1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:04,162
WWW.MY-SUBS.CO
1
00:00:00,233 --> 00:00:02,018
In the criminal justice system,
2
00:00:02,061 --> 00:00:03,323
the people are represented
3
00:00:03,367 --> 00:00:05,717
by two separate, yet
equally important groups:
4
00:00:05,760 --> 00:00:07,675
the police, who investigate crime,
5
00:00:07,719 --> 00:00:10,635
and the district attorneys,
who prosecute the offenders.
6
00:00:10,678 --> 00:00:13,290
These are their stories.
7
00:00:13,333 --> 00:00:16,249
Mr. Chapman thinks you
have real potential.
8
00:00:16,293 --> 00:00:18,599
But it takes practice,
honey... dedication.
9
00:00:18,643 --> 00:00:20,471
- I know.
- Do you?
10
00:00:20,514 --> 00:00:22,995
Because I don't hear
you playing every day.
11
00:00:23,039 --> 00:00:25,041
But I don't want to play every day.
12
00:00:25,084 --> 00:00:26,085
Wait.
13
00:00:29,610 --> 00:00:30,610
Mom, what is it?
14
00:00:32,918 --> 00:00:34,441
Go back to the car.
15
00:00:34,485 --> 00:00:36,182
Now.
16
00:00:45,844 --> 00:00:47,280
Judging by temp and lividity,
17
00:00:47,324 --> 00:00:49,021
I'd put time of death
somewhere in the neighborhood
18
00:00:49,065 --> 00:00:51,023
of 6:00 to 8:00 p.m.
19
00:00:51,067 --> 00:00:52,459
Cause of death?
20
00:00:52,503 --> 00:00:55,419
Pretty sure it wasn't a heart attack.
21
00:00:55,462 --> 00:00:56,681
Let's see.
22
00:00:58,770 --> 00:01:01,642
Hmm. Any defensive wounds?
23
00:01:01,686 --> 00:01:04,645
No indications of bruising
or abrasions on his hands.
24
00:01:04,689 --> 00:01:08,171
Yeah, probably didn't see it coming.
25
00:01:08,214 --> 00:01:11,000
Using a fire extinguisher as a weapon...
26
00:01:11,043 --> 00:01:13,045
it feels kind of personal.
27
00:01:13,089 --> 00:01:16,309
- Sure looks that way.
- Yeah, thanks.
28
00:01:16,353 --> 00:01:18,181
Witness didn't see
anyone coming in or out;
29
00:01:18,224 --> 00:01:20,357
neither did the attendant at the gate.
30
00:01:20,400 --> 00:01:22,446
Cameras in this part of
the garage are a bust...
31
00:01:22,489 --> 00:01:23,925
water damage on the hard drive,
32
00:01:23,969 --> 00:01:26,885
so I got a video canvas
going around the perimeter.
33
00:01:26,928 --> 00:01:30,062
Plenty of cash, credit cards.
34
00:01:30,106 --> 00:01:32,021
Doesn't seem like a robbery to me.
35
00:01:33,935 --> 00:01:36,286
The Honorable David Keating.
36
00:01:37,983 --> 00:01:40,638
Looks like our DOA was a judge.
37
00:01:43,119 --> 00:01:45,208
Not the verdict he was looking for.
38
00:01:57,084 --> 00:02:02,084
- Synced and corrected by chamallow - - www.MY-SUBS.com -
39
00:02:34,344 --> 00:02:36,041
I was at the neighbor's.
40
00:02:36,085 --> 00:02:39,479
Uh, we have a book club.
41
00:02:39,523 --> 00:02:42,091
Do you have any idea where
your husband was coming from?
42
00:02:42,134 --> 00:02:47,096
Courthouse? He gets home every
night at the same time... 7:00.
43
00:02:47,139 --> 00:02:48,706
Almost to the minute.
44
00:02:48,749 --> 00:02:50,142
Mrs. Keating, do you know of anyone
45
00:02:50,186 --> 00:02:51,883
who might want to hurt your husband?
46
00:02:51,926 --> 00:02:54,886
Was he having any problems,
professional, personal?
47
00:02:56,975 --> 00:03:01,197
The past few months,
David was distracted.
48
00:03:01,240 --> 00:03:04,809
He was a good man, but he had his moods.
49
00:03:04,852 --> 00:03:06,898
I asked him what was
going on several times,
50
00:03:06,941 --> 00:03:09,727
but that just seemed
to aggravate him more.
51
00:03:09,770 --> 00:03:12,469
When he was walking out
the door this morning,
52
00:03:12,512 --> 00:03:13,687
I...
53
00:03:15,298 --> 00:03:17,952
Told him that, uh, I was tired of
54
00:03:17,996 --> 00:03:19,302
walking on eggshells
55
00:03:19,345 --> 00:03:22,522
and that he needed to
adjust his attitude.
56
00:03:24,655 --> 00:03:26,483
That's the last thing I said to him.
57
00:03:32,358 --> 00:03:34,317
Do you know what was troubling him?
58
00:03:36,623 --> 00:03:37,668
Uh...
59
00:03:39,496 --> 00:03:41,454
It was probably his work.
60
00:03:41,498 --> 00:03:43,195
He, um... it was always in the middle
61
00:03:43,239 --> 00:03:44,631
of someone else's crisis.
62
00:03:44,675 --> 00:03:48,592
You know, divorce,
custody, visitation rights.
63
00:03:48,635 --> 00:03:49,897
It's a lot.
64
00:03:51,856 --> 00:03:52,944
It's family court.
65
00:03:52,987 --> 00:03:54,293
Everybody who walks in the door
66
00:03:54,337 --> 00:03:55,860
is having the worst day of their life.
67
00:03:55,903 --> 00:03:57,383
Yeah, we're gonna need a complete list
68
00:03:57,427 --> 00:03:59,777
- of his problem cases.
- Way ahead of you.
69
00:03:59,820 --> 00:04:02,649
First ten pages are the
judge's pending cases.
70
00:04:02,693 --> 00:04:05,522
The rest are people who threatened him.
71
00:04:05,565 --> 00:04:08,002
Does any case or person stand out?
72
00:04:08,046 --> 00:04:09,352
Not really.
73
00:04:09,395 --> 00:04:13,225
But there's one thing
that's not on the list.
74
00:04:13,269 --> 00:04:14,922
Judge mentioned someone confronted him
75
00:04:14,966 --> 00:04:17,186
on the courthouse steps the other day.
76
00:04:17,229 --> 00:04:18,883
He seemed pretty rattled.
77
00:04:18,926 --> 00:04:21,233
- When was this?
- Day before yesterday.
78
00:04:21,277 --> 00:04:22,887
He was on his way to the dentist.
79
00:04:24,715 --> 00:04:27,979
The clerk said the judge
left the building around 4:15.
80
00:04:30,373 --> 00:04:32,244
Yeah, there. That's him.
81
00:04:38,381 --> 00:04:40,121
It was more than a confrontation.
82
00:04:40,165 --> 00:04:41,949
Okay, I can't see his face.
83
00:04:41,993 --> 00:04:44,517
Do you have a camera
with a better angle?
84
00:04:44,561 --> 00:04:46,127
No, this is the best we have.
85
00:04:46,171 --> 00:04:47,346
Okay.
86
00:04:47,390 --> 00:04:50,219
Well, maybe she can help us.
87
00:04:50,262 --> 00:04:51,611
Do you recognize her?
88
00:04:51,655 --> 00:04:53,004
No.
89
00:04:53,047 --> 00:04:55,006
But if she was doing
business at the courthouse,
90
00:04:55,049 --> 00:04:57,400
then she would have signed
in or swiped a security pass.
91
00:05:03,580 --> 00:05:08,062
She has quite the client roster.
92
00:05:08,106 --> 00:05:10,717
Eli Manning, I used to
curse this guy every week.
93
00:05:10,761 --> 00:05:12,980
Now I'd give my left
thumb to get him back.
94
00:05:13,024 --> 00:05:15,853
Oh, this woman right here?
95
00:05:15,896 --> 00:05:18,638
She's gotta be one of the
best tennis players ever.
96
00:05:18,682 --> 00:05:21,293
I didn't figure you
for the Wimbledon set.
97
00:05:21,337 --> 00:05:22,468
Why is that?
98
00:05:22,512 --> 00:05:24,644
'Cause you're...
99
00:05:24,688 --> 00:05:26,167
a cop.
100
00:05:26,211 --> 00:05:28,996
Isn't she the one that had
that breakdown a while back
101
00:05:29,040 --> 00:05:30,433
and had to pull out
of that big tournament?
102
00:05:30,476 --> 00:05:32,478
Yeah, French Open.
103
00:05:32,522 --> 00:05:35,220
- Morning.
- Morning.
104
00:05:35,264 --> 00:05:36,830
What can I do for you fellas?
105
00:05:36,874 --> 00:05:40,747
We'd like to ask you a few
questions about David Keating.
106
00:05:40,791 --> 00:05:44,098
I'm still in shock.
107
00:05:44,142 --> 00:05:46,666
We went to law school together.
108
00:05:46,710 --> 00:05:49,060
I ran into him just the
other day at the courthouse.
