic music]
♪
[wolf howls]