109
00:05:49,103 --> 00:05:50,409
That's why we're here.
110
00:05:50,453 --> 00:05:52,150
A man confronted him, shoved him.
111
00:05:52,193 --> 00:05:55,588
He was scary... accused
David of ruining his life.
112
00:05:55,632 --> 00:05:59,288
Got physical. I started
calling the police,
113
00:05:59,331 --> 00:06:00,767
then he left.
114
00:06:00,811 --> 00:06:03,553
Do you happen to know this guy's name?
115
00:06:03,596 --> 00:06:05,598
Yeah, I saw it on the news.
116
00:06:05,642 --> 00:06:07,644
Couldn't happen to a nicer guy.
117
00:06:07,687 --> 00:06:09,341
It's not polite to
speak ill of the dead.
118
00:06:09,385 --> 00:06:10,516
Don't worry, I spoke ill of him
119
00:06:10,560 --> 00:06:11,778
when he was alive too.
120
00:06:11,822 --> 00:06:13,432
I take it you didn't like his ruling
121
00:06:13,476 --> 00:06:15,260
on your child custody case?
122
00:06:15,304 --> 00:06:16,566
He's a self-righteous prick.
123
00:06:16,609 --> 00:06:18,102
- Mm.
- Who the hell is he to say
124
00:06:18,145 --> 00:06:19,960
I can only see my son
every other weekend?
125
00:06:20,004 --> 00:06:21,484
Decision could've had something to do
126
00:06:21,527 --> 00:06:23,224
with your two arrests
for domestic violence.
127
00:06:23,268 --> 00:06:24,748
That was between me and my ex.
128
00:06:24,791 --> 00:06:26,445
It had nothing to do with my kid.
129
00:06:26,489 --> 00:06:29,361
Not sure about that.
Violence is violence.
130
00:06:29,405 --> 00:06:32,277
Where were you last night around 7:00?
131
00:06:32,321 --> 00:06:33,452
Home.
132
00:06:33,496 --> 00:06:34,975
- All night?
- Mm.
133
00:06:35,019 --> 00:06:37,413
Nuked some leftovers.
Had a couple of beers.
134
00:06:37,456 --> 00:06:40,198
- Watched a Rangers game.
- Can anyone verify that?
135
00:06:40,241 --> 00:06:42,635
No. I was alone.
136
00:06:42,679 --> 00:06:45,899
Thanks to Judge Keating.
137
00:06:45,943 --> 00:06:48,424
Greg Wallace is lying his ass off.
138
00:06:48,467 --> 00:06:50,948
Video from his apartment
building has him leaving at 5:23.
139
00:06:50,991 --> 00:06:52,558
He doesn't get back until 10:08.
140
00:06:52,602 --> 00:06:53,820
That's plenty of time for him to get
141
00:06:53,864 --> 00:06:54,952
to Keating's garage and back.
142
00:06:54,995 --> 00:06:56,562
And he's got one hell of a motive.
143
00:06:56,606 --> 00:06:58,999
Lou! I got something.
144
00:06:59,043 --> 00:07:01,959
Cell sites have Wallace's
phone pinging a tower
145
00:07:02,002 --> 00:07:04,353
a few blocks from
Judge Keating's garage.
146
00:07:04,396 --> 00:07:05,571
Where does Wallace live?
147
00:07:05,615 --> 00:07:08,400
168... in the Bronx.
148
00:07:08,444 --> 00:07:09,662
A long way from home.
149
00:07:09,706 --> 00:07:11,360
Any reason for him to be hanging around
150
00:07:11,403 --> 00:07:12,404
the Upper East Side?
151
00:07:12,448 --> 00:07:13,971
No, nothing obvious anyway.
152
00:07:14,014 --> 00:07:15,668
All right. We gotta move on this.
153
00:07:15,712 --> 00:07:17,409
1PP is breathing down my neck,
154
00:07:17,453 --> 00:07:18,715
and the mayor's office is calling me
155
00:07:18,758 --> 00:07:20,151
every two hours, so...
156
00:07:20,194 --> 00:07:22,458
- Yep.
- Understood?
157
00:07:24,416 --> 00:07:26,810
You lied, Greg.
158
00:07:26,853 --> 00:07:28,507
You weren't home watching hockey
159
00:07:28,551 --> 00:07:29,856
when Judge Keating was murdered.
160
00:07:29,900 --> 00:07:31,989
Cell phone has you on
the Upper East Side.
161
00:07:32,032 --> 00:07:33,294
You live in the Bronx.
162
00:07:33,338 --> 00:07:36,689
What, I'm not allowed
to visit Manhattan?
163
00:07:36,733 --> 00:07:38,299
Is there a new rule on the
books I need to know about?
164
00:07:38,343 --> 00:07:42,652
- Yeah! It's called lying to the police.
- It's not new.
165
00:07:42,695 --> 00:07:44,828
It's been around forever.
166
00:07:44,871 --> 00:07:46,351
It's not what you think.
167
00:07:46,395 --> 00:07:49,223
No, what I think is you
found out where Keating lived,
168
00:07:49,267 --> 00:07:51,617
learned his schedule,
and went there to finish
169
00:07:51,661 --> 00:07:53,227
what you started on
the courthouse steps.
170
00:07:53,271 --> 00:07:54,620
No, no, no...
171
00:07:57,275 --> 00:07:59,930
I was with my son.
172
00:07:59,973 --> 00:08:02,280
Okay, if my ex finds out I
violated the visitation order,
173
00:08:02,323 --> 00:08:04,587
she'll... she'll make it so
I can never see him again.
174
00:08:04,630 --> 00:08:07,328
Your ex lives in the Bronx.
175
00:08:07,372 --> 00:08:11,027
Yeah, but she stays with her
boyfriend on 75th Street with my son.
176
00:08:13,334 --> 00:08:14,901
So what did you and your son do?
177
00:08:14,945 --> 00:08:18,905
Uh, we went to the movies,
and then we got ice cream.
178
00:08:18,949 --> 00:08:21,734
- You got receipts?
- It's on my debit card.
179
00:08:21,778 --> 00:08:23,475
You... you can check the statement.
180
00:08:23,519 --> 00:08:25,259
Yeah, we will.
181
00:08:25,303 --> 00:08:27,479
Listen, listen, I...
182
00:08:27,523 --> 00:08:29,133
I admit
183
00:08:29,176 --> 00:08:32,136
that I wanted to beat that judge's ass.
184
00:08:32,179 --> 00:08:33,920
I did.
185
00:08:33,964 --> 00:08:35,531
After that lady left,
I even followed him
186
00:08:35,574 --> 00:08:37,358
from the courthouse.
187
00:08:37,402 --> 00:08:38,708
- You followed him?
- Yeah.
188
00:08:38,751 --> 00:08:41,493
- To where?
- Some hotel.
189
00:08:41,537 --> 00:08:42,537
Yeah, there were lots of people there.
190
00:08:42,538 --> 00:08:44,104
Lots of security cameras.
191
00:08:44,148 --> 00:08:45,628
So I took off.
192
00:08:51,547 --> 00:08:53,723
Judge's wife said he was preoccupied.
193
00:08:53,766 --> 00:08:57,378
Ah, nothing like a sidepiece
to preoccupy someone...
194
00:08:57,422 --> 00:08:59,511
also doubles the chance of
you getting bludgeoned to death
195
00:08:59,555 --> 00:09:02,471
in a parking garage.
196
00:09:02,514 --> 00:09:03,994
Ma'am.
197
00:09:04,037 --> 00:09:06,126
Uh, we're wondering if
somebody named David Keating
198
00:09:06,170 --> 00:09:08,955
booked a room here two days ago.
199
00:09:08,999 --> 00:09:10,261
Keating...
200
00:09:10,304 --> 00:09:13,482
I'm not showing a
reservation under that name.
201
00:09:13,525 --> 00:09:14,874
Maybe he just walked through the lobby
202
00:09:14,918 --> 00:09:16,659
to get to someone else's room.
203
00:09:16,702 --> 00:09:19,270
Going to a woman's room, perhaps.
204
00:09:19,313 --> 00:09:20,532
This is what he looked like.
205
00:09:20,576 --> 00:09:21,751
Oh, yeah.
206
00:09:21,794 --> 00:09:23,883
He's a judge, right?
207
00:09:23,927 --> 00:09:26,190
How would you know that? Was he
carrying a gavel or something?
208
00:09:26,191 --> 00:09:28,148
Practically.
209
00:09:28,192 --> 00:09:30,411
He was the keynote speaker
at this event in the ballroom.
210
00:09:30,455 --> 00:09:32,805
Hmm. What event was that?
211
00:09:32,849 --> 00:09:34,981
Some sort of legal conference.
212
00:09:35,025 --> 00:09:37,157
I did the guy a favor...
offered to help set up
213
00:09:37,201 --> 00:09:39,638
his PowerPoint deck.
214
00:09:39,682 --> 00:09:41,335
To be honest...
215
00:09:41,379 --> 00:09:43,294
he was kind of a dick.
216
00:09:43,337 --> 00:09:45,514
Greater Manhattan University of Law.
217
00:09:45,557 --> 00:09:46,993
Never heard of it.
218
00:09:47,037 --> 00:09:49,996
It's one of those
unaccredited for-profit places.
219
00:09:50,040 --> 00:09:51,694
Yeah, but why is a judge shilling
220
00:09:51,737 --> 00:09:53,696
for a scam operation like that?
221
00:09:53,739 --> 00:09:55,480
Because the school paid him 10 grand.
222
00:09:55,524 --> 00:09:56,525
Really?
223
00:09:56,568 --> 00:09:57,656
He's that hard up?
224
00:09:57,700 --> 00:09:59,179
The guy probably makes 250 a year.
225
00:09:59,223 --> 00:10:00,267
Maybe.
226
00:10:00,311 --> 00:10:02,052
But according to Financial Crimes,
227
00:10:02,095 --> 00:10:05,011
He was flat broke,
practically no savings,
228
00:10:05,055 --> 00:10:07,579
and that was after taking
a second mortgage last year.
229
00:10:07,623 --> 00:10:09,799
Three credit cards all maxed out.
230
00:10:09,842 --> 00:10:11,583
The guy was drowning in debt.
231
00:10:11,627 --> 00:10:13,542
His tab was close to $1 million.
232
00:10:13,585 --> 00:10:15,326
Any idea where that money went?
233
00:10:15,369 --> 00:10:18,024
- Was he living a big life?
- Doesn't look that way.
234
00:10:18,068 --> 00:10:19,591
His apartment was nice,
but nothing special.
235
00:10:19,635 --> 00:10:20,853
Mm-hmm.
236
00:10:20,897 --> 00:10:22,681
So much for living a big life.
237
00:10:22,725 --> 00:10:24,988
But that money just doesn't disappear.
238
00:10:25,031 --> 00:10:27,338
So let's find out where it went.
239
00:10:27,381 --> 00:10:29,470
Okay.
240
00:10:29,514 --> 00:10:31,864
So this judge had a
serious gambling problem...
241
00:10:31,908 --> 00:10:33,562
had an account on First Down.
242
00:10:33,605 --> 00:10:34,867
I'm familiar.
243
00:10:34,911 --> 00:10:36,521
Well, I hope your touch
was better than his.
244
00:10:36,565 --> 00:10:39,480
This guy was down about 200K,
shut him off three months ago.
245
00:10:39,524 --> 00:10:43,049
Yeah, better to put your
money in a paper shredder.
246
00:10:43,093 --> 00:10:45,530
Looks like he was doing a lot
of betting with a bookie too.
247
00:10:45,574 --> 00:10:47,097
You got a name?
248
00:10:47,140 --> 00:10:50,056
No... lots of text messages
going back and forth, though.
249
00:10:50,100 --> 00:10:52,145
A few of them are from a Dr. Weisman.
250
00:10:52,189 --> 00:10:54,321
Owed him a lot of
money... about 100 grand.
251
00:10:54,365 --> 00:10:57,020
Two days ago, he sends
a text to the judge.
252
00:10:57,063 --> 00:11:01,894
"Need to get paid by tomorrow,
or this ain't gonna end well."
253
00:11:07,552 --> 00:11:11,643
You were at the garage where
Judge Keating was killed.
254
00:11:11,687 --> 00:11:14,428
That's you. No question about it.
255
00:11:16,039 --> 00:11:17,997
You also threatened the guy.
256
00:11:18,041 --> 00:11:20,652
Mm-hmm.
257
00:11:20,696 --> 00:11:25,701
"Need to get paid by tomorrow,
or this ain't gonna end well."
258
00:11:25,744 --> 00:11:27,354
That was a text.
259
00:11:27,398 --> 00:11:29,443
Don't you see it didn't end well?
260
00:11:29,487 --> 00:11:31,054
In fact, it ended really badly.
261
00:11:31,097 --> 00:11:34,666
The guy got his head smashed
in with a fire extinguisher.
262
00:11:34,710 --> 00:11:36,494
So it wasn't just a text.
263
00:11:36,537 --> 00:11:38,191
No.
264
00:11:38,235 --> 00:11:40,716
Never got physical with the judge.
265
00:11:40,759 --> 00:11:41,759
Ever.
266
00:11:43,414 --> 00:11:46,547
What is this, uh, Dr. Weisman crap?
267
00:11:46,591 --> 00:11:49,159
- Excuse me?
- You sent a text to the judge.
268
00:11:49,202 --> 00:11:51,117
You signed it "Dr. Weisman."
269
00:11:51,161 --> 00:11:53,903
I went to dental school for
two months and dropped out.
270
00:11:53,946 --> 00:11:55,121
The name stuck.
271
00:11:55,165 --> 00:11:58,037
Look, you guys are way off base here.
272
00:11:58,081 --> 00:11:59,865
I didn't have a beef with Keating.
273
00:11:59,909 --> 00:12:01,258
He paid me in full.
274
00:12:01,301 --> 00:12:02,301
We've seen his bank accounts.
275
00:12:02,302 --> 00:12:03,564
He didn't have a pot to piss in.
276
00:12:03,608 --> 00:12:05,349
How does he suddenly
come up with 100 grand?
277
00:12:05,392 --> 00:12:07,090
I don't know what to tell you.
278
00:12:07,133 --> 00:12:08,831
He said he had the money
and told me to come down
279
00:12:08,874 --> 00:12:10,702
and meet him at the garage.
280
00:12:10,746 --> 00:12:13,879
Son of a bitch delivered
too. That's what's in the bag.
281
00:12:13,923 --> 00:12:15,228
Cash.
282
00:12:25,064 --> 00:12:26,413
Yeah?
283
00:12:26,457 --> 00:12:28,328
Forensics came back on
the fire extinguisher.
284
00:12:28,372 --> 00:12:31,244
No discernable prints,
but they recovered a hair.
285
00:12:31,288 --> 00:12:32,506
Didn't belong to the victim,
286
00:12:32,550 --> 00:12:35,727
and it doesn't match
anyone in the system.
287
00:12:35,771 --> 00:12:38,251
Oh. Well, that eliminates Weisman.
288
00:12:38,295 --> 00:12:39,600
I sent it to a private lab
289
00:12:39,644 --> 00:12:43,387
for genealogy and disease analysis.
290
00:12:43,430 --> 00:12:46,303
Pulling out all the stops, huh?
291
00:12:46,346 --> 00:12:48,784
He was a judge, Kevin.
292
00:12:48,827 --> 00:12:50,350
Come on.
293
00:12:50,394 --> 00:12:53,614
You know I wish we had the
resources to go the extra mile
294
00:12:53,658 --> 00:12:55,965
for every unsolved, but we don't.
295
00:12:56,008 --> 00:12:57,836
Funny how they always
manage to find the cash
296
00:12:57,880 --> 00:13:00,970
when the victim's a white
dude from the Upper East Side.
297
00:13:01,013 --> 00:13:03,581
But when it's a poor black
kid from East Flatbush,
298
00:13:03,624 --> 00:13:06,192
"Ooh, I'm sorry. We don't
have it in the budget."
299
00:13:06,236 --> 00:13:07,933
I hear you.
300
00:13:07,977 --> 00:13:09,805
Do you?
301
00:13:09,848 --> 00:13:11,763
Look, we got a profile:
302
00:13:11,807 --> 00:13:14,766
brown eyes, black hair,
sub-Saharan ancestry,
303
00:13:14,810 --> 00:13:16,159
likely a diabetic...
304
00:13:17,508 --> 00:13:18,988
And it belongs to a woman.
305
00:13:22,818 --> 00:13:23,993
Okay.
306
00:13:30,695 --> 00:13:33,393
Got a couple more questions for you.
307
00:13:33,437 --> 00:13:36,309
Did you see anyone else in that garage?
308
00:13:36,353 --> 00:13:37,484
A woman, maybe?
309
00:13:39,443 --> 00:13:41,662
Yeah, when I was leaving.
310
00:13:41,706 --> 00:13:44,013
She was getting out of
a car on 87th street.
311
00:13:44,056 --> 00:13:45,231
She was running towards me.
312
00:13:45,275 --> 00:13:46,798
So I held a door open for her.
313
00:13:46,842 --> 00:13:48,278
Did you notice anything
unusual about this woman?
314
00:13:48,321 --> 00:13:49,801
No.
315
00:13:49,845 --> 00:13:52,151
Couldn't see her face,
she had sunglasses.
316
00:13:52,195 --> 00:13:53,936
Was wearing a big, black jacket.
317
00:13:53,979 --> 00:13:55,154
Hmm.
318
00:13:55,198 --> 00:13:56,199
Was she alone?
319
00:13:56,242 --> 00:13:57,461
Yeah.
320
00:13:57,504 --> 00:13:59,855
She hopped out of a black SUV.
321
00:13:59,898 --> 00:14:01,813
Driver's side?
322
00:14:01,857 --> 00:14:03,946
Passenger.
323
00:14:03,989 --> 00:14:05,164
It was a Range Rover, I think.
324
00:14:09,168 --> 00:14:10,169
Jesse Malloy?
325
00:14:10,213 --> 00:14:11,692
Yeah, that's me.
326
00:14:11,736 --> 00:14:15,784
Do you own a 2019 Range
Rover, license plate 6PHE4Z?
327
00:14:15,827 --> 00:14:17,568
Yeah. You want me to move it?
328
00:14:17,611 --> 00:14:18,961
Uh, no, no. We're good.
329
00:14:19,004 --> 00:14:21,746
Uh, were you driving that
vehicle on Thursday night,
330
00:14:21,790 --> 00:14:23,400
around 7:00 p.m.?
331
00:14:23,443 --> 00:14:25,184
Thursday. Yeah, I think so.
332
00:14:25,228 --> 00:14:26,707
You stopped on 87th Street,
333
00:14:26,751 --> 00:14:30,015
and a woman got out of your car.
334
00:14:30,059 --> 00:14:31,974
Did her father send you guys?
335
00:14:32,017 --> 00:14:33,105
- Excuse me?
- Hmm?
336
00:14:33,149 --> 00:14:34,541
Lucy's father.
337
00:14:34,585 --> 00:14:37,936
He's very protective.
338
00:14:37,980 --> 00:14:39,677
Who's Lucy?
339
00:14:39,720 --> 00:14:41,853
My girlfriend, Lucy McDaniel.
340
00:14:41,897 --> 00:14:44,160
Uh...
341
00:14:44,203 --> 00:14:45,596
the tennis player?
342
00:14:46,684 --> 00:14:50,253
You dropped her off at the
parking garage two nights ago?
343
00:14:50,296 --> 00:14:51,950
Yes. Why?
344
00:14:51,994 --> 00:14:53,865
Who was she going to see?
345
00:14:53,909 --> 00:14:55,040
I don't know, she said she was gonna
346
00:14:55,084 --> 00:14:57,042
run some errands. Why, what is going on?
347
00:14:57,086 --> 00:15:00,654
Does the name Judge David
Keating mean anything to you?
348
00:15:01,786 --> 00:15:03,657
That a TV show or something?
349
00:15:06,008 --> 00:15:08,924
So Lucy McDaniel, one of
the best tennis players
350
00:15:08,967 --> 00:15:11,230
in the world, no history of violence,
351
00:15:11,274 --> 00:15:13,232
just rolls up and kills a judge?
352
00:15:13,276 --> 00:15:14,451
Doesn't make sense.
353
00:15:14,494 --> 00:15:17,410
She fits the DNA profile to a tee:
354
00:15:17,454 --> 00:15:19,935
Black woman, brown eyes, black hair,
355
00:15:19,978 --> 00:15:22,328
definitely has the strength
to swing a fire extinguisher
356
00:15:22,372 --> 00:15:24,548
and take a piece of a man's skull out.
357
00:15:24,591 --> 00:15:28,900
Plus, I read somewhere
that she's type 1 diabetic.
358
00:15:28,944 --> 00:15:30,336
What?
359
00:15:30,380 --> 00:15:32,251
Why is everyone so surprised
that I follow tennis?
360
00:15:32,295 --> 00:15:33,774
All right, if it is her,
361
00:15:33,818 --> 00:15:35,689
there has to be some connection.
362
00:15:35,733 --> 00:15:36,908
I'm telling you there's nothing.
363
00:15:36,952 --> 00:15:38,562
We checked the judge's case files,
364
00:15:38,605 --> 00:15:40,607
his appointment calendar,
his phone logs, his email...
365
00:15:40,651 --> 00:15:42,261
But her lawyer, Clara Newhall,
366
00:15:42,305 --> 00:15:43,567
is friends with Judge Keating.
367
00:15:43,610 --> 00:15:45,786
She was with him the
day that Greg Wallace
368
00:15:45,830 --> 00:15:48,398
confronted him at the
courthouse, and a day later,
369
00:15:48,441 --> 00:15:50,095
Keating turns up dead.
370
00:15:50,139 --> 00:15:51,836
Hell of a coincidence.
371
00:15:51,880 --> 00:15:54,926
- No such thing.
- Exactly.
372
00:15:54,970 --> 00:15:57,407
Let's pay Lucy a little surprise visit,
373
00:15:57,450 --> 00:16:00,323
and see if she'll agree to a DNA test.
374
00:16:00,366 --> 00:16:01,628
All right, let's go.
375
00:16:05,458 --> 00:16:06,938
Sorry, guys. She's in training...
376
00:16:06,982 --> 00:16:07,982
can't be interrupted.
377
00:16:07,983 --> 00:16:09,027
It's important.
378
00:16:09,071 --> 00:16:10,289
Not more important than training.
379
00:16:10,333 --> 00:16:12,509
Disagree.
380
00:16:12,552 --> 00:16:14,772
Hey, buddy. Take five, please.
381
00:16:14,815 --> 00:16:17,296
- Hey, what the hell are you doing?
- I'm Detective Cosgrove.
382
00:16:17,340 --> 00:16:20,082
We'd like to ask you a few questions.
383
00:16:20,125 --> 00:16:22,649
Thursday evening, Jesse
Malloy gave you a ride
384
00:16:22,693 --> 00:16:24,173
to the Upper East Side of Manhattan.
385
00:16:24,216 --> 00:16:25,957
Don't answer.
386
00:16:26,001 --> 00:16:27,045
What's this about?
387
00:16:27,089 --> 00:16:28,177
Are you familiar with a man
388
00:16:28,220 --> 00:16:29,439
by the name of David Keating?
389
00:16:29,482 --> 00:16:30,483
He was a judge.
390
00:16:30,527 --> 00:16:32,398
This conversation is over.
391
00:16:32,442 --> 00:16:35,488
We were wondering if you'd be
willing to submit a DNA test.
392
00:16:35,532 --> 00:16:37,926
The answer is no. Look, I don't know
393
00:16:37,969 --> 00:16:39,536
what the hell you
guys are talking about,
394
00:16:39,579 --> 00:16:41,233
but she sure as hell is
not talking to you guys
395
00:16:41,277 --> 00:16:42,843
without a lawyer present.
396
00:16:42,887 --> 00:16:44,541
Sir, with all due respect,
I'm talking to your daughter,
397
00:16:44,584 --> 00:16:45,934
not to you, so please shut up.
398
00:16:47,500 --> 00:16:49,502
Ma'am, would you be willing
399
00:16:49,546 --> 00:16:51,983
to voluntarily submit a DNA sample?
400
00:16:52,027 --> 00:16:53,811
It's in your best interest
so we can eliminate you
401
00:16:53,854 --> 00:16:55,291
as a suspect in a homicide.
402
00:16:55,334 --> 00:16:57,162
Tell him no.
403
00:16:57,206 --> 00:16:58,859
Tell him you're not answering
any more of his questions.
404
00:16:58,903 --> 00:17:00,861
Tell him you want an attorney.
405
00:17:00,905 --> 00:17:03,429
Now.
406
00:17:03,543 --> 00:17:05,066
I'm not giving you a DNA sample,
407
00:17:05,110 --> 00:17:07,242
and I'm not answering
any of your questions,
408
00:17:07,286 --> 00:17:08,461
and I want a lawyer.
409
00:17:08,504 --> 00:17:09,636
Okay, come on, baby.
410
00:17:21,474 --> 00:17:24,607
I'll call the DA's office for
a swab order to get her DNA.
411
00:17:24,651 --> 00:17:26,261
Don't bother.
412
00:17:26,305 --> 00:17:27,436
You stole her towel?
413
00:17:27,480 --> 00:17:29,047
Technically, it's abandoned property.
414
00:17:29,090 --> 00:17:31,092
Well, it wasn't exactly
in the trash can.
415
00:17:31,136 --> 00:17:33,355
It was in the laundry
hamper, close enough.
416
00:17:33,399 --> 00:17:34,487
Besides, it's not her property...
417
00:17:34,530 --> 00:17:36,793
belongs to the tennis club.
418
00:17:36,837 --> 00:17:38,795
And if the hair on the fire extinguisher
419
00:17:38,839 --> 00:17:41,102
syncs up with the sweat in this towel...
420
00:17:41,146 --> 00:17:43,061
It's game, set, match.
421
00:17:48,098 --> 00:17:49,587
We still don't have a connection
422
00:17:49,631 --> 00:17:52,080
between Lucy McDaniel and Judge Keating?
423
00:17:52,124 --> 00:17:53,777
Correct... detectives
reinterviewed his clerk,
424
00:17:53,821 --> 00:17:55,214
checked Lucy's phone, her emails.
425
00:17:55,257 --> 00:17:58,043
The only thing we have
is, Lucy's personal lawyer
426
00:17:58,086 --> 00:18:00,262
was with Judge Keating
the day before the murder.
427
00:18:00,306 --> 00:18:02,134
Find out what they were talking about.
428
00:18:02,177 --> 00:18:04,987
Tried. She made herself
part of the defense team,
429
00:18:04,988 --> 00:18:08,183
filed an appearance at the arraignment.
430
00:18:08,227 --> 00:18:09,227
Okay.
431
00:18:11,230 --> 00:18:13,884
So let's work with what we have.
432
00:18:13,928 --> 00:18:16,452
You've tried cases
without motive before.
433
00:18:16,496 --> 00:18:18,541
I have, but not first-degree murder,
434
00:18:18,585 --> 00:18:22,806
and not when the defendant
was a global icon.
435
00:18:22,850 --> 00:18:24,983
Just tell the jury what you have,
436
00:18:25,026 --> 00:18:26,027
not what you don't have.
437
00:18:26,371 --> 00:18:27,463
If you don't,
438
00:18:27,507 --> 00:18:30,466
the defense will. So
be upfront with them.
439
00:18:30,510 --> 00:18:32,991
Otherwise, they'll never
believe another word
440
00:18:33,034 --> 00:18:34,209
that comes out of your mouth.
441
00:18:38,648 --> 00:18:42,826
We don't know why the
defendant killed Judge Keating.
442
00:18:42,870 --> 00:18:47,831
But we can prove beyond
a reasonable doubt
443
00:18:47,875 --> 00:18:52,923
that she did, in fact, kill him.
444
00:18:52,967 --> 00:18:57,145
The evidence will show that
on February 3rd of this year,
445
00:18:57,189 --> 00:19:00,801
Judge David Keating parked
his car where he always did:
446
00:19:00,844 --> 00:19:02,498
a garage on 87th Street,
447
00:19:02,542 --> 00:19:05,153
just across from his
Upper East Side apartment.
448
00:19:05,197 --> 00:19:09,375
He was in that garage at 6:58 p.m.
449
00:19:09,418 --> 00:19:13,161
when the defendant's boyfriend
dropped her off outside,
450
00:19:13,205 --> 00:19:15,033
and we have that captured on video.
451
00:19:15,076 --> 00:19:16,469
You'll be able to see it.
452
00:19:16,512 --> 00:19:18,123
The defendant entered the garage
453
00:19:18,166 --> 00:19:19,515
through the back stairwell
454
00:19:19,559 --> 00:19:22,692
just as Judge Keating was
walking to the elevators.
455
00:19:22,736 --> 00:19:25,521
She grabbed...
456
00:19:25,565 --> 00:19:27,349
a fire extinguisher
457
00:19:27,393 --> 00:19:30,048
and smashed him in the head with it
458
00:19:30,091 --> 00:19:32,702
repeatedly
459
00:19:32,746 --> 00:19:35,531
and then fled,
460
00:19:35,575 --> 00:19:36,576
left him there to die.
461
00:19:38,752 --> 00:19:42,930
But she left something behind:
462
00:19:42,973 --> 00:19:44,366
a strand of her hair.
463
00:19:44,410 --> 00:19:46,629
It was on the surface
of the fire extinguisher,
464
00:19:46,673 --> 00:19:48,892
embedded in the judge's blood.
465
00:19:48,936 --> 00:19:51,069
The hair was tested for DNA.
466
00:19:51,112 --> 00:19:53,984
The results are irrefutable.
467
00:19:54,028 --> 00:19:56,596
The hair is hers.
468
00:19:58,511 --> 00:20:03,124
We don't know what set Lucy
McDaniel into a murderous rage.
469
00:20:03,168 --> 00:20:07,563
But we do know that it happened...
470
00:20:11,698 --> 00:20:15,223
That she killed Judge Keating.
471
00:20:31,239 --> 00:20:32,936
I held the door open for a lady
472
00:20:32,980 --> 00:20:34,590
who was coming into the stairwell.
473
00:20:34,634 --> 00:20:38,159
How much time elapsed between
the time you left the judge
474
00:20:38,203 --> 00:20:40,944
and the time you saw this woman?
475
00:20:40,988 --> 00:20:42,120
Less than a minute.
476
00:20:46,298 --> 00:20:47,560
You never identified my client
477
00:20:47,603 --> 00:20:50,040
as the woman you saw
in the garage, did you?
478
00:20:50,084 --> 00:20:52,478
Not by name.
479
00:20:52,521 --> 00:20:55,350
Lucy McDaniel is one of
the most recognizable faces
480
00:20:55,394 --> 00:20:58,179
in the world, and you
didn't know it was her?
481
00:20:58,223 --> 00:21:00,964
Her glasses were covering her face.
482
00:21:01,008 --> 00:21:03,880
So let me get this straight.
483
00:21:03,924 --> 00:21:06,013
You were with Judge
Keating at the crime scene?
484
00:21:06,056 --> 00:21:07,580
It wasn't a crime
scene when I was there.
485
00:21:07,623 --> 00:21:09,103
Judge Keating owed you a lot of money.
486
00:21:09,147 --> 00:21:10,452
We were all square.
487
00:21:10,496 --> 00:21:12,628
You've threatened him
in the past, correct?
488
00:21:12,672 --> 00:21:15,501
You sent a text the day
before he was murdered saying,
489
00:21:15,544 --> 00:21:19,461
"Need to get paid by tomorrow
or this ain't gonna end well."
490
00:21:19,505 --> 00:21:21,420
I didn't mean that as a threat.
491
00:21:21,463 --> 00:21:23,422
- It was...
- Last year, you were convicted
492
00:21:23,465 --> 00:21:25,511
of assault in the second degree.
493
00:21:25,554 --> 00:21:26,554
Is that correct?
494
00:21:26,555 --> 00:21:27,730
Yes.
495
00:21:27,774 --> 00:21:30,994
Yeah, you hit someone with a lead pipe?
496
00:21:31,038 --> 00:21:35,434
I... I'd been drinking.
497
00:21:35,477 --> 00:21:37,175
Last summer, you were
convicted of assault
498
00:21:37,218 --> 00:21:40,178
- in the third degree.
- Objection! The witness is not on trial.
499
00:21:40,221 --> 00:21:41,831
No, but he should be.
500
00:21:41,875 --> 00:21:43,790
He's the only person
in this damn courtroom
501
00:21:43,833 --> 00:21:46,445
who had the motive,
means, and opportunity
502
00:21:46,488 --> 00:21:48,403
to actually kill Judge Keating.
503
00:21:48,447 --> 00:21:51,232
- Your Honor...
- That's enough, Mr. Mendez.
504
00:21:51,276 --> 00:21:52,276
Nothing further.
505
00:22:02,649 --> 00:22:06,595
Mr. Malloy, did you
drop Ms. McDaniel off
506
00:22:06,639 --> 00:22:11,121
at 87th Street near Park Avenue
on the evening of February 3rd?
507
00:22:16,823 --> 00:22:19,565
Would you like me to
repeat the question?
508
00:22:19,608 --> 00:22:22,089
I respectfully decline
to answer on the grounds
509
00:22:22,132 --> 00:22:23,612
it might incriminate me.
510
00:22:23,656 --> 00:22:26,833
Uh, Your Honor, we concede
that Mr. Malloy could face
511
00:22:26,876 --> 00:22:30,010
criminal liability and
accept his assertion,
512
00:22:30,053 --> 00:22:34,014
which is why we've prepared
a grant of immunity.
513
00:22:39,280 --> 00:22:42,501
That means you have to answer
the question, Mr. Malloy.
514
00:22:52,554 --> 00:22:53,642
Is this your Range Rover?
515
00:22:56,428 --> 00:22:57,429
Yes, that's my car.
516
00:22:57,472 --> 00:22:58,865
And the woman in the picture,
517
00:22:58,908 --> 00:23:01,824
you've previously identified
her as Lucy McDaniel.
518
00:23:07,700 --> 00:23:09,441
Mr. Malloy, would you please identify
519
00:23:09,484 --> 00:23:10,485
the woman on the monitor?
520
00:23:10,529 --> 00:23:12,270
I can't be sure if it's her.
521
00:23:12,313 --> 00:23:13,575
She got out of your car.
522
00:23:13,619 --> 00:23:14,750
You can't tell us that
she's your girlfriend?
523
00:23:14,794 --> 00:23:15,838
Your Honor, he's badgering the witness.
524
00:23:15,882 --> 00:23:19,668
Okay, fine. Let's... let's
move on from the photo.
525
00:23:19,712 --> 00:23:22,454
Mr. Malloy, you dropped off
526
00:23:22,497 --> 00:23:25,587
your girlfriend, Lucy McDaniel,
527
00:23:25,631 --> 00:23:27,110
in front of that parking garage
528
00:23:27,154 --> 00:23:30,244
shortly before 7:00 p.m., correct?
529
00:23:37,773 --> 00:23:40,341
- Yes.
- Nothing further.
530
00:23:46,391 --> 00:23:48,393
We put her at the scene.
531
00:23:48,436 --> 00:23:53,354
That, plus the DNA evidence.
We're in a good place.
532
00:23:57,315 --> 00:24:00,274
- Have you checked your email?
- Why?
533
00:24:00,318 --> 00:24:03,321
Defense just filed a psych notice.
534
00:24:03,364 --> 00:24:04,452
Psych notice?
535
00:24:04,496 --> 00:24:05,496
They changed their defense.
536
00:24:05,497 --> 00:24:08,935
They're going with "not
guilty by reason of insanity."
537
00:24:11,285 --> 00:24:14,506
I know she had some issues
on the court a while ago,
538
00:24:14,549 --> 00:24:18,205
but she's a high-functioning,
world-class athlete.
539
00:24:18,248 --> 00:24:21,208
How could she possibly
be legally insane?
540
00:24:28,694 --> 00:24:30,565
My name is Dr. Stewart Moore.
541
00:24:30,609 --> 00:24:32,480
I'm a board-certified psychiatrist
542
00:24:32,524 --> 00:24:34,613
and director of the
Restorative Health Clinic
543
00:24:34,656 --> 00:24:36,919
in Greenwich, Connecticut.
544
00:24:36,963 --> 00:24:39,444
Was Lucy McDaniel a
patient at your clinic?
545
00:24:39,487 --> 00:24:40,967
Yes. Four times.
546
00:24:41,010 --> 00:24:42,751
First visit was six years ago.
547
00:24:42,795 --> 00:24:44,405
Her most recent stay was two months ago.
548
00:24:44,449 --> 00:24:45,841
What is her diagnosis?
549
00:24:45,885 --> 00:24:48,104
- Bipolar I.
- Hmm.
550
00:24:48,148 --> 00:24:50,411
She suffers from manic depression.
551
00:24:50,455 --> 00:24:51,804
Yes.
552
00:24:51,847 --> 00:24:54,023
How did Lucy's mania manifest?
553
00:24:54,067 --> 00:24:56,417
Ms. McDaniel exhibited
a number of symptoms,
554
00:24:56,461 --> 00:24:59,855
including disruptive
behavior, inflated self-esteem,
555
00:24:59,899 --> 00:25:03,555
and increased psycho-motor agitation.
556
00:25:03,598 --> 00:25:04,773
And the depression?
557
00:25:04,817 --> 00:25:07,907
She reported feelings of worthlessness
558
00:25:07,950 --> 00:25:10,953
and had recurring thoughts
of suicidal ideation.
559
00:25:10,997 --> 00:25:13,216
Dr. Moore, do you have
an opinion as to whether
560
00:25:13,260 --> 00:25:16,698
or not this condition
interfered with Lucy's ability
561
00:25:16,742 --> 00:25:19,440
to understand the
nature and consequences
562
00:25:19,484 --> 00:25:21,790
of her conduct on February 3rd?
563
00:25:21,834 --> 00:25:24,402
Yes. I believe it did.
564
00:25:24,445 --> 00:25:27,361
You believe she was
incapable of determining
565
00:25:27,405 --> 00:25:28,754
right from wrong?
566
00:25:28,797 --> 00:25:30,059
Correct.
567
00:25:33,062 --> 00:25:35,021
Thank you. Nothing further.
568
00:25:38,372 --> 00:25:41,810
You're not saying that
everyone with Bipolar Disorder
569
00:25:41,854 --> 00:25:43,638
is criminally insane, are you?
570
00:25:43,682 --> 00:25:46,424
No, that's definitely
not what I'm saying.
571
00:25:46,467 --> 00:25:47,599
Because many of the people
572
00:25:47,642 --> 00:25:49,818
with the disorder are high-functioning
573
00:25:49,862 --> 00:25:51,690
and productive members of society.
574
00:25:51,733 --> 00:25:52,995
Yeah, I would agree with that.
575
00:25:53,039 --> 00:25:54,910
Uh, Winston Churchill
had the condition...
576
00:25:54,954 --> 00:25:56,477
he called it his "black dog."
577
00:25:56,521 --> 00:25:58,218
I read that, yes.
578
00:25:58,261 --> 00:26:02,048
In fact, Lucy had been
managing a rigorous training
579
00:26:02,091 --> 00:26:04,006
and competition schedule right up until
580
00:26:04,050 --> 00:26:05,747
she killed Judge Keating.
581
00:26:08,707 --> 00:26:10,752
I understand what you're saying,
582
00:26:10,796 --> 00:26:13,276
but this disease is complicated.
583
00:26:13,320 --> 00:26:16,454
The only reason Lucy has
been symptom-free is because
584
00:26:16,497 --> 00:26:18,760
she has the benefit of intensive therapy
585
00:26:18,804 --> 00:26:20,632
and proper medication.
586
00:26:20,675 --> 00:26:24,113
She also has the love and
guidance of her father.
587
00:26:24,157 --> 00:26:26,115
The best thing that
ever happened to Lucy
588
00:26:26,159 --> 00:26:28,857
was having Tom appointed
as her guardian.
589
00:26:37,213 --> 00:26:39,868
The defendant's father
is her legal guardian?
590
00:26:39,912 --> 00:26:41,435
Is that what you're saying?
591
00:26:41,479 --> 00:26:42,479
Yes.
592
00:26:46,788 --> 00:26:48,747
When did this guardianship begin?
593
00:26:48,790 --> 00:26:51,184
Six years ago.
594
00:26:51,227 --> 00:26:53,403
And the guardianship was court-ordered?
595
00:26:53,447 --> 00:26:56,102
Yes, but the records were sealed.
596
00:26:56,145 --> 00:26:59,192
Unfortunately, mental illness
still carries a stigma.
597
00:27:03,022 --> 00:27:04,371
Nothing further at this time.
598
00:27:23,085 --> 00:27:25,827
Confirmed with the family court.
599
00:27:25,871 --> 00:27:29,178
Judge Keating appointed Tom
McDaniel as Lucy's guardian.
600
00:27:29,222 --> 00:27:32,747
He also appointed his old law
school chum, Clara Newhall,
601
00:27:32,791 --> 00:27:34,049
to be their lawyer.
602
00:27:34,793 --> 00:27:36,098
Shrink slipped up.
603
00:27:36,142 --> 00:27:38,536
No, he didn't slip up.
That was choreographed.
604
00:27:38,579 --> 00:27:40,799
They wanted the jury to know.
605
00:27:40,842 --> 00:27:44,280
This has to be connected
to motive somehow.
606
00:27:44,324 --> 00:27:46,544
Lucy didn't want a guardian,
607
00:27:46,587 --> 00:27:48,371
didn't want her father
to control her life,
608
00:27:48,415 --> 00:27:51,418
so she killed the judge
in charge of her case.
609
00:27:51,461 --> 00:27:54,907
Sounds plausible if we actually
had the evidence to back it up.
610
00:27:54,908 --> 00:27:56,510
Mm.
611
00:27:56,554 --> 00:27:58,599
This guardianship thing, though,
612
00:27:58,643 --> 00:28:00,427
it makes things a lot more complicated.
613
00:28:00,470 --> 00:28:02,560
- What do you mean?
- Legal guardians are assigned
614
00:28:02,603 --> 00:28:04,387
to protect people who can't take care
615
00:28:04,431 --> 00:28:05,998
of their own basic needs,
616
00:28:06,041 --> 00:28:08,957
which means the jury is gonna
assume that Lucy is, in fact,
617
00:28:09,001 --> 00:28:11,481
insane, and therefore, is not guilty.
618
00:28:11,525 --> 00:28:13,614
Different standards,
different definitions.
619
00:28:13,658 --> 00:28:15,964
I know, but try explaining
620
00:28:16,008 --> 00:28:17,705
the difference between legally insane
621
00:28:17,749 --> 00:28:19,968
versus mentally incapacitated.
622
00:28:20,012 --> 00:28:23,581
To them... to most
people... insane is insane.
623
00:28:25,191 --> 00:28:27,497
Question is...
624
00:28:27,541 --> 00:28:30,109
is Lucy really that incapacitated,
625
00:28:30,152 --> 00:28:32,372
or is this a tennis dad
626
00:28:32,415 --> 00:28:34,853
trying to manage his
rich, famous daughter?
627
00:28:34,896 --> 00:28:37,116
Oh, let's review her
medical records again,
628
00:28:37,159 --> 00:28:39,684
and make sure Dr. Moore
gave us all his files...
629
00:28:39,727 --> 00:28:43,296
Waste of time... found out he
never actually treated Lucy.
630
00:28:43,339 --> 00:28:44,602
What? He just testified.
631
00:28:44,645 --> 00:28:45,690
He runs the clinic,
632
00:28:45,733 --> 00:28:48,257
but he never worked with her directly.
633
00:28:48,301 --> 00:28:51,913
So find the doctor who did.
634
00:28:51,957 --> 00:28:54,742
There has to be a good reason
he or she wasn't called.
635
00:28:59,573 --> 00:29:03,403
Dr. Moore fired me two months ago.
636
00:29:03,446 --> 00:29:05,623
Did it have anything to
do with Lucy McDaniel?
637
00:29:07,537 --> 00:29:10,062
Lucy's disorder first manifested itself
638
00:29:10,105 --> 00:29:13,282
when she had a very public
incident on the tennis court
639
00:29:13,326 --> 00:29:15,371
about six years ago.
640
00:29:15,415 --> 00:29:17,460
She got treatment. She was doing well.
641
00:29:17,504 --> 00:29:19,071
Things were under control.
642
00:29:19,114 --> 00:29:21,769
I told Dr. Moore she didn't
need in-patient treatment.
643
00:29:21,813 --> 00:29:24,380
Then why was she at the clinic?
644
00:29:24,424 --> 00:29:25,773
My opinion?
645
00:29:25,817 --> 00:29:29,124
He's a way for Tom
McDaniel to control her.
646
00:29:29,168 --> 00:29:30,430
Control her...?
647
00:29:32,171 --> 00:29:34,695
When Lucy didn't wanna play
in a particular tournament,
648
00:29:34,739 --> 00:29:37,567
or she'd wanna go on
vacation with her boyfriend,
649
00:29:37,611 --> 00:29:39,134
he'd punish her...
650
00:29:39,178 --> 00:29:41,223
send her away.
651
00:29:41,267 --> 00:29:44,139
It's all a part of his
plan to control her life
652
00:29:44,183 --> 00:29:46,664
and finances.
653
00:29:46,707 --> 00:29:50,450
You shared your concerns with Dr. Moore?
654
00:29:50,493 --> 00:29:52,931
I wrote a letter to Judge Keating too.
655
00:29:52,974 --> 00:29:57,631
- Saying what?
- That the guardianship should be terminated.
656
00:29:57,675 --> 00:29:59,720
It just wasn't right.
657
00:29:59,764 --> 00:30:03,028
Lucy didn't need someone
to control her life,
658
00:30:03,071 --> 00:30:05,552
make decisions for her.
659
00:30:05,595 --> 00:30:08,511
Two days later, Dr. Moore fired me.
660
00:30:11,776 --> 00:30:12,907
Okay.
661
00:30:12,951 --> 00:30:16,345
You sent this letter to the courthouse?
662
00:30:16,389 --> 00:30:17,912
Certified mail.
663
00:30:21,394 --> 00:30:23,178
The guardianship was a sham.
664
00:30:23,222 --> 00:30:25,833
Her father was using it
as a device to control her.
665
00:30:25,877 --> 00:30:27,705
What about Judge
Keating? Was he involved?
666
00:30:27,748 --> 00:30:29,141
Sure looks that way.
667
00:30:29,184 --> 00:30:31,534
All he did was rubber stamp
anything and everything
668
00:30:31,578 --> 00:30:32,884
Tom McDaniel asked for.
669
00:30:33,007 --> 00:30:34,661
He also buried the paper trail,
670
00:30:34,704 --> 00:30:36,576
making it impossible to find.
671
00:30:36,619 --> 00:30:38,534
If they hadn't put her
mental state in play,
672
00:30:38,578 --> 00:30:40,406
we never would've even
found out about it.
673
00:30:40,449 --> 00:30:43,278
Did Lucy ever try to
terminate the guardianship?
674
00:30:43,322 --> 00:30:46,629
The hearings were held in
secret, but they were recorded,
675
00:30:46,673 --> 00:30:48,457
and we've had them transcribed.
676
00:30:48,501 --> 00:30:50,938
According to the transcripts,
Lucy didn't even know
677
00:30:50,982 --> 00:30:52,940
she could terminate the guardianship.
678
00:30:52,984 --> 00:30:54,724
- What?
- She was living in a bubble,
679
00:30:54,768 --> 00:30:56,683
following her father's orders,
680
00:30:56,726 --> 00:30:59,947
while he paid himself
a $10 million salary.
681
00:30:59,991 --> 00:31:01,470
Okay, let's say you're right.
682
00:31:01,514 --> 00:31:04,952
The father was trying to
control her, profit off her.
683
00:31:04,996 --> 00:31:06,649
Why did she kill Judge Keating?
684
00:31:06,693 --> 00:31:08,651
She wanted to marry her boyfriend.
685
00:31:08,695 --> 00:31:10,131
But Judge Keating said no,
686
00:31:10,175 --> 00:31:12,090
because her father
didn't want it to happen.
687
00:31:12,133 --> 00:31:14,440
She had no autonomy whatsoever...
688
00:31:14,483 --> 00:31:17,095
legally, financially, romantically,
689
00:31:17,138 --> 00:31:19,184
despite the fact she was mentally fit.
690
00:31:20,968 --> 00:31:23,492
Ask me, this isn't first-degree murder.
691
00:31:23,536 --> 00:31:25,146
This is manslaughter.
692
00:31:25,190 --> 00:31:28,323
Uh... I agree that she
was being mistreated,
693
00:31:28,367 --> 00:31:29,716
but the facts are the facts.
694
00:31:29,759 --> 00:31:32,806
She hopped in a car,
traveled across the city
695
00:31:32,850 --> 00:31:34,634
to confront Keating, and
when he wouldn't give her
696
00:31:34,677 --> 00:31:36,157
what she wanted, she bashed his head in
697
00:31:36,201 --> 00:31:37,289
with a fire extinguisher.
698
00:31:37,332 --> 00:31:39,857
What she wanted? No.
699
00:31:39,900 --> 00:31:42,598
What she was entitled
to as a human being.
700
00:31:42,642 --> 00:31:44,383
They were enslaving her, for God's sake.
701
00:31:44,426 --> 00:31:46,820
I understand, but she
still murdered a judge.
702
00:31:46,864 --> 00:31:48,517
A corrupt judge.
703
00:31:48,561 --> 00:31:51,172
Do you have any proof of that?
704
00:31:51,216 --> 00:31:52,478
Nothing concrete.
705
00:31:52,521 --> 00:31:55,916
But I'm guessing the
100 grand he came up with
706
00:31:55,960 --> 00:31:58,614
to pay off his bookie didn't
just drop from the sky.
707
00:32:04,969 --> 00:32:06,622
I agree with Ms. Maroun.
708
00:32:08,059 --> 00:32:10,322
The correct charge here is manslaughter.
709
00:32:10,365 --> 00:32:12,715
Defense will never agree to
a manslaughter instruction.
710
00:32:12,759 --> 00:32:14,717
Then talk to her lawyer.
711
00:32:14,761 --> 00:32:16,763
Try to work something out.
712
00:32:19,940 --> 00:32:21,899
Lucy agrees to plead guilty,
713
00:32:21,942 --> 00:32:24,249
we'll reduce the charge to Man One,
714
00:32:24,292 --> 00:32:26,729
we'll recommend she serve 15 years.
715
00:32:26,773 --> 00:32:27,992
15 years?
716
00:32:28,035 --> 00:32:29,950
My daughter isn't serving 15 days.
717
00:32:29,994 --> 00:32:33,475
If she loses, she'll end up
doing life without parole.
718
00:32:33,519 --> 00:32:37,653
We appreciate your offer, but we
are going to proceed with the trial.
719
00:32:40,178 --> 00:32:41,178
You're serious?
720
00:32:44,399 --> 00:32:45,444
You realize the only reason
721
00:32:45,487 --> 00:32:46,793
we're offering to reduce the charge
722
00:32:46,836 --> 00:32:48,969
is because we have empathy
for her, because we know
723
00:32:49,013 --> 00:32:50,666
you're manipulating and controlling her.
724
00:32:50,710 --> 00:32:52,364
- Excuse me?
- You misrepresented
725
00:32:52,407 --> 00:32:53,800
your daughter's mental illness
726
00:32:53,843 --> 00:32:56,194
in order to control her
finances... her life!
727
00:32:56,237 --> 00:32:59,284
You caused her to kill Judge Keating!
728
00:32:59,327 --> 00:33:01,547
You don't know what the
hell you're talking about.
729
00:33:01,590 --> 00:33:04,593
Are you even going to ask
Lucy what she wants to do here?
730
00:33:04,637 --> 00:33:06,682
She'll want what I want.
731
00:33:06,726 --> 00:33:07,857
Trust me.
732
00:33:22,372 --> 00:33:25,353
Okay, let's get started.
733
00:33:25,397 --> 00:33:27,616
I'll hear you and
your motion, Mr. Price.
734
00:33:27,660 --> 00:33:29,227
Your Honor,
735
00:33:29,270 --> 00:33:30,489
we're asking the court to terminate
736
00:33:30,532 --> 00:33:31,969
the defendant's guardianship
737
00:33:32,012 --> 00:33:35,102
and remove Mr. McDaniel
and Ms. Newhall from having
738
00:33:35,146 --> 00:33:36,799
any further involvement in this case.
739
00:33:36,843 --> 00:33:38,018
No, this is ridiculous.
740
00:33:38,062 --> 00:33:39,498
Just because we
rejected their plea offer
741
00:33:39,541 --> 00:33:41,326
doesn't mean we're bad people.
742
00:33:41,369 --> 00:33:42,675
It means we have a strong case.
743
00:33:42,718 --> 00:33:44,329
It means we're gonna win.
744
00:33:44,372 --> 00:33:46,548
Yeah, Mr. Price, if you want
to terminate the guardianship,
745
00:33:46,592 --> 00:33:48,028
file an application in family court.
746
00:33:48,072 --> 00:33:49,421
We don't have time for that.
747
00:33:49,464 --> 00:33:52,641
The reason we're here is,
Mr. McDaniel's legal team
748
00:33:52,685 --> 00:33:54,730
is not looking out
for her best interests.
749
00:33:54,774 --> 00:33:56,167
Well, that's a hell of an allegation.
750
00:33:56,210 --> 00:33:57,385
It's true.
751
00:33:57,429 --> 00:34:00,998
Oh, then bring proof, lots of it.
752
00:34:01,041 --> 00:34:03,522
Otherwise, your motion is denied.
753
00:34:12,096 --> 00:34:13,793
- So now what?
- We move forward.
754
00:34:13,836 --> 00:34:15,490
On what charge?
755
00:34:15,534 --> 00:34:16,578
Murder.
756
00:34:16,622 --> 00:34:18,319
You read those transcripts.
757
00:34:18,363 --> 00:34:20,626
She was practically being held hostage.
758
00:34:20,669 --> 00:34:24,108
Her father forced her to have
an IUD implanted, for God's sake,
759
00:34:24,151 --> 00:34:26,414
and Judge Keating just let it happen.
760
00:34:26,458 --> 00:34:28,460
We presented her with a generous offer.
761
00:34:28,503 --> 00:34:33,421
But her lawyers and her father said no.
762
00:34:33,465 --> 00:34:35,684
Listen to what you just said, Nolan.
763
00:34:35,728 --> 00:34:38,513
Her lawyers and her father said no
764
00:34:38,557 --> 00:34:40,385
like Lucy's not a person...
765
00:34:40,428 --> 00:34:43,953
doesn't have her own
opinions or feelings.
766
00:34:43,997 --> 00:34:46,521
She's in love with Jesse.
She wanted to get married.
767
00:34:46,565 --> 00:34:50,221
But her father...
no... her boss said no,
768
00:34:50,264 --> 00:34:52,658
then blamed it on the big, bad judge,
769
00:34:52,701 --> 00:34:54,138
and Lucy lost it.
770
00:34:54,181 --> 00:34:56,618
That was the last straw.
771
00:34:56,662 --> 00:35:00,492
- That's not murder.
- I share your frustration.
772
00:35:00,535 --> 00:35:03,451
Unfortunately, they're the
people in charge of Lucy,
773
00:35:03,495 --> 00:35:05,366
and right or wrong, they don't want her
774
00:35:05,410 --> 00:35:06,672
to plead out on a lesser charge.
775
00:35:06,715 --> 00:35:09,892
They want to roll the
dice on an NGI verdict.
776
00:35:09,936 --> 00:35:11,155
Nothing we can do.
777
00:35:11,198 --> 00:35:13,809
Yeah, so she can keep playing tennis,
778
00:35:13,853 --> 00:35:15,463
keep laying golden eggs.
779
00:35:15,507 --> 00:35:16,595
It is what it is.
780
00:35:18,336 --> 00:35:19,859
I'm not so sure about that.
781
00:35:39,096 --> 00:35:40,532
Have a seat.
782
00:35:42,099 --> 00:35:43,404
You're about to be convicted
783
00:35:43,448 --> 00:35:46,407
and sent to prison for
the rest of your life.
784
00:35:46,451 --> 00:35:48,235
Might as well hear me out.
785
00:35:48,279 --> 00:35:49,628
Does my dad know you're here?
786
00:35:49,671 --> 00:35:51,151
Shh.
787
00:35:51,195 --> 00:35:53,284
Don't talk.
788
00:35:53,327 --> 00:35:54,546
Just listen.
789
00:35:57,418 --> 00:35:59,638
It's your father's number
one priority to get you
790
00:35:59,681 --> 00:36:03,337
back out on the court
to make more money,
791
00:36:03,381 --> 00:36:07,036
and he is willing to gamble your future,
792
00:36:07,080 --> 00:36:09,169
your life,
793
00:36:09,213 --> 00:36:10,910
in order to make that happen.
794
00:36:12,999 --> 00:36:14,522
It was your father
795
00:36:14,566 --> 00:36:16,916
that prevented you from marrying Jesse.
796
00:36:19,223 --> 00:36:20,398
No, he said that was the judge.
797
00:36:20,441 --> 00:36:23,966
He blamed it on him. I know.
798
00:36:24,010 --> 00:36:25,403
But it was your father.
799
00:36:27,100 --> 00:36:30,408
He told the judge to...
800
00:36:30,451 --> 00:36:33,280
"deny your request."
801
00:36:35,587 --> 00:36:38,416
It's all here in the court transcripts.
802
00:36:40,592 --> 00:36:41,941
Read 'em for yourself.
803
00:36:50,079 --> 00:36:54,562
Did you know the prosecutor
offered you a deal?
804
00:36:56,651 --> 00:36:59,350
- What?
- Yeah.
805
00:36:59,393 --> 00:37:01,221
They presented it to your
father and your lawyers.
806
00:37:01,265 --> 00:37:03,919
But they didn't tell you.
807
00:37:03,963 --> 00:37:06,487
Reason I'm here.
808
00:37:09,273 --> 00:37:11,797
Lucy...
809
00:37:11,840 --> 00:37:15,670
plead guilty to manslaughter
and serve 15 years,
810
00:37:15,714 --> 00:37:18,499
and move on with your life.
811
00:37:18,543 --> 00:37:21,937
Marry Jesse, have some babies,
812
00:37:21,981 --> 00:37:23,461
build a life together.
813
00:37:25,637 --> 00:37:27,856
More importantly...
814
00:37:27,900 --> 00:37:30,119
you'll be free.
815
00:37:30,163 --> 00:37:31,469
No more guardianship,
816
00:37:31,512 --> 00:37:33,775
and you can do whatever
the hell you wanna do.
817
00:37:42,567 --> 00:37:44,308
Read the transcripts.
818
00:38:06,939 --> 00:38:09,158
Is everyone ready to proceed?
819
00:38:09,202 --> 00:38:10,638
The People are ready.
820
00:38:10,682 --> 00:38:12,379
Defense is ready.
821
00:38:14,381 --> 00:38:16,731
Your Honor, I wanna plead guilty.
822
00:38:22,433 --> 00:38:23,458
If I may have a moment with my client...
823
00:38:23,477 --> 00:38:24,652
No, I don't want a moment.
824
00:38:24,696 --> 00:38:26,263
Lucy, sit down now!
825
00:38:26,306 --> 00:38:27,829
Can I just say something?
826
00:38:27,873 --> 00:38:29,788
Would you like to consult
with another lawyer?
827
00:38:29,831 --> 00:38:31,398
No. Please, no more lawyers.
828
00:38:31,442 --> 00:38:32,442
I just want to talk.
829
00:38:32,443 --> 00:38:35,489
- Lucy, stop!
- Shut up.
830
00:38:35,533 --> 00:38:37,143
For once, just let me talk.
831
00:38:42,540 --> 00:38:44,585
Your Honor,
832
00:38:44,629 --> 00:38:47,022
I killed Judge Keating.
833
00:38:47,066 --> 00:38:49,503
I didn't plan to.
834
00:38:49,547 --> 00:38:52,767
I went there to ask him
to let me marry Jesse.
835
00:38:52,811 --> 00:38:56,162
The judge... he wouldn't listen,
836
00:38:56,205 --> 00:38:57,250
said it wasn't an option,
837
00:38:57,294 --> 00:38:59,774
then he just started walking away.
838
00:38:59,818 --> 00:39:01,210
And I...
839
00:39:01,254 --> 00:39:03,517
I snapped.
840
00:39:03,561 --> 00:39:05,519
I grabbed a fire extinguisher,
841
00:39:05,563 --> 00:39:07,086
and I attacked him.
842
00:39:09,218 --> 00:39:12,483
I wish I could take back
what I did, but I can't.
843
00:39:14,311 --> 00:39:18,967
So what I wanna say is that...
844
00:39:19,011 --> 00:39:21,100
I'm so sorry.
845
00:39:21,143 --> 00:39:23,581
I feel so horrible for what I did.
846
00:39:25,670 --> 00:39:27,454
But I'm a good person.
847
00:39:27,498 --> 00:39:28,673
I am.
848
00:39:35,419 --> 00:39:37,029
I just wanted to marry Jesse.
849
00:39:49,128 --> 00:39:51,217
Your Honor...
850
00:39:51,260 --> 00:39:53,611
I'm gonna accept the
offer the prosecutor made.
851
00:39:56,048 --> 00:39:58,964
I wanna plead guilty to manslaughter.
852
00:39:59,007 --> 00:40:01,836
- You're sure about that?
- I am.
853
00:40:01,880 --> 00:40:04,012
Would you like to
consult with your lawyers?
854
00:40:04,056 --> 00:40:05,666
No.
855
00:40:05,710 --> 00:40:08,669
I don't wanna consult anyone
or ask for anyone's permission.
856
00:40:08,713 --> 00:40:10,323
I just wanna control my own life.
857
00:40:16,329 --> 00:40:19,114
I spoke with the
Financial Frauds Bureau.
858
00:40:19,158 --> 00:40:20,681
They're going to open an investigation
859
00:40:20,725 --> 00:40:22,814
against Tom McDaniel and Clara Newhall.
860
00:40:26,644 --> 00:40:28,602
Couldn't just sit there
861
00:40:28,646 --> 00:40:32,214
and watch her get screwed over again.
862
00:40:32,258 --> 00:40:33,258
How'd you do it?
863
00:40:34,652 --> 00:40:36,001
Do what?
864
00:40:36,044 --> 00:40:38,656
Let Lucy know about the
deal we were offering.
865
00:40:42,529 --> 00:40:44,618
I had Bernard reach out to her.
866
00:40:46,881 --> 00:40:48,579
If you ever pull a
stunt like that again,
867
00:40:48,622 --> 00:40:50,319
I'll fire you.
868
00:41:17,429 --> 00:41:22,429
- Synced and corrected by chamallow -
- www.MY-SUBS.com -